Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 2 & 92
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CJ Court
Case: WP(C) No. 2744/2026 &
WP(C) No. 1251/2025
…Petitioner (s)/Appellant(s)
Wajahat Qayoom and ors.
Through: Mr. Abhinav Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
M/s Abhirash Sharma, Aditiya Manhas & Vansh
Verma, Advocates.
V/s
…. Respondent(s)
Mohd. Saleem and ors.
Through: Mr. Rahul Pant, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Anirudh Sharma, Advocate
Mr. Anuj Dewan Raina, Advocate.
Ms. Meenakshi Slathia, GA.
CORAM: HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
ORDER
04.11.2026
(ORAL)
01.
The petitions, in hand, are arising out of the impugned orders dated
25.09.2024 and 11.02.2025 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jammu
Bench, Jammu, in OA No. 421/2022 (Mohd. Saleem & anr. Vs. Union Territory of
J&K & anr.) and TA No. 5079/2021 (Mohd. Ashraf wani & ors. Vs. State of J&K
and ors.).
02.
The prayer made in OA No. 421/2022 reads as follows:
i. Direct the respondents to convene the DPC/PSC and to place
the cases of the applicants before the DPC/PSC for their
substantive promotion to the posts of the Assistant Regional
Officers retrospectively from the date they were made in-charge
of the post, with all consequential benefits:
03.
The prayer made in TA No. 5079/2021 is as under:
a) Allow this writ petition of the petitioners.
b) Issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari quashing the impugned
final seniority list of Motor Vehicle Inspectors (Technical and
Survey) issued by the respondent no. 2 & 3 vide Government
Order No. 24-TR of 2011 dated 25.03.2011, whereby the
petitioners, despite being senior to the private respondent no.5
to 18 have been wrongly placed below the private respondents
in the impugned seniority list.
c) Issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus Commanding the
official respondents to issue a fresh final seniority list strictly in
accordance with the relevant rules, thereby placing the
petitioners over and above the private respondent no. 5 to 18 a
the petitioners were senior to the private respondents.
d) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the official
respondents to place the petitioners over and above the private
respondent no. 5 to 18 as per their seniority in the final
seniority list/length of service in the Motor Vehicle Department
and in accordance with the relevant rules.
e) Any other writ, order command or direction as this Hon‟ble
Court may deem just and proper in the given facts and
circumstances of the case may also be passed in favour of the
petitioners.”
04.
The prayer made in WP(C) No. 1251/2025 reads as under:
a) allow the present writ petition;
b) quash and set aside judgment and order dated 11.02.2025 passed/
rendered by the Central Administrative Tribunal Bench Jammu in
TA No.5079/2021 titled “Mohd. Ashraf Wani & ors V/s State of
J&K & ors", whereby and whereunder, the Tribunal while
allowing the aforesaid TA has quashed final seniority list of
Motor Vehicle Inspectors (Technical and Survey) of the Motor
Vehicle Department, issued vide Govt. Order no. 24-TR of 2011
dated 25.03 .2011 in which the names of the petitioners figured
over and above the names of respondent no. 1 to 5 and a further
direction has been issued to proforma respondents to issue fresh
seniority list while placing the names of respondent no. 1 to 5 over
and above the names of the petitioners;
c) ANY other order or direction which this Hon'ble Court may deem
fit or proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
The prayer made in WP(C) No. 2744/2026 reads as under:
a)
(b)
allow the present writ petition;
quash and set aside the impugned judgment and order dated
25.09.2024 passed/rendered by the Central Administrative
Tribunal Bench Jammu in OA no. 421/2022 titled “Mohd. Saleem
& anr. Vs. UT of J&K & ors.”, whereby and whereunder, the
Tribunal while allowing the aforesaid OA has directed the
proforma respondents to convene the DPC /PSC and to place the
cases of respondents no. 1 and 2 before DPC/PSC for their
substantive promotion to the post of Assistant Regional Transport
Officers retrospectively from the date they were made in-charge of
the post, with all consequential benefits, notwithstanding the fact
that respondent no. 1 and 2 were not even eligible for promotion
to the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector and also to the post of
Assistant Regional Transport officers particularly from the
retrospective effect i.e. w.e.f. the date they were made incharge of
the post of Assistant Regional Transport Officers;
Prayer for setting aside the aforesaid impugned
judgment and
order dated 26.09.2024 by dismissing the
aforesaid OA No. 421/2022;
(c) ANY other order or direction which this Hon'ble Court may deem
fit or proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
06.
The crux of the matter in these cases concerns a promotional and
appointment dispute between direct recruits and promotees regarding the post of
Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey and Technical). The dispute escalated as a
consequence of various judgments including SWP No. 1792/2007 (Gurmeet
Singh Vs. State and ors.) and the impugned orders—because both segments viz.
direct recruits and promotees asserted senior status over the other. The
promotees to the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey/Technical) were,
admittedly, the recipient of the benefit of promotion prior to the direct recruits
and, thus, when the direct recruits claimed seniority over them, the whole issue
came before the Courts.
07.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner Mr. Abhinav Sharma submits
that the Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey) was, in fact, a post which did not find
mention in the Rules and nor the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector (Technical)
finds any place in the Rules at the entry level. The Departmental Promotional
Committee (DPC) allowed the promotees on the basis of the Draft Rules, which
were supported by earlier judgment Gurmeet Singh (supra). Mr. Sharma, has
drawn our attention to Gurmeet Singh‟s judgment, relevant part of which is
reproduced as under:
“I am in agreement with Mrs. Shekhar, AAG. In the absence
of Recruitment Rules, it was open for the Government in
exercise of its plenary powers to create new posts and to
provide for the mode of filling of these posts. The
Government with a view to create promotional avenues for
the employees who are in the lower cadre appears to have
provided for the promotion to the post of Motor vehicle
inspector (survey) by reserving 50% of post for them, in the
Draft Rules. As Draft Rules have not been finalized,
therefore, the Government could have independently adopted
any mode of appointment including the one envisaged by
draft rules for filling up the posts of vehicle Inspectors
(survey). The petitioner not being in-service person has no
right to question the promotions of the private respondents.
The private respondents in the absence of Recruitment Rules
cannot be said to be usurpers of public office In SWP No.
1108/91 titled Raj Shekhar and ors. Vs State and others and
SWP No. 61/ 92 Bipin Singh vs. State and others, decided on
14-8-2000, promotion of the private respondents in both the
writ petitions to the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey)
was questioned on the ground that the private respondents
who belonged to ministerial cadre of Transport Department
were not eligible for holding the Technical posts as they were
not possessing the requisite qualification as mentioned in
1974 Rules. The respondents contested the writ petition on
the ground that the post of Motor vehicle Inspector
(Technical) and Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey) were two
different categories while the qualification for Technical post
is Diploma or Degree in Automobile Engineering, it is not so
for the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey). It is also
submitted that the post to which the private respondent had
been promoted were not technical posts requiring of
qualification of Automobile Engineering.
While repelling the contention of the writ petitioners, this
Court observed as follows:"Despite efforts Mr. Kotwal could not Point out that
technical qualification is also a pre-condition for
promotion or appointment to the post of Survey
Inspectors. He however, pointed out that the order of
promotion does not indicate that the private respondents
have been promoted to the post of survey inspectors and
therefore, it is camouflage. However, the order mentions
that promotees have been promoted in the Survey Cell
and not technical side,."
In the above titled Service Writ Petitions, the writ
petitioners had also sought the quashment of the
promotions of the private respondents on the ground
that they were usurpers of the public office. That
contention was also repelled by this Court and it was
held:
"The other aspect of the case that the petitioners
are not in service candidates. They have no right to
compete with the private respondents. The order of
promotion cannot be quashed because unless it is
against the recruitment rules and they cannot be held to
be the usurper of the public. post."
There is no merit in this writ petition, which is as such,
dismissed. Connected CMP shall also stand disposed of.”
08.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner further submits that the Gurmeet
Singh‟s case (Supra) has been rendered on the basis of Draft Rules, which till date,
even after passage of more than two years have not culminated into any kind of
crystallization as Rules or Statute. It is submitted that the Motor Vehicle Inspector
is a post, which is envisaged under the Rules of J&K Transport Controller‟s
(Subordinate) Service constituted under J&K Transport Controllers
(Subordinate) Service Recruitment Rules, 1974 (for brevity „the Rules of
1974‟). He has laid down the emphasis on Rules 2, 3 4, 5 13 and 15 which reads as
under:
“
Definitions:
Rule 2 (a) 'Cadre' means the cadre of the service;
2(c) ‘Member of the Service’ means a person appointed to a
post in the service under the provisions of these rules, or the
rules; and orders repealed by rule 76;
2(d) „Schedule’ means the schedule annexed to these rules
2(e) „Service‟ means the Jammu and Kashmir Transport
Controller's (Subordinate) Service;
Rule 3
Organization
The service shall comprise of the posts, classes, categories and
grades as are indicated in Schedule 'A'.
Rule 4
Cadre
The cadre of the service shall consist of such posts and such
number of them as may be fixed for each of its classes from
time
to
time
by
the
Government;
provided,
at
the
commencement of these rules the cadre of each class shall
consist of the posts shown in Schedule 'A'.
Rule 5
Qualification and Method of Recruitment
(1) No person shall be eligible for appointment or promotion
to any class, category or grade in the service unless he
possesses the qualifications as laid down in Schedule 'A' and
fulfils
the
requirements of recruitment provided in the rules and orders
for
the time being in force.
(2)
Appointments to the service shall be made(a) by direct recruitment;
(b) by promotion /selection;
(c) partly by direct recruitment and partly by promotion
/selection; in the ratio and in the manner as indicated
against each post in Schedule 'A'.
Rule 13
Seniority
(1) The seniority of the members of the service in various classes
and categories shall be determined in accordance with the
provisions
of
the Jammu
and
Kashmir
Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1956, and the Jammu
and Kashmir Civil Services (Decentralization of and Recruitment
to
Non-Gazetted
Cadre)
Rules,
1969.
(2) The Food Supplies and Transport Department shall maintain
an up-to-date and final seniority list of the members of the
service.
Rule 15
Interpretation
If any question arises relating to the interpretation of these rules, the
decision of the Government thereon shall be final.”
09.
Mr. Sharma, as per Rule 4, has drawn the attention of this Court to
Schedule “A” of the Rules of 1974 where the route of the post in question goes
in its Technical part, which refers to Motor Vehicle Inspector in Pay Grade
(340-700) prescribing Qualification with 100% direct recruitment or by
promotion from in-service Junior Engineers in the PW(R&B) Department,
possessing the qualification prescribed for direct recruitment, in case direct
recruits are not available and till they become available.
A
Mechanical
inspectors
340-700
Diploma in automobile Engineering By
direct
from any recognized institution recruitment
having at least 5 years experience in
any recognized institution of State
Transport Undertaking.
B
Motor
Vehicle
Inspector
340-700
(i)
(i) Minimum general education
qualification of pass in X standard;
(ii) A degree in Automobile
Engineering
Or
Diploma in Automobile Engineering
3 years course Or
A
Degree
in
Mechanical
Engineering Or
Diploma in Mechanical Engineering
3 years course; and
(iii)
Working experience of at
least one year in a reputed
automobile
workshop
which
undertakes repairs of both light
Motor Vehicles, heavy goods
vehicles and heavy passengers motor
vehicles fitted with petrol and diesel
engine; and
(iv) Must hold a driving licence
authorizing him to drive motor
cycle, heavy goods vehicles and
heavy passenger motor vehicle.
(ii)
[100%
by
direct
recruitment
Or
By deputation
from
inservice Junior
Engineers in
the PW(R&B)
Department,
possessing the
qualification
prescribed for
direct
recruitment,
in case direct
recruits
are
not available
and till they
become
available.]
10.
Mr. Sharma submits that, even if, post of the Motor Vehicle Inspector was to
be bifurcated in Survey and Technical by giving two separate nomenclatures, then
also it was required to be done by prescribing in the Statute Book, the requirements
including the Grade Pay, the Minimum Qualification for direct recruitment,
Minimum Qualification for promotion, if at all provided, and the Method of
Recruitment. It is submitted that no such provisions have been brought to the
Statute Book till today. He has also referred to the J&K Transport (Gazetted)
Services Recruitment Rules, 1987 (for brevity „the Recruitment Rules of 1987)
which also provide for „Cadre‟ and „Member of Service‟ of similar descriptions and
also deals with a part of the controversy i.e., designation of Assistant Regional
Transport Officers.
The same is dealt with in Schedule -II of Rule 1987 which is reproduced as
under:
CLASS
CATEGORY
DESIGNATION
GRADE
MINIMUM
QUALIFICATION
FOR
DIRECT RECRUITMENT
MINIMUM QUALIFICATION
FOR
DEPARTMENTAL
PROMOTION/SELECTION
METHOD
RECRUITMENT
II
A.
Assistant
Regional
Transport
Officer
10001560
Graduation
from
recognized
University.
Preference being given to
Law Graduate/Commerce
Graduates
By promotion from Motor
Vehicle Inspectors of Survey
Cell (Non Technical) having
at least seven years service as
such.
I.
50 % by
promotion
II.
50% by
recruitment.
11.
Mr. Sharma submits that though the Assistant Regional Transport Officer
refers to method of recruitment being 50% by promotion and 50% by direct
recruitment but again the minimum qualification required for promotion/selection is
that a person has to be Motor Vehicle Inspector of Survey, having at least seven
years of service and, also a qualification of Graduate from a recognised University,
with preference to Law Graduates/Commerce Graduates. Moreso, again Motor
OF
direct
Vehicle Inspector has been given the minimum qualification though he may be of
Survey, but the nomenclature Survey is not given in the Rules of 1974.
12.
Mr. Sharma submits that when the core question of Motor Vehicle Inspector
is gone into then the basic parameter would be the eligibility for such post even if
the stand of the State regarding the promotional posts is accepted. Mr. Sharma has
further taken us to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short „the Act of 1988)
Section 213 providing for appointment of Motor Vehicle Inspectors and has drawn
attention of this Court to 213 (1) & 213(4) which is reproduced as under:
“213. Appointment of motor vehicles officer—
(1) The State Government may, for the purpose of carrying into
effect the provision of the Act, establish a Motor Vehicles
Department and appoint as Officer thereof such persons as it
thinks fit.
......
......
.....
..... ...
(3) The Central Government may, having regard to the objects of
the Act, by notification in the Official Gazette, prescribe the
minimum qualification which the said officers or any class
thereof shall possess for being appointed as such.”
13.
It is further submitted that the minimum eligibility prescribed by the Central
Government has to prevail. Thereafter, he has referred us to S.O. 443 in which, in
exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (4) of the Act of 1988, the Central
Government has prescribed the minimum qualification for the Class of Officers
consisting of the category of Inspectors of Motor Vehicles or Assistant Inspectors
of Motor Vehicles as under:
“S.O. 443 (E)—In exercise of the powers conferred by subsection (4) of Section 213 of the Motor Vehicles At, 1988( 59
of 1988), the Central Government hereby prescribes that the
minimum qualification for the class of officers consisting of
the category of Inspector of motor vehicles or Assistant
Inspector of motor vehicles (by whatever names called) shall
be as under—
Qualification:
1. Minimum general educational qualification of a pass in X
standard; and
2. A diploma in Automobile Engineering (3 year course)
Or
A diploma in Mechanical Engineering awarded by the
State Board of Technical Education (3 year course); and
3. Working experience of at least one year in a reputed
authomobile workshop which undertakes repairs of both
light motor vehicle, heavy goods vehicles and heavy
passenger motor vehicles fitted with petrol and diesel
engine; and
4. Must hold a driving licence authorizing him to drive motor
cycle, heavy goods vehicles and heavy passenger motor
vehicles.
2. Nothing contained in the notification shall apply to a
officer appointed to such post before the first day of July,
1989 and to an officer appointed to discharge function of a
non-technical nature.
3. This notification shall come into force on the first day of
July,1989.”
14.
It is submitted that any post of Motor Vehicle Inspector, even if, proposed to
be bifurcated in Survey/Technical then also the basic requirement of minimum
qualification, and the petitioners, who are directly recruited, possess such minimum
qualification and, thus, qualified the eligibility criteria. Mr. Sharma, submits that
the promotees may find a channel and may have an equity but, at the same time,
even if a criteria of promotion was created for them, then also, the Government
could not have overcome the basic parameter of minimum eligibility qualification,
which stands prescribed and crystallized by the power of Section 213 of the Act of
1988 read with S.O 443.
15.
It is further contended that the same qualification has been prescribed in the
Statute Book. And in the Rules also the qualification is absolutely in line with such
qualification prescribed by the Government. Mr. Sharma submitted that at this
belated stage when both the promotees and the direct recruits have spent decades in
the service of the Department, the issue would not go back to the root of their
appointment but ought to be restricted to the seniority only, while keeping into
consideration the minimum eligibility for the post in question.
16.
Mr. Sharma has also taken us to the Final Seniority List of the Motor Vehicle
Inspectors (Technical and Survey) issued by Government on 25.03.2011, in which
the promotees were placed below the direct recruits, which became the bone of
contention in the present litigation. He further submits that while narrowing the
issue down to seniority, the aforementioned laws clearly stipulate that Motor
Vehicle Inspectors, even in the event of bifurcation—must adhere to both the
fundamental eligibility parameters and the precedent established in the case of
Gurmeet Singh’s case,(supra) was only protecting the equitable part of the service
of the promotees, rather than laying down a law. He also submitted that if the Draft
Rule was to be made a basis of any relief at this belated stage for the purpose of
examining the tentative seniority list, then it would not only deprive the fruits of the
employment to the direct recruits but would also be detrimental to the larger
interests of the promotees as well because the Government has ultimately chosen
to abandon the draft rules, following a protracted and considerable delay. The
core issue, thus, raised by Mr. Sharma was that without meeting the technical
qualification required for the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector and keeping them
over the direct recruits, would be prejudicial to their long term interests and future
promotions as well.
17.
Ms. Meenakshi Slathia, learned Deputy Advocate General, at this stage,
submitted that their stand was clear before the learned Tribunal that the promotees
were not entitled for their promotion even initially as the Motor Vehicle Inspectors
and subsequent promotions as In-charge Assistant Regional Transport Officers as
the promotion of the applicants was effected on the basis of Draft Rules and these
Draft Rules were not confirmed by the Competent Authority. She further submits
that vide Government Order No. 90-TR of 2009 dated 23.11.2009, the tentative
seniority list of Motor Vehicle Inspectors was issued, which resulted into the filing
of various representations/objections, which were duly examined and a Committee
was constituted under the Chairmanship of the then Director, State Motor Garages,
vide Government order No. 56-TR of 2010 dated 09.09.2010, which has laid down
its report forming the part of the record. The Committee has gone into the complete
dispute in an analytical manner and has come with a conclusion that the past
practice of promotion of officers from Ministerial Cadre against the post of Motor
Vehicle Inspectors (Survey) was in clear violation of the Government Orders and
the recommendations of the High Level Committee. It is also submitted that the
practice continued upto 2007 as the promotees were brought in as Motor Vehicle
Inspectors (Survey). However, the confirmation was subject to the prerequisite
conditions as per the High Level Committee which required them to undergo six
months training in Automobile Engineering through Government Polytechnic and
one month Police training. It is further submitted that an equitable solution was
found out by the High Level Committee so as to enable the Ministerial Staff given
due promotions to be equipped with the task of the Motor Vehicle Inspector. It is
submitted that merely by holding the charge of ARTO, they cannot be held entitled
for such promotions because the promotions to the post of Motor Vehicle
Inspectors were to be conducted only strictly in accordance with rules. She further
submitted that the issue was resolved in strict accordance with the Committee‟s
recommendations, with no further relaxation in terms of the minimum eligibility to
ensure compliance with both the Rules of 1974 Rules and the provisions of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1939.
18.
Mr. Rahul Pant, learned Senior counsel as also Mr. Anuj Dewan Raina,
learned counsel for the private respondents/promotees drew our attention to the fact
that a conscious decision was taken, in the shape of Draft Rules, which was adhered
to by the Government only for the purpose of creating a way out for not reverting
the promotees to the original post after prolonged service. The counsel for the
promotees also tried to impress upon the Court that the Government had ample
powers to notify the cadre and the posts and once the Government had intended to
create a post of Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey), then it cannot retrospectively
declare that the Rules which mandated a 50-50 split between promotees and direct
recruits, have ceased to exist. It is submitted that, in that case if the promotions of
Motor Vehicle Inspectors (Survey) go away, then the appointments of the direct
recruits will also meet the same fate because there will be no cadre in existence by
the nomenclature of Motor Vehicle Inspectors (Survey). It is also submitted that the
promotees have been the long standing employees of the Department without there
being any misrepresentation or any kind of misleading actions. It was the
Government, which thought it appropriate to give them a career advancement by
putting a channel in Department in the shape of Motor Vehicle Inspectors (Survey)
whereby 50% could be absorbed on promotional posts by the length of their service
while maintaining the 50% as direct recruits. The counsel also submitted that the
Rules of 1974 even if do not have the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey)
then also, it was the prerogative of the State to have notified the same and having
once given effect to the Policy, they were precluded by the principle of promissory
estoppel, to have gone by their own stand that such a process was in shape and was
in accordance with law.
19.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties, this Court finds that the
bone of contention is Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey), which is a nomenclature
arising out of the basic post of Motor Vehicle Inspector. The Motor Vehicle
Inspector post has been given minimum general education qualification of pass in
Xth standard with a degree in Automobile Engineering Or Diploma in Automobile
Engineering three years course or a Degree in Mechanical Engineering or Diploma
in Mechanical Engineering three years course; and a working experience of at least
one year in a reputed automobile workshop which undertakes repairs of both light
Motor Vehicles, heavy goods vehicles and heavy passengers motor vehicles fitted
with petrol and diesel engine; and the person must hold a driving licence
authorizing him to drive motor cycle, heavy goods vehicles and heavy passenger
motor vehicle as per the Rules of 1974 in Schedule “A”. The subsequent corollary
of the Gazetted posts for the ARTO is given in the Rule of 1987.
20.
This Court holds that, even if, the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector
constituted the basic cadre which was subsequently bifurcated into the Survey and
Technical wings, still the Statute of 1974 must govern the parent post's eligibility
criteria and recruitment modalities, unless a distinct statutory provision explicitly
prescribes separate qualifications, eligibility criteria, and recruitment procedures
and, thus, if the basic eligibility itself is not satisfied by the promotees, to keep
them in the promoted post itself would have been difficult, although the same
would have to be sustained in light of the Gurmeet Singh‟s judgment (supra),
which had already attained finality and there is no reason to interfere with it at this
belated stage.
21.
This Court has taken note of the minutes of meeting of the High Level
Committee formed by the Government, which, in its meeting regarding fixation of
seniority of Motor Vehicle Inspector on 07.12.2010 has deliberated upon the whole
issue and has come out with a categorical finding that the Recruitment Rules were
not finalised, which resulted into the Motor Vehicle Department repeating the
practice of Ministerial Cadre promotions to the post of Motor Vehicle Inspector
(Survey) in clear violation of the Government directives and the recommendations.
The Committee systematically analyzed the chronology, with the High-Level
Committee explicitly noting that the issue has arisen on account of the nonfinalization of Recruitment Rules and such failure to finalize the Recruitment Rules
precipitated a total operational fiasco, ultimately leading to the promotion of
unqualified persons to the position of Motor Vehicle Inspector (Survey).
The relevant part of the Report read as follows:
“ Now keeping view all the facts and circumstances of the case and
all the representations in this regard the Committee constituted for
the purpose came to the following conclusions:
1) The Transport Department has failed to update the Recruitment
Rules ( Both gazetted and non-gazetted) and with the result the
decisions taken by the Government from time to time have been
violated and promotions have been effected in utter violations of the
government directives as well as qualification prescribed for MVIs
by the Central Government vide S.O. No. 443 dated 12.06.1989
which provides as under:
i) Minimum general educational qualification of
a pass in X standard; and
ii) A diploma in Automobile Engineering (3 year
course)
Or
A diploma in Mechanical Engineering awarded
by the State Board of Technical Education (3
year course); and
iii)
Working experience of at least one year
in a reputed authomobile workshop which
undertakes repairs of both light motor vehicle,
heavy goods vehicles and heavy passenger motor
vehicles fitted with petrol and diesel engine; and
iv)
Must hold a driving licence authorizing
him to drive motor cycle, heavy goods vehicles
and heavy passenger motor vehicles.
The route cause of violation is non-finaliziation of the Recruitment
Rules which needs to be finalized as soon as possible so as to avoid
any such deviation in future and the qualification for the Inspector
should be prescribed as has been prescribed by the Central
Government in above said notification.
2) That the promotions made by the Department against the posts of
MVI Survey from ministerial cadre in violation of the government
orders and recommendations of High Level Committee in 2007
needs to be reconsidered in view of the technical qualification
prescribed for MVIs as per the notification of Central Government,
however, in view of the stand taken by the Department before the
Hon'ble Court in SWP No. 1792/07, the department has to take a
decision whether they want to continue with these promotions. In
case they want to allow these promotions then they should devise a
syllabus in consultation with the Technical Education Department
for their training course to be completed within a minimum period
of six months so that they are well conversant with the Automobile
Engineering for delivering the goods efficiently as Motor Vehicle
Inspector. They may also be deputed for police training for a
minimum period of one month and only after their successful
completion of the training, their placement may be considered by the
government at the tail end of the seniority list owing to the fact that
their promotions in the year 2007 were effected against the direct
recruitment quota in violation of the rules. It has also been seen that
S.No. 2 to 6 of the tentative seniority list, some non-technical
persons have been included in the list and they do not possess the
requisite qualification and these persons also need to be deputed for
the training as in case of others already discussed above so that they
acquire necessary technical know how for which as already
recommended, the department should take up the issue with the
Technical Education Department for their training in automobile
engineering. They may also be deputed for Police Training for a
minimum period of 30 days.
3) The Committee while giving due considerations to the
representations submitted by the persons also recommends that Sh.
Swarn Singh and Abdul Majid Bhat needs to be reflected in the
seniority list at their due places above Sh. Peerzada Shabir Ahmad
as they are still incharge ARTOs and shall necessarily figure in the
seniority of MVIs.
4) The seniority of Sh. Jugal Kishore has to be restored above to Sh.
Mukhtar Ahmad Sofi and others because as per the selection letter
of Service Selection Board Shri Jugal Kishore figures above Shri
Mukhtar Ahmad Sofi and others.
5) The date of appointment recorded aganst Shri Kuldeep Singh as
27/03/2009 noods to be recorded as "27/03/2008". Moreover, since
Neeraj Sharma figures above to Shri Kuldeep Singh in selection list
therefore the claim of Shri Kuldeep Singh that he is senior to Neeraj
Sharma does not merits any consideration.
6) This disposes off all the communications received by the Committee
in this connection.
22.
This Court firmly holds that the Statute Book of Rules 1974, in Schedule
“A” provided for the original post of the Motor Vehicle Inspectors and, if at all,
the same has to be dealt with as a base point for the promotees or direct recruits,
then the Government fundamentally failed in its statutory duty by promoting
individuals who lacked the requisite minimum qualifications and, particularly,
when the prescribed mode of recruitment was designated as 100% via direct
recruitment. Even if, due to the long passage of time and the various judgments
rendered and if the issues surrounding direct recruitment could be mitigated, this
Court remains firmly of the opinion that the core eligibility criteria and basic
qualification which is required cannot be substituted by any alternative mode.
The view of the Court is further strengthened by the Statute provided in Motor
Vehicles Act 1989, whereby in Section 213, the powers have been envisaged to
lay down the minimum qualification by the Central Government in Sub-section
(4) and such powers have been exercised by S.O.443 whereby minimum
qualifications have been laid down and which are also in tandem with Schedule
“A” of Rules 1974. Thus, deviating from the Rules which are the eligibility and
basic parameters for appointment to the post is not possible. However, previous
implementation of the recommendations of the High Power Committee giving
training to the people who are not qualified for the job, as recommended by the
Committee, also shows that what the Government wanted in the present case and
how it saw the issue of promotions. However, looking into the past factual
matrix and the judgments rendered in the cases of Gurmeet Singh (supra) and
Rajesh Gupta and ors vs, State and ors. (SWP No. 1195/2006) and drawing
the overall analogy, this Court deems it appropriate to restrict its adjudication
only to the seniority list rather than going into the basic promotions which have
happened more than 20 years ago. So the core adjudication remains the seniority
list, the process of drawing the seniority list by giving the promotions to the
persons who are eligible in terms of Rules of 1974 read with the Act of 1988 as
also the SO 443, it will be, in the fitness of things that in seniority list, direct
recruits are given preference and they remain over and above the promotees. The
sequence has to be done as per the various recommendations which are recorded
and some prime parts of them have already been reproduced. Thus, while
standing by the direct recruits, who are qualified and eligible and not relying
upon the proposed or draft rules, this Court finds that standing on the pedestal of
the statutes of Rules of 1974, the Act of 1988 would be in accordance with law
to resolve the limited issue by the Court.
22.
Thus, while setting aside the impugned order(s), we direct that the
seniority list be strictly maintained while keeping the direct recruits over and
above the promotees and the promotees, as per the decision taken by the
Government shall, continue to be at the bottom of the seniority list only to
maintain the equitable parameters, which have been consistently laid down by
the previous judgments of this Court, particularly, in Gurmeet Singh‟s case
(supra) as also the Policy Recommendations of the Government itself. Such
position of law is being only laid in the peculiar factual matrix by limiting its
adjudication to seniority part.
23.
Both the writ petitions are allowed. The disposal of the writ petitions in
the manner mentioned above, shall not preclude the Government to operate the
seniority list for future promotions.
24.
The petitions are, accordingly, disposed of along with connected
applications.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
(DR. PUSHPENDRA SINGH BHATI)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Jammu
04.11.2026
Sunita
Whether the order is speaking.
Whether the order is reportable.
Yes
Yes.
SUNITA KOUL
2026.11.16 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review