Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
"
!
%
&
!
# !
!
"
%%
!
!
%%
!
!
%%
*
Digitally signed
by SACHIN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
#
#
'
(
*+
+
"$
# !
&
!
#
"
)
-2-
! "#
!
! $$
!
%
&
'
'
! ()
!
* '$(+
&
, (*( #+
&
-(*( #'
$
+
&
&
%
&
-(*( #'
'
.
$
(+
+
%
++# '# $
&
#$ '# )
&
++# '# $
%
-3-
*
+
&
&
!
!
%
, (*( #'
'
&
-(*( #'
$
&
&
%
-(*( #'
'
(+
$
%
+$) '# $
-4-
&
#$ '# )
&
+$) '# $
%
*
+
&
!
!
!
!
'
&
$
&
!
!
%
, (*( #'
+
&
(
-(*( #'
&
&
-5-
%
-(*( #'
$.
+
(+
(
%
++
'# $
++
'# $
&
#$ '# )
&
%
!
!
/
/
#
!
/
01 1 233124 251 67418 9: ;01 91<167=725: =02441<>7<>
;01 ?@8>A1<; 2<8 2B258 32
18 9: ;01
7D74 @8>1 2; &2429@2>7 7<
C ++
'# $ 82;18
#$ '# )
887;7C<24
1<7C5
+$) 2<8 ++# C6
-6-
'
42<8
CD15<A1<; C6 &25<2;2E2 2=F@7518 ;01
C6 ;01 357D2;1 51 3C<81<;
G42<8 4C 15 H 7< ;01 1 233124
<1B 5274B2: 47<1
:
C
01<=16C5;0 51615518 2
6C5 ;01 3@53C 1 C6 42:7<> 2
01 2=F@7518 42<8
$ ' A12 @57<> #$ 2=51 $* >@<;2
+ $ A12 @57<> #$ 2=51 '' >@<;2
A12 @57<> #+ 2=51
7442>1
@4925>2
<C;767=2;7C< @<815
B2 7
B151 91257<>
#( >@<;2
:
C
+
:
C
$
2<8
7;@2;18 2;
C5?2A9>2
24@E 2<8
7 ;57=; 51 31=;7D14:
1=;7C< +
C6 ;01
=;
@18 C<
2<8
=F@7 7;7C<
'# # 6C44CB18 9: 2 67<24 <C;767=2;7C<
82;18 '" #* '#
$
< 2B258 B2
18 9: ;01
2<8
=F@7 7;7C<
667=15 81;15A7<7<> ;01 =CA31< 2;7C< 32:2941 2; 2 @A C6
01 42<8 4C 15 61147<> 2>>571D18 9:
$+ I(+ - 315 2=51
;01 =CA31< 2;7C< 81;15A7<18
1=;7C<
*
B07=0
C6 ;01
2<8
C ++
'# $ +$) '# $ 2<8 ++# '# $ B151
51>7 ;1518 916C51 ;01
&2429@52>7
C@>0; 516151<=1 @<815
01 =427A2<;
=F@7 7;7C<
887;7C<24
=;
*)+ 6C44CB7<>
1<7C5
7D74
@8>1
67418 ;0175 51 31=;7D1 =427A
-7-
31;7;7C<
=C<;1<87<> ;02; ;01: 028 527 18 2 92<2<2
342<;2;7C< 7< ;0175 42<8
2<8 B151 24 C 527 7<> D1>1;2941
2 2< 7<;15 =5C3
01 =427A 31;7;7C< B151 C9?1=;18 9: ;01
2331442<; 01517<
<
42<8 4C 15
@33C5; C6 ;01 =427A 31;7;7C<
B151 1J2A7<18 2<8 ;01: A25E18 8C=@A1<;
01 2331442<; 24 C 1J2A7<18 C<1 C6 7;
2<8
;01
A25E18
8C=@A1<;
8C=@A1<;25: 1D781<=1
2 18
;01
C<
16151<=1
C667=724
;01
C524
2<8
C@5; =C< 781518
;01 <2;@51 2<8 615;747;: C6 ;01 42<8 2<8 ;2E7<> 7<;C
=C< 78152;7C< ;01 62=; ;02; ;01 42<8
7< F@1 ;7C< B151
7557>2;18 42<8
0148 ;02; ;01 42<8
B151
>5CB7<> C<7C<
; 24 C =C< 781518 ;01 A2J7A@A 357=1 C6
C<7C< 2; 2
@A C6
@7;2941 6C5
$ I## - 315 F@7<;24 2<8 ;2E7<> ;01
:7148 315 2=51 2; (# ;C<1 2557D18 2; ;01 D24@1 C6 ;01 C<7C<
>5CB< 2; 2 @A C6 Rs.
*# ### - 315 2=51 C@; C6 B07=0 7;
818@=;18 (#K ;CB258 ;01 =C ; C6 =@4;7D2;7C< 2<8 2557D18
2; ;01 <1; D24@1 C6 2
@A C6
)# ### - 315 2=51
;
2334718 A@4;734715
# 2<8 =C< 781518 ;01 A25E1; D24@1 C6
;01 2=F@7518 42<8
2; 2
@A C6
) ## ### - 315 2=51
-8-
2E7<> 7<;C 2==C@<; ;02; ;01 42<8 4C 15
=5C3
=C@48 527 1 ;BC
7< 2 :125 7; 0148 ;02; ;01 D24@1 C6 ;01 =5C3
=C@48 91 >5CB< 7< ;01 42<8 B2 2 @A C6
0@
;02;
* ## ### -
7; 244CB18 ;01 516151<=1 2<8 1<02<=18 =CA31< 2;7C<
65CA
$+ I(+ - 315 2=51 ;C 2 @A C6
* ## ### - 315
2=51
; 24 C 0148 ;02; ;01 42<8 4C 15
251 1<;7;418 ;C
C42;7@A 2; $#K C< ;01 1<02<=18 =CA31< 2;7C< 2<8
7<;151 ; 2; ;01 52;1 C6 )K 315 2<<@A 6C5 ;01 675 ; :125
65CA ;01 82;1 C6 ;01 <C;767=2;7C< @<815
1=;7C< +
(K 315 2<<@A 6C5 ;01
;744 813C 7;
@9 1F@1<; :125
24 C 0148 ;02; ;01 42<8 4C 15
A25E1; D24@1 C6
2<8
=;
65CA
;01
B144
;01
F@2<;@A
16151<=1
C6
=CA31< 2;7C<
C6 ;01
C6 2335CD24 C6
; 8751=;18 ;01
2331442<;
=CA31< 2;7C< 7< 1F@24 35C3C5;7C<
;01
1=;7C< '$
82;1
<C;767=2;7C< ;C ;01 82;1 C6 ;01 2B258
CD15<A1<;
;
251 1<;7;418 6C5 2887;7C<24
'K 315 2<<@A @<815
=F@7 7;7C<
2<8
;C
32:
;2;1
;01
17<> 2>>571D18 9:
81;15A7<18
C@5; ;01 2331442<; 7 7< ;01 1 233124
9:
;01
-9-
+
01 4125<18 =C@< 14 6C5 ;01 2331442<; =C<;1<818
;02; ;01 42<8 4C 15
=427A18 7< ;0175 =427A 31;7;7C<
;01: 028 244 527 18 2 92<2<2 342<;2;7C<
;02;
1 =C<;1<818
;02; 1J=13; 2< 1<;5: 7< 2 51D1<@1 51=C58 5142;7<> ;C 42<8 7<
@5D1:
;01
C
$
278 42<8
B07=0
0CB18 ;02; C<7C< B2
244 ;01 =427A2<;
527 18 2 92<2<2 342<;2;7C<
;01
16151<=1
>5CB< 7<
=427A18 ;02; ;01: 028
1 ;01516C51 =C<;1<818 ;02;
C@5; =C@48 <C; 02D1 =C< 781518 C<7C< 2
;01 =5C3 >5CB< 9: ;01 =427A2<;
1 24 C =C<;1<818 ;02;
;0151 7 <C;07<> ;C 0CB ;02; ;BC =5C3 C6 C<7C< =C@48 91
527 18 7< 2 :125 2<8 ;01516C51 ;01
=CAA7;;18 2 157C@ 155C5 7< 2
16151<=1
C@5;
@A7<> @<;C 7; 146 ;02; ;01
=427A2<;
B151 1<;7;418 ;C =CA31< 2;7C< 9: =C< 78157<>
C<7C< 2
;01 =5C3 >5CB< 7< ;01 42<8
=C<;1<818 ;02; ;01
16151<=1
2=F@7518
1 24 C
C@5; =CAA7;;18 2< 155C5 7<
2B2587<> 7<;151 ; 2; ;01 52;1 C6 )K 315 2<<@A 65CA ;01
82;1 C6 ;01 35147A7<25: <C;767=2;7C< 7< ;128 C6 65CA ;01
82;1 C6 87 3C
7C<
- 10 -
(
01 4125<18 =C@< 14 6C5 ;01 42<8 4C 15
C;015 02<8 =C<;1<818 ;02; ;01 42<8
7;@2;18
C5?2A9>2
7< 2
@4925>2
1 8C1
7442>1
C< ;01
7< F@1 ;7C< 251
24@E 2<8
7 ;57=;
<C; 87 3@;1 ;01 62=; ;02; ;01 42<8
4C 15 028 ;2;18 7< ;0175 =427A 31;7;7C< ;02; ;01: 028 244
527 18 92<2<2 342<;2;7C< 7< ;0175 51 31=;7D1 42<8
@9A7;;18 ;02; 7< 51 31=; C6 2=F@7 7;7C< C6 42<8 7<
7442>1 7< ;15A C6 2 <C;767=2;7C< 82;18
3@53C 1
C6
1<02<=18
65CA
I
A7<C5
;01
@A
$+ (##
+ "## - 315 2=51
27418 916C51 ;07
7<>41 @8>1 C6 ;07
1 =C<;1<8
28<CC5
+ #* '##" 6C5 ;01
7557>2;7C<
C6
=CA31< 2;7C<
;C
;02; ;01
@A
C@5; 7<
C '##$$
C@5; 7< ;15A
C6 2 ?@8>A1<; 82;18
' "# ### - 315 2=51
?@8>A1<; ;01
5C9
C6
2A1 B2
'#'' 2<8 2
'" #" '#'$ 028 1<02<=18 ;01 =CA31< 2;7C< ;C 2
;07
B2
@A C6
1 24 C =C<;1<8 ;02; 6C44CB7<>
7D7 7C<
1<=0 C6 ;07
C@5; 7<
C '###"$ '# I 028 1<02<=18 ;01 =CA31< 2;7C< ;C
@A C6
28<CC5
' "# ### - 315 2=51
7442>1 7
7<
07;;23@5
1 =C<;1<8
24@E B07=0 7
;02;
625 2B2:
- 11 -
65CA
@4925>2
7;: 2<8 ;01516C51 ;01 D24@1 C6 ;01 42<8
2=F@7518 7 A@=0 AC51 ;02< B02; B2 2=F@7518 7<
28<CC5
7442>1
28<CC5
1 6@5;015 =C<;1<8
;02; ;01 42<8
7<
7442>1 B151 2=F@7518 7< ;01 :125 '##" 2<8 76 1 =242;7C< 7
244CB18 2;
#K =@A@42;7D14:
1<;7;418 ;C =CA31< 2;7C< C6 2
2=51
;01 42<8 4C 15
@A C6
BC@48 91
I )# $"# - 315
1 ;01516C51 =C<;1<818 ;02; ;01 =CA31< 2;7C<
81;15A7<18 9: ;01
16151<=1
C@5; 7
<C; 1JC597;2<; 9@;
7 512 C<2941 2 ;01 42<8 C6 ;01 42<8 4C 15 7 7<
24@E 2<8 =CAA2<8 2 07>015 A25E1; D24@1
;02; 7< D71B C6 ;01 ?@8>A1<; C6 ;01
C6
31J
@4925>2
1 @9A7;
C@5; 7< ;01 =2 1
2 42<8 4C 15 7
<C; =C<=15<18 B7;0 ;01 3@53C 1 6C5 B07=0 ;01 42<8 7
2=F@7518 2<8 ;02; ;01
0C@48 81;15A7<1 ;01
2A1
2AC@<; C6 =CA31< 2;7C< 7< 51 31=; C6 244 42<8 4C 15
;01516C51 =C<;1<8
C@5;
;02; 76 ;01 2=F@7 7;7C< 7<
28<CC5
7442>1 7 ;2E1< 2 2 :258 ;7=E ;01< ;01 =CA31< 2;7C< 6C5
2=F@7 7;7C< C6 42<8
2;
C5?2A9>2
7442>1 B744 02D1 ;C 91
- 12 -
2335C3572;14: =24=@42;18 2<8 76 8C<1 ;01 =427A2<;
91 1<;7;418 ;C 2 @A C6
I
* ## ### - 315 2=51
51>258
2B25818 9: ;01
<C;767=2;7C< @<815
BC@48
;01 7<;151 ; 2; )K 315 2<<@A
16151<=1
C@5; 65CA ;01 82;1 C6
1=;7C< +
01 62754: =C<=1818 ;02; ;01
=427A2<; 251 1<;7;418 ;C 7<;151 ; 2; )K 315 2<<@A 6C5 ;01
675 ; :125 65CA ;01 82;1 C6 87 3C
"
7C<
1 02D1 =C< 781518 @9A7
6C5 ;01 91<167=725: 2
42<8 4C 15
2B258 32
B144 2
7C< C6 ;01 4125<18
;01 4125<18 =C@< 14 6C5 ;01
1 02D1 24 C 315@ 18 ;01 ?@8>A1<; 2<8
18 9: ;01
16151<=1
C@5; 2
B144 2
7;
51=C58
*
< ;01 =427A 31;7;7C<
67418 9: ;01 42<8 4C 15
;01: 02D1 31=767=244: ;2;18 ;02; ;01 42<8 2=F@7518 B151
244 7557>2;18 42<8
427A2<; 02D1 =427A18 ;02; ;01 D24@1
C6 ;01 42<8 2=F@7518 7 AC51 ;02<
< ;01 1D781<=1 51=C5818 916C51 ;01
=427A2<;
'( ## ### - 315 2=51
16151<=1
C@5; ;01
02D1 244 =C<;1<818 ;02; ;01: 028 527 18 2
- 13 -
92<2<2 342<;2;7C< 7< ;01 42<8 2<8 B151 24 C 527 7<> =0744:
C<7C< 2<8 D1>1;2941 2 2< 7<;15 =5C3
;02; ;01: 028 342<;18
01: 02D1 =427A18
' # 92<2<2 342<;
B151 >1;;7<> :7148 C6 +# ;C<1 315 2=51
315 2=51 2<8
01 62=; ;02; ;01
=427A2<; 02D1 527 18 92<2<2 342<;2;7C< 7 <C; 87 3@;18 7<
;0175 =5C
-1J2A7<2;7C<
CB1D15 ;01 51D1<@1 51=C58 7<
51 31=; C6 ;01 42<8 2=F@7518 6C5 ;01 5141D2<; :125 8C <C;
7<87=2;1 ;02; ;01 =427A2<; 028 527 18 2 92<2<2 342<;2;7C<
)
1 ;02; 2 7; A2: ;01 42<8 7< F@1 ;7C< 471 =4C 1
;C &2A2423@5 2<8 7 7557>2;18 2<8 ;01516C51 ;01 3C
79747;:
C6 ;01 =427A2<; 527 7<> 92<2<2 342<;2;7C< =2<<C; 91 5@418
C@; 2
&2A2423@5 342<;27< 02
>5CB< 7< ;01 2512
2 4125<18
C '##$$
2=F@7518 7<
-;2> 6C5 ;01 92<2<2
;2;18 9: ;01 4125<18 =C@< 14 6C5
;01 42<8 4C 15
'#''
28<CC5
7<>41 @8>1 C6 ;07
81;15A7<18
;01
C@5; 7<
D24@1
C6
42<8
7442>1 7< ;01 :125 '##" 92 18 C<
=5C3 =237;247 2;7C< 9: ;2E7<> 92<2<2 2 ;01 A2?C5 =5C3 2<8
028 81;15A7<18 ;01 =CA31< 2;7C< 32:2941 2; 2
$
$
-
07 2B258 7
2;7 6718 9: ;01
@A C6
=F@757<>
- 14 -
@;0C57;: 2<8 01<=1 =2< 91 ;2E1< 2 2 261 7<87=2;C5
7 <C; 7< 87 3@;1 ;02;
65CA ;01 42<8
28<CC5
7442>1 7
7< F@1 ;7C<
' "# ### - 2
;
7;@2;18 625 2B2:
6 B1 ;2E1 2
@A C6
;01 D24@1 C6 92<2<2 =5C3 7< ;01 :125
'##" 2<8 62=;C5 *K 315 2<<@A 2
;01 1 =242;7C< 7< ;01
D24@1 C6 ;01 =5C3 ;01 D24@1 C6 ;01 =5C3 BC@48 91 2 @A C6
( )) *$+ - 5C@<818 C66 ;C
;02; D71B C6 ;01 A2;;15
I ## ### - 315 2=51
<
B1 =C< 7815 7; 2335C3572;1 ;C
81;15A7<1 ;01 D24@1 C6 ;01 42<8
2=F@7518 9: ;512;7<>
92<2<2 2 ;01 A2?C5 =5C3 2<8 518@=1 ;01 =CA31< 2;7C< C6
* ## ### - 315 2=51 2B25818 9: ;01
;C 2
@A C6
@9 15D1
;01
I ## ### - 315 2=51
1<8
C6
?@ ;7=1
16151<=1
;01
C@5;
BC@48 24 C
=CA31< 2;7C<
81;15A7<18 9: @ 7 ?@ ; 2<8 512 C<2941
#
@5;015
57>0;4: =C<;1<818 9: ;01 4125<18
=C@< 14 6C5 ;01 91<167=725: ;01 =427A2<;
251 1<;7;418 ;C
7<;151 ; 2; ;01 52;1 C6 )K 315 2<<@A 6C5 ;01 675 ; :125
65CA ;01 82;1 C6 ;01: 917<> 87 3C
F@1 ;7C<
18 65CA ;01 42<8 7<
- 15 -
==C587<>4: ;01 6C44CB7<>!
01 233124 251 244CB18 7< 325;
01 =CA31< 2;7C< C6
* ## ### - 315
2=51 81;15A7<18 9: ;01
518@=18 ;C 2
@A C6
16151<=1
C@5; 7
I ## ### - 315
2=51
01 =427A2<; 251 24 C 1<;7;418 ;C C42;7@A
2; $#K C< ;01 518@=18 =CA31< 2;7C< 2<8
7<;151 ; 2; )K 315 2<<@A 6C5 ;01 675 ;
:125
65CA
;01
82;1
C6
;01:
917<>
87 3C
18 2<8 2;
(K 315 2<<@A 6C5
;01
@9 1F@1<; :125
;744 ;01 82;1 C6
813C 7;
7D
7E1B7 1 ;01: 251 1<;7;418 ;C 2887;7C<24
91<167; 2; ;01 52;1 C6
@<815
1=;7C< '$
'K 315 2<<@A
C6 ;01 2<8
=F@7 7;7C<
- 16 -
=;
65CA
;01
82;1
C6
35147A7<25:
<C;767=2;7C< ;744 ;01 82;1 C6 2B258
D
<: 2AC@<; 7< 813C 7; 7
;52< 615518 ;C ;01
'
667=1 7
C581518 ;C 91
16151<=1
C@5;
8751=;18 ;C 51;@5< ;01
C@5;
1=C58
!,*
(
#)
#
( "
7 ;
C!
C ! '+
!,*
#
#
'
")
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review