Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 16TH MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 25.08.2016 IN OA NO.90 OF 2013 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
NORTH BLOCK, PARLIAMENT STREET, NEW DELHI 110 001.
THE CENTRAL BOARD OF EXCISE & CUSTOMS,
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN AND SPECIAL SECRETARY TO
GOVT. OF INDIA, NORTH BLOCK, PARLIAMENT STREET,
NEW DELHI 110 001.
THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS,
CUSTOM HOUSE, WILLINGDON ISLAND, COCHIN
BY ADVS.
SRI.T.V.VINU, CGC
RESPONDENTS/APPLICANT & ADDL.APPLICANTS 2 TO 4:
SHRI K.ACHUTHAN NAIR (DIED),
RESIDING AT XI/532, KATLAMADOM(PALIYAM),
CHENDAMANGALAM, ERNAKULAM 683 512.
VARADHA A NAYAR,
AGED 56 YEARS,
W/O.LATE K.ACHUTHAN NAYAR,RESIDING AT XI/532,
KALLAMADOM (PALIYAM)CHENDAMANGALAM, ERNAKULAM 683 512.
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-22025:KER:24240
YAMINI SATHYAJIT,
AGED 36 YEARS,
W/O.SATHYAJIT SUKUMARANKAMALALAYAM,
MAMBRA P.O.,WEST KORATTY, TRISSUR DISTRICT.
P.RADHAKRISHNAN,
AGED 34 YEARS,
S/O.LATE K.ACHUTHAN NAYAR, RESIDING AT XI/352,
KALLAMADOM (PALIYAM),CHENDAMANGALAM,
ERNAKULAM 683 512
THIS
05.02.2025,
FOLLOWING:
OP
THE
(CAT)
COURT
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
ON
SAME
DAY
THE
HEARD
ON
DELIVERED
THE
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-32025:KER:24240
JUDGMENT
K.V.JAYAKUMAR , J.
The present O.P.(CAT) is preferred against the
order
of
the
Central
Administrative
Tribunal
in
O.A.No.90/2013 dated 25.08.2016, whereby the claim of
the respondents-applicants was allowed.
2.
The facts necessary for disposal of the
controversy are enumerated hereunder:
First respondent – applicant was an employee of
the Central Excise Department. During the pendency of
the
Original
K.Achuthan
Application,
Nayar
died
the
and
his
original
legal
applicant,
heirs
were
impleaded in the party array, as per the order in the
Miscellaneous Application No.937/2016.
K.Achuthan
Nair, the first applicant, approached the tribunal for a
declaration that, he is entitled to get notional promotion
with effect from the date on which his juniors were
promoted to the grade of Assistant Commissioner and
then to Joint Commissioner and also sought for a
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-42025:KER:24240
direction to grant arrears of salary in the higher post.
3.
K.Achuthan
Nayar
was
promoted
as
Appraiser on 30.01.1985 and regularized with effect from
01.04.1989.
The applicant was granted ACP in 2001
with effect from 09.08.1999 and promoted as Appraiser
on 30.01.1985. On completion of eight years, the
applicant became eligible to be promoted as Assistant
Commissioner.
His
Chandramouli
were
juniors
Sri.Phalgunan
promoted
Commissioners in the year 1997.
as
and
Assistant
Chandramouli was
again promoted as Joint Commissioner in 2007.
4.
There were a disciplinary proceedings
and Rule 27(2) proceedings under the Central Civil
Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965
against the deceased applicant, and thus, he was not
considered for promotion till the matter was culminated
by
Annexure
A8
order
passed
by
Administrative Tribunal on 15.11.2011.
the
Central
The applicant
contended that after completion of the disciplinary
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-52025:KER:24240
proceedings, the department was bound to follow sealed
cover procedure, and after the culmination of the
inquiry, the applicant was entitled to be promoted.
5.
The petitioners/respondents resisted the
claim of the 1st applicant contending that, disciplinary
proceedings were initiated against late Achuthan Nayar
while he was working as an Appraiser.
The allegation
against him was that, he attempted to plant a nonexisting
informer
with
a
malafide
intention
of
appropriating the reward amount of Rs.87,00,000/-,
which would have been disbursed to the non-existing
informer. Further allegation was that, he exceeded the
jurisdiction of his official work and actively engaged in
anti smuggling work, like patrolling in the sea.
It was
found by the Inquiry Officer that charge No.1 was proved
against the 1st applicant. Thereafter the disciplinary
authority imposed a penalty of reduction of pay from
Rs.8100/- to 6500/- in the pay of Rs.6500-200-10500 for a
period of one year, with a further direction that, he will
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-62025:KER:24240
not earn any increment of pay during the said period.
When appeal was preferred by the original applicant, the
appellate authority imposed a penalty of dismissal from
service.
6.
The 1st applicant challenged the findings
before the tribunal and also before this Court.
7.
This
Court
vide
judgment
dated
20.12.2006 in W.P.(C)No.25841 of 2006, upheld the
order of the tribunal, with a direction to complete the
proceedings within a period of four months. As per the
order of this Court, the penalty of reduction in pay for a
period of one year was set aside by the appellate
authority.
8.
After
several
rounds
of
litigation
between the parties, in O.A.No.852 of 2011, the Central
Administrative Tribunal set aside all the proceedings and
restored the original minor penalty which was imposed
on 09.05.2001.
9.
On 18.05.2012, the deceased – applicant
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-72025:KER:24240
submitted a representation requesting to revise all his
service benefits. Vide Annexure A20 order passed by the
petitioners/respondents on 28.02.2013, the deceased
applicant was re-instated into service with a direction
that the applicant shall be paid full pay and allowances
for the period from 15.05.2005 to 18.06.2007 and from
07.05.2008 to 22.03.2010, for which he would have been
entitled had he not been dismissed from the service. As
per Annexure A20 order, the period of his absence from
duty due to the dismissal was considered as his duty and
has also been granted the benefit of ACP Scheme.
10.
The
Central
Administrative
Tribunal,
noticing the rival contentions of the parties, disposed of
all the original applications with a direction to grant
notional promotion to the deceased applicant, as if he
was in service on the date when his immediate junior
was granted promotion as Assistant Commissioner and
later as Joint Commissioner.
11.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
first
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-82025:KER:24240
applicant
supported
the
order
of
the
Central
Administrative Tribunal.
12.
On the other hand, learned Central
Government Counsel, Sri.T.V.Vinu, submitted that the
impugned order of the tribunal is patently illegal and
unsustainable.
Learned Central Government Counsel
submitted that the tribunal has failed to appreciate that
as per DoPT O.M. No.22011/5/86 (D) dated 10.04.1989,
while promotions will be made in the order of the
consolidated
list,
such
promotion
will
have
only
prospective effect even in cases where the vacancies
relate to earlier years.
13.
We have heard the rival contentions of
the learned counsel for the parties and appraised the
paper books.
14.
battle
The tribunal noticing the prolonged legal
between
department
with
the
deceased
respect
to
applicant
the
initiation
and
the
of
the
disciplinary proceedings, his dismissal from service for
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-92025:KER:24240
more than two occasions and subsequent reinstatements,
also considering the fact that his juniors were promoted
to the posts of Assistant Commissioner and Joint
Commissioner, held that the deceased applicant was also
entitled to get notional promotion, as if he was in service,
when his immediate junior was granted promotion. The
relevant
paragraphs
of
the
order
in
the
Original
Application are extracted hereinbelow:
“7. If the applicant was under cloud of doubt at the
relevant time when DPC was convened then sealed
cover procedure should have been followed. There is
no case for the respondents that there was any other
legal inhibition granting promotion to the applicant.
See also Annexure A8 order passed by this Tribunal
on 5.11.2011. It was only because the applicant had
chosen
to
file
appeal
against
the
order
passed/penalty initially imposed on the applicant.
Therefore, the penalty initially imposed by the
disciplinary authority awarding reduction to the
minimum of the pay scale for a period of one year
was restored. When that is the position, as has been
said even in Annexure A20, the deceased applicant
must be deemed to have been in service and the
period shown therein should be treated as period
spent on duty and accordingly the deceased
applicant was entitled to get promotion to the next
higher post, as was given to his two immediate
juniors.
8. It is not disputed that applicant was promoted as
Appraiser on 30.1.1985. On completion of eight
years of service, he was eligible to be promoted as
Assistant Commissioner. Shri Chandramouli was
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-102025:KER:24240
junior to the deceased applicant in the cadre of
Appraiser who was promoted as Assistant
Commissioner in 1997. That Chandamouli was again
promoted as Joint Commissioner in 2007. It was only
due to the pendency of the disciplinary proceedings
and proceedings under Rule 27(2) of CCS (CCA)
Rules, the deceased applicant was not considered
for promotion till the matter was culminated by
Annexure A8 order of this Tribunal. Therefore, the
deceased applicant was entitled to get notional
promotion with effect from the date on which his
junior in the grade of Appraiser; namely Shri
Chandramouli was promoted. Consequently the
deceased applicant would be entitled to get further
promotion as Joint Commissioner in the next
hierarchical scale as pleaded by the deceased
applicant.
9. If a penalty is imposed on a government servant
based on disciplinary proceedings, the sealed cover
procedure has to be adopted. After the penalty
period the sealed cover is to be opened and acted
upon as per the rules. His case for promotion is to
be considered by the next DPC in the normal course
and having regard to the penalty imposed on him.
Since the deceased applicant Achuthan Nair was
found guilty in the inquiry and was imposed a
penalty of reduction in pay for one year and that
stood restored as per the order passed by the
Tribunal in Annexure A8, the deceased applicant
was very much available to be considered for
promotion. It is contended that in view of the order
passed under Annexure A8 the deceased applicant
accepted the original minor penalty imposed by the
respondents authority. Since even as per Annexure
A20 the applicant was granted all other benefits, it
has to be held that the applicant was for all practical
purposes entitled to get promotion to the next
higher post when his immediate junior Shri
Chandramouli in the list was promoted as Assistant
Commissioner and later as Joint Commissioner.
10. Since the penalty initially imposed by the
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-112025:KER:24240
disciplinary authority is restored on completion of
the period of one year, he should be restored to the
original position and as such the deceased applicant
was entitled to be considered for promotion on the
dates when his immediate junior was considered and
granted promotion as Assistant Commissioner and
later as Joint Commissioner. But it is made clear
that the applicants 2 to 4 are not entitled to get any
arrears of pay consequent to the notional promotion
of the deceased applicant, but the applicants 2 to 4
would be entitled to get only notional fixation benefit
which will have a bearing on the computation of
retiral benefits/pension applicable to the deceased
applicant. The pension payment order has to be
revised accordingly.
11. In the result this OA is disposed of directing the
respondents to grant notional promotion to the
deceased applicant as if he was in service as on the
date when his immediate junior was granted
promotion as Assistant Commissioner and later as
Joint Commissioner. It is made clear that the
deceased applicant would not have been entitled to
get arrears of salary had he been alive and
consequently the additional applicants 2 to 4 will not
be entitled to get arrears of pay/salary because of
the notional fixation ordered to be done. The
aforesaid notional promotion and fixation of pay will
be counted for re-fixing the pension/retiral benefits
due to the deceased applicant Achuthan Nair. Since
Achuthan Nair died subsequently the family pension
would also have proportionate change in tune with
the pension amount to be consequently fixed. The
aforesaid direction shall be complied with within a
period of two months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order. No order as to costs.”
Upon hearing the submissions of the counsel for
the parties and on perusal of the paper books, we do not
find any illegality or perversity, much less fallacy in the
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-122025:KER:24240
order of the Central Administrative Tribunal. We are in
agreement
with
Administrative
the
reasoning
Tribunal.
interference is made out.
No
of
good
the
Central
ground
O.P.(CAT) fails and thus
dismissed.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
vv
for
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-132025:KER:24240
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 86/2017
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A1
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF PENALTY
NO. DIS 1/95-ESTT. CUS. DATED
10.05.2000.
ANNEXURE A2
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY
THIS HON'BLE TRIBUNAL IN O.A. NO. 508
OF 2005 DATED 03.07.2006.
ANNEXURE A3
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT PASSED BY
THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA IN
W.P.(C) NO. 25841 OF 2006 DATED
20.12.2006.
ANNEXURE A4
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY THE
APPELLATE AUTHORITY F. NO. C-11016-4
7-2000-AD, V/7456 DATED 07.05.2008.
ANNEXURE A5
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY
THIS HON'BLE TRIBUNAL IN O.A. NO.
481/2008 DATED 05.02.2010.
ANNEXURE A6
A TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER
PASSED BY THIS TRIBUNAL ON 13.10.2011
IS IN O.A NO. 852/2011
ANNEXURE A7
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT
FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS IN O.A. NO.
852/2011 DATED 11.11.2011.
ANNEXURE A8
A TRUE COPY OF THE FINAL ORDER PASSED
BY THIS HON'BLE TRIBUNAL IN O.A NO.
852/2011 .
ANNEXURE A8(A)
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF REFIXING
THE SALARY OF THE APPLICANT AFTER THE
PERIOD OF MINOR PENALTY DATED
14.05.2001.
ANNEXURE A9
A TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE OF THE ORDER
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-142025:KER:24240
NO. 60/2007 DATED 19.06.2007.
ANNEXURE A10
A TRUE COPY OF THE PAY SLIP OF THE
APPLICANT FOR THE MONTH OF JULY 2007.
ANNEXURE A11
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER F. NO.
243/46/99-PAY UNIT DATED 06.06.2001.
ANNEXURE A12
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. 45/90
DATED 16.02.1990, PASSED BY THE
PRINCIPAL COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS,
MADRAS.
ANNEXURE A13
A TRUE COPY OF THE CIRCULAR NO. 117/92
COMBINED SENIORITY LIST OF APPRAISERS
UNDER MADRAS CUSTOMS HOUSE DATED
13.12.1992.
ANNEXURE A14
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. 11/92-93
DATED 31.08. 1992 SANCTIONING REWARD
OF RS. 10,000/- TO THE APPLICANT.
ANNEXURE A15
A TRUE COPY OF THE INDIAN CUSTOMS AND
CENTRAL EXCISE GROUP A RECRUITMENT
RULES 1987.
ANNEXURE A16
A TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT EXTRACTS
OF THE CIRCULAR ISSUED BY THE
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA IN THE MATTER OF
PROCEDURE TO BE FOLLOWED BY THE DPC
AFTER COMPLETION OF DISCIPLINARY
PROCEEDINGS.
ANNEXURE A17
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
21.09.2012 RECEIVED UNDER RTI ACT.
ANNEXURE A18
A TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT EXTRACT OF
THE SERVICE BOOK OF THE APPLICANT.
ANNEXURE A19
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION
SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT ON
18.05.2012.
OP (CAT) NO. 86 OF 2017
-152025:KER:24240
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF OA NO.90/2013 DATED
24/1/2013 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT DATED
11/11/2011 FILED BY THE PETITIONERS
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 25/8/2016 IN
OA NO.90 OF 2013 OF THE CAT ERNAKULAM
BENCH
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE MA NO. 1073/13 DATED
20.09.2013 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT IN
THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
ERNAKULAM BENCH.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review