The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. Having analysed the legal position as above, we would now come to the specific qualification of the applicant as could be seen from a reading of the impugned order. It is pertinent to note that the Tribunal had not called for the application and also the decision which made the minds of the authorities from rejecting the application of the applicant. Be that as it may, from the indisputed facts as could be seen from the order impugned, it is clear that the applicant had studied 2025:KER:27253 Malayalam only up to 9th standard and whereas she had opted for Sanskrit for the 10th Standard thereby making her ineligible for applying to the post pursuant to Annexure-A1 notification. Therefore, we are clear in mind that the applicant was not eligible for applying to the post and accordingly, the Tribunal ought not to have granted the interim order allowing the candidate to appear provisionally for the examination. The result of the above discussion leads to a conclusion that the petitioners are entitled to succeed. Accordingly, the Original Petition is allowed. Ext.P3 order dated
16. 10.2023 in O.A.No.590/2021 of the Central Administrative Tribunal is set aside. The restriction placed by this Court in its interim order dated 5.4.2024 is lifted. The Original Application would stand accordingly dismissed. No order as to costs.”
8. The issue involved in this matter is no longer res integra. In view of the above judgment, this OP(CAT) is allowed setting aside the impugned order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal. Sd/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27253
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP (CAT) NO. 206 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 16.10.2023 IN OA NO.180/588/2021
OF CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS IN OA:
UNION OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATION DEPARTMENT
OF POSTS, REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DAK BHAVAN,
SANSAD MARG NEW DELHI, PIN - 110001
THE CHIEF POST MASTER GENERAL KERALA
OFFICE OF THE CHIEF POST MASTER GENERAL P.M.G
JUNCTION, TRIVANDRUM, PIN - 695033
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICE
IDUKKI DIVISION, THODUPUZHA, PIN - 865584
BY ADV S.KRISHNA
RESPONDENTS/APPLICANT IN OA:
PRIYA RAMESH, AGED 33 YEARS, W/O RAMESH KUMAR K
MOOVELIPARAMBIL GLENMARY P O, PEERMADE, NOW WORKING
AS BRANCH POST MASTER BRANCH POST OFFICE, KALTHOTTI,
AYYAPPANKOVIL, IDUKKI, PIN - 685531
ROOBEN, AGED 36 YEARS, S/O KJANAYYA KARUPPAN COLONY,
SOORYANELLI P O CHINNAKKANAL, IDUKKI, NOW WORKING AS
ASSISTANT BRANCH POST MASTER BRANCH POST OFFICE,
CHINNAKKANA, PIN - 685618
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 28.03.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
JUDGMENT
K. V. JAYAKUMAR, J
This OP(CAT) is preferred by the Union of India and its officers
challenging the order dated 16.10.2023 of the Central Administrative
Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench, whereby the Central Administrative
Tribunal has allowed the claim of the applicants.
2.
Succinctly, the facts in brief are as follows:
The applicants are engaged as Gramin Dak Sevak Mail
Deliverer (GDS MD) to various places in Kerala under the postal
department. The Chief Post Master General issued notification dated
04.10.2021 inviting applications for Limited Departmental Competent
Examination (LDCE) to the post of Postman and Mail Guard.
3.
As per the said notification, the eligibility criteria
under clause 3(ii)(a) and (c) were 10 th standard pass from a recognized
Board and that the candidate should have studied local language
(Malayalam) atleast upto 10th standard.
4.
The applicants responded to the notification. Their
applications were not entertained on the ground that, each of the
applicants has not studied Malayalam atleast upto 10 th standard. The
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
validity of clause 3(ii)(c) of notification dated 04.10.2021 and clause (ii)
of column 7 of schedule of the Recruitment Rules 2018 to the extent of
providing that the candidate should have studied local language atleast
upto 10th standard was challenged on the ground of violation of Article 14,
15, 16 and 29(1) of the Constitution of India and ultra vires to the
provisions of the Constitution and was hence illegal.
5.
The
Central
Administrative
Tribunal,
after
considering the rival contentions of the applicants and the Union of India
allowed the claim in the following manner:
“32. Having considered the entire facts in the
above perspective it is only to be held that the OAs are
liable to be allowed holding that the impugned clauses
are arbitrary, unconstitutional and cannot be sustained in
the eye of law.
33. In the result all the OAs stands allowed as
follows:
i) Clause 7(ii) in the Recruitment Rule No.
GSR 899(E) dated 20th September, 2018 to the
extent of prescribing that "The candidate should
have studied local language at least up to 10th
standard” stands quashed.
ii) Clause No. 3(ii)(c) in the notification
No. B2/2-4/2019, dated 26.8.2019 for recruitment to
the post of Postman and Mail Guard from eligible
MTS and GDS for the vacancy for the year 2018 to
the extent of prescribing that "The candidate
should
have
studied
local
language
(Malayalam) at least up to 10th standard”
stands quashed.
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
ⅲ) In the light of the above, the results of
the candidates including that of the applicants who
have been successful in the qualifying examination
shall be considered in accordance with law and the
results shall be finalized and declared by the
Department as expeditiously as possible at any rate
within 3 months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order as if the above offending clauses are not in
existence.
34. OAs are allowed to the above extent. No costs.”
6.
The sole question involved in this OP(CAT) is
whether clause 3(ii)(a) and (c) of the notification dated 04.10.2021 fixing
the eligibility criteria that candidates should have studied local language
(Malayalam) atleast upto 10th standard is violative of Article 14, 15, 16 and
29(1) of the Constitution.
7.
The aforesaid issue was considered by a Division
Bench of this Court [in which one of us is a member, Justice Amit Rawal]
in OP(CAT) No.62/2024. The relevant paragraphs of the said judgment
are extracted hereunder:
9. A perusal of the order impugned reveals that
the Tribunal had considered the principles laid down by
the Supreme Court in V.N.Sunanda Reddy & Ors. v.
State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. [AIR 1995 SC
914]. We are afraid that the reliance placed by the
Tribunal on the aforesaid judgment was completely
misplaced. The Tribunal misdirected itself to the entire
issue at large. The facts of the case in V.N.Sunanda
Reddy (supra) was entirely different and had no
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
relevance to the facts in the present case. In
V.N.Sunanda Reddy (supra), the Supreme Court was
considering a case where weightage was given in a
selection to a post to those persons who had studied in
Telugu Medium school. On an analysis of the various
provisions of the Constitution of India, the Supreme
Court came to the conclusion that the said weightage of
giving additional marks to persons who had passed in
Telugu Medium does not stand the test of Articles 14 and
16 of the Constitution of India and accordingly, had
declared the said weightage as invalid.
10. On an analysis of the law laid by the
Supreme Court, we fail to see as to how the Central
Administrative Tribunal could have applied the principles
laid down in the above judgment to the case on hand. A
close reading of the order impugned would show that the
Tribunal held in the absence of any satisfactory material
to satisfy that there were valid reasons for introducing
such clause in the present Rules and the fact that the
anterior and posterior Recruitment Rules did not contain
such Rules clearly shows that the provisions were
arbitrarily introduced and not supported by any
justifiable reasons. We do not subscribe to the said
finding, especially in view of the fact that the restriction
which is stated to have been caused as per Annexure-A1
notification and Annexure-A5 Rules, does stand the test
of Article 16 of the Constitution of India. Therefore, the
discrimination based on the language cannot be a ground
to test the validity of a Recruitment Rules.
11. Still further, it is pertinent to note that
Annexure-A5 Recruitment Rules though challenged was
not interfered with. What was interfered with was the
posterior rules, namely Recruitment Rules of 2018 and
the notification issued on this behalf. The notification
which was interfered by the Tribunal was not applicable
to the case of the applicant, since she admittedly did not
apply pursuant to such notification.
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
12. Even assuming for a moment that the
reasoning adopted by the Tribunal was a plausible one,
even then, we are not persuaded to hold that merely
because such restriction was not contained in the anterior
and posterior Rules, the Recruitment Rules could be
challenged on the ground of inequality under Article 16 of
the Constitution of India.
13. It is advantageous to point out that in the
revised Recruitment Rules, which was issued on
30.8.2023, there is a separate prescription by which the
person who does not posses the knowledge of a local
language had applied for appointment, would be required
to pass a test in the local language to be conducted in the
manner as decided by the Postal circle concerned and
passing of such local language test shall be a precondition for completion of probation. We have referred
to the aforesaid Rules only to drive home the point that
the requirement of knowledge of local language was
always in the mind of the petitioners, either expressly
under the Recruitment Rules, which would disable the
candidate from applying or though not expressly
provided under the Recruitment Rules, which would
enable such candidate to apply, such candidates are
required to pass test in the local language as a
precondition for passing their probation. Therefore, the
requirement of having a knowledge in the local language
was always in minds of the petitioners/respondents,
insofar as selection to the post of GDS-MD was
concerned.
14. Having analysed the legal position as
above, we would now come to the specific qualification of
the applicant as could be seen from a reading of the
impugned order. It is pertinent to note that the Tribunal
had not called for the application and also the decision
which made the minds of the authorities from rejecting
the application of the applicant. Be that as it may, from
the indisputed facts as could be seen from the order
impugned, it is clear that the applicant had studied
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
Malayalam only up to 9th standard and whereas she had
opted for Sanskrit for the 10th Standard thereby making
her ineligible for applying to the post pursuant to
Annexure-A1 notification. Therefore, we are clear in mind
that the applicant was not eligible for applying to the post
and accordingly, the Tribunal ought not to have granted
the interim order allowing the candidate to appear
provisionally for the examination. The result of the above
discussion leads to a conclusion that the petitioners are
entitled to succeed. Accordingly, the Original Petition is
allowed.
Ext.P3
order
dated
16.10.2023
in
O.A.No.590/2021 of the Central Administrative Tribunal
is set aside. The restriction placed by this Court in its
interim order dated 5.4.2024 is lifted.
The Original Application would stand
accordingly dismissed. No order as to costs.”
8.
The issue involved in this matter is no longer res
integra. In view of the above judgment, this OP(CAT) is allowed setting
aside the impugned order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/-
K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
Sbna/
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 206/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A5
TRUE COPY OF THE CLAUSE A1C) OF THE
NOTIFICATION
NO.
RECTT/12-2/2021
DATED
04.10.2021.
Annexure A1
A TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
POSTMAN RECRUITMENT RULES, 2017.
Annexure A2
A TRUE COPY OF THE KERALA OFFICIAL LANGUAGE
LEGISLATION ACT, 1969.
Annexure A3
A TRUE COPY OF THE GOVT. ORDER NO. ,GO(MS)
NO. 697 DATED 1.9.1965
Annexure A4
A TRUE COPY OF THE GOVT. ORDER NO. 1708/2018/SPB-1 DATED 16.5.2019.
Annexure A6
A TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER IN
M.A.NO.180/00652/2021
IN
OA.NO.180/00708/2019
DATED
25.10.2021
PASSED BY THIS HON'BLE TRIBUNAL
Annexure R1
TRUE COPY OF THE POSTMAN AND MAIL GUARD
RECRUITMENT RULES -2O18
Annexure R2
TRUE COPY OF POSTMAN AND MAIL GUARD (GROUP
C' POST) RECRUITMENT (AMENDMENT) RULES,
Annexure R3
A TRUE COPY OF KERALA OFFICIAL LANGUAGE
(LEGISLATION) AMENDMENT 1973 (ACT 15 OF
1973].
Annexure R4
A TRUE COPY OF ANNEXURE E OF POSTAL
DIRECTORATE LETTER NO. 17-O8/20L8-SPB-I
DATED 10.05.2019
Annexure R5
A TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 27.10.2016 IN OA
NO. 191/2O15
Annexure R6
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF THE HONLCLE
OP(CAT) No.206/2024
2025:KER:27253
SUPREME
COURT
IN
PUSHPARAAI & OTHERS
UNIONOF
INDIA
VS.
Annexure A7
TRUE COPY OF THE RESULTS PUBLISHED UNDER
LETTER NO.RECTT/12-2/2021(CON) DATED 26-052022
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION
DATED 01.11.2021 IN O.A. NO. 180/00588/2021
FILED BEFORE THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL, EMAKULAM BENCH BY THE RESPONDENTS
Exhibit P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT DATED
22.02.2022 IN O.A. NO.180/00588/2021, FILED
BEFORE THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
ERNAKULAM BENCH BY THE PETITIONERS
Exhibit P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 16.10.2023
IN O.A. NO. 180/00588/2021, ISSUED BY THE
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, EMAKULAM
BENCH
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE MA.NO.392/2022 IN OA.NO.
588/2021 ON THE FILE OF THE HONBLE TRIBUNAL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review