Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
MONDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 12TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 30.05.2019 IN WP(C) NO.22171 OF
2012 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS 1-4 AND 6&7:
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE
(DEPARTMENT OF FOOD), KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI-110 001.
THE PAY AND ACCOUNTS OFFICER,
CENTRAL PENSION ACCOUNTING OFFICE,
MINISTRY OF FINANCE,GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
TRIKOOT II COMPLEX,BHIKAJI CAMA PLACE,
NEW DELHI-110 066.
THE ZONAL MANAGER,
THE FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA,
HADDOWS ROAD, CHENNAI-600 006.
THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR FOOD
FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA, SOUTHERN REGION,
CHENNAI HOUSE, 7, ESPELANADE,CHENNAI-600 106.
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS,
FOOD AND PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION, NEW DELHI-110 001.
THE SENIOR ACCOUNTS OFFICER,
PAY AND ACCOUNTS OFFICE,
MINISTRY OF FOOD AND PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION,
SASTHRI BHAVAN,CHENNAI-600 006.
BY ADV.
SRI.T.C.KRISHNA, ASG (IN CHARGE)
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-22025:KER:26708
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER & 6TH RESPONDENT:
P.M.ROCKEY,
AGED 79 YEARS, PALLIPARAMBIL HOUSE,
H.NO.XX/2492, PERUMPADAPPU,
PALLURUTHY P.O., KOCHI-682 006.
THE BRANCH MANAGER,
CANARA BANK, THOPPUMPADY, KOCHI-5.
BY ADV.:
SRI K R GANESH
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
03.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-32025:KER:26708
JUDGMENT
AMIT RAWAL, J.
The present intra-court appeal at the instance of
the Union of India, respondent Nos.1 to 4 and Additional
respondent Nos.6 and 7 before the writ court, is directed
against the judgment dated 30.05.2019 rendered in Writ
Petition No.22171 of 2012, whereby the following reliefs
have been sought:
“(I)
issue a writ of certiorari or any other
appropriate order for direction to Exhibit
P9 order passed by the respondents
revising the pension of the petitioner.
ii)
issue a writ of Mandamus or any other
appropriate writ, order or direction
directing the respondents to disburse the
pensionary benefits to the petitioner and
continue to pay the same in accordance
with the directions contained in Exhibit
P5 judgment.”
2. Vide the judgment impugned, Ext.P9 order
dated 28.08.2012 revising the pension of the respondent
– petitioner at Rs.4,274/- (Rupees Four thousand two
hundred and seventy four only) from 01.01.1997 to
31.12.2006 and Rs.9901/- from 01.01.2007 has been set
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-42025:KER:26708
aside as the respondent – petitioner, prior to Ext.P9 was
allegedly drawing Rs.6100/- (Rupees Six thousand one
hundred only) from 01.01.1997 to 31.12.2006 instead of
Rs.4,274/- (Rupees Four thousand two hundred and
seventy four only), by relying upon the Single Bench
judgment of this Court vide Ext.P5 dated 29.01.2003,
upheld by the Division Bench along with other connected
matters vide judgment dated 01.10.2002 Ext.P6 and
affirmed by the Honourable Supreme Court in Civil
Appeal
No.238-244-2004
vide
judgment
dated
10.02.2010 Ext.P7.
3.
The
facts
in
narrow
compass
are
Government
employees,
on
enumerated hereinbelow:
All
the
Central
setting up of the Food Corporation of India (FCI) were
given option to opt for the absorption in the service of
FCI and benefits as per the provisions of Section 12A(4)
of the Food Corporations Act, 1964 and other terminal
benefits as applicable to the employees of the Central
Government. It is pertinent to mention here that there
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-52025:KER:26708
were two kinds of pay scales i.e., the Industrial Dearness
Allowance (IDA) pattern pay scale drawn in the FCI and
the Central Dearness Allowance (CDA) Pay scale of the
Central Government.
Most of the employees including
the respondent - petitioner opted for the IDA pay scale
on
absorption
and
retirement
benefits
as
CDA;
accordingly not only the pay but pension were also to be
revised. Thus, the question of pay revision as wells as
the pension revision was taken up by the department and
dispute arose as to whether the employees would be
getting the pay revision and pension revision on the basis
of CDA or on IDA and matter was taken up before this
Court in O.P.No.12609 of 2000.
4.
The learned Single Bench of this Court
vide judgment dated 29.01.2003 Ext.P5, allowed the writ
petition filed by the Ex-employees of the FCI, being a
covered
matter
in
O.P.No.1642
of
(Ext.P3)
rendered by another Single Bench of this Court on
14.03.2000. The matter was taken up before the Division
Bench in various writ appeals including the one against
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-62025:KER:26708
the decision of the Single Bench in O.P.No.12609 of
2000. The writ appeal filed by the Union of India, was
dismissed by holding that once the employees of the
Central Government had given option under clause
12A(4)(a),(b),(c)
and
opted
the
pattern
of
Central
Government, they would be entitled to receive all
benefits of Central Government employees and entitled
to the pay revision and pension revision strictly as per
the aforementioned Act.
5.
The matter was taken up before the
Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.238-224 of 2004 and
vide judgment dated 10.02.2010 upheld the judgment of
the Single Bench and the Division Bench by holding in
paragraph No.13 that the Central Government did not
have the jurisdiction to unilaterally alter or change the
option exercised by the writ petitioners therein under
Section 12A(4) (b) read with Section 12A(4C) of the FCI
Act.
Though in the judgment aforementioned,
the
provisions of Section 12A(4C) was also extracted but by
upholding the reasoning given in the Single Bench,
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-72025:KER:26708
dismissed the SLP by noticing in paragraph No.13, as
above.
In
the
aforementioned
writ
petition,
Sri.P.M.Rockey, respondent-petitioner was one of the
parties.
6. On analysis of the aforesaid judgments, Union
of India passed an order Ext.P9 dated 28.08.2012 which
was challenged before the Single Bench in writ petition
bearing No.22171 of 2012.
The learned Single Bench
vide impugned judgment relying upon the judgments of
the previous Single Bench, subsequent Single Bench,
Division Bench and honourable Supreme Court allowed
the writ petition by referring to the provisions of Section
12A (4)(a) and (b) read with section 12(4C) of the Act
holding that the writ petitioner had opted for pensionary
benefits applicable to the Central Government i.e., the
pensionary benefiits are payable under the CCS Pension
Rules and what was available is the revised pension with
Dearness Reliefs thereon as specified in the CCS Pension
Rules.
The relevant portion of the judgment dated
30.05.2019 reads as under:
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-82025:KER:26708
“4.It is submitted by the learned counsel for the
petitioner that the petitioner was initially
appointed in the Food Department of the Union
of India and had been absorbed in the service of
the Food Corporation of India (FCI for short). It
is stated that the rights of the employees, who
were transferred to the FCI were governed by
the provisions of the Food Corporation of India
Act (the Act for short). It is stated that section
12A(4) of the Act specifically provided for
exercise of options to be governed by the scale
of pay applicable in the Government or the scale
of pay applicable to the post under the FCI. A
further option was provided for being governed
by the leave, provident fund, retirement or other
terminal benefits admissible to the employees of
the Central Government or the terminal benefits
admissible to the employees of the Corporation.
The petitioner had opted for scale of pay as
applicable under the FCI and terminal benefits
as applicable to employees of the Central
Government. This Court in Exhibit P3 judgment
specifically found that such option was
completely in order, going by the terms of
Section 12(4)(a) and (b) of the Act and that the
said option being statutorily in character was
liable to be accepted and acted upon by the
respondents. Though the respondents have
taken up the matter in appeal, Exhibit P6
judgment of the Apex Court was the result. In
the meanwhile, the petitioner and other
similarly situated employees had approached
this Court seeking release of terminal benefits
and dearness relief on pension payable to them
under the CCS pension Rules, 1972. It appears
that it was aggrieved by the rejection of their
claim for pension under the Pension Rules that
they had approached this Court. The orders of
rejection issued by the Government were
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-92025:KER:26708
quashed by this Court relying on Exhibit P3
judgment and the 2nd respondent was directed
to reconsider the claim of the petitioner in the
light of the observations in Exhibit P3. It
appears that the Union of India had taken up
the matter before the Apex court by filing SLP
as against Exhibit P6 judgment. Exhibit P7 was
a well considered judgment issued considering
the legal aspects of the matter. It was found
that the option exercised by the employees
being statutory in nature, even bipartite
settlements which were entered into in the
meanwhile would not affect such option
exercised by them. It was found that the
respondents were duty bound to honour the
options exercised by the employees in terms of
Section 12A(4)(a) and (b) read with section
12(4C) of the Act. It was found that the action of
the Government in having revised/reduced the
retirement benefits payable to the respondents
unilaterally was completely without jurisdiction.
The employees were, therefore, held to be
entitled to pension and dearness relief under
the CCS Pension Rules, 1972 in terms of the
option exercised by them under Section 12A(4)
(a) and (b) read with section 12(4C) of the Act.
Exhibit P9 communication issued by the
Additional 7th respondent proceeds on the basis
that the petitioner, who retired from service of
the FCI is not entitled to the pensionary benefits
granted to him in terms of the CCS Pension
Rules, 1972. It is stated that he is entitled only
for IDA dearness relief as applicable, since he
had been given the benefits of the IDA wage
revisions. It appears that the impact of Exhibits
P3, P5, P6 and P7 judgments have not been
considered by the respondents, even in a
cursory manner, while issuing Exhibit P9
communication. The judgments referred to
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-102025:KER:26708
above specifically considered the legal issue and
found that the option under Section 12A(4) is a
dual option. The employees could have opted
the pay scale applicable in the Central
Government or the FCI under sub-clause (a) of
the said Rule. There was a separate and distinct
option available to opt for the retiral benefits
applicable either to employees of the Central
Government or those applicable to employees of
the FCI. It is not in dispute before me that the
petitioner is a person who had been opted for
the pensionary benefits applicable to Central
government employees, that is, the pensionary
benefits as are payable under the CCS Pension
Rules, 1972. In the above view of the matter,
what is available to him is the revised pension
with dearness relief thereon as specified in the
CCS Pension Rules. The finding in Exhibit P9 to
the effect that since the petitioner is an
employee who had drawn the pay revision
benefits and the variable DA applicable thereto,
he cannot draw the pension and dearness relief
as provided in the CCS Pension Rules is
completely unsustainable and is at variance with
the binding judgments of this Court in Exhibits
P3, P5, P6 and P7.
5.The impugned order is, therefore, set aside.
There will be a direction to the respondents to
disburse the pensionary benefits to the
petitioner in terms of his entitlement under the
CCS Pension Rules. All arrears shall be
calculated and continued to be disbursed to the
petitioner as early as possible, at any rate,
within a period of three months from the date of
receipt of copy of this judgment”
7.
Mr.Krishna, learned Assistant Solicitor
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-112025:KER:26708
General (in charge) appearing on behalf of the appellants
submits that in none of the aforementioned judgments,
provisions of Section 12(4C) has been referred to
in
correct perspective and if looked into, it clearly says that
the pension has to be calculated on the basis of last pay
drawn under the IDA in the Corporation and accordingly,
while calculating the pension, last pay drawn under the
IDA is the reckoning pay and not the pay which the other
Central Government employees were drawing.
This
aspect has been considered in extenso vide judgment
dated 03.03.2016 in Writ Appeal No.1418 of 2015 by the
Division Bench of this Court, wherein the judgment of
the Single Bench of this Court in Writ Petition No.16338
of 2011 was set aside,
with certain directions.
The
aforementioned judgment though was available at the
time when the Single Bench passed the order herein, but
for the reason best known could not be cited for effectual
adjudication.
8.
It was further contended that all the
previous judgments relied upon by the Single Bench do
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-122025:KER:26708
pertain to the provisions of Section 12A(4) A,B,C and a
direction has been issued to calculate the pension strictly
as per the provisions of the Act, but has not read the
contents of 12A(4C) meticulously, with humility, as Union
of India had calculated the pension on the basis of the
aforementioned provisions, whereas the pension has to
be calculated on the basis of the last drawn pay.
9.
It is settled law that the judgment of the
Division Bench has not been assailed before the Supreme
Court, therefore, still holding the field and is not in
contradiction to the other judgments which have referred
to the same very provisions, but the expression last pay
drawn has not been deliberated upon as it should have
been in the manner and mode as has been done in
Annexure A1 judgment. Therefore, the judgment under
challenge is liable to be modified.
10.
appearing
On the other hand, learned counsel
on
behalf
of
the
respondent-petitioner
countered the aforementioned submissions by do not
denying the ratio decidendi culled out in the Annexure
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-132025:KER:26708
A1 judgment but submitted that in all the previous round
of litigations, the respondent writ petitioner was a party
and therefore, judgment which was upheld up to the
Supreme Court is inter-parte judgment, cannot be
interdicted by relying upon the ratio decidendi culled out
in Annexure A1 i.e., Writ Appeal No.1418 of 2015
decided on 03.03.2016 because finding of fact and law
has been derived by giving a re-interpretation of the
provisions of the FCI Act and urged this Court for
dismissal of the intra-court appeal.
11.
We have heard learned counsel for the
parties and appraised the paper book.
12.
We would be failing in duty in not
extracting the relevant portion of the judgments in the
previous round of litigation i.e., Exts.P5, P6 and P7.
Ext.P5 judgment in O.P.No.12609 of 2000:
“The petitioners are ex employees of the Food
Corporation of India.
Initially, they were
employed in the Food Department of the Union
of India. Later, they were absorbed in the Food
Corporation of India. This Original Petition is
filed claiming terminal benefits and dearness
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-142025:KER:26708
relief on pension applicable to them under the
C.C.S. Pension Rule 1972. Their claim in this
regard has been rejected by the Government by
Exts.P9 to P14 orders. The point raised by the
petitioners is covered in their favour by Ext.P7
judgment.
The said judgment of a learned
Single Judge has been affirmed by a Division
Bench of this Court in W.A.No.2835/00 which is
produced as Ext.P15. Therefore, the Original
Petition is allowed Exts.P9 to P14 are quashed.
The 2nd respondent is directed to reconsider the
claim of the petitioners for terminal benefits
including dearness relief on pension in
accordance with law in the light of the
observations made herein above within three
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment and pay the amounts found due to
them without any further delay.”
13. Operative part of the judgment of the
Division Bench dated 01.10.2002 in O.P.No.10692 of
1999 and connected matters is extracted hereinbelow.
On perusal of the same, provisions of Section 12A (4) (a)
and (b) have been extracted, but not (c).
“….Admittedly the petitioners thereon opted to
Central Government scheme and they had
retired without receiving benefits as per Central
Government pattern. The appellants herein
contend that they will not get dearness reliefs
as applicable to Central Government employees
as at the time of retirement they were
employees of Food Corporation of India. But as
per Section 12A(4) in view of their option
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-152025:KER:26708
petitioners are entitled to get their terminal
benefits admissible to Central Government
employees. These employees were originally
Government of India employees at the time of
formation of Food Corporation of India. They
Were given to right for option under clause
12A(4) (a) and (b) and they opted the pattern of
Central Government and they are entitled to
receive all the benefits of Central Government
employees. Therefore, there are no reasons for
discriminating them. These petitioners also will
be entitled to get the benefits as they are
treated as Central Government employees in
view of the option exercised by them. We fully
agree with the decision of Karnataka High Court
and learned Single Judge. In view of the above
decision there is no merit in the writ appeals
and are dismissed.”
14.
In Ext.P7 judgment of the Honourable
Supreme Court, in paragraph No.4, provisions of 12A(4)
and 4C has been extracted and in paragraph Nos.13 to
20, the findings arrived at, the same reads as under:
“4. The Food Corporation of India (for short "the
Corporation") was established under Section 3
of the Act. The services of the private
respondents, who were then working under the
Ministry of Food, Government of India were
placed at the disposal of the Corporation.
Section 12A was inserted in the Act by
Amending Act No. 57/1968 to facilitate transfer
of
the
government
employees
to
the
Corporation. Simultaneously, an opportunity
was given to every transferred employee to opt
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-162025:KER:26708
for the scale of pay applicable to the post held
by him under the Government immediately
before the date of transfer or the scale of pay
applicable to the post under the Corporation to
which he is transferred as also leave, provident
fund, retirement or other terminal benefits
admissible to the employees of the Central
Government in accordance with the rules and
orders of the Central Government, as amended
from time to time, or the leave, provident fund
or other terminal benefits admissible to the
employees of the Corporation. For the sake of
convenient reference, Section 12A (1), (2), (4)
and (4C) are reproduced below:12A. Special provisions for transfer of
Government employees to the Corporation in
certain cases - (1) Where the Central
Government has ceased or ceases to perform
any functions which under Section 13 are
functions of the Corporation, it shall be lawful
for the Central Government to transfer, by order
and with effect from such date or dates (which
may be either retrospective to any date not
earlier than the lst January, 1965, or
prospective) as may be specified in the order, to
the corporation any of the officers or employees
serving in the Department of the Central
Government dealing with food or any of its
subordinate or attached offices and engaged in
the performance of those functions:
Provided that no order under this sub-section
shall be made in relation to any officer or
employee in such Department or office who has,
in respect of the proposal of the Central
Government to transfer such officer or employee
to the Corporation, intimated within such time
as may be specified in this behalf by that
Government, his intention of not becoming an
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-172025:KER:26708
employee of the Corporation.
(2) In making an order under sub-section (1),
the Central Government shall, as far as may be,
take into consideration the functions which the
CentralGovernment has ceased or ceases to
perform and the areas in which such functions
have been or are performed.
(4) Every officer or other employee transferred
by an order made under sub-section (1) shall,
within six months' from the date of transfer,
exercise his option in writing to be governed,(a) by the scale of pay applicable to the post
held by him under the Government immediately
before the date of transfer or by the scale of pay
applicable to the post under the Corporation to
which he is transferred,
(b) by the leave, provident fund, retirement or
other terminal benefits admissible to employees
of the Central Government as amended from
time to time or the leave, provident fund or
other terminal benefits admissible to the
employees of the Corporation under the
regulations made by the Corporation under this
act, and such option once exercised shall be
final:
Provided that the option exercised under clause
(a) shall be applicable only in respect of the post
to which such officer or employee is transferred
to th Corporation and on appointment to a
higher post under the Corporation, he shall be
eligible only for the scale of pay applicable to
such higher post:
Provided further that if immediately before the
date of his transfer any such officer or employee
is officiating in a higher post under the
Government either in a leave vacancy or in any
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-182025:KER:26708
other vacancy of a specified duration, his pay,
on transfer, shall be protected for the unexpired
period of such vacancy and thereafter he shall
be entitled to the scale of pay applicable to the
post under the Government to which he would
have reverted or to the scale of pay applicable
to the post under the Corporation to which he is
transferred, whichever he may opt:
Provided also that when an officer or other
employee serving in the Department of the
Ministry of the Central Government dealing
with food or in any of its attached or
subordinate offices is promoted to officiate in a
higher post in the Department or office
subsequent to the transfer to the Corporation or
any other officer or employee senior to him in
that Department or office before such transfer,
the officer or other employee who is promoted
to officiate in such higher post shall, on transfer
to the Corporation, be entitled only to the scale
of pay applicable to the post he would have held
but for such promotion or the scale of pay
applicable to the post under the Corporation to
which he is transferred, whichever he may opt.
(4C) Where an officer or other employee has
exercised an option under sub-section (4), or
exercise, or is deemed to have exercised, an
option under that sub-section, read with subsection (4A) or sub-section (4B), to be governed
by the leave, provident fund, retirement or other
terminal benefits admissible to the employees of
the Central Government, such benefit shall be
calculated on the basis of the pay and
allowances drawn by him in the Corporation."
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxx
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-192025:KER:26708
13. Dehors the above conclusion, we are
convinced that the action taken by the
appellants to revise and reduce the retiral
benefits payable to the respondents was ex
facie, arbitrary, unreasonable and unjustified
and the learned Single Judge did not commit
any error by declaring that the Central
Government did not have the jurisdiction to
unilaterally alter/change the option exercised by
the writ petitioners under Section 12A(4) (b)
read with Section 12A(4C).
14. We may now advert to the bipartite
settlement on which reliance has been placed by
the appellants to justify the directive given by
the Central Government for adverse revision of
the retiral dues payable to the respondents.
Para 7.1 of the memorandum of settlement, the
extracts of which has been placed before this
Court in the form of Annexure R-4 read as
under:
"Pension: In the case of Food Transferee
employees who have opted Section 12-A of the
Food Corporation Act, 1964 to be governed by
the Pension Rules of the Central Government as
amended from time to time, Pension shall be
worked out as under:
(i) For those retiring during the period 1 st
August 1983 to 30th March, 1985,
employments for purposes of working out
pension will be the pay in the revised
scale.
In the case of persons retiring prior to 31 st
May, 1984 emoluments for the period
prior to 1st August, 1983 shall be the
emoluments which would have been taken
into account for the purpose of pension as
per the then existing orders.
(ii) For those retiring during the period
31st March, 1985 to 31 st December, 1985
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-202025:KER:26708
emoluments for purposes of pension will
be pay in the revised scale and Industrial
DA as admissible in FCI on 1st November,
1984.
In the case of persons retiring prior to 31 st
December, 1985 emoluments for the to
period prior to 31st March, 1985 shall be
the emoluments which would have been
taken into account for the purpose of
pension as at Senior (i) above.
(iii) For those retiring during the period 1 st
Jan., 1986 to 31st July, 1987 pension shall
be worked out with reference to
emoluments for purposes of pension as
shown in Col.4 and Col.5 of Annexure 17
to 28 whichever is more.
In the case of persons retiring prior to 31 st
Oct., 1986 emoluments for the period
prior to 1st Jan., 1986 shall be the
emoluments which would have been taken
into account for the purpose of pension as
at Senior No. (ii) above."
15. A perusal of what has been reproduced
above makes it clear that the settlement was
applicable to the employees retiring between
1.8.1983 and 31.7.1987. None of the private
respondent is shown to have retired during that
period. Therefore, the terms of settlement
cannot be invoked by the appellants to justify
reduction of the retiral benefits payable to
them.
16. A reading of the consequential order
dated 18.7.1990.
(Annexure R-6) issued by the Government of
India does give an impression that the
settlement is applicable to employees like the
private respondents but, in our view, the same
cannot be relied upon for the purpose of
supporting
the
directive
given
for
revising/reducing retiral benefits payable to the
private respondents because the Central
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-212025:KER:26708
Government is not bestowed with the power to
amend, alter or revise the terms of bipartite
settlement.
17. Even if the memorandum of settlement is
held applicable to other employees of the
Corporation, the same cannot adversely affect
the option exercised by the private respondents
in terms of Secti 12A (4) (a) and (b) read with
Section 12A (4C) of the Act. It has neither been
suggested on behalf of the appellants nor it can
be laid down as a proposition of law that the
bipartite settlement arrived at between the
Unions of the employees and the Management
the Corporation could take away the right
acquired by the respondents as a sequel to
exercise of option in terms of Section 12A(4) (b).
18. The judgment on which reliance has been
placed by Shri Srivastava has no bearing on the
issue raised in these appeals because in that
case the Court was not called upon to decide
whether the Central Government can pass an
order or issue a directive adversely affecting the
statutory option exercised by the employees.
19. In the result, the appeals are dismissed.
Each of the private respondents shall get cost of
Rs.10,000/- from the appellants.
20. Since the appeals have been dismissed,
the concerned authorities are directed to
release the amount payable to the respondents
and other similarly situated persons within
period of three months from today, else they
shall have to pay interest to @ 9% per annum
from the date of this order.”
15.
On
perusal
of
the
observations
in
paragraph No.14, no doubt it is clear that all the writ
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-222025:KER:26708
petitioners therein were held entitled to the benefit
under Section 12A (4)(b) read with Section 12A(4C).
above
16.
The aforementioned provisions as noticed
have
been
noticed
in
the
judgment
dated
03.03.2016 in writ appeal No.1418 of 2015 by the
Division Bench wherein in paragraph No.24, it has been
read as under:
“24. According to the option exercised by the
petitioner, he opted for pay scale of the
Corporation under sub-clause (a) of subsection
(4) and opted for leave, provident fund,
retirement or other terminal benefits admissible
to the employees of the Central Government in
accordance with the Rules and orders of the
Central Government as amended from time to
time under clause (b) of subsection (4). Subsection (4-C), which is also relevant for the
present case, is quoted below:
“(4-C) Where an officer or other employee
has exercised an option under sub-section
(4) or exercises, or is deemed to have
exercised an option under that subsection, read with sub-section (4-A) or subsection (4-B) to be governed by the leave,
provident fund, retirement or other
terminal benefits admissible to the
employees of the Central Government,
such benefits shall be calculated on the
basis of the pay and allowances drawn by
him in the Corporation.”
Also, in paragraph No.25 it has been interpreted in the
following manner.
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-232025:KER:26708
“25. Sub-section (4-C) provides that, where an
officer or employee has exercised an option
under sub-section (4) to be governed by the
leave, provident fund, retirement or other
terminal benefits admissible to the employees of
the Central Government, such benefits shall be
calculated on the basis of the pay and
allowances drawn by him in the Corporation.”
17.
After noticing all the aforementioned
findings in paragraph No.29 learned Division Bench
noticed that the IDA pay revision was effected after every
five(5)
years
i.e.,
with
effect
from
01.08.1983
to
01.08.1987 and 01.02.1992 whereas the CDA pay scale
was revised after every ten(10) years, thus, allowed the
writ appeal in the following manner.
“40. The Apex Court further held that the
action taken by the appellants to revise and
reduce the retiral benefits payable to the
respondents
was
ex
facie
arbitrary,
unreasonable and unjustified and the learned
Single Judge did not commit any error in setting
aside the said exercise. The Apex Court further
held in paragraph (17) that the right acquired
by the respondents as a sequel to exercise of
option in terms of Section 12A(4)(b) cannot be
taken away by any bipartite settlement.
Following was stated in paragraph (17):
“17. Even if the memorandum of
settlement is held applicable to other
employees of the corporation, the same
cannot adversely affect the option
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-242025:KER:26708
exercised by the private respondents in
terms of Section 12A(4)(a) and (b) read
with Section 12A (4C) of the Act. It has
neither been suggested on behalf of the
appellants nor it can be laid down as a
proposition of law that the bipartite
settlement arrived at between the Unions
of the employees and the Management of
the Corporation could take away the right
acquired by the respondents as a sequel to
exercise of option in terms of Section
12A(4)(b).”
41. From the above judgment also, it is clear
that the Apex Court upheld the order of the
learned Single Judge on the ground that it
adversely affected the petitioners, without
giving opportunity to them and further the
statutory option exercised under Section 12A(4)
(b), cannot be diluted by any bipartite
settlement. The judgments of this Court and the
Apex Court are to the effect that the petitioners
are entitled to all retiral benefits admissible to
the Central Government employees, including
the Central Dearness Relief (CDR).
42. Dearness Relief has been defined under
Rule 3(1)(cc) read with Rule 55A of the CCS(P)
Rules. Rule 55A was inserted by Government of
India by notification dated 22.1.1991 which was
the relief granted on pension against price rise,
at such rates and subject to such conditions as
the Central Government may specify from time
to time. Rule 55A is extracted below:
“55-A.
Dearness
Relief
Pension/Family Pension
on
(i) Relief against price rise may be
granted to the pensioners and family
pensioners in the form of dearness relief
at such rates and subject to such
conditions as the Central Government may
specify from time to time. (ii) If a
pensioner is re-employed under the
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-252025:KER:26708
Central or State Government or a
Corporation/Company/ Body/ Bank under
them in India or abroad including
permanent
absorption
in
such
corporation/Company/Body/Bank, he shall
not be eligible to draw Dearness Relief on
pension/ family pension during the period
of such re-employment.”
43. Thus, the petitioners were entitled to CDR
and all other retiral benefits admissible to
Central Government. They being exercised their
option under Section 12A(4)(b) as observed
above, all such benefits have to be computed on
the basis of the salary drawn by them in the
Corporation.
44. Now, we come to Exts.P9 and P10, which
were challenged in the writ petition. Ext.P10 is
the order issued by the Government of India,
Ministry of Food and Public Distribution, Pay
and Accounts Office dated 18.5.2011 where
instructions were issued to grant Central
Dearness Relief from 1.2.1993 onwards and
Central Dearness Relief @ 61%, 64%, 67% and
71% should be paid on the basic pension from
1.1.2004. It is true that the letter states the
petitioner as IDA pensioner by stating “IDA
Revision with CDR as per Supreme Court's
order”.
45. As observed above, the petitioner having
received the IDA pay scale, which was the last
pay drawn at the time of his retirement in the
Corporation, which pay scale is the basis for
computation of all the benefits, the petitioner
cannot be heard in saying that computation of
retirement benefits should be made on the basis
of corresponding pay scale of Central
Government as admissible to employees who
had drawn their last salary in the Central
Government pay scale. Such interpretation is
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-262025:KER:26708
wholly misconceived and runs counter to the
statutory scheme indicated in Section 12A(4-C),
as discussed above.
46. The instructions given under Ext.P10,
after directing for revision of the petitioners,
are as follows:
Instructions
“1. As per Supreme Court judgment Central DR
has to be paid on pension and family pension. IDA
DR already paid on SP/FP is to be adjusted against
the Central DR to be paid from 01.02.1993 onwards
to current date. Since 50% merger on pension as on
01.04.2004 is NOT applicable, Central DR @ 61%,
64%, 67% and 71% should be paid on basic pension
from 01.01.2004 till 31.12.2005 respectively.
2.VI PCR benefits should not be allowed except
Central DR.
3. There is No change in Commutation / DCRG
due to this Updation.”
47. The instructions further mention that 6 th
Central Pay Revision shall not be applicable to
the petitioner except Central Dearness Relief.
No exception can be taken to the said direction.
Since as explained above, the petitioner is
entitled for the benefit of revision under IDA pay
scale which revision was made, if any, on the
last drawn pay of the petitioner. The pay scale
drawn by the Central Government employees
were not relevant for the petitioner for
computation of retiral benefits. We, thus, do not
find any error in Exts.P9 and P10, and
interference by the learned Single Judge was
unwarranted. However, there cannot be any
dispute that petitioner was entitled to receive
all retiral benefits admissible to Central
Government employees in accordance with the
CCS(P) Rules and the orders issued by the
Central Government from time to time.
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-272025:KER:26708
48. In the result, the judgment of the learned
Single Judge deserves to be modified in the
following manner:
a)The direction of the learned Single Judge, in
so far as it set aside Exts.P9 and P10, is set
aside.
b)The retiral benefits of the petitioner shall be
computed as admissible to Central Government
employees in accordance with the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 and the orders
issued by the Central Government from time to
time. The calculation of the retiral benefits of
the petitioner shall be made on the basis of his
last drawn pay in the Corporation i.e. IDA pay
scale.
c)The writ petitioner shall be entitled for
Central Dearness Relief and all other benefits as
admissible to Central Government employees.
d)The petitioner is given an opportunity to
represent against computation of pension in
consequence to Exts.P9 and P10 raising
objections which shall be considered and a
decision be taken and communicated by the first
respondent expeditiously, preferably within two
months from the date, the representation is
received.”
18.
Similar
question
is
also
now
posed
against before us. We are of the view that, no doubt, all
the employees of the FCI who have given an option as
per the provisions of Section 12A of the Act would be
governed by the same for the purpose of drawing the IDA
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-282025:KER:26708
in the FCI and CDA in the Central Government for the
purpose of calculating pension, but if looked deeply 4C of
Section
12A,
reproduced
in
the
judgment
aforementioned, leaves no manner of doubt that it has to
be as per the last pay drawn.
19.
For the sake of brevity 4C of 12A
is
extracted again:
“(4C) Where an officer or other employee has
exercised an option under sub-section (4), or
exercise, or is deemed to have exercised, an
option under that sub-section, read with subsection (4A) or sub-section (4B), to be governed
by the leave, provident fund, retirement or other
terminal benefits admissible to the employees of
the Central Government, such benefit shall be
calculated
on
the
basis
of
the
pay
and
allowances drawn by him in the Corporation."
20.
The
expression
‘pay
and
allowances
drawn by him in the Corporation’ is the barometer for
the purpose of determination of the pension under the
CDA pay scale. This is precisely what has been done in
Ext.P9. In none of the judgments noticed by the Single
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-292025:KER:26708
Bench it has been held that the employees would not be
entitled to the benefits of 12(4C).
For the sake of
repetition the expression ‘pay and allowances’ is the
criteria to be followed for assessing the pension under
the CDA.
If
4C is omitted and the claim of the writ
petitioner is accepted it would amount to rewriting of 4C
much less assessment of the pay revision on the basis of
the
pay
and
allowances
Government
employees,
preposterous
and
drawn
by
the
Central
which
will
be
wholly
aberrative.
This
aspect,
in
our
considered view, has not been noticed by the learned
Single Bench while allowing the writ petition. We thus,
modify the judgment of the Single Bench in the similar
lines as has been done in Annexure A1 by giving
directions to the appellants-Union of India which are
extracted hereinbelow:
“48. In the result, the judgment of the learned
Single Judge deserves to be modified in the
following manner:
a)The direction of the learned Single Judge, in
so far as it set aside Exts.P9 and P10, is set
aside.
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-302025:KER:26708
b)The retiral benefits of the petitioner shall be
computed as admissible to Central Government
employees in accordance with the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 and the orders
issued by the Central Government from time to
time. The calculation of the retiral benefits of
the petitioner shall be made on the basis of his
last drawn pay in the Corporation i.e. IDA pay
scale.
c)The writ petitioner shall be entitled for
Central Dearness Relief and all other benefits as
admissible to Central Government employees.
d)The petitioner is given an opportunity to
represent against computation of pension in
consequence to Exts.P9 and P10 raising
objections which shall be considered and a
decision be taken and communicated by the first
respondent expeditiously, preferably within two
months from the date, the representation is
received.”
21.
The
retirement
benefits
of
the
respondent-petitioner and all similar employees shall be
computed as admissible to the Central Government
Employees in accordance with the Central Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1972 and the orders issued by the
Central
Government
calculation
of the
from
time
retirement
to
time,
benefits
of
and
the
the
writ
petitioner shall be made on the basis of his last drawn
WA NO. 467 OF 2021
-312025:KER:26708
pay in the Cooperation i.e., IDA pay scale.
The
respondent writ petitioner shall also be entitled to
Central Dearness Reliefs and all other benefits as
admissible to Central Government Employees.
Before
doing that, opportunity will be given to the respondent
writ petitioner for raising the objections which though
have not been taken notice in either of the judgments by
us.
Writ
appeal
stands
disposed
of
in
aforementioned terms .
Sd/AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
vv
the
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review