Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:13801
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
MONDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 14TH MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 58 OF 2020
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 12.10.2018 IN OA NO.1084 OF 2017 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
DEPARTMENT OF POSTS, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
NEW DELHI-110001.
THE CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL,
KERALA CIRCLE, TRIVANDRUM-695033.
THE SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICES
KOLLAM POSTAL DIVISION, KOLLAM-691001.
SRI T C KRISHNA, DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA IN
CHARGE
RESPONDENT/APPLICANTS:
MARIYAMMA C.KOSHY
W/O.(LATE) E.GEEVARGHESE, AGED 72 YEARS, KOVOOR VEEDU,
PALLIMUKKU, VADAKKEVILA P O, KOLLAM-691010.
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 03.02.2025, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
-2-
OP(CAT) NO.58 OF 2020
2025:KER:13801
JUDGMENT
K. V. JAYAKUMAR, J.
This O.P.(CAT) is preferred by the Union of India and its Officers
impugning the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal in
O.A.No.1084/2017 dated 12.10.2018, whereby the following claim of the
respondent/applicant for reimbursement was disposed of.
"(i) To quash Annexure Al and Annexure A2
(ii) To direct the respondents to sanction and disburse the
reimbursement of the Medical Expenses sought for in
Annexure A-5 and Annexure A-6.
(iii) Grant such other reliefs as may be prayed for and as the
Court may deem fit to grant, and
(iv) Grant the cost of this Original Application."
2.
The facts in a narrow compass are as follows:
The husband of the respondent/applicant, E.Geevarghese, is retired as Sub
Postmaster from the Postal Department on 29.02.1996 on attaining
superannuation, was drawing Rs.20,281/- as pension with Fixed Medical
Allowances (FMA) of Rs.100/-.
3.
The Central Government Pensioners residing within
the area of CGHS are entitled to reimburse the medical expenses in full
OP(CAT) NO.58 OF 2020
-3-
2025:KER:13801
but, those who are residing outside the CGHS area are granted FMA of
Rs.300/- per month. On the basis of the recommendations of the 5 th
Central Pay Commission, the amount was revised from Rs.100/- to
Rs.300/- vide Annexure-A3 OM dated 26.05.2010.
4.
Late Geevarghese, the husband of the respondent,
underwent major surgery at Travancore Medical College in two spells. In
the 1st spell, he had incurred medical expenses to the tune of Rs.31,992/and in the 2nd spell, an amount of Rs.56,272/-. He submitted AnnexuresA5 and A6 applications before the petitioners claiming reimbursement of
the medical bills. The case of the applicant was that the treatment was
effected due to emergency, to save the life of her husband. The applicant
had submitted Emergency Certificate (Annexures-A7 and A8) before the
Tribunal.
5.
The stand of the petitioners before the Tribunal and
before us is that, retired employees where CGHS facilities are not available,
cannot avail the medical reimbursement instead, they are entitled to Fixed
Medical Allowances of Rs.500/- per month. The Tribunal, noticing the
rival contention of the counsel for the parties, disposed the OA with a
direction to the petitioners to consider the reimbursement of medical
expenses incurred by the husband of the applicant.
OP(CAT) NO.58 OF 2020
-4-
2025:KER:13801
6.
The learned counsel for the respondent/applicant
supported the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal. According to
the learned counsel, no interference is warranted in this case.
7.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the Union of India
submitted that the impugned order is patently illegal and unsustainable.
8.
We have heard the rival contentions of the counsel for
the parties and appraised the paper book.
9.
Adv.T.C.Krishna, Deputy Solicitor General of India-in-
Charge submitted that, as per Clause (iv) of note 2 to Rule 1 of the Civil
Service (Medical Attendance) Rules 1944, there is no provision of law to
entertain the claims of retired Government officials.
It is further
submitted that the Tribunal has failed to note that the husband of the
respondent has not opted for CGHS and he has been drawing Family
Medical Allowance ever since his retirement. The Tribunal, noticing the
rival contentions of the counsel for the parties disposed of the application
in the following manner.
“8.
The short question put forward by this
Original Application is that whether the retired employees
who are residing in non-CGHS areas are entitled for
reimbursement of medical expenses or not?
OP(CAT) NO.58 OF 2020
-5-
2025:KER:13801
9. Learned counsel for the applicant has drawn our
attention to the O.A 24/2015 decided by this Tribunal in
2017 which is identical in situation where a retired person
superannuated while working as Senior Superintendent of
Post Offices. Kollam. He has claimed the medical expenses
which was rejected vide Annexure A-1 order on the ground
that as he is a retired employee his claim is not covered
under CS(MA) Rules, 1944. This Tribunal quashed and set
aside Annexure A-1 and directed the respondents to reconsider the claim of the applicant in the light of the
observations made in order dated 18.7.2013 in O.A
No.64/2013 of the coordinate Bench of this Tribunal at
Ahmadabad and the judgment dated 28.12.2015 of the High
Court of Himachal Pradesh in CWP No.4621/2011 and
consider reimbursement of the expenses incurred by the
applicant as per bills. Paragraph 14 of O.A 64/2013 reads as
follows:
"14. If the serving government officials and the
retired government officials are treated differently in the
matter of protecting their health, keeping a wide hiatus
between the two categories in the context of granting medical
facilities, the same would be violative of fundamental right of
equality guaranteed in Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It
is worth reminding that when policies relating to retired
government servants and pensioners are formulated, they
should be in consonance with the directive principles of State
policy envisaged in Articles 41 and 47 in Part IV of the
Constitution of India. Medical assistance and facilitating
emergency treatments to the old retired government servants
will be a step forward in mitigating their "ündeserved want"
arising out of their health situation in the post-retirement life.
This is a situation contemplated in Article 41 of the
Constitution. Therefore, this matter requires a benevolent
approach from the Central and State Governments."
10. In a nutshell, Ahmedabad Bench has decided
the matter clearly on the ground of discrimination between
serving government official viz-a-viz retired government
official. By taking shelter of this judgment, this Tribunal is
OP(CAT) NO.58 OF 2020
-6-
2025:KER:13801
of the view that the present Original Application has merit
on its side and this Original Application is disposed of with a
direction to the respondents that they may consider
reimbursement of the medical expenses incurred by the
applicant herein in terms of the Ahmedabad Bench
judgment relied by the Ernakulam Bench in O.A 24/2015.
This order shall be complied within a period of 60 days from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”
10.
The reasoning of the Tribunal is that, there cannot be
any discrimination between the serving Government officials viz-a-viz
referred Government officials in the matter of protecting their health. We
are in agreement with the aforesaid reasoning.
Upon hearing the submissions of the learned counsel across the
Bar and on perusal of the paper book, we do not find any illegality or
perversity in the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal. No good
ground for interference is made out.
OP(CAT) No.58/2020 fails and it is dismissed.
Sd/AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
Sbna/
OP(CAT) NO.58 OF 2020
-7-
2025:KER:13801
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 58/2020
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE ORIGINAL PETITION 84 OF
2017 WITH ANNEXURES (PAGES 11-49)
ANNEXURE P1(A1)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.E19/MR/GNL DATED
09.01.2017 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE P1(A2)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. E19/MR/GNL DATED
15.05.2017 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE P1(A3)
TRUE COPY OF THE OM NO.4/25/2008-P AND PW
(D) DATED 26.05.2010.
ANNEXURE P1(A4)
TRUE COPY OF G.I. MIN OF HEALTH & F.W OM
NO.S-14025/4/96-MS DATED 05.06.1998
ANNEXURE P1(A5)
TRUE COPY OF APPLICATION FOR CLAIMING
REFUND OF MEDICAL EXPENSES DATED 02.01.2017
ALONG WITH THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY DATED
21.10.2016.
ANNEXURE P1(A6)
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION FOR CLAIMING
REFUND OF MEDICAL EXPENSES DATED 04.05.2017
ALONG WITH THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY DATED
14.02.2017.
ANNEXURE P1(A7)
TRUE COPY OF THE EMERGENCY CERTIFICATE
DATED
02.01.2017
WITH
RESPECT
TO
THE
TREATMENT ADMINISTERED ON THE APPLICANT
ISSUED BY THE TRAVANCORE MEDICAL COLLEGE.
ANNEXURE P1(A8)
TRUE COPY OF THE EMERGENCY CERTIFICATE
DATED
02.01.2017
WITH
RESPECT
TO
THE
TREATMENT ADMINISTERED ON THE APPLICANT
ISSUED BY THE TRAVANCORE MEDICAL COLLEGE.
ANNEXURE P1(A9)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN OA 64/2013 DATED
18.07.2013 AVAILED FROM SWAMY'S NEWS.
TRUE COPY OF THE LR. NO.21-13/2014-MEDICAL
DATED --/10/2014 ISSUED ON BEHALF OF THE
1ST RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE P1(A10)
OP(CAT) NO.58 OF 2020
-8-
2025:KER:13801
ANNEXURE P1(A11)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 20.3.2017 IN
OA 24/2015 OF THIS HON'BLE TRIBUNAL.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY AFFIDAVIT.
ANNEXURE P2(R1)
TRUE COPY OF THE RULE 1(2)AN NOTE BELOW THE
SAID RULE OF THE CCS (MEDIAL ATTENDANCE)
RULES, 1944.
ANNEXURE P2(R2)
TRUE COPY OF THE OM NO.45/57/97-P AND PW(C)
DATED 30.12.1998.
ANNEXURE P2(R3)
TRUE COPY OF THE
DATED 20.08.2004.
ANNEXURE P2(R4)
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 18.10.2006
IN WP(C) 14055 OF 2006(5)
ANNEXURE P2(R5)
TRUE COPY OF THE CLARIFICATION VIDE OM NO.S
14025/23/2013-MS-EHSS DATED 29.09.2016.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.180/1084/2017 DATED 12.10.2018
ERNAKULAM BENCH.
OM
NO.S.14025/4/96-MS
IN
OF
OA
CAT,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review