The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. before Evidently, as per the appointment orders produced the Central Administrative Tribunal, the respondents/applicants were appointed after 01.09.1993. On a reading of the order impugned, it becomes evidently clear that a wrong question was posed before the Tribunal which resulted in the impugned order. The Tribunal completely went wrong in addressing the crucial issue as to whether the vacancies were liable to be filled up by considering the appointment of the applicants who were temporarily appointed as casual labourers by treating them as full time casual labourers. Even assuming for a moment, the contention of the respondents/applicants was liable to be accepted and they were eligible to be considered for full time casual labourers, but the Tribunal did not address itself on the crucial issue as to whether, the Rules entitled the applicants to claim appointment even though they were appointed after 01.09.1993. In view of the above, we are of the considered view that the Central Administrative Tribunal went wrong in allowing the claim in the Original Application. Even though the Recruitment Rules did not apply to the applicants, the Tribunal exceeded in its jurisdiction and granted the relief to the applicants which they were not entitled to claim. Accordingly, we allow the Original Petition, set aside the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal in O.A.No.85/2014 date…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF JUNE 2024 / 15TH JYAISHTA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 108 OF 2017
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 24.06.2016 IN OA NO.85 OF
2014 OF CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
COMMUNICATIONS, NEW DELHI.
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POSTS
DAK BHAVAN, NEW DELHI.
CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL
KERALA CIRCLE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT
RMS ‘TV’ DIVISION, THIRUVANANTHAPRUAM 695 036.
SUPERINTENDENT
RMS, ‘CT’ DIVISION, KOZHIKODE.
BY ADVS.
ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL
SRI.T.V.VINU, CGC
RESPONDENTS/APPLICANTS:
A.MOHANDAS
S/O.THE LATE ARU, WORKING AS PART-TIME SCAVENGER,
SUB RECORD OFFICER, ‘RMS’ CT DIVISION,PALAKKAD
RESIDING AT KENNOTH PARAMBU, CIVIL STATION BACK,
PALAKKAD 678 001.
V.SINDHU
S/O.THE VELA WORKING AS PART-TIME SCAVANGER,SUB
RECORD OFFICE, OTTAPPALAM,RESIDING AT ERAPPAKODE
HOUSE, THEKKUMURY, KELLEPPULLY, PALAKKAD 678 005.
BY ADVS.
SRI.ANTONY MUKKATH
SRI.O.V.RADHAKRISHNAN SR.
SMT.K.RADHAMANI AMMA
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 05.06.2024,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) 108/2017
AMIT RAWAL & EASWARAN S., JJ.
-----------------------------------OP (CAT) No.108 of 2017
------------------------------------Dated this the 5th day of June, 2024
JUDGMENT
Easwaran S., J.
The applicants, who are presently working as part time
scavengers under “RMS CT Division” under the administrative
control of the 1st respondent was selected and appointed as Part
Time Scavenger as per memos dated 31.10.1998 (Annexure-A1)
and
16.5.2000
(Annexure-A2),
respectively.
Later,
the
Department of Posts (Group 'D' Posts) Recruitment Rules, 2002,
Annexure-A3, were issued by the President in exercise of the
power conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution
of India and in supersession of the Indian Posts and Telegraphs
(Class-IV Posts) Recruitment Rules, 1970. According to the said
Rules, the vacancies shall be filled up by selection-cum-seniority
basis
in
the
Recruitment
manner
Rules
prescribed
were
therein.
superseded
by
Annexure-A3
Annexure-A6,
Department of Posts Multi Tasking Staff Recruitment Rules, 2010,
which came into force with effect from 20.12.2010.
OP(CAT) 108/2017
2.
The applicants contended that there were twelve (12)
vacancies for Group-D posts existing immediately before the date
of coming into force of Annexure-A6 Recruitment Rules, and that
the inaction on the part of the respondents in not initiating steps
for regular promotion from Gramin Dak Sevaks (GDS) like the
applicants to Group-D posts against the unfilled vacancies was
violative of the provisions contained under Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India.
3.
filed
their
The respondents, petitioners herein, appeared and
reply
statement
pointing
out
that
as
per
the
Recruitment Rules, though the vacancies were to be filled up by
selection-cum-seniority, there were sufficient number of GDS for
consideration for appointment as Multi Tasking Staff (MTS) and
the question of offering the vacancies to part time casual
labourers does not arise for consideration.
The right of the
applicants to claim promotion under the Recruitment Rules was
emphatically denied, in view of the fact that they were appointed
only as part time casual labourers.
4.
Considering the contentions raised by the parties, the
learned Central Administrative Tribunal allowed the Original
OP(CAT) 108/2017
Application directing the petitioners/respondents to issue orders
promoting the applicants 1 & 2 to Group-D post in the order of
their seniority against the existing vacancies reserved for casual
labourers of RMS TV Division, which existed in 2009 and prior to
to that date and reserved for casual labourers of RMS TV
Division, as admissible under the roster points which fall under
25% quota set apart for casual labourers under Annexure-A3
Recruitment Rules, 2002.
The said order is under challenge in
the present original petition.
5.
We
have
heard
Sri.T.V.Vinu,
learned
Central
Government Counsel appearing for the petitioner/respondents
and Sri.Antony Mukkath, the learned counsel appearing for the
respondents/applicants.
6.
Sri.T.V.Vinu,
learned
Central
Government
Counsel
appearing for the petitioners would contend that the Tribunal
erred
egregiously
in
granting
the
reliefs
in
the
Original
Application as prayed for, essentially since the applicants were
only recruited as part time casual labourers and they are not
eligible to be considered in terms of the Recruitment Rules. He
would further place reliance on Annexure-A3 Rules, especially
Column No.11, which prescribed the method of appointment,
OP(CAT) 108/2017
wherein it is prescribed that 25% of the vacancies remaining
unfilled after retirement of employees mentioned at Sl.No.2, shall
be filled up by selection-cum-seniority in the following order:
(a) by casual labourers with temporary status of the
recruiting division or unit failing which,
(b) by full time casual labourers of the recruiting
division or unit, failing which,
(c) by full time casual labourers of neighbouring division
or unit failing which,
(d) by part time casual labourers of the recruiting
division or unit failing which,
(iii) by direct recruitment.
7.
On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for
the respondents/applicants would contend that going by the
Explanation or definition given to the casual labourers, there can
be no doubt that the applicants have served for more than four
hundred and eighty (480) days as casual labourers and as such
for the purpose of recruitment, they must be deemed to have
completed one year service as full time casual labourers.
Therefore, on a conjoint reading of Annexures-A3 and A9, there
can be no doubt that the respondents/applicants are entitled to
OP(CAT) 108/2017
be
considered
as
full
time
casual
labourers,
thereby
entitling them to claim the benefit of Annexure-A3 Recruitment
Rules.
8.
We have considered the rival submissions raised
across the bar.
9.
Going by the averments contained in the Original
Application and a perusal of Annexures-A1 and A2 appointment
orders issued by the Office of the Sub Record Officer, RMS CT
Division, Palakkad -2, it become evidently clear that 1 st and 2nd
applicants were appointed as part time scavenger and part time
sweeper, respectively, with effect from the respective dates. The
specific stand taken by the petitioners/respondents before the
Central Administrative Tribunal was that there were sufficient
number
of
appointment,
candidates
and
available
therefore,
the
for
consideration
question
of
offering
for
the
vacancies to the part time casual labourers does not arise at all
for consideration.
Still further, it is pointed out that under
Annexure-A6 Rules, which came into effect on 20.12.2010, 25%
of the vacancies are to be filled up by department recruitment
from GDS based on selection-cum-seniority and the next 25% by
direct recruitment on the basis of competitive examination
OP(CAT) 108/2017
restricted to GDS and 25% by casual labourers appointed on or
before 1.9.1993.
The relevant extract of Annexure-A6 (column
No.11) reads as follows:
“(i) (a) 25% by appointment of Casual Labourers
conferred with temporary status on the basis of
selection-cum-seniority failing which by;
(b) appointment of existing Casual Labourers
engaged on or before 1.9.1993 working for eight
full hours in a day on the basis of selection cum
seniority failing which by;
(c) appointment of existing part time Casual
Labourers, engaged on or before 1.9.1993, on the
basis of selection-cum-seniority failing which by;
(d) direct recruitment as per the scheme
circulated by the Department of Posts from time to
time;
(ii) 75% by direct recruitment as per the scheme
circulated by the Department of Posts from time to
time.”
10.
before
Evidently, as per the appointment orders produced
the
Central
Administrative
Tribunal,
the
respondents/applicants were appointed after 01.09.1993.
On a
reading of the order impugned, it becomes evidently clear that a
wrong question was posed before the Tribunal which resulted in
the impugned order.
The Tribunal completely went wrong in
addressing the crucial issue as to whether the vacancies were
liable to be filled up by considering the appointment of the
OP(CAT) 108/2017
applicants who were temporarily appointed as casual labourers
by treating them as full time casual labourers.
Even assuming
for a moment, the contention of the respondents/applicants was
liable to be accepted and they were eligible to be considered for
full time casual labourers, but the Tribunal did not address itself
on the crucial issue as to whether, the Rules entitled the
applicants
to
claim
appointment
even
though
they
were
appointed after 01.09.1993.
In view of the above, we are of the considered view that the
Central Administrative Tribunal went wrong in allowing the claim
in the Original Application.
Even though the Recruitment Rules
did not apply to the applicants, the Tribunal exceeded in its
jurisdiction and granted the relief to the applicants which they
were not entitled to claim.
Accordingly, we allow the Original
Petition, set aside the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal
in O.A.No.85/2014 dated 24.6.2016 and dismiss the Original
Application. No order as to costs.
Sd/AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
jg
OP(CAT) 108/2017
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 108/2017
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A1
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO NO. PT/RECRUITS/98 DATED
31.10.1998
OF
THE
SUB
RECORD
OFFICER,
RMS'CT'DIVISION, OTTAPALAM.
ANNEXURE A2
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO NO. PT/RECTT/SRO OTP
DATED 16.05.2000 SUB RECORD OFFICER, RMS'CT'
DIVISION, OTTAPALAM.
ANNEXURE A3
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PORTION OF THE
DEPARTMENT
OF
POSTS
(GROUP
D
POSTS)
RECRUITMENT RULES, 2002 AS PER NOTIFICATION
DATED 23.01.2002.
ANNEXURE A4
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. 37-15/2001 SPB-1
DATED 30.01.2002 OF THE ASST. DIRECTOR GENERAL
(SPN).
ANNEXURE A5
TRUE COPY
2005/52/13
RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A6
TRUE COPY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF POST MULTITASKING STAFF RECRUITMENT RULES 2010 AS PER
GSR NO.984(E) DATED 12.12.2010 ALONG WITH
COVERING LETTER NO. 37-33/2009-PB-I DATED
28.01.2011 OF THE 5TH RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A7
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 23.12.2009 IN
WPC NO. 28574 OF 2009 AND CONNECTED CASES OF
THE HONOURABLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA.
ANNEXURE A8
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 20.08.2013 IN OA
NO. 536/2012 OF THIS HONOURABLE TRIBUNAL.
ANNEXURE A9
TRUE COPY OF THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA LETTER
NO. 65-24/88-SPB.I DATED 17.05.1989.
OF THE COMMUNICATION
DATED
29.10.2013
OF
NO.
THE
RTI
1ST
ANNEXURE A10 TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION NO. D4/RTI/SRM
DATED 05.11.2014 OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT ALONG
WITH THE APPLICATION DATED 29.09.2014.
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE OA NO.180/00085/2014 DATED
26/1/2014 FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS BEFORE THE
CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT
12/3/2014, FILED BY THE PETITIONERS
DATED
OP(CAT) 108/2017
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER
FILED BY THE APPLICANT
DATED
7/6/2015
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY STATEMENT
DATED 3/7/2015 FILED BY THE PETITIONERS
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REJOINDER DATED
26/9/2015 FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE SECOND ADDITIONAL REPLY
STATEMENT
DATED
30/10/2015
FILED
BY
THE
PETITIONERS
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN OA NO.180/85/2014
DATED 24/6/2016 OF THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review