Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on:
03.07.2026
Pronounced on: 14.08.2026
Uploaded on:
14.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Arb P No. 54/2024
Union of India,
Through the Executive
Engineer(c), CPWD Landoi
Bridge, Satwari Cantt. Jammu180003.
…. Petitioner(s)/Appellants
Through:-
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Karan Sharma, CGSC.
V/s
M/S PNSC Infrastructure Pvt.
Ltd. Through its Director Shri
Purna Nand Ground FloorProperty No. 13 PKT, E-4 Sector7, Rohini New Delhi-110085.
…..Respondent(s)
Through:-
Mr. K. Nirmal Kotwal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Rajveer Singh Isher, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner-Union of India has filed the instant petition for
substitution of Arbitrator appointed by the Additional Director General
(Jammu), CPWD in terms of order dated 14.03.2023.
Arb P No. 54/2024
Factual Matrix
2.
It is stated that the respondent was awarded a contract for the work of
“Construction of Transit Campus at IIT, Jammu (J&K) SH: Additional
RCC Retaining Wall and structural steel works of Domes and Deck
Bridge”,
regarding
which
an
agreement
bearing
No.
01/EE/JMCD/2017-18 was also executed between the parties. As
certain disputes arose between the parties, the respondent sought
reference of the disputes to arbitration in terms of Clause 25 of the
General Conditions of Contract for Central P.W.D. Works, 2014 (GCC2014). The Additional Director General (Jammu) CPWD, being
appointing authority, vide Order dated 14.03.2023 appointed Sh.
Akhilesh Kumar, as the Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate upon the 18
claims raised by the respondent.
3.
It is further stated by the petitioner that the contract was awarded at
Jammu, and the work was also to be executed at Jammu. The Arbitrator
was appointed by the Additional Director General (Jammu), CPWD at
Jammu. The contract between the parties was entered into in the year
2017 at Jammu, J&K. The arbitration clause contained in GCC-2014,
provides that the arbitration proceedings shall be governed by the
provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, or the Jammu
and Kashmir Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997, as the case may
be or any statutory modification or re-enactment thereof and the rules
made thereunder for the time being in force. Thus, it is urged by the
petitioner that after the repeal of the 1997 Act, the arbitral proceedings
are required to be governed by statutory modification or re-enactment
Arb P No. 54/2024
thereof, which is the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as
applicable to the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir.
4.
It is stated that the Arbitrator entered upon the reference on 17.03.2023
and invited the parties for a preliminary hearing to be held on
13.04.2023 at 12:00 hrs through Web Conferencing on Google Meet to
decide the procedures to be followed under Section 19 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. In the morning of 13.04.2023 at
08:38:13 AM, Arbitrator sent an email attaching therewith the list of
tentative points for discussion in the preliminary hearing scheduled for
13.04.2023. The preliminary hearing was held as scheduled on
13.04.2023, during which all issues proposed in the tentative list were
discussed. In view of the technical complexities involved and the
voluminous documentary record, the petitioner requested for physical
hearings at Jammu and offered to render all necessary logistical
assistance to the Arbitrator. However, the learned Arbitrator directed
that all future hearings be conducted virtually via web-conferencing,
reserving physical hearings only for unavoidable circumstances at a
venue to be decided subsequently. After the conclusion of the hearing
on 13.04.2023, the minutes of the proceedings were sent through email
and the next hearing in the arbitral proceedings was held on 01.11.2023
through web conferencing and due to network issues, the petitioner
was not satisfied with the conduct of hearing and after the meeting was
over, the petitioner received the minutes of meeting through email and
found that the points put forth did not find mention in the minutes of
hearing dated 01.11.2023, so much so the Arbitrator was recording the
Arb P No. 54/2024
minutes of hearing by recording the consent of the petitioner on his
own. The petitioner thereafter filed a detailed application dated
11.12.2023 requesting the Arbitrator to hold the subsequent
proceedings physically at Jammu, citing the network issue as well as
number of other reasons prejudicing the effective conduct of the
proceedings. The petitioner submits that the appointment of a technical
expert, specifically an engineer, as Arbitrator, along with holding of
arbitration at Jammu, was intended to enable the Arbitrator to conduct
on-site inspections of the construction works for an effective, spot
assessment of the claims and counterclaim. In the hearing conducted on
11.12.2023, the learned Arbitrator recorded the petitioner’s application
requesting physical hearings and invited objections from the
respondent. However, upon receiving the minutes of the hearing
through email, the petitioner was surprised to find that the learned
Arbitrator had unilaterally recorded the petitioner’s alleged consent to
proceed virtually, despite the petitioner having explicitly filed an
application seeking physical hearings due to the practical difficulties
encountered in virtual proceedings. Thereafter, vide order dated
25.12.2023, Arbitrator disposed of the petitioner’s application for
physical hearings by directing that future proceedings shall continue
virtually,
except
where
physical
attendance
becomes
strictly
unavoidable. In doing so, the learned Arbitrator relied upon
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court regarding the beneficial use
of technology, while failing to appreciate that virtual proceedings are
inherently unsuited for arbitral matters involving extensive technical
Arb P No. 54/2024
complexities and voluminous documentary records. In the subsequent
hearings, the petitioner again found that the Arbitrator was recording
the minutes of the hearings arbitrarily and incorrectly, by recording the
consent/confirmation of the petitioner without even asking the
petitioner.
5.
It is further stated that the Arbitrator failed to complete the proceedings
and pass the award within statutory period of 12 months, his mandate
expired on 16.03.2024 in terms of Section 29-A of Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, as such, the petitioner intimated the Arbitrator
through the medium of communication dated 10.05.2024 that his
mandate stood expired and he has become functus officio, and the
petitioner is not consenting to the extension of time for making the
award. The Arbitrator invited objections to the said application from
the respondent and vide order dated 16.05.2024, rejected the plea of the
petitioner regarding termination of mandate on 16.03.2024 on the
pretext that the pleadings in the case were completed on 12.09.2023
and in the minutes of hearing dated 13.04.2023, he has already held the
seat of arbitration to be Delhi with the consent of the parties, as such,
the provision of Section 29A(1) as applicable in Delhi will be
applicable. It is urged by the petitioner that it was only after going
through the order dated 16.05.2024, the petitioner for the first time
realized that in the minutes of hearing dated 13.04.2023, the Arbitrator,
arbitrarily and without the consent of the petitioner, had recorded that
the seat of the arbitration shall be at Delhi, whereas the fact remains
that the petitioner never consented for the same. The learned
Arb P No. 54/2024
Arbitrator’s recording of the petitioner’s alleged consent to fix the seat
of arbitration at Delhi defies all logic and reason. Given that the
contract was awarded and executed in Jammu, and the Arbitrator was
appointed in Jammu under the provisions of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, there was simply no occasion or justification
for the petitioner to agree to shifting the seat of arbitration to Delhi. It is
stated that this is an act of fraud on the part of Arbitrator which can be
gathered from the fact that in the list of tentative points to be discussed
on 13.04.2023, there was no point with respect to seat of Arbitration
which is indisputably at Jammu, where the cause of action arose.
6.
The respondent has filed the response and has raised preliminary
objection with regard to the entertainability and maintainability of the
present petition on the ground that this Court lacks territorial
jurisdiction because as per the preliminary hearing held on 13.04.2023,
the seat of Arbitration was fixed at Delhi with the mutual consent of the
parties. It is also contended by the respondent that the mandate of
learned Arbitrator is still in force as the date of appointment of Sole
Arbitrator is 14.03.2013 and as per Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, for completion of pleadings six months’ time is required and the
same were completed well within six months i.e. 12.09.2023 and after
pleadings, 12 months is provided for arguments and for publication of
award. Therefore, the mandate of the Arbitrator would expire on
11.09.2024. It is also stated that in terms order dated 23.04.2024, both
the parties consented for extension of six months period as per Section
29A (3) of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997, therefore, the
Arb P No. 54/2024
mandate of the Tribunal is still in place. It is stated that total 12
hearings have been conducted and 12th hearing was held on 22.05.2024
and the order was issued by the learned Arbitrator on 23.05.2024. The
claimant’s arguments remained un-concluded and with the consent of
both the parties, the next date of hearing was fixed for 16.07.2024. The
respondent has given the details of hearings conducted from 25.05.2023
till 15.05.2024. The respondent has denied that Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, applicable specifically to Union Territory of
Jammu and Kashmir under Section 29A will be applicable in the instant
case as the Seat of the Arbitration is at Delhi. The respondent has in
fact denied the grounds raised by the petitioner for appointment of
substitute Arbitrator. It is further submitted that the petitioner never
raised any connectivity or technical issues during the entire course of
the proceedings. Furthermore, the learned Arbitrator never denied the
petitioner an opportunity for physical hearings, provided a genuine
need was established. Had the petitioner faced any legitimate difficulty,
it ought to have recorded its objection upon issuance of the orders;
however, the petitioner failed to do so. It is legally impermissible and
improper for the respondent to resile from its express consent regarding
the six-month extension of time, which was recorded during the hearing
on April 20, 2024, and formally embodied in the procedural order dated
April 23, 2024. Had there been any bona fide error in recording its
consent for the extension of time, the respondent would have promptly
brought the same to the attention of the learned Arbitrator immediately
upon issuance of the procedural order.
Arb P No. 54/2024
Submissions:
7.
Mr. Vishal Sharma, learned DSGI has submitted that procedural order
dated
13.04.2023
itself
clearly
demonstrates
the
Arbitrator's
questionable conduct. In the initial tentative points for discussion, no
reference was made to fixing Delhi as the seat of arbitration. On the
contrary, Serial No. 24 of the tentative points expressly provided that
the proceedings would be concluded from the date the Sole Arbitrator
enters upon the reference, a stipulation made strictly in the context of
Section 29-A(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, as applicable
to the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir. He further submitted
that under the procedural order dated 13.04.2023, the seat of arbitration
was designated as Delhi without the petitioner's consent. Concurrently,
however, the Arbitrator applied Section 29-A of the Act as applicable
to Jammu and Kashmir to govern the timeline of the proceedings,
reflecting a contradictory and fraudulent approach. He also highlighted
that despite the petitioner filing an application requesting physical
hearings, the Arbitrator wrongly recorded in a subsequent order that
both parties were satisfied with virtual hearings through video
conferencing and faced no difficulty during the proceedings. Finally, it
was submitted that had Section 29-A of the Act as applicable to the rest
of India been governing the present matter, there would have been no
requirement for the parties to formally record their consent to extend
the Arbitrator's mandate.
8.
Per contra, Mr. Nirmal K Kotwal, learned Senior counsel appearing for
the respondent has submitted the seat of arbitration was fixed at Delhi
Arb P No. 54/2024
with the mutual consent of the parties. Consequently, this Court lacks
the requisite territorial jurisdiction to entertain the present petition. He
further contended that the petitioner’s plea of being unaware that Delhi
was designated as the seat, attributing this to an oversight in examining
the procedural order/minutes dated April 13, 2023, is merely a lame
excuse. It was also submitted that the Arbitrator had, in fact, permitted
physical hearings, rendering the petitioner’s claim that its request for a
physical hearing was rejected entirely incorrect. He emphasized that
had the petitioner harboured any genuine grievance regarding the
learned Arbitrator's conduct, it would not have consented to extending
the Arbitrator's mandate. In any event, such consent was legally
redundant, as the pleadings were finalized only on September 12, 2023,
and the statutory period had not expired. Finally, he drew the Court’s
attention to the record of proceedings conducted by the Arbitrator to
demonstrate that the entire narrative advanced in the present petition is
an afterthought.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
Appreciation:
10.
Respondent has raised the preliminary objection that as the seat of
Arbitration has been fixed at Delhi, with the mutual consent of the
parties, this Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain this petition.
11.
The petitioner seeks the substitution of the Sole Arbitrator primarily on
the ground that the Arbitrator fraudulently designated Delhi as the seat
of arbitration, despite the petitioner never having consented to such an
arrangement. Specifically, in paragraph 15 of the petition, it is
Arb P No. 54/2024
explicitly pleaded that the fixing of the seat of arbitration at Delhi
constitutes an act of fraud on the part of the Arbitrator.
12.
It is the petitioner’s contention that since the work was allotted,
executed, and the Arbitrator appointed at Jammu, the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, as applicable to the Union Territory of Jammu
and Kashmir, governs the matter. Strangely, as noted in paragraph 7 of
the petition, the petitioner admits to having received the procedural
order dated 13.04.2023 on the very same day. However, the petitioner
seeks to dispute the minutes of the proceedings conducted on
13.04.2023, contending that the tentative points for discussion did not
contain any reference to fixing Delhi as the seat of arbitration. Further,
item No. 24 of the tentative points clearly demonstrates the learned
Arbitrator’s intention to apply Section 29-A of the Act as applicable to
Jammu and Kashmir, as it specifically stipulated that the arbitral
proceedings would be concluded within the prescribed period
calculated from the date on which the learned Sole Arbitrator entered
upon the reference.
13.
Surprisingly, the similar provision was retained in the minutes of the
proceedings dated 13.04.2023 but the fact remains that at Serial No. 19
of the minutes of the proceedings, it is specifically mentioned that
“with the consent of both the parties, it was decided that the Seat of
Arbitration, shall be at Delhi”.
14.
In paragraph 15 of the petition, the petitioner asserts that it was only
upon perusal of the order dated 16.05.2024, that it realized, for the first
time, that the Arbitrator had recorded in the procedural minutes dated
Arb P No. 54/2024
13.04.2023, that the seat of arbitration shall be at Delhi, an
incorporation the petitioner claims was made fraudulently and without
its consent. While this Court refrains from commenting on the
plausibility of the petitioner acquiring knowledge of the minutes dated
13.04.2023 only on May 16, 2024, the undisputed fact remains that the
petitioner continued to participate in the proceedings before the
Arbitrator for over a year.
15.
Prima facie, this Court is of the view that, since the seat of arbitration
was designated as Delhi, notwithstanding the petitioner’s belated
dispute in this regard, it would be appropriate for the present
controversy to be adjudicated by the Court having jurisdiction in
accordance with the designated seat of arbitration.
16.
In “Indus Mobile Distribution Pvt. Ltd Vs. Datawind Innovation
Pvt. Ltd”, AIR 2017 Supreme Court 2105, the Hon’ble Apex Court
has held as under:
“20. A conspectus of all the aforesaid provisions shows
that the moment the seat is designated, it is akin to an
exclusive jurisdiction clause. On the facts of the
present case, it is clear that the seat of arbitration is
Mumbai and Clause 19 further makes it clear that
jurisdiction exclusively vests in the Mumbai courts.
Under the Law of Arbitration, unlike the Code of Civil
Procedure which applies to suits filed in courts, a
reference to "seat" is a concept by which a neutral
venue can be chosen by the parties to an arbitration
clause. The neutral venue may not in the classical sense
have jurisdiction - that is, no part of the cause of action
may have arisen at the neutral venue and neither
would any of the provisions of Sections 16 to 21 of the
CPC be attracted. In arbitration law however, as has
been held above, the moment "seat" is determined, the fact
that the seat is at Mumbai would vest Mumbai courts with
exclusive jurisdiction for purposes of regulating arbitral
proceedings arising out of the agreement between the
parties.”
(emphasis added)
Arb P No. 54/2024
17.
In “Inox Renewables Limited vs. Jayesh Electricals”, 2023 (3) SCC
733, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held as under:
“17. The reliance placed by learned counsel for the
Respondent on Indus Mobile (supra), and in particular, on
paragraphs 18 and 19 thereof, would also support the
Appellant’s case, inasmuch as the “venue” being shifted
from Jaipur to Ahmedabad is really a shifting of the
venue/place of arbitration with reference to Section 20(1),
and not with reference to Section 20(3) of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996, as it has been made clear that
Jaipur does not continue to be the seat of arbitration and
Ahmedabad is now the seat designated by the parties, and
not a venue to hold meetings. The learned arbitrator has
recorded that by mutual agreement, Jaipur as a
“venue” has gone and has been replaced by
Ahmedabad. As clause 8.5 of the Purchase Order must
be read as a whole, it is not possible to accept the
submission of Shri Malkan that the jurisdiction of
Courts in Rajasthan is independent of the venue being
at Jaipur. The two clauses must be read together as the
Courts in Rajasthan have been vested with jurisdiction
only because the seat of arbitration was to be at Jaipur.
Once the seat of arbitration is replaced by mutual
agreement to be at Ahmedabad, the Courts at
Rajasthan are no longer vested with jurisdiction as
exclusive jurisdiction is now vested in the Courts at
Ahmedabad, given the change in the seat of
arbitration.”
(emphasis added)
18.
This Court could entertain the petitioner’s prayer for the appointment
of a substitute arbitrator only if it were to hold that the seat of
arbitration is located at Jammu. However, given the serious dispute
between the parties concerning the designated seat of arbitration, this
Court is of the considered view that adjudicating upon the merits of the
petitioner’s contentions would implicitly amount to rendering a finding
that the seat of arbitration was indeed Jammu, a premise this Court
cannot assume without usurping jurisdiction.
19.
In view of the above, without commenting upon the merits of the
claims of the respective parties, this Court deems it proper to return the
present petition to the petitioner to present it before the competent
Arb P No. 54/2024
Court having jurisdiction to determine the controversy raised in the
present petition in view of prima facie finding returned by this Court
that seat of arbitration has been fixed at Delhi.
20.
Disposed of.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
JAMMU
14.08.2026
Neha-1
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
Neha Kumari
2026.08.14 13:26
I attest to the accuracy and
P No. 54/2024
integrity of this Arb
document
Yes.
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review