Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT At CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:The Hon’ble Justice Madhuresh Prasad
And
The Hon’ble Justice Prasenjit Biswas
M.A.T. 2299 of 2025
With
CAN 1 Of 2026
CAN 2 of 2026
Union of India & Ors.
Vs.
Yuvraj Chand Rajwar
For the U.O.I.
: Mr. Dhiraj Trivedi, Ld. A.S.G.,
Mr. Uttam Basak,
Ms. Katha Sarkar,
Ms. Divyanshi Shaw
For the respondents
: Mr. K.B.S. Mahapatra, Adv.
Mr. Aditya Shit.
Judgment on
: 10. 09. 2026
Madhuresh Prasad, J.:
1. The present intra court appeal arises out of a judgment of the learned
Single Judge Bench dated 02.09.2025 in WPA No.30572 of 2016
quashing the order dated 14.06.2025 whereby and whereunder the
writ petitioner was prematurely retired. The learned Single Judge
Bench
directed
consideration
of
the
petitioner’s
case
by
an
appropriate review committee constituted as per Fundamental Rules
(FR) 56 (j) and Rule 48 Central Civil Service (Pension) Rules, 1972.
There was a further direction by the learned Single Judge Bench that
if the petitioner had not attained the age of superannuation he should
be reinstated along with arrears of salary and allowances with interest
at the rate of 6 per cent per annum.
2. The writ petitioner was an inspector in the Central Industrial Security
Force (CISF). At the relevant point of time he was posted at the unit of
the force guarding Eastern Coalfields Limited at Sitalpur. By an order
dated 14.06.2016 issued by the Deputy Inspector General of the
Force, CISF North Eastern Zone, the petitioner was pre-maturely
retired from service. The order was issued with immediate effect. The
petitioner was also paid a sum equivalent to the amount of his pay
and allowances for 3 months (notice period) as per his last pays
drawn. The order of pre-mature retirement dated 14.06.2016 was put
to challenge by the writ petitioner in W.P. No.30572 (W) of 2016.
3. Assailing the judgment of the learned Single Judge, the learned ASG,
Mr. Trivedi submitted that the order of the learned Single Judge is
unsustainable. Insofar as alleged incompetence of the Review
Committee, the submissions were devoid of substance. Pursuant to
instructions issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of
India one CISF Circular No.16/2015, dated 07.09.2015 was issued.
By this circular the Internal Screening Committee, Superannuation
Review Committee and Representation Committee for disposal of
cases under FR 56 (j) and Rule 48 of CCS (Pension) Rule 1972 was
reconstituted. The circular provided 3 separate screening committees
for separate rank of members of the force. For the rank of Inspector
(petitioner) the circular provided for a 3-member Superannuation
Review Committee comprising of a:
(i) Chairman- SDG/ADG (HQrs),
(ii) Member (I)-IG (HQrs), and
(iii) Member-(II)-AIG (Estt).
4. The petitioner’s claim was therefore, considered by a competent review
committee comprising of AIG (Establishment), Inspector General
(Headquarters) and Additional Director General (Headquarters). The
submissions
regarding
the
decision
of
petitioner’s
pre-mature
retirement being taken by an incompetent authority, is unsustainable.
The provisions relied upon by the writ petitioner are not applicable to
the petitioner’s case. The provisions relied upon are for review of
officers on civil posts in the Government of India. Paragraph 2 of the
circular No.16 of 2015 clearly states that the committee was
constituted for reviewing the superannuation for members of the
force. There is no allegation that the circular No.16 of 2015 was not
complied by the authorities.
5. It is submitted by the learned ASG that the power of the authorities to
prematurely retire, a member of the force is not in dispute. The
decision is taken by a competent Review Committee. Further it is
submitted that the Committee has taken into consideration the
relevant factors including the 02 major punishments awarded to the
petitioner while in service and 5 minor punishments awarded to him.
The punishments were awarded having regard to the repeated
misconduct of the petitioners in the force. The nature of misconduct
for
which
the
petitioner
was
awarded
punishment
included
involvement in theft of property of a guarded installation, use of
derogatory language and threatening members of the force. He was
also punished for other acts of indiscipline including absence from
shift duty, and also for not taking prompt action in respect of one
seriously injured Late Constable while performing R.I duty. The
Review Committee therefore arrived at a decision regarding the
petitioner’s continuance in the force to be unsustainable based on
relevant material. For the purposes of premature retirement, no
provision circumscribes the consideration limited to entries in the
ACR. Therefore, the decision was based on consideration of relevant
material; and was beyond the scope of judicial review under Article
226 of the Constitution of India. The learned Single Judge therefore,
should not interfere with the decision of the Review Committee.
6. The learned ASG relied upon decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of Union of India vs. Col J.N. Sinha & Anr. Reported in (1970)
2 SCC 458, to submit that the decision of the Review Committee
cannot be interfered with, since the authority formed a bona fide
opinion based on relevant consideration regarding the petitioner’s
premature retirement to subserve public interest. Such opinion which
was not an arbitrary one and taken for energising the force, having
regard to the requisite efficiency of a uniform and discipline force
cannot be interfered with in exercise of judicial review.
7. Another judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India relied upon
by the learned ASG is in the case of Central Industrial Security
Force vs. HC (GD) Om Prakash reported in (2022) 5 SCC 100. The
Apex
Court
considered
various
earlier
judgments
as
regards
premature retirement including judgment of a three judge bench of
the Apex court in the case of State of Punjab vs. Gurdas Singh
reported in (1998) 4 SCC 92 wherein the Apex Court held that before
decision to prematurely retire a government servant is taken, the
authorities are required to consider the whole record of service. The
judgment also considered earlier judgment of the Apex court in the
case of Pyare Mohan Lal vs. State of Jharkhand reported in (2010)
10 SCC 693, wherein the Apex Court clarified that adverse entries
prior to promotion would have no relevance and be treated as wiped
off when the case of the government employee is considered for
further promotion. “However, this “washed-off theory” will have
no application when the case of an employee is being assessed
to determine whether he is fit to be retained in service or
requires to be given compulsory retirement. The rationale given
is that since such an assessment is based on “entire service
record”, there is no question of not taking into consideration the
earlier old adverse entries or record of the old period. We may
hasten to add that while such a record can be taken into
consideration, at the same time, the service record of the
immediate past period will have to be given due credence and
weightage. For example, as against some very old adverse
entries where the immediate past record shows exemplary
performance, ignoring such a record of recent past and acting
only on the basis of old adverse entries, to retire a person will be
a clear example of arbitrary exercise of power. However, if old
record pertains to integrity of a person then that may be
sufficient to justify the order of premature retirement of the
government servant.”
8. Considering earlier judgments, the Apex court held in the case of HC
(GD) Omprakash (supra) at para 15:
“15. The entire service record is to be taken into
consideration which would include the ACRs of the
period prior to the promotion. The order of premature
retirement is required to be passed on the basis of entire
service records, though the recent reports would carry
their own weight.”
9. The learned ASG also relied upon recent decision of a Co-ordinate
Bench of this court in the case of Swapan Kumar Roy Ex-Head
Constable/GD vs. Union of India & Ors., in MAT 146 of 2024 on
03.09.2024, wherein the Coordinate Bench considered the plea of the
writ petitioner therein that since he was granted career progression
within last 5 years prior to the order of premature retirement, the
premature retirement was unsustainable. The Coordinate Bench held:
“16. The contention of the appellant that, he was
promoted within five years from the order of retirement,
unfortunately is not substantiated by the evidence on
record. Appellant was granted benefit under the career
progression scheme within last five years of the order of
retirement. We are unable to consider grant of such
benefit as a grant of promotion in the service career of
the appellant.”
10.
The learned Advocate for the writ petitioner submitted that
judgment of the learned Single Judge did not require any interference.
11.
The Deputy Inspector General issued the impugned order of pre-
mature
retirement
dated
14.06.2016,
whereas
the
authority
competent to take such decision for the petitioner’s head of the
department, namely the Director General of the Force. Learned
Advocate submitted that the Government of India specified the
Constitution of Review Committee for consideration; and for taking a
decision in respect of premature retirement. For non-gazetted officers,
the Annexure II in Appendix IX of the CCS Pension Rules specified:
ANNEXURE-II
CONSTITUTION OF COMMITTEES
Classification
Composition of Review Committee
Composition of
Representation
Committee
…………………..
……………..
……….
(ii)
Non-gazetted (ii) The Head of the Department or the
officers
under
serving appointing Authority whomsoever is
a higher
would
be
the
Chairman;
Ministry/Departme
another senior officer nominated by
nt.
an
appropriately
higher
authority
and who does not exercise direct
immediate control or supervision over
…………….
the
officers
being
screened
as
member. If action is proposed to be
taken on grounds of lack of integrity,
the Vigilance Officer concerned shall
be associate as third Member. Final
orders
will
be
passed
by
the
appropriate authority.
………..
12.
………….
………….
The petitioner was a non-gazetted officer in the force. As per the
provision decision in respect of his pre-mature retirement was to be
taken by a review committee comprising of the petitioner’s head of the
department (Director General of the Force). The order issued by the
DIG is unsustainable. He submits that the order of premature
retirement issued by the DIG is based on scrutiny by a Committee
comprising of an Assistant Inspector General/Estt, Inspector General
(HQrs) and an Additional Director General (HQrs). Therefore, neither
the scrutiny, nor the impugned order is issued by the competent
authority. The decision therefore is taken by authorities who have no
jurisdiction to consider the petitioner’s pre-mature retirement. The
order of pre-mature retirement was thus unsustainable, and fit to be
quashed.
13.
The learned Advocate for the writ petitioner/respondent submitted
that the criteria to be followed by a Review Committee while making
recommendations is laid down in Clause 10 (iv) of the Office
Memorandum dated 28.08.2020. Accordingly, no government servant
should ordinarily be made to retire prematurely if his service during
the preceding 5 years, or where he has been promoted to a higher post
during that 5 year period and his service in the highest post, has been
found satisfactory. In case of a government servant promoted during
the last 5 years the previous entries in the ACRs may be taken into
account only if he was not promoted on merit. The specific provision
relied upon reads:
“(iv) No Government servant should ordinarily be retired on
ground of ineffectiveness, if, his service during the preceding 5
years or where he has been promoted to a higher post during
that 5 year period, his service in the highest post, has been
found satisfactory. There is no such stipulation, however,
where the Government servant is to be retired on grounds of
doubtful integrity. In case of those Government servants who
have been promoted during the last 5 years, the previous
entries in the ACRs may be taken into account if he was
promoted on the basis of seniority cum fitness, and not on the
basis of merit. (v) The entire service record of a Government
servant should be considered at the time of review. The
expression 'service record' refers to all relevant records and
therefore,
the
review
should
not
be
confined
to
the
consideration of the ACR/APAR dossier. The personal file of the
Government servant may contain valuable material. Similarly,
his work and performance could also be assessed by looking
into files dealt with by him or in any papers or reports
prepared and submitted by him. It would be useful if the
Ministry I Department/Cadre puts together all the data
available about the Government servant and prepares a
comprehensive
Committee.
brief
Even
for
consideration
uncommunicated
by
the
remarks
ACRs/APARs may be taken into consideration.”
Review
in
the
14.
In the present case there is no issue of adverse ACR. In fact the
petitioner was granted the benefit of MACP within the last 5 years.
Under the circumstances there was no occasion for the petitioner’s
premature retirement.
15.
The learned Advocate also submitted that the Screening Committee
had recommended the petitioner to be “fit for retention”. However, the
review committee found the petitioner to be “unfit”. The decision of the
Review Committee, therefore, is at stark variance with decision of the
Review Committee, and the same is unsustainable. Reliance is placed
on a CISF Circular No.1 of 2014 to submit that the eligibility condition
for grant of the career progression were one and the same, as required
for grant of regular promotion. For grant of career progression (Scale)
also, a member of the force was required to be attaining the
prescribed benchmark, Qualifying in PCC and in physical SHAPE-I
categorization. Only upon fulfilling such requirement, otherwise
requisite for a promotion, the petitioner was granted the benefit of
MACP. Therefore, as per clause 10 of the office Memorandum,
extracted above, the decision of the Review Committee to prematurely
retire the writ petitioner is unsustainable. He submits that the Review
Committee was overwhelmed by past penalties inflicted against the
petitioner, which could not have been considered. Once the petitioner
was found fit for promotion at the time of grant of benefit of MACP,
there was no scope for the petitioner to be considered unfit or
ineffective; for prematurely retiring the petitioner.
16.
He further submits that the Review Committee did not specify any
reasons for differing with the recommendations made by the screening
committee, favourable to the petitioner. Thus, the decision of the
Review Committee is unsustainable.
17.
We have considered the rival submissions, the relevant provisions
relied upon, and the judgments cited at the bar.
18.
Insofar as submission regarding lack of competence of the Review
Committee, we find force in the submission of the learned ASG that
the petitioner’s case for the purposes of pre-mature retirement was
required to be scrutinized by the “Superannuation Review Committee”,
specified for Inspectors in CISF Circular No.16 of 2015. The Circular
was issued by the office of the Director General of the Force pursuant
of instructions issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs in this regard.
The circular was issued for considering and disposing of cases of CISF
personnel under FR 56 (j) and Rule 48 of the CCS (Pension) Rules
1972.
19.
The circular therefore covers the services of the members of the
armed forces. This circular was not questioned/challenged by the writ
petitioner. Under the circumstances we find no scope for the
petitioner to place reliance on the Constitution of a committee under
Appendix (ix) of the CCS Pension Rules. The same was for civil
employees of the Government of India, and not for member of the
force (CISF). We, therefore, find no infirmity in composition of the
review committee which considered the desirability of continuance; or
discontinuance by premature retirement of members of the force,
including
the
writ
petitioner.
The
committee
comprising
of
AIG/Establishment, Inspector General/HQ and Additional Director
General/HQ was competent as per the CISF Circular No. 16/2015 to
consider and decide the petitioner’s premature retirement.
20.
The learned advocate for the petitioner also made a submission that
in view of the nature of ACR entries in the petitioner’s service records,
there was no basis for petitioner’s premature retirement. However, the
learned advocate for the petitioner has not shown any provision
circumscribing the limit of scrutiny for this purpose, limited only to
ACR Entries. In fact, the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in the case of Swapan Kumar Roy (supra); Central Industrial
Security Force (supra); Col J.N Sinha (supra) relied upon by the
learned ASG leaves no ambiguity that all relevant factors including
ACR was required to be considered. In the present case all relevant
factors including various penalties awarded to the petitioner have
been considered to conclude that the petitioners continuance in the
force would not be in public interest.
21.
Insofar as the submission that the punishment cannot be
considered since the petitioner was granted a benefit of MACP, after
many of the punishments, such submission, in our opinion is equally
devoid of substance.
22.
Paragraph 6 of the CISF Circular No.1 of 2014 regarding MACP, on
which the petitioner placed reliance reads:
“06 Since, the other two conditions viz., (a) qualifying of PCC
and (b) attaining SHAPE-1 medical categorization which were
essential for granting Financial Upgradation under ACP
scheme are no longer required to be followed under MACP
Scheme, the aspect of having consequential impact of
deferment of FUGs under MACPS resulting due to delay in
qualifying PCC / attaining SHAPE-I under ACP Scheme would
not have any consequential deferring impact in granting
2nd/3rd Financial Upgradations under MACP scheme as they
are no longer pre-requisites for granting FUGs under MACPS”.
23.
A plain reading of the provisions reveals that the eligibility for the
purposes of grant of, Financial Upgradation (FUG) under MACP
Scheme is much less than the eligibility for grant of a regular
promotion. The circular has diluted the earlier requirement for grant
of FUGs under ACP, which included qualifying PCC, and being in
Shape 1 medical category, at per with requisite qualifications for grant
of promotion, as per submission of the learned advocate for the writ
petitioner. The CISF circular no.1 of 2014 therefore does not support
the petitioner’s case.
24.
The learned advocate also relied on decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in the case of J.D. Shrivastva vs. State of M.P. &
Ors., reported in 1948 Lab I.C. 337, wherein the Apex Court took
notice of the fact that for taking a decision to compulsorily retire the
appellant therein, the employer did not rely upon anything apart from
the confidential records. The employer therein relied upon old dug out
files containing ACR Entries adverse to the petitioner. It is in this
context that the Apex Court held such action of the employer to be
unsustainable.
25.
Reliance placed by the learned advocate for the writ petitioner on
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of J.D
Shrivastva (supra) is misplaced. Judgment of the Apex Court was
considering the case is of a civil employee and not a member of an
armed force, who is bound by a more rigorous standard of suitability
having regard to the nature of duties and responsibilities to be
discharged in harsh and stressful considerations, and also a
requirement of a high degree of discipline, integrity and dedication to
duty.
26.
In the present case the Review Committees considered the various
penalties inflicted upon the petitioner. Bona fide consideration of the
entire service record has to be viewed keeping in the background the
fact that petitioner was an Inspector in a disciplined Central Armed
Police Force which requires a high level of discipline, integrity,
dedication and duty. Therefore, the decision not to continue the
petitioner, in public interest, does not suffer from any infirmity. We
have also found above that there is no fetter on such consideration in
respect of members of the force.
27.
We further observe that neither a case of perversity nor a case of
arbitrariness is made out in the decision making process. There is no
specific alleged mala fide against any authority involved in the process
of consideration. We, therefore, find force in the submission of the Ld.
ASG that there was no scope for the writ court to sit in appeal over
the decision of the Review Committee to compulsorily retire the writ
petitioner.
28.
Insofar
as the
submission
that the
impugned
order
dated
14.06.2016 is issued by the Deputy Inspector General, who is not
competent. We are of the view that the submission is unsustainable.
The impugned order is a mere communication, signed by the
petitioner’s
appointing
consideration
Supplementary
of
a
authority.
Review
Affidavit
on
The
same
Committee
behalf
of
is
preceded
Annexure-R-4
the
respondents
to
by
the
which
Committee we held was constituted in accordance with law, and
taking into consideration relevant factors.
29.
Under the circumstances, the decision of the learned Single Judge
to interfere with the order of compulsory retirement and to pass
consequential orders, in our view, is unsustainable in the eyes of law.
30.
The appeal is allowed.
31.
The order of the learned Single Judge is set aside. Consequently,
the writ petition stands dismissed.
32.
Urgent certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties, expeditiously after complying with all necessary legal
formalities.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
I agree.
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review