The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. Out of the aforesaid claims, the substantial amount has been awarded under Claim No. 2 (Incorrect Pricing). Learned Arbitrator awarded the said claim upon due appreciation of the documentary evidence on record, and re-appreciation of the evidence is beyond the scope of interference under Section 34/37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The remaining claims challenged by the petitioners have also been allowed by the learned Arbitrator after proper appreciation of the documentary evidence and due application of mind. Although the amounts awarded under the remaining claims are considerably lower than the amount awarded under Claim No. 2, the findings recorded thereon are equally based on the evidence on record and do not warrant interference under Section 37 of the Act.
9. In ‘Ramesh Kumar Jain vs. Bharat Aluminum Company Ltd.(Balco)’, 2025 INSC 1457, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has held that “It is a settled proposition of law as has been constantly observed by this court and we reiterate, the courts exercising jurisdiction under section 34 do not sit in appeal over the arbitral award hence they are not expected to examine the legality, reasonableness or correctness of findings on facts or law unless they come under any of grounds mandated in the said provision.” It has been further observed that “When it comes to Section 37 of the A&C Act, it provides for a limited appellate remedy against an order either setting aside or refusing to set aside an arbitral award passed by civil court in exercise of its power under section 34. This court in MMTC Ltd. v. Vedanta Ltd.15, at Paragraph 14 observed that interference with an order made under section 37 cannot travel beyond the restrictions laid down in section 34”.
10. We have examined the judgment passed by the learned Commercial Court and we are in perfect agreement with the findings recorded by the learned Commercial Court that no ground as contemplated under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act exists warranting interference with the award. Accordingly, the appeal fails on merits and is accordingly dismissed. (M.A. Chowdhary) Judge (Rajnesh Oswal) Judge Jammu
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: AA No. 16/2025
CM No. 4657/2026
CM No.7423/2025
Reserved on: 28.07.2026
Pronounced on:11.08.2026
Uploaded on:12.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced :Full
1. Union of India through Chief
Engineer, udhampur Zone, PO
Garhi, Udhampur.
2. Garrison Engineer (Project)
Nagrota.
……Petitioner(s)…..
Through: Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Karan Sharma, CGSC and
Mr. Eishaan Dadhichi, CGSC
v/s
M/s Bharat Construction,
11, East Extension, Sector
No.1-A, Trikuta Nagar,
Jammu.
Through:
Mr. Pooja Gupta, Advocate
……Respondent(s)…
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
PER OSWAL-J
1. This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 31.07.2025 passed
by the learned Addl. District Judge (Commercial Court), Jammu (for
short “the Commercial Court) in the petition under Section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997. whereby the petition preferred
AA No. 16/2025
by the appellants for setting aside the arbitral award dated 29.12.2017
as amended on 03.02.2018 passed by the Sole Arbitrator Sh.
S.S.Bansal Joint DG (Contracts) CEWC, has been dismissed.
Grounds of Challenge:
2. The impugned judgment dated 31.07.2025 is challenged, inter alia, on
the following grounds:
(i)
That the order impugned suffers from patent illegality, besides
being arbitrary, and suffers from failure of lawful exercise of
jurisdiction, as such is liable to be set aside.
(ii)
That the learned Addl. District Judge (Commercial Court),
Jammu has failed to appreciate that the arbitral award is
contrary to the express terms and conditions of the Contract, a
specific ground raised in the application under Section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997. The award, being in
violation of Section 28(3) of the Act, which mandates that the
arbitral tribunal shall decide in accordance with the terms of the
contract, is patently illegal and opposed to the public policy of
India. The Court below has failed to consider and adjudicate
upon this specific ground.
(iii) That the learned Addl. District Judge (Commercial Court),
Jammu has failed to appreciate that a specific ground was raised
in the petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1997 that the arbitral award is a non-speaking
award, unsupported by reasons, in violation of the mandatory
requirement of Section 31(3) of the Act and, therefore, opposed
AA No. 16/2025
to the public policy of India. The Court below, however,
erroneously held that no ground under Section 34(2)(b)(ii) of
the Act had been raised to assail the arbitral award.
(iv) That the impugned order is a non-speaking order. The Court
below has failed to consider any of the specific grounds of
challenge raised under Section 34(2)(b)(ii) of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1997 and has merely reproduced settled
legal principles without returning any findings on the objections
raised against the arbitral award.
(v)
That the Court below has failed to appreciate that the arbitral
award is contrary to the terms of the contract, unsupported by
reasons, and therefore patently illegal and opposed to the public
policy of India. The Court below has further failed to examine
the objections to each claim independently and, having
dismissed the petition without adjudicating the specific grounds
raised under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1997, the impugned order is unsustainable and liable to be set
aside.
Factual Matrix:
3. Brief facts necessary for the disposal of the present appeal are that the
respondent entered into Contract Agreement bearing CA No.
CEUZ/135WE/06/2012-13 for "Provision of OTM Accommodation
for 'A' Engineer Regiment (Phase-II) at Nagrota." Certain disputes
having arisen out of the execution of the said contract, the respondent
invoked the arbitration clause contained in Condition 70 of IAFW2249 (General Conditions of Contract), which provided for reference
AA No. 16/2025
of disputes to a sole arbitrator to be appointed by the Chief Engineer,
Zone Udhampur. Accordingly, Sh. S.S. Bansal, Chief Engineer
(Q&C), Joint DG (Contracts), Engineers Branch, HQ Western
Command, Chandimandir, was appointed as the Sole Arbitrator. The
learned Sole Arbitrator entered upon the reference on 20.02.2017,
heard the parties and, upon conclusion of the arbitral proceedings,
published the arbitral award dated 29.12.2017, which was received by
the appellants on 04.01.2018. Thereafter, an amended award was
published on 03.02.2018, which was received by the appellants on
12.02.2018.
4. Being aggrieved of the arbitral award dated 29.12.2017, as amended
on 03.02.2018, the appellants filed a petition under Section 34 of the
Jammu & Kashmir Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997 before the
learned Commercial Court seeking its setting aside, however, vide the
impugned judgment dated 31.07.2025, the learned Commercial Court
dismissed the petition.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
meticulously.
Appreciation:
6. The facts which are not in dispute are that the respondent was
awarded
Contract
Agreement
bearing
CA
No.
CEUZ/135WE/06/2012-13 for "Provision of OTM Accommodation
for 'A' Engineer Regiment (Phase-II) at Nagrota." Disputes arose
between the parties during the execution of the contract. In terms of
Condition 70 of IAFW-2249 (General Conditions of Contract), the
AA No. 16/2025
disputes were referred to arbitration and Sh. S.S. Bansal was
appointed as the Sole Arbitrator. The learned Sole Arbitrator entered
upon the reference on 20.02.2017 and, after completion of the arbitral
proceedings, made and published an arbitral award on 29.12.2017.
Subsequently, an amended award was published on 03.02.2018.
Aggrieved by the arbitral award dated 29.12.2017, as amended on
03.02.2018, the appellants preferred a petition under Section 34 of the
Jammu & Kashmir Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997 before the
learned Additional District Judge (Commercial Court), Jammu,
seeking setting aside of the award. Respondent filed objections before
the Commercial Court stating therein that the challenge to the arbitral
award was beyond the limited scope of interference under Section 34
of the Jammu & Kashmir Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1997. It
was further contended that the award was passed after affording due
opportunity to both the parties, in compliance with the principles of
natural justice, and that it is a reasoned award based on the terms of
the contract and the material on record. The respondent accordingly
prayed for dismissal of the instant appeal with costs. The learned
Commercial Court, vide judgment dated 31.07.2025, dismissed the
said petition. Aggrieved thereof, the appellants have preferred the
present appeal.
7. A perusal of the petition filed under Section 34 of the Act reveals that
the appellants had assailed the Claim Nos. 2 (Incorrect Pricing), Claim
No. 7 (Damages due to unlawful recoveries from RARs), Claim No. 8
(Damages due to breach of Condition 64 of IAFW-2249 -General
Conditions
AA No. 16/2025
of
Contract),
Claim
No.
(Escalation
reimbursement/refund on account of variation in prices), Claim No.
11 (Damages due to breach of Condition 66 of IAFW-2249 – General
Conditions of Contract), Claim No. 15 (Provision of lintel band in the
garage for the air compressor), Claim No. 16 (Interest), and Claim 17
(Costs of Arbitration).
8. Out of the aforesaid claims, the substantial amount has been awarded
under Claim No. 2 (Incorrect Pricing). Learned Arbitrator awarded the
said claim upon due appreciation of the documentary evidence on
record, and re-appreciation of the evidence is beyond the scope of
interference under Section 34/37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996. The remaining claims challenged by the petitioners have
also been allowed by the learned Arbitrator after proper appreciation
of the documentary evidence and due application of mind. Although
the amounts awarded under the remaining claims are considerably
lower than the amount awarded under Claim No. 2, the findings
recorded thereon are equally based on the evidence on record and do
not warrant interference under Section 37 of the Act.
9. In ‘Ramesh Kumar Jain vs. Bharat Aluminum Company
Ltd.(Balco)’, 2025 INSC 1457, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
has held that “It is a settled proposition of law as has been constantly
observed by this court and we reiterate, the courts exercising
jurisdiction under section 34 do not sit in appeal over the arbitral
award hence they are not expected to examine the legality,
reasonableness or correctness of findings on facts or law unless they
come under any of grounds mandated in the said provision.” It has
been further observed that “When it comes to Section 37 of the A&C
AA No. 16/2025
Act, it provides for a limited appellate remedy against an order either
setting aside or refusing to set aside an arbitral award passed by civil
court in exercise of its power under section 34. This court in MMTC
Ltd. v. Vedanta Ltd.15, at Paragraph 14 observed that interference
with an order made under section 37 cannot travel beyond the
restrictions laid down in section 34”.
10.We have examined the judgment passed by the learned Commercial
Court and we are in perfect agreement with the findings recorded by
the learned Commercial Court that no ground as contemplated under
Section 34 of the Arbitration Act exists warranting interference with
the award. Accordingly, the appeal fails on merits and is accordingly
dismissed.
(M.A. Chowdhary)
Judge
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
11.08.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Yes.
Whether order is reportable? No.
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.08.12 10:16
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
AA No. 16/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review