Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WA.556 of 2025
-:1:2025:KER:26139
“C.R.”
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. NITIN JAMDAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 556 OF 2025
[AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 24-02-2025 IN WP(C) NO.44196 OF 2024]
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
TRIVANDRUM APOLLO TOWERS PVT. LTD.,
DOOR NO. XIX/315-U, CITY PLAZA, CENTRAL BAZAAR,
MANJERI, MALAPPURAM – PIN – 676121.
REPRESENTED BY MANAGING DIRECTOR –
KORAMBAPALAMKUNNATH SABITH.
HOTEL CITY PLAZA PVT. LTD.,
DOOR NO. XIX/ 315-T, CITY PLAZA, CENTRAL BAZAAR,
MANJERI, MALAPPURAM, REPRESENTED BY DIRECTOR –
KORAMBAPALAMKUNNATH SABITH, PIN – 676121.
BY ADVS. SRI. R.JAIKRISHNA
SRI. AKHIL SHAJI
SRI. ANISH P.
SRI. C.S.ARUN SHANKAR
SRI. NARAYANI HARIKRISHNAN
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF FINANCE, JEEVAN DEEP BUILDING,
PARLIAMENT STREET, NEW DELHI, PIN – 110003.
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY.
ASSISTANT DIRECTOR,
ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE, KOCHI ZONAL OFFICE,
KANEES CASTLE, MULLASSERY CANAL ROAD WEST,
ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682011.
WA.556 of 2025
-:2:2025:KER:26139
ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE,
MINISTRY OF FINANCE, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
6TH FLOOR, LOK NAYAK BHAVAN, KHAN MARKET,
NEW DELHI, PIN – 110003, REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR.
ADJUDICATING AUTHORITY (PMLA),
OFFICE OF THE ADJUDICATING AUTHORITY, ROOM 26,
4TH FLOOR, JEEVAN DEEP BUILDING,
PARLIAMENT STREET, NEW DELHI,
REPRESENTED BY REGISTRAR, PIN – 110001.
AXIS BANK LTD., THE SALVATION ARMY INDIA SOUTH WESTERN
TERRITORY, KURAVANKONAM ROAD, KOWDIAR P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695003,
REPRESENTED BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER.
DHANALAXMI BANK LTD.,
GROUND FLOOR, KORAMBAYIL COPERATE MALL,
CENTRAL BAZAR, CALICUT ROAD, MANJERI,
MALAPPURAM, PIN – 676121,
REPRESENTED BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER.
HDFC BANK LTD., TC 25/2344,
PREMIER TOWERS, AYURVEDA COLLEGE JUNCTION,
MG ROAD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695001.
REPRESENTED BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER.
STATE BANK OF INDIA LTD.,
COMMERCIAL BRANCH, GANESH KRIPA, JAS HOTEL ROAD,
THYCAUD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695014.
REPRESENTED BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER.
BY ADV. SRI. KRISHNA T. C.,
R6 BY ADV. SRI. C.K. KARUNAKARAN,
R7 BY ADV. SMT. AKSHARA RAJU.
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 24.03.2025, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WA.556 of 2025
-:3:2025:KER:26139
“C.R.”
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 24th day of March, 2025.
Nitin Jamdar, C. J.
This Appeal under Section 5 of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958,
is filed challenging the order passed in W.P.(C) No.44196 of 2024,
dated 24 February 2025, by which, the learned Single Judge rejected the
prayer for interim relief sought by the Appellants in the writ petition.
2.
The Appellants/Original Petitioners are engaged in the business of
hotel construction. During the course of the search conducted on the
premises, statements were recorded under Section 17 of the Prevention
of Money-Laundering Act, 2002 (Act 15 of 2003). Recording that the
hotel property appears to have been built using the proceeds of crime
obtained through unsecured loans by the group of companies and that
the proceeds of crime are held in the bank accounts, an order was passed
by the Assistant Director, Enforcement Directorate, Ernakulam, under
Section 17(1A) of Act 15 of 2003, directing the Banks – Respondent
Nos. 5 to 8, to freeze the accounts to the extent of the balance mentioned
therein.
3.
Being aggrieved by the above action, the Appellants have filed the
writ petition challenging the order passed by Respondent No. 2 –
Assistant Director, freezing the bank accounts of the Appellants. The
WA.556 of 2025
-:4:2025:KER:26139
Appellants have also prayed for a writ of mandamus directing
Respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 – Enforcement Directorate and the
Adjudicating Authority, to forbear from proceeding with any
proceedings against the Appellants, including the adjudication
proceedings under the Act 15 of 2003. Interim relief was also sought by
the Appellants to lift the freeze on the bank accounts. The learned Single
Judge, by the impugned order dated 24 February 2025, rejected the
interim relief sought by the Appellants. Challenging this order, the
present Appeal is filed.
4.
We have heard Mr. Jaikrishna R., learned counsel for the
Appellants, Mr. C.K. Karunakaran, learned counsel for Respondent No.
6, and Ms. Akshara Raju, learned counsel for Respondent No. 7.
5.
Apart from the merits of the impugned order and the claim of the
Appellants, other questions arise. The writ petition is filed as Writ
Petition (Civil) - “W.P.(C)”. First, it will have to be examined as to
whether the subject writ petition is a Civil Writ Petition or Criminal Writ
Petition. There is a distinction between a Civil Writ Petition and a
Criminal Writ Petition. This distinction is elaborated in the decision of
this Court in the case of N.Prakash v. Manoj Kumar1. In the said
decision, this Court observed as follows:
“7. Though civil proceedings and criminal proceedings
have not been statutorily defined under the Kerala
2025 (1) KLT 835
WA.556 of 2025
-:5:2025:KER:26139
High Court Act and the Rules, these proceedings are
different and distinct, and there could be some overlap.
An identical position has arisen in other High Courts as
well, and the view taken by these High Courts
following the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
will guide us to make a distinction and to ascertain
whether the present petition should be treated as a
criminal writ petition.
***
14. Noticing and analysing these decisions, the
Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in M/s.
Nagpur Cable Operators’ Association, speaking
through R.M. Lodha, J. (as His Lordship then was), laid
down the following position of law:
“21. In the light of the aforesaid legal position
explaining the nature of proceedings under Article
226 of the Constitution, and the classification
whether the said proceeding is civil or criminal,
when the provisions of the Appellate Side Rules
are looked into, it would be found that all
applications under Article 227 of the Constitution
challenging the orders and decisions of the Courts
constituted under the Criminal Procedure Code
are dealt with on the side of criminal business of
the Appellate Side of this Court, but the said
clause (i) of Part II, Criminal of Rule 2 of Chapter
I is not all exhaustive. Rule 2-B of Chapter I, as
observed above, states that all petitions/
applications under Article 226/227 of the
Constitution arising out of or relating to the order
of penalty or confiscation or an order in the nature
thereof or an order otherwise of penal character
and passed under any Special Statute shall be
heard and decided by the Division Bench hearing
WA.556 of 2025
-:6:2025:KER:26139
writ petitions. This rule only allocates that the
class of petitions/applications under Articles 226
and/or 227 of the Constitution of India
mentioned in Rule 2-B shall be decided by the
Division Bench hearing writ petitions, but does
not classify the nature of proceedings whether the
said writ petition/application shall be criminal or
civil writ petition. Applying the tests laid down by
the Apex Court in Narayan Row's case (supra), we
are of the view that if the writ petition/application
under Articles 226 and/or 227 of the Constitution
arises out of or relates to a proceeding in which, if
carried to its conclusion ultimately it may result in
sentence of death or by way of imprisonment, fine
or forfeiture of the property then such writ
petition/application under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India and/or under Article 227 of
the Constitution, should be treated as a "criminal
writ petition" and styled as such. For hearing and
decision of such petition, it should be listed before
the Division Bench allocated such business by
Hon'ble the Chief Justice or if it pertains to the
single Judge jurisdiction, before the Bench
assigned such work. As regards petitions/
applications under Article 226 of the Constitution
seeking writs or orders in the nature of habeas
corpus, Rule 1 of Chapter XXVIII of Appellate
Side Rules, also provides only allocation of such
writ petitions to the Division Bench taking
criminal business of the Appellate Side of the
High Court. Obviously, since the petitions/
applications under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India for issuance of writs of habeas corpus arise
out of the unlawful detention, in its very nature,
WA.556 of 2025
-:7:2025:KER:26139
such petitions too should be styled as criminal writ
petitions. Criminal writ petitions would also cover
those writ petitions which arise out of the orders
and the matters relating to prevention or breach of
peace or maintenance of peace and order or such
orders aimed at preventing vagrancy contemplated
to be passed. 'Criminal writ petition' shall also
take in its embrace the petitions/ applications
under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of
India if it arises out of or relates to investigation,
enquiry or trial of the offences either under special
or general statute. When a statute commands or
prohibits an act, disobedience of such statute is
prima facie criminal unless criminal proceedings
are excluded by such statute and the petitions/
applications under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India in connection thereto or
arising therefrom would be criminal proceeding
and should be styled as 'Criminal Writ Petition'.
However, such cases are to be distinguished from
the cases where an act may be prohibited or
commanded by the statute in such a manner that
the person contravening the provision is liable to
pecuniary penalty and such recovery is to be made
a civil debt. In such type of cases the
contravention would not be a crime and,
therefore, petitions/applications under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India arising
therefrom would not be criminal proceeding.”
(emphasis supplied)
15. According to us, the same test can be adopted
while determining in which circumstances a "criminal
writ petition" - W.P.(Crl.) is to be filed and in which
WA.556 of 2025
-:8:2025:KER:26139
cases a civil writ petition – W.P.(C) is to be filed in this
court as well. Obviously, the list cannot be exhaustive.
Also, there can be overlap. Broadly stated, if a writ
petition or application under Articles 226 and/or 227
of the Constitution of India concerns a legal proceeding
that could ultimately lead to a sentence of death,
imprisonment, a fine, or the forfeiture of property, it
would be a "criminal writ petition" - W.P.(Crl.).
Additionally, criminal writ petitions include those that
arise from orders related to maintaining peace and
order, preventing breaches of peace, or addressing
vagrancy. Furthermore, any writ petition or application
under Article 226 or 227 connected to the
investigation, inquiry, or trial of offences, whether
under a special or general law, would also be considered
a criminal writ petition.”
***
As pointed out by the Registry, as per the present Roster, Civil Writ
Petitions and Criminal Writ Petitions are assigned to different Single
Judges. Also, Appeals arising from the orders passed in Civil Writ
Petitions and Criminal Writ Petitions are placed before different
Benches. The learned Single Judge has the Roster of Civil Writ Petition.
Thus, the enquiry as to whether the writ petition is a Civil Writ Petition
or a Criminal Writ Petition is necessary to ascertain whether it falls
within the present Roster.
6.
To examine whether a matter pertains to the Roster / allocation is
important in view of the recent decision of the Supreme Court in the case
of Garden Reach Shipbuilders and Engineers Limited v. Grse Limited
WA.556 of 2025
-:9:2025:KER:26139
Workmens Union and Others , wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has declared the legal effect of the order passed in a case outside the
Roster and without specific order of allocation. The relevant observations
are as follows:
“9. In the light of the law laid down by the High Court
itself [authoritatively speaking through Hon’ble P.D. Desai,
CJ. (as the Chief Justice then was)] in Sohan Lal Baid v.
State of West Bengal (AIR 1990 Calcutta 168), as
approved by a three-Judge Bench of this Court in State of
Rajasthan v. Prakash Chand [(1998) 1 SCC 1] which has
subsequently been approved by a Constitution Bench in
Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms v.
Union of India [(2018) 1 SCC 196], as well as Rule 26
(supra), we hold that any order which a bench – comprising
of two judges or a single judge – may choose to make in a
case that is not placed before them/him by the Chief Justice
of the High Court or in accordance with His Lordship's
directions, such an order is without jurisdiction. In other
words, an adjudication, beyond allocation, is void and such
adjudication has to be considered a nullity. It needs no
emphasis that the Chief Justice of the High Court, being
the primus inter pares, has been vested with the power and
authority to set the roster, as articulated in Sohan Lal Baid
(supra), and such roster is final and binding on all the
‘Companion Justices’ of the said court. Plainly, therefore,
the order dated March 11, 2024 and the impugned order
are without jurisdiction.
10. On this limited ground, but without examining the
merits of the rival claims, the impugned order is liable to be
and is, accordingly, set aside. We order a remand, with the
2025 SCC OnLine SC 582
WA.556 of 2025
-:10:2025:KER:26139
result that the writ petition shall stand revived on the file of
the High Court. We request the Chief Justice of the High
Court to assign the writ petition to an appropriate bench
for its consideration and disposal, as early as possible, but
preferably within six months from today, considering that
the respondents have been waiting for their turn for
compassionate appointment and the appellants have their
own reasons for not proceeding with making such
appointment resulting in a delayed determination.”
(emphasis supplied)
Thus, the dicta of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is clear that any order
passed in a matter outside the Roster or not specifically assigned would
be without jurisdiction and nullity.
7.
The learned counsel for the parties submitted that prima facie, the
present writ petition will have to be considered as a Criminal Writ
Petition, however, this inquiry will have to be conducted by the learned
Single Judge at the first instance.
8.
Accordingly, we dispose of the Appeal to enable the learned Single
Judge to examine whether W.P.(C) No.44196 of 2024 is a Civil Writ
Petition or Criminal Writ Petition. If the learned Single Judge comes to
the conclusion that the writ petition is a Criminal Writ Petition and does
not pertain to the assigned Roster, then as per the law declared by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Garden Reach Shipbuilders and
Engineers Limited, the order dated 24 February 2025 will be treated as a
WA.556 of 2025
-:11:2025:KER:26139
nullity and the writ petition will have to be placed as per the Roster. If
the learned Single Judge is of the opinion that the writ petition is a Civil
Writ Petition and pertains to the Roster, and consequently the impugned
order is within the jurisdiction, then we permit the Appellants to restore
the Appeal for consideration of the Division Bench.
Sd/NITIN JAMDAR,
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/S. MANU,
JUDGE
krj/-
//TRUE COPY//
P.A. TO C.J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review