Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(c) No.681 of 2023
1. Tripurna Joy Tripura (38 years),
S/o- Rupajoy Tripura,
R/o- Binoy Kumar Roaja Para,
Chhamanu, Dhalai Tripura.
2. Dhananjoy Reang (43 years),
S/o- Bai Thang Rai Reang,
R/o- Manaiksha Para, Salthang Manu,
Santir Bazar, Bogafa, South Tripura.
……..Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary,
Tribal Welfare Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN- 799010.
2. The Member Secretary,
Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions Society
(TTWREIS), Gurkhabasti Agartala, Tripura West.
3. The Principal,
Ekalavya Model Residential School, Kumarghat, North Tripura, PIN799264.
4. The Principal,
Ekalavya Model Residential Schook, Birchandra Nagar, Santirbazar,
South Tripura, PIN- 799144.
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
24th January, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
YES.
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel and Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned
Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
It is the case of the petitioners that the petitioner No.1 was
engaged as a casual worker from 14.09.2005 to 18.03.2010 at
Residential School, Kumarghat, North Tripura under Tripura Tribal
Welfare
Residential
Educational
Institutions
Society
[in
short,
TTWREIS] under the respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4. Similarly, petitioner
No.2 was engaged as a casual worker in the Residential School,
Birchandra Nagar, Santirbazar, South Tripura under TTWREIS from
27.09.2005 to 18.03.2010. Thereafter, vide memorandum dated
15.02.2010 issued by respondent No.2 (Annexure-3 to the writ
petition), offer of appointment to the post of Group-D on fixed pay
basis were issued to certain persons and both the petitioners, along
with 10(ten) other persons were also offered appointments to the post
of Group-D as DRW (Daily Rated Worker) basis.
3.
Accordingly, as per the memorandum dated 09.03.2010
(Annexure-4 to the writ petition), petitioner No.1 joined as a DRW on
18.03.2010 and petitioner No.2 joined as DRW on 17.03.2010. Along
with them two other casual workers, namely, one Sri Upendra Tripura
and Sri Senchandra Tripura also joined as DRWs on 17.03.2010 and
18.03.2010 respectively.
4.
Meanwhile, according to Mr. Barman, learned senior counsel
keeping in view of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in a case in between Secretary, State of Karnataka and Others
versus Umadevi (3) and Others reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1, the
State Government issued two notifications regarding the regularisation
of such DRWs/casual workers/contingent workers upon completion of
their 10(ten) years of service, vide memorandum dated 01.09.2008 and
21.01.2009 and another notification dated 03.01.2014 (Annexure-8, 9
and 10 respectively) for the regularisation of such DRWs and casual
workers on completion of their 10(ten) years of service. Thereafter, vide
memorandum dated 31.07.2018 (Annexure-11 to the writ petition), the
State Government withdrew the said scheme of regularisation by way of
repealing the above-mentioned two notifications dated 01.09.2008 and
21.01.2009 along with other related notifications. Learned senior
counsel also contends that if the initial engagement as casual worker is
taken into account, then before such withdrawal of said scheme by the
State Government, both the petitioners and said Sri Upendra Tripura,
Sri Senchandra Tripura and some others had completed their 10(ten)
years of services as both casual worker and DRW, however, their
services were not regularized, notwithstanding the fact that they were
all engaged against vacant Group-D post on a DRW basis.
5.
Thereafter, said Sri Upendra Tripura and Sri Senchandra
Tripura filed WP(C) No.860 of 2021 before this Court praying for
regularisation of their services as Group-D employee and a coordinate
bench of this Court vide judgment dated 15.03.2022 (Annexure-15 to
the writ petition) passed the following order :
“23. Having appreciated the submissions of the learned
counsel appearing for the parties and having taken note of
the proposal sent by the Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential
Educational Institutions Society vide Note No.19 [as
reproduced], this court is of the view that the respondents
shall consider the regularisation of the petitioners in the post
of Cook cum Mashalchi/Watchman in the scale of pay of
Rs.4,840-13,000/- GP-1,400/- under Tripura State Pay
Matrix, PB-1 Cell-1, Level-1, Entry pay-Rs.16,000/-, not in
terms of the policy of the government which have been
repealed but for their completing of their ten years of service
as the Daily Rated Worker. From the Note No.19, it is evident
that the competent authority in the Society has taken the
responsibility of finance, as may be required for such
regularisation, having clearly declared as under :
“The requirement of fund for the said purpose will be borne
from the Grant to EMR School and Recurring Grant to Society
as per the details herein below :
For 01 (one) No. DRW staff
Present wages
Fixed Pay Basis
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
Monthly
Yearly
Monthly
Yearly
6,900/-
82800/-
12,000/-
1,44,000/-
18,080/-
2,16,960/-
@ Rs.230/- per day
(75% of
initial pay)
For 11(eleven) nos. DRW staff
Present wages
Fixed Pay Basis
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
Monthly
Yearly
Monthly
Yearly
75,900/-
9,10,800/-
1,32,000/-
15,84,000/-
2,16,960/-
26,03,520/-
Therefore, the posts for such regularisation be created by the
respondents.
24.
In this juncture, this court may refer to a decision of
the apex court in Nihal Singh and Others Versus State of
Punjab and Others reported in (2013) 14 SCC 65 where it
has been held :
“32. Coming to the other aspect of the matter pointed
out by the High Court - that in the absence of
sanctioned posts the State cannot be compelled to
absorb the persons like the appellants into the services
of the State, we can only say that posts are to be
created by the State depending upon the need to
employ people having regard to various functions the
State undertakes to discharge.
“Every sovereign Government has within its
own jurisdiction right and power to create
whatever public offices it may regard as
necessary to its proper functioning and its own
internal
administration.”42
American
Jurisprudence 902, para 31
33. It is no doubt that the assessment of the need to
employ a certain number of people for discharging a
particular responsibility of the State under the
Constitution is always with the executive Government
of the day subject to the overall control of the
Legislature. That does not mean that an examination by
a Constitutional Court regarding the accuracy of the
assessment of the need is barred.
35. Therefore, it is clear that the existence of the need
for creation of the posts is a relevant factor reference
to which the executive government is required to take
rational decision based on relevant consideration. In
our opinion, when the facts such as the ones obtaining
in the instant case demonstrate that there is need for
the creation of posts, the failure of the executive
government to apply its mind and take a decision to
create posts or stop extracting work from persons such
as the appellants herein for decades together itself
would be arbitrary action (inaction) on the part of the
State.”
[Emphasis added]
Therefore, the direction as regards creation and sanction
of posts has been made on the assessment made by the
competent authority for regularisation of the petitioners and
others.
25.
As regards the other two reliefs, it is directed that if
the petitioners are getting less wage than as directed in
Jagjit Singh(supra), than they shall be paid equivalent
wage, minimum to the scale of the Group-D employee of
Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions
Society.
26.
So far the recording of the education qualification is
concerned, the respondent No.2, after verification of the
qualification certificate if it is found that the same has been
issued from any institute, approved by the Government of
India or by the Government of Tripura that, may be reflected
in the service records of the petitioner No.1. The directions as
regards regularisation and payment of wage shall be carried
within a period of 3 (three) months from the date when a
copy of this order will be furnished by the petitioners.
In terms of the above, the writ petition stands allowed
and disposed of.
No order as to costs.”
6.
Challenging the said judgment the respondents preferred
WA No.153 of 2022, which was dismissed by the Division Bench of this
Court vide judgment dated 12.12.2022, inter-alia, with the following
observations :
“We have perused the entire records. It is an
admitted position that the petitioners were first
appointed in the year 2007 as Casual Worker, and in
the year 2010 they were appointed/engaged as DRW.
The schemes for regularization were made applicable
for both Casual/Contingent/Daily Rated Workers and
not only for Daily Rated Workers. The service rendered
by the petitioners cannot be separated from services as
Daily Rated Worker (DRW). The period the petitioners
served as Casual Workers, under the scheme, must be
accounted to the period of service of the petitioners as
DRWs. Be that as it may, the petitioners have
completed 10 years of service in the year 2017 and as
such, they come within the purview of the schemes for
regularization formulated by the Government of Tripura
before the schemes were repealed in the year 2018. In
other words, the petitioners completed 10 years of
service during the existence of those schemes for
regularization.
We do not find any ground to interfere with the
judgment and order passed by the learned Single
Judge. The judgment and order passed by the learned
Single Judge are affirmed and upheld. Accordingly, the
appeal stands dismissed. The respondents are directed
to complete the entire process of regularization of the
petitioners within a period of 3 (three) months from
the date the petitioners shall furnish a copy of this
order to the appellant-State respondents.”
7.
Against the said judgment of the Division Bench, the
respondents
then
preferred
a
Special
Leave
Petition(Civil)
Diary
No(S).20762 of 2023 and the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order dated
04.09.2023 (Annexure-17 to the writ petition) dismissed the same.
8.
Learned senior counsel also submits that one, Ananta
Reang, standing on the same footing also filed WP(C) No.737 of 2020
and vide judgment dated 10.05.2022, similarly one coordinate bench of
this Court allowed the said writ petition with the following observations :
“The facts are admitted, but the way the
petitioner has been treated is grossly arbitrary, as
someone cannot be discarded for being younger. It has
been admitted by the respondents that the petitioner
was senior in service to Santosh Kumar Tripura.
Despite that his name was not recommended.
According to this court, that was grossly arbitrary. As
Santosh Kumar Tripura has been appointed as the night
watchman on the fixed pay basis, against the regular
post, the petitioner ought to have been similarly
treated by engaging him against the fixed pay post of
Cook cum Masalchi, attendant and cleaner. The
vacancies are available, but the respondents have not
been considering his case.
It may also be noted that the petitioner was,
however, engaged as a Group–D personnel (DRW) but
initially the petitioner was accommodated against a
vacancy meant for the UR category candidates.
The respondent No. 2 has categorically stated in
para 10 of the reply that they are agreeable to appoint
the petitioner on a regular post on fixed pay basis and
for that purpose they have sent the records for
approval of the finance department. Such approval is
being awaited.
As this court finds that there is clear
discrimination against the petitioner while appointing
Santosh Kumar Tripura as his case was not at all
considered. The respondent No.2 shall appoint the
petitioner in the post of cook cum masalchi on similar
terms and conditions as laid down in the memorandum
dated 24.09.2011 (Annexure-6 to the writ petition).
Such appointment shall be made in favour of the
petitioner within three months from the date when the
petitioner shall submit a copy of the order to the
respondent No.2.
In terms of the above, this writ petition stands
allowed and disposed of. No order as to costs.”
9.
According to the learned senior counsel, all the above-said
three persons have already been regularised in their service after the
judicial pronouncements. Learned senior counsel also refers to the Note
No.23, initiated from the office of respondent No.2, wherein Department
noted that 11 Nos. of DRW staffs were appointed in the month of March,
2010 against the posts created with the concurrence of the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura to utilise their services at different
schools run by TTWREIS. He further submits that among the said 11
Nos. of DRWs, two are the present petitioners, along with said Sri
Ananta Reang, Sri Upendra Tripura and Sri Senchandra Tripura.
Therefore, it is quite clear that they were appointed against the vacant
sanctioned posts.
10.
from
Learned senior counsel also refers to Note No.19 initiated
the
office
of
respondent
No.2
and
as
submitted
by
the
respondents, wherein the matter was processed for the regularisation of
both the present petitioners with 9(nine) other persons including said Sri
Ananta Reang, Sri Upendra Tripura and Sri Senchandra Tripura. The
Department itself was of the view that the services of the petitioners
should be regularised. For useful reference entire Note No.19 is
reproduced herein below :
Note No.19
Sub : Proposal for regularization of 11 nos. of
DRW staff-reg.
11(eleven) nos. DRW staff of TTWREIS have
completed 10(ten) years of continuous service during
the month of March, 2020 and are presently working in
different schools under TTWREIS w.e.f. March, 2010.
2.
They were recruited under Tripura Tribal Welfare
Residential Educational Institutions Society (TTWREIS)
against the created posts with prior concurrence from
the Finance Deptt., Govt. of Triura vide U.O.
No.1438/Fin(G)/08 dated 16.12.2008 and Memo
No.F.1-496/TW/Estt.(Vol-1)/2007.3077-80
dated
14.01.2009 (copy of Page-60).
3.
In this connection, it is to mention here that,
after completion of 10(ten) years of continuous service
as on March, 2020 in the post of DRW, the following
staff are eligible for regularization of their services
Finance
Department
Memos
vide
No.F.10(2)Fin(G)/2008(Part) dated 21st January, 2009 (copy vide
at Page-63) & No.F.10(12)-FIN(G)/2007(Part-1) dated
7th November, 2012 (copy vide at Page-64).
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Name of the
DRW
staff/employee
Sri
Tripurna
Joy Tripura
Smt.
Kumari
Reang
Sri Dhananjoy
Reang
Sri
Ananta
Reang
Sri
Ajit
Debbarma
Sri
Abadhan
Tripura
Smt.
Danabi
Chakma
Sri Draw Kr.
Reang
Sri
Upendra
Tripura
Sri Senchandra
Tripura
Smt.
Sebika
Tripura
Presently Post
held
DRW w.e.f.
Presently working at
Cook-CumMasalchi
Cleaner
18/03/2010(F/N) BMRS, KGT
Watchman
17/03/2010(F/N) BMRS, BCN
Cook-CumMasalchi
Cook-CumMasalchi
Watchman
18/03/2010(F/N) RMMAS, KCP
Cleaner
18/03/2010(F/N) AS, Karbook
Watchman
18/03/2010(F/N) AS, Karbook
Cook-CumMasalchi
Watchman
17/03/2010(F/N) BNRS, BCN
Cleaner
17/03/2010(F/N) RS, Bhuratali
18/03/2010(F/N) RMMAS, KCP
18/03/2010(F/N) RMMAS, ABS
17/03/2010(F/N) RS, Bhuratali
18/03/2010(F/N) RS, Bhuratali
4.
In this regard, it is stated here that, a joint
representation (vide at Page-59) has been received
from these 11(eleven) nos. of DRW staff for
regularization of their services on sympathetically and
humanitarian ground.
5.
Presently, these 11(eleven) no. DRW staffs of
TTWREIS have completed their 10(ten) years of
continuous service are being paid at par with there
revised rate of wages @ Rs.230 per day w.e.f.1st
October, 2018 as amended by the State Finance Deptt.
Issued vide Memo No.7(2)-FIN(PC)/2018 dated 6th
November, 2018 (copy at flag-„A‟).
6.
The
requirement
of
Cook-cum-Mashalchi,
Watchman & Cleaner for Residential School(s) are
utmost essential for smooth functioning of the schools
as they play vital role to maintain proper hygiene and
nutrition in and around hostels and schools.
7.
In view of the above, the matter is no placed
before the authority for regularization of 11(eleven)
nos. DRW staff as they completed their 10(ten) years
of continuous service as on March, 2020, if approved.
8.
The initial Scale of Pay of Group-D staff for the
posts of Cook-cum-Masalchi, Watchman & Cleaner as
per Tripura State Pay Matrix 2018 is Rs.4,840/13000/- GP-1,400/-, PB-1, Cell-1, Level-1, Entry PayRs.16,000/-(copy at flag-„B‟) and the requirement of
fund for the said purpose will be borne from the Grant
to EMR School and Recurring Grant to Society as per
the details herein below :
(In Rupees)
For 01 (one) No. DRW staff
Present wages
Fixed Pay Basis
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
Monthly
Yearly
Monthly
Yearly
6,900/-
82800/-
12,000/-
1,44,000/-
18,080/-
2,16,960/-
@ Rs.230/- per day
(75%
of
initial pay)
For 11(eleven) nos. DRW staff
Present wages
Monthly
Yearly
Fixed Pay Basis
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
Monthly
Yearly
1,32,000/-
15,84,000/-
2,16,960/-
26,03,520/-
75,900/-
9,10,800/-
11.
According to the learned senior counsel, the withdrawal of
the policy decision for regularisation in the year 2018 will not affect the
right of the present petitioners for regularisation, as they were engaged
against the vacant Group-D posts and moreover, in similar situation said
Sri Upendra Tripura, Sri Senchandra Tripura and Sri Ananta Reang have
already been regularised. Finally, learned senior counsel urges for the
regularisation of present two petitioners on the ground that their cases
also stand on the same footing like above said persons.
12.
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. submits that the
concerned Department TTWREIS was initially of the view that the
services of present petitioners should be regularised and accordingly,
they had initiated the proposal for the same and sought opinion of the
Finance
Department,
Government
of
Tripura
but
the
Finance
Department gave the opinion that the Department was to follow the
extant Rules of the State Government on the proposed matter vide their
Note No.24 dated 09.07.2021 and as during that period already the
notification of 2018, dated 31.07.2018 was the latest instruction from
the Government, therefore, following the same the claims of the
petitioners were rejected. Learned Addl. G.A. on that ground submits
that as the scheme of regularisation is not in force, the writ petition
deserves dismissal.
13.
This Court has given due consideration to both the rival
contentions. It is admitted position that after the judgment passed by
this Court in WP(C) No.860 of 2021, directing the regularisation of
services of Sri Upendra Tripura and Sri Senchandra Tripura, the matter
was challenged before the Division Bench of this Court and then before
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and the matter was finally set at
rest and became binding upon the respondents. In compliance with said
direction, both said Sri Upendra Tripura and Sri Senchandra Tripura
were also regularised in their services. Similarly, service of another writ
petitioner, namely, Sri Ananta Reang was also regularised following the
judgment passed by this Court in WP(C) No.737 of 2020, as admitted by
both parties.
14.
In WA No.153 of 2022, the Division Bench of this Court, as
indicated above, also observed that the services rendered by the
petitioners of said case as casual workers could not be separated from
their services as DRWs. Therefore, the period of petitioners service as
casual workers must be counted as part of their service for the purpose
of regularisation. In the present case, if the service rendered by both
petitioners as casual workers is counted, they completed their 10(ten)
years of service before said scheme of regularisation was withdrawn by
the State Government in the year 2018.
15.
From the appointment letter dated 16.03.2010 (Annexure-5
to the writ petition), it appears that petitioner No.1 was appointed to the
post of Group-D against the post of Cook-Cum-Masalchi on DRW basis,
and similarly, petitioner No.2 was issued the appointment letter dated
16.03.2010 (Annexure-6 to the writ petition), appointing him to the post
of Group-D against the post of Watchman on DRW basis. From the
above-mentioned Note No.19 of the office of respondent No.2, as
submitted by the respondents and also from the memorandum dated
15.02.2010 of respondent No.2 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition), it
appears that said Sri Upendra Tripura, Sri Senchandra Tripura, Sri
Ananta Reang and some others were appointed as Group-D on a DRW
basis, along with present petitioners vide the said memorandum. When
other three persons have already been regularised in their services after
such judicial pronouncements and the matter being finally decided by
the Hon’ble Apex Court, there is no reason to deny such benefit to the
present petitioners. The petitioners should not be deprived from such
benefit of regularisation in service.
16.
In view
of above, the
writ
petition
is allowed. The
respondents are directed to consider the regularisation of the petitioners
to the posts of Cook-Cum-Masalchi/Watchman on completing their
10(ten) years of service as DRWs. However, before such regularisation,
the respondents will be at their liberty to verify other conditions of the
service as per the rules and procedure. Their pay will be fixed notionally
from the date of regularisation and actual financial benefits shall be paid
to them w.e.f. 3(three) years prior to the filing of the writ petition as
arrear. The entire process should be completed within 3(three) months
from the date the petitioner furnishes copy of the judgment to the
respondents.
With the above said observation(s), the writ petition is
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
SATABDI Digitally
SATABDI DUTTA
2025.01.28
DUTTA Date:
17:35:06 +05'30'
Dinashree
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review