Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
CRA 681 OF 2007
TRIPURESH KUMAR DEY
VS
TUSHAR KANTI JANA & Anr.
For the Appellant
:
Mr. Sujit Mitra, Adv.
For the State
:
Mr. Ratul Ghosh, Adv.
For the Opposite
Party no. 2
: Mr. Amitabha Karmakar, Adv.
Last heard on
: 10.12.2025
Judgement on
: 13.02.2026
Uploaded on
: 13.02.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS:1. This is an application for special leave to file under /section 378 Sub-Section
(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,1973 against the judgement and order of
acquittal dated May, 24, 2007 passed by the Learned Metropolitan Magistrate,
4th Court , Calcutta in case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument
Act.
Brief Fact
2. The present Opposite Party no. 2 took an emergency accommodation loan of
Rs. 1,90,000 for his own business purpose in the following manner:a) On 28.04.2001
Rs. 1,00,000.00
b) On 03.05.2001
Rs.
30,000.00
c) On 14.05.2001
Rs.
60,000.00
_____________________
Rs. 1, 90, 000.00
The Opposite Party no. 2 issued receipts for such loan of Rs. 1, 90,000/- by
his own hand writing. He took the said emergency loan for the purpose of
prints and other miscellaneous expenses in releasing his film “Sesh Ashray”
and the Opposite Party no. 2 also issued a Cheque dated June 8, 2007 being
numbered 375355 in favour of the petitioner against the loan amount taken by
him.
3. In re-payment of the said loan the Opposite Party no. 2 issued a cheque to the
petitioner being cheque no. 375355 dated 08.06.2001 drawn on Punjab
National Bank , New Market ,Branch. The petitioner deposited the said cheque
in his bank on June 22, 2001 but the same was returned to the petitioner with
the endorsement (insufficient fund). The petitioner intimated the Opposite
Party no. 2 about the said fact of dishonour of the cheque given by him to the
petitioner in discharge of his obligation to repay the loan and such intimation
was given by issuing a
demand notice dated 02.07.2001. By issuing such
demand notice the petitioner demanded the payment of the cheque amount
within 15 days from the date of receipt of the said legal notice which was duly
received by the Opposite Party no, 2 on July 12, 2001.
4. It is the case of the petitioner that Opposite Party no. 2 despite receipt of such
legal notice did not comply the same and did not pay to the petitioner the
money against the dishonour cheque and made himself liable to be punished
under Section 138 of the N. I. Act. Having no other alternative a complaint was
lodged by the petitioner where Opposite Party no. 2 appeared in the proceeding
and pleaded not guilty and the charge was framed and matter was tried by the
Learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 4th Court, Calcutta.
5. Before the Learned Court the Opposite Party no. 2 was examined and crossexamined and as his defence he stated that it was given to the petitioner as
security for the commission payable to the appellant/petitioner for exhibition
proceeding of the said film “Sesh Ashray”, as per agreement between the
parties where the petitioner was investor and no transaction of loan took place
between them. Therefore there had been no dischargeable liability of the
accused and hence the Opposite Party no. 2 has not committed punishable
offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act and he is not liable
to be convicted.
6. It is the further case of the petitioner that no witness was examined on behalf
of the Opposite Party no. 2 excepting himself. The petitioner adduced evidence
and the documents were relied upon were marked with the exhibit but the
Learned Court passed the judgement and order of acquittal which is bad in
law contrary to evidence on record and perverse and not sustainable in the eye
of law. Accordingly this appeal has been filed with the special leave of the
Court.
Submission
7. The Learned Advocate representing the petitioner submits that an amount of
Rs. 1,90,000/-was given as a loan in three different cheques. The demand
notice was within statutory period of time the presumption under Section 139
of N.I, Act not complied. The judgement and order of acquittal suffers from
surmise, conjecture and swiping observation which is prejudicial
to the
petitioner. It is an admitted fact that Opposite Party no. 2 took loan of Rs.
1,90,000/- for his own business purpose and a valid receipt was given by him.
There was no agreement executed in between the parties but the document
was exhibited. Civil disputes are pending between the parties. The learned
Advocate put reliance upon a Decision of Madras High Court reported in J.
Iqbal versus Azhagarsamy1 in order to establish that if a cheque issued, if
dishonoured also attract Section 138 N.I. Act. Another judgement was relied
upon reported in laws (Kar) 2006-3042 in this regard. Accordingly prayed for
setting aside the judgement and order of Acquittal.
8. The Learned Advocate appearing on behalf of Opposite Party on the other hand
would submit that no agreement was executed between them. The order of
acquittal has been passed in connection with the case initiated by the
complainant has been affirmed by the Co-Ordinate Bench. That apart the defacto complainant failed to prove whether any legally enforceable debt was
there or not since no evidence could be adduced to establish that any amount
was actually paid and hence this appeal is not maintainable in the eye of law.
2005 (3) DCR 408
Analysis
9. Heard the submission. The genesis of the dispute rest upon issuance of
cheque in question which is exhibited as 2. Both the learned court of
Magistrate and the Learned Appellate court did not accept the case of the
complainant however accepted that complainant discharged his initial burden
of providing his case that the cheque was issued in discharge of his liability.
The complaint was lodged by Opposite Party no. 2 where specific allegation
was levelled against the present petitioner of taking loan of lumpsum amount
from the complainant with the assurance to re pay the said loan within a
certain time and one cheque of Rs. 1, 90,000/- was issued to liquidate the
part of his liability bearing cheque no. 375355 dated June 8, 2001 drawn with
Punjab National Bank , New Market Branch . The said cheque was
dishonoured on deposit by the petitioner at Allahabad Bank, Kasba Branch on
June 22, 2001 for encashment within the validity period for ‘insufficient fund’.
Demand for re-payment of such amount through the Advocate’s letter dated
July 2, 2001 was given with a request to the accused/Opposite Party no. 2 to
make payment of the said amount within 15 days from the date of receipt of
the said letter. Despite receiving the letter on July 12, 2001 the accused
deliberately failed to pay the said amount. It is therefore assailed that the
accused person had no intention to re pay the said amount from the very
inception and dishonestly and deliberately failed to keep sufficient amount in
his bank account. In order to substantiate this the complainant on S.A. was
examined by the Learned Magistrate.
From his evidence it could be gathered that against the loan amount of Rs. 1,
90,000/- which was admittedly taken on different dates to the Opposite Party,
the petitioner gave only single receipt. The petitioner was known to the
accused since 2000 as the petitioner had his office adjoining the office of the
Opposite Party 2 .The evidence would show that from the bank statement or
from Income Tax statement the O.P no. 2 could not show that he gave that
money as loan to the Opposite Party no 2.
10. It is settled law that in cheque bounce case the complainant enjoy a
statutory presumption in their favour and at the outset not obligated to prove
the financial capacity. The burden of rebuttal lies on the accused who need to
substantiated by adducing evidence to challenge the presumption.
So the accused must rebut the presumption that the cheque was issued for a
real debt. In this case the cheque was signed by the petitioner.
In the case of
Rajaram s/o Srira mulu Naidu (since deceased) through
LRS Maruth Achaleam (since deceased) through LRS.2 it is held that the
presentation under Section 118 & 139 N.I Act can be rebutted by the accused
examines the Income Tax Office and Bank Officials of the complainant. In this
case no such evidence is adduced.
The petitioner has constantly taken stand that the amount given by him was
received by the O.P. as personal loan and it was not related to the agreement
entered into between him and Sukumar Nandy or Rankan Kundu. The
complainant himself produced the agreement which was marked with “A” on
admission. The accused tried to pay by money order in commission with the
said agreement towards commission which was refused. The Ext. 1 that is the
(2023) 16 SCC 125
document whereby the disputed loan amounts were received was duly signed
by the Opposite Party/accused. His defence that it was obtained by force but
no complaint was lodged by him.
So whether the complainant informed Sukumar Nandy or Ranjan Kundu
becomes irrelevant in view of the fact that the amount received as loan by the
accused is no way connected to that the P.W. 2 and 3 the bank official
supports the version of the complaint that the cheque was placed and
dishonoured due to insufficient amount.
Admittedly no agreement to that effect of loan was executed between the
parties but in course of evidence he admitted execution of an agreement
between him and one Sukumar Nandy with the accused person on 1st of
January, 2001.
11. Mr. Alok Mukherjee, an Officer of PNB P.W. 2 deposed before the Court who
produced statement of account of the accused /Opposite Party. He showed the
credit balance in the account of T.K. Jana which of Rs. 8480.00 on June 8,
2001 and on June 22, 2001 the credit balance was of Rs. 25,480.55/-. He also
said that there was insufficient fund in the account of Tushar Kanti Jana on
23.06.2001 to honour the cheque no. 375355 dated 8.06.2001 .They sent the
cheque with return memo to the collecting bank.
12. The next witness Sanjib Kumar Talukder , Assistant Manager of Allahabad
Bank, Kasba Branch, deposed that the last entry made on the statement on
account of S.B. account no. 8146 for the period from 24.5.2001 to 30.6.2001
was on 25.6.2001. He also said that from the pay in slip it appears that the
cheque was deposited in party account on 23.6.2001. They sent the cheque to
drawer’s bank for clearance. The cheque was dishonoured on the ground of
insufficient fund. The accused/complainant was examined under 251 Cr.P.C
and the incriminating materials were placed before him and he stated that he
had issued the cheque for commission and not to repay the loan. He again said
that he did not issue the cheque for loan re-payment.
13. The Learned Trial Court considered that the petitioner issued the
acknowledgement receipt on April 28,2001 of Rs. 100,000/- , Rs. 30,000/- on
3.5.01 and Rs. 60,000 on 14.5.2001.Therefore the acknowledgement receipt
dated 28.04.2001 was issued in advance in respect of the amount paid on
three different dates. It also prima facie established that the cheque in
question dated 08.06.2001 was given to the complainant on the same date
that is 28.4.2001 as post-dated cheque and when the cheque was issued the
entire amount was not received since the amount of 30,000/- and Rs.
60,000/-was paid on 3rd May, 2001 and 14 the May, 2001 respectively which
is after the said cheque was issued. Therefore the Learned Court was of the
view that the cheque which was issued by the petitioner dated 28.04.2001 of
Rs. 1,90,000/-in discharge of his liability in full regarding the amount covered
by that cheque. This court is unable to accept such contention since the
receipt showing acceptance of the amount as personal loan containing the
signature of the accused is not denied. Even if the cheque is issued toward
security it was placed as per the terms mentioned in the exhibit 1.
14. It was held by the Karnataka High Court in the case as relied upon that any
cheque whether issued towards re-payment of date or liability as a security if
dishonoured, the drawer of cheque incurs liability to prosecution under
Section 138 of N.I. Act. Unlike other securities the cheque even it is issued as
repayment it is very much negotiable instrument and with implied instruction
for deferred on future if the date is unpaid as per agreement terms.
15. In the decision of Ashok Singh V. State of Uttar Pradesh and another
reported in3 the legal position has been re-affirmed that once the drawer
admits to send the cheque the presumption under Section 139 of the
Negotiable Instrumental Act cannot be rebutted merely by questioning the
complainants dated giving capacity. In the decision of J. Iqbal (Supra).It was
decided by Bench of Madras High Court taking note of the above decision that
it is settled law that the onus is not on the complainant at the threshold to
have been is capacity/financial wherewithal to make the payment in discharge
of which the cheque is alleged to have been issued in his favour.
16. The presumption under section 139 will only arise when the complainant
could established that against a legally enforceable debt the cheque was
issued. In this case the factum of issuing the cheque in discharge to the lawful
debt as claimed by the petitioner is proved as per exhibit 1 which has said to
have been obtained by force. He never informed the police station about such
incident. His account had a very paltry amount and being a mechanical
Engineer he was well aware about the legal consequence of issuing a receipt
showing acceptance of an amount of Rs. 1,90,000/- despite that he did not in
force the price. .
17. In the case of Anss Rajashekar v. Augustus Jeba Ananth18, a two-Judge
Bench of this Court reiterated the decision of the three-Judge Bench of this Court
in Rangappa v. Sri Mohan19 on the presumption under Section 139 of the NI Act.
The Court held : Section 139 of the Act mandates that it shall be presumed,
2025 Live Law ( SC) 383
unless the contrary is proved, that the holder of a cheque received it, in
discharge, in whole or in part, of a debt, or liability. The expression “unless the
contrary is proved” indicates that the presumption under Section 139 of the Act
is rebuttable. Terming this as an example of a “reverse onus clause” the threeJudge Bench of this Court in Rangappa (supra) held the standard of proof for
rebuttal of the presumption under Section 139 of the Act is guided by a
preponderance of probabilities.
18.
It is a settled position that when an accused has to rebut the presumption
under Section 139, the standard of proof for doing so is that of “preponderance
of probabilities”. Therefore, if the accused is able to raise a probable defence
which creates doubts about the existence of a legally enforceable debt or
liability, the prosecution can fail. In this case the factum of issuance of cheque
in discharge to legal debt is otherwise proved in terms of exhibit 1.
19. In a decision reported in State of Madras vs. A. Vaidyanathalyer4 it was
held that “ it introduces an exception to the general rule as to the burden of proof
in criminal cases and shifts the onus on to the accused”
Conclusion
20.
The accused /Opposite Party has disputed taking any loan but according
to him that was in connection with the agreement executed between the
parties over the commission in connection with the film “Sesh Ashray”.This
fact has not been established. The accused did not rebut the same by
adducing any evidence. He did not deny his signature. The accused in his
examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C said to adduce evidence but did not do
the same. Merely by denial to issue cheque without challenging the signature
AIR 1958 SC 61
the presumption under Section 139 N.I. Act cannot be invoked. He did not give
any reply to the demand notice neither any complaint lodged thereafter.
Therefore it cannot be said that the initial onus of proving that the cheque is
not in discharge of any debt or liability is on the accused/drawer of the cheque
is not proved by the accused.’
21. Hence the order of acquittal is liable to be set aside. The accused is
convicted for the offence punishable under Section 138 of N.I. Act. 1881.
22. Tripuresh kumar Dey the accused is directed to pay an amount of Rs. 3 lacs
in default to suffer simple imprisonment for 1 month and to pay compensation
of Rs. 1 Lakh to be paid within 1 month in default it would incur an interest at
the rate of 7% till it is paid. The fine amount as paid by the accused is directed
to be disbursed by way of compensation.
23. From the record nothing reflects that any amount was deposited at the time
of admission of appeal. The matter was pending since 2007.
24. The bail bond if any stands cancelled.
25. Let a copy of the order be forwarded to the concerned Court for necessary
compliance.
26. Urgent certified copy if applied by any of the parties to be supplied subject
to observance of all formalities.
(CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review