Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ananya Bandyopadhyay
C.R.A. 698 of 2014
Bhotto Sk. @ Bhottu Sk. @ Guddu
-vsThe State of West Bengal
With
CRA 699 of 2014
Md. Bablu @ Bablu Khan
-vsThe State of West Bengal
For the Appellant
(In CRA 698 of 2014)
: Mr. Arup Kumar Bhowmick
For the Appellant
(In CRA 699 of 2014)
: Mr. Bibaswan Bhattacharya
For the State
(In CRA 699 of 2014)
: Mr. Avishek Sinha
For the State
(In CRA 698 of 2014)
: Mr. Bidyut Kumar Roy
Judgment on
: 05.05.2026
Ananya Bandyopadhyay, J.:1. These two instant appeals are preferred against the judgment and order of
conviction dated 19.09.2014 & 20.09.2014 passed by the Learned Additional
District & Sessions Judge, 2nd Court, Barrackpore, North 24 Parganas in
Sessions Trial No.03(03)2014 arising out of Sessions Case No.522/2013 &
G.R. Case No.6061 of 2014 convicting the appellants under Sections 489B,
489C, 120B of the Indian Penal Code and sentencing them to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for 4 years and also to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/- in default to
suffer 1 month rigorous imprisonment more for the offence under Section
489B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and to suffer rigorous imprisonment for
4 years and also to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/- in default to suffer 1 month
rigorous imprisonment more for the offence under Section 489C of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 and both the sentences were directed to run
concurrently.
2. The prosecution case was instituted on the basis of a written complaint, as
lodged by Inspector Atanu Ghosal of Special Operations Group, C.I.D., West
Bengal (PW-1), before the Inspector-in-Charge of the Airport P.S., inter alia
stated that on the basis of a secret source information on 11.09.2013, the
raiding party was able to apprehend the appellants in front of the flyover
from Sarat Colony More on Jessore Road towards Dakshineswar, connecting
Belghoria Expressway with Fake Indian Currency Notes (FICN). Then, the
matter was recorded in the General Diary and communicated to Superior
Officer. On search, Fake Indian Currency Notes (FICN) was found from both
the appellants and all the articles were seized under seizure list. Thereafter,
the Fake Indian Currency Notes (FICN) were sealed and labeled. The
appellants were arrested maintaining all formalities of law and taken to
police station. The matter was recorded in the General Diary and
communicated to Superior Officer.
3. On the basis of a written complaint lodged by the complainant, Airport Police
Station
Case
No.266
of
dated
11.09.2013
under
Sections
489B/489C/120B of the Indian Penal Code was initiated for investigation.
4. Charges
were
framed
against
the
appellants
under
Sections
489B/489C/120B of the Indian Penal Code to which they pleaded not guilty
and claimed to be tried.
5. In order to prove its case, the prosecution examined as many as 6 witnesses
and examined certain documents.
6. The Learned Advocate representing the appellant/Bhotto Sk. @ Bhottu Sk. @
Guddu submitted as follows:i. “The evidence of the prosecution witnesses i.e. PW-1 revealed that no nil
seizure list was prepared by the police personnel’s which shows that the
appellants were not given any chance to search the complainant and his
associates during the time of investigation. As a result the impugned
judgment passed by the Learned Judge was palpably wrong in the eye of
law and liable to be set aside for interest of justice.
ii. It had escaped the notice of the Learned Judge that the seizure list
prepared by the complainant and his associates did not contain any seal
of the rank of gazette officer nor any seal of C.I.D., which shows that the
said seizure list was manufactured to tag the appellant in the said offence
and did not have any evidentiary value in the eye of law.
iii. The Learned Judge did not take into consideration in proper perspective
the evidence of PW-1 to specifically deposed that he did not knows that
there was many shop rooms at the place of occurrence but curiously
enough the investigation officer (PW-6) as well as PW-3, one of the raiding
officers specifically deposed during trial that there were many shop rooms
nearer to the place of occurrence which reflects that the place of occurrence
was doubtful as a result.
iv. The Learned Trial Court lost sight of the fact that the evidence of PW-5,
who claimed himself as expert of determine counterfeit currency notes but
curiously enough he did not possess any official certificate which reflects
that there was a question mark in his ability to determine the counterfeit
current notes.
v. The investigation conducted by the investigating agency was totally in
perfunctory manner as observed by the trial court but surprisingly the trial
proceeded and the conviction imposed on the basis of such trial which
denotes that entire episode was nothing but grave abuse of the process of
law and the conviction should be set aside to meet ends of justice.
vi. The Learned Trial Court while dealing with the point of sentence should
have a judicial approach as regards invoking the provision of either Section
360 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or Probation of Offenders Act in
considering the nature of the case and the antecedents of the appellant.
Although, it was a discretionary power but if the Learned Judge proposes
not to deal under the aforesaid Sections, he had to specify special reasons
under Section 361 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. So the Learned acted
not in accordance with law which vitiated in his judgment as Section 361
of the Code of Criminal Procedure was mandatory in nature.
vii. Considering and judging the entire episode as alleged and also the
discrepancies in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, the entire story
as alleged by the prosecution was based on falsehood and should not be
relied upon.
viii. In view of the aforesaid state of affairs and the evidence as also materials
on records, the conviction of the appellant under the said Section was not
at all sustainable in law and liable to be set aside for ends of justice as the
prosecution had miserably failed to prove the ingredients of the offence as
alleged beyond all reasonable doubt coupled with the fact that excepting
interested witnesses, no independent witnesses was examined in that
case.”
7. The Learned Advocate representing the appellant/Md. Bablu @ Bablu Khan
further submitted as follows:i. “The proceedings in the instant case were instituted on the basis of a
Written Complaint, as lodged by Inspector Atanu Ghosal of Special
Operations Group, CID, West Bengal i.e., PW-1, before the Inspector-inCharge of the Airport Police Station, inter alia notifying therein as to how
on the basis of a secret source information on September 11, 2013, the
Raiding Party herein was able to apprehend the present appellant and
another Co-Accused Bhottu Sk. Guddu in front of the flyover from Sarat
Colony More on Jessore Road towards Dakshineswar, connecting
Belghoria Expressway, and how allegedly from each of them, 100 pieces
of FICN, each having denomination of ₹ 500/-was recovered (presumably
amounting to 50,000/- from each). Admittedly, it is the Prosecution Story
herein that upon receipt of the said source information, when the Raiding
Party had left for the recovery operation, the said matter was diarized vide
S.O.G., C.I.D., W.B., CC. No.343/13 dated September 11, 2013, yet the
corresponding seizure list, marked as Exhibit-1, pertaining to the alleged
recovery of the F.I.C.N., in connection with the instant proceedings,
revealed the same to have been prepared in connection with/reference to
an altogether different proceedings, the same being S.O.G., C.I.D., W.B.,
CC. No. 340/13 dated September 11, 2013. That raises serious questions
and dubiety regarding the very alleged recovery of the F.I.C.N., in the
instant case, inasmuch as there is every possibility of the same being
recovered in connection with some other prior case, as the corresponding
reference number would itself suggest, connected in no way with the
instant proceedings. What was even more surprising and startling was
that, contrary to the settled practice and procedure, the said contended
seizure list in question neither bore any stamp and/or seal of any of the
Departments of the Investigating Agency/Raiding Agency, in spite of
consisting of two pages, only contained the apparent signatures of the
accused persons, including the present appellant, only on the second page,
did not contain the official stamp or seal of any of the seizure witnesses
(all of whom were official police witnesses), and even contained
exaggerated and pretentious depictions of the supposed place and manner
of recovery of the same from the accused persons, which was not even
stated/narrated in the First Information Report (F.I.R.) in the instant case,
nor stated by any of the prosecution.
ii. Witnesses in course of their respective depositions before the Learned Trial
Court. It raises serious doubts and uncertainty regarding the authenticity
and genuineness of the said document as well as the corresponding
purported recovery of F.I.C.N. from the accused persons, since there
appears
high
probability
of
the
same
being
created/prepared/manufactured at a much subsequent point of time, with
certain fictitious contents, solely to implicate the Accused Persons.
iii. A bare perusal of the First Information Report (F.I.R.) in the instant case
would reveal that it was contended by the PW-1 (the complainant) that the
aforementioned seizure herein was effected under a valid seizure list, in
the presence of witnesses as well as the members of the raiding party, yet
the aforesaid seizure list would unmask the same to have been effected
only in the presence of S.I. Anupam Chakraborty (P.W.-3) and A.S.I. Ritwik
Banerjee (not examined during the course of trial in the instant case and
not even mentioned either in the written complaint or in the deposition of
the PW-1 to be at all present as a member of the said raiding party), both
officials of the C.I.D., West Bengal.
That further casts a dense cloud of suspicion, disbelief and doubt
over
the entire prosecution
case and
the entire
process
of
the
corresponding alleged recovery of F.I.C.N. from the purported possession of
the accused persons.
iv. It was also quite shocking to note that although the alleged recovery of the
F.I.C.N. from the apparent possession of the accused persons was effected
for over a considerable period of time, from an admittedly densely
populated/busy and hustling area that too at a reasonable time of the
day, yet not a single local/independent witness was ever cited nor the
signature of a single respectable person of the locality was ever obtained
to further corroborate and validate the Prosecution Case herein, apparently
because they had denied to assist and had left the place, but even their
names and addresses were never noted by the PW-1, nor were any one of
them ever served with any valid notice, requesting them to assist in the
concerned operation.
It further questions the alleged process of recovery of the F.I.C.N.
from the purported possession of the accused persons and renders it
highly improbable and unconvincing.
v. It was quite astonishing to note that it was not the prosecution case that
the alleged F.I.C.N. recovered from the purported possession of the
accused persons were of an extremely low quality and as such, quite
surprisingly, without admittedly having any prior expertise/specialty in
the field, all of them were extremely presumptuous while confidently and
assuredly detecting the same to be F.I.C.N. at a moment's glance.
That only goes on to further distrust and repudiate the overall case
of the prosecution, especially with regard to the alleged recovery of the
F.I.C.N. from the supposed possession of the accused persons.
vi. PW-1 had categorically stated in his written complaint as well as in course
of his testimony before the Learned Trial Court that prior to the searching
of the accused persons for the F.I.C.N., the raiding party had apparently
offered themselves to be searched, but the same was denied by them, but
no documents whatsoever were ever produced to validate such claims of
offering themselves to be searched before searching the accused persons;
additionally, the PW-5, PW-2 & PW-3, who were supposedly also members
of the self-same raiding party, never in course of their respective
depositions before the Learned Trial Court, ever supported such view of
offering themselves to be searched by the accused persons.
Gross violation of the settled procedure of law, the accused persons,
being laymen, were not even informed of their basic rights to search the
members of the raiding party and there remains ever possibility of false
implication on the basis of possible articles planted on them, especially
since there were no independent witnesses supporting the said alleged
recovery of the F.I.C.N. from the apparent possession of the accused
persons.
vii. A copy of the Log Book Register of the vehicle, apparently used by the
members of the raiding party in connection with the instant case, was
never placed before the Learned Trial Court.
Leaves behind more shortcomings and/or defects in the entire
prosecution case and raises serious doubts over the motivated manner in
which the investigation was obviously conducted by the investigating
agency.
viii. Although the PW-2 (apparently a member of the raiding party) had spoken
about the presence of A.S.I. Ritwik Banerjee in the concerned raiding party
on the fateful date, yet he did not at all speak about the presence of the
PW-1 and gives an absolutely vague description about the apparent
recovery of the F.I.C.N. from the alleged possession of the accused persons
both in terms of quantity and manner.
That further raises serious questions over the veracity of the entire
prosecution case, as the testimonies of those official police witnesses
appear to have been subsequently arbitrarily incorporated, solely to
superficially fill up the obvious lacunae in the Prosecution Story.
ix. PW-5, being the Manager (Production), Bharatiya Reserve Bank Note
Mudran Private Limited, had apparently received the alleged F.I.C.N. on
September 16, 2013 from A.S.I. Ritwik Banerjee (not examined) and along
with other members of his team (none of whom were even named in the
corresponding expert’s report or even examined on behalf of the
prosecution in course of the instant trial, he had examined the same in
their Forgery Note Detective Cell at Salboni and had apparently found
them to be fake in respect of its design, signature of the Governor and
serial numbers. He had gone on to admit that he did not possess any
official certificate designating him to be an expert to determine the
authenticity of counterfeit currency notes and for reasons, best known only
to him, he had refused to disclose the methodology and the process of
identifying the contented F.I.C.N., at their laboratory.
Substantially reduces the evidentiary value and reliability of the
said arbitrary Report, predominantly owing to
the utter lack
of
transparency and clarity in the process behind its preparation. It was his
categorical version that the corresponding report, prepared by him in his
official
capacity,
was
submitted
under
Reference
No.839/(S)
21.02.02/2013-2014 dated November 11, 2013 and was marked as
Exhibit-4, nonetheless, a physical perusal of the said report would reveal
that the Reference number was appearing as /(S) 21.02.02/2013-2014
(blank) and in the subsequent page, the Reference No. for the information
of the Investigating Agency was also found to be dissimilar, i.e., 839A/(S)
21.02.02/2013-2014.
In the absence of any conclusive proof, a reasonable question quite
obviously remains whether the report exhibited before the Learned Trial
Court was at all in connection with the instant case or not.
x. PW-6 being the Investigating Officer of the instant case, in course of his
deposition before the Learned Trial Court, had stated that after taking up
investigation on September 11, 2013, he had taken charge of the accused
persons along with the seized alamats and had sent the same for expert’s
opinion, but without re-seizing the same.
Not only he absolutely silent about the actual date when the said
seized alamats were actually sent for expert’s opinion, additionally the
prosecution was totally mum with regard to the whereabouts of the said
seized alamats in the instant case for about 5 (five) whole days and no
malkhana register or other allied documents were ever placed before the
Learned Trial Court to conclusively establish the continuous and
uninterrupted custody of the F.I.C.N., apparently recovered from the
possession of the accused persons, which only gone on to render the
prosecution case highly dubious, evasive and questionable, Additionally,
as per the version of the PW-5, it was A.S.I. Ritwik Banerjee, who had
personally handed over the concerned F.I.C.N. from the custody of the
Investigating Agency for chemical examination and verification thereof, but
for reasons only best known to the prosecution, even in the face of flagrant
discrepancies, irregularities and inconsistencies, he was never examined
in course of the instant trial proceedings to further corroborate the
prosecution case, which only gone on to leave behind even greater
loopholes, deformities and blemishes in the entire prosecution story.
xi. The Examination of the accused persons under the provisions of Section
313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 also demonstrates a glaring
example of utter and outright violation of the said statutory and procedural
provisions, inasmuch as, the testimonies of all the prosecution witnesses,
including the PW-6 (being the Investigating Officer of the instant case),
were never placed before the accused persons at all and a few restricted
portions of the depositions of the PW-1, PW-3 & PW-5 only were placed
before them, thereby flagrantly denying and depriving them of a legitimate
opportunity of understanding and properly explaining, answering and/or
defending the various circumstances attempted to be established against
them by the prosecution.
Various vital incriminating circumstances, inter alia including
offering the accused persons to search the members of the raiding party
prior to the search operation, non-availability of independent seizure
witnesses, the sending of the allegedly recovered F.I.C.N., for its chemical
examination and the receipt of the corresponding expert’s report by the
Investigating Officer, the specific contents of the corresponding chemical
expert’s report and the methodology etc., applied therein, etc., were never
placed before the accused persons and hence, they never got the
opportunity to aptly explain and/or rebut such contentions of the
Prosecution.
Furthermore, in course of such examination, the accused persons
had distinctively claimed innocence and had outright asserted and averred
that the various documents relied upon by the prosecution, were
unequivocally fabricated, misguided and subsequently manufactured ones
and were consciously prepared in collusion, to immorally and unjustly
implicate them in the alleged offences.
xii. It was a settled principle of law that if a point in evidence was important
and vital against an accused and the conviction was intended to be based
upon the same, it was just and proper that the accused should always be
questioned about the matter and be given an opportunity of explaining it
and where no specific question had been put to the accused on an
inculpatory material in the prosecution evidence, it would unconditionally
vitiate the entire trial proceedings and in case the court fails to put the
needed question, it would result in a handicap, disadvantage and
prejudice to the accused and he can always legitimately claim that no
evidence, without offering him an opportunity to explain, can be used
against him.
In that regard, reliance was humbly placed upon the findings of the
Hon’ble Apex Court of India in the matter of Asraf Ali vs. The State of
Assam, reported in (2008) 16 SCC 328, most specifically to paragraph
numbers 21, 22, 23 and 24 thereof.
xiii. The
Charges
in
the
instant
case
were
framed
under
Sections
4898/489C/120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and the conviction was
ultimately handed to the Accused Persons herein under Sections
489B/489C of the Indian Penal Code 1860 for the alleged offence of
carrying and/or having in possession F.I.C.N. for its selling and/or using
as genuine, despite having knowledge of the same to be counterfeit;
however, even if for the sake of arguments only, we are to accept the
prosecution story to be the gospel truth, then also it was quite apparent
that the prosecution in the instant case has utterly failed to indicate, bring
on record and/or establish the fact that the accused persons, had in their
possession and/or carried the said F.I.C.N., for the purpose of its selling or
for using the same as genuine, being fully aware and knowing the fact
that the same were not genuine, but counterfeit.
Evidently, such question was also never put to the accused persons,
inter alia with regard to their intention, purpose or knowledge of
carrying/possessing such purported F.I.C.N., in course of their respective
examinations under the provisions of Section 313 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973. As such, in the absence of any conclusive or proved mens
rea, intention or active knowledge on the part of the accused persons
whatsoever, they ought not to have been convicted for the commission of
the alleged offences.
xiv. It was rather concerned to note that while evidently delivering the
impugned order and judgment of conviction and sentence in the instant
case, for reasons best to known to the Learned Trial Court, contrary to the
entirety of the materials-on-record, the very first point for consideration
before it was whether the accused persons were guilty of committing
offences punishable under Sections 376(2)(f) (g)/511,323, 506/34 of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860.
The apprehension remains as to the nature and credibility of the
materials-on-record actually appreciated, considered and relied upon by
the Learned Trial Court, while arriving at the conclusion of guilt of the
Accused Persons herein, including the present appellant.
xv. While delivering the impugned order of conviction and sentence, it was
further inter alia observed therein by the Learned Trial Court that the
accused persons were not offered to search the police personnel at the
place of occurrence and no efforts on the part of the investigating agency
were found to clarify wherefrom the accused persons were came and how
they meet to gauge the mens rea and apparently, in the absence of any
direct evidence regarding criminal conspiracy, they were acquitted of the
Charges under Section 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
Therefore, where the Learned Trial Court was itself satisfied that
there was utter dearth and/or absence of any admissible evidence to
establish any criminal conspiracy, mens rea and/or knowledge on the part
of the accused persons with regard to the alleged offences, which was one
of the most vital ingredients for sustaining a conviction under Sections
489B/489C of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, there ought not to have been
any conviction under the said provisions of law.
xvi. The sum total of all the materials-on-record in the instant case would
unambiguously and conclusively go on to reveal that the prosecution had
miserably failed to bring on record any independent or admissible
evidence to establish the guilt of the present appellant in the alleged
offences beyond all reasonable doubt and had solely relied extensively
upon the uncorroborated, dubious and inconsistent depositions of the PWs1, 2 & 3 (all being members of the Raiding Party herein) for the same,
which did not even receive any form of support/substantiation from any
independent source or witness, as even the alleged recovery of the
contented F.I.C.N. from the supposed possession of the accused persons
was substantially flawed, fallacious and questionable, inconsistent and
contradictory to established principles of law and the customary doctrines
of law were repeatedly outright violated, desecrated and defiled in every
step of the instant trial proceedings, thereby resonantly rendering it a
mistrial in the eyes of law.
xvii. Under such foregoing circumstances, it was most humbly and respectfully
prayed that this Hon’ble Court may, after going through the entirety of the
materials-on-record and after considering the rival submissions and
arguments, as advanced on behalf of the respective parties, most
graciously be pleased to set aside the impugned order of conviction and
sentence, thereby acquitting the appellant of all the alleged charges
and/or pass such other incidental and/or consequential orders, as this
Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice, equity and
good conscience.”
8. The Learned Advocate representing the State submitted as follows:i. “PW-1 has deposed that on 11.09.2013 he received information from a
secret source that the present appellant was arriving at Airport area at
Jessore Road with fake currency. Following which PW-2 and PW-3
accompanied him to Airport. The same has been corroborated by PW-2 and
PW-3.
ii. According to PW-1’s statement as well as from the seizure list it is evident
that the present appellant has signed in the seizure list which at least
marks his presence during the seizure, which cannot be denied by any
means. The same has been corroborated by PW 2 and 3 respectively. Even
PW-1 and PW-3 were signed the same as witness corroborating the fact
that the appellant was present and FICN amounting to four bundles of 50
pieces of Rs.500/- was found, amounting to Rs.1,00,000/- which was
seized from his possession which was later on marked as Mat. Exbt.-1.
The presence of the appellants at the place of occurrence thus suggests the
probability that the F.I.C.N. so seized was inherently in the appellant's
possession.
iii. PW-1 identified the appellants in the Court and deposed that the written
complaint marked as Exbt.-2 was signed by him as the complainant in the
official capacity.
iv. PW-1 acknowledged in his cross examination that the CC no. was 340, but
the written complaint bearing no.343 was a clerical mistake. Hence he
cleared up the possible air of confusion relation to the reference of the
appellants in terms of certain other case. Thereby he rejected the
contention of presence of two CCs for one case and clarified the
prosecution stratum that no unnecessary cases were intermingled with the
one in which the present appellant were roped in.
v. PW-5 who happened to be the expert concluded that after examination of
all the 200 notes of Rs.500/- as found by PW-1 was found to be fake and
false. Following which he submitted his report dated 11.11.2013 bearing
the official seal and his signature, marked as Exbt.-4.
vi. Taking charge of the present case the investigating officer, i.e., PW-6 sent
the seized alamat for expert opinion which was delivered given by PW-5.
He submitted the charge-sheet and deposed that the appellant was
identified.
vii. In a case of seizure of F.I.C.N. from the possession of an accused, the two
things which are necessary to attract the provisions under Indian Penal
Code are seizure and forensic report that the recovered currencies were
fake. In the instant case, both are prover beyond reasonable doubt.
Further, there are decisions of this Hon'ble Court which holds that in the
event large amount of F.I.C.N. were seized from the possession of an
accused it would be presumed that the accused was not only liable for
possession but also actively involved with trafficking. It was also trite law
as has been held in catena of decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court, that
evidence of police witnesses can be relied so far as the seizure was
concerned and it was not necessary to look for corroboration from
independent witnesses.
viii. Hence, in the backdrop of aforesaid discussion it can be argued that the
prosecution has been able to prove that the notes seized were fake.
Presence of the appellant at the place of occurrence and seizure from his
possession was corroborated by PWs-1, 2 & 3 as such the case was
proved beyond reasonable doubt and it did not require any interference by
this Hon'ble court.”
9. The evidence of the prosecution witnesses revealed that the prosecution case
emanated from a source information received by the officers attached to the
Special Operation Group, C.I.D., West Bengal regarding transportation of
Fake Indian Currency Notes in the Airport area at Sarat Colony More on
Jessore Road. The prosecution sought to establish that acting upon such
information, the raiding team proceeded to the place of occurrence,
intercepted the appellants and recovered
amounting
to
Rs.1,00,000/-
consisting
of
counterfeit currency notes
pieces
of
Rs.500/-
denomination from their possession.
10. PW-1 deposed that on 11.09.2013 he was posted in the Special Operation
Group, C.I.D., West Bengal. On that date he received source information that
one Bablu Ali Khan would arrive at the Airport area carrying Fake Indian
Currency Notes. According to the witness, after receiving such information
he communicated the matter to his superior authority and, acting on the
direction received from the superior officer, proceeded towards the Airport
area accompanied by PW-2, PW-3 and other members of the raiding party in
a government vehicle. The witness stated that after reaching Airport Police
Station at about 4:45 p.m., the information was diarised vide G.D.E. No.891
dated 11.09.2013. Thereafter, the raiding team reached Sarat Colony More
near the flyover where, on being identified by the source person, two persons
namely Bablu Ali Khan and Bhottu Sk. @ Bhottu were detained.
11. PW-1 further stated that upon interrogation the detained persons admitted
that they were carrying Fake Indian Currency Notes procured from Bishnab
P.S. area under Malda district for delivery to another person. The witness
stated that efforts were made to secure independent witnesses from the
locality though none expressed willingness to participate in the search and
seizure process. According to him, the detained persons were first offered an
opportunity to search the members of the raiding party though they
declined. Thereafter, search of the appellants led to recovery of 200 pieces of
Rs.500/- denomination currency notes arranged in four bundles amounting
in aggregate to Rs.1,00,000/-. A seizure list was prepared in respect of the
recovered articles and the seized notes were labelled and sealed. The seizure
list was marked Exhibit-1 and the packets containing the seized notes were
marked Mat. Exhibit-I collectively. PW-1 stated that thereafter both accused
persons were arrested and a written complaint was lodged before Airport
Police Station, which was marked Exhibit-2.
12. During cross-examination PW-1 admitted that the seizure list reflected C.C.
No.340 whereas the written complaint referred to C.C. No.343, which
according to him might have occurred due to clerical oversight. He stated
that he did not lodge any separate G.D.E. on his arrival at Airport Police
Station with the seized articles and accused persons and expressed lack of
familiarity with the expression “working G.D.E.”. The witness admitted that
no statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. was recorded from local persons
and no notice had been served upon them. He stated that the entire process
of search and seizure consumed nearly ninety minutes. PW-1 also admitted
that the seizure list did not bear any seal of a Gazetted Officer. He further
stated that the written complaint did not contain reference to the presence of
A.S.I. Rittwik Banerjee during the raid and also did not specify that the
counterfeit notes had been recovered from the pockets of the appellants.
According to the witness, no nil seizure list had been prepared. He further
stated that although he received telephonic instruction from his superior
officer for endorsing the case for investigation, such fact did not find place in
the written complaint. The witness admitted that the log book of the vehicle
used during the raid had not been produced before the Court. He further
stated that several shops were situated near the place of occurrence.
13. PW-2 deposed that on the relevant date he was attached to the Special
Operation Branch, C.I.D., West Bengal as Sub-Inspector of Police. According
to him, acting upon source information he accompanied the raiding team
consisting of S.I. Anupam Chakraborty, A.S.I. Rittwik Banerjee and other
police personnel to the Airport area where two persons namely Bablu Ali
Khan and Bhutto Sk. @ Guddu were detained and Fake Indian Currency
Notes were recovered from them. The witness stated that the officers
prepared seizure documents, arrested the appellants and lodged the FIR.
14. In cross-examination PW-2 stated that a Sub-Inspector could obtain
Command Certificate as per procedure. He stated that though he was not an
expert in counterfeit currency detection, he had undergone training to
identify Fake Indian Currency Notes. According to him, the seizure list did
not bear any seal of the C.I.D. He further stated that the raiding party
remained at the place of occurrence for nearly two hours.
15. PW-3 deposed that on 11.09.2013 he was posted at the S.O.G. Section,
C.I.D., West Bengal at Bhawani Bhawan as Sub-Inspector of Police.
According to him, acting on source information Inspector Atanu Ghosal,
A.S.I. Rittwik Banerjee, S.I. Krishnendu Ghosh and other police personnel
travelled in a vehicle bearing registration no. WB-26R-1534 to Airport Police
Station where the information was diarised vide G.D.E. No.891 dated
11.09.2013. Thereafter, they proceeded towards Sarat Pally near the flyover.
The source person identified Bablu Ali Khan and another individual who
were allegedly carrying Fake Indian Currency Notes. According to the
witness, the appellants were detained and upon search counterfeit currency
notes were recovered from their possession. The seized articles were taken
into custody under a seizure list and the witness placed his signature
thereon. The seizure list was marked Exhibit-1/1 and the seized notes were
marked Mat. Exhibit-I collectively.
16. During cross-examination PW-3 stated that he was not an expert in
counterfeit currency detection. He admitted that his movement had not been
entered in the movement register. He stated that the seizure list had been
written at the spot on a writing pad or support board and that the raiding
team remained at the place of occurrence for nearly one hour and forty-five
minutes. According to him, the place of occurrence was a busy thoroughfare
surrounded by several shops. The witness admitted that he had not affixed
his official seal beneath his signature on the seizure list and that the seizure
list contained no official seal of any department. He stated that the
appellants voluntarily signed the seizure list. He further admitted that after
returning to Airport Police Station no separate G.D.E. had been lodged by
him and his return to office at about 11:15 p.m. had not been entered in the
movement register.
17. PW-4 deposed that on 11.09.2013 he was posted at Airport Police Station as
Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police. According to him, upon receiving the
written complaint from Inspector Atanu Ghosal he initiated the instant case
by making endorsement on the written complaint, marked Exhibit-2/1, and
thereafter prepared the formal FIR, marked Exhibit-3. The Officer-in-Charge
thereafter endorsed the case to S.I. Sougata Ghosh for investigation. During
cross-examination the witness stated that he had no personal knowledge
regarding the occurrence.
18. PW-5, who was examined as an expert witness, deposed that at the relevant
time he was serving as Manager (Production) at Bharatiya Reserve Bank
Note Mudran Pvt. Ltd. According to him, pursuant to requisition made in
connection with Airport P.S. Case No.266/13 dated 11.09.2013, four sealed
envelopes
containing
currency
notes
of
Rs.500/-
denomination
suspected to be counterfeit were received through Court challan. The witness
stated that he, along with other members of the Forgery Note Detective Cell,
examined the notes by comparing them with authentic specimen notes with
the
aid
of
scientific
instruments
and
technical
parameters.
Upon
examination of eighteen distinct parameters relating to design, signature of
the Governor and serial numbers, the team concluded that all 200 notes
were counterfeit. He prepared a report in official capacity and submitted the
same before the Court. The report was marked Exhibit-4 and the seized
notes were identified by the witness as Mat. Exhibit-I collectively.
19. During cross-examination PW-5 stated that before examining the currency
notes he had not received a copy of the formal FIR. He asserted that he
possessed expertise in identification of counterfeit currency though he did
not hold any official certificate to that effect. The witness also stated that the
names of the other members of the examining team were not reflected in the
report and he declined to disclose the detailed methodology adopted in the
laboratory for identification of counterfeit notes.
20. PW-6, the Investigating Officer, deposed that on 11.09.2013 he was posted
at S.O.G., C.I.D., West Bengal as Sub-Inspector of Police and was entrusted
with investigation of the case by his superior authority. According to him, he
visited Airport Police Station, took charge of the accused persons and seized
articles, interrogated the available witnesses and the appellants, visited the
place of occurrence and prepared a rough sketch map with index marked
Exhibit-5. He stated that the seized articles were forwarded for expert
opinion and after collection of the expert report marked Exhibit-4, he
submitted charge-sheet upon completion of investigation.
21. During cross-examination PW-6 stated that though he was not an expert, he
had undergone departmental training enabling him to identify counterfeit
currency notes. He could not readily produce documents relating to such
training. The witness admitted that he did not obtain signature of any local
respectable person during investigation though shops and establishments
were situated near the place of occurrence. He stated that statements under
Section 161 Cr.P.C. were recorded at Airport Police Station between 9:35
p.m. and 10:30 p.m. The witness could not recollect the G.D.E. number
reflecting receipt of the seized documents and articles. He further stated that
he had not re-seized the seized articles and that he had not produced the
movement
register
before
the
Court.The
evidence
adduced
by
the
prosecution, when examined in the backdrop of the statutory ingredients of
Sections 489B, 489C and 120B of the Indian Penal Code, does not inspire
the degree of assurance necessary for sustaining the conviction of the
appellants. The materials on record reveal deficiencies in the manner of
search, seizure, investigation and proof of conscious possession which strike
at the foundation of the prosecution case. The cumulative effect of such
infirmities renders the conviction unsafe.
22. To bring home a charge under Section 489B IPC, the prosecution is required
to establish not merely possession or recovery of counterfeit currency notes,
but active use, trafficking, delivery or circulation of such notes coupled with
knowledge or reason to believe that the notes were counterfeit. Section 489C
IPC similarly postulates conscious possession accompanied by the requisite
mens rea that the currency notes were forged or counterfeit and intended to
be used as genuine. Suspicion, however grave, cannot substitute proof of
such foundational ingredients.
23. In the present case, the prosecution evidence proceeds substantially on the
testimony of police personnel attached to the raiding team. No member of the
public was associated with the alleged search and seizure although the
evidence of PW-1, PW-3 and PW-6 clearly discloses that the place of
occurrence
was
a
busy
thoroughfare
surrounded
by
shops
and
establishments. The prosecution witnesses admitted that several shop rooms
existed near the place of occurrence. Even then, no sincere endeavour
appears to have been made to secure participation of local persons in the
search and seizure process. The explanation furnished that none agreed to
become
witness
remains
a
bare
assertion
unsupported
by
any
contemporaneous record or notice. No written refusal of any local person
was obtained. No action was initiated against any person declining to assist
the police. The absence of independent witnesses in a case resting entirely
upon official testimony assumes significance particularly when the alleged
recovery forms the fulcrum of the prosecution case.
24. The seizure process itself suffers from conspicuous irregularities. PW-1
admitted that the seizure list did not contain the seal of any Gazetted Officer.
PW-2 stated that the seizure list bore no seal of the C.I.D. PW-3 also
admitted that neither his official seal nor any departmental seal was affixed
upon the seizure documents. The evidence further reflects divergence
regarding the duration and manner of the search operation. PW-1 stated
that the process consumed nearly ninety minutes, PW-2 stated that they
remained at the place of occurrence for about two hours, whereas PW-3
stated that they remained there for nearly one hour and forty-five minutes.
These discrepancies, though apparently peripheral, assume relevance in a
prosecution founded entirely on an alleged roadside recovery unsupported by
independent corroboration.
25. The prosecution version also suffers from procedural discontinuities which
weaken the sanctity of the seizure. PW-1 admitted that no separate G.D.E.
was lodged upon return to the police station with the accused persons and
seized articles. PW-3 similarly admitted that no G.D.E. was lodged after
return from the place of occurrence and that his movement was not reflected
in the movement register. PW-6, the Investigating Officer, could not recollect
the G.D.E. number reflecting receipt of the seized articles and documents.
The prosecution also failed to produce the movement register or log book of
the vehicle used during the raid. Such omissions create a visible gap in the
chain relating to movement, custody and handling of the seized articles.
26. The written complaint also does not fully correspond with the oral evidence
tendered before Court. PW-1 admitted that the written complaint did not
mention the presence of A.S.I. Rittwik Banerjee during the raid and further
omitted reference that the alleged counterfeit notes were recovered from the
pockets of the appellants. The witness also admitted discrepancy regarding
the Command Certificate number appearing in the seizure list and the
written complaint. Though the prosecution attempted to explain the
discrepancy as clerical in nature, the inconsistency acquires significance
when viewed cumulatively with the other shortcomings in the prosecution
case.
27. The prosecution also failed to establish the essential ingredient of conscious
possession with the requisite knowledge contemplated under Sections 489B
and 489C IPC. The evidence merely establishes alleged recovery of
counterfeit currency notes from the possession of the appellants. There is no
material demonstrating that the appellants attempted to circulate the notes
or intended to pass them as genuine. No transaction involving use of such
currency notes was brought on record. No conduct attributable to the
appellants indicating awareness regarding the counterfeit nature of the notes
was proved through cogent evidence.
28. The prosecution witnesses themselves admitted lack of expertise in
identification of counterfeit currency. PW-2 and PW-3 specifically stated that
they were not experts though they had received certain training. PW-6
similarly stated that he was not an expert though he had undergone
departmental training, documents relating to which could not be produced
readily. The alleged confession made by the appellants before the police
personnel regarding transportation of counterfeit notes cannot be accorded
substantive evidentiary value in view of the embargo contained in Sections
25 and 26 of the Evidence Act. Once such alleged disclosure is excluded
from consideration, the prosecution case rests solely on recovery evidence
whose reliability already stands impaired by procedural deficiencies and
absence of independent corroboration.
29. The prosecution further sought to invoke Section 120B IPC. Yet, beyond the
assertion that the appellants were found together carrying counterfeit notes,
no material has been brought on record indicating prior meeting of minds,
agreement or concert between the accused persons to commit an illegal act.
Criminal
conspiracy
cannot be
inferred
merely from association or
simultaneous presence. The prosecution must establish circumstances
revealing a conscious and pre-arranged plan. The evidence on record falls
short of that threshold.
30. The expert evidence of PW-5 undoubtedly establishes that the seized notes
were counterfeit. However, proof that the currency notes were fake does not
by itself establish the culpability of the appellants under Sections 489B or
489C IPC unless the prosecution further proves conscious possession and
requisite knowledge. The expert report cannot bridge the evidentiary
deficiencies surrounding recovery, custody and intention.
31. The investigation also reflects notable omissions. PW-6 admitted that no
signature of any respectable person of the locality was obtained during
investigation despite existence of shops and establishments near the place of
occurrence. No attempt appears to have been made to ascertain the alleged
source from where the counterfeit notes were procured or the intended
recipient to whom delivery was allegedly to be made. No material was
collected showing linkage of the appellants with any larger racket relating to
counterfeit currency circulation. Such gaps assume significance when the
prosecution sought conviction for serious offences carrying stringent
punishment.
32. Criminal jurisprudence proceeds on the principle that where two views are
reasonably possible on the evidence, the view favourable to the accused
must prevail. In the present case, the deficiencies in search and seizure,
absence of independent witnesses, discontinuity in documentary safeguards,
lack of convincing proof regarding conscious possession and failure to
establish the essential ingredients of conspiracy create substantial doubt
regarding the prosecution version. The appellants are therefore entitled to
the benefit arising from such doubt. An additional aspect which deserves
notice is that offences under Sections 489B and 489C of the Indian Penal
Code are not attracted merely upon recovery of counterfeit currency notes
from the possession of an accused person. The statutory scheme consciously
incorporates the element of mens rea. The prosecution is required to
establish that the accused had knowledge or reason to believe that the
currency notes were counterfeit and further intended to use the same as
genuine or facilitate such use. The mental element is therefore not ancillary
but constitutes the core of the offence itself.
33. In cases involving counterfeit currency, Courts have consistently maintained
that mere physical possession divorced from surrounding incriminating
circumstances cannot automatically lead to conviction. The prosecution is
expected to place before the Court reliable circumstances demonstrating
conscious and informed possession. Such circumstances may emerge from
conduct of the accused, attempt to circulate the notes, recovery during an
actual transaction, prior association with counterfeit currency rackets,
incriminating communication, concealment indicating awareness, or other
surrounding facts capable of establishing the requisite state of mind. In
absence
of
such
connecting
circumstances,
recovery
alone
remains
insufficient to sustain conviction.
34. The distinction between possession simpliciter and conscious possession
assumes particular importance in prosecutions under Section 489C IPC. A
person may come into custody of counterfeit notes without knowledge
regarding their nature. Criminal liability arises only when the prosecution
establishes awareness regarding the counterfeit character of the notes
coupled with intention that they be used as genuine. The burden of
establishing these foundational facts always rests upon the prosecution and
never shifts merely because counterfeit notes were allegedly recovered.
35. The evidence on record in the present case does not disclose any
circumstance showing that the appellants attempted to put the notes into
circulation or engaged in any transaction involving use of the seized notes as
genuine currency. No shopkeeper, trader or member of the public was
examined to show that the appellants attempted to pass the notes as
genuine. No material demonstrating prior involvement of the appellants in
counterfeit currency circulation was brought on record. Even the alleged
source and intended recipient of the notes remained beyond the sweep of
investigation. Such omissions leave the prosecution case resting upon bare
recovery unsupported by surrounding incriminating circumstances.
36. The charge under Section 489B IPC stands on an even higher footing. The
expression “uses as genuine”, “traffics in” or “delivers to another” occurring
in the provision contemplates an overt act relating to circulation or
movement of counterfeit currency with the requisite knowledge. The
prosecution evidence in the present case does not disclose any completed
transaction, attempted delivery, negotiation or circulation of the alleged
counterfeit notes. There is no evidence that the appellants were apprehended
while offering the notes in a commercial transaction or while attempting to
induce any person to accept them as genuine currency. The foundational
ingredients of Section 489B IPC therefore remain absent.
37. So far as the charge under Section 120B IPC is concerned, conspiracy is
essentially an agreement to commit an illegal act. Such agreement may
indeed be proved through circumstantial evidence, since direct evidence of
conspiracy seldom becomes available. Yet the circumstances relied upon
must form a coherent chain pointing towards a meeting of minds. Mere
companionship,
simultaneous
presence
or
joint
possession,
without
additional material suggestive of concerted design, cannot by itself justify
conviction for criminal conspiracy. In the present matter, the prosecution did
not recover communication devices, records of contact, prior transactions or
any material suggestive of coordinated planning between the appellants. The
allegation of conspiracy therefore remains in the realm of assumption rather
than proof.
38. The Court must also remain mindful that procedural safeguards attending
search and seizure acquire heightened importance where the prosecution
case is founded substantially upon recovery evidence. The requirement of
associating independent witnesses, maintaining contemporaneous records,
preserving chain of custody and ensuring documentary continuity are not
empty formalities. These safeguards lend authenticity and transparency to
the investigative process. When such safeguards remain absent and the
entire prosecution case rests solely upon official witnesses, the evidence
requires careful judicial scrutiny before conviction may safely follow.
39. The inconsistencies relating to G.D.E. entries, absence of movement register,
omission of departmental seals, non-production of log books and failure to
secure independent witnesses collectively affect the evidentiary assurance
ordinarily expected in a criminal trial involving serious penal consequences.
The Court cannot overlook such deficiencies merely because counterfeit
notes were ultimately opined by the expert to be fake. Proof regarding the
counterfeit nature of the notes constitutes only one limb of the prosecution
burden. The remaining and equally vital component relates to conscious
possession, knowledge and intended circulation, which have not been
established through cogent and reliable evidence.
40. In such circumstances, continuation of the conviction would rest more upon
conjecture than upon legally admissible proof satisfying the standard
required in criminal law.
41. Accordingly, the conviction and sentence imposed upon the appellants under
Sections 489B, 489C and 120B of the Indian Penal Code do not merit
affirmation. The appeal deserves to be allowed. The judgment of conviction
and order of sentence are liable to be set aside. The appellants are acquitted
of the charges levelled against them and be discharged from their bail bonds,
if not wanted in connection with any other case.
42. In view of the above discussions, the prosecution cannot be said to have
proved its case beyond reasonable doubt and as such the instant criminal
appeals being CRA 698 of 2014 with CRA 699 of 2014 are allowed.
43. Under such facts and circumstances, the judgment and order of conviction
dated 19.09.2014 and 20.09.2014 passed by the Learned Additional District
and Sessions Judge, 2nd Court, Barrackpore, North 24 Parganas in Sessions
Trial No.03(03)2014 arising out of Sessions Case No.522/2013 & G.R. Case
No.6061 of 2014, is set aside.
44. It transpires from the record that appellant Bhutto Sk. @ Guddu @ Bhottu
Sk. in CRA 698 of 2014 had served out the sentence was released on
154.06.2017 as per the report dated 13.09.2023 of the Dum Dum Central
Correctional Home.
45. Accordingly, the instant criminal appeals being CRA 698 of 2014 with CRA
699 of 2014 stand disposed of.
46. There is no order as to costs.
47. Trial Court records along with a copy of this judgment be sent down at once
to the Learned Trial Court for necessary action.
48. Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the parties on
priority basis on compliance of all formalities.
(Ananya Bandyopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review