Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Prasenjit Biswas
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
Partha Sarathi Neogi & Anr.
-VersusThe State of West Bengal
: Mr. Debasis Kar,
Mr. Husen Mustafi,
Ms. Paromita Mukherjee.
For the Appellants
For the State
:
Mr. Debasish Roy, Ld. PP,
Ms. Faria Hossai, Ld. APP,
Ms. Manisha Sharma.
Hearing concluded on
:
13.02.2026
Judgment On
:
18.02.2026
Prasenjit Biswas, J:1.
This instant appeal is directed against the impugned judgment
and order of conviction dated 01.10.2013 and 03.10.201 passed
by the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, 2nd Court,
Barrackpore in connection with Sessions Trial No. 6(9)2012
corresponding to Sessions Case No. 212 of 2011.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
2.
By passing the impugned judgment these appellants were found
guilty for commission of offence punishable under Section 306 of
the Indian Penal Code and were sentenced to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for seven years along with a fine of Rs. 5000/each and in default of payment of fine to suffer undergo further
rigorous imprisonment for one year each.
3.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said impugned
judgment and order of conviction, the present appeal is
preferred at the behest of the appellants.
4.
In short compass, the story of the prosecution, as delineated in
the record, may be summarized as follows:
“The case originated from a complaint lodged
by the defacto complainant, Smt. Kousalya Neogi,
who is the wife of the deceased, Sandip Neogi.
According to the written complaint, the complainant
was married to the victim in 1995. Although the
couple was not blessed with any children, their
marital
relationship
was,
at
the
initial
stage,
described as cordial and harmonious. It is, however,
contended that with the passage of time the
appellants began to behave improperly with the
complainant and the deceased on a regular basis,
subjecting them to both mental cruelty and physical
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
harassment. They are said to have used abusive and
slang
language
with
the
alleged
intention
of
obtaining a share in the property of the victim. The
complaint further states that in 2005, the victim fell
seriously ill and was admitted to hospital. On the
advice
of
medical
professionals,
the
victim
underwent amputation of his male organ. It is
alleged that following this incident, the appellants
intensified their harassment, making it extremely
difficult for the complainant and the victim to
continue
residing
in
the
house.
The
written
complaint additionally alleges that appellant no.1
defamed the character of the victim with the
assistance of a local individual named Barun Ghosh.
Despite repeated requests by the complainant and
her husband to desist from such acts, the alleged
harassment continued unabated. The complaint also
narrates an allegation involving one Smt. Saraswati
Biswas, a tenant in their house and proprietor of a
shop called Shilpa Ladies’ Tailor, who had purchased
a portion of the house. It is alleged that Saraswati
Biswas, taking advantage of the couple’s alleged
helpless condition, attempted to acquire the entire
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
property with the support of a local political party.
In furtherance of this purported plan, it is contended
that she sent her young niece, aged approximately
ten years, to the vicitm and propagated the false
allegation that the victim had sexually assaulted the
child, despite the victim’s incapacity to engage in
sexual
relations.
complainant,
the
According
to
cumulative
the
effect
defacto
of
this
harassment and mental torture by the appellants
caused the victim to become deeply depressed,
ultimately leading him to commit suicide. The
complaint also refers to a suicidal note discovered
by the complainant, in which the deceased allegedly
attributed
responsibility
for
his
death
to
the
appellants. On the basis of this written complaint,
Bizpur Police Station registered Case No. 295 dated
03.09.2010 under Section 306 of the Indian Penal
Code.
Thereafter,
the
police
carried
out
an
investigation and, upon its completion, submitted a
charge-sheet against the accused persons under
Section 306 IPC, thereby formally initiating criminal
proceedings against the appellants for abetment of
suicide.
This
narrative,
as
presented
by
the
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
prosecution,
formed
the
foundation
for
the
subsequent trial and conviction of the appellants.”
5.
It is submitted that the Trial Court, upon consideration of the
materials on record, framed a charge against the appellants
under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The charge
was read over and explained to the appellants in a language
known to them, following which they expressly pleaded not
guilty and claimed to be tried. This plea necessitated a full trial
in accordance with law.
6.
During the course of the trial, the prosecution examined a total
of thirteen (13) witnesses, whose testimonies were adduced to
substantiate the allegations leveled against the appellants. In
addition, relevant documents were tendered by the prosecution
and duly marked as exhibits to reinforce the evidentiary value of
their case.
7.
In stark contrast, the defence did not adduce any oral evidence
nor
produce
any
documentary
material
to
counter
the
prosecution’s case. The appellants, through their counsel, relied
solely on their plea of innocence, without calling any witnesses
or submitting documents in support of their defence. This
procedural posture underscores that the burden of proof rested
entirely
on
the
prosecution,
which,
having
examined
its
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
witnesses and tendered the relevant exhibits, relied upon the
strength of its case as adduced before the Court.
8.
Learned Advocate for the appellants, Mr. Debasis Kar, has
strenuously contended that the impugned judgment and order
of conviction suffer from serious infirmities, inasmuch as the
evidence on record is replete with material contradictions,
omissions, and inconsistencies which go to the root of the
prosecution case. According to him, such discrepancies render
the findings of the learned Trial Court legally unsustainable and
unworthy of reliance in the eye of law.
9.
Elaborating his submissions, learned Advocate has
drawn
attention to the testimony of the defacto complainant (PW1). It
is pointed out that during cross-examination, PW1 admitted that
she approached the police station to lodge the complaint
approximately 20 to 25 days after the death of her husband.
This inordinate and unexplained delay in lodging the FIR,
according to the defence, creates serious doubt regarding the
genuineness of the allegations and raises the possibility of
afterthought and embellishment. PW1 further deposed that her
husband had previously attempted to commit suicide in the year
due
to
illness,
thereby
indicating
a
pre-existing
vulnerability on the part of the deceased which was unrelated to
the present appellants.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
10.
It is further submitted that although PW1 alleged that the
appellants used to inflict mental and physical torture upon the
victim, she admittedly did not lodge any complaint before any
police station or competent authority during the lifetime of her
husband.
Such
inaction,
despite
the
alleged
continuous
harassment, materially weakens the prosecution version. The
learned Advocate also relies on PW1’s admission in crossexamination that appellant no. 1 was residing separately after
erecting a partition wall, thereby reducing the possibility of
regular interaction or interference. In the absence of any cogent
evidence
of
direct
instigation
or
proximate
provocation
attributable to the appellants, it is argued that there can be no
presumption of abetment to suicide. The prosecution, according
to him, has failed to establish any proximate cause linking the
acts of the appellants with the suicide of the deceased.
11.
The learned Advocate has further referred to PW1’s admission
regarding the earlier suicide note dated 01.07.2005 (Exhibit-A).
PW1 acknowledged that the names mentioned therein were
known to her and included persons such as a doctor, an
advocate, a political leader, and a school teacher, yet she had
no grievance against any of them. This, according to the
defence, demonstrates that the deceased’s earlier suicidal
tendency was linked to personal and medical issues rather than
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
to any conduct of the present appellants. It is also emphasized
that the said suicide note pertains to the year 2005, whereas
the
alleged
incident
occurred
on
09.08.2010,
after
a
considerable lapse of time. Therefore, no evidentiary value can
reasonably be attached to that document for implicating the
present appellants.
12.
Attention has also been drawn to the contradictory evidence
regarding alleged property disputes. PW4 stated that there was
a dispute between the two brothers’ families relating to
property, whereas PW5 categorically deposed that there was a
cordial relationship between appellant no. 1 and the victim and
that no property dispute existed. These mutually destructive
versions, it is argued, cast serious doubt on the prosecution’s
attempt to establish motive.
13.
With regard to PW10, the brother of the defacto complainant,
the learned Advocate submits that he admitted in crossexamination that the mental and physical condition of the victim
was normal prior to his death. He also stated that there was no
regular interaction between the family of appellant no. 1 and the
victim and that he had never lodged any complaint alleging
torture. Such evidence, according to the defence, is inconsistent
with the theory of sustained harassment leading to suicide.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
14.
Serious reliance is also placed on the testimony of PW13, the
Investigating Officer. In cross-examination, PW13 admitted that
the defacto complainant had not stated before him that the
appellants had instigated or provoked her husband to commit
suicide. Likewise, other witnesses did not make any such
allegation in their statements under Section 161 CrPC. This
omission, it is contended, is fatal to the prosecution case, as it
strikes at the foundation of the charge of abetment.
15.
On the legal aspect, the learned Advocate submits that to
constitute an offence under Section 306 of the Indian Penal
Code, mere harassment or ill-treatment is insufficient. The
prosecution must establish a clear mens rea to instigate or aid
the commission of suicide and must further prove that such
instigation was the proximate and effective cause of the suicide.
In the present case, there is no evidence of any direct or
indirect act of incitement, nor any material to show that the
suicide was the immediate result of any conduct of the
appellants. Vague and general allegations of harassment,
without proof of a live and proximate link with the act of suicide,
do not satisfy the statutory requirement of abetment.
16.
In support of these submissions, reliance has been placed on
authoritative pronouncements of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Prakash & Ors. vs. The State of Maharashtra & Anr.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
(2025) 2 Supreme 695 and Gangula Mohan Reddy vs.
State of Andhra Pradesh (2010) 1 SCC 750, wherein the
scope and ingredients of Section 306 IPC have been elaborately
discussed and the necessity of proving proximate instigation has
been emphasized.
17.
On the cumulative assessment of the evidence and the settled
principles of law, it is argued that the learned Trial Judge failed
to properly appreciate the material contradictions and omissions
on record. The findings, according to the defence, are based on
conjectures and surmises rather than on legally admissible and
reliable evidence. It is therefore urged that the impugned
judgment and order of conviction are unsustainable in law and
liable to be set aside.
18.
Ms. Manisha Sharma, learned Advocate appearing for the State,
submitted
that
the
prosecution
has
placed
credible
and
trustworthy evidence on record, which sufficiently establishes
the guilt of the appellants. According to the learned Advocate,
there is nothing in the material before the Court that would
render the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses unreliable
or unworthy of credence.
19.
It was contended that the prosecution witnesses, particularly
PW1,
the
defacto
complainant,
and
PW10,
her
brother,
consistently supported the prosecution case in their depositions.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
PW1, in particular, deposed that the appellants used to inflict
both mental and physical torture upon the deceased, Sandip
Neogi. The learned Advocate emphasized that PW1’s testimony
closely mirrors the allegations made in the written complaint
lodged with the police, thereby demonstrating a consistent and
coherent narrative from the inception of the complaint through
the trial proceedings.
20.
Further, the learned Advocate pointed out that PW10 also
corroborated PW1’s version, stating that the appellants caused
mental distress and harassment to the victim, which ultimately
resulted in his decision to commit suicide. The combined testimony
of these witnesses, as submitted by the State, clearly indicated
that the appellants actively engaged in conduct that contributed to
the deceased’s mental anguish.
21.
It was further argued that the suicidal note left by the victim
constitutes additional evidence indicating the involvement of the
appellants in the circumstances that led to his death. According to
the learned Advocate, the note supports the assertion that the
deceased attributed his suffering to the acts of the appellants.
22.
Mr. Roy emphasized that the depositions of PW1 and PW10 were
not materially shaken during cross-examination. The witnesses
maintained their account under scrutiny, and there were no
contradictions that could meaningfully impeach their testimony. In
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
light of the entirety of the evidence, it was submitted that the
learned Trial Judge correctly appreciated the facts, found that the
appellants were responsible for abetting the suicide of the
deceased, and imposed sentences in accordance with the law.
23.
Accordingly, it was urged on behalf of the State that the impugned
judgment and order of conviction are legally sound and fully
supported by the record. The learned Advocate submitted that the
appeal filed by the appellants is devoid of merit and should be
dismissed,
thereby
upholding
the
findings
and
convictions
recorded by the Trial Court.
24.
I have considered the rival submission anxiously adverse by
both the parties and have gone through all the materials on
record.
25.
PW1, Koushala Neogi, who is the wife of the deceased, lodged a
written complaint before the police alleging, interalia, that the
present appellants used to subject her husband to mental
torture by spreading defamatory statements in various forms
and by allegedly instigating him to commit suicide. According to
her version in the complaint, such conduct on the part of the
appellants caused severe mental distress to the victim, as a
result of which he became deeply depressed and ultimately
committed suicide by jumping before a running train in front of
Kanchrapara Workshop Gate on 09.08.2010.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
26.
However, a careful scrutiny of her evidence, particularly in
cross-examination,
reveals
several
circumstances
which
materially affect the credibility and probative value of her
testimony. PW1 admitted that she approached the police station
to lodge the complaint only after 20 to 25 days from the date of
her husband’s death. No satisfactory explanation has been
offered for such a substantial delay in lodging the FIR. In
criminal
jurisprudence, prompt lodging of
a complaint is
considered a safeguard against embellishment or afterthought.
An unexplained delay of this nature inevitably creates doubt as
to the spontaneity and authenticity of the allegations and gives
rise to the possibility of deliberation or external influence.
27.
PW1 further admitted in cross-examination that the deceased
had earlier attempted to commit suicide in the year 2005 due to
his illness. The defence brought on record the suicide note
relating to the 2005 incident, which was marked as Exhibit-A
(collectively). She candidly acknowledged that her husband’s
male organ had been amputated owing to illness, and that this
had led him into a state of mental depression. This admission is
of considerable significance, as it indicates a pre-existing
psychological vulnerability and a history of suicidal tendency
unrelated to the present allegations.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
28.
The witness also deposed that appellant no. 1 was residing
separately after constructing a partition wall in the house and
that there were no cordial relations between the families after
her marriage. If, by her own showing, the appellants and the
victim’s family were living separately and had little or no
interaction, the allegation of continuous instigation or abetment
becomes inherently doubtful. Abetment to suicide ordinarily
requires some degree of proximity, interaction, or conduct
capable of influencing the mind of the deceased; a situation of
estrangement and separate residence considerably weakens
such a theory.
29.
Another material inconsistency emerges regarding the lodging of
the complaint. PW1 stated that the scribe, Sunita Bhattacharjee,
had reduced her elaborate narration into a concise written
complaint
which
was
submitted
to
the
police.
She
simultaneously admitted that her elaborate written complaint
was not submitted before the police. This shifting stand
regarding the very foundation of the prosecution case, the
written
complaint,
raises
doubt
about
the
accuracy
and
completeness of the allegations made at the earliest stage.
30.
Though PW1 made general allegations that the appellants
mentally
tortured
the
victim
by
spreading
defamatory
statements and by instigating him to commit suicide, she
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
admitted that during her entire marital life she never lodged any
complaint before any police station or authority against the
appellant no. 1. Such inaction, despite the alleged persistent
torture, undermines the natural course of human conduct and
weakens the reliability of her claims.
31.
Her evidence further shows that the deceased’s earlier suicide
attempt in 2005 was linked to his illness and mental depression.
She admitted that the names mentioned in the suicide note
dated 01.07.2005 were known to her and included a doctor, an
advocate, a political leader, and a school teacher, yet she had
no grievance against any of them. She also admitted that on
that occasion appellant no. 1 had taken her husband to the
hospital while she herself was not at home. These facts suggest
that the deceased’s fragile mental condition and prior suicidal
tendencies were rooted in personal and medical issues rather
than any conduct attributable to the appellants. It is therefore a
plausible
inference
that,
having
once
attempted
suicide
unsuccessfully, the deceased may have taken the extreme step
subsequently due to his continuing mental depression.
32.
PW1 also admitted that she had read the suicide note seized by
the police in the present case and that it did not disclose any
reason for the commission of suicide. Significantly, the note did
not attribute blame to the appellants or refer to any act of
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
instigation or harassment by them. This omission is crucial, as a
suicide note, if it exists, is often the most direct evidence of the
deceased’s state of mind.
33.
PW2, Amal Saha, and PW3, Sandha Saha, who were tenants
residing in the same premises with the defacto complainant, are
natural witnesses inasmuch as they were situated in close
physical proximity to the family of the deceased and were in a
position to observe the day-to-day interactions, if any, between
the parties. However, their testimonies do not support the
prosecution case in any manner so far as the involvement of the
present appellants is concerned.
34.
PW2, in his cross-examination, categorically stated that during
the entire period of his tenancy in the house of the victim, there
was no visiting term or interaction between the family of the
deceased and the appellants. This statement is significant
because, if there had been persistent harassment, instigation, or
any form of mental torture as alleged, a tenant living in the
same house would reasonably be expected to have noticed
some form of interaction, quarrel, or discord. His clear assertion
of absence of contact materially weakens the prosecution’s
theory of continuous provocation or harassment.
35.
PW3, who is the wife of PW2 and an equally natural witness,
corroborated the version of her husband. She stated that she
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
personally did not witness any relationship or visiting term
between the victim’s family and appellant no. 1. Her evidence
reinforces the inference that there was little or no interaction
between the two families. Where two independent witnesses
residing in the same premises consistently speak to the absence
of contact, it becomes difficult to accept the allegation of
sustained instigation.
36.
It is true that both PW2 and PW3 were declared hostile and were
cross-examined by the prosecution. However, merely declaring
a witness hostile does not dilute the evidentiary value of the
portions of testimony that remain unshaken. In the present
case, nothing material could be elicited from their crossexamination to advance the prosecution story or to establish
any overt act, instigation, or conduct on the part of the
appellants. Their evidence, therefore, does not implicate the
appellants and rather probabilizes the defence version of
estrangement.
37.
PW4, Sri Amar Roy, initially stated in his examination-in-chief
that there was a property dispute between the two brothers’
families, namely the family of Partha Sarathi Neogi and that of
the victim. However, in cross-examination, he admitted that he
had
not
personally witnessed
any
incident
and that
his
deposition was based entirely on hearsay. Hearsay evidence, by
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
its very nature, is weak and generally inadmissible to prove the
truth of its contents unless it falls within recognized exceptions.
Since PW4 lacked direct knowledge, his statement regarding
dispute cannot be treated as reliable proof of motive.
38.
In contrast, PW5, Niloy Dutta, deposed that there was a good
relationship between appellant no. 1 and the victim and that no
property dispute existed between them. This version directly
contradicts
PW4.
Such
contradictory
evidence
among
prosecution witnesses on a material aspect like motive creates
serious doubt about the veracity of the prosecution’s narrative.
39.
PW5 further stated that he had not been examined by the police
during investigation and that he was deposing for the first time
before the Court. He clarified that his role was limited to
identifying the house of the victim at the request of the police
and signing a paper as directed. He had no personal knowledge
regarding any alleged mental torture by the appellants. Thus,
his testimony does not advance the prosecution case on the
core allegation of abetment.
40.
PW7, Sri Samar Roy, was merely a seizure witness to the
recovery of the suicide note. His role was confined to signing the
seizure list. He did not claim any personal knowledge regarding
the alleged acts of the appellants. A seizure witness proves only
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
the procedural aspect of recovery and cannot, by itself, establish
the truth of the allegations against the accused.
41.
Similarly,
PW8,
Sri
Soumen
Dutta,
admitted
in
cross-
examination that he knew nothing about the incident and that
he had not been examined by the police during investigation. He
stated that he signed the seizure list at the police station as per
police instruction. PW9, Bablu Debnath, echoed the same
version, stating that he signed the seizure list for certain papers
at the police station on police instruction. Their testimonies are
formal in nature and do not establish the factum of seizure in a
convincing manner, far less do they connect the appellants to
the alleged offence.
42.
On a cumulative assessment, the evidence of PW2, PW3, PW5,
PW7, PW8, and PW9 does not incriminate the appellants in any
substantive way. These witnesses denied the existence of
interaction between the parties, contradict the prosecution on
motive, or are merely formal witnesses to procedural steps
taken by the police. Their testimonies fail to establish any
element
of
instigation,
abetment,
or
proximate
conduct
attributable to the appellants. Consequently, these pieces of
evidence do not strengthen the prosecution case and, in several
respects, lend support to the defence by creating reasonable
doubt regarding the prosecution’s allegations.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
43.
The
prosecution has
placed
considerable
reliance
on the
testimony of PW10, Bhola Barman, who is the brother of the
defacto complainant, to corroborate the version of PW1 and to
lend support to the allegations made in the written complaint. At
the time of hearing, learned counsel for the State has submitted
that PW10, along with PW1, has fully supported the prosecution
case and the narrative set out in the complaint. However, a
careful and analytical reading of his evidence, particularly when
tested in cross-examination, reveals material inconsistencies
and admissions that substantially weakens the probative value
of his testimony.
44.
In his examination-in-chief, PW10 stated that he had told the
police that the appellants, being the “Dada” and “Boudi” of the
victim, used to subject both the defacto complainant and the
deceased to torture, and that such alleged torture drove the
deceased to commit suicide. He further asserted that he had
informed the police that the appellants propagated defamatory
statements against the couple on the ground that they had no
children, and that due to such humiliation and harassment the
victim ultimately committed suicide, leaving behind a suicide
note which was recovered and seized by the police in his
presence.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
45.
At first glance, these statements appear to support the
prosecution case. However, the credibility of a witness is not
assessed merely on the basis of examination-in-chief but on the
totality of his evidence, including cross-examination. In crossexamination, PW10 admitted that the mental and physical
condition of the deceased was normal prior to his death. This
statement assumes significance because it does not align with
the prosecution theory of continuous mental torture leading to a
fragile psychological state culminating in suicide. If the deceased
was mentally and physically normal, the causal link between
alleged harassment and the extreme act becomes less certain
and calls for stricter proof.
46.
More importantly, PW10 candidly admitted that prior to the
incident there was no talking or visiting term between the family
of appellant no. 1 and the family of the deceased. This
admission strikes at the very root of the prosecution’s allegation
of sustained harassment and instigation. Abetment by way of
instigation ordinarily presupposes some degree of interaction,
communication, or conduct capable of influencing the mind of
the victim. Where there is admitted absence of contact or
communication, the allegation of regular mental torture or
instigation becomes inherently doubtful.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
47.
Another significant aspect is his conduct. Though he claimed
knowledge
of
defamatory
statements
and
mental
torture
allegedly inflicted by the appellants, he conceded that he never
lodged any complaint before any police station or authority
regarding such conduct. Such inaction on the part of a close
relative, who was aware of the alleged harassment, appears
inconsistent with normal human conduct and reduces the
evidentiary weight of his allegations. If the alleged acts were
serious enough to drive a person to suicide, it is reasonable to
expect that some complaint or protest would have been made at
an earlier point of time.
48.
PW10
also
stated
in
cross-examination
that
the
defacto
complainant handed over the suicide note from the victim’s
diary to the police at the time of lodging the complaint, but he
himself had not read the contents of that note. Therefore, his
assertion regarding the contents or implications of the suicide
note is not based on personal knowledge. His evidence on this
point is, at best, derivative and lacks independent evidentiary
value.
49.
When these aspects are considered cumulatively, it becomes
evident
that
PW10’s
testimony
is
marked
by
material
contradictions and notable omissions. On one hand, he makes
general allegations of torture and defamation; on the other, he
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
admits
absence
of
interaction
between
the
parties,
acknowledges normal mental and physical condition of the
deceased, and demonstrates prior inaction despite alleged
knowledge of harassment. His lack of personal knowledge
regarding the suicide note further diminishes the reliability of his
account.
50.
In criminal trials, where the standard is proof beyond reasonable
doubt,
the
testimony
inconsistencies
cannot
of
a
be
witness
suffering
accepted
from
such
uncritically.
The
contradictions in PW10’s evidence create a clear dent in the
prosecution story and render his testimony insufficiently reliable
to form the basis of a finding of guilt. Consequently, it would be
unsafe to place reliance on the evidence of this witness for
sustaining a charge of abetment to suicide.
51.
PW13, the Investigating Officer of the case, is a crucial witness
from the standpoint of testing the consistency and credibility of
the prosecution version, because his testimony reflects what
was actually stated by the witnesses at the earliest stage of the
investigation.
His
cross-examination
assumes
particular
significance in the present matter, as it brings to light material
omissions in the earlier statements of the key witnesses.
52.
In cross-examination, PW13 categorically stated that the defacto
complainant (PW1), in her written complaint/FIR, did not
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
mention that the accused persons had instigated or provoked
the victim to commit suicide. He further clarified that even in
her statement recorded during investigation, she did not state
that the accused persons had instigated or provoked her
husband, Sandip Neogy, to commit suicide. This omission is not
a minor discrepancy but goes to the root of the prosecution
case. Where the gravamen of the charge is abetment to suicide,
the element of instigation or provocation is a foundational fact
which would ordinarily find place in the very first version of the
informant if it were true. Its absence at that stage raises a
serious doubt as to whether such allegations were later
improvements.
53.
PW13 further deposed that the other prosecution witnesses,
namely PW2, PW3, PW4, PW5, PW6, PW7, PW8, PW9, and
PW10, also did not state at the time of recording their
statements that the accused persons had instigated or provoked
the victim to commit suicide. Thus, across the board, none of
the material witnesses attributed any act of instigation or
provocation to the accused at the earliest point of time when
their memories were fresh and there was little scope for
deliberation or embellishment.
54.
In criminal jurisprudence, omissions of this nature in prior
statements, particularly under Section 161 CrPC, assume great
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
importance. When a witness introduces a new incriminating fact
for the first time before the Court which was absent in the
earlier statement to police, such omission can amount to a
contradiction if it touches a vital aspect of the prosecution case.
Here, the allegation of instigation is not collateral but central to
establishing an offence of abetment to suicide. Therefore, its
absence
in
the
earlier
statements
materially
affects
the
credibility of any subsequent claim to that effect.
55.
These omissions also have a logical bearing. If the accused had
truly been instigating or provoking the victim, it is natural to
expect that the family members and close witnesses would have
disclosed such a crucial fact to the Investigating Officer at the
first available opportunity. The uniform silence of all these
witnesses on this vital point indicates either that no such acts
occurred or that the prosecution story evolved subsequently.
56.
Consequently, the testimony of PW13 exposes a fundamental
weakness in the prosecution case. It demonstrates that the
essential ingredient of instigation or provocation was not part of
the original narrative given to the police. This creates a serious
dent in the prosecution story and undermines the allegation of
abetment. In such circumstances, it would be legally unsafe to
hold that the prosecution has succeeded in establishing the
charge of abetment to suicide beyond reasonable doubt.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
57.
To constitute an offence under Section 306 of the Indian Penal
Code, it is not sufficient for the prosecution merely to establish
that the victim was subjected to harassment, ill-treatment, or
mental distress. The essential ingredients of the offence, as
consistently recognized in judicial pronouncements, require
proof of direct or indirect instigation by the accused, which must
be the proximate and effective cause leading the victim to
commit
suicide.
defamatory
Mere
statements,
vague
or
allegations
general
of
harassment,
ill-treatment,
without
evidence of a clear act or series of acts intentionally directed to
push the deceased toward taking his own life, do not satisfy the
statutory threshold under Section 306 IPC.
58.
In the present case, an examination of the record reveals that
the prosecution has not established any such proximate or
immediate instigation by the appellants. There is no evidence,
either oral or documentary, indicating that the appellants
inflicted harassment on the deceased immediately prior to the
suicide or at any occasion which compelled him to end his life.
While PW1, the wife of the deceased, alleged that the appellants
used to inflict mental torture by propagating defamatory
statements, she admitted in cross-examination that she did not
lodge any complaint with the police or approach any other
authority during the lifetime of her husband. This omission is
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
material because a reasonable and concerned spouse, aware of
such alleged harassment, would ordinarily take steps to seek
intervention, and her failure to do so undermines the credibility
of the allegation of persistent torture leading to suicide.
59.
Further, PW13, the Investigating Officer, corroborated this
lacuna by stating that in her written complaint or statement,
PW1 did not mention that the accused persons instigated or
provoked the victim to commit suicide. This omission at the
earliest stage of reporting is highly significant. Where the
essential act of instigation is absent from the initial complaint, it
raises a substantial doubt as to whether the alleged harassment
was genuinely the proximate cause of the suicide or whether it
was later concocted to implicate the accused.
60.
The record also demonstrates that the deceased had previously
attempted suicide in 2005 due to illness. PW1 admitted that her
husband’s male organ had been amputated, which caused him
severe mental distress and depression, leading to the prior
suicide attempt. The suicidal note from that earlier episode
(Exhibit-A collectively) mentions certain persons known to the
deceased but against whom she had no grievance, indicating
that the prior attempt was unrelated to the present appellants.
This fact suggests a pre-existing psychological vulnerability and
shows that the decision to commit suicide in 2010 may have
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
been influenced by factors other than the alleged harassment by
the appellants.
61.
Moreover, PW1 admitted that appellant no.1 resided separately,
having constructed a partition wall, and that there was no
cordial
relationship
or
regular
interaction
between
the
deceased’s family and the appellants. If there was no proximate
interaction
or
communication,
the
allegation
of
abetment
becomes inherently improbable. Without any such contact, it is
difficult to conceive how the appellants could have instigated or
left the deceased with no option but to commit suicide.
62.
The principles governing Section 306 IPC have been succinctly
laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Prakash (supra). In
paragraphs 13 and 14 of the judgment, the Court observed:
“Section
of
the
IPC
has
two
basic
ingredients—first, an act of suicide by one person and
second, the abetment to the said act by another
person(s). In order to sustain a charge under Section
306 IPC, it must necessarily be proved that the
accused person has contributed to the suicide by the
deceased by some direct or indirect act. To prove such
contribution
or
involvement,
one
of
the
three
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
conditions outlined in Section 107 IPC has to be
satisfied.
Section 306 read with Section 107 IPC, has
been interpreted, time and again, and its principles are
well-established. To attract the offence of abetment to
suicide, it is important to establish proof of direct or
indirect acts of instigation or incitement of suicide by
the accused, which must be in close proximity to the
commission
of
suicide
by
the
deceased.
Such
instigation or incitement should reveal a clear mens
rea to abet the commission of suicide and should put
the victim in such a position that he/she would have
no other option but to commit suicide.”
61.
In consonance with these principles, it is evident that for abetment
to suicide to arise, the accused must actively contribute through
acts or words to a situation where the victim sees no alternative
but to end his life. There must be a demonstrable mens-rea and a
proximate causal link. The mere existence of mental harassment
or defamatory statements in the past, without any immediate
triggering act, cannot substitute for this statutory requirement.
Each individual reacts differently to harassment, and the law
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
requires concrete evidence that the accused’s acts were the direct
or proximate cause of the suicide
62.
In the present case, the record does not demonstrate any such
positive act of instigation by the appellants. There is no evidence
that any communication, act, or intentional aid on the part of the
appellants left the deceased with no other option but to commit
suicide.
The
allegations
of
harassment, in
the
absence
of
proximate connection and mens rea, are insufficient to attract the
offence under Section 306 IPC. Therefore, on a careful analysis of
the evidence and the principles laid down by the Apex Court, it is
apparent that the prosecution has failed to establish the essential
ingredients of abetment to suicide, and the charge under Section
306 IPC cannot be sustained against the appellants.
63.
In the case of Gangula (supra) the Hon’ble Apex Court has
reiterated and clarified the legal principle regarding abetment
under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code. The Court held that
abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or
intentionally aiding a person in the commission of an act.
Importantly, the Court emphasized that without a positive act on
the part of the accused an act intended to instigate, encourage, or
aid the deceased, conviction for abetment cannot be sustained.
The mere perception of harassment, general ill-treatment, or even
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
adverse conduct, absent a clear and proximate act of instigation,
is legally insufficient to constitute the offence.
64.
Applying this principle to the instant case, it is evident that the
prosecution has failed to demonstrate any such positive act on the
part of the appellants. There is no material on record to show that
the deceased was actively goaded, encouraged, or instigated by
the appellants to commit suicide. While the defacto complainant
(PW1)
alleged
that
the
appellants
used
to
inflict
mental
harassment by propagating defamatory statements, her own
evidence, coupled with the statements of other witnesses and the
Investigating Officer (PW13), fails to establish that any such act
was proximate in time or direct in effect.
65.
As the Apex Court observed in Gangula Mohan Reddy (supra),
abetment requires that the accused’s conduct must have a direct
causal connection with the act of suicide. If a person actively
suggests, encourages, or otherwise goads another into the act,
either by explicit words, gestures, or conduct, then such positive
involvement can amount to abetment. However, in the present
matter, nothing in the record indicates that the suicide of the
deceased was the direct result of words uttered by the appellants
or of any ill-treatment alleged to have been inflicted by them.
There is no occasion proved where the appellants’ acts could have
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
created a situation leaving the deceased with no alternative but to
take his own life.
66.
Moreover, none of the prosecution witnesses, including PW1, PW2,
PW3, PW4, PW5, PW7, PW8, PW9, or PW10, could point to any
specific act or instance of torture or ill-treatment by the appellants
immediately preceding the suicide. No contemporaneous complaint
was lodged by the victim or his wife against the appellants, and
the Investigating Officer’s cross-examination confirms that no
statements were made to the police implicating the appellants in
abetting the suicide. The evidence, therefore, is devoid of any
direct or circumstantial indication that the appellants’ alleged
conduct was the proximate cause of the deceased’s death.
67.
In light of the legal position elucidated in the above report, and
considering the factual matrix of the present case, it is manifest
that Section 306 IPC has no application. Abetment presupposes a
positive act or active instigation, which is conspicuously absent in
the record. Mere allegations of past harassment, defamatory
statements, or mental distress, unconnected to the immediate act
of suicide, cannot sustain a conviction under the provision.
Consequently, in the instant matter, no liability can attach to the
appellants under Section 306 IPC, as there is neither evidence of
proximate
instigation
nor
any
act
demonstrating
that
the
deceased’s suicide was a direct result of the appellants’ conduct.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
68.
In view of the foregoing facts, circumstances, and detailed
discussions on the evidence adduced before the Court, I am of the
opinion that the prosecution has manifestly failed to prove the
charge levelled against the appellants under Section 306 of the
Indian
Penal
Code.
A careful
and
holistic
analysis
of
the
testimonies of the prosecution witnesses including PW1, PW2,
PW3, PW4, PW5, PW7, PW8, PW9, PW10, and PW13 reveals
substantial
omissions,
contradictions,
and
inconsistencies.
Crucially, there is no material evidence to establish that the
appellants actively instigated, goaded, or abetted the deceased to
commit suicide, nor is there any proof of proximate conduct that
could be said to have compelled the victim to end his life.
69.
The law, as clearly articulated by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Prakash (supra) and Gangula Mohan Reddy (supra), requires
that for an offence under Section 306 IPC to be made out, there
must be: (i) a positive act or direct involvement by the accused;
(ii) a proximate causal link between such act and the suicide; and
(iii) an evident mens rea on the part of the accused, indicating an
intention to instigate, aid, or encourage the deceased to commit
suicide. The record in the present case is conspicuously silent on
all these essential elements. There is no evidence of immediate
harassment, direct instigation, or actionable conduct by the
appellants that could have led to the victim’s decision to take his
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
own life. The alleged defamatory statements and supposed mental
harassment, even if taken at face value, are remote in time,
general in nature, and insufficient to constitute abetment under
the law.
70.
Furthermore, the deceased had a prior history of mental distress
and a suicide attempt in 2005 due to illness, as admitted by PW1.
The suicidal note from that incident (Exhibit-A collectively) does
not implicate the appellants, and there is no evidence that the
events of 2010 had any immediate connection with the conduct of
the accused. The independent statements of tenants and other
witnesses corroborate the absence of any significant interaction or
relationship between the deceased’s family and the appellants,
further undermining the prosecution case.
71.
In light of these factors, it becomes apparent that the learned Trial
Judge
has
based
the
impugned
judgment
on
conjectures,
surmises, and assumptions rather than on legally admissible and
reliable evidence. The conclusions drawn by the Trial Court lack
the requisite factual and legal foundation necessary to sustain a
conviction under Section 306 IPC. This constitutes a gross
miscarriage of justice and cannot stand in the eyes of law.
72.
Accordingly,
applying
the
well-settled
principles
of
criminal
jurisprudence and the binding ratios of the Hon’ble Apex Court,
the impugned judgment and order of conviction are liable to be set
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
aside. The prosecution has not discharged the burden of proving
the essential ingredients of abetment beyond reasonable doubt,
and in the absence of credible and proximate evidence, the
appellants cannot be held criminally liable for the alleged offence.
73.
Accordingly, the instant appeal be and the same is hereby
allowed.
74.
The
impugned
judgment
and
order
of
conviction
dated
01.10.2013 and 03.10.2013 passed by the learned Additional
District and Sessions Judge, 2nd Court, Barrackpore, in Sessions
Trial No. 6(9)2012 corresponding to Sessions Case No. 212 of
2011 is hereby set aside.
75.
The appellants are on bail. They are to be discharged from their
respective bail bonds and be set at liberty if they are not wanted
in connection with other cases.
76.
In compliance with the mandate of Section 437A of the Code of
Criminal Procedure (corresponding to Section 483 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023), the appellant is
required to execute bail bonds backed by adequate and reliable
sureties. Such bonds, once duly executed, shall remain valid and
operative for a period of six months, thereby securing the
appellant’s availability as and when called upon by the Court
and ensuring the proper and effective administration of justice.
C.R.A. 868 of 2013
77.
Let a copy of this judgment along with the Trial Court record be
sent down to the Trial Court immediately for necessary
compliance.
78.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
given to the parties on payment of requisite fees.
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review