Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
WP(C) No. 438 of 2022
1.
Tripura Board of Secondary Education, represented by its Secretary
Pandit Nehru Complex, Gurkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, Pin799006, West Tripura.
-----Petitioner(s)
-V-E-R-S-U-S-
1.
Shri Anowar Hossen, resident of ward No.1, P.O. Kama Nagar, R.D.
Block, Boxanagar, Gaon Panchayat, Anandanagar, District: Sepahijala
Tripura.
2.
Grameen Mukt Vidhyalayi Shiksha Sansthan, represented by its
Secretary, 1/11955, Ground Floor, Muskan Building, Keshav Chowk,
Panchsheel Garden, Naveen Shahdara, Delhi, Pin-110032.
3.
Council of Boards of School Education in India, represented by its
General Secretary, 6H BigJo’s Tower, A-8 Netaji Subhash Place, Ring
Road, Delhi-110034.
4.
Union of India, represented by the Secretary to the Ministry of Human
Resource Development Department of School Education and Literacy,
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi.
[***As per Hon’ble Court’s order dated 18.07.2022 passed in I.A. No.01 of 2022
National Commission for Minorities has been incorporated as respondent No.5.]
5.
National Commission for Minorities, Government of India, represented
by its Chairman 3rd Floor, Block-3, CGO Complex, New Delhi-11003.
-----Respondent(s)
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, G.A.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI.
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. B. Majumder, CGC.
Mr. K. Debnath, Advocate.
20.04.2023
:
:
27.04.2023
YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard D. Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. assisted by Mr. S. Saha,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Somik Deb,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K. Debnath, learned counsel as well
as Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI and Mr. B. Majumder, learned
CGC, appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This present writ petition has been filed under Article-226 of
the Constitution of India for setting aside the findings recorded on
20.12.2021 by the National Commission for Minorities by its
communication dated 04.01.2021.
[3]
The brief facts of the present petition is that the petitioner
TBSE is a government of Tripura recognized school education board
which is responsible for the promotion and development of secondary
education in the State. The respondent No.2 by an application dated
05.08.2017 sought admission of students passed from there institutes to be
admitted under the school affiliated recognized by the petitioner in ClassXI. The petitioner by a letter dated 29.08.2017 intimated the respondent
No.2 that the students who passed the secondary education conducted by
the respondent No.2 are eligible for admission into Class-XI in any school
affiliated to petitioner subject to pass the subjects as per NCERT syllabus
and the same has been again communicated by a letter dated 30.08.2017.
[4]
The petitioner by a memorandum dated 30.06.2018
withdrawn the aforesaid permission so communicated on 30.08.2017 and
the said memorandum has been duly notified in the local daily newspaper.
This has been further intimated that unrecognized member of respondent
No.3 may not be accepted by the Educational Institutions for further
studies. The respondent No.2 by a letter dated 20.06.2018 informed the
respondent No.1 that the association of respondent No.1 so affiliated by
the respondent No.2 automatically cancelled with immediate effect.
Thereafter, the respondent No.1 made complaint to National Commission
for Minorities who after final hearing recorded its findings on 04.01.2022
and recommended to take examination process within 30 days and
certificates be issued to the students.
[5]
Hence, the present writ petition has been filed before this
Court by the petitioner for redress.
[6]
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. assisted by Mr. S. Saha,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that the
petitioner by a letter dated 29.08.2017 intimated the respondent No.2 that
the students who passed the secondary education conducted by the
respondent No.2 are eligible for admission into Class-XI in any school
affiliated to petitioner subject to pass the subjects as per NCERT syllabus.
The same has been again communicated by a letter dated 30.08.2017. The
petitioner vide memorandum dated 30.06.2018 withdrawn the aforesaid
permission so communicated on 30.08.2017. The said memorandum has
been duly notified in the local daily newspaper. It is highlighted that the
permission accorded by the petitioner in favour of the respondent No.2
confined to the students of Tripura jurisdiction.
[7]
He has further contended that the petitioner made a
communication dated 28.10.2018 to the respondent No.4 regarding the
status of respondent No.2. In reply to that, the respondent No.4 informed
that the respondent No.2 is neither approved nor recognized by them. The
respondent No.3 by a communication dated 13.12.2018 informed that the
Boards or institutions set up by an Act of Parliament or State Legislative of
by an Executive order of the Central/State Government grants
membership. The membership of respondent No.2 is no longer available
with the office of respondent No.3.
[8]
that
Vide letter dated 09.01.2017, the respondent No.4 informed
having
membership
of
respondent
No.3
no
Boards/Council/Educational Institution become an authority for conduct of
public examination and award certificate. This has been further intimated
that unrecognized member of respondent No.3 may not be accepted by the
Educational Institutions for further studies.
[9]
The respondent No.2 by a letter dated 20.06.2018 informed
respondent No.1 that the association of respondent No.1 so affiliated by
the respondent No.2 automatically cancelled with immediate effect. The
National Commission for Minorities issued one notice on 23.08.2021 on
the complaint of respondent No.1 to the petitioner. The National
Commission for Minorities has no jurisdiction to take cognizance on a
complaint regarding permission to admit students in Class-XI to the
schools affiliated by the petitioner accepting the eligibility of pass
certificate in Secondary Examination from the respondent No.2.
[10]
The permission confined to the students irrespective of any
classification like minority or majority or any religious complaint in spite
of the fact that the respondent No.2 is no longer a recognized body either
by the Central Act or by the State Act, and therefore, the association of
respondent No.1 is also claimed to be an illegal status. No student has
come forward to make complaint to the commission or to the petitioner or
even the affiliated schools of the petitioner. On bare perusal of the record it
would show that the permission has been accorded on 30.08.2017 and
withdrawn on 30.06.2018 i.e. by 10 months no Board or a recognized
institution can hold examination of Secondary Education.
[11]
On further scrutiny of the representation dated 05.08.2017 it
would show that the respondent No.2 stated that there institution has been
fulfilled the criteria of respondent No.4 and they are recognized by SCERT
and Himachal Pradesh Board of School Education. But, such status is no
longer in existence as would be evident from letters dated 22.10.2018 and
letter dated 13.12.2018. Upon final hearing on 20.12.2021 the Commission
recorded its findings which has been communicated by a letter dated
04.01.2022. The Commission recommended to take examination process
within 30 days and certificates be issued to the students.
[12]
It has further been submitted that if a body recognized by the
law or affiliated have no legal basis to carry out the process of admission,
examination and issuing pass certificate, the acts of such body is violation
of the norms of the petitioner Board. The beneficiary of that
body/institution is supposed to be legally barred to claim any relief. The
petitioner has no knowledge about the admission of students by the
respondent No.1 herein in the mean time for Class-X & XII together.
[13]
The petitioner issued recognition to number of schools in
remote part of the State for free education of the children particularly
under Right to Education Act, 2006. The government of India Schemes
namely, Sarva Shikkya/Samagra Sikhhya is simultaneously running
throughout the State to educate children. The present complaint is
monitored by the petitioner by passing/ignoring legal and constitutional
obligations therefore; the present complaint is required to be dismissed.
[14]
Though
objection
of
jurisdiction
of
the
Minorities
Commission, New Delhi was raised on behalf of the petitioner herein, but
such was rejected in light of Section-9 of the National Commission for
Minorities Act, 1992 though requisite norms of the petitioner were not
followed by the respondent No.1. Taking cue from the note of the
Minorities Commission, New Delhi in its 4th page last paragraph wherein it
may be seen that though the fact that there were violation of norms by the
respondent No.2 herein, but failed to appreciate that the letter of petitioner
dated 29.08.2017 was much earlier than the occurrence of violation, which
came within its knowledge.
[15]
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. has further averred that the
Minorities Commission, New Delhi failed to appreciate the fact of
respondent No.2 had also cancelled its affiliation for the respondent No.1
on 20.06.2018 and also failed to appreciate the fact that the petitioner
Board on 30.06.2018 informed the respondent No.2 about the cancellation
of their affiliation based on a news article published on behalf of GMVSS
relating to guaranteed pass out of examination.
[16]
The Minorities Commission, New Delhi has also failed to
appreciate the fact that the petitioner by the communication dated
29.08.2017 gave the permission to the students to get admission in ClassXI in the schools affiliated to TBSE who passed Secondary Examination
under GMVSS, respondent No.2. After getting eligibility from the
petitioner, students take admission in the schools affiliated by TBSE and
after successful completion of the course; one may appear at Class –XII
exam conducted by TBSE. The conducting exam of Class-X by GMVSS is
not the matter of TBSE. But, in the communication dated 29.08.2017, it
was not mentioned about any kind of permission for conducting Class-XI
exam by GMVSS. Eligibility was given only for taking admission in
Class-XI in the school under TBSE.
[17]
The Minorities Commission, New Delhi failed to appreciate
the fact that MHRD vide letter dated 22.10.2018 informed the petitioner
Board that there is no such affiliated body (Respondent No.2 herein)
recognized by their department and as such institutions are contrary to the
constitutional provisions. It has also been failed to appreciate that on
13.12.2018 Council of Boards of School Education (COBSE) informed
that the respondent No.2 (GMVSS). Further, MHRD vide letter dated
09.01.2017 informed the institute of Secondary Distance Education that
certificate issued by the unrecognized member/Boards/COBSE may not be
acceptable by the educational institutions for further studies.
[18]
The balance of convenience and inconvenience lies strongly
in favo9ur of the petitioner. If a stay order on the order after the hearing
note of the Hon’ble Minorities Commission, New Delhi dated 20.12.2021
is not passed in favour of the petitioner, the petitioner will be highly
prejudiced and there would be serious complication. Ex-facie the
respondents are not eligible for affiliation from the petitioner Board
pursuant to their conduct which is evident on records.
[19]
In view of above discussion, it reveals that the respondent was
informed that students who pass the secondary examination conducted by
GMVSS are eligible for admission in Class-XI in any school affiliated to
Tripura Board of Secondary Education provided they had passed in the
subjects as per NCERT Syllabus [Annexure-2 to the writ petition]. TBSE
vide letter dated 30th June, 2018 communicated to the respondent that some
complications have arisen another organization has arrived in the scene
with same name. In addition, advertisements have been published in local
newspapers inviting applications for on demand Madhyamik Examination
of GMVSS by 17th June, 2018 with the assurance that on passing this
Madhyamik Examination of GMVSS the students would get the scope of
getting admitted in Class-XI in any school affiliated to TBSE this year
itself. In view of above, TBSE hereby withdraws the clearance it had given
earlier vide its letter dated 30th August 2017. A fresh view will be taken on
the issue after obtaining the opinion of MHRD, Govt. of India and
Education Departments of NCT, New Delhi, Himachal Pradesh and
Uttarakhand, which is not being challenged by the respondent herein.
[20]
Government of India, Ministry of Human Resource
Development Department of School Education and Literacy (School-3)
vide its letter dated 9th January, 2017 has informed regarding membership
of COBSE. For the purpose of reference, it may be quoted as under:
“F.No.14-2/2017(Sch.3)
Government of India,
Ministry of Human Resource Development
Department of School Education and Literacy
(School-3)
New Delhi dated 9th January, 2017
To,
The President,
Institute of Secondary Distance Education (ISDC)
2, Street New Market, Timarni,
Madhya Pradesh,
PIN-461228
Subject: Regarding membership of COBSE.
Sir,
I am directed to refer to your letter No. Ref. No.10100/16 dated 26.12.2016
on the subject cited above and to inform that Council of Boards of School
Education in India (COBSE) is a non-governmental organization (NGO).
Ministry of Human Resource Development has not authorized COBSE to
grant membership to the Boards/Councils/Educational Institutions. It is also
informed that by obtaining membership of COBSE, no
Boards/Council/Educational Institution become an authority for conduct of
public examination and award certificates. The certificates issued by the
unrecognized Member Boards/Council/Educational Institutions of COBSE
may not be acceptable by the Educational Institutions for further studies.
Therefore, you are advised to seek recognition from appropriate
Government for conduct of public examination and award of certificates.
This is also brought to the notice of the following organizations:1. Chairman CBSE, Delhi.
2. Chairman, NIOS, Delhi.
3. Chairman, UGC, Delhi.
4. Vice Chancellor, Delhi University, Delhi.
5. President, A.I.U. Delhi.
Yours Faithfully
Sd.
(M.P.Singh)
Under Secretary to the Govt. of India.”
[21]
Regarding cancellation of affiliation with Grameen Mukta
Vidhyalayi Shiksha Sansthan (GMVSS), in accordance with the letter
dated 21.03.2018 issued the provisional affiliation for Tripura State. It has
been observed that since this association with Grameen Mukt Vidhyalayi
Shiksha Sansthyan (GMVSS), violating the rules and regulations as
descrbied and is defacing the image of Grameen Mukt Vidhyalayi Shiksha
Sansthan (GMVSS) due to this; it was informed that the affiliation term is
automatically cancelled from immediate effect.
[22]
Needless to mention here that the respondent No.1 informed
Mr. Anwar Hussain that he is violating the rules and regulations of the
board and hence association/affiliation is automatically cancelled with
immediate effect vide its letter dated 20.06.2018. On this backdrop, it is
submitted that if a body recognized by the law or affiliated have no legal
basis to carry out the process of admission, examination and issuing pass
certificate, the acts of such body is violation of the norms of the Board.
The beneficiary of that body institution is legally barred to claim any
relief.
[23]
The statements need identification of the individual concerns
which are subject to proof by this commission and the authorized
representative for the petitioners was a coordinator of GMVSS, whose
affiliation terms were cancelled by the respondent No.1. Number of
schools in remote part of the State for free education of the children
particularly under Right to Education Act, 2006 is running. The
government of India Schemes namely Sarva Shikkya/Samagra Sikhhya is
simultaneously run throughout the State to educate children. The present
complaint is monitored by the respondent by passing legal and
constitutional obligations. The respondent No.2 by a communication dated
29.08.2017 informed respondent No.1 that the students who passed
secondary examination are eligible to get admission in Class-XI in the
schools affiliated to Tripura Board subject to the conditions that they have
passed in the five subjects according to NCERT syllabus.
[24]
In view of the above observations and submissions made by
the learned counsel, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
petitioner has made out a case for interference and accordingly, the prayer
as sought for by the petitioner in the present writ petition stands allowed.
Consequently, the impugned order of recommendation of the minorities’
stands set aside. There is no statistics provided by the respondent No.1
and the respondent No.2 has also not placed anything on record before the
minorities’ commission. There was also no documents about the students
are on record before the concerned respondents hypothetical orders are
passed by the Minority Commission. Most importantly it is under the
Society Registration Act not a minority recognition institution.
[25]
In the result, the present petitions stands allowed and thus
disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review