The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. The learned counsel for the opposite parties submitted that even the application before the ECC itself was hopelessly barred by limitation as it was filed 4 years after the incident. As per section 10 of the Act, the application has to be filed within a period of 2 years and the Commissioner has the power to entertain an application after the 2025:KER:30057 expiry of the period of 2 years only if proper reason has been shown. No justifiable or proper reason has been shown to condone the delay in filing this appeal. The ECC had proceeded on surmises and conjectures rather than on facts and legal principles. There has been no finding to the effect that the injury sustained by the deceased employee had occurred during the course of his employment. The learned counsel relying on the register regarding night duty (Kidamura register) which was maintained by the opposite parties does not reveal that the deceased was on night duty on the relevant date. The deceased was employed as a Thakil player. The death was not during the course of playing the Thakil at the temple. The factual aspects that lead to the death of the deceased as put forth do not reveal any connection whatsoever with the employment of the deceased. AW2 who was examined from the side of the applicant had during cross examination confronted with the Kidamura register and he had admitted that on the relevant day, the dece…
7. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the applicants submitted that the order of the ECC does not require any interference as it had been laid down in accordance with the law. Refuting the contention that Thakil players are not assigned night duties, especially as Kidamura, the learned counsel relying on the Kidamura register submits that there had been instances when the Thakil players were assigned night duties. Hence the purported reliance based on the register by the Devaswom is termed as unreliable. He further buttresses the said submission by pointing to the objection filed wherein there had been no denial that the deceased was not on duty on the fateful day and further submits that the objection reveals that the employer-employee relationship stands admitted. With 2025:KER:30057 respect to the contention regarding limitation, it is submitted by the learned counsel that the Act is a welfare enactment to provide compensation moving to unfortunate fatal accidents or any other accidents suffered by a workman. The provisions thereof are to be benevolently construed in favour of the workman. Reliance is placed on the dictum laid down in Ramachandran P. and another v. M. Amutha and others [2022 KHC 2674] and Leela Bai and another v. Seema Chouhan and another [(2019) 4 SCC 325]. The learned counsel further invokes the concept of notional extension relying on the dictum i…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MFA (ECC) NO.31 OF 2024
ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER DATED 30.01.2024 IN ECC NO.43
OF 2018 OF EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSIONER, IDUKKI,
PEERMADE
APPELLANTS/OPPOSITE PARTIES 1 TO 3:
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, DEVASWOM HEAD
QUARTERS, NANTHANCODE, KOWADIYAR P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695003
DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD, DEVASWOM HEAD QUARTERS,
NANTHANCODE, KOWADIYAR P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695003
ASSISTANT DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD, KOTTAYAM GROUP OFFICE,
VADAKKENADA, THIRUNAKKARA, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686001
BY ADV G.SANTHOSH KUMAR
RESPONDENTS/APPLICANTS 1 TO 3:
VALSALAKUMARY. T.S
W/O.M.G.MADHUSOODHANAN, AMBADY,
PARIYARAM, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686021
GOPIKA
D/O.M.G.MADHUSOODHANAN, AMBADY,
PARIYARAM, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686021
GOVIND
S/O.M.G.MADHUSOODHANAN, AMBADY,
PARIYARAM, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686021
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
BY ADVS.
GOPAKUMAR R.THALIYAL, R1 TO R3
R.B.BALACHANDRAN(K/411/2004), R1 TO R3
THIS
MFA
(ECC)
04.04.2025, THE COURT
FOLLOWING:
HAVING
BEEN
ON THE SAME
FINALLY
HEARD
DAY DELIVERED
ON
THE
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 04th day of April, 2025
This appeal is filed challenging the order in E.C.C.No.43 of
2018 dated 30.01.2024 on the files of the Employees Compensation
Commissioner (ECC), Idukki, Peermade. The appellants were the
opposite parties and the respondents were the applicants in the said
proceedings. Parties are hereinafter referred to as per their status
before the ECC.
2. Applicants are the wife and children of deceased M.G.
Madhusoodanan who was a Thakil player employed under the
opposite parties. He had a fall in the premises of the Puthiyakavu
Devaswom Temple on 18.10.2014. He was on night duty. He was
taken to the hospital in the early morning of 19.10.2014 with severe
pain due to a cervical spine injury. He underwent treatment and a
major surgery on 29.10.2014. However, he succumbed to death on
15.11.2014. Terming his death as arising from an accident in the
course of employment with the opposite parties, the applicants
moved the ECC seeking compensation of Rs.5,84,800/- invoking the
provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
referred to as 'the Act').
3. The ECC framed five issues and parties adduced evidence.
Exhibits A1 to A7 were marked and AW1 and AW2 were examined
by the applicants. Exts.R1 and R2 were marked and RW1 was
examined by the opposite parties. After hearing, the ECC vide order
impugned, awarded a compensation of Rs.5,84,800/- with 12%
interest and cost. The opposite parties challenge the same in this
appeal.
4. The substantial question for consideration is as follows:
“Can an employee who was not holding any duty in the
temple as of the date of the alleged incident be entitled to
Workmen's Compensation and whether such incident can be
termed as one caused during the course of employment?”
5. Heard Sri.Santhosh Kumar G., Advocate for the appellants/
opposite parties and Sri.Gopakumar R.Thaliyal for the respondents/
applicants.
6. The learned counsel for the opposite parties submitted that
even the application before the ECC itself was hopelessly barred by
limitation as it was filed 4 years after the incident. As per section 10 of
the Act, the application has to be filed within a period of 2 years and
the Commissioner has the power to entertain an application after the
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
expiry of the period of 2 years only if proper reason has been shown.
No justifiable or proper reason has been shown to condone the delay
in filing this appeal. The ECC had proceeded on surmises and
conjectures rather than on facts and legal principles. There has been
no finding to the effect that the injury sustained by the deceased
employee had occurred during the course of his employment. The
learned counsel relying on the register regarding night duty
(Kidamura register) which was maintained by the opposite parties
does not reveal that the deceased was on night duty on the relevant
date. The deceased was employed as a Thakil player. The death was
not during the course of playing the Thakil at the temple. The factual
aspects that lead to the death of the deceased as put forth do not
reveal any connection whatsoever with the employment of the
deceased. AW2 who was examined from the side of the applicant
had during cross examination confronted with the Kidamura register
and he had admitted that on the relevant day, the deceased
employee was not on duty. This crucial evidence was ignored by the
ECC. There was no night duty as alleged and night duty was
assigned only in cases of urgency. Persons employed as the Thakil
players are not assigned night duties, especially as Kidamura. There
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
were no eyewitnesses to the alleged incident and yet the ECC held
that the deceased employee had met with the accident while on duty.
There was no direct evidence before the ECC to come to such a
conclusion. The ECC should have relied on Exts.R1 and R2
Kidamura register which clearly proves the fact that on 18.10.2014
the deceased employee was not holding any duty in the temple. The
injury and the death were not arising out of or in the course of
employment. There must be a causal relationship between the
accident and the employment. The expression arising out of
employment is not confined to the mere nature of the employment.
The expression applies to employment as such to its nature, its
conditions, its obligations and its incidents. Only if the accident had
occurred on account of a risk which is an incident of employment,
would the claim for compensation succeed. Reliance is placed on the
dictum laid down in
Sunder Pal v. Sunder [2021 KHC 4058].
Accident, ordinarily will have to be understood as uncomprehended
or as one which could not be foreseen. A finding of fact has to be
arrived at inter alia having regard to the nature of the work and the
situation in which the deceased was placed. There is a crucial link
between the casual connections of employment with death. Such a
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
link with evidence cannot be a matter of surmise or conjuncture.
Reliance is placed in this respect on the dictum laid down in United
India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Devkumari and others [2020 KHC
2929]. As laid down by the Supreme Court in Jyothi Ademma v.
Plant Engineer, Nellore and another [(2006) 5 SCC 513] there has
to be some causal connection between the death of the workman and
his employment.
If the workman dies as a natural result of the
disease which he was suffering or while suffering from a particular
disease, he dies of that disease as a result of wear and tear of the
employment, no liability would be fixed upon the employer. Reliance
is placed in this respect on the dictum laid down by the Supreme
Court in Mackinnon Mackenzie and Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. Ibrahim
Mahommad Issak [1969 KHC 558]. The ECC had rendered the
impugned order finding that the employee had suffered a heart attack
in the course of the employment. Only because the cause of death
was due to a heart attack does not by itself be a ground to arrive at a
conclusion that an accident had occurred resulting in injury. Reliance
is placed in this respect on the dictum laid down by the Supreme
Court in Shakuntala v. Prabhakar [2006 KHC 1813] This Court had
held in Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shahina
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
and Ors. [2017 (5) KHC 407] that the expression arising out of
employment means that there must be a causal relationship between
the accident and the employment. If the accident had occurred on
account of the risk which is an incident of employment, only then can
it be held that the accident has arisen out of the employment and in
the course of employment. The said requirement has not been met in
the facts of the case at hand. The learned counsel for the Devaswom
thus vehemently sought to set aside the impugned order.
7. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the applicants
submitted that the order of the ECC does not require any interference
as it had been laid down in accordance with the law. Refuting the
contention that Thakil players are not assigned night duties,
especially as Kidamura, the learned counsel relying on the Kidamura
register submits that there had been instances when the Thakil
players were assigned night duties. Hence the purported reliance
based on the register by the Devaswom is termed as unreliable. He
further buttresses the said submission by pointing to the objection
filed wherein there had been no denial that the deceased was not on
duty on the fateful day and further submits that the objection reveals
that the employer-employee relationship stands admitted. With
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
respect to the contention regarding limitation, it is submitted by the
learned counsel that the Act is a welfare enactment to provide
compensation moving to unfortunate fatal accidents or any other
accidents suffered by a workman. The provisions thereof are to be
benevolently construed in favour of the workman. Reliance is placed
on the dictum laid down in Ramachandran P. and another v. M.
Amutha and others [2022 KHC 2674] and Leela Bai and another v.
Seema Chouhan and another [(2019) 4 SCC 325]. The learned
counsel further invokes the concept of notional extension relying on
the dictum in Daya Kishan Joshi and another v. Dynemech
Systems Pvt. Ltd. [2017 KHC 5071] and submits that the incident
that occurred within the premises of the temple that too in the building
assigned to the employees to take rest can only be deemed as the
accident that had taken place in the course of employment. That an
appeal under the Act is not an open appeal and this court would not
proceed to re-examine the factual aspects arrived at by the ECC is
conveyed by relying on the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in
Fulmati Dhramdev Yadav v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. [2023
KHC 6818]. It is thus submitted by the learned counsel that no
substantial question of law is revealed and that the appeal is only to
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
be dismissed.
8. I have heard both sides in detail and have considered the
contentions put forth. It is trite law as laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in C. Manjamma and another v. Divisional
Manager, New India Assurance Company Ltd. [(2022) 6 SCC 206]
that an appeal is maintainable before this Court from an order of the
ECC only if a substantial question of law arise from the same. This
Court can interfere with the findings of the ECC only if the findings
are perverse or suffer from any manifest illegality to give rise to a
substantial question of law. As regards the contentions based on
limitation, I note that as per section 10 of the Act, the ECC has the
power to entertain the claim application after expiry of the stipulated
period of 2 years if sufficient cause is shown. Once the said power
has been exercised by the ECC in accordance with law and without
any perversity there cannot be an interference on the same at the
appellate state. [See Lila Bai v. Mehrban Singh (2021 KHC 2935)].
It is the specific contention of the appellants/opposite parties that
there was no evidence to attribute the death to the injury allegedly
suffered while the deceased was in the temple premises. I note this
essentially is a question of fact that falls within the sphere of the ECC
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
to appreciate and arrive at based on the evidence tendered. Once the
said appreciation has been carried out by the Commissioner and a
decision arrived at on that factual aspect, the scope for interfering
with the same by this Court in an appeal is extremely limited. The
question whether the employee was holding any duty in the temple as
of the date of the alleged incident or not is a factual question which
already stands answered by the ECC in favour of the employee. This
Court cannot then sit in appeal over the same. Once the said
question has been answered by the ECC in favour of the employee
and it has thus become final, the ancillary question as to whether the
incident could be termed as one caused during the course of
employment also stands answered. Nothing has been revealed to
lead me to conclude that the order impugned suffers from perversity.
In view of the above, the substantial question of law framed stands
answered in favour of the respondents/applicants and against the
appellants/opposite parties.
The MFA (ECC) is dismissed. No costs. The interim stay
granted is vacated. All interlocutory applications are closed.
Sd/-
SYAM KUMAR V.M.
JUDGE
csl
MFA (ECC) NO.31/2024
2025:KER:30057
APPENDIX OF MFA (ECC) 31/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure-A1
True copy of the receipt dated 25/05/2024
showing the deposit of Rs.12,58,880/- before
the Employees Compensation Commissioner and
Industrial Tribunal, Idukki .
Annexure
COPY APPLICATION
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review