The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. The injunction application was taken up for hearing on 5th July, 2024 and in this detailed order passed by the learned Trial Court, whereby the contention of both the parties were taken into account, the learned Trial Court passed an injunction order only in respect of creating third party interest. No order was passed relating to the construction in the premises in question. The order dated 8th March, automatically comes to an end, when the injunction application was disposed of by the learned Trial Court. The order of the learned Trial Court passed subsequently on application under Section 151 CPC on 26th September, 2024 filed by the plaintiff / opposite party is without any basis as the order dated 8th March, 2022 had merged with the order dated 5th July, 2024. Similarly the impugned order dated 7th October, 2024 has also not taken this point into consideration and has been passed mechanically and thus liable to be set aside. It is also pertinent to mention here that even in the order dated 7th December, 2024 whereby application under Order 39 Rule (4) was decided there was no discussion as to the modification of the order regarding the construction.
10. The Court, therefore, considers that the order dated 26th September, 2024 and 7th October, 2024 are liable to be set aside. The injunction application has been decided by the learned Trial Court vide order dated 5th July, 2024. However, this will not preclude the opposite party / plaintiff from filing a fresh application for injunction before the learned Trial Court.
11. In view of the discussions made hereinabove, the present petition stands disposed of. Connected pending application, if any, stands disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
23.06.2026
Court No.2
Item No.65
sudipta
CO 4055 of 2024
With
CAN 1 of 2025
Transparency Builders Private Limited & Anr.
Vs.
Sekhar Roy & Anr.
Mr. Tarique Quasimuddin
Mr. Abbas Ibrahim Khan
…for the petitioners
Mr. Prabhat Kumar Singh
Mr. Dipankar Mondal
Mr. Prashant Kumar Singh
…for the opposite parties
1.
Present petition has been filed challenging the
order dated 7th October, 2024 passed by the Learned
Judge, Bench-VI, City Civil Court, Calcutta in Title Suit
No. 518 of 2022 whereby the application filed by the
petitioner / defendant under Section 151 CPC was
dismissed. The petitioner aggrieved of this has invoked
the jurisdiction of this Court.
2.
Briefly stated the facts are that the opposite party
/ petitioner filed Title Suit No. 518 of 2022 for
declaration of permanent injunction along with an
application for injunction.
The suit was taken up for
hearing on 8th March, 2022.
following order was passed.
On 8th March, 2022
“Order No.2
Date:08.03.2022
Hazira has been filed today on behalf of the Plaintiff.
Defendants / Caveators appears today being represented
by their Ld. Advocate.
The prayer for ad interim relief of injunction has been
moved today on behalf of the plaintiff and with this
contention that there is extreme urgency in this matter,
because of negotiation as being taken up by the
defendants to create third party interest in respect of the
suit property.
Ld. Advocate appears on behalf of the defendants has
submitted that, he needs some time to file written
objection against the application for injunction as filed by
the Plaintiff. However, he has disputed regarding
contention of the plaintiff, initiatives on the part of the
defendants for creating third party interest out of the suit
property and for carrying on construction violating the
notice of municipal authority and he has further
contended that on behalf of the defendant, he has given
the undertaking as being instructed by his client being
present in the Court that they will not proceed with the
construction work or any negotiation for creating any
third party interest in respect of the suit property till
disposal of this application.
He has further submitted that in view of the undertaking
as it is given today on behalf of the defendant, matter
may be fixed as an early date for the convenience of both
sides.
Considering the submissions of the Ld. Advocates
appearing on behalf of the respective sides, it is a view of
this Court that, without giving opportunity to the
defendants, caveator to file the written objection against
the injunction application as filed by the plaintiff, hearing
of injunction cannot be taken place. In view of that, they
will be given reasonable opportunity and time to file
written objection as they prayed for today.
However, in the light of undertaking as given before this
Court today on behalf of the defendant, the defendants
are directed to abide by their own unde3rtaking as given
before this Court through their Ld. Counsel.
Prayer for granting time to file written objection is
allowed.
Written objection be filed in the meantime.”
3.
Subsequently, the application for injunction was
taken up for hearing on 5th July, 2024.
The learned
Trial Court vide order no. 42 dated 5th July, 2024 vide a
detailed order restrained the defendant / petitioner from
selling, transferring, conveying, encumbering or parting
with the possession of premises no. 3, Tottle Lane,
Kolkata 700016 till disposal of the suit.
4.
While the matter rested thus, the plaintiff /
opposite party filed an application under Section 151
CPC seeking a direction to the Officer-in-Charge, New
Market P.S. as well as Commissioner of Police, Kolkata
to ensure that order dated 8th March, 2022 and 5th July,
2024 are strictly complied.
Learned Trial Court vide
order dated 26th September, 2024 passed the following
order.
“Order No. 47, date4d 26.09.2024
Today the record is put up as per prayer of the Plaintiff,
who files one application u/s. 151 of C.P.C. praying for
an order directing the Officer-In-Charge, New Market
P.S.. as well as Commissioner of Police, Kolkata to see
that the order passed by this Court dated 08.03.2022
and 05.07.2025 are strictly implemented and complied
with against the Defendants and to ensure that no
violation is committed to those orders by the Defendant.
Copy of the same is received by the Defendant.
The Plaintiff also files one application under Order 26
Rule 9 read with section 151 of the C.P.C. Copy served
upon the Defendant, which is received with objection.
On behalf of the Defendants, two sets of application for
adjournment is seeking for hearing of the petition filed by
the Plaintiffs. Copy is not served.
Heard Ld. Advocate for the Plaintiff and also the
Defendant.
The Ld. Advocate for the Defendant stated that an
objection is required to be filed against the application
fled u/s. 151 of C.P.C. by the Plaintiff.
Ld. Advocate for the Plaintiff stated that whatever prayer
they have made is very pertinent as it is the duty of both
the parties to the suit to abide by the direction of this
Court. As the Plaintiff stated that due to wrongful act, the
order passed by this Court has been violated for which a
supervision is required by the local P.S. as to whether the
order passed by this Court has been strictly complied
with or not.
Without prejudice the interest of the parties, I think it is
the duty of the Court to preserve the order passed by it in
proper manner and in that occasion, if either party to the
suit is violating the same that should be stopped with the
intervention of the police. Whatever allegation given by
the Plaintiff in this case coupled with the order passed by
this Court, I think the prayer made by the Plaintiff is
modest and for the interest of justice, the same should be
allowed without prejudicing the interest of the Defendant.
Accordingly, the O.C., New Market P.S. is directed to see
that the order passed by this Court on 08.03.2022 and
05.07.2024 has been properly maintained by both the
sides, or not and to report this Court by the date fixed.
Let this order along with the copies of order dated
08.03.2022 and 05.07.2024 be communicated to the
O.C., New Market P.S. for information and taking
necessary action and report this Court by 13.01.2025.
To 13.01.2025 for submission of report and for hearing of
the petition under 1 Rule 10(2) of C.P.C. read with
section 151 of C.P.C. and also the petition under Order
39 Rule 4 of C.P.C. and also hearing of acceptance of
W/S. W/O in the meantime.”
5.
The
defendant
/
petitioner
herein
filed
an
application under Section 151 CPC, inter alia, stating
that in absence of any restrain order of the learned Trial
Court regarding the construction and in view of the fact
that revised sanctioned plan has been issued by the
Kolkata Municipal Authority, police has no authority to
stop the construction. This application was dismissed
by the impugned order dated 7th October, 2024 which is
the subject matter of the present petition. In the
meanwhile, an application under Order 39 Rule 4 filed
by the defendant / petitioner for modification of order
was dismissed by the learned Trial Court vide order
dated 7th December, 2024.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that in the order dated 5th July, 2024, vide which the
injunction application was decided, there was no
injunction regarding the construction in the premises in
question and, therefore, the learned Trial Court fell into
an error by issuing the direction to the police vide order
dated 26th September, 2024 and further by dismissing
the application under Section 151 CPC vide order dated
7th October, 2024.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel for the opposite party /
plaintiff submitted that as there was a clear undertaking
given by the defendant / petitioner on 8th March, 2022,
that they will not proceed with the construction work,
they are estopped from carrying out any construction.
It was submitted that the defendant / petitioner has no
authority
to
carry
out
the
construction
activities
whether any revised sanctioned plan has been approved
by the KMC or not. Learned counsel submits that if the
construction activity is carried out, it will irreparably
prejudice the opposite party / petitioner.
8.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties
and perused the record carefully. The order dated 8th
March, 2022 as has been reproduced above was passed
by the learned Trial Court at the initial stage when there
was a prayer for ad interim injunction.
This was
possibly the first date of hearing when even the written
statement was not filed. It is also pertinent to mention
that the learned Trial Court had merely recorded the
undertaking of the petitioner / defendant and issued a
direction to abide by their undertaking given before the
Court.
9.
The injunction application was taken up for
hearing on 5th July, 2024 and in this detailed order
passed by the learned Trial
Court,
whereby the
contention of both the parties were taken into account,
the learned Trial Court passed an injunction order only
in respect of creating third party interest. No order was
passed relating to the construction in the premises in
question.
The
order
dated
8th
March,
automatically comes to an end, when the injunction
application was disposed of by the learned Trial Court.
The
order
of
the
learned
Trial
Court
passed
subsequently on application under Section 151 CPC on
26th September, 2024 filed by the plaintiff / opposite
party is without any basis as the order dated 8th March,
2022 had merged with the order dated 5th July, 2024.
Similarly the impugned order dated 7th October, 2024
has also not taken this point into consideration and has
been passed mechanically and thus liable to be set
aside. It is also pertinent to mention here that even in
the order dated 7th December, 2024 whereby application
under Order 39 Rule (4) was decided there was no
discussion as to the modification of the order regarding
the construction.
10. The Court, therefore, considers that the order
dated 26th September, 2024 and 7th October, 2024 are
liable to be set aside.
The injunction application has
been decided by the learned Trial Court vide order dated
5th July, 2024.
However, this will not preclude the
opposite party / plaintiff from filing a fresh application
for injunction before the learned Trial Court.
11. In view of the discussions made hereinabove, the
present petition stands disposed of. Connected pending
application, if any, stands disposed of.
12. It is made clear that the learned Trial Court shall
decide
the
matter
independently
without
being
influenced by the order of this Court.
13.
All parties shall act on the basis of the server copy
of this order duly downloaded from the official website of
this Court.
(Dinesh Kumar Sharma, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review