Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
DATED : 17th AUGUST, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRP No.05 of 2016
:
Petitioner
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia,
S/o Late Nim Tenzing Bhutia,
R/o Yangyang,
Rangang,
South Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia,
S/o Late Nim Tenzing Bhutia,
R/o Jorethang Road
Yangyang,
Rangang,
South Sikkim.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Ms. Aruna Chettri,
Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. B. N. Sharma, Advocate
for the Respondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India, filed by the Petitioner, impugns the Order dated 20-07-2016,
passed by the Learned Civil Judge (South), South Sikkim, at
Namchi, in Title Suit Case No.09 of 2014, whereby the Learned Trial
Court rejected the prayer of the Petitioner herein, to validate the
document dated 21-12-2001, Exhibit ‗A‘, in terms of the Notification
No.2947 G, dated 22-11-1946.
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
2.
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
Assailing the said Order, Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioner expostulates that, the said Order suffers from irregularity
and illegality as the Learned Trial Court has taken recourse to the
provisions of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (for short ―TPA‖), to
reject the Petition for validation, when the TPA had not been
enforced in the State of Sikkim at the time of publication of the
Notification of 1946. In this situation, the requirements and
intricacies of various provisions of the TPA and particularly Sections
122 and 123 of the TPA, relating to gift are not a requirement for
application of Notification No.385/G, dated 11-04-1928 (hereinafter
‗Notification of 1928‘) of which Para 2 has been amended by
Notification No.2947 G, dated 22-11-1946 (hereinafter ‗Notification
of 1946‘), promulgated by the
Maharaja of
Sikkim.
That,
Notification of 1946 clearly provides that, an unregistered document
(which ought in the opinion of the Court to have been registered)
may, however, be validated and admitted in Court to prove title or
other matters contained in the document, on payment of penalty up
to fifty times the usual registration fee. That, on the face of the said
provision, the validation of Exhibit ‗A‘ ought to have been allowed.
It is his further contention that after validation the document may
be admitted in Court to prove the title or other matters contained in
the document, as laid down in Notification of 1946.
That, at this
stage, the Court cannot look into the contents of the document
or the merits of the case, but has only to allow the document
to be validated. Taking this Court through the Judgment in
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
Kul Bahadur Gurung and Others vs. Gajendra Gurung and Others1, it was
urged that the Judgment lays down that any unregistered document
cannot be excluded from the purview of the Notification of 1946 on
the ground that it does not answer the description of sale deed, and
includes
every
unregistered
document
effecting
immovable
property, thereby covering the instant case.
3.
It was vehemently canvassed that the Notification of
1946 does not refer to any particular document, such as, gift or
sale, but merely addresses an unregistered document, to prove title
or other matters contained in the document. The option thereafter
lies with the party who seeks validation of the document to get the
same legally admitted in evidence, however, such validation does
not change the value, nature and character of the document. The
Learned Trial Court is empowered to give findings on the validity
and admissibility of the document while deciding the case finally on
merits. Hence, the impugned Order be set aside and the document
be allowed to be validated and admitted in evidence, in terms of the
Notification of 1946.
4.
The vociferous contra contention raised by Learned
Senior Counsel for the Respondent is that, the document relied on
by the Petitioner would reveal that the land in question infact
belonged to his mother, one Lakik Bhutia, but Exhibit ‗A‘ was signed
by the father, who gifted away the property. He is not competent to
sign the document or gift the property as he is not the owner of the
AIR 2007 Sikkim 23
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
property in question. Secondly, Exhibit ‗A‘ is only a declaration and
not a deed, thus, the prayer seeking its validation is not tenable. In
the third leg of his argument it was expostulated that the document
does not comply with the provisions of Sections 122 and 123 of the
TPA, the document having been executed on 21-12-2001, after the
extension and enforcement of the TPA to the State of Sikkim on 0109-1984. It was also further urged that the Respondent denies the
signature appearing on the document as that of his father and
should the document be allowed validation, it will tantamount to
validation of the contested signature, thereby giving the Petitioner a
handle to put forth the claim that contested signatures appearing on
other documents, relied on by him are genuine, hence, the Petition
being without merit deserves no consideration and ought to be
dismissed.
5.
I have heard Learned Counsel for the parties at length
and given due consideration to their submissions.
I have also
perused the records of the case, the contested document as also the
impugned Order of the Learned Trial Court, the Notification of 1928
and of 1946 and the relevant provisions of Law.
6.
A glimpse of the facts in dispute are necessary for
appreciation of the matter at hand.
The Petitioner herein is the
Defendant, while the Respondent herein is the Plaintiff, before the
Learned Trial Court (hereinafter ‗Plaintiff‘ and ‗Defendant‘).
The
Plaintiff and the Defendant are blood brothers, the Defendant being
the Plaintiff‘s elder brother. The Plaintiff laid claim to the suit land
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
alleging that his mother, Lakik Bhutia, had verbally gifted him the
property in the year 1980.
Lakik Bhutia passed away in the year
2008. The Plaintiff claims possession of the suit land since 1980, to
the exclusion of his other siblings.
After his mother‘s demise, he
approached the Office of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Ravangla,
South Sikkim, for mutation of the suit property in his name. This
was objected to by the Defendant, inter alia, on the ground that,
vide a document dated 21-12-2001 (marked as Exhibit ‗A‘),
executed by his father, Late Nim Tenzing Bhutia, allegedly in the
presence of the Defendant and his brothers, the suit property was
infact gifted to him. It is this document, Exhibit ‗A‘, dated 21-122001, that the Defendant seeks to validate on the basis of the
aforesaid Notification.
7.
It needs
no
deep rumination
to
assess that the
Notifications of 1928 and 1946 relied on by Learned Senior Counsel
for the Petitioner and Sections 122 and 123 of the TPA pertain to
completely different matters. In order to examine the matter in its
correct perspective, it is apposite to consider the provisions of
Section 122 of the TPA, which defines ‗gift‘ and reads as follows;
“122. “Gift” defined.—―Gift‖ is the transfer of
certain existing moveable or immoveable property
made voluntarily and without consideration, by one
person, called the donor, to another, called the donee,
and accepted by or on behalf of the donee.
Acceptance when to be made.—Such acceptance
must be made during the lifetime of the donor and
while he is still capable of giving.
If the donee dies before acceptance, the gift is
void.”
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
8.
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
On the heels of Section 122 of the TPA is Section 123 of
the TPA, which delineates how transfer of the gift is to be effected
and provides the following;
“123. Transfer how effected.—For the purpose
of making a gift of immovable property, the transfer
must be effected by a registered instrument signed by
or on behalf of the donor, and attested by at least two
witnesses.
For the purpose of making a gift of movable
property, the transfer may be effected either by a
registered instrument signed as aforesaid or by
delivery.
Such delivery may be made in the same way as
goods sold may be delivered.”
9.
On the other hand, Notifications of 1928 and 1946 deal
with registration of documents and read as follows;
NOTIFICATION OF 1928
“SIKKIM STATE
GENERAL DEPARTMENT
Notification No. 385/G;
All Kazis, Thikadars and Managers of Estates.
In continuation of the previous rules on
the subject, His Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim is
pleased to order that the Law of Registration applicable
in the State shall be amended. Notification No. 314 and
2283-36/G., dated the 23rd January, 1907 and 19th
July, 1922, respectively shall be read and applied as
under :―Any document such as mortgage and sale
deeds and other important documents and deeds, etc.
will not be considered valid unless they are duly
registered.
The contents of an unregistered document
(which ought in the opinion of the court to have been
registered) may be provided in court but a penalty
upto fifty times the usual registration fee shall be
charged.
Exception :- Handnotes duly stamped
shall be exempt from registration penalty‖.
BY ORDER OF HIS HIGHNESS THE MAHARAJA OF
SIKKIM
Gangtok
The 11th April, 1928
Gyaltsen Kazi
General Secretary to
H.H. the Maharaja of Sikkim.”
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
NOTIFICATION OF 1946
“SIKKIM STATE
GENERAL DEPARTMENT
Notification No: 2947 G.
Amendment of para 2 of Notification No: 385/G
dated the 11th April, 1928.
An unregistered document (which ought in
the opinion of the court to have been registered) may
however be validated and admitted in court to prove
title or other matters contained in the document on
payment of a penalty upto fifty times the usual
registration fee.
Issued by order of H.H. the Maharaja of Sikkim.
Gangtok
The 22nd Nov., 46
T. Tsering
(Offs) General Secretary to
H.H. The Maharaja of Sikkim.
……………………………………………………………………..”
Thus, the Notification of 1946 is relevant for the present
purpose.
10.
On perusal of the above Laws, it transpires that Section
122 of the TPA pertains to how a gift deed is to be executed, Section
123 of the TPA explains how the gift of Immovable property must be
effected,
while
the
Notification
of
lays
down
how
an
unregistered document can be validated. The purposes of the above
Sections and the Notification are specific and the question of the
Notification of 1946 being promulgated by the Maharaja of Sikkim
and, therefore, inapplicable to the instant situation is a mis-placed
argument of Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner.
True, the
Notification is one of 1946 and, therefore, protected under the
provisions of Article 371F(k) of the Constitution of India, which
commences with a non obstante clause; but this is not the contest
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
at hand, which pivots around the contention as to whether Exhibit
‗A‘ ought to be validated.
The Notification of 1946 allows an
unregistered document, which the Court is of the opinion ought to
have been registered, to be validated on payment of penalty up to
fifty times the usual registration fee and the contents thereof to be
admitted in Court, to prove title or other matters, borne in the
document. This being the situation, I am of the considered opinion
that the document sought to be validated, being bereft only of
registration, ought in substance, to be compliant of the provisions of
Section 122 and Section 123 of the TPA, the said Act having been
extended and enforced in the State of Sikkim on 01-09-1984, prior
to Exhibit ‗A‘, which was executed on 21-12-2001.
This Court is
conscious that a document need not adhere to a specific format, in
other words, substance and not the form of a document is relevant,
but a glance at Exhibit ‗A‘ clearly indicates that it does not conform
to the legal mandate.
Consequently, the Court cannot perpetuate
any irregularity or for that matter illegality, sans compliance of
provisions of Law.
It goes without saying that the provisions of
Sections 122 and 123 of the TPA go hand in hand with Notification
of 1946 and are not at cross purposes.
Validation of a document
after 1984 can be allowed in terms of the Notification of 1946, if the
requirements of Sections 122 of the TPA are fulfilled, but that of
Section 123 of the TPA remains incomplete, on account of nonregistration of the document. Although it was contended that this
Court in Kul Bahadur Gurung1 had held as follows;
“23. ……………………. This goes to show that the
expression 'unregistered documents' is wide enough to
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
include every unregistered document effecting
immovable property. Therefore, the plain language
employed in the Notification makes it amply clear that
an unregistered document cannot be excluded from
the purview of the Notification on the ground that it
does not answer the description of sale deed, as
contended by the learned Counsel for the
Respondents. Therefore, this contention raised by the
learned counsel for the respondent also deserves to be
rejected.”
11.
But, it is evident from the Judgment supra that the
document in question therein had been validly executed. In other
words, the document had in substance complied with the provisions
of Law, although not in form and had remained unregistered due to
the death of the seller soon after execution of the sale deed in the
year 1968.
The case at hand is undoubtedly distinguishable from
the afore cited ratio, lacking, as already stated, in the necessary
requisites of Section 122 and Section 123 of the TPA. Besides the
authenticity of the signature alleged to be of the Defendant‘s father
is contested by the Plaintiff.
12.
The consequence of validation of the unregistered
document as per the Notification of 1946 is that, the document is to
be admitted in Court to prove title or other matters contained in the
document.
This points to the inevitable conclusion that the
document ought to have been correctly executed under relevant
provisions of Law, which consequently allows its admission as
evidence, subsequent to the validation.
‗Valid‘ as per Bryan A.
Garner Black‘s Law Dictionary, Eighth Edition, 2nd Reprint – 2007,
means ―legally sufficient or binding‖.
By ordering validation of
Exhibit ‗A‘, this Court would be implying that the document is legally
CRP No.05 of 2016
Mr. Topden Pintso Bhutia
vs. Mr. Sonam Plazor Bhutia
sufficient and binding which is not the correct position herein as the
document falls short of the legal requirements. That apart, no Court
has opined that the document ought to be registered, which is a
prerequisite under the Notification of 1946. Thus, it
is
not
every
document that has not been registered which can be validated by
the Order of the Court, but only those documents which bear
compliance to the legal provisions.
13.
In the said circumstances, I find that the impugned
Order of the Learned Trial Court brooks no interference.
14.
Consequently, the Petition stands dismissed.
15.
The Learned Trial Court shall proceed in the matter as
per Law, without being prejudiced by the findings herein, which are
not to be construed as a decision on the merits of the Suit, confined
as it is to one document.
16.
Records of the Learned Trial Court be remitted forthwith
along with a copy of this Order.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
17-08-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review