Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
03.9.2026
Sl.13
Ct.No.-34
sg
WPA 28522 of 2025
Timir Ranjan Das
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Gangadhar Das
Mr. Tanmoy Chattopadhyay
…for the petitioner.
Mr. Dibashish Basu
Ms. Sneha Dutta
Mr. Chandrachur Lahiri
Ms. Puja Mondal
…for the State.
1.
The present
writ petition has been filed
challenging a notification dated January 29, 2025
along with Memo No. 179/SCH -25 dated February
27,2025
as
well
as
order
issued
vide
Memo
no.229/SCH dated March12,2025 and the reasoned
order dated December 1,2025 coupled with the order
issued vide Memo no.324 /SCH -25 dated April
08,2025 issued by the
Directorate of Child Rights &
Trafficking, Shaishali Building, 3rd Floor, Salt
Lake City,Sector-1, Kol-64 being respondent no.2
dated January 29th, 2025 re-fixing the salary at a
reduced rate and thereby sought to deduct the alleged
overdraw of the petitioner .
2.
The factual matrix unveils that the petitioner
had served for long 30 years of continuous service as
a teacher at Suryodaya Children Home for Deaf and
Dumb Boys and Girls under respondent no.7 Raiganj,
within District Uttar Dinajpur since June 13, 1994
against a sanctioned post but on casual basis and his
status was recognized by the respondent authorities
and had allowed protection of tenure of service and
financial entitlements on several occasions.
3.
The Department of Finance Government of
West Bengal issued
of Memo No .9008-F(P) dated
September 16,2011 of the Finance Department ,Audit
Branch extending benefits as provided therein to
certain
categories
engaged
on
casual
of
employees
basis in
including
those
various government
establishment upon fulfilling certain conditions. The
petitioner was extended with the benefits vide order
dated December 12, 2012 and March19, 2013 with
effect from August 1, 2011. On May 20, 2013 the
Government enhanced the remuneration in terms as
provided in Memo no.9008-F(p) dated September
2016 and that too was extended to this petitioner .
The remuneration of the petitioner further revised vide
order dated September 6, 2013 and subsequently on
several occasion in accordance with the memorandum
published from the Ministry of child and welfare
Department.
4.
It is the further case of the writ petitioner
that Respondent 7 in the year 2017 sought for a
clarification
from
Respondent
no.2
regarding
enhancement of the remuneration on the basis of
completion of 22 years of service as on 2017 .The
petitioner
was
remuneration
further
with
extended
effect
from
enhancement
March
of
and
thereafter 2019.
5.
On August 9, 2019 post facto approval
granted to the enhancement of pay of the petitioner.
Thereafter suddenly the petitioner was served with a
letter by Respondent no.7 whereby relying on the
letter dated January 29,2015 of Respondent no 2
informed that his total overdrawn amount is Rs
12,57,169 after preparing re-fixation during the period
from August 2011 to January 31 ,2025 and directed to
refund the said amount .
6.
Due
to
such
notice
the
salary
petitioner got substantially got reduced
of
the
from earlier
order of fixation issued by the higher authorities and
further directed the petitioner to refund an amount of
Rs 12,57,169/- said to have been overdrawn by the
petitioner and to return it within 18 months in equal
monthly installments .
7.
The petitioner gave a representation before
the respondent no.7 about the incorrect fixation and
arbitrary reduction of the salary and demanding
illegally, the overdrawn amount, on March 22, 2025.
8.
The writ petitioner had to file a writ petition
since no response was received from the concerned
Authority, being WPA 17771 OF 2025 and by an order
dated August 28, 2015
the learned co-ordinate
Bench after hearing all the parties directed respondent
no.2 to hear out the grievance of the petitioner and to
decide his claim in the light of the case made out in
the writ petition.
9.
Pursuant to such direction
the concerned
Department the Respondent no.2 passed an order on
December 1,2025 where it was held that the previous
fixation allowing
of
Finance
consolidated remuneration in terms
Department
Memo
No.
–(F)(P)
1.3.2024,
erroneously took into account
the period
prior to 1.8.2011.
10.
Learned advocate appearing on behalf of the
petitioner strenuously argued since after his joining as
a casual teacher he was given benefit on various
occasion in terms of the office memo passed
from
time to time and his salary was increased to
Rs.
24,500/- by virtue of an order dated 22nd February,
2019.
In the year 2012 from the Department of
Women & Child Development and Social Welfare
benefit
was
allowed
with
respect
of
daily
rated/casual/contractor workers engaged before 1. 10.
2010 against the sanctioned post and list of those
employees as annexed with the writ petition and
Commissioner of Social Welfare Benefit was further
directed to follow rules and regulation as laid down as
fixed Finance Department Memo No. Memo No. 9008(F) (P), dated 16.9.2011 in respect of providing
benefits to the workers. Therefore the entire action on
the part of the respondent no.2 and the interpretation
made is in stark contrast to the Finance Department
Memo
no.9008-F(P)
dated
16.8.2011.The
order
passed by the Respondent no.2 is devoid of any
reason of deciding the date of engagement when
throughout he was given such benefit.
11.
Learned Counsel representing the State, on
the other hand seeks to justify the impugned action on
the basis of the admission of the petitioner before the
respondent.no.2 at the time of hearing and it is
submitted that previously an incorrect fixation was
made erroneously as would be reflected from the
reasoned
order
dated
1st
December,
and
therefore, date of engagement ought to have been
reckoned in terms of such order that is with effect
from 1.8.2011. It is further argued that the petitioner
himself submitted before the authority at the time of
hearing he joined in the institution as outsourced
voluntary worker which has been clarified that purely
on honorary /voluntary basis and he only received
honorarium during that period and not engaged under
any regular or sanctioned post. The petitioner must
not get the benefit of an erroneous calculation when it
is very much apparent.
12.
Heard and considered the rival contention of
both the learned advocates and perused the materials
on record. The short question arises for consideration
is whether the employees similarly situated can be
subjected to unequal pay fixation merely because their
appointment
or
joining
dates
were
recorded
on
different dates. It is not in dispute that the present
petitioner joined as a casual teacher at the Suryodaya
Children Home for Deaf and Dumb Boys and Girls,
Raiganj. It is also not dispute that subsequent thereto
during continuation of service on various occasion he
was given the benefit from time to time in accordance
with the direction passed by the Government of West
Bengal, Department of Women & Child Development
and Social Welfare and his salary was enhanced .The
respondents have permitted the petitioner to receive
salary and increment on the existing basis for a
substantial period.
13.
In addition to the same vide an order dated
28th December, 2012 under Memo no.8122-SW/3E50/2009 the Joint Secretary of Government of West
Bengal addressed a letter to
Department of Women &
Child Development and Social Welfare, West Bengal
whereby benefit in terms of Memo No. 9008- F(P),
dated 16.9.2011 was allowed to the
casual
daily rated/
/ contractual worker against sanctioned posts
under the said Department.
The said order further
disclosed that such direction as passed in accordance
with the direction of the Hon’ble Governor
who has
pleased to allow
10 daily rated/casual/contractual
workers
before
engaged
April
1,2004
against
sanctioned post and list of such names annexed with
the writ petition contains the name of the petitioner .
That apart two of such employees of the same list was
subsequently given the benefit reckoning the date of
engagement in service that is from 1995 and 1996
respectively as can be revealed document annexed in
affidavit-in-reply dated 26th August, 2025.
14.
The
order
passed
by
the
authority
in
consonance with the direction of learned Co-ordinate
Bench
only
mentioned
about
previous
erroneous
calculation without mentioning the reason for such
erroneous fixation or on what basis such fixation was
considered to be erroneous. The purpose of issuing the
Memorandum no.9008-F(P) was to provide security of
tenure ,appropriate emolument and certain terminal
benefits .The petitioner’s engagement was accepted
against a sanctioned post .In the decision of Jaggo vs
Union of India & Ors. it was observed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court that- “It is a disconcerting reality that
temporary
employees
particularly
in
government
institutions
,often
face
multifaceted
forms
of
exploitation
.While
the
foundational
purpose
of
temporary contracts may have been to address shortterm
or
seasonal
needs
,they
have
increasingly
become a mechanism to evade long-term obligations
owed to employees .
Employees
engaged
for
work
that
is
essential,recurring, and integral to the functioning
of an institution are often labeled as ‘Temporary’ or
‘contractual ’even when their roles mirror those of
regular employees .Such misclassification deprives
workers of the dignity ,security and benefits that
regular
employees
are
entitled
to
,despite
performing identical tasks “.
15. The Learned Co-ordinate Bench also observed
that several factual enquiries are required to be
conducted on the basis of the existing records relating
to the petitioner’s employment and only on the finding
of such fact finding enquiry the pay fixation can
correctly be done. Unfortunately the respondent no2
could only assign the reason as erroneous calculation
without
ascertaining
the
cause
of
arriving
such
conclusion and hence is not sustainable.
16.
Different
dates
of
joining
can
never
be
attributed to the petitioner for any fault on his part. It
is not only a case where there is mis-calculation of
incorrect pay fixation for once.
It is persistent from
the record that he was given the benefit taking into
consideration against a sanctioned post.
17. The impugned order and the notification in so
far its refixation of the salary of the petitioner taking
the
date
from
August
1,
suffers
from
arbitrariness and is violative of Article 14 of the
constitution of India.
18. Therefore this court is of the view that an
administrative circular or notification cannot override
the fundamental requirement of non-discrimination in
the matter of pay-fixation .The petitioner is therefore
entitled to have the salary applicable immediately
prior to the impugned reduction, granting all the
consequential benefits to which the petitioner would
have been entitled had the impugned action not been
taken.
19. In the light of above discussion the order dated
January 1,2025 followed by the Memo issued by the
Directorate of Child Rights & Trafficking on 29 th
January, 2025 from the office Directorate of Child
Rights & Trafficking is hereby quashed qua the
petitioner .
20.
Respondent
no.7
is
directed
to
forthwith
implement the said Memo No. 9008-F (P), dated
16.9.2011 as amended thereafter considering the
petitioner at par with the two other employees who
have been granted similar benefit as appears from the
order dated 26th August, 2025. Such exercise is to be
completed within period of 8 weeks from this date.
21. The petitioner is further entitled to interest at
the rate of 6% per annum on the arrear amount from
this date till date of payment.
22. The writ petition is accordingly allowed.
23. Urgent certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be supplied to the parties after compliance of all
legal formalities.
24. All parties shall act in terms of this order duly
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
[Chaitali Chatterjee (Das), J.]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review