The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. 09.2021 issued by the Deputy Secretary (Education),Government of Manipur to the Director of (Education-S), the service of the petitioner’s husband was re-instated from the date of his joining and vide order dated 23.11.2011 issued by the Zonal Education Officer, Government of Manipur, the ban from attending the school was lifted and he was re-instated and the husband of the petitioner continued service till his superannuation on 28.02.2014. Since no pensionary benefit was granted to him, the petitioner’s husband approached this Court by way of the writ petition being WP(C) No. 27 of 2017 and vide order dated 16.01.2017, this Court directed the State respondent to grant provisional pension to the petitioner during the pendency of the criminal case. [5] It may be noted that on the recommendation of the vigilance report dated 24.05.2007, FIR case No. 8(5) 2005-VPS U/S 420/468/471/120-B IPC was registered against the husband of the Page 2 petitioner and cognizance was taken in the case being Cril.(P) Case No. 13/2010/202/2013. Vide order dated 04.06.2022 passed in Cril.Misc.Case No. 41 of 2022, the criminal case was closed as the husband of the petitioner died on 17.05.2022 during the pendency of the criminal case. [6] The admitted fact before this Court is that in pursuance to the recommendation of the vigilance report dated 24.05.2007, the service of the petitioner was terminated…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No. 33
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 577 of 2022
Thounaojam Mema Devi
…..Petitioner/s
- Versus –
State of Manipur & 2 Ors.
.... Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
Order (Oral)
05.09.2024
[1]
Present Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned G.A. for the State respondent and
Mr. L. Gunindro, learned counsel for respondent No. 3.
[2]
Vide order dated 24.03.1982, the husband of the
petitioner and others were appointed as Teacher in Government
School. On the basis of the vigilance report dated 24.05.2007 regarding
fake certificate for class 10th and 12th submitted by the husband of the
petitioner, the Zonal Education Officer, Government of Manipur issued
an O.M. dated 10.07.2007 informing the husband of the petitioner not
to attend school and he was debarred from drawing any pay and
allowance and he should be deemed to be ceased in the service. In
fact, the OM dated 10.07.2007 is the termination order of the service of
the petitioner’s husband.
Page 1
[3]
Being
aggrieved,
the
husband
of
the
petitioner
challenged the said O.M. dated 10.07.2007 by a writ petition being
WP(C) No. 585 of 2007 before this Court and vide order dated
21.01.2008, this Court directed the State respondent to issue a notice
and consider reply to the show cause notice before issuing the O.M.
terminating the service of the petitioner’s husband. It was held that the
same was in violation of the principle of natural justice and directed to
give the show cause notice. If the same was not considered within 4
weeks, the service of the petitioner’s husband would be deem to be reinstated.
[4]
dated
In pursuance to the direction of this Court, vide letter
26.09.2021
issued
by
the
Deputy
Secretary
(Education),Government of Manipur to the Director of (Education-S),
the service of the petitioner’s husband was re-instated from the date of
his joining and vide order dated 23.11.2011 issued by the Zonal
Education Officer, Government of Manipur, the ban from attending the
school was lifted and he was re-instated and the husband of the
petitioner continued service till his superannuation on 28.02.2014.
Since no pensionary benefit was granted to him, the petitioner’s
husband approached this Court by way of the writ petition being WP(C)
No. 27 of 2017 and vide order dated 16.01.2017, this Court directed the
State respondent to grant provisional pension to the petitioner during
the pendency of the criminal case.
[5]
It may be noted that on the recommendation of the
vigilance report dated 24.05.2007, FIR case No. 8(5) 2005-VPS U/S
420/468/471/120-B IPC was registered against the husband of the
Page 2
petitioner and cognizance was taken in the case being Cril.(P) Case
No. 13/2010/202/2013. Vide order dated 04.06.2022 passed in
Cril.Misc.Case No. 41 of 2022, the criminal case was closed as the
husband of the petitioner died on 17.05.2022 during the pendency of
the criminal case.
[6]
The admitted fact before this Court is that in pursuance to
the recommendation of the vigilance report dated 24.05.2007, the
service of the petitioner was terminated by the State respondent and he
was subsequently re-instated in compliance of the order passed by this
Court and also a criminal proceeding was initiated against the petitioner
in compliance of the said vigilance report. Subsequently, the FIR case
was closed on the death of the husband of the petitioner. As on date,
there is no departmental proceeding against the husband of the
petitioner nor
any criminal proceeding. There is no order that the
husband of the petitioner was found to be guilty in a departmental
proceeding or in a criminal proceeding.
[7]
Mr. N. Umakanta, learned counsel for the petitioner,
draws the attention of this Court to the provisions of CCS Pension
Rule, 1977 especially rule 9 where it is stated that the authority could
withhold the pensionary benefit of a retired employee, if he was found
to be guilty in departmental or judicial proceeding. Learned counsel for
the petitioner submits that there is no any other provisions for denying
of the pensionary benefit. In the present case, the pensionary benefit to
the husband of the petitioner as well as family pension entitled to her
has been denied on the basis of the recommendation of the vigilance
report. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that as none
Page 3
of the conditions laid down in Rule 9 of CCS Pension Rule, 1977 has
been satisfied in the present case, the pension and other retiral benefit
cannot be withheld.
[8]
On the other hand, Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned G.A. for the
State respondent, submits that in the vigilance enquiry, there is clear
finding that the certificate of the husband of the petitioner for passing
class 10th and 12th were not genuine and hence, a recommendation
was made for termination of his service. The husband of the petitioner
failed to challenge the finding of the vigilance report regarding status of
the genuineness of the certificate and hence, the appointment of the
petitioner’s husband was on the basis of the fake document and he is
not entitled to any pensionary benefit. Learned G.A. draws the attention
of this Court to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of Union of India vs. Dattatray S/O Namdeo Mendhekar & Ors.
reported as (2008) 4 SCC 612 wherein it was held that once the caste
certificate of the appointee was to be found fake, the appointment
would be cancelled.
[9]
Mr. L. Gunindro, learned counsel for respondent No. 3,
submits that the Office of the Accountant General, Manipur did not
receive any information from the administrative department and the
process for granting pension or family pension to the husband of the
petitioner and the petitioner cannot be initiated.
[10]
This Court has perused the materials on record and
considered the submissions made the bar.
[11]
The short question involved in the present case is
whether the pensionary benefit of a retired Government Employee can
Page 4
be withheld under the provisions of Rule 9 of the CCS Pension Rule
only on the ground that his appointment was purportedly on the basis of
fake certificates. In the present case, the admitted fact is that the
service of the petitioner was terminated on the basis of the vigilance
report to the effect that his class 10th and 12th certificates were not
genuine. The termination of the petitioner’s husband was re-instated on
the direction of this Court and he continued his service till his
superannuation. It is also admitted fact that there is no departmental
proceeding against the husband of the petitioner with respect to the
allegation of fake certificates. However, the criminal case against the
petitioner for producing fake certificate was closed on the death of the
husband of the petitioner. As on date, there is no departmental
proceeding against the husband of the petitioner nor any criminal case
against him.
[12]
It may be noted that there is no order of verdict of guilty
to the husband of the petitioner in any departmental or criminal
proceeding for the alleged offence of submitting fake certificates.
[13]
1977,
On mere perusal of Rule 9 of the CCS Pension Rule,
the only ground for enabling the employer to withhold the
pension of a retired Government Employee is verdict of guilty in a
departmental proceeding or in a criminal proceeding.
[14]
This Court is of the opinion that in the present case, there
is no such finding by a competent authority and any other ground is not
stipulated in Rule 9 for confiscating the pension. The plea of the State
Government that pension cannot be granted as the husband of the
petitioner submitted the fake certificates at the time of his appointment
Page 5
is not sustainable, being in violation of the contemplation of Rule 9 of
CCS (Pension) Rule.
[15]
In view of the above, this Court is of the opinion that the
husband of the petitioner is entitled to the pensionary benefit and the
same cannot be denied on the basis of the fake certificates as recorded
in the vigilance report. Consequently, the petitioner is also entitled to
family pensionary benefit as per law. The State Government is directed
to process the necessary paper for preparation of the pensionary
benefit as well as family pension of the petitioner and forwarded the
same to the office of the Principal Accountant General, Manipur. The
said process of processing paper shall be completed within a period of
2 (two) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and the
office of the Principal Accountant General shall issue necessary
pension payment order and others within a further period of 2 (two)
months from the date of receipt of necessary papers from the
administrative department.
[16]
Writ petition is allowed and disposed of. No cost.
[17]
Send a copy of this order to the respondent No. 1 for
information and necessary compliance.
JUDGE
Kh. Joshua Maring
JOSHUA
KH. JOSHUA KH.
MARING
Date: 2024.09.17
MARING
10:27:13 +05'30'
Page 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review