The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In the facts and circumstances of the case and upon analysis of the entire materials on record, we are of the view that the proposed amendments would change the nature and character of the writ petition by making the recast writ petition and to be a totally different and a new case. The petitioner by way of this miscellaneous case wants to amend the entire pleadings and if the same is allowed, it would lead several complications. Further, the drafting of the irrelevant and immaterial statements as found in the writ petition cannot be cured by way of the proposed amendments thereby inserting certain new paragraphs. In fact, the basic issue raised in the writ petition has been exhausted and the cause of action of the writ petition has ceased to exist. When such being the factual position, the writ petitioners have to work out their remedy in the manner known to law and not by way of amendments in the present writ petition. Further, the proposed alternative prayer, prima facie, cannot be permitted, as the same would beyond the scope of writ jurisdiction.
18. As could be seen from the records that the main ground for filing W.P.(C) No.378 of 2019 was that the second respondent MPSC has not amended the MPSC (Procedure and Conduct of Business) Rules, 2011 and, this Court, in its order MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023 Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022 P a g e | 15 dated 2.5.2022, dismissed the said writ petition. Thus, it is clear that the same subject matter was brought in W.P.(C) No.378 of 2019 and this Court decided the issue in favour of the second respondent MPSC thereby directing them to go ahead with the recruitment process of MCSCC (Preliminary) Examination, 2019. Therefore, the writ petitioners herein cannot pretend to be ignorant and are now by way of the present proposed amendments attempting to re-agitate the same matter, which has already decided by this Court in the earlier round of litigation. Therefore, in the aforesaid factual scenario, we are of the view that the present miscellaneous case is devoid of merits and if the proposed amendments are permitted, it would in fact change the very nature and character of the writ petition and introduce an entirely different cause of action, which is in law impermissible.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
SHAMURAILATPA Digitally
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
M SUSHIL SHARMA SHARMA
Date: 2023.03.15 13:56:47 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(WP(C)) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
1. Shri Thoudam Arunkumar, aged about 31 years, S/o
Th. Gulapi Singh, resident of Khurai Thoudam Leikai,
Lamlong, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Imphal East District,
Manipur-795010.
……Applicant
-Versus1. The State of Manipur represented by the Chief
Secretary, Secretariat South Block, Babupara, Imphal
West, Manipur, Pin No.- 795001.
2. Manipur Public Service Commission, represented by
the Secretary, MPSC, North AOC, Imphal East, Pin No.
795001.
…….Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Applicant
::
Mrs. G. Pushpa, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Lenin Hijam, AG
Mr. M. Rarry, Adv.
Mr. Chongnem, Adv.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
27.02.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
13.03.2023
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
::
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
(M.V. Muralidaran, Acting CJ)
This miscellaneous case has been filed by the
petitioner, who is the third petitioner in the writ petition, to amend
the prayer of the writ petition and also to insert certain
paragraphs after paragraph 30 in the writ petition.
2.
Heard Mrs. G. Pushpa, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate General, Advocate
for the first respondent and Mr. M. Rarry, learned counsel for the
second respondent.
3.
The grievance of the petitioner is that glaring
irregularities found in the conduction of the MCSCCE (Main)
2016(2022) due to the improper and faulty rules which are not
amended in the light of the order dated 28.2.2017 passed in
W.P.(C) No.803 of 2016 read with the judgment dated
18.10.2019 passed in W.A.No.19 of 2017.
4.
Mrs. Pushpa, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that being apprehended by the callous and the failure
of the Manipur Public Service Commission to amend the MPSC
(Procedure and Conduct of Business) Rules, 2011 despite the
orders and directions passed by this Court in various
proceedings and also in the conduction of the MCSCCE (Main)
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
Page |3
2016 by the MPSC, the writ petitioners have filed W.P.(C) No.312
of 2022.
The learned counsel would submit that the writ
petitioners have approached this Court with a prayer to the
appropriate Government to handover the conduct of the
examination, namely MCSCE (Main) 2016 to the Union Public
Service Commission or to any other State Public Service
Commission
so
as
to
avoid
irregularities,
illegalities,
manipulations which were going to crop up in the conduct of the
examination 2016 in the event MPSC (Procedure and the
Conduct of Business) Rules, 2011, as amended on 22.6.2017,
4.6.2020, 14.6.2020 and 7.8.2020, was going to apply in the
conduct of the examination as prayed at prayer (ii) of the writ
petition.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further
submitted that though the conduct of the examination completed,
the order dated 11.5.2022 passed by this Court in the writ petition
has not been regarded in its true spirit. The second respondent
MPSC have totally neglected and have not complied with the
order and direction dated 3.2.2022, for which, as on date it has
become necessary to amend the prayer in the writ petition by way
of inserting prayer between prayer (i) and (ii) as the existing
prayer Nos.(i) and (ii) has rendered infructuous during the
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
Page |4
pendency of the writ petition. Thus, a prayer has been made to
amend the prayer portion in writ petition as also permit the
petitioner to insert certain paragraphs in the pleading after
paragraph 30.
6.
Refuting the submissions made by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, the learned counsel for the second
respondent MPSC,inter alia, submitted that when the main
prayers are rendered infructuous, the writ petition itself has
becomes infructuous too. Therefore, the prayer for amending the
main prayers of the writ petition is unacceptable as well as not
sustainable in the eyes of law, as the petitioners can very well file
a fresh writ petition with fresh cause of action, if it has arisen.
7.
Mr. M. Rarry, the learned counsel for the second
respondent would submit that the MPSC has conducted the
MCSCCE (Main) 2016 (2022) afresh from 26.5.2022 to
11.6.2022 in compliance of the order dated 11.2.2022 passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP (C) No.5680 of 2021 and the
order passed in W.A.No.19 of 2017 and declared the final merit
list as well. Thus, the basic issue raised in the writ petition has
been exhausted and the cause of action of the writ petition has
ceased to exist and, therefore, the present miscellaneous case
is not maintainable.
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
Page |5
8.
Adding further, the learned counsel for the second
respondent argued that MCSCCE (Main) 2016 (2022) was held
as per the amendments made in the MPSC (Procedure and
Conduct of Business) Rules, 2011 and the same amendments
have been placed before this Court at the time of hearing of
W.P.(C) No.378 of 2019 and connected cases and, this Court
passed an order dated 2.5.2022,whereby dismissing the writ
petitions and allowed the MPSC to go ahead with the recruitment
process of MCSCC (Preliminary) Exam, 2019 and that the
amendments made by the MPSC were already upheld and
approved by this Court and, therefore, the same principles are
equally applicable in the present case also. Thus, a prayer has
been made to dismiss the miscellaneous case.
9.
We have also heard the learned Government
Advocate, who adopted the arguments raised by the learned
counsel for the second respondent MPSC.
10.
We have considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
11.
The writ petitioners have filed the present writ
petition seeking direction on the second respondent MPSC to
amend the MPSC (Procedure and Conduct of Business) Rules,
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
Page |6
2011 as amended on 22.6.2017, 4.6.2017, 14.6.2020 and
7.8.2020 in the light of the judgment dated 18.10.2019 passed in
W.A.No.19 of 2017 and its related cases, as the same is going to
haunt the candidates who had approached this Court since the
year 2016 and had wasted the prime time of entire lives in
pursuing the litigations before this Court as well as before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and to direct the State Government to
hand over the conduct of the MCSCCE (Main) 2016 to the UPSC
or to any other State Public Service Commission to avoid
irregularities and illegalities which are going to crop up in the
conduct of the Examination 2016 in the event the MPSC
(Procedure and Conduct of Business) Rules, 2011 is applied.
The writ petitioners have also prayed to quash the policy decision
taken by the MPSC not to furnish the evaluated answer scripts
for descriptive type papers to candidates as reflected in the letter
dated 19.11.2020 issued by the SPIO, MPSC.
12.
Now the petitioner, who is arrayed as third
respondent in the writ petition on behalf of the other writ
petitioners, seeks to amend the prayer as under:
“(ia) to issue a writ in the nature of certiorari
or any other appropriate writ or writs for
quashing and further be pleased to direct to
re-conduct the MCSCC main examination
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
Page |7
(2022) as
the
examination
was
conducted without amending the Manipur
Public Service (Procedure & Conduct of
Business) Rules, 2011 in the light of the order
and direction passed by the Hon’ble Division
Bench of this Hon’ble Court in W.A.No.19 of
2017 & batch and the judgment dated
17.12.2020 of the said Division Bench in
Review Petition no.3 of 2020 & batch, as the
same has attend finality.
(iia) To issue notice to the MPSC as to why
MPSC had not followed the mindful advice
from the ends of this Hon’ble Court passed
vide order dated 11/05/2022in the above
referred writ petition as to the implementation
of the directions passed by the Division
Bench of this Hon’ble court in W.A.No.19 of
2017 & Batch and the judgment and order
dated 17/12/2020 of the said Division Bench
in Review Petition No.3 of 2020 & batch
which has attained finality in the conduct of
the
MCSCC
(Main)
Examination
(2022).
(iiia) To issue notice as to why the signatures
for the supervisor column has been removed
from the answer booklet and as to why the
instruction “to draw a line at the end of each
answer and to start the next question from
the next page” has been removed by the
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
Page |8
MPSC from the Main Examination 2016 and
as to why such sudden changes has been
made by the MPSC.
(iva) To direct the MPSC to produce the
decision of the Full Commission of the MPSC
with reason, if any.”
And/Or in the alternative, the petitioner also sought the following
direction as prayer (v):
“(v) To direct the Government of Manipur to
appoint the petitioners to any post equivalent
to MCS Grade-II, MPS Grade-II or any other
posts as mentioned in the advertisement.”
13.
Apart from the proposed amendment in the prayer
portion, the petitioner has also sought insertion of the following
paragraphs after paragraph 30 as paragraphs 30A, 30B, 30C,
30D, 30E and 30F:
“30A. That the petitioners being candidates
who
had
participated
the
MCSCCE
examination 2016 have come across while
appearing the aforesaid examination held in
the year 2022 that the MPSC has repeated
the same process of examination as was
done in the MCSCC main examination 2016
which was quashed and set aside by an
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
Page |9
order dated 18.10.2019 passed by the
Special Division Bench of the Hon’ble High
Court of Manipur based on dozens of
irregularities and illegalities committed by the
MPSC that goes to the root of the matter.
This order itself was upheld by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India.
30B. That the petitioners being the bonafide
and law-abiding citizen of India and being writ
petitioners in the matter of MCSCCE main
examination 2016 submitted memorandum
(Annexure A/11 to the writ petition) to the
MPSC to frame proper and appropriate rules
and regulation for conducting the MCSCCE
main examination 2016 afresh.
That the
petitioners were hoping that the MPSC will
consider the memorandum dated 10/03/2022
(Annexure A/11 to the writ petition) submitted
by the petitioners to amend the rules as per
the judgment & order dated 18.10.2019.
However, on seeking information by way of
RTI application seeking a copy of the
amended MPSC Procedure and Conduct of
Business Rules 2011, if any. Despite the RTI
application the MPSC had never provided a
full and complete copy of the MPSC
Procedure and Conduct of Business Rules,
2011. On the other hand a full and complete
copy of the MPSC Procedure and Conduct of
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
P a g e | 10
Business Rules, 2011 was furnished by the
counsel of the MPSC in W.P.(C) No.378 of
2019 during the course of hearing in the
matter of MCSCCE examination 2019, under
which the petitioners came across several
defects
and
loopholes
in
the
MPSC
Procedure and Conduct of Business Rules,
2011.
30C. That the petitioners being apprehended
that the examination which was on the way
was not going to be an untained examination
if the same would be conducted by using the
defective rules particularly the questionsetting rules and the procedure of evaluation
& evaluation rules.
It has come to the
knowledge of the petitioners that the MPSC
have not amended the Rules by way of
following the observations, directions and
findings by the judgment and order dated
18/10/2019 passed by the Special Division
Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Manipur
in W.A.No.19 of 2017 & batch.
Accordingly, the writ petitioners have filed the
above referred writ petition being W.P.(C)
No.312 of 2022 well in advance i.e. before
conducting the exam “MCSCCE main exam
2016.
30D. That the petitioners in view of the order
dated 11/05.2022 passed by this Hon’ble
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
P a g e | 11
Court well before the commencement of the
Main examination 2016 (2022) were hoping
that MPSC will consider and follow the order
dated 11.05.2022. To mention some of the
defects which came vividly at the time of
examination are cited as under:a) Lack of Column for the signature of the
supervisor
b) The no. of pages on which a candidate
attempts the questions and wrote their
answers to be filled by the examiner.
c) Removal of an important instruction to the
candidates “To draw a line at the end of
each answer and star the answer of the
next question on a fresh page”
d) Unequal distribution of marks for each
and every question in many optional
papers.
e) Asking questions out of the syllabus and
asking
question
which
was
directly
present in books and guide books etc.
30E. That it may be pertinent to mention
herein that the writ petitioners have also
preferred a Misc. application in the above
referred writ petition highlighting the defects
cited above as the writ petitioners have come
across such defects during the course of the
examination and prayed before this Hon’ble
Court for staying the declaration of results of
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
P a g e | 12
the Main examination 2016 (2022), however
this Hon’ble Court was pleased to dismiss the
Misc. Application.
30F. That on 23/12/2022 the SPIO of MPSC
provided information to the Misc. Applicant
as the applicant was seeking for information
by way of filing RTI Application dated
29/11/2022. The SPIO MPSC had informed
the applicant herein with the following
information which amounts to revealing the
defects and irregularities in the conduct of the
Main examination 2016 (2022).
Main
examination
conducted
irregularly
for
That the
(2022)
the
was
following
reasons which are reflected in the RTI replay
dated 23/12/2022.
I.
No head examiners were appointed
II.
No
question
moderators
were
appointed
III.
No moderation was done
IV.
No scaling was done
V.
Supervisors were appointed by no
column for signatures were provided
on the front page of the answer
booklets.”
14. Admittedly, the examination in question has already
been held and the result was also declared. When that being the
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
P a g e | 13
position, the proposed amendments sought by the petitioner
cannot be permitted at this distant point of time, as the same
would change the fundamental character and nature of the writ
petition. That apart, the subsequent cause of action, i.e. after the
examination, cannot be brought into the present writ petition, as
it would amount to a totally different cause of action.
15.
It is well settled by decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court as well as this Court that Courts should be
extremely liberal in granting the prayer for amendment of
pleadings unless serious injustice or irreparable loss is caused to
the other side.
As stated supra, after completion of the
examination in question, the entire cause of action has changed
and the petitioner cannot be allowed to amend the writ pleadings
so as to alter materially or substitute the cause of action.
16.
The well settled proposition is that where the
amendment changes the nature of the litigation or the cause of
action, so as to set up an entirely new case, foreign to the case
set up originally, the amendment must be disallowed. In the
instant case, admittedly, the petitioner wants to introduce a new
case by way of amendments, which cannot be permitted.
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
P a g e | 14
17.
In the facts and circumstances of the case and upon
analysis of the entire materials on record, we are of the view that
the proposed amendments would change the nature and
character of the writ petition by making the recast writ petition
and to be a totally different and a new case. The petitioner by
way of this miscellaneous case wants to amend the entire
pleadings and if the same is allowed, it would lead several
complications. Further, the drafting of the irrelevant and
immaterial statements as found in the writ petition cannot be
cured by way of the proposed amendments thereby inserting
certain new paragraphs. In fact, the basic issue raised in the writ
petition has been exhausted and the cause of action of the writ
petition has ceased to exist. When such being the factual
position, the writ petitioners have to work out their remedy in the
manner known to law and not by way of amendments in the
present writ petition. Further, the proposed alternative prayer,
prima facie, cannot be permitted, as the same would beyond the
scope of writ jurisdiction.
18.
As could be seen from the records that the main
ground for filing W.P.(C) No.378 of 2019 was that the second
respondent MPSC has not amended the MPSC (Procedure and
Conduct of Business) Rules, 2011 and, this Court, in its order
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
P a g e | 15
dated 2.5.2022, dismissed the said writ petition. Thus, it is clear
that the same subject matter was brought in W.P.(C) No.378 of
2019 and this Court decided the issue in favour of the second
respondent MPSC thereby directing them to go ahead with the
recruitment process of MCSCC (Preliminary) Examination, 2019.
Therefore, the writ petitioners herein cannot pretend to be
ignorant and are now by way of the present proposed
amendments attempting to re-agitate the same matter, which has
already decided by this Court in the earlier round of litigation.
Therefore, in the aforesaid factual scenario, we are of the view
that the present miscellaneous case is devoid of merits and if the
proposed amendments are permitted, it would in fact change the
very nature and character of the writ petition and introduce an
entirely different cause of action, which is in law impermissible.
19.
In the result, MC (WP) No.33 of 2023 is dismissed.
No costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
MC(WA) No. 33 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 312 of 2022
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review