The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. A bare perusal of the order impugned before the High Court as also the statements made before us in the counter-affidavit filed by the respondents, we are satisfied that the statutory authority has already applied its mind and has formed an opinion as regards the liability or otherwise of the appellant. If in passing the order the respondent has already determined the liability of the appellant and the only question which remains for its consideration is quantification thereof, the same does not remain in the realm of a show-cause notice. The writ petition, in our opinion, was maintainable.” [8] I have carefully perused the aforesaid judgment rendered by the Hon‟ble Apex Court and this Court is of the considered view that the said principle of law had been laid down in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case and such principle of law are not applicable in the present case for the simple reason that the facts and WP(C)No. 451 of 2021 Page 8 circumstances of the present case and the facts and circumstances of the cases cited by the counsel for the petitioner are totally different. [9] I have heard at length the submissions advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the parties and considered the rival submissions. In my considered view, even though, the petitioner was appointed by the Under Secretary (MAHUD), Government of Manipur, by an order dated 06-03-2023 issued …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed
LAISHRA Digitally
by LAISHRAM
DHAKESHORI
M
DEVI
DHAKESH Date:
ORI DEVI 2024.08.30
14:01:27 +05'30'
Item Nos. 50
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 451 of 2024
Thongam Shyamo Singh
…Petitioner
Vs.
State of Manipur & 2 ors.
…Respondents
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
28.08.2024
Heard Mr. I. Denning, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner; Mr. Phungyo Zingkhei, learned Dy. GA appearing for
respondent Nos. 1 & 2; Mr. S. Nepolean, learned GA appearing for
respondent No. 3 and Mr. L. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel
assisted by Md. Fakirrudin, learned counsel appearing for respondent
No. 4.
[2]
The present writ petition has been field challenging the
show cause notice dated 19-06-2024 issued by the respondent No.
2 against the petitioner. In the said show cause notice, it has been,
inter alia, alleged that the petitioner has violated the provisions of
Section 29(2)(d) read with Section 59 of the Manipur Municipalities
Act, 1994 by having share and interests in the execution of contract
works of the Thoubal Municipal Council and directing the petitioner to
submit his show cause as to why appropriate action shall not be taken
against him.
The learned counsel appearing for the respondents raised
a preliminary issue with regard to the maintainability of the
present writ petition. It has been submitted by the learned
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 1
counsel appearing for the respondents that the impugned show
cause notice does not rise to any cause of action inasmuch as,
no right of the petitioner has been affected nor any action
affecting the petitioner‟s right to be a councilor has been
infringed by the said show cause notice. It has also been
submitted that the competent authority issued the show cause
notice in terms of the relevant provisions of the Manipur
Municipalities Act 1994 and Rules made thereunder and the
same is perfectly valid and legally tenable and that the present
petition is premature and liable to be dismissed in the threshold.
In support of the contentions, the counsel for the respondents
have relied on the following decisions of the Hon‟ble Apex
Court:“(i) “State of Uttar Pradesh –vrs.- Brahm Datt
Sharma & anr.” reported in (1987)2 Supreme Court
Cases 179 wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court in paragraph
No. 9 of the judgment held as under :“9. The High Court was not justified in quashing the
show cause notice. When a show cause notice is
issued to a government servant under a statutory
provision calling upon him to show cause, ordinarily
the government servant must place his case before
the authority concerned by showing cause and the
courts should be reluctant to interfere with the
notice at that stage unless the notice is shown to
have been issued palpably without any authority of
law. The purpose of issuing show cause notice is to
afford opportunity of hearing to the government
servant and once cause is shown it is open to the
government to consider the matter in the light of the
facts and submissions placed by the government
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 2
servant and only thereafter a final decision in the
matter could be taken. Interference by the court
before that stage should be premature. The High
Court in our opinion ought not have interfered with
the show cause notice.”
(ii)
“Union of India & anr. –vrs.- Kunisetty
Satyanaraya” reported in (2006)12 Supreme Court
Cases 28 wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court in paragraph
No. 13 & 14 of the judgment held as under :-
“13. It is well settle by a series of decisions of this
Court that ordinarily no writ lies against a chargesheet or show-cause notice vide Executive Engineer,
Bihar State Housing Board –vrs.- Ramesh Kumar
Singh, Special Director –vrs.- Mohd. Ghulam
Ghouse, Ulagappa –vrs.- Divisional Commr., Mysore,
State of U.P. –vrs.- Brahm Datt Sharma, etc.
“14. The reason why ordinarily a writ petition
should not be entertained against a mere showcause notice or charge-sheet is that at that stage
the writ petition may be held to be premature. A
mere charge-sheet or show-cause notice does not
give rise to any cause of action, because it does not
amount to an adverse order which affects the rights
of any party unless the same has been issued by a
person having no jurisdiction to do so. It is quite
possible that after considering the reply to the showcause notice or after holding an enquiry the
authority concerned may drop the proceedings
and/or hold that the charges are not established. It
is well settle that a writ petition lies when some right
of any party is infringed. A mere show-cause notice
or charge-sheet does not infringe the right of
anyone. It is only when a final order imposing some
punishment or otherwise adversely affecting a party
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 3
is passed, that the said party can be said to have
any grievance.”
(iii) “Special Director & anr. –vrs.- Mohd. Ghulam
Ghouse & anr.” reported in (2004)3 Supreme Court
Cases 440 wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court in paragraph
No. 5 of the judgment held as under :-
“5. This Court in a large number of cases has
deprecated the practice of the High Courts
entertaining writ petitions questioning legality of the
show-cause notices stalling enquiries as proposed
and retarding investigative process to find actual
facts with the participation and in the presence of
the parties. Unless the High Court is satisfied that
the show-cause notice was totally non est in the eye
of the law for absolute want of jurisdiction of the
authority to even investigate into facts, writ petitions
should not be entertained for the mere asking and
as a matter of routine, and the writ petitioner should
invariably be directed to respond to the show-cause
notice and take all stands highlighted in the writ
petition. Whether the show-cause notice was
founded on any legal premises, is a jurisdictional
issue which can even be urged by the recipient of
the notice and such issues also can be adjudicated
by the authority issuing the very notice initially,
before the aggrieved could approach the court.
Further, when the court passes an interim order it
should be careful to see that the statutory
functionaries specially and specifically constituted for
the purpose are not denuded of powers and
authority to initially decide the matter and ensure
that ultimate relief which may or may not be finally
granted in the writ petition is not accorded to the
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 4
writ petitioner even at the threshold by the interim
protection granted.”
[3]
Relying on the law laid down by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in
the aforesaid judgments, it has been submitted by the learned
counsel appearing for the respondents that the present writ petition is
premature and not maintainable and the same is liable to be rejected.
[4]
Mr. I. Denning, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner submitted that the petitioner has assailed the impugned
show cause notice on the following two grounds :(i) The authority who issued the show cause notice has
no jurisdiction to issue the said show cause notice ;
(ii) The show cause notice has been issued with
predetermined minds.
Elaborating the above points, it has been submitted by the
learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner had been
appointed as a Caretaker Chairperson of the Thoubal Municipal
Council by virtue of the order passed by this Court on 19-01-2023 in
WP(C)No. 935 of 2022 and batches of writ petitions. In the said
order, one of the directions given by this court is that the interim
order granted by the court on 04-11-2022 in the said writ petitions
should continue till issuance of the notification of the Election of the
Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) and Autonomous District Council.
[5]
In compliance with the said directions given by this court,
the Under Secretary (MAHUD), Government of Manipur, issued an
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 5
order dated 06-03-2023 allowing the concerned Ex-Caretaker
Mayor, Ex-Caretaker Chairpersons and Ex-Caretaker Councilors of the
previous terms/Councils of the Urban Local Bodies, including the
present petitioner, to continue as Ex-Caretaker Mayor, Ex-Caretaker
Chairpersons and Ex-Caretaker Councillors of the concerned Urban
Local Bodies till the issuance of the notification of the Election of the
Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) by the Election Commissioner. The learned
counsel further submitted that since the petitioner had been
appointed by an executive order pursuant to the direction given by
this Court, the provision of the Municipality Act and Rule are not
applicable to the petitioner. In such view of the matter, it has been
submitted that the authority, who issued the impugned show cause
notice, does not have the power or jurisdiction to issue the said show
cause notice.
[6]
Elaborating the second point, it has been submitted by the
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner that initially 10(ten)
Caretaker Councillors of the Thoubal Municipal Council made a written
complaint against the petitioner to the Commissioner (MAHUD),
Government of Manipur, raising certain allegations against the
petitioner, however, subsequently 3(three) of the said complainants
have withdrawn themselves from the said complaint. However, the
authorities never disclose such development. The learned counsel
further submitted that even though the petitioner has submitted his
written reply to the show cause notice, no action has been taken up
by the respondents and that such factum of submitting reply to show
cause notice has not also been disclosed by them. In view of the
above, it has been submitted by the learned counsel that the action of
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 6
the respondents in issuing the show cause notice is a predetermine
action.
[7]
Mr. I. Denning, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner cited the case laws reported in (2006)12 SCC 33 “Siemens
Ltd. –vrs.- State of Maharashtra & ors.” wherein the Hon‟ble
Apex Court held as under :-
”9. Although ordinarily a writ court may not exercise its
discretionary jurisdiction in entertaining a writ petition
questioning a notice to show cause unless the same inter
alia appears to have been without jurisdiction as has been
held by this Court in some decisions including State of
U.P. v. Brahm Datt Sharma, Special Director v. Mohd.
Ghulam Ghouse and Union of India v. Kunisetty
Satyanarayana, but the question herein has to be
considered from a different angle viz. when a notice is
issued with premeditation, a writ petition would be
maintainable. In such an event, even if the court directs
the statutory authority to hear the matter afresh,
ordinarily such hearing would not yield any fruitful
purpose. (See K.I. Shephard v. Union of India). It is
evident in the instant case that the respondent has clearly
made up its mind. It explicitly said so both in the counteraffidavit as also in its purported show-cause notice.
10. The said principle has been followed by this Court in
V.C., Banaras Hindu University V. Shrikant, stating :
(SCC p. 60, paras 8-9)
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 7
“48. The Vice-Chancellor appears to have made up
his mind to impose the punishment of dismissal on
the respondent herein. A post-decisional hearing
given by the High Court was illusory in this case.
“49. In K.I. Shephard v. Union of India this Court
held : (SCC p.9, para 16)
„It is common experience that once a decision
has been taken, there is a tendency to uphold it
and a representation may not really yield any
fruitful purpose.’”
11. A bare perusal of the order impugned before the High
Court as also the statements made before us in the
counter-affidavit filed by the respondents, we are satisfied
that the statutory authority has already applied its mind
and has formed an opinion as regards the liability or
otherwise of the appellant. If in passing the order the
respondent has already determined the liability of the
appellant and the only question which remains for its
consideration is quantification thereof, the same does not
remain in the realm of a show-cause notice. The writ
petition, in our opinion, was maintainable.”
[8]
I have carefully perused the aforesaid judgment rendered
by the Hon‟ble Apex Court and this Court is of the considered view
that the said principle of law had been laid down in the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the case and such principle of law are not
applicable in the present case for the simple reason that the facts and
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 8
circumstances of the present case and the facts and circumstances of
the cases cited by the counsel for the petitioner are totally different.
[9]
I have heard at length the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties and considered the rival
submissions. In my considered view, even though, the petitioner was
appointed by the Under Secretary (MAHUD), Government of Manipur,
by an order dated 06-03-2023 issued in compliance with the direction
given by this Court, the facts still remains that he is acting as a
Councillor of the Thoubal Municipal Council and he is discharging his
duties and functioning within the four corners of provisions of the
Manipur Municipalities Act and Rules made thereunder. Accordingly,
this court is of the considered view that the provisions of the Manipur
Municipality Act and Rules made thereunder are applicable to the
petitioner and as such, this Court cannot agree with the submission
advanced on behalf of the petitioner that the authority who issue the
show cause notice has no jurisdiction or power to issue the said show
cause notice.
[10]
So far as the second contention made by the learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner is concerned, this court is of the
considered view that there is no substance or merit in such
contention, inasmuch as, the competent authority issued the show
cause notice on the basis of the complaint made by some Councillors
of the Thoubal Municipal Council alleging commission of illegal acts by
the petitioner. On the basis of such complaint, the competent
authority issued the show cause notice in terms of the provision of
the aforesaid Act and Rules to find out the veracity or truthfulness of
such allegations and for taking appropriate action if required.
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 9
Moreover, since no adverse action has been taken against the
petitioner, this court cannot agree with the submission made by the
learned counsel for the petitioner that the show cause notice had
been issued with a predetermined mind. This Court is also of the view
that the present writ petition is premature. Accordingly, at this stage,
this Court is not inclined to interfere with the impugned show cause
notice. In the result, the writ petition is hereby dismissed as it is not
maintainable.
It is made clear that this Court has not decided or
consider any merit of the present petition and the authorities are at
liberty to proceed with any further action relating to show cause
notice, if so advised and complete the same within a period of
3(three) months from today by passing appropriate order as deem fit
and proper.
JUDGE
Dhakeshori
WP(C)No. 451 of 2021
Page 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review