The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. Contentions of the appellants in brief : ● The Sub Court erred in its appreciation of evidence and law. 2025:KER:29931 The judgment and decree are liable to be set aside. ● Ext.X2 produced by the Village Officer would reveal that 4.05 Ares of land had been assigned to the original appellant to compensate for the loss caused to him due to acquisition of certain other land in the same village. This crucial evidence points to which the title of the original appellant was brushed aside by the Sub Court. ● The original appellant had filed O.S.No.231 of 1967 before the Munsiff Court, Thiruvananthapuram, to evict the 1 st respondent from the acquired properties. Though the same happened to be dismissed for default and was not restored or challenged in appeal, Order 9 Rule 9 of the CPC would be attracted as the disposal was not on merits. ● The appellant was in possession of tax receipt for 1967-68, which could not be produced earlier. The Sub Court had erroneously turned down the request to permit its production. ● The tax receipt produced by the 1 st respondent ought not to have been accepted by the Sub Court as she had been remitting it on behalf of the original appellant. ● The 1st respondent's statements, when examined as DW1, 2025:KER:29931 were inconsistent and unreliable. The Sub Court ought not to have relied on them. ● In the written statement filed by the respondent in OS No…
6. Contentions of the 1st respondent in brief : ● The contentions put forth by the appellant/s are not legally sustainable. The judgment and decree of the Sub Court do 2025:KER:29931 not call for any interference. LAA is only a chance litigation devoid of any bona fides. ● The Sub Court, based on the evidence tendered, including the records produced by the Village Officer, validly concluded that, based on a pokkuvaravu case, the patta of the property bearing No.1001/1 had been transferred in favour of the 1 st respondent. The property had thus been included in the respondent's thandapper account. ● Exts.D1 and D2 documents clearly revealed that the respondent had been paying tax interest of the acquired property from 1979 onwards. ● The appellant/s had not produced even a single tax receipt to substantiate their claim regarding title and ownership. The contention now put forth that appellants are ready to produce the same, if afforded an opportunity, is bald and devoid of any bona fides. The objective is only to further protract the matter. ● Assessment registers for the years 1972-73, 1978-79, 198889, and 1993-94, copies of which had been produced, clearly evidence that the 1st respondent is the owner of the property. ● The 1st respondent produced Ext.D5, tax receipt for the 2025:KER:29931 building situated in the property, revealing that she is its owner. She also produced Ext.D…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
LA.APP. NO. 675 OF 2002
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 06.06.1996 IN LAR
NO.33 OF 1994 OF II ADDITIONAL SUB COURT,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
APPELLANT/CLAIMANT (E):
THOMAS CRUZ ANDRUZE
KONATHU VEEDU,PATTOM, TRIVANDRUM.
: DIED
ADDL.R2
B.J.SELINE,
W/O.LATE THOMAS CRUZE ANDRUZE, PRESENTLY RESIDING
JACOB VILA, T.C.3/560 (1),T.K.DIVAKARAN ROAD,
PARAYIL DEVI TEMPLE LANE, MUTTADA P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
ADDL.R3
MERCY,
JACOB VILLA,T.C.3/560 (1), T.K.DIVAKARAN ROAD,
PARAYIL DEVI TEMPLE LANE, MUTTADA P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
ADDL.R4
THRESIAMMA,
JACOB VILA,T.C.3/560 (1), T.K.DIVAKARAN ROAD,
PARAYIL DEVI TEMPLE LANE, MUTTADA P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
ADDL.R5
METTILDA,
JACOB VILA,T.C.3/560 (1), T.K.DIVAKARAN ROAD,
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
PARAYIL DEVI TEMPLE LANE, MUTTADA P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
LEGAL HEIRS OF THE DECEASED IST APPELLANT IS
IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL APPELLANTS 2 TO 5 VIDE
ORDER DATED 16.11.2017 IN I.A.NO.1269/2011 IN LAA
NO.675/2002.
BY ADV B.S.SWATHI KUMAR
RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANT D:
THYVANI JAGATHAMMA
T.C 42/720, AJITHA BHAVAN,
MUTTATHARA, TRIVANDRUM.
STATE OF KERALA.
BY ADVS.
B.KRISHNA MANI
N.V.SANDHYA, R1
REKHA C.NAIR, SR.GOVERNMENT PLEADER, R2
DHANUJA M.S
THIS
LAND
ACQUISITION
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD ON 02.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 02nd day of April, 2025
This Land Acquisition Appeal (Pauper) is filed challenging the
judgment and decree dated 06.06.1996 in LAR No. 33 of 1994 of the
II Additional Sub Court, Thiruvananthapuram.
2. The dispute relates to the disbursement of award amounts
under a land acquisition award. Originally there were four claimants
in the LAR. They were enumerated as claimants A to D.
Apportionment made by the reference court to claimants A to C are
not in dispute. The dispute and difference arose among claimants D
and E. Both of them stake claim over the award amount of
Rs.3,32,669.45 lying in deposit. Appellant was the claimant
E/claimant No.5 (hereinafter referred to as “the appellant”) and
respondents were the claimant D/claimant No.4 (hereinafter referred
to as the 1st respondent) in the LAR and State.
3.
Land
having
an
extent
of
4.05
Ares
comprising
Sy.No.2610/25-50 of Muttathara Village along with building therein
was acquired for development of Thiruvananthapuram Airport. Since
a dispute arose between the appellant and the respondent as to who
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
is entitled to receive the said amount, reference was made to decide
on apportionment. Before the reference court, both sides tendered
evidence. The appellant marked Ext.E1 and examined EW1 and
EW2. The 1st respondent marked Exts.D1 to D6 and examined DW1
and DW2. Exts.X1 and X2 were also marked in the LAR. After due
appreciation of evidence and hearing, the learned Sub Judge
permitted the respondent to withdraw Rs.3,32,669.45 lying in deposit
before the court less notice charges. The said judgment and decree
is challenged by the appellant in this LAA.
4. The appellant passed away during pendency of the
proceedings and his legal heirs were impleaded as additional
appellants vide order dated 16.11.2017. I.A.No.2 of 2025 was filed
by the additional appellants producing Annexure A1 document which
is a true copy of the certificate dated 01.02.2025 issued by the
Principal Sub Registrar, Thiruvananthapuram, stating that no
documents concerning the property had been executed by the
appellant/s in favour of anyone during the period
01.01.1964 to
31.12.1999.
5.
Contentions of the appellants in brief :
● The Sub Court erred in its appreciation of evidence and law.
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
The judgment and decree are liable to be set aside.
● Ext.X2 produced by the Village Officer would reveal that 4.05
Ares of land had been assigned to the original appellant to
compensate for the loss caused to him due to acquisition of
certain other land in the same village. This crucial evidence
points to which the title of the original appellant was brushed
aside by the Sub Court.
● The original appellant had filed O.S.No.231 of 1967 before the
Munsiff Court, Thiruvananthapuram, to evict the 1 st respondent
from the acquired properties. Though the same happened to
be dismissed for default and was not restored or challenged in
appeal, Order 9 Rule 9 of the CPC would be attracted as the
disposal was not on merits.
● The appellant was in possession of tax receipt for 1967-68,
which could not be produced earlier. The Sub Court had
erroneously turned down the request to permit its production.
● The tax receipt produced by the 1 st respondent ought not to
have been accepted by the Sub Court as she had been
remitting it on behalf of the original appellant.
● The 1st respondent's statements, when examined as DW1,
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
were inconsistent and unreliable. The Sub Court ought not to
have relied on them.
● In the written statement filed by the respondent in OS No. 231
of 1967, she did not claim that the land belonged to her. She
had only stated that it did not exclusively belong to the original
appellant and that her children, too, had a share therein along
with the original appellant.
● There was no evidence that the ownership of the land had
been transferred to the name of the 1st respondent.
● The Sub Court ought to have allowed the appellant's plea to
summon the Tahsildar with all revenue records, which would
have exposed the falsity of the respondent's claim. The Sub
Court erred in declining this plea.
● Relying on Annexure A1 certificate dated 01.02.2025 issued
by the Principal Sub Registrar, Thiruvananthapuram, it is
contended that since no documents had been executed by the
appellant/s in favour of anyone during the period 01.01.1964
to 31.12.1999, the respondent cannot claim to have obtained
any title over the property. The documents relied on by her are
thus unreliable in law and confer no title upon her.
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
● The judgment and decree impugned is thus unsustainable in
law and fit to be set aside.
● The LAR ought to be remanded for fresh consideration after
the additional appellants afforded the opportunity to adduce
further evidence.
● Res judicata will not be attracted by the dismissal in default of
O.S.No.231 of 1967. Reliance is placed on the dictum laid
down
by
this
Court
in
Manakkal
Nandakumar
v.
Subramanyan M and others [2017 KHC 2719].
● The documents Exts.X1 and X2 relied on by the respondent
have no sanctity in the eye of the law. It is a trite law that the
Tahsildar has no power to examine issues of title and validity
of documents. Reliance is placed on the dictum laid down by
this Court in Santhosh Jacob v. Tahsildar Muvattupuzha
Taluk [2024 (2) KHC 665].
● Reliance is placed on the dictum of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Union of India v. Moksh Builders and Financiers
Ltd. and others [1977 KHC 409], wherein it had been held
that an admission is substantive evidence of fact admitted and
the admission duly proved is admissible evidence irrespective
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
of whether the party making them appeared in the witness box
or not and whether the party when appearing as witness was
confronted with those statements in case it made a statement
contrary to those admissions. It is thus contended that the
admission in the written statement filed by the respondent in
O.S.No.231
of
before
the
Munsiff
Court,
Thiruvananthapuram, is binding and relevant. This aspect was
overlooked by the Sub Court while rendering the impugned
judgment.
● In the context of Annexure A1 document produced, reliance is
placed on the dictum laid down in Synudheen v State of
Kerala [2013(1) KHC 437] and it is contended that mutations
carried out in favour of the respondent have no value in the
eye of the law as regards the question of titular rights over the
property. The admission in the Written statement has now
been corroborated by Annexure A1 and hence the judgment of
the Sub Court impugned in this LAA is fit to be set aside.
6. Contentions of the 1st respondent in brief :
● The contentions put forth by the appellant/s are not legally
sustainable. The judgment and decree of the Sub Court do
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
not call for any interference. LAA is only a chance litigation
devoid of any bona fides.
● The Sub Court, based on the evidence tendered, including the
records produced by the Village Officer, validly concluded that,
based on a pokkuvaravu case, the patta of the property
bearing No.1001/1 had been transferred in favour of the 1 st
respondent. The property had thus been included in the
respondent's thandapper account.
● Exts.D1 and D2 documents clearly revealed that
the
respondent had been paying tax interest of the acquired
property from 1979 onwards.
● The appellant/s had not produced even a single tax receipt to
substantiate their claim regarding title and ownership. The
contention now put forth that appellants are ready to produce
the same, if afforded an opportunity, is bald and devoid of any
bona fides. The objective is only to further protract the matter.
● Assessment registers for the years 1972-73, 1978-79, 198889, and 1993-94, copies of which had been produced, clearly
evidence that the 1st respondent is the owner of the property.
● The 1st respondent produced Ext.D5, tax receipt for the
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
building situated in the property, revealing that she is its
owner. She also produced Ext.D7, which revealed that the
Municipal
Corporation
had
issued
permission
to
the
respondent to construct the building in the said property.
● The court correctly concluded that there was no evidence to
substantiate the appellant's claim that he had constructed a
hut on the acquired property.
● Though the original appellant had contended that the building
in the acquired property had been rented out to the
respondent, this claim was not substantiated by any
documents.
● O.S.No.231
of
before
the
Munsiff
Court,
Thiruvananthapuram, had been filed by the original appellant
seeking eviction of the respondent and claiming recovery of
possession on the strength of title. In the said suit, the
contention of the original appellant was not that the premises
had been rented out to the respondent. On the other hand, it
had been contended therein that the respondent had
encroached into the said property. The said suit had been
dismissed for non-prosecution. No restoration, no appeal had
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
been filed by the original appellant therein.
● The Sub Court rightly concluded that the original appellant,
who was the plaintiff in OS No.231 of 1967, was precluded
from filing a fresh suit on the same cause of action.
● The Sub Court had rightly concluded that the purported
admission in the written statement filed by the respondent in
O.S.No.231 of 1967 does not confer any title on the
appellant/s. The title to the property has to be proved by
producing documents. No such documents have been
produced by the appellant/s. Patta had been transferred to the
respondent after the filing of the written statement in
O.S.No.231 of 1967.
● The only document relied on by the appellant/s is Ext.E1
written statement, which is strikingly inadequate to prove the
title.
● The documents produced by the 1st respondent clearly
revealed that the title to the property was vested in the
respondent. The finding of the Sub Court to this effect is valid
and remains uncontradicted.
● Annexure A1 certificate dated 01.02.2025 issued by the
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
Principal Sub Registrar Thiruvananthapuram now produced
after decades does not prove any title on the original
appellant. The purported absence of conveyance documents
during the period 01.01.1964 to 31.12.1999 does not confer
title. The title has to be independently proved and established.
Annexure A1 does not invalidate the documents produced by
the respondent which were relied on by the Sub Court to
render the impugned judgment. Documents relied on by the 1 st
respondent continue to be reliable and Annexure A1 does not
even cast a shadow of doubt on said documents.
7. Discussion and analysis :
I have heard both sides in detail and have perused the
records. The bone of contention between the parties relates to the
title over the acquired property and the right to claim the
compensation amounts lying in deposit. The Sub Court is seen to
have elaborately considered the evidence on record. The appellant/s
had only produced a single document Ext.E1 which is the copy of a
written statement filed by the respondent in a suit of the year 1969.
The contention put forth based on Ext.E1 is that the admission
therein that the property is jointly owned with the appellant, binds the
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
1st respondent and negates the stance taken by her based on
Exts.D1 to D6. Even in this LA.Appeal the attempt made by the
appellant/s is to bolster the said contention by producing Annexure
A1 which, according to the appellant/s, when read along with the
admission in Ext.E1 would evidence that the respondent had made
an admission regarding the joint ownership of the original appellant
over the property. On this point, I find legal merit in the observation
of the learned Sub Judge that title to a property has to be
independently proved and established by producing legally reliable
documents. Even though a faint contention had been put forth by the
appellant that he is in possession of the tax receipts and is ready to
produce the same, it is noted that no documents other than
Annexure A1 had been produced, to substantiate the title claimed by
the appellant/s. The same buttresses the contention of the
respondent that the claim of being in possession of additional
documents is merely a charade and devoid of any bonafides.
Nothing has been brought to my notice to term the appreciation of
Exts.D1 to D6 by the learned Sub Judge as erroneous. They are
found to be legally reliable documents which clearly substantiate the
claims put forth by the respondent regarding her title. The reliance
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
placed by the learned Judge on Exts.X1 and X2 also cannot be
termed as faulty. The said documents are produced from the legal
custody and possession of the concerned officials and are found
reliable. There has been a total absence of any effort on the part of
the appellant/s to prove title. The contentions put forth based on the
purported admission by the respondent in a written statement and
the mere absence of any document to prove that he had executed
any conveyance transferring the property to the respondent during
the periods 01.01.1964 to 31.12.1999 as sought to be proved by the
production of Annexure A1 document are not substitutes for
positively proving the title that appellant/s claims over the acquired
property. Ext.D6 which is termed a ‘Thandapper kanakku’ read along
with tax receipts from 1979 onwards to 1990 substantiates the claim
of the respondent. Ext.D4 judgment and Exts.X1 and X2 add on to
the evidence in favour of the title of the respondent. Even assuming
that there is merit in the reliance placed on the dictum in Manakkal
Nandakumar (supra), the same by itself is incapable of winning this
appeal for the appellant/s. Further Exts.X1 and X2 documents relied
on by the respondent remain unchallenged. The purported reliance
on the dictum in Santhosh Jacob (supra) that revenue officials
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
cannot confer title does not plug the total lack of evidence regarding
the existence of or vesting of title upon the appellant/s. The dictum in
Moksh Builders and Financiers (supra) that the admission duly
proved are admissible evidence irrespective of whether the party
making them appeared in the witness box or not, is a totally
inadequate substitute for evidence regarding title. Though it is trite
as laid down in Synudheen (supra) that mutations carried out in
favour of a party have no value in the eye of law as regards the
question of titular rights over the property, the same are not the sole
reliance placed by the 1st respondent and are seen produced only to
buttress the claim put forth.
Conclusion:
In view of the above, there are no valid reasons to interfere
with the judgment and decree dated 06.06.1996 in LAR No.33 of
1994 of the IInd Additional Sub Court, Thiruvananthapuram. LAA
No.675 of 2002 is dismissed. All interlocutory applications filed in the
LAA stand closed.
Sd/SYAM KUMAR V.M.
JUDGE
csl
LA.APP. NO.675/2002
2025:KER:29931
APPENDIX OF LA.APP. 675/2002
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A1
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE NO. 1141/2024
DATED 1-2-2025 ISSUED BY SUB REGISTRAR
OFFICE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review