Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.02.17
TELEN KOM Date:
11:11:09 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.111 of 2023
1. Shri Thokchom Purnachandra Singh, aged about 71 years, S/o (L) Th.
Kullabidhu Singh, resident of Thangmeiband Lourung Purel Leikai, PO & PS
Imphal, District, Imphal West, Manipur.
2. Shri Laishram Arenkumar Singh, aged about 51 years, S/o L. Ibobi Singh,
resident of Nagamapal Singjubung Leirak, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
3. Shri Hijam Nutanchandra Singh, aged about 55 years, S/o Hijam
Gunachandra Singh, a resident of Thangmeiband Thingel Leikai, PO & PS
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur- 795001.
…Petitioners
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur through the Commissioner (MAHUD), Govt. of
Manipur, Old Secretariat Block, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
2. The Director (MAHUD), PDA Complex, near 2nd M.R. Gate, PO & PS
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
3. The Imphal Municipal Corporation represented by its Municipal
Commissioner, Imphal Municipal Corporation, Manipur having its office
at Imphal Municipal Corporation Complex, Kangla Park PO Imphal, P.S.
Imphal P.S. City Police Station, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
…Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
:
Mr Th. Khagemba, Advocate,
For the Respondents
:
Mr. M. Devananda, Addl.AG & Mr.
L.Raju, Adv for private respondent.
Date of hearing
:
09.02.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
14.02.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
1. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners to quash the
impugned order and notice dated 17.1.2023 and to direct the respondents to
de-reserve Ward Nos.2, 3 and 4 by treating the said Wards as an
unreserved/general seat enabling all candidates, including the petitioners to
contest the Imphal Municipal Corporation, 2023.
2.
Assailing the impugned notification and order dated 17.1.2023, Mr.KH.
Khagemba, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that this Court, in its
order dated 23.5.2022 in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021 directed the respondents to
give reasonable opportunities of being heard to the explanatory note placed
before this Court and before finalization and publication of the reservation policy
for Imphal Municipal Corporation. However, the same was not complied, rather
violated the order of this Court and issued the notification dated 5.10.2022 for
holding lottery on 7.10.2022 at 10 a.m. at GM Hall. The
learned
counsel
would submit that the notification dated 5.10.2022 has not been given effect in
view of the order dated 13.10.2022 and the explanatory note for reservation
placed before this Court has not been furnished to all the interested parties.
3. The learned counsel further submitted that the erstwhile Imphal
Municipal Council was upgraded to a separate and larger entity and status as
Imphal Municipal Corporation from the year 2015 and after the existence of
Imphal Municipal Corporation, no lottery was held for reservation for Women,
General and ST.
The earlier reservation from the beginning was full of
irregularities. According to the learned counsel for the petitioners, there should
be 33% reservation for Women and in a continuous 3 terms (cycle), there
should be only one term reservation for Women for a Ward. As such, the
reservation should be done afresh for Imphal Municipal Corporation after its
existence as Corporation without any connection with the erstwhile Imphal
Municipal Council.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioner then submitted that the
representation of the petitioners was rejected without any cogent reasons and
on the same day, the Commissioner, MAHUD, Government of Manipur issued
the impugned notification, thereby finalizing the reservation of seats in respect
of Imphal Municipal Corporation without publishing the explanatory note nor
finalization as directed by this Court in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021.
5. The learned counsel next submitted that one of the Ex-Corporator of
Ward No.19 has challenged the impugned order dated 17.1.2023 in W.P.(C)
No.63 of 2023 on various grounds, including the post-decisional hearing of
objection of Corporators and, this Court, by the order dated 24.1.2023, stayed
the notification in regard to Ward No.19.
In the same manner, one
Hajarimayum Bobby Sharma of Ward No.5 has filed W.P.(C) No.71 of 2023
and, by the order dated 27.1.2023, this Court, stayed the notification dated
17.1.2023 in regard to Ward No.5.
6. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the reservation
of seats in different categories in Ward Nos.2, 3 and 4 of Imphal Municipal
Corporation has to be done by strictly following Rule 109 of Manipur
Municipalities (Election of Councillors) Rules, 1994. The learned counsel for
the petitioners urged that as the reservation of seats in different categories has
not been followed properly since 1995, all the earlier reservation of seats cannot
be taken into account and a fresh reservation has to be done in order to
streamline proper reservation policy in the Imphal Municipal Corporation.
Thus, a prayer has been made to set aside the impugned notification and order
and to direct the respondents to de-reserve Ward Nos.2, 3 and 4 by treating
the said Wards as unreserved.
7. Per contra, Mr. M. Devananda, learned Additional Advocate General
appearing for the respondents, submitted that the reservation of seats for
SC/ST, SC/ST (Women) and Women of all 27 ULBs of Manipur was done as
provided under Section 17 of the Manipur Municipalities Act, 1994 read with
Rule 107(1) of the Manipur Municipalities (Election of Councillors) Rules, 1994.
The representation of the petitioners was duly considered by the respondent
authorities and passed the impugned order and also issued the impugned
notification.
8. The learned Additional Advocate General further submitted that since
the impugned order and notification have been passed strictly in accordance
with the applicable Rules, the same cannot be interfered with. Further, the
petitioners cannot seek quashing of the impugned notice dated 17.1.2023 on
the whole alleging that the same is in contradiction of the order passed in
W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the writ
petition.
9. This Court considered the submissions made by learned counsel
appearing on either side and also perused the materials available on record.
10. The petitioners challenged the impugned order and notification firstly
on the ground that the respondents have violated the direction of this Court
passed in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021. Secondly, the respondents issued notice
dated 5.10.2022 which is also in violation of the order passed in W.P.(C) No.396
of 2021. Thirdly, draw of lot was done on 7.10.2022 in violation of the order of
this Court.
Fourthly, the respondents issued notice dated 13.10.2022 in
violation of the interim order dated 13.10.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.850 of
2022.
11. According to the petitioners, the conduct of the respondent
authorities in issuing notices dated 5.10.2022 and 13.10.2022 amount to sitting
over the Hon’ble Court’s direction passed in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021. In other
words, the notification dated 171.2023 is even more serious, as the reservation
policy cannot be finalized without finalizing and publishing the explanatory note.
Likewise, the impugned notice dated 17.1.2023 is illegal and void ab initio, as
it has no foundation.
12. On the other hand, it is the say of the respondent authorities that the
impugned order and notification have been issued pursuant to the direction of
this Court in W.P.(C) No.1121 of 2022 dated 29.12.2022 and, therefore, there
is no infirmity in it. Moreover, the respondent authorities have not violated the
orders of this Court made in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021.
13. As could be seen from the records, by a notification dated 28.2.2014,
the whole notified area in respect of the Imphal Municipal Council in Imphal
West and Imphal East Districts have been declared as Municipal Corporation
with effect from the said date.
Pursuant to coming into force the Manipur
Municipalities Act, 1994, the first reservation was made for the Imphal Municipal
Corporation and other Municipal Councils for reservation of Women under
Section 17(1)(ii) and (iii) of the Act and rotational reservations have been done
at Ward Nos.2, 4, 7, 9, 11, 17, 18 and 20 respectively for total number of 26
Wards, including ST Women Ward Nos.5 and 25 respectively. Subsequently,
the total Wards have been increased from 26 to 27 and, as per the notification
dated 20.4.2021, for the 27 Wards, reservations have been done, which
according to the petitioners is not in accordance with the provisions of the
Imphal Municipalities Act, 1994.
14. According to the petitioners, by a notification dated 6.5.2016, the
reservation for Women, including ST Women, have been reserved at Ward
Nos.21 and 22 and Women ST Ward No.21 and reservation has been done at
Ward Nos.1, 2, 6, 10, 12, 14, 15, 21, 23 and 24. Further, by a notification dated
24.4.2011, the reservation for Women has been given at Ward Nos.22, 25 and
26 and Ward No.26 is for Women. Altogether, reservation has been done at
Ward Nos.1, 6, 7, 11, 14, 17, 20, 26 and 27 respectively without following the
provisions of the Act.
Further, by another notification dated 27.4.2016,
reservation for ST Women has been done at Ward No.1, 21 and 24 and for
other Women reservation including ST Women at Ward Nos.8, 12, 16, 18, 19,
22, 23, 24 and 25 etc., which are incorrect.
15. The case of the petitioners is that reservations for the Women have
to be allotted by rotation to different Ward in a Municipalities. However, the
rotational reservations for Women have not been strictly followed and,
therefore, a suitable direction needs to be issued by this Court for strict
implementation of Section 17(1)(ii) and (iii) of the Act and also Rules 107, 108
and 109 of the Manipur Municipalities (Election of Councillors) Rules, 1994
while making reservations for Women and ST candidates under the Imphal
Municipal Corporation.
16. Being unsatisfied with the alleged irregular reservation and praying
for implement of Section 17(1)(ii) and (iii) of the Act, the petitioners and others
have filed W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021, wherein the petitioners have also sought
for reservation of seats for both Male and Female including the reservation of
the office of the Chairperson/Major, Vice Chairperson/Deputy Mayor of the
Imphal Municipal Corporation with effect from 28.2.2014 before holding the next
election.
17. By the order dated 23.5.2022, this Court disposed of W.P.(C) No.396
of 2021. The operative portion of the order reads thus:
“In view of the submissions made above, the present writ petition is
hereby disposed of by directing the respondents to give a
reasonable opportunity to all the present Caretaker Councillors to
submit objections/suggestions and also a reasonable opportunity of
being heard before finalization and publication of the said
reservation policy contained in the said explanatory note.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is disposed
of.”
18. The MAHUD has also prepared the explanatory note on seats to be
reserved for the election of Corporators of Imphal Municipal Corporation for the
year 2021 and also the explanatory note on reservation of seat for the office of
the Mayor, Imphal Municipal Corporation for the year 2021. On 5.10.2022, the
Deputy Secretary (MAHUD) issued a notification whereby informing to draw lots
in connection with the reservation of seats for SC/ST, SC/ST Women and
General (Women) for the ensuing General Election to 27 Urban Local Bodies,
Manipur, including Imphal Municipal Corporation, 2022. In this connection, the
said authority also requested all the MLAs, whose Assembly Constituencies are
included in the Imphal Municipal Areas and 26 other ULBs, all leaders of various
political parties, District Collectors concerned to participate during draw of lots.
19. Challenging and aggrieved by the notification dated 5.10.2022, two
former Councillors/Corporators have filed W.P.(C) No.850 of 2022 before this
Court. This Court, by the interim order dated 13.10.2022, directed the
respondents not to take up any further action pursuant to the impugned
notification dated 5.10.2022 without the leave of the Court. On the same day
i.e. on 13.10.2022, the Commissioner, MAHUD, issued a notification calling for
objections/suggestions
from
the
Ex-Corporators
of
Imphal
Municipal
Corporation in respect of the reservation policy for SC/ST, SC/ST (W) and
Women within 15 days from the date of receipt of the notification, failing which,
it will be presumed that there is nothing to say/submit to the reservation policy,
and it will be finalized ex-parte. It is seen that draw of lots for reservation of
SC/ST, SC/ST(W) and Women was conducted on 7.10.2022 and objections
were also called for from the Ex-Corporators in respect of the reservation policy.
20. On 19.10.2022, the petitioners and other Ex-Councillors/Corporators
have jointly submitted a representation to the Commissioner, MAHUD, stating
that they are not furnishing any suggestions or objections to the notification
dated 13.10.2022 at that stage. However, in the said representation, they have
given their suggestions and objections after the disposal of the pending writ
petition.
On a perusal of the said representation, it is seen that the Ex-
Councillors/Corporators have given solutions for the issue and finally prayed to
restore Caretaker Mayor along with Standing Committees/Councillors
immediately to avoid further commission of irregularities.
21. On a perusal of the records, two of the petitioners herein have
challenged the notification dated 13.10.2022 by filing W.P.(C) No.1121 of 2022
with a prayer to finalize the reservation policy of Imphal Municipal Corporation,
2022. By the order dated 29.12.2022, this Court disposed of the said writ
petition. The order reads thus:
“Heard Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents No.1 and 2 and Mr. U.Augusta, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent No.3.
The grievances raised by the petitioners in the present writ petition is
that pursuant to the direction given by this court in its order dated
13.10.2022 passed in WP(C) No.850 of 2022, the Commissioner
(MAHUD), Government of Manipur issued a Notification dated
13.10.2022 thereby inviting suggestions/objections from the ExCorporators of Imphal Municipal Corporation in respect of the
Reservation Policy for SC/ST, SC/ST (Women) and Women within 15
days from the date of receipt of the said notification.
The case of the petitioners is that the action of the authorities in calling
the objections under the said notification has been done by way of post
decision inasmuch as the authorities have already taken decision with
regard to the Reservation Policy.
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned Government Advocate as well as Mr.
U.Augusta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents vehemently
submitted that the authorities have not taken any final decision with
regard to the Reservation Policy for SC/ST, SC/ST (Women) and
Women and that the said notification has been issued in compliance
with the order passed by this court.
As the election of the People’s Representatives in the local bodies
cannot be postponed indefinitely, this court is of the considered view
that the present writ petition can be disposed of with the following
directions:(i)
The petitioners or any Ex-Corporators of the Imphal
Municipal Corporation, who are willing and interested in
submitting objection pursuant to the notification dated
13.10.2022
are
given
liberty
to
submit
their
suggestions/objections with regard to the Reservation Policy
for SC/ST, SC/ST (Women) and Women to the concerned
authorities.
Such
suggestions/objections
should
be
submitted within a period of 10 (ten) days from today.
(ii)
In the event of submitting such suggestions/objections within
the stipulated period, the concerned authorities of the State
Government are directed to consider and taken a final
decision with regard to the Reservation Policy for SC/ST,
SC/ST (Women) and Women within a period of 15 days from
the last date of receipt of the suggestions/objections by
interest parties.”
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is disposed of.”
22. On 6.1.2023, the petitioners 1 and 2 have jointly preferred their
objection/suggestion to the Commissioner, MAHUD, wherein they have stated
that the draw of lot conducted on 7.10.2022 is in violation of the order of this
Court passed in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021 and that the explanatory note has not
been furnished to the interested parties till date.
23. All along when the petitioners challenging the notifications of the
respondent authorities by filing various writ petitions, they have not raised a
plea that they have not been served with the explanatory note and for the first
time in the representation dated 6.1.2023 the petitioners have stated that the
explanatory note has not been furnished to them. If really, they were not served
with the explanatory note, the petitioners would have brought to the notice of
this Court when W.P.(C) No.1121 of 2022 was taken up for hearing. Further,
in their representation dated 19.10.2022 also, the petitioners have not stated
anything about the non-supply of the explanatory note. Only after knowing the
contents of the explanatory note, the petitioners have submitted their
representations and agitating the issue before this Court. Therefore, the nonfurnishing of the explanatory note to them pleaded and canvassed by the
petitioners cannot be countenanced.
24. On a perusal of the representation dated 6.1.2023, the petitioners
prayed to settle the issue amicably by conducting a fresh reservation lottery
from the date of existence of Imphal Municipal Corporation i.e. 2015 without
any connection or reference with the erstwhile Imphal Municipal Council. The
said prayer of the petitioners is also beyond what was prayed in W.P.(C)
No.1121 of 2022 and the directions issued by this Court therein and also the
earlier directions of this Court in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021.
25. After considering the representation of the petitioners, the
Commissioner, MAHUD, Government of Manipur, has passed the impugned
order dated 17.1.2023, which reads thus:
“No.CCe-301/2/2023-MAHUD-MAHUD:
Whereas,
Shri
L.Arenkumar singh, Ward No.4 and Shri Th. Purnachandra Singh,
Ward No.2, Ex-Councillors, IMC have filed a representation
submitting their objections/suggestions to MAHUD Department in
pursuance of Hon’be High Court of Manipur’s order dated
29.12.2022 passed in connection with W.P.(C) No.1121 of 2022;
2. Whereas, the Hon’ble High Court of Manipur vide order dated
29.12.2022 passed in connection with W.P.(C) No.1121 of 2022 has
given liberty to the petitioners or any ex-Corporators of the Imphal
Municipal Corporation who are willing and interested in submitting
objection pursuant to the notification dated 13.10.2022 to submit
their suggestion/objections with regard to the reservation policy for
SC/ST, SC/ST (Women) and Women to the concerned authorities
within a period of 10 (ten) days from the date of order;
3. Whereas, draw of lots for reservation of SC/ST, SC/ST (Women)
and Women for conducting election to the 27 (twenty-seven) ULBs
was conducted on 7.10.2022 and no further action has been taken
up in compliance of Hon’ble High Court of Manipur’s order dated
13.10.2022 passed in connection with W.P.(C) No.850 of 2022;
4. Whereas, the reservation of seats for SC/ST, SC/ST (Women)
and Women of all the 27 (twenty-seven) ULBs of Manipur is done
as provided under Section 17 of the Manipur Municipalities Act,
1994 read with Rule 107(1) of the Manipur Municipalities (Election
of Councillors) Rules, 1994. Further, the population date is based
on Census, 2011;
5. Whereas, as per section 2(34) of the Manipur Municipalities Act,
1994, “Municipality” means the Nagar Panchayat or the Municipal
Council or the Municipal Corporation, as the case may be,
constituted under the provision of this Act;
6. Now, thereof the request made for conducting fresh reservation
lottery after coming into existence of the Imphal Municipal
Corporation in 2015 is untenable, unjustified and without any valid
reasons.
4. The representation filed by Shri L.Arenkumar Singh, Ward No.4
and Shri Th. Purhachandra Singh, Ward No.2, Ex-Councilors, IMC
submitting their objections/suggestions in pursuance of Hon’ble
High Court of Manipur’s order dated 29.12.2022 poassed in
connection with W.P.(C) No.1121 of 2022 stands disposed of
accordingly.”
26. On 17.1.2023, the Commissioner, MAHUD, also issued a notification
to finalize and to notify the reservation of seats for SC/ST, SC/ST (Women) and
Women in respect of Imphal Municipal Corporation as per the result of the
lottery held on 7.10.2022, as it was done as per rules without any defect. The
publication of the reservation policy contained in the explanatory note has been
consulted with the all concerned during the meeting held on 7.10.2022, which
would be evident from the notification dated 13.10.2022, wherein it has been
stated as under:
“F.No.ELECT-201/1/2020-MAHUD-MAHUD-Part(3): Whereas, the
State Government took a decision to hold the general elections to
Imphal Municipal Corporation and the 26 Urban Local Bodies in the
month of November 2022.
2. AND, WHEREAS, a draw of lots for reservation of SC/ST, SC/ST
(W) and Women was conducted on 07.10.2022 at G.M. Hall for the
27 ULBs including Imphal Municipal Corporation.
3. AND, WHEREAS, the Hon’ble High Court’s in its Orders and
Judgement dated 23.05.2021 passed in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021
directed the Respondents to give a reasonable opportunity ot all the
present Caretaker Councillors to submit objections/suggestions and
also a reasonable opportunity of being heard being finalization and
publication of the said reservation policy contained in the said
explanatory note;
4. NOW, THEREFORE, the Governor of Manipur is pleased to invite
objections/suggestions from the Ex-Corporators of Imphal Municipal
Corporation in respect of the reservation policy for SC/ST, SC/ST
(W) and Women as annexed at Annexure “A” and “B” to the
Government within 15 (fifteen) days from the date of receipt of this
notification, failing which, it will be presumed that there is nothing to
say/submit to the reservation policy, and it will be finalized ex-parte.”
27. Challenging the notification dated 17.1.2023, two writ petitions,
namely, W.P.(C) Nos.63 and 71 of 2023 have been filed in respect of Ward
Nos.19 and 5 respectively and, this Court, by separate orders dated 24.1.2023
and 27.1.2023, granted interim stay of operation of the impugned notification
dated 17.1.2023 in respect of Ward Nos.19 and 5 of the Imphal Municipal
Corporation till the next date. The said writ petitions are directed to be listed
on 16.2.2023.
28. In the instant case, the petitioners have challenged both the order
dated 17.1.2023 and the notification dated 17.1.2023. As far as the order dated
17.1.2023 impugned herein is concerned, this Court is of the view that the same
has been passed pursuant to the direction of this Court in W.P.(C) No.1121 of
2023 and taking note of all the relevant facts and circumstances of the case put
forth by the petitioners as well as the other Ex-Councillors. Therefore, this
Court is not inclined to interfere with the same.
29. Coming to the impugned notification dated 17.1.2023 is concerned,
the respondent authorities have conducted lots in respect of Ward Nos.2, 3 and
4 taking note of the factual scenario and also as per the provisions of the Act
and Rules. Therefore, there is no question of de-reserve of Ward Nos.2, 3 and
4 would arise as pleaded by the petitioners. That apart, the grievance of the
petitioners is that the reservation is in contradiction of the order passed in
W.P.(C) No.396 of 2021 and the explanatory note has not been published till
date.
30. On a perusal of the explanatory note, the details of seat reservation
of the SC/ST and Women in the 1st and 2nd duration and to be reserved in the
3rd duration have been tabulated, where from, this Court is able to see that
Ward Nos.2, 3 and 4 have been reserved for General (W) taking note of the
population and also in compliance of the provisions of the Act and Rules.
Therefore, this Court finds no infirmity in the reservation done in respect of
Ward Nos.2, 3 and 4. Further, the records produced by the petitioners show
that they have participated in the lots for reservation conducted on 7.10.2022.
Having participated in the lots, the petitioners cannot now challenge the
reservation in respect of Ward Nos.2, 3 and 4 made by the respondent
authorities. Only considering the ground situation and applying the applicable
laws, the respondent authorities have reserved Ward Nos.2, 3 and 4 as General
(W). When the respondent State has taken a policy decision, exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the High Court cannot
interfere with the same. Since the interim orders passed in W.P.(C) No.63 and
71 of 2023 pertains to Ward Nos.5 and 19, the said interim orders are not
applicable to the facts of this case.
31. For all the reasons stated above, this Court is of the view that there
is no merit in the writ petition. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. There
will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review