Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHOUGRAKPAM
DEVANANDA
SINGH
[1]
SHOUGRAKPAM DEVANANDA
SINGH
Date: 2025.09.01 16:28:20
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Shri Thingbaijam Naresh Kumar, aged about 44, S/o (L) Th.
Kulabidhu Singh, resident of Sagolband Nepra Menjor Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District: Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
... Petitioner
-Versus-
1. The State of Manipur through the Commissioner
(Education/S), Government of Manipur, New Secretariat
Building, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur – 795001.
2. The Director of Education (Schools), Government of
Manipur, Lamphelpat, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795004.
… Official respondents
3. Shri Victor Konsam, aged about 39 years, Assistant
Engineer, Education Engineering Wing, Education-S
Department, Government of Manipur, resident of Khurai
Konsam Leikai, P.O. Lamlong, P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur – 795010.
4. Shri Leishangthem Mahindra Kumar Singh, OBC(M),
aged about 40 years, C/o the Director of Education
(Schools), Government of Manipur, Lamphelpat, P.O. &
P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795004.
5. Shri MK Thekho John Pao, aged about 54 years, C/o the
Director of Education (Schools), Government of Manipur,
Lamphelpat, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District,
Manipur – 795004.
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[2]
6. Smt. Huidrom Victoria Devi (Gen.), aged about 37 years,
C/o the Director of Education (Schools), Government of
Manipur, Lamphelpat, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795004.
7. Smt. Samira Begum (Gen.), aged about 35 years, C/o the
Director of Education (Schools), Government of Manipur,
Lamphelpat, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District,
Manipur – 795004.
… Private Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the petitioner
::
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, Sr. Advocate
asstd. by Ms. Julekha Khan, Advocate.
For the respondents
::
Mr. S. Nepolean, GA;
Mr. H.S. Paonam, Sr. Advocate asstd.
by Mr. A. Sushruta, Advocate;
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Sr. Advocate asstd.
by Mr. Th. Ningtamba, Advocate &
Mr. S. Rupachandra, Sr. Advocate
asstd. by Mr. Royal Ray, Advocate
Date of hearing
::
26-08-2025
Date of judgment & order ::
01-09-2025
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel assisted
by Ms. Julekha Khan, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner;
Mr. S. Nepolean, learned GA appearing for the respondents No. 1 and
2, Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. A. Sushruta,
learned counsel appearing for the respondents No. 3, 4 and 5,
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Th. Ningtamba,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 6 and Mr. S.
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[3]
Rupachandra, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Royal Ray,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 7 .
In this petition, the dispute between the parties is about the
fixation of seniority position of the petitioner and respondents No. 3 to 7,
who are serving as Assistant Engineers in the Engineering Wing of the
Department of Education (Schools). Having been aggrieved by the
fixation of his seniority position in the Final Seniority List of the Assistant
Engineers of Education Engineering Wing, Department of Education (S),
the petitioner filed the present writ petition assailing the Final Seniority
List dated 11-09-2024 issued by the Secretariat: Education (S),
Department, Government of Manipur.
[2]
The facts of the present case are simple and undisputed. For
the purpose of engaging against 17 (seventeen) different categories of
posts, including 1 (one) post of Executive Engineer and 10 (ten) posts of
Assistant Engineers, on contract basis, the State Project Director, SSA
State Mission Authority, Manipur, issued a Notification dated 21-02-2011
inviting applications from interested and eligible candidates. In response
to the said Notification, the respondents No. 3 to 7 submitted their
application forms and the petitioner also submitted his application form
applying for both the said two different posts of Executive Engineer and
Assistant Engineers.
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[4]
[3]
Upon completion of the selection process, the Principal
Secretary (Education-S), Government of Manipur, issued a Notification
dated 17-04-2012 notifying the list of selected candidates and also the
candidates in the Waiting List for engagement on contract basis. As
per the said Notification, the petitioner was selected for the post of
Executive Engineer and the mark he obtained is shown as 53.847,
however, he was not selected for the post of Assistant Engineer and his
name was included in the Waiting List. All the private respondents No. 3
to 7 were selected for the posts of Assistant Engineers. As per the said
Notification, the merit position and the marks scored by the respondents
No. 3 to 7 and the petitioner are as under:“ASSISTANT ENGINEER (CIVIL) – LIST OF SELECTED CANDIDATES
UN-RESERVED
NAME OF THE CANDIDATE
SL.
NO.
ROLL NO.
CAT.
SCORE
1.
KONSAM VICTOR SINGH
9/IE
GEN
62.871
2.
KHWAIRAKPAM SACHIDANANDA
3/BISH
SC
60.122
3.
HELIYA KEISHAM
10/IE
GEN
57.943
4.
LEISHANGTHEM MAHINDRAKUMAR
SINGH
926/TBL
OBC (M)
57.698
5.
NARENGBAM LIVINGSTONE SINGH
34/SPO
OBC(M)
56.994
ROLL NO.
CAT.
SCORE
50/SPO
OBC(M)
55.977
ROLL NO.
CAT.
SCORE
OBC MEITEI
SL.
NO.
NAME OF THE CANDIDATE
1.
MOIRANGTHEM ROMEN SINGH
SCHEDULED TRIBE
SL.
NO.
NAME OF THE CANDIDATE
1.
MEIRINGMEI MAKUTHUI
27/SPO
ST
51.767
2.
M.K. THEKHO JOHN PAO
1/SPT
ST
49.901
3.
VICTOR KAMEI
63/SPO
ST
47.621
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[5]
ASSISTANT ENGINEER (CIVIL) – WAITING LIST
UN-RESERVED
W/L
NO.
NAME OF THE CANDIDATE
ROLL NO.
CAT.
SCORE
1.
HUIDROM VICTORIA DEVI
60/SPO
GEN
56.588
2.
SAMIRA BEGUM
12/SPO
GEN
55.049
ROLL NO.
CAT
SCORE
61/SPO
OBC (M)
53.509
ROLL NO.
CAT
SCORE
OBC-MEITEI
W/L
NO.
1.
NAME OF THE CANDIDATE
THIGBAIJAM NARESH KUMAR
SCHEDULED TRIBE
W/L
NO.
[4]
NAME OF THE CANDIDATE
1.
KAIGOULAL KIPGEN
200/SPT
ST
47.382
2.
DANGMEI GAIGAMLONG R. NAGA
30/SPO
ST
43.929
Consequent upon their selection, the petitioner was appointed
as Executive Engineer while the respondents No. 3 to 7 were appointed
as Assistant Engineers on contract basis and the period of their contract
service was extended from time to time. After about four years from the
date of their initial appointment and while they were serving on contract
basis, the State Government created substantive posts in the rank of
Executive Engineer and Assistant Engineers and against the newly
created posts, the services of the petitioner and nine other incumbents
including the respondents No. 3 to 7 were regularised as Assistant
Engineers by issuing an order dated 16-12-2016. At para. 5 of the said
order, it is mentioned that the seniority of the employees whose services
have been regularised shall be determined later on. It is on record that
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[6]
no one including the present petitioner and the respondents No. 3 to 7
challenged either their initial appointment on contract basis or the
regularisation of their service as Assistant Engineers under the aforesaid
order dated 16-12-2016 issued by the Commissioner (Education-S),
Government of Manipur and they all accepted such appointments
without any objection or protest.
[5]
After about eight years from the date of their regularisation as
AE, the Secretariat: Education Department issued a Notification dated
29-07-2024 notifying the Tentative Inter-se Seniority List of Assistant
Engineers of Education Engineering Wing under Education-S Dept.,
Government of Manipur inviting claims and objections. The Inter-se
Seniority position of the 10 (ten) Assistant Engineers were fixed on the
basis of the marks obtained by them at the time of their selection for
appointment as Assistant Engineers on contract basis. In the said
Tentative Seniority List, the name of the petitioner is placed at Sl. No. 5,
the name of the respondent No. 3 at Sl. No. 1, the name of the
respondent No. 4 at Sl. No. 2, the name of the respondent No. 5 at
Sl. No. 7, the name of the respondent No. 6 at Sl. No. 3 and the name
of the respondent No. 7 at Sl. No. 4.
[6]
After considering the claims and objections submitted in
connection with the said Tentative Seniority List, the Commissioner,
Education (S), Government of Manipur, issued a Notification dated
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[7]
11-09-2024 notifying the Final Seniority List of Assistant Engineers
of the Education Engineering Wing, Department of Education (S),
Government of Manipur. In the said Final Seniority List, the name of the
petitioner is placed at Sl. No. 6, the respondent No. 3 at Sl. No. 1, the
respondent No. 4 at Sl. No. 2, the respondent No. 5 at Sl. No. 3, the
respondent No. 6 at Sl. No. 4 and the respondent No. 7 at Sl. No. 5.
Having been aggrieved, the petitioner challenged the said Final Seniority
List by filing the present writ petition.
[7]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioner submitted that the petitioner was initially selected and
appointed as Executive Engineer on contract basis and he rendered
service as Executive Engineer on contract basis for a period of about
four years. It has also been submitted that at the time of issuing the
regularisation order dated 16-12-2016 regularizing the services of the
petitioner as well as the respondents No. 3 to 7 as Assistant Engineers,
the name of the petitioner was placed at Sl. No. 1 in the said order,
therefore, while fixing the inter-se seniority of the petitioner and the
respondents No. 3 to 7, seniority position of the petitioner should be
placed above the respondents No. 3 to 7. The senior counsel further
submitted that as there was no selection process or comparative merit
of the nine Assistant Engineers, including the petitioner and the
respondents No. 3 to 7 at the time of their regularisation as Assistant
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[8]
Engineers, the inter-se seniority of the said nine Assistant Engineers
whose services were regularized by the said order dated 16-12-2016
should be based on their personal age.
Alternatively, it has also been submitted by the learned senior
counsel that as the petitioner was initially appointed to the higher post of
Executive Engineer on contract basis and rendered service as Executive
Engineer for about four years before his regularisation as AE and as the
petitioner was placed at Sl. No. 1 in the regularisation order of the
petitioner and the respondents No. 3 to 7, the petitioner is entitled to be
placed above the private respondents No 3 to 7 at the time of fixation of
their Final Inter-se Seniority.
[8]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel further submitted
that the methodology or criteria adopted by the Selection Committee at
the time of consideration for selection of the candidates and for
preparation of their Merit List or rather for awarding marks was never
notified or made known to the candidates and as such, fixation of the
inter-se seniority of the petitioner and the respondents No. 3 to 7 on the
basis of the marks obtained by them at the time of selection process for
appointment as AE on contract basis is arbitrary and unreasonable and
should not be permitted.
[9]
It has also been submitted by Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned
senior counsel that placing of the respondent No. 5 at Sl. No. 3 in the
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[9]
Final Seniority List is not at all permissible in law as he secured
only 49.901 marks as reflected in the Tentative Seniority List dated
29-07-2024 and that even if the petitioner is in the Waiting List, he
secured more marks than the respondent No. 5 and therefore, his name
must be placed above the respondent No. 5 if the inter-se seniority is
fixed on the basis of the marks obtained by them.
In support of his contentions, the learned senior counsel cited
the following case laws:1. (2024) 2 SCC 1 “Tej Prakash Pathak & ors. Vs. Rajasthan
High Court & ors.” wherein it has been held as under:“35. The discernible ratio in K. Manjusree is that the criterion for
selection is not to be changed after completion of the
selection process, though in absence of rules to the contrary
the Selection Committee may fix minimum marks either for
written examination or for interview for the purposes of
selection. But if such minimum marks are fixed, it must be
done before commencement of selection process. This view
has been followed by another three-Judge Bench of this
Court in Ramesh Kumar v. High Court of Delhi wherein the
law on the issue has been summarised thus: (SCC p. 109.
para 15)
"15. … in case the statutory rules prescribe a particular
mode of selection, it has to be given strict adherence
accordingly. In case, no procedure is prescribed by the
rules and there is no other impediment in law, the
competent authority while laying down the norms for
selection may prescribe for the tests and further specify
the minimum benchmarks for written test as well as for
viva voce."
“51. What is clear from above is that the object of any process of
selection for entry into a public service is to ensure that a
person most suitable for the post is selected. What is
suitable for one post may not be for the other. Thus, a degree
of discretion is necessary to be left to the employer to devise
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[10]
its method/procedure to select a candidate most suitable for
the post albeit subject to the overarching principles
enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution as also
the rules/statute governing service and reservation.”
"52. Thus, in our view, the appointing authority/recruiting
authority/ competent authority, in absence of rules to the
contrary, can devise a procedure for selection of a candidate
suitable to the post and while doing so it may also set
benchmarks for different stages of the recruitment process
including written examination and interview. However, if any
such benchmark is set, the same should be stipulated
before the commencement of the recruitment process. But
if the extant Rules or the advertisement inviting applications
empower the competent authority to set benchmarks at
different stages of the recruitment process, then such
benchmarks may be set any time before that stage is
reached so that neither the candidate nor the evaluator/
examiner/interviewer is taken by surprise.”
“53. The decision in K. Manjusree does not proscribe setting of
benchmarks for various stages of the recruitment process
but mandates that it should not be set after the stage is over,
in other words after the game has already been played. This
view is in consonance with the rule against arbitrariness
enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution and meets the
legitimate expectation of the candidates as also the
requirement of transparency in recruitment to public
services and thereby obviates malpractices in preparation
of select list.”
2. 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2316 “Salam Samarjeet Singh Vs.
High Court of Manipur at Imphal & anr.” wherein it has
been held as under:“31. In the present case, no notice was given to the petitioner
regarding the imposition of minimum 40% marks for
interview. Prescribing minimum marks for viva voce segment
may be justified for the holistic assessment of a candidate,
but in the present case such a requirement was introduced
only after commencement of the recruitment process and in
violation of the statutory rules. The decision of the Full Court
to depart from the expected exercise of preparing the merit
list as per the unamended Rules is clearly violative of the
substantive legitimate expectation of the petitioners. It also
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[11]
fails the tests of fairness, consistency, and predictability and
hence is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.”
[10]
Rebutting the contention made on behalf of the petitioner,
Mr. S. Nepolean, learned GA submitted that at para. 7 of the Notice
dated 21-02-2011 advertising one post of Executive Engineer and 10
posts of Assistant Engineers for appointment on contract basis, it was
clearly notified that the State Project Officer, Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan
State Mission Authority, Manipur, shall have authority to prescribe
minimum percentage of marks in relevant qualifying exam and based
on such percentage, the shortlisted candidates only may be called
for assessment in Selection Board Meeting. The learned GA further
submitted that the procedure for selection and system for giving marks
to each and every candidates was determined by the competent
authority as notified above and that uniform marking system was applied
to all the candidates. As none of the candidates, including the present
petitioner, challenged or questioned the selection process or the initial
appointment of the respondents No. 3 to 7, the petitioner has no right to
contend that the selection process or the system of giving marks is not
permissible in law and that such contention made on behalf of the
petitioner be rejected outright.
[11]
Mr. S. Nepolean, learned GA also submitted that the
authorities have determined and fixed the inter-se seniority of the nine
Assistant Engineers, including the petitioner and the respondents No. 3
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[12]
to 7 and whose services were regularised by a common order dated
16-12-2016, on the basis of the marks obtained by them at the time
of their initial selection for appointment as Assistant Engineers on
contract basis and the same is permissible in law since it was only the
comparative merit of the disputing parties. The learned GA further
submitted that the petitioner was regularised as Assistant Engineer due
to the fact that the post held by him as Executive Engineer on contract
basis was a promotional post of Assistant Engineer and that the
petitioner instead of continuing on contractual basis as Executive
Engineer choose to be regularised as Assistant Engineer and as such,
the service rendered by him as Executive Engineer on contract basis
cannot be taken into account for the purpose of fixing seniority in the
substantive post of Assistant Engineer.
In support of his contention, the learned GA cited the following
case laws:1. (1994) 6 SCC 301 “Chairman, Puri Gramya Bank & anr. Vs.
Ananda Chandra Das & ors.” wherein it has been held as
under:“2. This appeal arises from the judgment of the High Court of
Orissa in OJC No. 1007 of 1988, dated 4-3-1992. The
respondent and others were selected by direct recruitment as
managers of Rural Bank. His rank was No. 9 in the merit list.
He was directed to be given seniority on the basis of the date
of his reporting to duty. It is reported that the first respondent
is dead. The only question in this case is that what shall be
the ranking among the direct recruits? Is it the date on which
they joined duty or according to the ranking given by the
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[13]
Selection Board? On comparative evaluation of the
respective merits of the candidates for direct recruitment, the
Board had prepared the merit list on the basis of the ranking
secured at the time of the selection. It is settled law that if
more than one are selected, the seniority is as per ranking of
the direct recruits subject to the adjustment of the candidates
selected on applying the rule of reservation and the roster. By
mere fortuitous chance of reporting to duty earlier would not
alter the ranking given by the Selection Board and the
arranged one as per roster. The High Court is, therefore,
wholly wrong in its conclusion that the seniority shall be
determined on the basis of the joining reports given by the
candidates selected for appointment by direct recruitment
and length of service on its basis. The view, therefore, is
wrong. However, we need not interfere with the order, since
the first respondent has died.”
2. (2007) 1 SCC 405 “Suresh Chandra Jha Vs. State of Bihar
& ors.” wherein it has been held as under:“3. Background facts in a nutshell are as follows:
In response to the advertisement for appointment to the post
of Assistants in Dr. Joggnath Mishra Institute for Technology
(a private institution hereinafter referred to as "the Institute"),
the appellant and several others applied for the said post. After
selection at a test conducted, five persons were appointed and
the appellant was one of them. The appellant was appointed
vide order dated 18-7-1981 and was given six weeks' time from
the date of issue of the letter to report for duty to the office of
the General Secretary, Mithila Vikas Sansthan, Laheriasarai,
Darbhanga, Director of the Institute at Darbhanga. In case of
Respondent 8, P.K. Choudhary, the appointment letter was
dated 22-7-1981 and he joined on the same day. The appellant
who claims to have received the appointment letter on 23-71981, in fact, joined on 24-7-1981. At this juncture, it is to be
noted that though in the appeal, challenge was made to the
appointment of Respondent 7, the same was not pressed. On
the basis of Section 5(2) of the Act and in purported exercise
of powers under Section 5(3) of the Act, Respondent 8 was
retained in service while the appellant was not retained. The
appellant questioned correctness of the procedure adopted.
When there was no positive response, the writ petition was
filed before the Patna High Court which was allowed by the
learned Single Judge. It was noted by the learned Single Judge
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[14]
that the order dated 31-1-1991 issued by the State Government
absorbing in service of some of the respondents was contrary
to law. It was noted that the procedure of determining as to
who had joined the college earlier was wrong. It was pointed
out that admittedly selection was on 18-7-1981 and six weeks'
time was granted for joining. Merely because of fortuitous
circumstances, Respondent 8 joined earlier that cannot be a
ground to make him senior to the appellant, though in the merit
list prepared the appellant was ranked 20 while Respondent 8
was ranked 43. The learned Single Judge accepted the stand.
In the appeal filed by Respondent 8, different view was taken
by the Division Bench. It was held that the seniority is to be
reckoned on the basis of the date of joining. According to the
High Court the logic of last come first go was applicable and,
therefore, the appellant who has joined later was to be treated
as junior to Respondent 8.”
“4. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the view
taken by the Division Bench is clearly contrary to law. If there
are no rules governing the field, it is the placement in the merit
list which is determinative and not the date of joining. It is
accepted that no rules had been framed and, therefore, the
merit as appearing in the rank list has to be taken.”
“5. In response, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that
right from 1981, Respondent 8 has worked and he having
joined earlier has to be treated as senior to the appellant.”
“6. There is no dispute that the appellant was ranked higher to
Respondent 8. There is also no dispute that in the appointment
letter the appellant was given six weeks' time to join. Merely
because Respondent 8 joined earlier that did not in any way
affect the merit placement.”
“7. This Court in Chairman, Puri Gramya Bank v. Ananda Chandra
Das held as follows: (SCC p. 301, para 2)
"2. This appeal arises from the judgment of the High Court of
Orissa in OJC No. 1007 of 1988, dated 4-3-1992. The
respondent and others were selected by direct recruitment
as managers of Rural Bank. His rank was No. 9 in the merit
list. He was directed to be given seniority on the basis of
the date of his reporting to duty. It is reported that the first
respondent is dead. The only question in this case is that
what shall be the ranking among the direct recruits? Is it
the date on which they joined duty or according to the
ranking given by the Selection Board? On comparative
evaluation of the respective merits of the candidates for
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[15]
direct recruitment, the Board has prepared the merit list on
the basis of the ranking secured at the time of the selection.
It is settled law that if more than one are selected, the
seniority is as per ranking of the direct recruits subject to
the adjustment of the candidates selected on applying the
rule of reservation and the roster. By mere fortuitous
chance of reporting to duty earlier would not alter the
ranking given by the Selection Board and the arranged one
as per roster. The High Court, is, therefore, wholly wrong in
its conclusion that the seniority shall be determined on the
basis of the joining reports given by the candidates
selected for appointment by direct recruitment and length
of service on its basis. The view, therefore, is wrong.
However, we need not interfere with the order, since the
first respondent has died."
“8. Since there was no rule in operation, obviously the ranking in
the merit list was to decide the respective seniority. The ratio
in Chairman, Puri Gramya Bank case has full application to the
facts of the case. The appellant's claim that he was to be
treated as senior to Respondent 8 was rightly accepted by the
learned Single Judge. Unfortunately, the Division Bench did
not address itself to the specific question and has placed
undue stress on Respondent 8 having joined earlier.”
[12]
Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondents No. 3 to 5 submitted that as against nine advertised posts
of Assistant Engineers (Civil), nine candidates have been recommended
for appointment against the said nine advertised posts under different
category as per the reservation rules. Out of the nine selected
candidates, five candidates were recommended under the Un-reserved
category reflecting their respective score for determining merit, one
candidate in OBC(M) category and three candidates in Scheduled Tribe
category and that these nine candidates could be considered as the
candidates recommended for appointment in order of merit. It has also
been submitted that two candidates have been kept in the Waiting
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[16]
List under the Un-reserved category and one candidate under the
OBC(M) category and two candidates under the Scheduled Tribe
category Waiting List. It has been submitted that the two recommended
candidates at Sl. Nos. 2 and 3 under the Un-reserved category did not
joined services and the recommended candidates at Sl. No. 5 under the
same category although joined service initially subsequently left as he
have been appointed in another Department and thus, the candidates
from the Waiting List under the Un-reserved category were given
appointment against the available vacant posts.
[13]
The learned senior counsel submitted that the aforesaid two
candidates who have been appointed from the Waiting List are the
respondents No. 6 and 7 in the present writ petition and that as the
petitioner was never appointed as Assistant Engineer but opted for
joining as Executive Engineer, the respondents No. 3, 4 and 5 who have
been appointed earlier to the respondents No. 6 & 7 and the petitioner,
are placed above the said petitioner and the respondents No. 6 and 7 in
the Final Seniority List. The learned senior counsel further submitted that
the writ petitioner having been never appointed to the post of Assistant
Engineer in terms of the advertisement, his regularisation to the post of
Assistant Engineer itself was an illegal regularisation and his claim for
placing his name higher in the seniority list by virtue of his having been
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[17]
appointed to the post of Executive Engineer, which is altogether a
different cadre, is not supported by any legal provision.
[14]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent No. 6 submitted that in the order dated 16-12-2016 issued
by the Government, nothing is mentioned therein that the regularisation
of the contract services of the petitioner and respondents No. 3 to 7 was
in order of merit. According to the learned senior counsel, the said
regularisation was not on the basis of any merit and that at para. 5 of
the said regularisation order dated 16-12-2016, it is clearly provided
that seniority of the employees whose services have been regularized
shall be determined later on. According to the learned senior counsel,
the claim made by the petitioner that he should be placed above the
respondents No. 3 to 7 in the Final Seniority List is without any substance
or merit and the same is liable to be rejected.
[15]
It has also been submitted by the learned senior counsel that
as the petitioner has never raised any objection or challenged the
proceeding of the Selection Committee for selection of candidates for
appointment as Assistant Engineers on contract basis pursuant to the
Advertisement dated 21-02-2011, the petitioner has no right or locus to
question or to submit that preparation of the merit list or awarding of
marks by the Selection Committee is bad in law and that the inter-se
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[18]
seniority of the selected candidates cannot be determined on the basis
of the merit list prepared by the Selection Committee.
Mr. S. Rupachandra, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent No. 7 endorsed the submission made by Mr. S. Nepolean,
learned GA and the submission made by Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior
counsel appearing for the respondent No. 6.
[16]
I have heard at length the rival submission advanced by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties and also gone through the
materials available on record. The undisputed facts in the present case
are as under:(i) Pursuant to a Notice dated 21-02-2011 advertising various
posts including one post of Executive Engineer and ten posts
of Assistant Engineers for appointment on contract basis, the
petitioner and the private respondents applied for the said
posts. In fact, the petitioner applied for both the posts of
Executive Engineer and Assistant Engineers and the petitioner
was selected against the post of Executive Engineer and he
was appointed as Executive Engineer on contract basis.
However, the petitioner was not selected for the post of
Assistant Engineer and his name was kept in the Waiting List.
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[19]
All the respondents No. 3 to 7 were selected against
the posts of Assistant Engineers and the relative merits of the
petitioner and the respondents No. 3 to 7 based on the marks
secured by them are as under:Sl.
No.
Name
Marks
obtained
Remark
1.
Konsam Victor Singh
62.87
R3
2.
Leishangthem Mahindrakumar
Singh
57.69
R4
3.
Huidrom Victoria Devi
56.58
R6
4.
Samira Begum
55.04
R7
5.
Thingbaijam Naresh Kumar
53.50
Petitioner
6.
M.K. Thekho John Pao
49.90
R5
(ii) While the petitioner was serving as Executive Engineer on
contract basis and the respondents No. 3 to 7 were serving as
Assistant Engineers on contract basis, their services were
regularized by the Government against the newly created posts
of Assistant Engineers with immediate effect by issuing an
order dated 16-12-2016. In the said order, it was provided that
the seniority of the employees shall be determined later on.
(iii) No one including the petitioner and the respondents No. 3 to 7
raised any objection or questioned their initial appointment on
contract basis or challenged their regularisation against the
posts of Assistant Engineer and they accepted such initial
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[20]
appointment on contract basis and their regularisation as
Assistant Engineers.
(iv) The stand taken by the State Government is that the inter-se
seniority of the petitioner and the respondents No. 3 to 7 have
been fixed or determined on the basis of the marks obtained
by them in the selection process for their appointment as
Assistant Engineers on contract basis.
[17]
Taking into consideration the above undisputed facts and
circumstances of the present case, this court considered the rival
submissions advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
The contention made on behalf of the petitioner that as he was initially
appointed as Executive Engineer on contract basis and as his name
appeared at Sl. No. 1 in the regularisation order, his name should be
placed above the respondents No. 3 to 7 in the Final Seniority List is not
supported by any principle of law and as such, this court is not inclined
to be persuaded by such submissions. The submission made on behalf
of the petitioner that as the regularisation of the services of the petitioner
and the respondents No. 3 to 7 was not based on any inter-se merit, the
fixation of their inter-se seniority should be on the basis of their personal
age cannot also be accepted by this court for the simple reason that the
authorities maintained a Merit List of the petitioner and the respondents
No. 3 to 7 which was prepared at the time of their initial appointment.
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[21]
In the absence of any challenge being made by the petitioner
about the validity and legality of the proceedings of the Selection
Committee for selection and recommendation of the candidates for
appointment as Assistant Engineers on contract basis pursuant to the
Advertisement dated 21-02-2011, this court is not inclined to entertain
and accept the contention made on behalf of the petitioner that the
fixation of the inter-se seniority of the petitioner and the respondents
No. 3 to 7 cannot be fixed or determined on the basis of the marks
obtained by them as the methodology or criteria for preparing the merit
list was never made known to them or notified by the authorities.
[18]
The contention made on behalf of the petitioner that the
placement of the respondent No. 5 above the petitioner and the
respondents No. 6 and 7 in the Final Seniority List, even though he
obtained less mark than the petitioner and the respondents No. 6 and 7,
is arbitrary and impermissible in law has some force and this court is
inclined to accept the same. If the stand taken by the Government that
the inter-se seniority of the petitioner and the respondents No. 3 to 7
were based on the marks obtained by them is accepted, the placement
of the respondent No. 5 above the petitioner and the respondents No. 6
and 7, who got more marks than the respondent No. 5, is not acceptable
and impermissible in law.
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[22]
[19]
This court cannot also persuade itself to agree with the
submission made on behalf of the respondent No. 5 that as the
respondent No. 5 was appointed earlier than the respondents No. 6
and 7 by virtue of the reservation policy and as the petitioner was never
appointed as Assistant Engineer, the respondent No. 5 is entitled to be
placed above the petitioner and respondents No. 6 and 7 in the Final
Seniority List. It is to be pointed out that the fixation of Inter-se Seniority
List of incumbents who were regularized on the same day by the same
order has to be fixed on the basis of their inter-se merit and not on the
basis of the date of their joining services. It is also a settled law that
while fixing the inter-se seniority of incumbents who were appointed or
regularized on the same date, the authorities cannot adopt two yardstick
at the same time, such as the date of joining service and inter-se merit
of the incumbents, while fixing their inter-se seniority. In this regard, it
may be relevant and gainful to refer to the judgment rendered by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of “Manoj Parihar & ors. Vs. State of
Jammu & Kashmir & ors.” reported in (2022) 14 SCC 72 wherein the
Hon’ble Apex Court after referring to a number of its earlier judgment
held at para. 29 of the judgment as under:“29. Thus, the principle of law discernible from all the aforesaid
decisions of this Court is that the roster system is only for the
purpose of ensuring that the quantum of reservation is reflected
in the recruitment process. It has nothing to do with the inter se
seniority among those recruited. To put it in other words, the
roster points do not determine the seniority of the appointees who
gain simultaneous appointments; that is to say, those who are
appointed collectively on the same date or are deemed to be
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[23]
appointed on the same date, irrespective of when they joined their
posts. The position of law as discussed above could be said to be
prevailing even while the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir
decided by a Full Court Resolution to determine the seniority on
the basis of roster points.”
[20]
In view of the undisputed facts and circumstances of the
present case and for the findings and reasons given hereinabove, this
court is of the considered view that it will meet the ends of justice to issue
the following directions:(i) The impugned Final Seniority List dated 11-09-2024 of the
Assistant Engineers of Education Engineering Wing in the
Education (S), Department, Government of Manipur, is hereby
quashed and set aside so far as it concerns the placement of
the respondent No. 5 at Sl. No. 3 of the said Seniority List
and above the names of the respondents No. 6, 7 and the
petitioner;
(ii) The respondent No. 1 is hereby directed to rectify the said
impugned Seniority List by placing the name of the respondent
No. 5 below the name of the respondents No. 3, 4, 6, 7 and the
petitioner and to re-publish a fresh Final Seniority List;
(iii) The whole process for notification of a fresh Final Seniority
List of Assistant Engineers as indicated above should be
completed by the respondent No. 1 as early as possible and
not later than one month from today.
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
[24]
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is
disposed of.
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
WP(C) No. 694 of 2024
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review