Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 10-04-2026 ::: Pronounced on : 12-06-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE K.KUMARESH BABU
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
and CMP 11927 of 2019
The United India Insurance Company Limited,
13-A, Nethaji Road, Manjakuppam,
Cuddalore District.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. P. Kaliyaperumal
2. E. Raja
..Respondent(s)
Prayer : This petition to set aside the decree and Judgment passed in MCOP
No.2432 of 2014 on 12.10.2017 on the file of the learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal (Principal District Judge) at Cuddalore.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.J.Chandran
For Respondent(s):
Ms.Ramya V Rao (R1)
JUDGMENT
The present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal has been filed to set aside the
decree and judgement dated 12.10.2017 passed in M.C.O.P.No.2432 of 2014 on
the file of the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Principal District
Judge), Cuddalore.
__________
Page1 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
2. The facts giving rise to the present appeal are that the deceased was
engaged in the business as a seafood merchant and was earning a sum of
Rs.15,000/- per month. On 10.05.2014 at about 11.00 a.m., while the deceased
was travelling in the vehicle belonging to the 1st respondent bearing Registration
No.TN-51-M-6607 a mini-van, as the owner of the goods being transported
therein, from north to south at Semmangkudi. The driver of the said vehicle
drove the same in a rash and negligent manner and without adhering to traffic
regulations, as a result, the vehicle collided with a motorcycle bearing
Registration No.TN-05-T-8680 and thereafter capsized, causing the accident.
Due the accident the deceased sustained grievous injuries and multiple
fractures. Though she was immediately taken to the hospital for treatment, she
subsequently succumbed to the injuries. Consequently a criminal case was
registered in the Crime No. 206 of 2014 against the driver of the 1 st respondent's
vehicle, in Sirkali Police Station alleging that the accident had occurred solely
due to the rash and negligence of the aforesaid driver. The 1st respondent is the
owner of the offending mini-van and the 2nd respondent is its insurer. The
petitioner, being the husband of the deceased, filed a Claims Petition in
M.C.O.P.No.2432 of 2014 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
Cuddalore, against respondents 1 and 2, seeking compensation to a tune of
Rs.15,00,000/-.
__________
Page2 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
3. The 1st respondent remained absent before the Tribunal and was set ex
parte. The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company filed a counter statement denying
the averments made in the claim petition and put the petitioner to strict proof of
the age, occupation, monthly income of the deceased and prove whether he his
legal heir of the deceased. The 2nd respondent further contended that the
deceased was at best, an unauthorized passenger travelling in the vehicle and
therefore, the Insurance Company was not liable to pay any compensation. It
was further averred that, at the time of the accident more than ten persons
including the deceased, were travelling in the vehicle belonging to the 1st
respondent. Whereas as per the permit conditions, the permitted seating capacity
of the vehicle was only two persons, thereby constituting a clear violation.The
2nd respondent also had denied that the driver of the 1st respondent vehicle held
any valid driving license to drive the vehicle. The 2nd respondent also
contended that the compensation claimed by the petitioner was excessive and
exorbitant. Accordingly on the above grounds the 2nd respondent prayed for
dismissal of the claim petition.
4. Based on the pleadings on both the sides the learned Claims Tribunal had
framed the following points for determination.
1. Whether the accident had happened due to the rash and negligent driving
of the 1st respondent’s vehicle driver?
__________
Page3 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to get the compensation as alleged by
them?
3. To what other reliefs, the petitioner is entitled to?
5. On the petitoner’s side the petitioner had examined himself of as PW1 and
marked Ex.P1 to Ex.P3 as evidence, and on the side of the respondents, the staff
of the 2nd respondent company was examined as RW1.
6. Upon considering the arguments on both sides and perusing the evidences
available on record the learned Claims Tribunal had determined the aforesaid
points. As far as the Point No.1 is considered, the learned Claims Tribunal upon
the perusal of the evidence and deposition of PW1 had held that accident took
place due to rash and negligence of on the part of the driver of the 1 st respondent
vehicle. Further the perusal of Ex.P1, the FIR copy filed against the driver of
the 1st respondent vehicle, reveals that the police had registered the FIR filed
against the said driver for his negligence. The learned Claims Tribunal further
observed that the respondents had examined only a staff of the respondent
Insurance Company as RW1, who was not even an eyewitness to the accident.
Hence, the evidence of RW1 was held to be insufficient to substantiate the
claims of the respondent. The respondents had also failed to examine the driver
of the 1st respondent's to prove their claims with regard to his valid license.
__________
Page4 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
Further, there is no dispute that the vehicle belonging to the 1 strespondent was
duly insured with the 2nd respondent Insurance Company on the date of the
accident.
7. The main contention of the 2ndrespondent company is that the deceased
was gratuitous passenger and thereby the 2nd respondent is not liable to pay the
compensation to the petitioner. PW1, in his evidence, had deposed that the
deceased was travelling in the 1strespondent's vehicle as the owner of the goods
therein. The said claim was neither specifically denied by the 2 ndrespondent
during cross-examination nor was any contra evidence adduced to disprove the
same. In such circumstances, the learned Claims Tribunal held that the
contention of the 2ndrespondent that the deceased was a gratuitous passenger
could not be accepted. Accordingly, Point No.1 was answered in favour of the
petitioner.
8. Regarding the Point No.2, the learned Claims Tribunal upon the perusal of
the Ex.P2, the copy of the Postmortem Certificate had held that the age of the
deceased as 55 on the date of the accident. Further though the PW1 in his
evidence had deposed thatthe deceased was working as Sea Food Merchant and
thereby was earning a sum of Rs.15,000/-per month, but however has not
produced any documentary evidence to substantiate the same. Therefore the
learned Claims Tribunal upon considering the age and nature of work of the
__________
Page5 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
deceased had held that the monthly income of the deceased to be Rs.6000/- and
thereby the annual income would amount to Rs.72,000/-. Considering the
dependency 1/3rd of the income would be deducted towards her personal
expenses and thereby the annual income was calculated to be Rs.48,000/-.
Considering the age of the deceased as 55 years the learned Claims Tribunal
had adopted the multiplier 11. Further the learned Claims Tribunal had also
awarded Rs.1,00,000/- towards the Loss of Consortium and Rs.25,000/-towards
the Transport and funeral expenses. Therefore the learned Claims Tribunal had
held that the petitioner was entitled to a Sum of Rs.6,53,000/- rounded off to
Rs.6,50,000/- towards compensation. Accordingly the Point No.2 is answered.
9. Therefore the learned Claims Tribunal vide its judgment and decree dated
12.10.2017, had held that aforesaid Claims Petition was partly allowed and the
respondents 1 and 2 were directed to pay to a sum of Rs.6,50,000/- with interest
at the rate of 8% per annum from the date of petition to the petitioner with costs.
Accordingly the 2nd respondent companywas directed to deposit the award
amount together with the interest within one month of the date the order.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree the 2 nd respondent had filed the
present civil Miscellaneous Appeal against the petitioner and the 1 st respondent
and had impleaded them as the respondents therein.
__________
Page6 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
10. Heard Mr.J.Chandran, learned counsel for the appellant and
Ms.Ramya V Rao, learned counsel appearing for the respondents and perused
the materials placed on record, apart from the pleadings of the parties.
11. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant Insurance Company
would submit that a liability had been fastened upon it of a claim which had
arisen due to the fatal accident involving the vehicle that was insured with it that
too when the deceased was only a gratuitous passenger. Further, he would
submit that as per the policy that had been marked as Exhibit R1, admittedly,
the vehicle was a goods vehicle, which had not covered any gratuitous
passenger. The deceased cannot be treated as a third party to fasten the liability
on the appellant and only the vehicle owner is liable to be fastened with the
liability. He would further submit that the deceased had also not travelled in the
cabin, but over the goods that was carried in the vehicle as gratuitous passenger
along with several other persons at the time of the accident. He would submit
that there has been a clear violation of the permit condition and hence, for such
violation of permit condition, the insurance company ought to have been
exonerated of its liability under the policy of insurance. He would further
submit that as the insurance policy itself indicate that no premium had been paid
to cover any other persons other than the party, the liability ought not to have
been fastened upon the insurance company and in such cases, the principle of
pay and recovery cannot also be invoked. In that context, he had relied upon the
__________
Page7 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
Division Bench of this Court reported in 2018 (2) TNMAC 731. Hence, he
seeks indulgence of this Court.
12. Ms.Ramya V Rao, learned counsel appearing for the first respondent,
on the other hand, would contend that the deceased was not a gratuitous
passenger. She would submit that the deceased had travelled in the goods
vehicle along with the goods belonging to her and that a categorical finding had
been given by the Tribunal to hold that she is not a gratuitous passenger and
could be considered as a third party governed by the policy of insurance. To
discredit the findings given in that regard, no materials had been placed by the
appellant nor by PW1 who had categorically deposed that the deceased had
travelled with the goods, and the Tribunal has also recorded a categorical
finding that the second respondent in the cross-examination had not denied the
status of the deceased or adduced any contra evidence to the same in rejecting
the claim of the appellant that the deceased was a gratuitous passenger. In that
context, she would submit that the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel
appearing for the appellant cannot have any application to the facts of the case.
In such an event, she would further submit that there can be no question of
absolving the liability under the policy which is governed by the Statute. Hence,
he seeks dismissal of the appeal.
__________
Page8 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
13. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing on either side. I have also perused the materials placed on record,
apart from the pleadings of the parties.
14. The primordial contention of the appellant is that the deceased was a
gratuitous passenger and that the policy of the insurance cannot cover such
gratuitous passenger and therefore, liability ought not to have been fastened on
it.
15. The Tribunal under the impugned award had categorically rejected the
claim of the appellant that the deceased was a gratuitous passenger. It had relied
upon the evidence of PW1 who had categorically deposed that the deceased
travelled in the vehicle as the owner of the goods. The Tribunal has also
recorded the fact that the second respondent had neither discredited such a
deposition of PW1 nor produced any contra evidence to discredit the evidence
of PW1 with regard to the status of the deceased as gratuitous passenger. Even
before this Court, to assail the said finding, the appellant had not produced any
materials.
16. In that context, the other issue raised by the learned counsel for the
appellant with regard to the question of pay and recover, the principle of pay
and recover are not available in the present facts of the case is not necessary to
__________
Page9 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
be answered and the same could be left open to be decided in an appropriate
case.
17. For the aforesaid reasons, this Court do not find any merits in the
appeal and accordingly, this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal stands dismissed. No
order as to costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
12-06-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Maya
To
The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal
(Principal District Judge)
at Cuddalore.
__________
Page10 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
K.KUMARESH BABU, J.
Maya
CMA No. 2513 of 2019
12-06-2026
__________
Page11 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review