The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. For the reasons stated above, I do not find that there is any fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat perversity or illegality in the judgment and award passed by the reference Court. The Appeals preferred by the acquiring body sans merit. Hence, I pass the following order : First Appeals are dismissed. Award be drawn accordingly. There shall be no order as to costs. The amount deposited by the appellants – acquiring body shall be disbursed to the respondents – claimants with accrued interest as per their entitlement. In case the amount is not deposited, appellants shall make the payment expeditiously. [ SHAILESH P. BRAHME J. ] bsb/April 26
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:20025
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
FIRST APPEAL NO. 265 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Arjun Chandrabhan Bhogade
.. Appellants
..
Respondent
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 273 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
.. Appellants
Versus
Shamrao Murlidhar Bhogade and others .. Respondents
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 267 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Alkabai Bajirao Arune and others
.. Appellants
..
Respondents
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 263 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Sampat Rajaram Bhogade
Since deceased through his L.Rs.
Hirabai Sampat Bhogade and others
.. Appellants
..
Respondents
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 268 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
.. Appellants
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
Versus
Bhausaheb Ramchandra Bhogade
..
Respondent
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 271 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
.. Appellants
Versus
Anandrao Bhaktaji Bhogade and another.. Respondents
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 266 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Jalindar Ramchandra Bhogade
.. Appellants
..
Respondent
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 264 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Sushila Tukaram Bhogade
.. Appellants
..
Respondent
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 269 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Kashinath Keru Bhogade
.. Appellants
..
Respondent
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 274 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
.. Appellants
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
Versus
Ashok Laxman Bhogade
..
Respondent
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 272 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Nandu Keru Bhogade
Since deceased through his L.Rs.
Shahabai Nandu Bhogade and another
.. Appellants
..
Respondents
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 270 OF 2026
Union of India through the General
Manager, Central Railway and others
Versus
Gowardhan Sahebrao Bhogade
.. Appellants
..
Respondent
Shri Ajay G. Talhar, D.S.G.I.for the Appellants in all matters.
Shri Chandrakant K. Shinde and Ms. G. R. Jagtap, Advocates
for the Respondents/ claimants in all matters.
CORAM : SHAILESH P. BRAHME, J.
DATE : 18TH APRIL, 2026.
FINAL ORDER :
.
Taken up for final disposal with the consent of the parties.
2.
The acquiring body has preferred these appeals against
common judgment and award dated 09.09.20192 passed in group
of Reference Petitions. The rate fixed by the Reference Court for
the lands under acquisition and consequential quantum is under
challenge. The evidence adduced before the Reference Court is
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
common, hence these appeals are decided by this common order.
3.
Appellants have undertaken acquisition for laying down
new railway track from Ahmednagar – Beed – Parli. Lands from
various villages have been acquired, which resulted into filing of
various references. Those were decided by forming groups by the
Reference Court. The judgments passed by the Reference Courts
are subjected to challenge by the acquiring body as well as the
claimants in few of the matters.
In the present group the
claimants have not preferred any cross objection or appeal. The
lands are from village Sakat, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed.
4.
Following are the material particulars :
Sr.
No.
First
Appeal
No.
L.A.R.
No.
Gut
No.
Area
acquired
Date of Sec. Rate awarded Rate fixed by
by the SLAO
the Reference
notification
Court.
265/2026
48/2014
0.30R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
273/2026
44/2014
50/1
1.30R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
267/2026
45/2014
0.73r
09.09.2009
Rs. 735/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
263/2026
46/2014
59/2
0.49R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
268/2026
47/2014
61/1
0.24R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
271/2026
502014
50/1
0.45R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
266/2026
51/2014
61/1
0.31R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
264/2026
52/2014
59/1
0.14R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
269/2026
53/2014
59/1
0.09R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
St.
54/2014
8831/2022
50/1
1.30R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
274/2026
55/2014
59/3
0.84R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
272/2026
56/2014
59/1
0.07R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
270/2026
57/2014
64/1
0.22R
09.09.2009
Rs. 850/- per R Rs. 2,161/-/- per
dry land
R. dry land.
5.
The lands of the respondents were acquired by preliminary
notification U/Sec. 4 of the L. A. Act issued on 09.02.2009. The
Special Land Acquisition Officer passed award on 26.03.2010
offering the rate of Rs. 850/- per R for dry land in Group – I and
Rs. 735/- per R for Group II.
Being aggrieved respondents
approached the Civil Court by preferring reference petitions.
The Reference Court enhanced the rate to Rs. 2,161/- per R for
dry land.
6.
Mr. Ajay Talhar, learned D. S. G. I. submits that Reference
Court committed error of jurisdiction in enhancing the rate
which is not supported by adequate material. It is submitted
that S. L. A. O. had undertaken due procedure of law and
inspection was done. The documents were collected to arrive at
market rate. As against that the sale instances placed before the
Reference Court were incompatible. It is submitted that
considering the location and the potential of the lands under
acquisition, the Reference Court erred in enhancing the rate.
The Reference Court further committed illegality in granting
statutory benefits of solatium and additional component.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
– claimants supports the impugned judgment and award. It is
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
submitted that claimants – respondents have adduced oral and
documentary evidence. The appellants did not adduce any oral
evidence.
The sale deeds at Exhibit Nos. 30 and 31.
The
Reference Court found the sale instance at Exhibit Nos. 30 and
31 compatible and preferred. The reference Court has also relied
upon the award Exhibit 43 passed in L.A.R. No. 324 of 2006 and
another award at Exhibit 51 passed in L.A.R. No. 364 of 2010.
The Reference Court has adopted a reasonable and practical
approach in fixing the rate at Rs. 2,161/- per R. for dry land.
8.
I have considered rival submissions of the parties. I have
formulated following points for determination.
I.
Whether the enhancement granted by the Reference Court
is liable to be quashed ?
II
Whether the statutory benefits extended by the Reference
Court are in accordance with law ?
9.
The respondents adduced oral and documentary evidence.
The appellants did not lead oral evidence.
10.
Point No. I :
The evidence was led by the claimants in L.A.R. No. 48 of
2014. The claimants produced sale deeds at Exhibit Nos. 30 and
31, award at Exhibit 43 passed in L. A. R. No. 324 of 2006 and
award at Exhibit 51 passed in L.A.R. No. 364 of 2010. The land
in the sale instance at Exhibit No. 30 was from self same village.
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
The Reference Court, therefore, preferred to rely upon sale deed
Exhibit 30 for fixing the rate. Accordingly the rate is fixed at Rs.
2,161/- per R for dry lands. I do not find any illegality in the rate
fixed by the Reference Court. The discretion has been exercised
judiciously and reasonably.
The lands under acquisition are
treated to be dry lands.
11.
There is no reason to discard the rate. There is always
some element of guesswork in fixation of the probable market
value. It is permissible to have guesstimate as explained by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Trishala Jain V. State of Uttaranchal, reported in
AIR 2011 SC 2458 which is rightly followed by the reference Court.
The appellant has failed to make out any case to cause
interference in fixing the rate which is reasonable and akin to
the market value at the prevalent time.
I answered point No. I against the appellants.
12.
Point No. II
The claimants are granted benefits under Section 23(1-A)
of the Act. The interest has been awarded in accordance with
law laid down in State of Maharashtra V. Kailash Shiva Rangari reported
in 2016(3) Mh.L.J. 457. No case is made out by the appellants to
show any fault or illegality in awarding statutory benefits and
the interest.
I answered point No. II against the appellants.
13.
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
It is made clear that dismissal of these Appeals preferred
by the acquiring body would not bind any other claimants’ whose
lands have been acquired for the self same project in claiming
enhancement of the compensation by preferring independent
Appeals or the Cross-Objections. Their claims for any further
enhancement would be delt with in accordance with law and on
the basis of the evidence produced on record.
14.
It is further clarified that the counsel appearing for the
respondents/claimants has made candid statement that his
clients are unable to prefer any appeal or cross objection for
enhancement in the High Court.
They are precluded from
claiming enhancement in future.
15.
This Court had an occasion to deal with first appeals
preferred by the self same acquiring body challenging judgments
of the Reference Court arising out of self same purpose of
acquisition.
This Court dismissed the appeals by assigning
elaborate reasons in the matter of the Executive Engineer,
Central Railway, Pune and others Vs. Subhash Narayan
Gore and others in First Appeal No. 418 of 2026 with other
connected matters vide judgment and order dated
10.04.2026. I propose to follow the same course in upholding the
judgments rendered by the Reference Court in the present
matters also.
16.
For the reasons stated above, I do not find that there is any
fa 265.26 Adv. Shinde Sakat
perversity or illegality in the judgment and award passed by the
reference Court. The Appeals preferred by the acquiring body
sans merit. Hence, I pass the following order :
ORDER
A.
First Appeals are dismissed.
B.
Award be drawn accordingly.
C.
There shall be no order as to costs.
D.
The amount deposited by the appellants – acquiring body
shall be disbursed to the respondents – claimants with
accrued interest as per their entitlement.
E.
In case the amount is not deposited, appellants shall make
the payment expeditiously.
[ SHAILESH P. BRAHME J. ]
bsb/April 26
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review