The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. In view of the aforesaid reasons, we are satisfied that the writ petition deserves to be allowed. While passing the order, we deem it appropriate to observe that the Commission should refrain from entertaining such matters which are excluded under the Regulations of 2022 otherwise the Commission may be drawn on a slippery course likely to cause not only errors of jurisdiction but also a flood of unwanted litigations when the aggrieved person may have a statutory or constitutional remedy elsewhere before the appropriate forum or Court of law. The impugned order dated 08.07.2024 is accordingly set aside. The writ petition is allowed.
14. At the end, learned senior counsel for the private respondents Mr. P. Roy Barman has prayed that the complainant/private respondent may be allowed liberty to raise her claim for compassionate appointment before a competent Court of law. She is at liberty to do so subject to all limitations in law.
15. The writ petition is allowed in view of above terms. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. (S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ Pulak +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.542/2024
1. Union of India, represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Communication,
Government of India, Department of Posts, New Delhi-110011.
2. The Chief Postmaster General, North East Circle, Meghalaya, Shillong793001.
3. The Superintendent of Posts, Agartala Postal Division, Agartala, 799001,
District-West Tripura.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. Smt. Jyoti Bhowmik, wife of Late Arun Chandra Bhowmik, resident of
Thakurcherra, P.O.-Thakurcherra, P.S.-Baikhora, District-South Tripura.
2. Sri Pranjit Bhowmik, son of Late Arun Chandra Bhowmik, resident of
Thakurcherra, P.O.-Thakurcherra, P.S.-Baikhora, District-South Tripura.
3. Tripura Human Rights Commission, represented by its Secretary, Kunjaban,
P.O.-Kunjaban-799006, P.S.-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Deputy S.G.I.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Order
10/12/2024
Heard Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy S.G.I. appearing for
the petitioners-Union of India and Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents.
2.
Union of India and its officials are aggrieved by the order dated
08.07.2024 passed in Complaint No.12 of 2024 by the Tripura Human Rights
Commission (hereinafter referred to as Commission, for short) whereby the
learned Commission has entertained the claim by the complainant for
compassionate appointment under die-in-harness scheme framed by the Postal
Department. The claim for compassionate appointment of the second son of the
deceased Arun Chandra Bhowmik working as Gramin Dak Sevak (GDS) Peon
in the Postal Department dying in harness was rejected by the Superintendent of
Posts, Agartala Postal Division on the ground that there was one earning
member in the family of the deceased, i.e. his elder son. The learned
Commission made inquiries vide order dated 23.02.2024 asking the
Superintendent of Posts, Agartala Postal Division to submit his reply in writing
in respect of the allegations made by the complainant. The Postal Authorities
also submitted papers pursuant to the order dated 23.02.2024. The learned
Commission thereafter proceeded to analyze the claim of the complainant/
private respondent herein and directed the Superintendent of Posts, Agartala
Postal Division to take action in terms of the recommendation and submit a
report to the Commission within one month of the date of receipt thereof. The
relevant part of the impugned order containing the recommendation is extracted
hereunder:
"10. The complainant and her son Pranjit Bhowmik continued to approach
the Superintendent of Posts for consideration of their prayer, but did not get
any positive response.
It is quite clear from the communication of rejection that only on the
ground that one member of the family of the deceased has got a govt.
employment, the compassionate employment of Pranjit Bhowmik, s/o the
complainant has been refused and/or regretted. The complainant has produced
the family ration card, survival certificate and other documents. The family
ration card shows that it was originally consisting of the members including
deceased GDS Peon Arun Chandra Bhowmik, his wife Smt. Jyoti
Bhowmik(Petitioner), their son Pranjit Bhowmik and even in the original
ration card which was issued before the death of Arun Chandra Bhowmik, the
name of Biswajit Bhowmik, ie, the eldest son does not appear. After the death
of Arun Chandra Bhowmik his name was deleted in the year 2021. There is no
document to show that Biswajit Bhowmik was a member of the family of the
deceased GDS at the time of his death. No doubt, he was the son of the
complainant Jyoti Bhowmik and her deceased husband Arun Bhowmik, but
while he is a mature person married and got his own children and living away
with his own family may not be taking care of the other family members left
behind by the deceased GDS. Without having made a practical assessment in
terms of the scheme formulated by the Government of India, the Postal
authority should not have refused the compassionate appointment. Definitely,
such refusal has infringed the right to live a dignified life by the members of
the family of the deceased GDS. Simply because a son of the complainant and
the deceased got a govt. job, without having considered all other aspects in
accordance with the scheme, rejection of the prayer does not seem to be
justified and therefore, we are constrained to recommend that the
Superintendent of Posts, Agartala Postal Division shall consider the
compassionate appointment of Sri Pranjit Bhowmik, the unemployed
dependent son of the deceased GDS Arun Chandra Bhowmik and his wife, the
complainant of the case Smt. Jyoti Bhowmik.
11.
A copy of this recommendation may be sent to the Superintendent of
Posts, Agartala Postal Division to take action in terms of the recommendation
and to report the action taken to this Commission within one month from the
date of receipt of the recommendation.
A copy of this recommendation may also be sent to the complainant
for information.
List it on 12/08/2024."
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners-Union of India has questioned
the jurisdiction of the Commission to entertain a dispute relating to
compassionate appointment governed under the die-in-harness scheme framed
by the employer as a social security measure for dependants of the deceased
employee. He has referred to the provisions of the Protection of Human Rights
Act, 1993 and the regulations framed by the Tripura Human Rights
Commission under Section 10(2) read with Section 29 of the Act of 1993. He
submits that as per regulation-9, complaints relating to service matters or
industrial disputes are not ordinarily entertainable by the Commission. They
can be dismissed in limine. In support of his submission, he has placed reliance
upon the case of District Tourism Promotion Council Represented by its
Secretary vrs. State of Kerala Represented by the Secretary and others
reported in 2021 SCC OnLine Ker 3052. It is submitted that under similar
provisions relating to non-maintainability of service matter disputes, labour or
industrial disputes under the Kerala State Human Rights Commission
(Procedure) Regulations, 2001, the Kerala High Court held that the
Commission had no jurisdiction to entertain a complaint in service matters and
consequently adjudicate the same.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners-Union of India has also placed
reliance upon a decision of the Apex Court in the case of N.C. Dhoundial vrs.
Union of India & others reported in AIR 2004 SC 1272, paragraph-14 thereof.
Relying upon the opinion of the Apex Court, it is submitted that the
Commission which is the creature of the statute is bound by its provisions. Its
duties and functions are defined and circumscribed by the Act. The
Commission should necessarily act within the parameters prescribed by the Act
creating it and the confines of jurisdiction vested in it by the Act. The
Commission also should not operate under a notion that persons wronged by
such decisions of rejection of claim for compassionate appointment are not
without remedy if the Commission does not take up the matter. He submits that
the Commission has overstepped its jurisdiction and acted beyond the confines
of the Regulations of 2022 framed by itself which ordinarily bars complaints
relating to service matters or industrial disputes. It is submitted that if such a
recourse is adopted by the Commission, it would give rise to flood of
complaints relating to service matters or industrial disputes before the
Commission when the aggrieved parties have statutory remedies or remedy
before the Writ Court. Therefore, the impugned order may be set aside.
5.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the complainant/private
respondents herein, has in opposition drawn the attention of this Court to the
provisions of Section 12 under Chapter-III of the Act of 1993 which defines the
functions of the Commission. He has made special reference to Clause (j)
which, according to him, clothes the Commission to perform such other
functions as it may consider necessary for the promotion of human rights.
Learned senior counsel has also placed reliance upon the definition of 'human
rights' under Section 2(d) of the Act of 1993. He submits that denial of
reasonable source of sustenance available under a die-in-harness scheme also
affects right to life and right to live with dignity. Such a grievance, therefore,
falls under the jurisdiction of the State Human Rights Commission.
6.
Learned senior counsel for the complainant/private respondents
has referred to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Ram Deo
Chauhan alias Raj Nath vrs. Bani Kanta Das & others reported in (2010) 14
SCC 209, particularly paragraphs-41 to 47. He submits that the Apex Court in
the said case has held that the jurisdiction of NHRC stands enlarged by Section
12(j) of the Act of 1993 to take necessary action for the protection of human
rights. The Court also opined that if a person is entitled to a benefit under a
particular law and benefits under that law have been denied to him, it would
amount to violation of human rights. According to him, denial of a claim for
compassionate appointment falls in the category of human rights which is not a
service matter dispute as exhorted by the learned counsel for the petitionersUnion of India.
7.
Learned senior counsel for the private respondents has made
efforts to expand the meaning of the expression- 'life', 'equality' and 'dignity' to
support his submission that refusal to grant compassionate appointment by a
cryptic one line order without application of mind amounts to denial of right to
life and a decent source of livelihood which would ultimately affect the dignity
of the individuals who are dependants of the deceased employee. The
Commission has only made a recommendation. It is for the Postal Department
to act upon it or otherwise. In that way, the recommendation of the learned
Commission is as such not enforceable in law as in the case of writs or orders
issued by the High Courts. Therefore, the petitioners ought not to have
approached this Court against a mere recommendation by the Human Rights
Commission. The impugned order may not be interfered.
8.
We have given anxious consideration to the submissions of learned
counsel for the parties after hearing them at length. We have also perused the
impugned order and the background in which the Commission has proceeded to
entertain a complaint relating to claim for compassionate appointment.
9.
In the first place, even going by the submission of learned counsel
for the respondents that the claim for compassionate appointment would fall in
the definition of 'human rights' which are inalienable and basic to the existence
of a person by virtue of being born as a human being, the learned Commission
has in the body of the impugned order nowhere recorded that it is a case of
violation of human right which is essential ingredient for the Commission to
clothe itself with the jurisdiction to entertain such a claim. The Apex Court in
the case of N.C. Dhoundial (supra) had very categorically observed that the
Commission has no unlimited jurisdiction nor does it exercise plenary powers
in derogation of the statutory limitations since it is a creature of the statute
bound by its provisions. In execution of its statutory functions, it undoubtedly
has incidental or ancillary powers to effectively exercise its jurisdiction in
respect of the powers confided to it but the Commission should necessarily act
within the parameters prescribed by the Act creating it and the confines of
jurisdiction vested in it by the Act. Jurisdiction whenever vested by a statute is
coupled with a conscious duty upon the statutory body or the Court concerned
to be conscious of its limitations. The opinion of the Apex Court at paragraph14 of the report in the case of N.C. Dhoundial (supra) is appropriately quoted
hereunder:
"14. We cannot endorse the view of the Commission. The Commission
which is an “unique expert body” is, no doubt, entrusted with a very important
function of protecting the human rights, but, it is needless to point out that the
Commission has no unlimited jurisdiction nor does it exercise plenary powers
in derogation of the statutory limitations. The Commission, which is the
creature of statute, is bound by its provisions. Its duties and functions are
defined and circumscribed by the Act. Of course, as any other statutory
functionary, it undoubtedly has incidental or ancillary powers to effectively
exercise its jurisdiction in respect of the powers confided to it but the
Commission should necessarily act within the parameters prescribed by the
Act creating it and the confines of jurisdiction vested in it by the Act. The
Commission is one of the fora which can redress the grievances arising out of
the violations of human rights. Even if it is not in a position to take up the
enquiry and to afford redressal on account of certain statutory fetters or
handicaps, the aggrieved persons are not without other remedies. The
assumption underlying the observation in the concluding passage extracted
above proceeds on an incorrect premise that the person wronged by violation
of human rights would be left without remedy if the Commission does not
take up the matter."
10.
In the absence of a clear finding that the present dispute is a case
of a human rights violation, the Commission fell in serious error in entertaining
such a claim arising out of a scheme framed for compassionate appointment to
the dependants of the deceased employee. The scheme is a social security
measure not to the public at large but for those who are dependants of an
employee. Though learned counsel for the respondents has sought to distinguish
the category of service matters with the present dispute of compassionate
appointment but we do not accept that argument and agree to such an artificial
distinction on a claim for compassionate appointment arising on the death of an
employee in harness, i.e. during service.
11.
The regulations of 2022 have been framed by the learned
Commission in exercise of the powers under Section 10(2) read with Section 29
of the Act of 1993. The Commission has consciously chosen to exclude class of
complaints which relate to civil disputes, such as property rights, contractual
obligations or are relating to service matters or industrial disputes or are
allegations relating to public servant or those which do not make out any
specific violation of human rights. The regulation 9 also excludes matters
which are sub-judice before a Court or Tribunal or which are covered by a
judicial verdict or decision of the Commission. The underlying purpose for
framing such a regulation under the parent Act of 1993 is to exclude categories
of complaints which do not fall in the category of human rights violation and
otherwise are subjected to the jurisdiction of ordinary Courts or specialized
Tribunals or the High Courts.
12.
We are constrained to say that the learned Commission failed to
notice the very provision under the regulation 9 framed by itself while
proceeding to entertain a claim which does not fall in the category of human
rights violation. If such an expansive definition of human rights is read into
Section 2(d) of the Act, it would erode the very purpose of creating a
Commission under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, specifically
meant to deal with complaints relating to violations of human rights, i.e. rights
which are basic, inherent, immutable and inalienable to a person simply by
virtue of his being born a human. The present case definitely does not fall in
that category as such a claim by the respondent would not have arisen or are
enforceable, had she not been the widow of an employee dying in harness under
the Postal Department. The claim for compassionate appointment is on account
of being a dependant of an employee dying in harness under the State or its
instrumentality. Compassionate appointment is an exception to the general rule
under Article 14 of the Constitution of India which guarantees equality in
public employment. Reference is only made to the case of Umesh Kumar
Nagpal vrs. State of Haryana reported in (1994) 4 SCC 138 rendered by the
Apex Court for that purpose.
13.
In view of the aforesaid reasons, we are satisfied that the writ
petition deserves to be allowed. While passing the order, we deem it
appropriate to observe that the Commission should refrain from entertaining
such matters which are excluded under the Regulations of 2022 otherwise the
Commission may be drawn on a slippery course likely to cause not only errors
of jurisdiction but also a flood of unwanted litigations when the aggrieved
person may have a statutory or constitutional remedy elsewhere before the
appropriate forum or Court of law. The impugned order dated 08.07.2024 is
accordingly set aside. The writ petition is allowed.
14.
At the end, learned senior counsel for the private respondents Mr.
P. Roy Barman has prayed that the complainant/private respondent may be
allowed liberty to raise her claim for compassionate appointment before a
competent Court of law. She is at liberty to do so subject to all limitations in
law.
15.
The writ petition is allowed in view of above terms.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2024.12.23 11:47:39
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review