The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. 12.2012 thus, the respondent is drawing lesser pay than his junior Sri Baidya. After knowing about the said anomaly, the respondent has submitted representation with a prayer for stepping up of his pay at par with his juniors. [15] For the purpose of reference, the observation of the tribunal may be reproduced hereunder: “In the cited decision of the Hon’ble Karanata High Court also, as quoted above, the entitlement of the applicant to monetary benefits was restricted to three years only. Accordingly, entitlement of the applicant to arrear monetary benefits consequent upon the stepping up of his pay would be three years prior to the date of filing of this OA i.e. 07.05.2018. The OA is disposed of as above. There shall be no order as to costs.” [16] After meticulous appreciation of the evidence on record, it reveals that pay of the respondent was once stepped up at par Smt. Rupali Biswas, PA, which was subsequently withdrawn by the department on the ground that since he had earlier granted stepping up with Sri Biju Narayan Brahma, further stepping up is not admissible and recovery of Rs.48,568/was ordered vide memorandum dated 24.03.2018. It has also been transpired that the respondent never prayed for any stepping up of pay with Smt. Rupali Biswas, but the same was granted by the department on their own and had challenged the recovery of Rs.48,568/- in his OA but , the tribunal…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
WP(C)(CAT) No. 05 of 2020
1.
The Union of India, represented through the Secretary, Ministry of
Home Affairs, North Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi-110001.
2.
The Joint Deputy Director/CV, IB HQRs, Sadar Patel Marg,
Chanakya Puri, PIN-110021.
3.
The Joint Deputy Director/E, Subsidiary Intelligence Bureau, 35
H.G. Basak Road, Agartala, PIN-799001.
..........Petitioners
Versus
1.
Sri Gautam Kumar Das, son of late Harekrishna Das, 35 H.G. Basak
Road, Agartala, PIN-799001, SIB Office, Agartala, District: West
Tripura, PIN-799001.
..........Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. B. Majumder, CGC.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
14.09.2022
YES/NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned C.G.C. appearing for the
petitioners. Also heard Mr. S. Bhattacharjee and Mr. K. Nath, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent.
[2]
This petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India for enforcement of the Constitutional and
Fundamental rights of the petitioners guaranteed under Articles-14 and 21
of the Constitution of India and their legal and statutory right guaranteed
under CCS (Revised Pay) Rrules, 2008 along with the Rules/Instructions
relating to CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008, different office memorandums
issued by the Central Govt. and FR-SR. Also for setting aside/quashing the
impugned judgment and order dated 07.11.2019 passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Gauhati Bench, Circuit Court at Agartala in case
No. OA 041/00178 of 2018 for rendering substantive and consignable
justice to the petitioners.
[3]
The precise grievance of the respondent, herein, (applicant in
the O.A. 041/00178 of 2018) is that he was appointed stenographer GradeIII on 11.02.1993 under the petitioner’s department. He was, thereafter,
promoted to the post of personal assistant on 10.01.2008 without any
fixation. While one of his juniors namely Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya, P.A.
was allowed stepping up of pay w.e.f. 01.07.2006 and due to that, the
respondent has been drawing lesser pay than his junior. The respondent,
after lapse of couple of years, came to know about the anomaly of his pay
with reference to that of his said junior, he made several representations to
the department having requested for stepping up of his pay at par with his
juniors, but those were rejected.
[4]
The pay of the respondent had again been erroneously stepped
up at par Smt. Rupali Biswas, PA subsequently, which was cancelled. The
respondent being aggrieved thereby with the actions of the department
filed OA. challenging those orders. The department filed their common
counter/reply against the said OA pointed out that the respondent had
already availed the stepping up of his pay, thus, a second time stepping up
of his pay at par with his junior Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya is not
permissible under note 10 Rule-7 of CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 and
prayed for dismissal of the said OA. But, the learned CAT, on 07.11.2019
allowed the said OA.
[5]
The petitioners, herein, i.e. the Union of India, being
aggrieved thereby have preferred this petition assailing the impugned order
dated 07.11.2019 passed by the learned CAT and prayed for setting aside
the same.
[6]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned CGC appearing for the petitioners
has submitted that filing of original application by the respondent is not
tenable in the eye of law as the tribunal did not issue any notice to the
necessary party in the said proceeding. The tribunal while passing the
impugned order dated 07.11.2019 has given much stress to grant the
respondent stepping up of his pay at par with his junior Sri Dinesh Kumar
Baidya without going to the other aspect of the case that the respondent’s
pay was earlier stepped up at par with his juniors.
[7]
The tribunal at the time of passing impugned order dated
07.11.2019, under an erroneous thought, believed that had the respondent
got interim relief in his favour due to the reason of stay granted earlier not
to make payment of Rs.48,568/- only which was wrongly paid by the
department to him due to stepping up of his pay at par with Smt. Rupali
Biswas.
[8]
He has also stated that the impugned order dated 07.11.2019
is contrary to the provisions laid down under Note-10 Rule-7 of CCS
(Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 which, for the purpose of reference may be
reproduced as follows: “the setting up of pay is admissible with reference
to the first junior (not necessarily immediate junior) on only one occasion,
but if the junior concerned gets his pay stepped up at par with one junior
to him, then the pay of senior may again be stepped up.”
[9]
The tribunal ought to have understood that initially ACP was
introduced by the Govt. on India in 1998 and MACP is updated or
modified scheme as per recommendation of sixth CPC counting for up
gradation under MACP starts from direct entry grade on completion of 10,
20 and 30 years of service respectively. But the tribunal has failed to
understand that the pay of Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya is higher than the
respondent due to the grant of his stepping up of his pay w.e.f. 01.07.2006.
[10]
He has further argued that the pay of the respondent herein
was earlier stepped up with reference to pay of his junior vide order dated
24.06.2011 in terms of the said Rule, the stepping up of pay is admissible
with reference to the junior but (not necessarily immediate junior) on only
one occasion, but if the junior concerned gets his pay stepped up at par
with one junior to him, then the pay of senior may again be stepped up.
Therefore, according to the said Rule, the alleged claim of the respondent
for stepping up/re-fixation of pay with reference to pay of his another
junior, under the said Rules was not considered vide memo dated
11.01.2017 and 13.12.2017.
[11]
There is no rule for second time stepping up of pay with
reference to another junior in terms of note-10 under Rule-7 of the CCS
(Revised Pay) Rules, 2018, only stepping up of pay at second time is
allowed with reference to his first junior subject to fulfillment of all other
conditions under Note-10 Rule-7 of CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008. He
has submitted that stepping up of pay of the respondent for the second time
with respect to the pay of another junior other than his first junior Sri Biju
Narayan Brahma cannot be acceded to as well as tenable in law.
[12]
The respondent has made representations before the
department again and again and requested for stepping up of his pay w.e.f.
01.07.2006 to bring it at par one of his juniors namely, Dinesh Kumar
Baidya on the ground that the pay of the said Dinesh Kumar Baidya had
been stepped up with respect to another junior. He has submitted that
tribunal ought to have understood that keeping in view of the rule position
on stepping up of pay under Note-10 Rule-7 of CCS (Revised Pay) Rules,
2008 as well as under FR-22 (now FR-22(1)(a)(1), as the pay of the
respondent already been stepped up with reference to his junior namely,
Sri Biju Narayan Bramha, now his case for stepping up of pay for a second
time with reference to another junior namely Dinesh Kumar Baidya from
another date, is not permissible under the law.
[13]
Learned counsel appearing for the respondent has submitted
that according to the seniority list of stenographers as on 21.11.2007 as
well as seniority list of Pas as on 02.04.2011, the respondent is senior to
Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya who joined later than him on 21.03.1994.
Consequent upon implementation of 6th CPC pay of the respondent was
fixed at Rs.11,020/-+Grade Pay of Rs.4,600/- w.e.f. 01.07.2006 in the pay
band of Rs.9,300-34,800/-.
[14]
It has been further submitted that the anomaly arose when pay
of his junior Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya was stepped up and fixed at
Rs.13,860/- + Grade pay of Rs.4,600/- w.e.f. 01.07.2006 vide order dated
17.12.2012 thus, the respondent is drawing lesser pay than his junior Sri
Baidya. After knowing about the said anomaly, the respondent has
submitted representation with a prayer for stepping up of his pay at par
with his juniors.
[15]
For the purpose of reference, the observation of the tribunal
may be reproduced hereunder:
“In the cited decision of the Hon’ble Karanata High Court also, as quoted
above, the entitlement of the applicant to monetary benefits was restricted
to three years only. Accordingly, entitlement of the applicant to arrear
monetary benefits consequent upon the stepping up of his pay would be
three years prior to the date of filing of this OA i.e. 07.05.2018.
The OA is disposed of as above. There shall be no order as to costs.”
[16]
After meticulous appreciation of the evidence on record, it
reveals that pay of the respondent was once stepped up at par Smt. Rupali
Biswas, PA, which was subsequently withdrawn by the department on the
ground that since he had earlier granted stepping up with Sri Biju Narayan
Brahma, further stepping up is not admissible and recovery of Rs.48,568/was ordered vide memorandum dated 24.03.2018. It has also been
transpired that the respondent never prayed for any stepping up of pay with
Smt. Rupali Biswas, but the same was granted by the department on their
own and had challenged the recovery of Rs.48,568/- in his OA but , the
tribunal vide order dated 10.05.2018 stayed the recovery.
[17]
As per Note-10 to Rule-7 of the CCS (Revised Pay) Rules,
2008, stepping up of pay is admissible with reference to the first junior
(not necessarily immediate junior) on only one occasion, but if the junior
concerned gets his pay stepped up at par with one junior to him, then the
pay of the senior may again be stepped up. Accordingly, his pay was
earlier stepped up at par with Sri Biju Narayan Brahma w.e.f. 15.01.2008.
Therefore, the pay of the respondent can only be stepped up if the pay of
his junior Sri Brahma is also stepped up at par his junior which is not the
case here.
[18]
It reveals that the respondent is senior to Sri Dinesh Kumar
Baidya and upon implementation of the 6th CPC the pay of the respondent
was fixed at Rs.11,020/- + Grade pay of Rs.4,600/- w.e.f. 01.07.2006
whereas, Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya was drawing Rs.13,860/- + Grade pay
of Rs.4,600/- w.e.f. 01.07.2006. The petitioners have admitted that the
respondent is senior to Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya and the respondent is
drawing lesser pay than Sri Dinesh Kumar Baidya.
[19]
In view of above analogy, we are of the considered view that
there is no infirmity in the finding arrived at by the tribunal and thus, the
present petition stands dismissed and needs no interference whatsoever.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review