Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.545 of 2024
The Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited, a Government of Tripura
Enterprise having its registered office at Bidyut Bhawan, Banamalipur,
Agartala, Tripura West-799001 represented by its Managing Director.
………Petitioner(s);
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Department of Finance,
Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex, P.O. Secretariat, Agartala, Tripura799010
2. The Commissioner of Electricity Duty, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, Tripura799010
3. The Superintendent of Electricity Duty, Charge-I, Kar Bhawan, Agartala,
Tripura-799001
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
: Ms. M. Hazarika, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. D. Khan, Advocate.
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General,
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Order
20/08/2024
Heard Ms. M. Hazarika, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. D.
Khan, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate
General assisted by Ms. A. Chakraborty, learned counsel for the respondentsState.
2.
Petitioner is a Government of Tripura enterprise and a body
corporate engaged in generation, transmission and distribution of electricity and
also rural electrification. It is a licensee within the meaning of the Electricity
Act, 2003 and the Tripura Electricity Duty Act, 2019. An assessment
proceeding under the Tripura Electricity Duty Act, 2019 [„Act of 2019‟, for
short] brought into effect from 01.10.2019 was initiated against the petitioner
for levy of duty on inter-State sale of electricity (including Bangladesh), intraState sale of electricity (Domestic Consumer) and intra-State sale of electricity
(other than Domestic Consumer) in terms of notice bearing No.F.1/TR/CHI/2019/01/633 dated 20.07.2020 for the financial year 2019-20 under the Act of
2019. Petitioner had failed to submit the annual return in Form TED-06 despite
notices dated 27.05.2020, 20.07.2020 and 11.09.2020. Petitioner-licensee had
sought time by letter dated 31.08.2020 and 21.10.2020 to allow it reasonable
opportunity for preparation and production of the books of account in that
regard. Again a show cause notice was issued in favour of the licensee on
21.08.2020 asking it to appear and state reasons as to why demand for amount
of Rs.86.547 crore will not be raised against the financial year 2019-20 and
why penal action under Section 11(1) of the Act of 2019 be not taken upon it.
Letter dated 09.10.2020 was further issued asking the licensee to appear and
state reasons as to why no action should be taken against them in that regard,
but no reply was received. Thereafter, the Superintendent of Electricity Duty,
Charge-I, Agartala proceeded to assess the liability of the petitioner under the
Act of 2019. The assessment was made on the basis of the data provided by the
licensee to the Assessing Officer bearing letter No.F.14(91)/TSECL/FIN/2020/
17748-54 dated 26.06.2020 as the petitioner had failed to submit annual return
in Form TED-06. The electricity duty was computed in terms of the notification
dated 03.10.2019 issued by the office of the Commissioner of Electricity Duty,
Government of Tripura published as an extraordinary issue in the Tripura
Gazette on the same date [Annexure-1]. The electricity duty payable by the
licensee was ascertained in the following manner:
Sl.
No.
Nature of Sale
Inter-state (including Bangladesh)
Intra-state Sale
(Domestic Consumer)
Intra-state Sale (Other than
Domestic Consumer)
Amount
(in Crores)
841.70
277.345
Rate
@6%
@5%
Electricity Duty
(in Crores)
50.502
13.867
277.345
@7.5%
20.801
Total
Electricity Duty Deposited in 2019-20
Balance
Interest @ 18% p.a.
Penalty
Total Electricity Duty Due
85.17
4.891
80.279
14.450
0.001
94.73
This has been made subject of challenge in the present writ petition inter
alia on a number of grounds.
3.
Petitioner has also made a prayer to declare the provisions of
Section 4(1), (2)(a), 4(3) and Section 4(a), (b) & (d) as ultra vires the
Constitution of India. According to the petitioner, the Act of 2019 has come
into effect from 01.10.2019, but the impugned assessment order has computed
the electricity duty from the beginning of the financial year i.e. 01.04.2019
ending with 31.03.2020 which is not proper in the eye of law. Electricity duty
has also been imposed on inter-State sale and export of electricity outside India
even though the Constitution of India clearly debarred the State Government to
impose tax on inter-State trade and sales. Reliance is placed upon the judgment
dated 31.03.2021 passed by this Court in WP(C) No.14/2021 in the case of
ONGC Tripura Power Company Ltd. v. State of Tripura and another wherein
the provisions of Section 4(4)(d) of the Act of 2019 was held as ultra vires the
Constitution being beyond the competence of the State legislature. The intraState cess duty has also been levied mechanically ignoring the category of
consumers and exemptions granted by the various notifications of Government
of Tripura as per Annexure-20. Petitioner has also alleged that contrary to the
provisions of Section 10 of the Act of 2019, interest has been charged @18%
for the full year instead of 1.5% per month on the unpaid duty. The assessing
authority has also failed to appreciate the reasons for delay in furnishing the
audited accounts due to COVID-19. The electricity duty has been imposed not
only on the electrical energy consumed, but also on the fixed charge which is
illegal and arbitrary. Petitioner also contended that the annual return for the
financial year 2019-20 was submitted in the prescribed Form TED-06 on
31.03.2021, but the assessment order had been passed before that. Petitioner
has cited COVID delays and also the order passed by the Tripura Electricity
Regulatory Commission („TERC‟, for short) dated 04.04.2020 [Annexure-32].
Petitioner in its annual return has shown payment of electricity duty to the tune
of Rs.4,94,97,880/- [Annexure-22]. Despite detailed representation made to the
Superintendent of Electricity Duty citing glaring defects in the impugned
assessment order and praying for a reassessment, no heed was paid to it.
Thereafter, petitioner had approached the Commissioner of Electricity Dutyrespondent No.2 vide letter dated 20.09.2023 outlining the basic contention
raised by the petitioner against the impugned assessment order. Since the
petitioner is also a State Government entity, it also submitted an e-Office note
before the Secretary, Power Department, Government of Tripura. The
Commissioner in turn forwarded the office notice to TERC who called the
parties for hearing vide Annexure-25. However, after detailed consideration,
the TERC vide order dated 03.07.2024 [Annexure-28] disposed of the petition
without any specific direction as the Act provides the statutory remedy of
appeal and revision which the petitioner had not invoked, whereas the
Commission did not have any statutory power to interfere in the assessment
order. Thereafter, the petitioner has approached this Court with the following
prayers:
“In the premises aforesaid, the humble Petitioner prays to your Lordships
to be graciously pleased to call for the records of the case and issue a Rule calling
upon the Respondents to show cause Why a Writ in the nature of Certiorari
should not be issued setting aside and quashing the impugned assessment order
dated 30.11.2020 issued by the Respondent No.3 and why a writ in the nature of
Mandamus should not be issued declaring sections 4 (1), (2) (a), Section 4 (3) and
section (4 (a), (b) and (d) unconstitutional and ultra vires the Constitution of India
and why the Respondent Authorities should not be directed to refrain from taking
any action, be it coercive or otherwise, for realizing the demand made by the
impugned Assessment order directing the respondents and upon perusal of the
records and hearing the parties be pleased to make the Rule absolute and/or pass
such further or other order or orders as your Lordships may deem fit and proper.
And or pass such further Order/Orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem
fit and proper.
-AndPending the final disposal of this petition this Hon'ble Court may be
pleased to stay all further proceedings pursuant to the impugned Assessment
order dated 30.11.2020 (Annexure-14) direct the Respondent Authorities not to
take any coercive steps against the Petitioner for realizing any amount pursuant to
the Assessment order the pendency of the case.”
4.
Ms. M. Hazarika, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, submits
that since the assessing authority has also imposed electricity duty on interState sales and inter-country sales which is contrary to the constitutional
scheme, the impugned order is without jurisdiction. The vires of Section 4(4)(d)
of the Act of 2019 has been struck down by a Coordinate Bench of this Court in
WP(C) No.14/2021 vide judgment dated 31.03.2021 as being beyond the
competence of the State legislature. Section 4(4)(d) provided for levy of
electricity duty on electricity sold outside the State on sold energy charges. A
major component of the liability imposed upon the petitioner under Section
4(4)(d) towards inter-State sale and inter-country sales totalling Rs.50.502 crore
is wholly without jurisdiction. The impugned order is, therefore, amenable to
writ jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Petitioner has, therefore, approached this Court instead of availing the statutory
remedy of appeal and revision under the Act of 2019. Learned senior counsel
for the petitioner prays that though other issues of levy of electricity duty on
fixed charges has been raised and the vires of Section 4(1), (2)(a), 4(3) and
Section 4(a), (b) & (d) have been challenged but leaving those issues open for
the present, the matter may be remanded to the assessing authority to pass a
fresh assessment order, in accordance with law, taking into account the
judgment rendered by this Court in WP(C) No.14/2021 whereby the levy of
electricity duty on inter-State sale of electricity and inter-country sale of
electricity, has been held ultra vires. The levy of electricity duty on inter-State
sale and export of electricity outside India is wholly beyond the jurisdiction of
the State legislature in terms of the CGST Act, IGST Act, Article 286 of the
Constitution of India and also under Article 246A read with the relevant entries
of the Seventh Schedule list-II i.e. Entry 53 and 54 in its amended form and
Entry 92A of list-I, the impugned assessment order is unsustainable in law. The
learned Division Bench of this Court in the case of ONGC Tripura Power
Company Ltd. (supra) has squarely dealt with all these contentions on the
question of virus of Section 4(4)(d) of the Act of 2019. The said judgment has
attained finality. Therefore, the matter may be remanded to the Assessing
Authority for passing a fresh assessment order in accordance with law giving
opportunity to the petitioner to produce its relevant records including the annual
return in Form TED-06 for the financial year 2019-20. Petitioner may be
allowed to agitate other grounds before the assessing authority leaving the
question of vires of the relevant provisions of the Act of 2019 open for
consideration at an appropriate stage.
5.
Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General appearing for the
respondents-State, at the outset submits that this Court in the case of ONGC
Tripura Power Company Ltd. (supra) judgment dated 31.03.2021 in WP(C)
14/2021, has held that Section 4(4)(d) of the Act of 2019 is ultra vires the
Constitution of India being beyond the competence of the State legislature.
Therefore, no levy of electricity duty on inter-State sale and export of
electricity outside India would be levied by the Assessing Officer. He does not
dispute the plea raised by the petitioner that the impugned assessment order
suffers from jurisdictional error. He submits that in such circumstances, since
the impugned assessment order suffers from serious jurisdictional error, at this
stage instead of getting into the question of vires of the other provisions of the
Act of 2019, it would be proper that the matter is remanded to the assessing
authority to pass a fresh assessment order in accordance with law. Petitioner
may submit its detailed records and annual return before the assessing authority
in the reassessment proceeding. The assessing authority may be directed to pass
a fresh assessment order within a reasonable period as the assessment relates to
the financial year 2019-20.
6.
The relevant facts which have been placed from record have been
noted in the foregoing part of this order.
It appears that after coming into force of the Act of 2019 with
effect from 01.10.2019, the first assessment exercise for the financial year
2019-20 has been undertaken by the respondent No.3-Superintendent of
Electricity Duty, Charge-I, Agartala vide show cause notice dated 21.08.2020
[Annexure-9] issued upon the petitioner asking him to explain as to why
electricity duty be not imposed upon inter-State sale of electricity (including
Bangladesh) to the tune of Rs.50.502 crore; intra-State sale to the tune of
Rs.27.734 crore totalling Rs.78.236 crore minus the amount of electricity duty
deposited totalling Rs.4.891 crore i.e. the balance of Rs.73.345 crore with
interest @18% per annum. Since the petitioner did not submit its annual return
in Form TED-06 within time, the assessment has been made vide impugned
assessment order dated 30.11.2020 on the basis of the data provided by the
petitioner-licensee vide letter bearing No.F.14(91)/TSECL/FIN/2020/17748-54
dated 26.06.2020. The impugned assessment order has levied electricity duty to
the tune of Rs.50.502 crore on inter-State (including Bangladesh sale) and also
on intra-State sale (Domestic Consumer) for Rs.13.867 crore and intra-State
sale (other than Domestic Consumer) to the tune of Rs.20.801 crore totalling
Rs.85.17 crore minus the electricity duty deposited i.e. the balance outstanding
being 80.279 crore with interest @18% per annum. The total electricity duty
due upon the petitioner was assessed as Rs.94.73 crore. It appears that
petitioner had taken the plea of COVID delays in submission of its annual
return relying upon the decision of the TERC vide order dated 04.04.2020.
Petitioner however was pursuing the matter with the State Government on the
understanding that it being a State instrumentality, the matter would be
resolved without further litigation. Thereafter, it has approached the TERC
which has refused to interfere as the statute does not provide any remedy before
the Regulatory Commission. Petitioner has, therefore, approached this Court in
writ jurisdiction inter alia on a number of grounds which have been referred to
hereinbefore.
7.
However, during course of submission learned senior counsel for
the petitioner has confined her prayer for the present to the levy of electricity
duty on inter-State sale of electricity and export outside India which forms a
major component of the total liability assessed upon the petitioner i.e. 50.502
crore on the ground that the same is wholly beyond jurisdiction in view of the
lack of competence of the State legislature to levy tax or duty on inter-State
sale or export outside India under the Constitution of India and the judgment
dated 31.03.2021 rendered by this Court in WP(C) No.14/2021 whereby the
provisions of Section 4(4)(d) of the Act of 2019 was held to be ultra vires as
being beyond the competence of the State legislature.
8.
Learned Advocate General has fairly submitted that the impugned
assessment order, so far as it levies electricity duty on inter-State and intercountry sale i.e. export outside India is beyond jurisdiction as held by this Court
in the case of ONGC Tripura Power Company Ltd. (supra). However, he
submits that since the impugned assessment order suffers from an illegality and
jurisdictional error, it would be appropriate that the matter is remanded for the
assessing authority to pass a fresh assessment order in accordance with law. In
order to deal with the issue it is pertinent to refer to the charging provision
under Section 4, specifically sub-section 4 of the Tripura Electricity Duty Act,
2019.
“4. Levy of electricity duty:
(1) There shall be levied and paid to the State Government a duty, to be called the
“electricity duty", at the rate as prescribed by the Commissioner with the approval of
the State Government by Notification from time to time in the official gazette on the
aggregate value of energy charges and fixed charges.
(2) Levy of electricity duty on sales of energy by licensees:
(a) every licensee in the State of Tripura shall pay in the prescribed manner at the
rate as notified under sub-section (1) on the aggregate value of energy charges and
fixed charges within and outside the State;
(b) when a licensee has more than one licences duty shall be calculated and levied
under this section separately in respect of each license;
(3) Levy of electricity duty on consumersEvery consumer belonging to any of the classes, shall pay a duty every month to the
Government in the prescribed manner at the rate as notified under sub-section (1) on
the aggregate value of energy charges and fixed charges of energy consumed on the
basis of consumption measured (meter reading) as mentioned in sub-section (5) or
energy sold based on scheduled energy as per CERC/TERC norms;
Provided, it shall be competent for the Government either to reduce the rate at which
duty is leviable on such consumer or to exempt such consumer from payment of
duty subject to such terms & conditions that may be imposed in lieu of public
interest.
(4) Duty shall also be levied on(a) electricity consumed by or sold to the Government of India for consumption by
that Government; or
(b) consumed in the construction, maintenance or operation of any railway by that
Government of India or a railway company operating that railway or sold to that
Government or any such railway company for consumption in the construction,
maintenance or operation of any railway; or
(c) electricity generated and sold through non-conventional mode of energy
generation (viz. solar units, windmill, etc.), in case the aggregate annual generation
exceeds such units as may be prescribed; or
(d) electricity sold outside the State and licensees shall have to pay electricity duty
on sold energy charges.
(5) (a)For the purpose of computing the electricity duty under this section, the
consumption, shown in the meters or any other method to compute the energy sold
based on scheduled energy as per CERC/TERC norms shall be taken into account.
(b) For the purpose of sub-section (a), the computing shall be started from the
starting of the billing period immediately after the commencement of this Act.”
9.
For the present, the challenge has been confined to the leviablity of
the electricity duty on inter-state sale and sale of electricity outside the country
by the petitioner. Since, the vires of the said provision were specifically raised
before this court in ONGC Tripura Power Company Ltd. v. State of Tripura
and another (WP(C) No.14/2021) reported in 2021 SCC OnLine Tri 667 and a
definitive declaration has been made by this court earlier, we do not need to
dilate on the issue of vires of the said provision. Instead the opinion of this
court in the case of ONGC Tripura Power Company Ltd.(supra) are profitably
extracted hereunder:
“44. In the result, petition is disposed of with following directions and declarations :
(i) Section 4(4)(d) of the E. D. Act, 2019 is unconstitutional and ultra vires, being
beyond the competence of the State Legislature ;
(ii) No duty on the petitioner's inter-State sale of electricity shall henceforth be
levied and collected ;
(iii) Duty already collected is declared illegal ;
(iv) With respect to the duty already collected, the petitioner shall produce its full
accounts before the Secretary, Finance within a period of one month from today
pointing out the extent of duty borne by itself and the element of duty passed on by
the petitioner. The Secretary thereupon shall verify such documents and pass an
order refunding the duty to the extent it is not passed on by the petitioner to the
purchaser or any other consumer. Such order shall be passed after allowing the
authorized representative of the petitioner to be heard, if so desired by the petitioner.
The order shall be passed within three months of the petitioner filing its documents
and accounts before the Secretary, Finance Department ;
(v) To the extent the duty is found refundable, the same shall be refunded within
four months after the Secretary, Finance passes the order. As long as these timelines
are maintained by the respondents, of course subject to the petitioner itself filing
necessary documents before the Secretary, Finance within one month from today,
such refund shall carry no interest, failing which the refund shall carry simple
interest at six per cent. per annum, upon completion of the periods granted in this
order till actual payment.”
10.
The learned court has not only declared Section 4(4)(d) of the Act
of 2019 as unconstitutional and ultra vires being beyond the competence of the
State Legislature but has also gone on to hold that no duty on inter-state sale of
electricity shall be levied and collected. It has also held that duty already
collected is declared to be illegal.
11.
Thus we are of the considered view that since the issue relating to
levy of electricity duty on inter-State and inter-country sale of electricity is a
question of jurisdiction being wholly beyond the competence of the State
legislature and the issues stand decided in the case of ONGC Tripura Power
Company Ltd. (supra) by a Coordinate Bench of this Court, the writ petition is
fit to be entertained in the light of the principles laid down by the Apex Court
in the case of Magadh Sugar and Energy Limited v. State of Bihar and Others
reported in (2022) 16 SCC 428 . Paragraphs 20, 26 & 27 of the report are being
extracted hereunder:
“20. While a High Court would normally not exercise its writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution if an effective and efficacious alternative
remedy is available, the existence of an alternative remedy does not by itself bar
the High Court from exercising its jurisdiction in certain contingencies. This
principle has been crystallised by this Court in Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of
Trade Marks and Harbanslal Sahnia v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. Recently, in
Radha Krishan Industries v. State of H.P. a two-Judge Bench of this Court of
which one of us was a part of (D.Y. Chandrachud, J.) has summarised the
principles governing the exercise of writ jurisdiction by the High Court in the
presence of an alternative remedy. This Court has observed: (Radha Krishan
Industries case, SCC p. 795, para 27)
"27. The principles of law which emerge are that:
27.1. The power under Article 226 of the Constitution to issue writs can be exercised
not only for the enforcement of fundamental rights, but for any other purpose as
well.
27.2. The High Court has the discretion not to entertain a writ petition. One of the
restrictions placed on the power of the High Court is where an effective alternative
remedy is available to the aggrieved person.
27.3. Exceptions to the rule of alternative remedy arise where: (a) the writ petition
has been filed for the enforcement of a fundamental right protected by Part III of the
Constitution; (b) there has been a violation of the principles of natural justice; (c) the
order or proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction; or (d) the vires of a legislation
is challenged.
27.4. An alternative remedy by itself does not divest the High Court of its powers
under Article 226 of the Constitution in an appropriate case though ordinarily, a writ
petition should not be entertained when an efficacious alternative remedy is
provided by law.
27.5. When a right is created by a statute, which itself prescribes the remedy or
procedure for enforcing the right or liability, resort must be had to that particular
statutory remedy before invoking the discretionary remedy under Article 226 of the
Constitution. This rule of exhaustion of statutory remedies is a rule of policy,
convenience and discretion.
27.6. In cases where there are disputed questions of fact, the High Court may decide
to decline jurisdiction in a writ petition. However, if the High Court is objectively of
the view that the nature of the controversy requires the exercise of its writ
jurisdiction, such a view would not readily be interfered with.” (emphasis supplied)
*
*
*
26. The issues raised by the appellant are questions of law which require,
upon a comprehensive reading of the Bihar Electricity Act, a determination of
whether tax can be levied on the supply of electricity by a power generator
(which also manufactures sugar) supplying electricity to a distributor; and
whether the first respondent has the legislative competence to levy duty on the
sale of electricity to an intermediary distributor in view of the decision of this
Court in State of A.P. The question of whether the appellant is liable to file
returns under Sections 6-B(1) and 5-A of the Act is directly related to the issue of
whether the sale of electricity by the appellant to BSEB falls under the charging
provisions of Section 3(1). The questions raised by the appellant can be
adjudicated without delving into any factual dispute. Thus, the present matter is
amenable to the writ jurisdiction of the High Court.
27. We are of the considered view that the High Court made an error in
declining to entertain the writ petition and it would be appropriate to restore the
proceedings back to the High Court for a fresh disposal. In order to facilitate the
decision on remand, we have recorded the broad submissions of the parties on
merits but leave the matter open for a fresh evaluation by the High Court. We
accordingly allow the appeal and set aside the judgment of the High Court dated
18-9-2017 arising out of CWJC No. 4300 of 2015. The writ petition is restored to
the file of the High Court for fresh determination. The appeal is disposed of in the
above terms with no order as to costs.”
12.
Since the assessment order suffers from illegality and lack of
jurisdiction on the levy of electricity duty on inter-state and sale of electricity
outside India and calls for determination on a question of law without reference
to the factual scenario, the writ petition can be entertained. The impugned
assessment order dated 30.11.2020 [Annexure-18] levies electricity duty on
inter-state sale and sale or export of electricity outside India which is beyond
the jurisdiction of the State legislature as held in the case of ONGC Tripura
Power Company (supra), the same cannot be upheld in the eye of law.
Accordingly, it is set aside and the matter is remanded to the assessing
authority to pass a fresh assessment order in accordance with law. Since the
petitioner has confined its prayer to the issue of levy of electricity duty on interState and inter-country sale at the present, the other issues as to the vires of
Section 4(1), (2)(a), 4(3) and 4(a), (b) & (d) are left open to be raised at an
appropriate stage. Petitioner is at liberty to raise other issues on facts and law
before the assessing authority. The Assessing Officer shall, upon hearing the
parties and upon consideration of the relevant records, pass a fresh assessment
order in accordance with law within a reasonable period preferably 12(twelve)
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.
13.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the instant petition
stands disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Pijush/
signed by MUNNA SAHA
MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2024.09.06 16:22:38 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review