Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
FRIDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025/18TH MAGHA, 1946
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
IN THE MATTER OF TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD - REPORT NO. 6/2025 BY
THE OMBUDSMAN IN PETITION NO. 11/2024 - APPROVAL OF ESTIMATE AND AWARD
FOR THE WORK OF AYARKAVU DEVASWOM IN KOTTARAKKARA GROUP - CONSTRUCTING
CHUTTAMBALAM - SUO MOTU PROCEEDINGS INITIATED - REG.
PETITIONERS:
THE TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, NANTHANCODE, KAWDIAR P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695 003
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695003
RESPONDENT:
THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR
KERALA STATE AUDIT DEPARTMENT, TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD,
NANTHANCODE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695 003
OTHER PRESENT:
SRI. S. RAJMOHAN, SR.GP;
SRI. P. RAMAMCHANDRAN, AMICUS CURIAE;
SRI. G. BIJU, SC, TDB
THIS DEVASWOM BOARD PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
07.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
DBP No.12 of 2025
2025:KER:10299
ORDER
Anil K. Narendran, J.
This DBP is registered based on Report No.6 of 2025 of the
learned Ombudsman in Petition No.11 of 2024 filed by the
Travancore Devaswom Board and its Executive Engineer seeking
approval of the estimate and award of the work of Ayarkadu
Devaswom
in
Kottarakkra
Group,
for
the
construction
of
Chuttambalam. The report dated 03.01.2025 of the learned
Ombudsman reads thus;
“2. This petition was filed by the Travancore Devaswom
Board and the Executive Engineer seeking approval for the
award of the contract in respect of the work relating
Ayarkadu
Devaswom
construction
of
in
Kottarakkara
'Chuttambalam'
at
Group
an
for
the
estimate
of
Rs.47,63,000/-. It is mentioned in the petition that the
Board has accorded administrative sanction to the estimate
of the above work for Rs.47,63,000/- vide Board ROC
No.702/24/M dated 01.02.2024 based on DSR 2018
including 18% GST. Copy of the administrative sanction was
produced as Annexure A-I along with the petition. It is also
mentioned in the petition that the Temple Advisory
Committee has agreed to do the work at 25% below the
sanctioned estimate rate. For this they have nominated Sri.
Arun M.S as their nominee. The resolution of the Temple
Advisory Committee and written willingness of the nominee
Sri.Arun M.S were produced along with the petition as
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
Annexures II and III respectively. The Board has accorded
contract sanction in favour of the Temple Administrative
Committee nominee Sri.Arun M.S at 25% below the
sanctioned estimate rate and copy of the contract sanction
of the Board in favour of the Temple Advisory Committee
was produced along with the petition as Annexure IV. They
have also produced technical sanction for the work by the
Chief Engineer, copy of which was produced as Annexure V
along with the petition. They have also produced copy of the
estimate report based on DSR 2018 giving details of the
nature of the work and the amount required for each work,
copy of which was produced as Annexure VI to the petition.
They have produced sanctioned estimate (DSR 2018) along
with the petition as Annexure VII. It is stated in the petition
that the estimate was prepared based on the plan which was
prepared by the Travancore Devaswom Board Architect as
per Sasthric principle and produced copy of the plan so
prepared as Annexure VIII along with the specifications
given by Sri.V.P.Brahmadathan Namboodiripad, Vasthu
expert on this aspect. The Sub Group Officer, Chirakkadavu
Sub Group has produced income and expenditure statement
of the Ayarkadu Devaswom for the last three years and the
same was produced along with the petition as Annexure IX.
Since the estimate is above Rs.20 lakhs, this petition is filed
for getting approval and sanction of the Honourable High
Court.
3. On the basis of the averments in the petition, remarks
were called for from the State Audit Department and the
State Audit Department has filed their first remarks/counter
2025:KER:10299
affidavit dated 07.11.2024 wherein they analysed the
DBP No.12 of 2025
details mentioned in the Maramath Petition for approval and
the documents produced along with the petition by the
Travancore Devaswom Board. It was mentioned in the said
remarks that the concurrence of the Thanthri (Anujna) for
the proposed construction of Chuttambalam was not
produced along with the petition and that will have to be
produced for verification. Provisions for income-tax and
Kerala Building and other construction workers Welfare Fund
contribution should be made in the final estimate of the
work. Building Permit has to be obtained from the Local
Authority for the proposed construction of 'Chuttambalam'
after getting approval of the petition. The proposal can be
approved subject to audit of the expenditure incurred for
the aforesaid works. The counter affidavit/remarks of the
State Audit Department is produced as Annexure 01 to this
report.
4. On the basis of the first remarks, as per proceedings
dated 07.11.2024 the then Ombudsman observed that in
answer to the remarks of the Audit regarding building
permit from the local body, the Executive Engineer, who was
present, stated that as a practice no building permit from
the Local Authority is required as the work is related to
temple. In view of the request made by the Travancore
Devaswom Board, time was granted to submit the opinion
of the Thanthri and posted the case to 19.12.2024 and they
produced the consent from the Thanthri Sri. V. Vasudevaru
Vasudevaru dated 21.11.2024 along with the letter of the
Executive Engineer dated 02.12.2024. This letter was
received in the office on 09.12.2024 along with the consent
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
given
by
2025:KER:10299
Sri.Vasudevaru
Vasudevaru,
Harisree
Thazhamangalathu Madom, the Thanthri of the temple,
wherein
the
Thanthri
has
accorded
permission
for
construction of the 'chuttambalam' and stated that it is
highly required for the purpose of the temple as per the
'Nalambala Kshethracharam'. The letter of the Executive
Engineer dated 02.12.2024 along with the consent of the
Thanthri dated 27.11.2024 is produced as Annexure 02.
5. The State Audit Department has filed their second
remarks/counter affidavit darted 19.12.2024 in respect of
the necessity for obtaining building permit and also
consideration of the opinion given by the Thanthri. It was
mentioned therein that the Executive Engineer furnished
letter No 995 dated 01.12.2024 (received on 18.12.2024 by
the Audit) along with the letter of permission of the Thanthri.
It is further mentioned in the further counter affidavit that
the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules 2019 was issued under
G.O.(P)No 78/2019/LSGD dated 02.11.2019 and published
as per SRO No 829/2019 in the Kerala Gazette Extra
Ordinary No 2692 dated 08.11.2019. Chapter II Rule 4 deals
with Essentiality of Permit wherein it was mentioned as
follows: No person shall develop or redevelop any parcel of
land by subdividing into plots or cause the same to be done
without first obtaining permit for each such develop or
redevelop
from
the
Secretary.
This
is
applicable
to
Chuttambalam also. Building permit from the Panchayat has
to be obtained from the Panchayat Secretary.
6. It is further mentioned in the counter affidavit of the State
Audit Department that as per G.O. (Ms) No 120/2021/LSGD
2025:KER:10299
dated 28.06.2021 (Kerala Panchayat Building (Amendment)
DBP No.12 of 2025
Rules, 2021) and published as SRO No.482/2021 in Kerala
Gazette Extra Ordinary No 1897 dated 29.06.2021, under
Rule 4 (ii) permission may be obtained from the Panchayat
for the proposed building for religious purpose. The building
permit has to be obtained after getting approval for the
present petition and before the commencement of work.
They have submitted that the above petition may kindly be
approved subject to Audit of all the expenditure incurred in
the aforesaid work and also on the basis of the remarks
furnished by the Audit Department. The second counter
affidavit/remarks
dated
19.12.2024
is
produced
as
Annexure 03 along with this report.
7. The matter was heard on 23.12.2024 at 11.00 a.m and
Sri.T.K.Harikumar, Senior Deputy Director of the Kerala
State Audit Department submitted that approval can be
granted subject to obtaining building permit before the
commencement of the work and making the expenditure
subject to audit. Smt. Anjana Sasi, in charge of Executive
Engineer, Thiruvananthapurm submitted that as per the
practice no building permit is obtained for construction of
temple structures.
8. Considered the objections and documents produced along
with the petition for approval.
9. It is seen from the documents produced along with the
petition that necessary plan was prepared as per the DSR
2018 and administrative sanction granted and the plan was
prepared on the basis of the Shastric principles on the basis
of
the
suggestion
given
by
Sri.V.P.
Brahmadathan
Namboodiripad and the opinion of the Thanthri was also
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
obtained for this purpose. Administrative sanction for
contract was also given to entrust the work to the nominee
of the Temple Advisory Committee, Sri.Arun M.S who has
agreed to complete the work at less than 25% of the
estimated amount. The main objection raised in the counter
affidavit of the Audit Department was that building permit
is to be obtained before starting the construction as per the
Kerala Panchayat Building Rules 2019, as amended in 2021
and the expenditure incurred must be subjected to audit
and provision for income-tax and the Kerala Building and
other Construction Workers Welfare Fund Contribution
should be made with final estimate.
10. Chapter II Rule 4 of the Kerala Panchyat Building Rules
2019 deals with essentiality of permit. Sub-rule (1) of Rule
4 says that "No person shall develop or redevelop any parcel
of land by subdividing into plots or cause the same to be
done without first obtaining a permit for each such
development or redevelopment from the Secretary. Subrule (2) said Rules, which was amended in 2021 as per
G.O.(Ms)No.120/2021/LSGD
dated
28.06.2021
and
published as per SRO No 482/2021 in the Kerala Gazette
Extra Ordinary No.1897 dated 29.06.2021, says that no
person shall construct or reconstruct or make addition or
extension or alteration to any building or cause the same to
be done without first obtaining a building permit from the
Secretary and in the case of low risk building without
obtaining an Acknowledgment Receipt which shall be
deemed to be a permit from the Secretary. Rule 8 of the
said Rules deals with 'permit not necessary for certain
2025:KER:10299
works', which does not include the temple construction. Rule
DBP No.12 of 2025
7 of the said Rules deals with exemption to certain
operational construction by Government, both State and
Central, which also does not include any construction for
temple
purpose.
In
the
case
of
development
or
redevelopment of land, construction or reconstruction of
building including alteration, addition or extension or
change
in
the
occupancy
by
the
Central
or
State
Government departments, Rule 4 sub rule (3) says that they
need only to submit an intimation to the Secretary of the
Local Authority along with plan prepared by the Chief Town
Planner stating that the construction was in accordance with
the provisions of the Panchayat Building Rules and no
permission as such is required.
11. Further, this issue was considered by the Honourable
High Court in DBP No.109 of 2024 between Travancore
Devaswom Board and another v. Deputy Director, Kerala
State Audit Department, while considering report No. 65 in
Petition No.8 of 2024 filed by the Travancore Devaswom
Board and its Executive Engineer seeking approval of
estimate in respect of the construction of Oottupura in
Cheruthrikka Kallambalam Devaswom, Thrikkariyoor Group
and approval was granted with direction to obtain permit
under the provisions of the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules
2019 from the Local Authority, as per order dated
27.11.2024.
12. The remarks of the State Audit Department only says
that the building permit is to be obtained from the Local
Authority before the commencement of the construction and
the expenses will have to be subjected to audit and
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
provision will have to be made in respect of income-tax and
Kerala Building and other Construction Workers Welfare
Fund contribution should be included in the final estimate.
13. Rule 3 of the said Rules deals with applications under
the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules 2019 as amended in
2021 to all public and private buildings. It may be
mentioned here that Government has got power to grant
exemption
or
relaxation
for
any
building
from
the
applicability of Building Rules under sub-rule (5) of Rule 3
of the said Rules. If the Devaswom want any exemption,
they can approach the Government for granting such
exemption or relaxation in respect of development or
redevelopment or construction or reconstruction or change
of occupancy etc. In respect of constructions relating to
temple structures in the State.
14. On 09.01.2025 the Ombudsman has visited the said
temple along with the Assistant Devaswom Commissioner,
Kottarakkara. The Assistant Commissioner, Padinjarekkara
Devaswom who is in charge of this Devaswom as well, the
Executive
Engineer
Ananthakrishnan,
Smt.
Geetha
Assistant
Gopalakrishnan,
Engineer
and
Sri
Sri.Athul,
Overseer of the Devaswom Board and discussed about the
nature of work to be done as per this proposal. The
Ombudsman is convinced that the said work is required.
15. The Ombudsman also noticed that some of the tiles of
the roof and the temple are in a disarrayed manner. When
this was pointed out, the President and Secretary of the
Temple
Advisory
Committee,
who
are
also
present,
submitted that they will rectify the same while doing the
2025:KER:10299
maintenance work. The temple tank requires immediate
DBP No.12 of 2025
cleaning and this will also have to be considered.''
2.
Heard the learned Standing Counsel for Travancore
Devaswom
Board
for
the
petitioners,
the
learned
Senior
Government Pleader for respondent Deputy Director, Kerala State
Audit Department, Travancore Devaswom Board Audit and also the
learned Amicus Curie for the learned Ombudsman.
3.
In Arjunan T.N. v. President, Temple Advisory
Committee and others [2012 (4) KHC 155] a Division Bench
of this Court was dealing with a DBP registered on the basis of
TDB Report No.39 of 2011 of the learned Ombudsman on a
complaint made by the devotees of Kaippillikkavu Bhagavathi
Temple, which is a temple under the management of Travancore
Devaswom Board relating to purchase of 20 cents of land in front
of that temple, utilising the money collected from the devotees by
the Temple Advisory Committee of that temple. The Tantri of the
temple inaugurated the collection scheme. One Somanathan, who
was dealing with the affairs of the Temple Advisory Committee,
and Madhusoodhanan, registered a Trust in the name Sree
Bhagavathi Seva Trust and the land was purchased in the name of
that Trust utilising the funds collected from the devotees. The
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
registration of the Trust was more than two months after the
collection of funds and the property was got conveyed in favour of
Madhusoodhanan, Somanathan and Raveendran on behalf of that
Trust. The Division Bench held that the acquisition on behalf of
Sree Bhagavathi Seva Trust is, obviously, in the form of a
dedication to the deity of the temple concerned and such
dedication has been made utilising the funds collected from the
public at large, that too, by an entity acting on behalf of the people,
who were prepared to make such dedication. For such collection,
receipts have been issued by the Convenor of the Land
Endowment Scheme, a conglomeration of well minded devotees.
It has to be presumed that the benefit of such collection is for the
purpose of the deity.
Under such circumstances, the Division
Bench held that the extent of 20 cents of land covered by
document No.6540/2006 is an item of property which stands
dedicated in favour of the deity and the purchase of the land
utilising the amounts was only for the sake of; in favour of; and,
in the course of dedication to, the deity. The Travancore
Devaswom Board holds all the properties of the temples under its
control, in terms of the provisions of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu
DBP No.12 of 2025
2025:KER:10299
Religious Institutions Act. Therefore, the Division Bench declared
that the land covered by the aforesaid document and all structures
standing thereon vest absolutely in the deity of Kaippallikkavu
Bhagavathi Temple and those properties can only be managed by
the Travancore Devaswom Board. Any person occupying such
property, including Sree Bhagavathi Seva Trust, shall cease to
occupy
that
parcel
and
it
will
be
exclusively
under
the
management and control of the Travancore Devaswom Board on
behalf of the deity.
4.
In Murukan K.K. v. Travancore Devaswom Board
and others [2025 (1) KHC SN 17] in view of the prohibitions
contained in Clauses 9, 12 and 18 of the Rules (Bye-laws) for the
formation of Temple Advisory Committees in temples under the
management of Travancore Devaswom Board, any collection of
funds by the Temple Advisory Committee in connection with the
conduct of temple festival or construction or repair or renovation
work in the temple can only be made with the prior approval of
the Travancore Devaswom Board, against sealed coupons issued
by the Assistant Commissioner. The Secretary of the Temple
Advisory Committee has to cause the accounts relating to the
collection of funds, income and expenditure audited, which shall
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
be produced before the authorities in the Board before 30 th April
of every year. In view of the provisions contained in Clause 12 of
the Rules, in the event of any specific financial irregularities in the
activities of the Temple Advisory Committee, the Devaswom
Commissioner shall have the absolute power to remove that
Committee. Clause 18 of the Rules prohibits collection of funds by
the
Temple
Advisory
Committee
in
connection
with
any
ceremonies in the temples by placing kanikka vanchies or hundis.
No receipts without the seal of the Assistant Commissioner shall
be used for collecting funds, when the Board has granted
permission for collection of funds at the initiative of the Temple
Advisory Committee.
5.
In Murukan K.K. [2025 (1) KHC SN 17] this Court
held that, in view of the law laid down by this Court in Arjunan
T.N. [2012 (4) KHC 155], the collection of funds by the Temple
Advisory Committee, based on the approval granted by the Board,
against receipts with the seal of the Assistant Commissioner, in
connection with the conduct of temple festival or for construction,
repair or renovation work in the temple, is collection of money in
the name of the deity. The purpose of such collection is for the
DBP No.12 of 2025
2025:KER:10299
benefit of the deity. Therefore, the amounts collected by the
Temple
Advisory
Committees
in
the
temples
under
the
management of the Board, in connection with the conduct of
temple festivals or for construction, repair or renovation work in
the temple, which are credited into the account of the Temple
Advisory Committee, has to be transferred to the Devaswom fund
temporarily. Thereafter, adopting the method of issuing payment
cheques from the Devaswom fund, on the basis of payment bills
prepared by the Maramath wing of the Board, payments can be
released to the contractor. By adopting such a procedure, the
supervision of the Maramath wing of the Board will be more
effective and the work files can be kept in the Maramath wing,
which can be subjected to regular audit by the State Audit
Department, annually.
6.
In Travancore Devaswom Board and another v.
Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit Department [2024:
KER:89527] this Court held that in view of the provisions
contained in the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules, 2019, the award
of contract in favour of the contractor for the construction of
Ootupura in Cheruthikka Kalambalam Devaswom in Thrikkariyoor
Group, a temple under the management of the Travancore
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
Devaswom Board, shall be subject to the condition that the
construction shall be commenced only after obtaining building
permit under the provisions of the said Rules from the concerned
Local Self Government Institution. Paragraphs 6, 7 and also the
last paragraph of that order read thus;
“6. In the remarks dated 17.10.2024 filed by the respondent
Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Travancore
Devaswom Board Audit, which is marked as Annexure O3 in
report No.65 of 2024, it is specifically pointed out provisions
under Rule 4 of the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules, 2019,
which deals with essentiality of permit.
7. As per sub-rule (ii) of Rule 4 of the said Rules, no person
shall construct or reconstruct or make addition or extension
or alteration to any building or cause the same to be done
without first obtaining a building permit from the Secretary
and in the case of low-risk building without obtaining an
acknowledgement receipt which shall be deemed to be a
permit from the Secretary.
Having considered the pleadings and materials on record
and also the submissions made at the Bar, we deem it
appropriate to dispose of this DBP by granting approval of
estimate
for
Rs.29,72,000/-
for
the
construction
of
Oottupura in Cheruthrikka Kallambalam Devaswom in
Thrikkariyoor Group, and the award of contract in favour of
the contractor, subject to the condition that the construction
shall be commenced only after obtaining building permit
2025:KER:10299
under the provisions of the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules,
DBP No.12 of 2025
2019, from the concerned Local Self Government Institution
and that the entire income and expenditure in this regard
shall be subjected to statutory audit, by the State Audit
Department.”
7.
In paragraph 12 of Report No.6 of 2025, the learned
Ombudsman noticed the remarks of the State Audit Department
regarding the necessity of building permit, the provisions that
have to be made in respect of income tax and also contribution to
the Kerala Building and other Construction Workers Welfare Fund.
Having considered the pleadings and materials on record and
also the submissions made at the Bar, we deem it appropriate to
dispose of this DBP by granting approval for the estimate and the
award of contract work for the construction of chuttambalam of
Ayarkadu Devaswom in Kottarakkara Group as sought for in
Petition No.11 of 2024, subject to the directions contained in the
decisions of this Court in Murukan K.K. v. Travancore
Devaswom Board and others [2025 (1) KHC SN 17] and
Travancore Devaswom Board and another v. Deputy
Director, Kerala State Audit Department [2024:KER:89527]
and also the remarks of the Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit
Department referred to in paragraph 12 of Report No.6 of 2025 of
DBP NO. 12 OF 2025
2025:KER:10299
the learned Ombudsman. The entire income and expenditure in
relation to the construction work shall be subjected to statutory
audit by the State Audit Department.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
Dxy
DBP No.12 of 2025
2025:KER:10299
APPENDIX OF DBP 12/2025
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE O1
COPY OF REMARKS OF THE STATE AUDIT
DEPARTMENT DATED 07-11-2024
ANNEXURE O2
COPY OF LETTER DATED 02-12-2024 OF THE
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER ALONG WITH THE
CONSENT OF THE THANTHRI
ANNEXURE O3
COPY OF REMARKS OF THE STATE AUDIT
DEPARTMENT DATED 19-12-2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review