Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:14290
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
THURSDAY, THE 13TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 24TH MAGHA, 1946
RP NO. 33 OF 2025
AGAINST
THE
JUDGMENT
DATED
24.12.2024
IN
WP(C)
NO.46310 OF 2024 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
REVIEW PETITIONER/4TH RESPONDENT IN WPC NO.46310/2024:
THE THRISSUR URBAN CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD. NO. 87
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER,
MISSION QUARTERS, THRISSUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 680001
BY ADVS.
C.D.DILEEP
SHYLAJA VARGHESE
DHEERAJ PRADEEP C.
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER AND RESPONDENTS 1 TO 3 IN WPC
NO.46310 OF 2024:
ANTO D OLLUKARAN
AGED 60 YEARS
S/O.O.V.DEVASSY, OLLUKARAN HOUSE, CHURCH SQUARE,
PARAVATTANY, THRISSUR, PIN – 680001.
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO COOPERATIVE DEPARTMENT, OFFICE OF THE REGISTRAR OF
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, JAWAHAR SAHAKARANA
BHAVAN, DPI JUNCTION, THYCAUD.P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPUARAM., PIN – 695014.
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
THE REGISTRAR OFFICE OF THE REGISTRAR OF
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES,
JAWAHAR SAHAKARANA BHAVAN, DPI JUNCTION,
THYCAUD.P.O, THIRUVANANTHAPUARAM, PIN – 695014.
THE JOINT REGISTRAR CO-OPERATIVE (GENERAL),
CIVIL STATION AYYANTHOLE, THRISSUR,
PIN – 680003.
Smt. K.G. Sarojini- GP
THIS
REVIEW
13.02.2025,
FOLLOWING:
PETITION
THE
COURT
HAVING
ON
COME
THE
UP
SAME
FOR
DAY
ADMISSION
ON
DELIVERED
THE
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
ORDER
The present review petition is filed by the 4 th respondent in
the writ petition alleging suppression of material facts in the writ
petition.
2.
The main ground raised in the review petition is that
the petitioner in the writ petition did not disclose the filing of an
earlier writ petition as W.P.(C)No.44260/2024.
The facts
disclosed in the review petition shows that the petitioner in the
writ petition had approached this Court aggrieved by the attempt
made by the review petitioner to reappoint retired persons in
violation of Rule 183(2) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies
Rules, 1969.
This Court, while taking note of the contents of
Ext.P3 letter produced along with the writ petition, had disposed
of the writ petition directing the respondents 1 to 3 in the writ
petition to consider the representation and take appropriate
decision within a period of three months from the date of receipt
of the copy of the judgment. Till such time as the decision on
the representation is taken, the review petitioner was directed
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
not to make any appointments from among the retired hands. It
is pointed out by the review petitioner that for the same relief,
the writ petitioner had approached this Court and filed W.P.(C)
No.44260/2024 and which was not disclosed in the affidavit filed
along with the present writ petition.
3.
Both counsels were extensively heard on this issue.
4.
It is pertinent to mention that the review petitioner
does not raise any ground on merits, but, however, confines his
argument to the suppression of material facts at the hands of the
writ petitioner.
On a query raised by this Court regarding the
contents of Ext.P3 letter, the learned counsel for the review
petitioner admitted that his client is in receipt of Ext.P3 letter
restraining them from appointing any person who have retired
from service and that aggrieved by the directions, they have
approached the Government and their request to modify Ext.P3
is pending consideration.
5.
Coming to the contention of the review petitioner that
the present writ petition has been filed suppressing the pendency
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
of the earlier writ petition, the learned counsel for the writ
petitioner/1st respondent was extensively heard. Sri.K.P.Madhu learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioner, admits the fact
that his client had preferred an earlier writ petition as W.P.
(C)No.44260/2024 and going by the present system of e-filing,
the said writ petition was placed under machine scrutiny and the
writ petition was numbered.
However, on presentation of the
physical copy of the writ petition, the Registry had noted defect
stating that translation of vernacular documents were not
produced.
The original physical copy of the writ petition was
taken back and it was never re-presented.
Subsequently,
another writ petition was filed after curing the defects, which was
numbered as W.P.(C)46310/2024 and the same was considered
and disposed of by this Court by the judgment under review.
The learned counsel pleaded that the inadvertence on the part of
the counsel in not seeking withdrawal of the earlier writ petition
may be pardoned and that there is no malice on the part of the
counsel in having presented the present writ petition.
6.
I have considered the rival submissions raised across
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
the Bar.
7.
As stated above, since the review petitioner has not
sought review of the judgment on the ground of error apparent
on the face of the record, this Court finds that no ground is made
out for interference, insofar as the directions contained in the
judgment under review is concerned.
does not stop there.
But, however, the issue
Admittedly, while preferring the present
writ petition, the affidavit did not disclose the pendency of the
earlier writ petition.
8.
As per the note placed by the Registry, it is revealed
that the earlier writ petition was in fact numbered and it was
pending on the files of this Court.
Therefore, while preferring
the present writ petition, admittedly, the affidavit did not state
the correct facts.
Rule 146 of the Rules of the High Court of
Kerala, 1971, requires the manner in which the affidavit has to
be prepared while preferring the writ petition. The deponent is
under solemn obligation to disclose the correct facts and state as
to whether he has approached this Court with a similar relief in
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
an earlier writ petition.
In the present case, when we see the
affidavit, there is a categoric assertion that the petitioner has not
approached this Court with any writ petition earlier seeking
similar relief in the same subject, which is admittedly wrong.
Proviso to Rule 146 of the Rules of the High Court of Kerala,
1971 reads as under:
“Provided that no petition shall be entertained by the
Registry unless it contains a statement as to whether the
petitioner had filed any petition seeking similar reliefs in
respect of the same subject-matter earlier and if so, the
result thereof.”
Therefore,
the
petitioner
has
deliberately
suppressed
the
material fact, though the action is sought to be justified by
saying that the original copy of the writ petition was taken back
and it was never re-presented.
9.
It is also pertinent to mention that going by the
records, it is only subsequent to the disposal of the present writ
petition,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
writ
petitioner
–
Sri.K.P.Madhu, filed a complaint on 20.01.2025 to the Registry
pointing out the issues encountered by him with regard to e-
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
filing machine scrutiny.
A copy of the complaint is also placed
before the Court for perusal, wherein it is stated that the writ
petition initially passed the system verification without any
defects and was numbered, but it was later discovered to be
defective because of the lack of English translated documents. It
is stated that due to the delay in receiving the English translation
and also considering the urgency for obtaining orders, they had
decided to abandon the defects filed and file a fresh writ petition.
Though it is permissible for the petitioner and his counsel to
abandon the earlier writ petition, this Court finds that no steps
were taken by the petitioner or by his counsel to seek permission
of this Court to withdraw the writ petition by filing a suitable
memo or an appropriate application in this regard. Therefore, it
is a case were there is admittedly a violation of the provisions of
Rule 146 of the Rules of High Court of Kerala, 1971.
10.
The
question
before
this
Court
is
whether
the
judgment under review is vitiated for the error apparent on the
face of the record on the ground that there is material
suppression as stated above.
It is pertinent to mention that
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
since the 4th respondent has not raised any contention on merits
regarding the sustainability of the direction issued by this Court,
this Court is of the considered view that if an order is issued
recalling the judgment under review, it would perpetuate
an
illegality and the 4th respondent/review petitioner will be enabled
to proceed with the appointments of retired hands as prohibited
under Ext.P3. Therefore this Court is of the view that, if, as a
result of the exercise of the power of review, the resultant action
will perpetuate illegality, then this Court is perfectly justified in
not exercising the power of review which will perpetuate illegality
and therefore on that ground, the request for review is declined.
11.
However, having said so, this Court cannot remain
oblivious of the fact that the petitioner had taken this Court for a
ride by not disclosing the pendency of the earlier writ petition
and the intention to abandon the earlier writ petition for the
defects noted by the Registry is not reflected from records.
It
must be noticed that because of the present system of e-filing
being followed, as soon as the system completes the machine
scrutiny, the writ petitions get numbered. It is only because the
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
Registry found out that when the physical copy was presented
certain defects were noted, that the writ petition was not sent
before the Bench.
Therefore, this Court feels it appropriate to
issue direction to the Registry to strike off W.P.(C)No.46310 of
2024 from the system/records since physical copy is not
produced.
12.
Insofar as the conduct of the writ petitioner as well as
his counsel is concerned, no doubt the action of the petitioner as
well as his counsel has to be deprecated. Even now, it appears
that the writ petitioner has not sought permission of this Court to
withdraw the earlier writ petition and the same is still kept
pending on the files of this Court. Such a callous attitude of the
counsel cannot be appreciated. However, it is only considering
the larger interest and not to perpetuate the illegality, this Court
has refused the power of review.
However, that doesn't mean
that this Court can approve the conduct of the writ petitioner or
his counsel. Therefore, in the present case, this Court feels that
it is a fit case where an appropriate cost has to be mulcted on
the writ petitioner for the misstatement of facts in the affidavit
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
accompanying the present writ petition.
13.
In the above circumstances, this Court is of the
considered view that cost has to be imposed on the writ
petitioner for the misstatement of facts, which he has done in
the affidavit accompanying the writ petition. Therefore, the writ
petitioner is directed to pay a sum of Rs.5,000/- within a period
of one week from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment
to the Kerala State Legal Services Authority and produce the
receipt before this Court. If the aforesaid amount is not paid, the
Authority is free to take appropriate steps for the recovery of the
aforesaid amount.
Sd/-
EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
ACR
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
The case number, W.P.(C)-46310 of 2024 occurring in paragraph 11 at
page 10 of the order dated 13/2/2025 in RP-33/2025 is corrected as
W.P.(C)-44260 of 2024 as per the order dated 12/3/2025 in RP33/2025.
Sd/JOINT REGISTRAR
RP No.33/2025
in W.P.(C)No.46310/2024
2025:KER:14290
APPENDIX OF RP 33/2025
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure-A1
A TRUE COPY OF THE WRIT PETITION WP(C)
44260 OF 2024 AVOIDING EXHIBITS.
Annexure-A2
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
05.02.2024 IN WP(C) 4290 OF 2024 OF THIS
HON’BLE COURT.
Annexure-A3
A TRUE COPY OF THE NEWSPAPER EXTRACT
FROM MATHRUBHUMI DAILY PUBLISHED ON
30.12.2024 .
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review