Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:24639
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 14TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 25TH MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 220 OF 2020
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 28.11.2019 IN OA NO.1114 OF 2017 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS IN OA:
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICES
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM SOUTH DIVISION,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695 036.
THE CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL,
KERALA CIRCLE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695 033.
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY AND DIRECTOR GENERAL,
DEPARTMENT OF POSTS, DAK BHAVAN, NEW DELHI 110 001.
BY Sri.T.C.Krishna DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
charge
in
RESPONDENTS/APPLICANTS IN OA:
C.VASUDEVAN, RETIRED SUB POSTMASTER, KANJIRAMPARA SO,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695 001, RESIDING A T CHIRAKANDATHI, SRDA
95, KARAKULAM P.O. THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695 564.
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 14.02.2025, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
JUDGMENT
K. V. JAYAKUMAR, J
Feeling aggrieved by the order of the Central Administrative
Tribunal in O.A.No.1114/2017 dated 28.11.2019, Union of India and its
officers preferred this OP(CAT). As per the impugned order, the Central
Administrative
Tribunal
allowed
the
following
claims
respondent/applicant.
(i) Call for the records leading to the issue of Annexure A10
and set aside Annexure A10 to the extent it refuses 3rd
financial upgradation under MACP Scheme.
(ii) Declare that the applicant is entitled and eligible to be
granted 3rd MACP financial upgradation benefits reckoning
his service from the date on which he is appointed as Postal
Assistant.
(iii) Direct the respondents to grant financial upgradation to
the applicant on completion of 30 years from the date he has
been appointed as Postal Assistant and to revise the pay and
draw arrears with 12% interest.
(iv) Any other further relief or order as this Hon'ble Tribunal
may deem fit and proper to meet the ends of justice.
(v) Award the cost of these proceedings.
of
the
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
2.
Succinctly, the facts in brief are as follows:
The respondent/applicant, C. Vasudevan, joined the service of the
respondents/petitioners as Postman with effect from 22.04.1978. In the
year 1981, the respondent attended a competitive examination conducted
for the appointment as Postal Assistant and was appointed with effect from
05.05.1982. On completion of 16 years, the applicant was granted financial
upgradation under Time Bound One Promotion (TBOP) with effect from
10.05.1988 and Biennial Cadre Review (BCR) on completion of 26 years in
the cadre of Postal Assistant with effect from 01.07.2008.
3.
On the basis of the recommendations of 6 th CPC, the
claim of the respondent/applicant is that he is entitled to 3 rd Modified
Assured Career Progression (MACP) as he had completed more than 30
years in the service of Postal Assistant cadre itself with effect from
05.05.2012 and submitted a representation to that effect, which was
rejected vide Annexure-A10 order.
4.
The stand of the petitioners/Union of India before the
Tribunal and before us is that, since the applicant was granted two financial
upgradations and one promotion, he is not entitled to get 3rd MACP.
5.
The Tribunal, noticing the rival contentions of the
counsel for the parties, expressed the view that the respondent/applicant is
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
entitled to get financial upgradation as per the MACP Scheme on
completion of 30 years of service. The relevant paragraphs are extracted
hereunder:
“7.
The Hon'ble High Court of Delhi on
5.8.2014 in Union of India v. Shakeel Ahmad Burney
held as under:
"8. There is no magic in the use of the expression
"Promotion" or "Direct Recruitment"; whether, in fact, the
mode of entry to the service is through direct recruitment or
promotion would certainly be dependent on facts of each case
and the structure of the Rules. If one analyzes Rule 3, it would
be apparent that recruitment is through "a competitive
examination which will be open to both departmental
candidates and outside candidates. During the course of
submissions, the Union of India has emphasized that syllabus
for departmental candidates was prescribed in 1964; even this
fact nowhere indicates that a differential treatment is accorded
to direct recruits who are drawn from the open market. The
absence of any clearly stipulated and defined feeder post for
promotion by way of seniority, or any other known method like
seniority-cum-merit, selection etc., the mode prescribed in
Rule 3(a) (i.e., departmental candidates also having to qualify
in the competitive examination, along with outsiders) in this
Court's opinion clinches the matter. To that effect, the CAT's
decision that the entry of departmental candidates to the cadre
of Postal Assistant is by way of direct recruitment is
unexceptionable. We consequently affirm the findings of the
CAT in the impugned order."
8.
On the contrary respondents counsel
Shri N.Anilkumar submitted that the applicant's
appointment to the post of Postal Assistant is by LDCE i.e.
50% quota meant for departmental candidates which is
actually a promotional post. Therefore, it should be treated
as first promotion from 5.5.1982 when he has been
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
promoted as Postal Assistant. Thereafter he has been
granted 2nd financial upgradation on 10.05.1998 on
completion of 16 years of service under TBOP scheme
applicable from the date of the last promotion as Postal
Assistant and further on completion of 26 years he was
granted next upgradation under BCR scheme w.e.f.
1.7.2008. The applicant retired on 31.10.2013.
9. We are of the view that through 50%
departmental quota the applicant was selected and
appointed as Postal Assistant after competing in the
LDCE/test. Several categories including Group 'D'
employees are also allowed to participate in the said
LDCE/test and therefore, the rules of promotion is not in
picture and the only yardstick is to qualify the exam in the
order of merit for which standards are same as per the direct
recruitment by a common process of selection.
10. The rules of promotion is quite different as
the basic criteria is seniority-cum-fitness in order to get the
promotion and only the employees from the feeder category
is eligible who comes under the consideration zone so fixed
by the DPC. However, this is absent in the case of
appointment to the post of Postal Assistant from the
Limited Departmental Competitive Examination quota as it
is only by way of merit alone. Further we are not in
agreement with the respondents' contention that since
applicant is coming through 50% LDCE quota the
appointment to the post should be treated as promotion
post for the simple reason that the selection is made not
from feeder category alone but on the basis of seniority and
several other categories of employees are also eligible to
appear in the said examination who are not at all in the
feeder categories and further selection would be on the basis
of percentage of marks alone. The contention of Mr. N.
Anilkumar, SCGSC would have been correct in the case of
appointment to the post under 50% by way of promotion
which is the other category and they can be said to be
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
promotee Postal Assistant because they are coming on the
basis of seniority alone.
11. In view of the above legal position and the
facts and circumstances of the case, we find that the
selection to the post of Postal Assistant is by way of an exam
and which is a direct recruitment and shall not be counted
as promotion for the purpose of MACP. Therefore, applicant
is entitled for 3d financial upgradation as per the MACP
scheme on completion of 30 years of service. However, the
monetary benefits of arrears will be restricted to three years
prior to the date of filing of this OA as laid down by the apex
court in Union of India & Ors. v. Tarsem Singh
(2008) 8 SCC 648. The respondents shall implement the
order within three months from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order. Parties are directed to bear their own costs.”
6.
The learned counsel for the respondent/applicant
supported the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal.
7.
Per contra, Sri.T C Krishna, Deputy Solicitor General of
India-in-Charge submitted that the impugned order is legally unsustainable
and illegal and interference from this Court is warranted under Article 227
of the Constitution. Adv.T.C. Krishna submitted that the promotion of the
respondent/applicant as Postal Assistant should be treated as an offset
against 1st MACP, the TBOP granted to him on completion of 16 years
should be considered as 2nd MACP and BCR granted to him on completion
of 26 years should be treated as an offset against the 3 rd MACP and
therefore, the applicant has already been granted three financial
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
upgradations in his career and, there is no scope for further financial
upgradation.
8.
The issue involved in this case has already been
pondered by this Court in O.P(CAT) No.105/2020. As per the judgment
dated 23.10.2024, this Court decided the issue in favour of the Union of
India. The relevant paragraphs are extracted hereunder:
8. During the course of arguments, the learned
Central Government Counsel has relied on the judgment of
the Division Bench of this Court dated 18.06.2020 in O.P.
(CAT)No.23 of 2018 and connected matters. Paragraphs 9 to
17 of that judgment read thus;
“9. The Rajasthan and Karnataka High Courts
allowed the claim of the applicants, since it was not
demonstrated before them that there was a promotion
permissible from the post of Postman to Postal Assistant.
Here it has been clearly demonstrated that such a
promotional avenue is available. The Madras High Court
found the appointment as Postal Assistant was not by
virtue of the 10 year service as a Postman, but after
participating in a selection process. There is no reference
to a LDCE and in that circumstance it has to be assumed
that there the applicant was appointed in the direct
recruitment quota. The Chhattisgarh High Court followed
the other High Courts. We also are placed with an order in
SLP of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, from the decision of
the Madras High Court; which though dismissed the SLP,
left the question of law open. We hence take a different
view especially on the compelling material placed before us
by way of the Recruitment Rules.
10. We extract the Clarification as referred to
by the CGSC as below:
“MACP Scheme for Railway servants - treatment of
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
employees selected under LDCE/GDCE Scheme clarification
G.I.,
Railway
Board
Letter
No.PC-V/2009/ACP/2, dated the 12th September, 2012
References have been received from Zonal Railways
seeking clarification regarding grant of benefits under
MACPS in respect of the employees qualifying through
LDCE/GDCE. The matter has been examined in
consultation with Department of Personnel & Training
(DoP&T), the nodal department of Government on
MACPS and it has been decided as under:(i) if the relevant RRs provide for filling up of
vacancies in a grade by Direct Recruitment, induction
of an employee to that grade through LDCE/GDCE
may be treated as Direct Recruitment for the purpose
of grant of financial upgradation under MACPS. In
such cases, past service rendered in a lower pay
scale/Grade Pay shall NOT be counted for the
purpose of MACP Scheme.
(ii) If the relevant RRs prescribe a Promotion Quota
to be filled on the basis of LDCE/GDCE, such
appointment would be treated as promotion for the
purpose of benefit under the MACPS and in such
cases, past regular service shall also be counted for
further benefits, if any, under the MACP Scheme.
This issues with the concurrence of the Finance
Directorate of the Ministry of Railways.”
11. Clause 9 of the MACPS reads as under:
“9. Any Interpretation/clarification of doubt as to the
scope and meaning of the provisions of the MACP
Scheme shall be given by the Department of Personnel
and Training (Establishment-D). The scheme would be
operational with effect from 1.9.2008. In other words,
financial upgradations as per the provisions of the
earlier ACP Scheme (of August, 1999) would be granted
till 31.08.2008.”
The clarification issued by the Department of
Personnel and Training applies to all the Central
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
Government Departments, irrespective of who seeks
the clarification.
12.It is evident from the Recruitment Rules
that the appointment to the post of Postal/Sorting
Assistant is not by way of direct recruitment alone and
it has a 50% promotion quota of in-service candidate
selected by way of a LDCE.
Hence the induction
by LDCE is not covered by clause (i) and Clause
(ii)applies; for there is a specific promotion quota
spoken of in the Recruitment Rules.
13. We also see from the order of the CAT
impugned herein especially at Paragraphs 11 and 12
that the issue has been correctly analysed and the
claim “for counting MACP from the date of passing
LDCE is rejected”(sic). But however, in the operative
portion in paragraph 13 it was directed that the period
to be counted is declared to be from the date of
appointment as Postal Assistant, which according to us
is not only erroneous; but is diametrically opposite to
and against the reasoning as extracted below.
14. We extract herein paragraphs 11 and 12
of the impugned common order produced in OP (CAT)
No.23/2018.
“11. A promotion is an advancement made in the
career of an official in various modes as provided by
respondents through various channels. The channel
can be by moving to a higher position by virtue of
seniority or by a faster channel of qualifying in a
departmental examination. Both channels provide a
way out of stagnation which has been sought to be
alleviated by the TBOP/BCR and MACP Schemes. It
depends on the motivation of employee as to which
channel he proposes to use for his career
advancement. Just because various channels are
provided for career advancement, it does not provide a
right to applicant to claim that he should be
compensated for stagnation at every level of career
advancement. He can obtain the dignity, honour, rank
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
or grade by seniority or merit channel provided by
respondent, the preference of choice being left to him
but both are recognized channels for promotion being
provided to him for advancement. The intention of the
Pay Commission was that no employee should be
allowed to stagnate in a scale of pay for over 10 years.
Because the respondent has provided channels for
accelerated promotion through a scheme of
examination it cannot be obliterated or overlooked
and the stand taken that these are not promotions or
career advancement can not be accepted. Stagnation is
to be counted in the career of an employee and not at
every stage of promotion. Promotion by a faster
channel of examination has also been provided as a
way out of stagnation by the employer, exercised
wisely. Hence applicant cannot claim benefit in both
ways or all ways. The fine distinction sought to be
drawn between promotion by merit and promotion by
length of service in a particular grade is not necessary
as both are modes provided for career advancement
and the MACP incorporates all the avenues provided
to an employee to get out of the runt of stagnation in a
system. It should not be selectively applied to
individual desire or greed. Reasonable promotional
prospects where ever provided should be
acknowledged and made a part of the running career
advancement and should not be segregated into
stagnation pools in the rut of which reliefs are being
sought.
12. The judgment of this Tribunal in OA No.725/2012
of 20th August 2014 applies to the facts of this case
and we follow the same. MACP of 10, 20 and 30 years
will count from the date of promotion as Postman as
the stagnation issue has been addressed by providing
him a channel of career advancement by an
accelerated mode of promotion by departmental
examination. Hence the applicants in Oas Nos 1189,
1190 and 1197 of 2012 are entitled to get MACP only
w.e.f the date of completion of 10, 20 and 30 years
from the date of promotion as Postman. Claim for
counting MACP from the date of passing LDC exam is
rejected.”
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
15. We perfectly agree with the reasoning
and add, at the risk of repetition, that it is not relevant
as to how the employee gets promoted, by way of
seniority or a merit oriented selection. The financial
up-gradation as intended by the Career Progression
Schemes is to ensure that an employee does not suffer
the hardship of stagnation, for reason only of there
being not available enough avenues for promotion.
Such stagnated employees are allowed a financial upgradation, to the higher scale or the Grade Pay, without
a functional promotion to the higher status. The
employee having availed a fast track for promotion and
acquired it for reason of his superior merit, cannot
claim a further up-gradation as per the Assured Career
Progression Scheme. That would be conferring a double
benefit of promotion and financial up-gradation, when
by the former his career has progressed.
16. The applicants were appointed as
Postman after being engaged as Extra Departmental
Agent (EDA)/Gramin Dak Sevak (GDS). The Hon'ble
Supreme Court in AIR 2016 SC 3789 [Najithamol Y and
others v. Soumya S D and others] found that
recruitment to the post of Postman is a fresh
appointment. Hence the service, for granting MACP
has to be counted from that date. We notice the facts in
each of the above cases but emphasise that none of the
applicants have a contention that they applied under
the direct recruitment quota and were appointed as
Postal Assistants in that 50% quota. The very
contention that they were appointed after being
selected in a LDCE validates the stand of the P&T
Department that they were promoted to that post; as
per the Recruitment Rules.
17. The MACP Scheme was introduced on
01.09.2008. Prior to that in the Postal Department
there were two financial up-gradation; one in the 16th
year under Time Bound One Promotion (TBOP) and in
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
the 24th year, under the Biennial Cadre Review (BCR).
When MACP is introduced, the benefits though
reckoned on completion of 10,20 and 30 years, the
same would be payable only from 01.09.2008.”
9. In the said judgment, the Division Bench held that when
MACP Scheme is introduced, the benefit though reckoned
on completion of 10, 20 and 30 years, the same would be
payable only from 01.09.2008. In view of the law laid down
in the decision of the Division Bench in O.P(CAT)No.23 of
2018 and connected matters, Ext.P6 order dated 18.06.2019
of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench
cannot be sustained.”
9.
In view of the dictum laid down in the aforementioned
case, this OP(CAT) is allowed. Consequently, the O.A. is dismissed.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/-
K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
Sbna/
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 220/2020
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A1
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO NO. B.5/ACT/C DATED
17.04.1978 ISSUED BY THE SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT
OF POST OFFICER, MADARAS CITY CENTRAL DIVISION,
MADRAS.
ANNEXURE A2
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO D B/BCR/1/DLG DATED
04.02.1999 ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT IN OA.
ANNEXURE A3
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO O B/BCR/1/DLG DATED
18.08.2008 SUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT IN OA.
ANNEXURE A4
TRUE COPY OF OM ISSUED AS PER FILE NO. 4-7
(MACPS) 2009-PCC DATED 18.09.2009 ISSUED BY THE
DDG ESTABLISHMENT OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A5
TRUE COPY OF ORDER 16.03. 2016 UN
180/00008/2014 OF CAT ERNAKULAM BENCH.
ANNEXURE A6
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 14.03.2013
1088/2011 OF THE HONBLE MADRAS BENCH.
ANNEXURE A7
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 04.02.2015 IN
WPC 30629/2014 OF TH HONBLE COURT OF MADRAS,.
ANNEXURE A8
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 16.08.2016 IN
SLP @ NO. 4848/20165 OF THE HONBLE SUPREME
COURT.
ANNEXURE A9
TRUE COPY OF MEMO NO. B2/MACPIII/DLGS 2016 DATED
22.03.2017 ISSUED BY THE SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT
OF POST OFFICES, CHENAI CITY NORTH DIVISION.
ANNEXURE A10
TRUE COPY OF NO. B/MCAP/GNL DATED
ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT IN OA,
ANNEXURE R1
TRUE COPY OF THE DIRECTORATE LETTER
7(MACPS) 2009-PCC DATED 18.10.2010.
ANNEXURE R2
TRUE COPY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF POST'S POSTAL
ASSISTANTS AND SHORTING ASSISTANTS RECRUITMENT
RULES 1971.
OA
IN
NO.
A
06.11.2017
NO.
4-
OP(CAT) No.220/2020
2025:KER:24639
ANNEXURE R3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED TO THE APPLICANT
UPON PROMOTION TO THE CADRE OF POSTAL ASSISTANT.
ANNEXURE R4
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON ORDER DATED 07.08.2013
OF THE HONBLE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL IN
OA NO. 127/2012 AND CONNECTED CASES.
ANNEXURE R5
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE CAT, ERANAKULAM
BENCH DATED 20.08.2014 IN OA 725/2012.
ANNEXURE R6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE CAT ERNAKULAM
BENCH DATED 16.05.2017 IN OA NO. 448/2014.
ANNEXURE A11
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 18.07.2019 IN O.A. NO.
180/00136/2017 OF THE CAT ERNAKULAM BENCH.
ANNEXURE A12
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 30.07.2019 IN OA
NO. 180/00272/2018 OF THE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH.
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE OA NO. 1114/2017 FILED BY THE
PETITIONER DATED 2811.2019 BEFORE THE CAT,
ERNAKULAM BENCH.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
REPLY
STATEMENT
IN
OA
180/00114/2017 FILED BEFORE CAT, ERNAKULAM BENCH
BY THE PETITIONER IN OA NO. 1800/00114/2017.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF MA 1027/19 DATD 27.10.2019 FIELD BY
RESPONDENT IN OA.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN OA 1114 OF 2017 DATED
28.11.2019 ISSUED BY THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL ERNAKULAM BENCH.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review