The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Accordingly, the appeals and the connected applications are dismissed.
13. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty
&
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Saratahi Chatterjee
MAT 572 of 2025
+
IA No. CAN 2 of 2024
The Director of Technical Education and Training
Versus
Lila Lohar & Ors.
With
MAT 2200 of 2024
+
IA No. CAN 2 of 2025
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Versus
Rasomay Majumder & Ors.
With
MAT 2201 of 2024
+
IA No. CAN 2 of 2025
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Versus
Nemai Nayak & Ors.
With
MAT 2202 of 2024
+
IA No. CAN 2 of 2025
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Versus
Abhijit Routh & Ors.
For the Appellant(s)
[In All the Appeals]
:
Mr. Amal Sen, Ld. A.A.G.,
Mr. Sourav Mitra.
For the Respondents/
Writ petitioners
[In All the appeals]
:
Mr. Arunava Banerjee,
Ms. Simantika Dasgupta,
Ms. Ritika Mandal.
For the Respondent nos. 1-7
[In MAT 2202 of 2024]
:
Mr. Samim Ahammed,
Ms. Saloni Bhattacharya,
Mr. Arka Ranjan Bhattacharya,
Ms. Gulsanwara Pervin,
Mr. Swarup Ranjan Kar.
Hearing is concluded on
:
29th January, 2026.
Judgment On
:
9th February, 2026.
Tapabrata Chakraborty, J.
1. Records reveal that three (3) writ petitions being WPA 12458 of
2024, WPA 11670 of 2024 and WPA 11669 of 2024 were disposed of by
separate orders dated 05.08.2024 and the writ petition being WPA 24243 of
2024 was disposed of by an order dated 26.09.2024. By the said orders the
respondents were directed to treat the writ petitioners as permanent
Government employees and to extend the status and service benefits as
available to Group-D employees of the Government of West Bengal including
pay scale, allowance, service and superannuation benefits and to release all
service benefits from the respective dates of appointment. The above appeals
preferred against the said orders passed in the said writ petitions were
heard analogously.
2. Mr. Amal Kumar Sen, learned Additional Advocate General
appearing for the appellants argues that the conditions of service of the writ
petitioners would clearly reveal that the master of the writ petitioners is the
Hostel Committee. The right to control as also the right to determine the
manner and mode of working is also vested with the Hostel Committee.
There is no relationship of master and servant between the writ petitioners
and the Institutes in which they were appointed and the said Institutes were
not under any statutory obligation to run the canteen/mess. In view thereof,
the writ petitioners cannot be treated as Group-D employees. Such
contention was upheld in the case of State of West Bengal & Others versus
Prabir Chakraborty, reported in (2007) 3 Cal LT 545(HC) 545 which the
Hon’ble Supreme Court affirmed by dismissing the Special Leave Petition (in
short, SLP). Such argument, as urged, was glossed over by the learned
single Judge and no finding was returned on the same.
3. He submits that much reliance has been placed upon a note-sheet
dated 21.11.2014 issued by the Director of Technical Education and
Training which merely expressed an opinion that in view of the notification
dated 28.10.2014 issued by the Principal Secretary, Higher Education
Department, the Hostel/mess employees of Government and Sponsored
Polytechnic may be treated as Group-D government employees. The said
notification cannot be construed to be a reservoir of right towards
regularisation and it has no statutory force. It is not a decision of the
government and cannot be regarded as anything more than being
provisional in character. Reliance has been placed upon a judgment
delivered in the case of Nareshbhai Bhagubhai versus Union of India and
Others, reported in (2019) 15 SCC 1.
4. Mr. Sen contends that there subsists two contradictory views of
two co-ordinate Benches (both Division Bench) with regard to the
applicability of similar service facilities and/or status to the employees of
Hostel canteen-cum-kitchen staff being run by the Hostel Committee/Mess
Committee and in several polytechnics and Junior technical schools as are
being enjoyed by the employees of the Hostel canteen-cum-kitchen staff
being run in diverse Universities and/or colleges under the said universities.
In view of such conflicting decisions, the appropriate course of action was to
refer the matter to the larger Bench. Reliance has been placed upon a
judgment
delivered
in
the
case
of
Engineers
India Limited
versus
Commissioner of Income Tax, reported in (2018) 12 SCC 593.
5. Per contra Mr. Banerjee appearing for the writ petitioners contends
that the issue urged by the appellants is no more res integra and has been
finally decided in the cases of Director of Technical Education and Training
versus Chunilal Chakraborty & Others and Director of Technical Education
and Training versus Madan Mohan Sarkar & Others which were affirmed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court by dismissing the SLPs preferred against the
same. The canteens operated by the technical department and other
departments were identical in the type and quality of service rendered to the
students. They were permanent employees rendering continuous service
which was of the same type as other canteen employees under universities
or government aided colleges.
6. He submits that in a group of appeals (FMA 741-743 of 2005 and
FMA 2679-2681 of 2007), a coordinate Bench of this Court considering the
issue as to whether the cook and their assistants working in various
hostels/mess should be regularised as University employees as Group-D
staff passed an order 17.12.2007 observed inter alia that the issue has been
decided otherwise by another Division Bench and accordingly referred the
matters to a larger Bench for final consideration framing two issues by an
order dated 17.12.2007. Thereafter the Hon’ble Special Bench disposed of
the reference on 26.11.2014 observing inter alia that in view of memo dated
28.10.2014 issued by the Principal Secretary, Higher Education Department
conferring the status of non-teaching Hostel/Mess employees and the
benefit of General Provident fund and Pension to the Hostel/Mess employees
of
State-aided
Universities,
Government-aided
Colleges
including
Government General Degree Colleges and Government Engineering and
Technology Colleges in West Bengal, nothing remains for final consideration
so far as the reference made earlier by the order dated 17.12.2007.
Considering the same and upon distinguishing the judgment delivered in
the case of Prabir Chakraborty (Supra), two coordinate Benches in the cases
of Chunilal Chakraborty & Others (Supra) and Madan Mohan Sarkar & Others
(Supra) decided that the status Hostel/mess employees of Government and
Sponsored Polytechnic may be treated as Group-D government employees
and directed disbursement of all consequential benefits and as such the
appellant at this stage cannot reinvigorate an issue finally decided moreso
such directions have been complied with as would be explicit from the
memoranda dated 11.07.2024, 02.04.2025, 03.04.2025.
7. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the arguments
advanced by the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties and
have gone through the materials placed before us.
8. The argument advanced by Mr. Sen that there are contradictory
views of two coordinate Benches was considered and referred to a larger
Bench framing the following issues:
i) Would the canteen employees and hostel/mess employees of any
educational institution be entitled to recognition as Group ‘D’ stall
irrespective of the fact whether such institution was residential or
not?
ii) What would be the yardstick of deciding the issue for
regularization of canteen employees and /or hotel/mess employees,
specially when the State Government themselves have framed a
committee to fix the pay scale for these employees working in various
Universities under the State?
9. Thereafter, the Hon’ble Special Bench disposed of the reference on
26.11.2014 observing inter alia that in view of memo dated 28.10.2014
issued by the Principal Secretary, Higher Education Department, nothing
remains for final consideration so far as the reference made. The entire
sequence of facts and the order passed by the Hon’ble Special Bench on
26.11.2014 including the note-sheet dated 21.11.2014 were considered in
the cases of Chunilal Chakraborty & Others (Supra) and Madan Mohan
Sarkar & Others (Supra) and the judgment delivered in the case of Prabir
Chakraborty (Supra) was distinguished giving reasons and the Hon’ble
Supreme Court gave its imprimatur to the reasoning given by the Hon’ble
Division Benches in the cases of Chunilal Chakraborty & Others (Supra) and
Madan Mohan Sarkar & Others (Supra).
10. Doctrine of precedents and stare decisis are the core values of
legal system. When substantial judicial time and resources are spent on
references the same should not be made in a casual manner. It is only when
a proposition is contradicted by a subsequent judgment of the same Bench
or it is shown that the proposition laid down has become unworkable or
contrary to any well-established principle or when there is an irreconcilable
conflict, the matter may be referred to a larger Bench. We do not find any
compelling or strong reasons to depart from the orders passed by the
Division Bench in the cases of Chunilal Chakraborty & Others (Supra) and
Madan Mohan Sarkar & Others (Supra). The judgments upon which reliance
has been placed by the appellants are also distinguishable on facts.
11. An appellate power interferes not when the order appealed is not
right but only when it is clearly wrong. The learned single Judge upon
considering the factual issues arrived at a specific finding that the writ
petitioners, who are employees of polytechnics, stand in the same footing as
those aggrieved employees, who had earlier been granted similar benefits by
coordinate Benches. In appreciation of the proposition that judicial propriety
demands that the findings arrived at on the rudiments of similar facts by
another Court should be given respect and should be followed, the learned
single Judge extended the benefits to the writ petitioners and we do not find
any infirmity in the same.
12. Accordingly, the appeals and the connected applications are
dismissed.
13. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
14. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
given to the parties, as expeditiously as possible, upon compliance with the
necessary formalities in this regard.
(Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.)
(Tapabrata Chakraborty, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review