The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Accordingly, the appeal and the connected application are dismissed.
13. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
25.02.2026
Ct. No. 11
KCP
MAT 2355 of 2024
with
IA No. CAN 2 of 2025
(The State of West Bengal & Anr. Vs. Sandip Ghosh & Ors.)
Mr. Swapan Kumar Datta, Ld. G.P.
Mr. Tapash Kumar Dey
….. For the appellants
Mr. Arunava Banerjee
Ms. Simantika Dasgupta
Ms. Ritika Mondal
Mr. Sk. Qareeb
….. For the writ petitioners/respondents
1. Records reveal that the writ petition being WPA
11667 of 2024 was disposed of by an order dated 10th
September, 2024. By the said orders the respondents
were directed to treat the writ petitioners as permanent
Government employees and to extend the status and
service benefits as available to Group-D employees of
the Government of West Bengal including pay scale,
allowance, service and superannuation benefits and to
release all service benefits from the respective dates of
appointment. The above appeal has been preferred
against the said order by the Stata and its functionary.
2. Mr. Swapan Kumar Datta, learned Government
Pleader
assisted
by
Mr.
Dey,
learned
advocate
appearing for the appellants argues that the conditions
of service of the writ petitioners would clearly reveal
that the master of the writ petitioners is the Hostel
Committee. The right to control as also the right to
determine the manner and mode of working is also
vested
with
the
Hostel
Committee.
There
is
no
relationship of master and servant between the writ
petitioners and the Institutes in which they were
appointed and the said Institutes were not under any
statutory obligation to run the canteen/mess. In view
thereof, the writ petitioners cannot be treated as
Group-D employees. Such contention was upheld in
the case of State of West Bengal & Others versus Prabir
Chakraborty, reported in (2007) 3 Cal LT 545(HC) 545
which
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
affirmed
by
dismissing the Special Leave Petition (in short, SLP).
Such argument, as urged, was glossed over by the
learned single Judge and no finding was returned on
the same.
3. He submits that much reliance has been placed
upon a note-sheet dated 21.11.2014 issued by the
Director of Technical Education and Training which
merely expressed an opinion that in view of the
notification dated 28.10.2014 issued by the Principal
Secretary,
Higher
Education
Department,
the
Hostel/mess employees of Government and Sponsored
Polytechnic may be treated as Group-D government
employees. The said notification cannot be construed to
be a reservoir of right towards regularisation and it has
no statutory force. It is not a decision of the
government and cannot be regarded as anything more
than being provisional in character. Reliance has been
placed upon a judgment delivered in the case of
Nareshbhai Bhagubhai versus Union of India and
Others, reported in (2019) 15 SCC 1.
4. Mr. Datta contends that there subsists two
contradictory views of two co-ordinate Benches (both
Division Bench) with regard to the applicability of
similar service facilities and/or status to the employees
of Hostel canteen-cum-kitchen staff being run by the
Hostel Committee/Mess Committee and in several
polytechnics and Junior technical schools as are being
enjoyed by the employees of the Hostel canteen-cumkitchen staff being run in diverse Universities and/or
colleges under the said universities. In view of such
conflicting decisions, the appropriate course of action
was to refer the matter to the larger Bench. Reliance
has been placed upon a judgment delivered in the case
of Engineers India Limited versus Commissioner of
Income Tax, reported in (2018) 12 SCC 593.
5.
Per
contra
Mr.
Banerjee
learned
advocate
appearing for the writ petitioners contends that the
issue urged by the appellants is no more res integra
and has been finally decided in the cases of Director of
Technical Education and Training versus Chunilal
Chakraborty
&
Others
and
Director
of
Technical
Education and Training versus Madan Mohan Sarkar &
Others which were affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court by dismissing the SLPs preferred against the
same.
The
canteens
operated
by
the
technical
department and other departments were identical in
the type and quality of service rendered to the
students. They were permanent employees rendering
continuous service which was of the same type as other
canteen employees under universities or government
aided colleges.
6. He submits that in a group of appeals (FMA 741743 of 2005 and FMA 2679-2681 of 2007), a coordinate
Bench of this Court considering the issue as to whether
the cook and their assistants working in various
hostels/mess should be regularised as University
employees
as
Group-D
staff
passed
an
order
17.12.2007 observed inter alia that the issue has been
decided otherwise by another Division Bench and
accordingly referred the matters to a larger Bench for
final consideration framing two issues by an order
dated 17.12.2007. Thereafter the Hon’ble Special
Bench
disposed
of
the
reference
on
26.11.2014
observing inter alia that in view of memo dated
28.10.2014 issued by the Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department conferring the status of nonteaching Hostel/Mess employees and the benefit of
General Provident fund and Pension to the Hostel/Mess
employees of State-aided Universities, Governmentaided Colleges including Government General Degree
Colleges and Government Engineering and Technology
Colleges in West Bengal, nothing remains for final
consideration so far as the reference made earlier by
the order dated 17.12.2007. Considering the same and
upon distinguishing the judgment delivered in the case
of Prabir Chakraborty (Supra), two coordinate Benches
in the cases of Chunilal Chakraborty & Others (Supra)
and Madan Mohan Sarkar & Others (Supra) decided
that the status Hostel/mess employees of Government
and Sponsored Polytechnic may be treated as Group-D
government employees and directed disbursement of all
consequential benefits and as such the appellant at
this stage cannot reinvigorate an issue finally decided
moreso such directions have been complied with as
would
be
explicit
from
the
memoranda
dated
11.07.2024, 02.04.2025, 03.04.2025.
7. We have given our thoughtful consideration to
the arguments advanced by the learned advocates
appearing for the respective parties and have gone
through the materials placed before us.
8. The argument advanced by Mr. Datta that there
are contradictory views of two coordinate Benches was
considered and referred to a larger Bench framing the
following issues:
i) Would the canteen employees and hostel/mess
employees of any educational institution be entitled to
recognition as Group ‘D’ stall irrespective of the fact
whether such institution was residential or not?
ii) What would be the yardstick of deciding the
issue for regularization of canteen employees and /or
hotel/mess
employees,
specially
when
the
State
Government themselves have framed a committee to fix
the pay scale for these employees working in various
Universities under the State?
9. Thereafter, the Hon’ble Special Bench disposed of
the reference on 26.11.2014 observing inter alia that in
view of memo dated 28.10.2014 issued by the Principal
Secretary,
Higher
Education
Department,
nothing
remains for final consideration so far as the reference
made. The entire sequence of facts and the order
passed by the Hon’ble Special Bench on 26.11.2014
including
the
note-sheet
dated
21.11.2014
were
considered in the cases of Chunilal Chakraborty &
Others
(Supra)
and
Madan
Mohan
Sarkar
&
Others(Supra) and the judgment delivered in the case of
Prabir Chakraborty (Supra) was distinguished giving
reasons and the Hon’ble Supreme Court gave its
imprimatur to the reasoning given by the Hon’ble
Division Benches in the cases of Chunilal Chakraborty
& Others (Supra) and Madan Mohan Sarkar & Others
(Supra).
10. Doctrine of precedents and stare decisis are the
core values of legal system. When substantial judicial
time and resources are spent on references the same
should not be made in a casual manner. It is only when
a proposition is contradicted by a subsequent judgment
of the same Bench or it is shown that the proposition
laid down has become unworkable or contrary to any
well-established
principle
or
when
there
is
an
irreconcilable conflict, the matter may be referred to a
larger Bench. We do not find any compelling or strong
reasons to depart from the orders passed by the
Division Bench in the cases of Chunilal Chakraborty &
Others (Supra) and Madan Mohan Sarkar & Others
(Supra). The judgments upon which reliance has been
placed by the appellants are also distinguishable on
facts.
11. An appellate power interferes not when the
order appealed is not right but only when it is clearly
wrong. The learned single Judge upon considering the
factual issues arrived at a specific finding that the writ
petitioners, who are employees of polytechnics, stand
in the same footing as those aggrieved employees, who
had earlier been granted similar benefits by coordinate
Benches. In appreciation of the proposition that
judicial propriety demands that the findings arrived at
on the rudiments of similar facts by another Court
should be given respect and should be followed, the
learned single Judge extended the benefits to the writ
petitioners and we do not find any infirmity in the
same.
12. Accordingly, the appeal and the connected
application are dismissed.
13. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.
14.
Urgent
Photostat
certified
copy
of
this
judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties, as
expeditiously as possible, upon compliance with the
necessary formalities in this regard.
(Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.)
(Tapabrata Chakraborty, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review