The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. 07.2024 are reproduced herein-below: “24.07.2024 Today the case record is listed for Pws. Custody accused Swapan Shil is produced from the J/C. Ld. Defence Counsel Mr. R.Chowdhury is present for the accused. No bail petition filed for the accused person. Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present. Two witnesses namely P. Seikh Aslam and Puja Chowdhury are present, they are examined, cross-examined as PW-02 & 03and discharged. No other witness is present. No service report received regarding the summons. To date fixed (25.07.2024) for Pws(6 to 9) Accused is further remanded to J/C till 25.07.2024….” “25.07.2024 Today the case record is listed for Pws. Custody accused Swapan Shil is produced from the J/C. Ld. Defence Counsel Mr. R.Chowdhury is present for the accused. No bail petition filed for the accused person. Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present. Three witnesses namely Samar Debnath, Jitendra Choudhury and Narayan Ch. Debnath are present, they are examined, cross-examined as PW- 04, 05 & 06 and discharged. No other witness is present. Received one message intimating the fact that witness Sarbajit Choudhury is unable to appear before this court as he is on leave on medical ground. Keep it with the record. To date fixed (26.07.2024) for Pws. Accused is further remanded to J/C till 26.07.2024…………” “26.07.2024 Today the case record is listed for Pws. Custody accused Swapan Shil is pro…
14. 08.2024 passed by the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Sepahijala Tripura, Sonamura in case No Special (NDPS) 20 of 2024 is hereby set-aside. Accordingly, the matter is remanded back to the learned trial Court with a direction to conduct a fresh trial by calling upon the rest of the prosecution witnesses. However, it is made clear that reasonable opportunity shall be afforded to the prosecution witnesses. It is further made clear that after closure of evidences of all the prosecution witnesses, learned Court below shall deliver its judgment afresh. The entire exercise shall be completed expeditiously. [14] The accused-respondent is directed to surrender before the learned trial Court on or before 31st March, 2026. Upon his surrender, the learned trial Court may consider bail application, if so, filed by him, in accordance with law so that, his right is not infringed. [15] Resultantly, the present appeal is allowed to the extent as indicated above. As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall also stand closed. S. Datta Purkayastha, J. Sabyasachi. G. Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.A 43 of 2025
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary,
Home Department, Government of Tripura
…….Appellant(s)
Versus
Swapan Shil, son of late Janaki Shil of Nirvoypur,
P.S. Jatrapur, District- Sepahijala
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate
Mr. Ankan Tilak Paul, Advocate
Ms. Swarupa Das, Advocate
Mr. Joy Majumder, Advocate
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
: 10.03.2026.
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes/No.
……..Respondent(s)
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J.]
[1]
When the case is called, Mr. Raju Datta, learned P.P. appears for the
appellant-State. Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel appears on behalf of the
respondent.
[2]
The present appeal has been filed seeking the following reliefs:
“(a)
admit this appeal,
(b)
issue notice upon the respondents,
(c)
Call for the records and after hearing be pleased to set aside the Judgment dated
14.08.2024 passed by the Ld Special Judge (NDPS), Sepahijala Tripura, Sonamura in case
No Special (NDPS) 20 of 2024 and convict the respondents against the charge under
Section 21(C)/25 of NDPS Act and remand back the case to the court of Ld. Special Judge
(NDPS), Sepahijala Tripura, Sonamura and give reasonable opportunity to the prosecution
agency to produce their prosecution witnesses for proving their case.
AND
(d)
To pass such other order/orders as to this Hon'ble court may seem fit……….……”
[3]
Brief facts of the case, as described in the present appeal are that on
22.11.2023 at about 1535 hours on the basis of secret information, the complainant
accompanied with OC Jatrapur PS along with other staff conducted search and raid
in the dwelling house of accused at Nirvoypur under Jatrapur PS. During search,
they recovered one white colour plastic sack and 3 nos. motor cycles (one white and
gray colour Yamaha FZS BR No.R078109, one blue colour Yamaha R15 BR
No.R07E-6567, one Red Colour Yamaha FZS Bearing No.TR07D9493) containing
400 nos Phensedyl in the plastic sack. On the basis of that complaint, Jatrapur PS
case No. 2023/JTP/063 dated 22.11.2023 under Sections 21(C)/25/29 of NDPS Act
was registered against the accused person. After investigation, I.O. submitted Charge
Sheet under Sections 21(C)/25 of NDPS Act and the learned Trial Court framed
charge against the respondent under Sections 21(C)/25 of NDPS Act. According to
the appellant State reasonable opportunity was not provided to the prosecution to
produce their witnesses and only after examining 7(seven) prosecution witness, the
chapter of prosecution evidence was closed and learned Court below acquitted the
respondent from the charge framed under Sections 21(C)/25 of NDPS Act. Being
aggrieved, the appellant has preferred the instant appeal seeking the above-quoted
reliefs.
[4]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the appellant State submits
that learned Court below did not consider that offence under NDPS Act is a grave
offence against the society and huge quantity of contraband articles were recovered
from the accused and Investigating Officer also submitted charge sheet against the
accused person under the provisions of Cr.P.C. He contends that without giving
opportunity to the prosecution to produce all of their prosecution witnesses, the
learned trial Court most illegally closed the evidences and acquitted the accused
respondent. Mr. Datta, learned P.P. further submits that learned trial Court did not
consider the settled principle of law that no accused can be acquitted from a criminal
liability without facing proper trial and giving reasonable opportunity to the
prosecution agency to prove their case. It is also contended that during trial, the
learned trial Court examined only 7(seven) witnesses out of 12(twelve) cited
prosecution witnesses including the complainant and did not exhibited any
documents. He further contends that there are many cases of similar nature under
NDPS Act where the accused persons were acquitted without providing proper
opportunity to the prosecution. Placing reliance on the judgment and order dated
30.07.2025 passed by this Court in Criminal Appeal No.4 of 25, learned P.P. submits
that the aforesaid case deals with the similar circumstances and therefore, urges for
remanding back the case for conducting fresh trial after setting aside the impugned
order dated 14.08.2024 by affording reasonable opportunity to rest of the
prosecution witnesses for their examination and cross-examination.
[5]
Per contra, Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel for the respondent opposes
the submissions made on behalf of the appellant State. He submits that the
prosecution failed to examine any official from the state forensic science laboratory
(SFSL) and therefore the chemical examination was not duly proved in accordance
with the law. It is further contended that, in the instant case out of the total 12 nos. of
witnesses 7 nos. of witnesses has already been examined and the accused has
suffered prolonged incarceration. There were non-compliance of the mandatory
safeguards as enshrined under the NDPS Act and the prosecution miserably failed to
prove the seizure of the contrabands, chemical examination of the contraband
articles and also did not prove the safe custody of the articles. He urges that in view
of the serious deficiencies, the prosecution case suffers from enormous doubt
resulting in which the benefit of doubt must go in favour of the accused. He further
submits that learned trial Court after proper appreciation of the evidence and
material on record rightly acquitted the accused vide judgment and order dated
14.08.2024 as the prosecution miserably failed to prove the case against the accused
beyond reasonable doubt.
[6]
Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the respondents argues that remand
should be ordered only in exceptional circumstances where miscarriage of justice is
apparent and in the instant case no such circumstances exist and there is no
perversity, illegality in the order of the learned trial Court. He contends that in the
instant case, it is revealed from the examination of PW 7 i.e., SI Amar Kishore
Debbarma that, the secret information about keeping of the contrabands items was
received by one police officer Subrata Debnath but the prosecution failed to examine
said Subrata Debnath. Moreover, the secret information was neither reduced into
writing nor communicated to the superior official within a span of 72 hours violating
section 41 and 42 of the NDPS Act. He submits that since receipt of the
prior information being the foundation of the prosecution case, non-examination of
such a vital witness namely Subrata Debnath strikes at the root of the prosecution
story. He, therefore, urges this Court to dismiss the present appeal. To support his
contention, learned counsel for the respondent has also placed reliance on the
following paragraphs from the judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court:
1. Ajay Kumar Ghoshal etc. v. State of Bihar and Anr. reported in AIR 2017 SC
804:
“………..11. Though the word “retrial” is used under Section 386(b)(i) Cr.P.C.,
the powers conferred by this clause is to be exercised only in exceptional cases,
where the appellate court is satisfied that the omission or irregularity has
occasioned in failure of justice. The circumstances that should exist for warranting
a retrial must be such that where the trial was undertaken by the Court having no
jurisdiction, or trial was vitiated by serious illegality or irregularity on account of
the misconception of nature of proceedings. An order for retrial may be passed in
cases where the original trial has not been satisfactory for some particular reasons
such as wrong admission or wrong rejection of evidences or the Court refused to
hear certain witnesses who were supposed to be heard……….”
2. Karnail Singh v. State of Haryana reported in (2009) 8 SCC 539:
“…….35. In conclusion, what is to be noticed is Abdul Rashid did not require
literal compliance with the requirements of Sections 42(1) and 42(2) nor did Sajan
Abraham hold that the requirements of Section 42(1) and 42(2) need not be
fulfilled at all. The effect of the two decisions was as follows :
(a) The officer on receiving the information [of the nature referred to in
Sub-section (1) of section 42] from any person had to record it in writing in the
concerned Register and forthwith send a copy to his immediate official superior,
before proceeding to take action in terms of clauses (a) to (d) of section 42(1).
(b) But if the information was received when the officer was not in the
police station, but while he was on the move either on patrol duty or otherwise,
either by mobile phone, or other means, and the information calls for immediate
action and any delay would have resulted in the goods or evidence being removed
or destroyed, it would not be feasible or practical to take down in writing the
information given to him, in such a situation, he could take action as per clauses
(a) to (d) of section 42(1) and thereafter, as soon as it is practical, record the
information in writing and forthwith inform the same to the official superior .
(c) In other words, the compliance with the requirements of Sections 42
(1) and 42(2) in regard to writing down the information received and sending a
copy thereof to the superior officer, should normally precede the entry, search and
seizure by the officer. But in special circumstances involving emergent situations,
the recording of the information in writing and sending a copy thereof to the
official superior may get postponed by a reasonable period, that is after the search,
entry and seizure. The question is one of urgency and expediency.
(d) While total non-compliance of requirements of sub-sections (1) and
(2) of section 42 is impermissible, delayed compliance with satisfactory
explanation about the delay will be acceptable compliance of section 42. To
illustrate, if any delay may result in the accused escaping or the goods or evidence
being destroyed or removed, not recording in writing the information received,
before initiating action, or non-sending a copy of such information to the official
superior forthwith, may not be treated as violation of section 42. But if the
information was received when the police officer was in the police station with
sufficient time to take action, and if the police officer fails to record in writing the
information received, or fails to send a copy thereof, to the official superior, then it
will be a suspicious circumstance being a clear violation of section 42 of the Act.
Similarly, where the police officer does not record the information at all, and does
not inform the official superior at all, then also it will be a clear violation of
section 42 of the Act. Whether there is adequate or substantial compliance with
section 42 or not is a question of fact to be decided in each case. The above
position got strengthened with the amendment to section 42 by Act 9 of
2001…………”
[7]
Heard the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the material evidence
on record.
[8]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned Public Prosecutor for the State has fairly
represented before this Court that about 150 cases were decided within a short span
of time and all resulted in acquittal. When the matter was enquired with the Public
Prosecutor of the trial Court, he tendered his resignation and the State has expressed
doubt regarding the manner in which the cases were conducted and the resignation
was obtained. During the course of hearing, learned P.P. has mentioned that the
present appeal is one of such matters where the State has sought interference of this
Court on the ground that there has been gross violation of the provisions of the
Cr.P.C. in closing the prosecution evidence without affording adequate opportunity
to the prosecution to examine the witnesses.
[9]
In view of the fair submission made by the learned public prosecutor,
this Court feels that the present case in hand is to be taken as a special case for
appreciating the evidence for the welfare of the State of Tripura and in the interest of
the citizens. This Court feels that it cannot shut its eyes when the matter deals with
the interest of the citizens of the State of Tripura to the larger extent and it is not the
case that benefit should go to the accused persons for mere technicalities which are
pointed out by the learned counsel for the respondent. Since, the future of the youth
in Tripura is drowning in darkness day by day due to drug abuse, these sorts of
NDPS cases should be dealt with by the trial Court more seriously providing ample
opportunity to the prosecution to produce the vital witnesses.
[10]
It is seen from record that on 24.07.2024 two witnesses namely P. Seikh
Aslam and Puja Chowdhury were examined as PW.02 & P.W. 03 on 25.07.2024
three witnesses namely Samar Debnath, Jitendra Choudhury and Narayan Ch.
Debnath were examined as P.W.04, P.W.05 & P.W. 06 and on 26.07.2024, one
witness namely Amar Kishore Debbarma, I.O. was examined as P.W. 07 and he
learned Court below closed the prosecution evidence and fixed the case 06.08.2024
for examination of accused person under Section 313 Cr.P.C. For the purpose of
convenience, the relevant contents from the orders dated 24.07.2024, 25.07.2024 &
26.07.2024 are reproduced herein-below:
“24.07.2024
Today the case record is listed for Pws.
Custody accused Swapan Shil is produced from the J/C.
Ld. Defence Counsel Mr. R.Chowdhury is present for the accused.
No bail petition filed for the accused person.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present.
Two witnesses namely P. Seikh Aslam and Puja Chowdhury are present, they are
examined, cross-examined as PW-02 & 03and discharged.
No other witness is present.
No service report received regarding the summons.
To date fixed (25.07.2024) for Pws(6 to 9)
Accused is further remanded to J/C till 25.07.2024….”
“25.07.2024
Today the case record is listed for Pws.
Custody accused Swapan Shil is produced from the J/C.
Ld. Defence Counsel Mr. R.Chowdhury is present for the accused.
No bail petition filed for the accused person.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present.
Three witnesses namely Samar Debnath, Jitendra Choudhury and Narayan Ch. Debnath are
present, they are examined, cross-examined as PW- 04, 05 & 06 and discharged.
No other witness is present.
Received one message intimating the fact that witness Sarbajit Choudhury is unable to
appear before this court as he is on leave on medical ground.
Keep it with the record.
To date fixed (26.07.2024) for Pws.
Accused is further remanded to J/C till 26.07.2024…………”
“26.07.2024
Today the case record is listed for Pws.
Custody accused Swapan Shil is produced from the J/C.
L.d. Defence Counsel Mr. R. Chowdhury is present for the accused.
No bail petition filed for the accused person.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present.
One witness namely Amar Kishore Debbarma, IO is present, he is examined, crossexamined as PW- 07 and discharged.
No other witness is present.
As IO has been examined, on verbal submission of prosecution the evidence of prosecution
witnesses is hereby closed.
Accused is directed to furnish bail bond of Rs.50000/- in compliance of Section 437A of
Cr.P.C on the next date without fail.
Fix 06.08.2024 for examination of accused persons u/s 313 of Cr.P.C/execution of bail
bond.
Accused is further remanded to J/C till 06.08.2024…………”
[11]
From the above quoted orders of the learned trial Court, it is seen that
notices were issued upon the prosecution witnesses but, service report was awaited,
and without waiting for service report, prosecution witnesses have been closed at the
premature stage. Despite the intimation received from one witness namely Sarbajit
Choudhury regarding his inability to appear before the trial Court on medical
ground, no opportunity was extended to prosecution by the learned trial Court to
examine the said witness by closing the witnesses. This Court opines that there was
no necessity to decide the matter in such haste without granting proper opportunity
to the prosecution.
[12]
Since, in the present case the Officer in charge, Police Station was the
person who handled the entire crime scene, the question of compliance of Section 42
of the NDPS Act does not arise but, it falls under Section 41 of the NDPS Act and
the Officer in Charge, Police Station who is a gazetted officer stated to be P.W.11
was not examined as prosecution witness. This Court feels that his witness would be
very crucial in deciding the case. Since the evidence of certain vital prosecution
witnesses was not recorded though summons had been issued, the trial remained
incomplete. In the case in hand, out of 12 witnesses since 7 were only examined and
learned P.P. reported to this Court that there is no further witness, thus, we are of the
opinion that, the matter is liable to be remanded back to the learned trial Court for
fresh trial after recording the evidence of the remaining witnesses. It is also opined
that the judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court as referred by the learned counsel for
the respondent is not applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case.
[13]
With the above observations, the impugned judgment and order dated
14.08.2024
passed by the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Sepahijala Tripura,
Sonamura in case No Special (NDPS) 20 of 2024 is hereby set-aside. Accordingly,
the matter is remanded back to the learned trial Court with a direction to conduct a
fresh trial by calling upon the rest of the prosecution witnesses. However, it is made
clear that reasonable opportunity shall be afforded to the prosecution witnesses. It is
further made clear that after closure of evidences of all the prosecution witnesses,
learned Court below shall deliver its judgment afresh. The entire exercise shall be
completed expeditiously.
[14]
The accused-respondent is directed to surrender before the learned trial
Court on or before 31st March, 2026. Upon his surrender, the learned trial Court may
consider bail application, if so, filed by him, in accordance with law so that, his right
is not infringed.
[15]
Resultantly, the present appeal is allowed to the extent as indicated
above. As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall also stand
closed.
S. Datta Purkayastha, J.
Sabyasachi. G.
SABYASACHI GHOSH GHOSH
Date: 2026.03.16 16:58:11 +05'30'
Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review