Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
Crl. Petn. No.13 of 2026
The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Home
Department, Agartala.
…..Petitioner
VERSUS
Sri Sudip Goswami, son of Brajalal Goswami, resident of Rabindranagar, Ward No.51,
Rentus Colony, P.S. East Agartala, District: West Tripura.
…..Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. R. Datta, P.P.
: Mr. S. Sarkar, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Dhiman Gope, Advocate.
: 16.03.2026
Date of hearing
Date of judgment
And order
: 23.03.2026
Whether fit for reporting : YES
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
[1]
When the case is called, both sides present. Mr. S. Sarkar, learned
senior counsel appearing for the respondent-accused has submitted his written
objection and a copy of the same also served on Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P.
appearing for the petitioner-State. In view of the urgency explained, the matter has
been taken up today.
[2]
Heard Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the petitioner-State
and Mr. S. Sarkar, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. D. Gope, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent.
[3]
This is an application filed under Section-528 of BNSS for setting
aside/quashing the order dated 27.02.2026 passed in B.A. No.29 of 2026 by the
learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No.4, Agartala, West Tripura, whereby the
respondent-accused person has been granted bail.
[4]
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:
“It is, therefore, humbly prayed that Your Lordships would be graciously
pleased to set aside/quash the order dated 27.02.2026 passed in B.A. No.29 of
2026 by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No.4, Agartala, West Tripura,
whereby the respondent-accused person has been granted bail.”
[5]
The facts in brief are that the present criminal petition has been filed
by the State of Tripura challenging the legality and propriety of the order dated
27.02.2026 passed by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura,
Agartala in B.A. No.29 of 2026, whereby the respondent/accused Sri Sudip
Goswami was released on bail in connection with PRC (WP) 416 of 2025 arising
out of West Agartala P.S. Case No. 2025 WAG070. The case involves serious
allegations of submission and use of forged official documents, including a
memorandum for Council of Ministers purportedly bearing the signature of the
Hon'ble Chief Minister of Tripura, for securing wrongful gain in public
employment. During investigation, the SPIO, Directorate of Medical Education,
reported that such document had never been supplied, and an enquiry committee
also raised serious doubts regarding authenticity. The accused subsequently
informed the investigating officer in writing that the documents were lost giving
rise to suspicion and necessitating custodial interrogation.
[6]
The learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura, Agartala, by a
detailed order dated 24.02.2026, rejected the bail prayer after perusing the materials
and recorded specific findings regarding the sensitive nature of the documents, the
necessity of custodial interrogation, and the possibility of tampering with evidence.
Further investigation had already been permitted on 23.02.2026 and the case was
technically under investigation. However, within three days of remand and the
matter was fixed by District & Sessions Judge for hearing on 02.03.2026 and made
over the case to the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No.4, Agartala, West
Tripura though the case was fixed on 02.03.2026 but took up the matter on
27.02.2026 without recording urgency for advancement and granted bail. The
impugned order does not reflect proper consideration of the case diary, or the
detailed findings that got recorded earlier by the learned CJM. The order suffers
from non-application of mind, procedural impropriety, and misapplication of
settled principles governing bail.
[7]
Hence, the present petition has been filed before this Court seeking
setting aside of the impugned order dated 27.02.2026 passed in BA 29 of 2026.
[8]
Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the petitioner-State has
submitted that the impugned order dated 27.02.2026 granting bail to the accused
suffers from serious non-application of mind and improper exercise of judicial
discretion, inasmuch as it fails to adequately consider the gravity and seriousness of
the allegations involving submission and use of forged official documents,
including a "Memorandum for Council of Ministers" purportedly bearing the
signature of the Hon'ble Chief Minister of Tripura, for securing wrongful gain in
public employment. The learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura,
Agartala failed to consider that learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, by a detailed and
reasoned order dated 24.02.2026 in PRC (WP) 416 of 2025, had recorded specific
findings after perusal of the case record that the documents in question were highly
sensitive in nature, touching the internal functioning and secrecy of the Council of
Ministers and that custodial interrogation was necessary; the learned Sessions
Court failed to properly address or dislodge those findings.
[9]
The learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura,
Agartala failed to consider that further investigation had already been permitted on
23.02.2026 and at the time of remand the case was technically under investigation;
the impugned order overlooks the settled principle that when further investigation
is in progress and recovery of crucial documents is pending, custodial interrogation
may be justified notwithstanding earlier non-arrest during initial investigation. The
learned Court below erred in proceeding primarily on the premise that the accused
was not arrested during investigation, without appreciating that subsequent
developments i.e. including the enquiry report, forensic opinion, and the suspicious
conduct of the accused in claiming that the documents were "lost" materially
altered the factual situation and warranted custody.
[10]
The learned Court below failed to consider that the learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate had specifically recorded a reasonable apprehension that if
released, the accused could tamper with documentary evidence and influence
official witnesses connected with the Directorate of Medical Education and other
government offices the impugned order does not adequately neutralize or address
this apprehension. The impugned order does not reflect that the complete case diary
was called for and thoroughly examined before reversing the remand order dated
24.02.2026, in a case of such magnitude involving alleged forgery of high-level
governmental documents, perusal of the case diary was indispensable prior to
forming an opinion that custody was unwarranted.
[11]
The learned Court below erred in holding that custodial interrogation
was not warranted, despite the specific submission of the prosecution that certain
vital documents were in the exclusive possession and knowledge of the accused
and recovery thereof required sustained custodial interrogation. The learned Addl.
Sessions Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala while granting bail to the
accused person, failed to call for and peruse the case diary so as to ascertain
whether, pursuant to the order permitting further investigation dated 23.02.2026,
any additional incriminating materials or evidence had been collected against the
accused. In a case where further investigation had already been allowed and
custodial interrogation was being undertaken pursuant to a reasoned remand order
dated 24.02.2026 passed in PRC (WP) 416 of 2025, examination of the updated
case diary was indispensable before forming an opinion that further custody was
unwarranted. The failure to undertake such scrutiny vitiates the exercise of
discretion and renders the impugned order legally unsustainable.
[12]
The learned Court below failed to appreciate that the learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate had invoked statutory provisions relating to remand during
pendency of further investigation, recording reasons that further evidence was
likely to be obtained through custodial interrogation, such statutory reasoning has
not been meaningfully considered or rebutted in the impugned order passed by the
learned Addl. Sessions Judge.
[13]
Although the matter was fixed for hearing on 02.03.2026, without
any recorded urgency, exceptional circumstance, or compelling exigency, the case
was preponed and taken up on 27.02.2026 and bail was granted within even calling
the case diary and within three days of remand, thereby depriving the prosecution
of reasonable opportunity to place the updated progress of investigation. The
hurried consideration and grant of bail, while further investigation was underway
and recovery of allegedly forged and lost documents remained pending, has caused
serious prejudice to the prosecution and undermined the effective conduct of
investigation in a matter affecting public administration and governmental
integrity.
[14]
The impugned order proceeds on an erroneous assumption that
absence of arrest during initial investigation creates an indefeasible right to bail,
whereas the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the cases of Aman Preet
Singh v. CBI, Satender Kumar Antil v. CBI and Siddharth v. State of Uttar Pradesh
does not prohibit arrest or custody where further investigation reveals necessity for
custodial interrogation. The learned Court below has failed to consider that the
gravity and seriousness of the allegations, which involve manipulation of official
documents and matters connected with governmental decision-making process,
have far-reaching public ramifications and affect institutional integrity.
[15]
It has been further contended that the learned Court below did not
record any finding that the prosecution’s apprehension regarding tampering with
documentary evidence was unfounded, nor did it assess the possibility of the
accused influencing or pressurizing witness who are subordinate officials or
otherwise connected with the accused. The order granting bail does not adequately
consider that further investigation under BNSS had already been allowed and such
stage of investigation is a critical phase during which release of the accused is
likely to impede effective collection of evidence.
[16]
The learned Court below treated the issuance of summons at the stage
of cognizance as determinative of entitlement to bail, without considering that
subsequent developments, including the need for recovery of documents and
confrontation with materials collected during further investigation, justified
custodial interrogation. The learned Court below has failed to apply the settled
principle that while granting bail in serious offences involving public documents
and governmental process, the Court must balance individual liberty with societal
interest and the requirement of a fair and unhindered investigation.
[17]
The conditions imposed in the impugned order are insufficient
safeguards in the facts and circumstances of the case and do not adequately protect
against tampering with documentary evidence or influencing material witnesses.
The impugned order suffers from non-consideration of material aspects placed by
the prosecution and thus is legally unsustainable, warranting interference by this
Court. It is well settled bail once granted can be cancelled where the order granting
bail is perverse, based on misapplication of law, ignores material consideration, or
if passed in undue haste, the impugned order, having failed to balance individual
liberty with societal interest and the requirement of a fair and unhindered
investigation, is liable to be set aside.
[18]
Mr. Datta, learned PP appearing for the petitioner-State in support of
his arguments has placed reliance on some decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Bharatbhai Bhimabahi Bharwad v. State of Gujarat and Others, reported in
(2020) 18 SCC 693, Ajwar v. Waseem and Another a/w other, reported in (2024)
10 SCC 768, Shabeen Ahmad v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another, reported in
(2025) 4 SCC 172 and State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan Etc, reported in (2025)
SCC Online SC 1702.
[19]
In reply, Mr. S. Sarkar, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent-accused has submitted at the outset that the present petition under
Section-528 of BNSS for setting aside the order dated 27.02.2026 passed by the
learned Court below is not maintainable in its present form and nature inasmuch as,
it is settled law that the provision of Section-528 of BNSS cannot be invoked if
there is a specific provision in the statute for the redress of the grievance of the
aggrieved party i.e. the cancellation of bail. There is no direct evidence linking the
accused with the crime. The police has filed charge-sheet merely on suspicion and
based on the witnesses who are totally doubtful.
[20]
The learned Court below allowed the urgent hearing application of
the accused and on the same date without even calling the case diary, hurriedly the
case was heard and released the accused on bail without considering the fact that
the further investigation of the case had already been allowed and custodial
interrogation was being undertaken pursuant to a reasoned remand order dated
24.02.2026 passed in PRC (WP) No.416 of 2025, such type of argument made by
the learned P.P. for the petitioner-State cannot be accepted and completely false
and fabricated.
[21]
From the observation of the learned Court below it is crystal clear
that the learned Addl. Sessions Judge has passed a reasoned order observing with
the principles governing arrest and bail. Moreover, it is also transpired that the
learned Addl. P.P. who appeared during the hearing of bail application before the
learned Court below did not make any submission in respect of calling for case
diary. It is further categorically denied the statement of the petitioner to the effect
that the case involves grave allegations of submission and use of forged official
documents, including a memorandum for Council of Ministers, purportedly bearing
the signature of the Hon’ble Chief Minister for securing wrongful gain in public
employment.
[22]
Neither in complaint nor in the charge-sheet it has been disclosed that
the alleged disputed document namely memorandum for the Council of Ministers
bears the signature of the Hon’ble Chief Minister of Tripura. But the petitioner has
deliberately misguided this Court by suppressing the fact just to entangle the
accused in a false case and also tried to false narrative in order to create sensational
news and adverse reaction amongst the mass public. Personal liberty of the
individual is guaranteed by the Constitution of India and it is the matter of liberty
of the accused who was in custody and the right of the accused in preponement of
hearing in bail matter is also recognized by the Hon’ble Apex Court.
[23]
Moreover, the prosecution did not raise any objection either on the
put up petition filed on behalf of the accused seeking in preponement of hearing on
bail matter nor did raise the same at the time of hearing of bail application.
Moreover, the matter of early hearing of the bail application is discretion of the
learned Court where the liberty of the individual at stake for the interest of justice.
It also settled law that the interrogation of the accused can be done without being
arrested and custodial remand of the accused, if the accused co-operates the
investigation. As the objection on bail of the accused raised by the petitioner is not
at all sustainable in the eye of law.
[24]
It is well settled by a catena of judgments rendered by the Hon’ble
Apex Court that the consideration for grant of bail and cancellation thereof are
entirely different. The respondent fully cooperated with the I.O. of the case in the
earlier phase of investigation also and has not misused the liberty granted to him.
Further the personal liberty is guaranteed by the Constitution which is entitled by
the respondent. The principle of law that bail is the rule jail is the exception, the
Hon’ble Apex Court in a catena of recent judgments has time and again reaffirmed
the aforesaid principle of law and as such, the bail granted to the respondent is
liable to be continued as long as he complies with the conditions imposed by the
learned Court below.
[25]
It has been further averred that during the entire course of
investigation the accused was not arrested. From the charge sheet itself, it is
evident that upon receipt of notice under Section-35(3) (1) of BNSS, the accused
appeared before the IO and cooperated with the investigation. The IO being
satisfied that custodial interrogation was not necessary, did not arrest the accused
and ultimately submitted charge sheet. It has been further contended that after
filing of the charge-sheet and taking cognizance, the learned Court below issued
summons to the accused for appearance. In the meantime, the IO submitted an
application seeking permission for further investigation, which was allowed.
[26]
In support of his case, learned senior counsel has placed his reliance
on certain judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Padal Venkata Rama Reddy v.
Kovvuri Satyanarayana Reddy and Another, reported in (2011) 2 SCC 437 and
Aman Preet Singh v. Central Bureau of Investigation, reported in (2022) 13 SCC
764.
[27]
Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
[28]
It has been submitted by the learned PP that the investigation is
presently at a crucial stage. The recovery of the original forged document,
identification of other conspirators and seizure of digital devices connected with
the fabrication of the document are essential steps which are yet to be completed. It
has been also stated that being an influential person and having access to official
circles, is in a position to manipulate records and influence witnesses. If he
continues to remain at liberty, there exists a serious apprehension that he may
destroy material evidence or intimidate witnesses which may severely prejudice the
investigation.
[29]
Case record and lower court record is called for and perused. The
case was fixed on 02.03.2026 but on 27.02.2026 one “put up” request for urgent
hearing was filed by the accused before the court of learned Addl. Sessions Judge,
Court No.4, Agartala, West Tripura and on the same date without even calling the
Case Diary(CD), hurriedly the case was heard by the learned Court and by an
Order dated 27.02.2026 the learned Court below released the accused person on
bail on the ground that the accused was not arrested during investigation and IO
submitted charge sheet without arresting the accused and merely because further
investigation has been allowed, it does not automatically warrant custodial remand
of the accused. The learned Court below while granting bail to the accused person,
failed to call for and peruse the Case Diary so as to ascertain whether, pursuant to
the order permitting further investigation dated 23.02.2026, any additional
incriminating materials or evidence had been collected against the accused. In a
case where further investigation had already been allowed and custodial
interrogation was being undertaken pursuant to a reasoned remand order dated
24.02.2026 passed in PRC (WP) 416 of 2025, examination of the updated Case
Diary was indispensable before forming an opinion that further custody was
unwarranted.
[30]
It reveals from the record that in reply to RTI dated 16.04.2025,
SPIO, DME supplied all the information sought by the accused except point No.9
i.e. copy of memorandum for Council of Ministers as it was not available at
Directorate of Medical Education. But, the accused submitted application along
with some documents as enclosure to this Directorate regarding the promotion to
the post of Chief Technical Officer (Central Workshop), dated 26.04.2025. Among
those enclosures, the documents on serial page number 13 & 14 regarding copy of
memorandum for Council of Ministers contains forged signature of State Public
Information Officer, Directorate of Medical Education, Agartala, Tripura as this
document never counter signed and supplied to the accused-respondent.
[31]
The case involves grave allegations of submission and use of forged
official documents, including a "Memorandum for Council of Ministers"
purportedly bearing the signature of the Hon'ble Chief Minister of Tripura, for
securing wrongful gain in public employment. The learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, by a detailed order dated 24.02.2026 in PRC (WP) 416 of 2025, after
perusal of the case record, had recorded specific findings regarding the sensitive
nature of the documents, the suspicious conduct of the accused in claiming that
such documents were "lost," and the necessity of custodial interrogation in view of
further investigation already permitted.
[32]
In the above back ground, it is necessary to extract the “Put up”
request/application filed by the accused for advancement/early hearing of bail
petition. For the purpose of reference, the put up petition may be extracted
hereinbelow:
“The petitioner respectfully submits as follows:
(1) That, the above case is not listed before this Hon’ble Court as of now.
(2) That, the matter is extremely urgent basis the petitioner on behalf of the
accused person in custody wants to submit that petition.
(3) That, if the matter is not heard urgently, the petitioner will suffer a great
loss and hardship.
Therefore, it is most humbly prayed that this Hon’ble Court may be pleased to
direct that the above case put up for urgent hearing the earliest in the interest of
justice.
AND
For this act of kindness the humble the petitioner as in duty bound shall ever
pray.
Date
26/02/2026”.
[33]
In Bharatbhai Bhimabahi Bharwad v. State of Gujarat and Others,
reported in (2020) 18 SCC 693, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held as under:
“9. It is well settled that the consideration applicable for cancellation of bail
and consideration for challenging the order of grant of bail on the ground of
arbitrary exercise of discretion are different. While considering the application
for cancellation of bail, the Court ordinarily looks for some supervening
circumstances like; tampering of evidence either during investigation or during
trial, threatening of witness, the accused is likely to abscond and the trial of the
case getting delayed on that count etc. Whereas, in an order challenging the
grant of bail on the ground that it has been granted illegally, the consideration
is whether there was improper or arbitrary exercise of discretion in grant of
bail. The appellant has challenged the very grant of bail on the ground of
arbitrary exercise of discretion ignoring the relevant materials to be considered
in the application for bail. Since the High Court proceeded under the footing as
if the appellant had filed the application only for cancellation of bail for which,
the consideration is different, the impugned order is liable to be set aside and
the matter is remitted to the High Court for consideration of the matter afresh.”
[34]
In Ajwar v. Waseem and Another a/w other, reported in (2024) 10
SCC 768, the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed as follows:
“26. While considering as to whether bail ought to be granted in a matter
involving a serious criminal offence, the Court must consider relevant factors
like the nature of the accusations made against the accused, the manner in
which the crime is alleged to have been committed, the gravity of the offence,
the role attributed to the accused, the criminal antecedents of the accused, the
probability of tampering of the witnesses and repeating the offence, if the
accused are released on bail, the likelihood of the accused being unavailable in
the event bail is granted, the possibility of obstructing the proceedings and
evading the courts of justice and the overall desirability of releasing the
accused on bail. [Refer : Chaman Lal v. State of U.P. [Chaman Lal v. State of
U.P., (2004) 7 SCC 525 : 2004 SCC (Cri) 1974] ; Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v.
Rajesh Ranjan [Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan, (2004) 7 SCC 528 :
2004 SCC (Cri) 1977] ; Masroor v. State of U.P. [Masroor v. State of U.P.,
(2009) 14 SCC 286 : (2010) 1 SCC (Cri) 1368] ; Prasanta Kumar Sarkar v.
Ashis Chatterjee [Prasanta Kumar Sarkar v. Ashis Chatterjee, (2010) 14 SCC
496 : (2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 765] ; Neeru Yadav v. State of U.P. [Neeru Yadav v.
State of U.P., (2014) 16 SCC 508 : (2015) 3 SCC (Cri) 527] ; Anil Kumar
Yadav v. State (NCT of Delhi) [Anil Kumar Yadav v. State (NCT of Delhi),
(2018) 12 SCC 129 : (2018) 3 SCC (Cri) 425] ; Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar
[Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar, (2020) 2 SCC 118 : (2020) 1 SCC (Cri) 558] .]
27. It is equally well settled that bail once granted, ought not to be cancelled in
a mechanical manner. However, an unreasoned or perverse order of bail is
always open to interference by the superior court. If there are serious
allegations against the accused, even if he has not misused the bail granted to
him, such an order can be cancelled by the same Court that has granted the bail.
Bail can also be revoked by a superior court if it transpires that the courts
below have ignored the relevant material available on record or not looked into
the gravity of the offence or the impact on the society resulting in such an
order. In P v. State of M.P. decided by a three judge Bench of this Court
(authored by one of us (Hima Kohli, J), has spelt out the considerations that
must weigh with the Court for interfering in an order granting bail to an
accused under Section 439(1) CrPC in the following words:
24. As can be discerned from the above decisions, for cancelling bail once
granted, the court must consider whether any supervening circumstances have
arisen or the conduct of the accused post grant of bail demonstrates that it is no
longer conducive to a fair trial to permit him to retain his freedom by enjoying
the concession of bail during trail. To put it differently, in ordinary
circumstances, this Court would be loathe to interfere with an order passed by
the court below granting bail but if such an order is found to be illegal or
perverse or premised on material that is irrelevant, then such an order is
susceptible to scrutiny and interference by the appellate court.”
28. The considerations that weigh with the appellate court for setting aside the
bail order on an application being moved by the aggrieved party include inclu
any supervening circumstances that may have occurred after granting relief to
the accused, the conduct of the accused while on bail, any attempt on the part
of the accused to procrastinate, resulting in delaying the trial, any instance of
threats b being extended to the witnesses while on bail, any attempt on the part
of the accused to tamper with the evidence in any manner. We may add that
this list is only illustrative and not exhaustive. However, the court must be
cautious that at the stage of granting bail, only a prima facie case needs to be
examined and detailed reasons relating to the merits of the case that may cause
prejudice to the accused, ought to be avoided. Suffice it is to state that the bail
order should reveal the factors that have been considered by the Court for
granting relief to the accused.
30. Keeping in mind the aforesaid parameters, we may now proceed to examine
the pleas taken by the parties so as to decide as to whether the f impugned
orders can be sustained or not. On a careful consideration of the entire records,
we are inclined to agree with submission made by the learned counsel for the
appellant complainant that the impugned orders are unjustified and suffer from
grave infirmity. The primary factor that has swayed the learned Single Judge of
the High Court in granting bail to the accused Waseem is that even though the
prosecution version is that 11 accused persons had assaulted the appellant
complainant and members of his family on indiscriminate firing taking place,
only three persons had sustained injuries and two had expired on the side of the
appellant complainant. At the same time, serious injuries were also received on
the side of the accused which could not be explained by a the prosecution. In
the case of the accused Nazim, the High Court observed that there was no
distinction between the role attributed to him and the co-accused Waseem and
that the injuries suffered on the side of the respondent had not been explained
by the prosecution. The High Court has also gone on to observe that the
investigation conducted by the police was one-sided and the case set up by the
accused side was ignored. In the case of Aslam, his bail application was
allowed and the learned Single Judge observed that there is a cross-version of
the incident inasmuch as the accused side had also received b serious injuries
which were not satisfactorily explained by the prosecution. In the case of
Abubakar, noting that the co-accused Aslam was granted bail by a coordinate
Bench and the case of Abubakar was similar to that of Aslam, he was granted
the benefit of bail on grounds of parity.”
[35]
In Shabeen Ahmad v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another, reported
in (2025) 4 SCC 172, the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed as under:
“A. Annulment of bail orders
18.1. This refers to the appellate or revisional power to set aside a bail order
that is perverse, unjustified, or passed in violation f settled legal principles. It is
concerned with defects existing at the time the bail was granted, without
reference to subsequent conduct.
18.3. In Purna v. Rambials, it was held that a bail order can be set aside even in
the absence of post-bail misconduct if it is found to be unjustified, illegal or
perverse.
18.8. In Anil Kumar Yadav v. State (NCT of Delhi), this Court reiterated that
while no exhaustive list can be laid down, courts must always consider the
totality of circumstances, including the seriousness of the offence, prima facie
evidence, and potentional for interference with the trial.
18.9. In State of Kerala v. Mahesh, it was observed that even under Article136, where interference with bail orders is rare, this Court will exercise its
powers if the bail order is found to be lacking application of mind or based on
irrelevant considerations.
B. Cancellation of bail18.10. As per Halsbury’s Laws of England, the grant of bail does not set the
accused at liberty in the absolute sense but merely shifts custody from the State
to the sureties. Consequently, cancellation of bail entails an assessment of
whether the accused has absused the liberty so conferred.”
[36]
In Padal Venkata Rama Reddy v. Kovvuri Satyanarayana Reddy
and Another, reported in (2011) 2 SCC 437, the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed
as under:
“13. It is well settled that the inherent powers under Section 482 can be
exercised only when no other remedy is available to the litigant and not in a
situation where a specific remedy is provided by the statute. It cannot be used if
it is inconsistent with specific provisions provided under the Code.(vide Kavita v. State (2000 Cr LJ 315) and B.S. Joshi v. State of Haryana &
Anr. ((2003) 4 SCC 675). If an effective alternative remedy is available, the
High Court will not exercise its powers under this section, specially when the
applicant may not have availed of that remedy.
14. The inherent power is to be exercised ex debito justitiae, to do real and
substantial justice, for administration of which alone Courts exist. Wherever
any attempt is made to abuse that authority so as to produce injustice, the Court
has power to prevent the abuse. It is, however, not necessary that at this stage
there should be a meticulous analysis of the case before the trial to find out
whether the case ends in conviction or acquittal. (Vide Mrs. Dhanalakshmi vs.
R. Prasanna Kumar & Ors. AIR 1990 SC 494; Ganesh Narayan Hegde vs. S.
Bangarappa & Ors. (1995) 4 SCC 41; and M/s Zandu.”
[37]
In Aman Preet Singh v. Central Bureau of Investigation, reported in
(2022) 13 SCC 764, the Hon’ble Apex Court has observed as under:
“10. The said paragraph deals with directions issued to the criminal courts and
we would like to extract the portion of the same as under. (Court on its own
motion case, SCC OnLine Del para 26)
"26. Arrest of a person for less serious or such kinds of offence or offences
those can be investigated without arrest by the police cannot be brooked by any
civilised society.
Directions for criminal courts:
(1) Whenever officer-in-charge of police station or investigating agency like
CBI files a charge-sheet without arresting the accused during investigation and
does not produce the accused in custody as referred in Section 170 CrPC the
Magistrate or the court empowered to take cognizance or try the accused shall
accept the charge-sheet forthwith and proceed according to the procedure laid
down in Section 173 CrPC and exercise the options available to it as discussed
in this judgment. In such a case the Magistrate or Court shall invariably issue a
process of summons and not warrant of arrest.
(if) In case the court or Magistrate exercises the discretion of issuing warrant of
arrest at any stage including the stage while taking cognizance of the chargesheet, he or it shall have to record the reasons in writing as contemplated under
Section 87 CrPC that the accused has either been absconding or shall not obey
the summons or has refused to appear despite proof of due service of summons
upon him.
(iii) Rejection of an application for exemption from personal appearance on
any date of hearing or even at first instance does not amount to non-appearance
despite service of summons or absconding or failure to obey summons and the
court in such a case shall not issue warrant of arrest and may either give
direction to the accused to appear or issue process of summons.
(iv) That the Court shall on appearance of an accused in a bailable offence
release him forthwith on his furnishing a personal bond with or without sureties
as per the mandatory provisions of Section 436 CrPC
(v) The Court shall on appearance of an accused in non-bailable offence who
has neither been arrested by the police/Investigating Agency during
investigation nor produced in custody as envisaged in Section 170 CrPC call
upon the accused to move a bail application if the accused does not move it on
his own and release him on bail as the circumstance of his having not been
arrested during investigation or not being produced in custody is itself
sufficient to entitle him to be released on bail. Reason is imply. If a person has
been at large and free for several years and has not been even arrested during
investigation, to send him to jail by refusing bail suddenly, merely because
charge-sheet has been filed is against the basic principles governing grant or
refusal of bail.”
[38]
Further investigation of the case had already been allowed on
23.02.2026, and the case was technically under investigation at the time the
accused was remanded. The learned Chief Judicial Magistrate had specifically
observed that improper or incomplete investigation in a matter touching the internal
functioning and secrecy of the Council of Ministers may prejudice not only the
prosecution but the State at large. It is also not reflected that the complete Case
Diary were called for and thoroughly examined before reversing the remand order.
Such seriousness involving alleged forgery of high-level government documents,
judicial scrutiny of the case diary was indispensable prior to forming an opinion
that custodial interrogation was unwarranted.
[39]
The matter was fixed for hearing on 02.03.2026, without any
recorded urgency or compelling exigency, the case was taken up on 27.02.2026 and
the accused was released on bail within three days of being remanded to judicial
custody. It is to be noted that 28.02.2026 Saturday, 01.03.2026 falls on Sunday.
Moreover, the “put up” request made is not recognized by Cr. P.C. and BNSS and
also by any State amendment or State laws or criminal rules of practice. The said
“put up” request also does not indicate any urgency to take up the matter out of turn
by way of advancement. There is no advancement or adjournment provision of law
recognized under erstwhile Cr.P.C. or present BNSS. In the innovation of short cuts
is not permissible by law in absence of a procedure under the law. No exceptional
circumstance is reflected in the order justifying such preponement or immediate
release, particularly when further investigation was underway and report was
awaited. No separate orders are passed on the so called “put up” application.
Without deciding the same, orders of bail are granted. The hurried consideration
and grant of bail, without awaiting progress of custodial interrogation or
investigation, has caused serious prejudice to the prosecution and amounts to nonapplication of mind.
[40]
After over all analysis, I am of the opinion that the judgments relied
by the counsel for respondent are not applicable to the facts of the case. Further,
considerations applicable for cancellation of bail and considerations for challenging
the order of grant of bail on ground of arbitrary exercise of discretion are different.
While, considering application for cancellation of bail, Court ordinarily looks for
some supervening circumstances like tampering of evidence, threatening of
witnesses; in an order challenging the grant of bail on the ground that it has been
granted illegally, consideration is whether there was improper or arbitrary exercise
of discretion. Cancellation of bail is different from setting aside orders of granting
bail. In that view of the matter, this Court is of the opinion that ends of justice
would met if the petition is allowed by setting aside the impugned order passed by
the learned Court below and remand the matter to the concerned District &
Sessions Judge Court for fresh adjudication and, accordingly, the same is ordered.
[41]
In view of above observation and direction, the present petition
stands disposed of. As sequel, miscellaneous application, pending if any, shall
stand closed.
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
A. Ghosh
signed by ANJAN GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.03.26 12:24:08 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review