The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. On receipt of the charge sheet, learned SDJM Khowai took cognizance of the offence and committed the case to the learned Sessions Judge. During the Trial, the prosecution side examined as many as 14 witnesses namely:- 1) PW1 :- Narayan Ch Das. 2) PW2 :- Sri Chiranjit Roy. 3) PW3 :- Sri Monoranjan Debnath. 4) PW4 :- Sri Tinku Das. 5) PW5 : Sri Rakesh Debbarma. 6) PW6 :- Sri Jagadish Debbarma. 7) PW7 :- Sri Sudhanya Debbarma. 8) PW8 :- Sri Sukendu Debbarma. 9) PW9 :- Sri Sudhanya Debbarma. 10) PW10 :- Sri Samir Ch Bhoumik. 11) PW11 :- Sri Swapan Ch Ghosh. 12) PW12 :- Sri Biswajit Choudhury. 13) PW13 :- SI Sri Bikram Das. 14) PW14 :- Dr Ajitesh Pal. 5) Some documents and other items were also seized in connection with the case before the learned Trial Court. After completion of the trial, the learned Asst. Sessions Judge, Khowai delivered the judgment on 15.07.2020 in connection with case No.ST(TYPE-02) 02 of 2018 corresponding to Khowai P.S. Case No.15/2018 dated 26.01.2018 and vide the said judgment, the accused-person herein, Sri Rupak Paul was acquitted of the charges leveled against him and he was set at liberty. 6) Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the said impugned judgment and order dated 15.07.2020, passed by the learned Asst. Sessions Judge, Khowai, Tripura, the appellantState herein has filed this instant appeal. 7) Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the…
26. 01.2018 at about 9 P.M., P.W.- 09 heard some chaos going on in the barrack and also heard sounds of firing. The P.W.-09 was on sentry duty and he did not go there. It appears from the testimony of the P.W.-9 (victim) that he did not see the incident as he did not go there. Moreover, from the statement of all the PWs, it is crystal clear that there has been no direct eye-witness of the incident of the alleged stealing of a 100 rupee note by the accused from the trunk of Sudhanya Debbarma(P.W.-9). So as to corroborate the version of P.W.2 and P.W.-3 they even failed to state the denomination of the alleged 100 rupee note. After a thorough analysis of the evidence on record, it is clearly observed that the accused is not criminally responsible for an act of alleged theft. 13) Section 307 IPC provides that whoever does any act with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances that if he by that act caused death he would be guilty of murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine, and if hurt is caused to any person by such act, the offender shall be liable either to imprisonment for life or to such punishment. Law is also well-settled that the intention to murder can be inferred from the nature and number of injuries. In this case, the evidence does not suggest any sort of inju…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A NO.22 OF 2021
The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary,
Govt. of Tripura,
Home Department,
Agartala, West Tripura.
……… Appellant/Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Sri Rupak Paul,
S/o Sri Dhananjoy Paul of
Dhalabil, P.S. Khowai, P.O.-Khowai,
PinDistrict-Khowai, Tripura.
…… Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 15.11.2022.
Whether fit for reporting
: NO.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
This instant appeal has been filed under Section
378(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure against the impugned
judgment of acquittal dated 15.07.2020 passed by, Asst.
Sessions Judge, Khowai District, in case No.ST(T-2) 02 of 2018
acquitting the respondent/accused from the charges punishable
under Section 380/307 of IPC and Section 27(1) of the Arms Act.
2.
The facts of the case leading to this instant appeal is
that on 26.01.2018 in the night at around 21.00 hrs, the FIR
named the accused person herein, Rupak Paul was caught redhanded while stealing money from the steel box of constable Sri
Sudhanya Debbarma. On being asked the accused person
confessed that he had stolen Rs.100/- and when the complainant
along with other staff asked him to return the money, the
accused person herein became furious and attacked them with
his service 7.62 SLR by shooting 02(two) consecutive rounds of
bullets at them but somehow they could managed to escape. As
per instruction of his immediate superior, the FIR named accused
person was arrested and the said involved 7.62 SLR and 02 Nos.
of the empty cartridge were seized.
3.
On completion of the investigation, the investigating
officer of the case Sri Bikram Das submitted charge sheet vide
Khowai P.S. Case No.30/2018 dated 24.04.2018 under Section
380/307 of IPC and Section 27(1) of the Arms Act and thereafter
the trial commenced.
4.
On receipt of the charge sheet, learned SDJM Khowai
took cognizance of the offence and committed the case to the
learned Sessions Judge. During the Trial, the prosecution side
examined as many as 14 witnesses namely:-
1) PW1 :- Narayan Ch Das.
2) PW2 :- Sri Chiranjit Roy.
3) PW3 :- Sri Monoranjan Debnath.
4) PW4 :- Sri Tinku Das.
5) PW5 : Sri Rakesh Debbarma.
6) PW6 :- Sri Jagadish Debbarma.
7) PW7 :- Sri Sudhanya Debbarma.
8) PW8 :- Sri Sukendu Debbarma.
9) PW9 :- Sri Sudhanya Debbarma.
10) PW10 :- Sri Samir Ch Bhoumik.
11) PW11 :- Sri Swapan Ch Ghosh.
12) PW12 :- Sri Biswajit Choudhury.
13) PW13 :- SI Sri Bikram Das.
14) PW14 :- Dr Ajitesh Pal.
5)
Some documents and other items were also seized in
connection with the case before the learned Trial Court. After
completion of the trial, the learned Asst. Sessions Judge, Khowai
delivered the judgment on 15.07.2020 in connection with case
No.ST(TYPE-02) 02 of 2018 corresponding to Khowai P.S. Case
No.15/2018 dated 26.01.2018 and vide the said judgment, the
accused-person herein, Sri Rupak Paul was acquitted of the
charges leveled against him and he was set at liberty.
6)
Being
aggrieved
and
dissatisfied
with
the
said
impugned judgment and order dated 15.07.2020, passed by the
learned Asst. Sessions Judge, Khowai, Tripura, the appellantState herein has filed this instant appeal.
7)
Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the
appellant-State has strenuously argued before this Court that the
judgment and order dated 15.07.2020 passed by the learned
Trial Court is perverse, unjustified, and arbitrary and the same
needs to be set aside and quashed.
8)
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent vehemently opposed the said submission of the
learned Addl. P.P and urged this Court to uphold the judgment
and order as passed by the Court below.
10)
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties as
well the perused the evidence on record.
11)
In the trial Court, the charges leveled against the
accused herein were framed under Section 380/307 of IPC and
under Section 27(1) of the Arms Act.
12)
So far as offence under section 380 IPC is concerned
from the evidence it can be analyzed that on the night of
26.01.2018 at about 9 P.M., P.W.- 09 heard some chaos going
on in the barrack and also heard sounds of firing. The P.W.-09
was on sentry duty and he did not go there. It appears from the
testimony of the P.W.-9 (victim) that he did not see the incident
as he did not go there. Moreover, from the statement of all the
PWs, it is crystal clear that there has been no direct eye-witness
of the incident of the alleged stealing of a 100 rupee note by the
accused from the trunk of Sudhanya Debbarma(P.W.-9). So as to
corroborate the version of P.W.2 and P.W.-3 they even failed to
state the denomination of the alleged 100 rupee note. After a
thorough analysis of the evidence on record, it is clearly
observed that the accused is not criminally
responsible for an act of alleged theft.
13)
Section 307 IPC provides that whoever does any act
with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances
that if he by that act caused death he would be guilty of murder,
shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a
term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to
fine, and if hurt is caused to any person by such act, the offender
shall be liable either to imprisonment for life or to such
punishment. Law is also well-settled that the intention to murder
can be inferred from the nature and number of injuries. In this
case, the evidence does not suggest any sort of injury.The
intention to murder can’t be inferred from the trend of the
prosecution evidence. Law is also well settled in catena of
decisions that under Section 307 of I.P.C the intention precedes
the act attributed to the accused. Therefore, the intention is to
be gathered from all circumstances, and not merely from the
consequences, that ensue. The nature of the weapon used, the
manner in which it is used, the motive for the crime, the severity
of the blow, and the part of the body where the injury is inflicted
are some of the factors that may be taken into consideration to
determine the intention. It observed that a person is criminally
responsible for an attempt to commit murder when, with the
intention or knowledge requisition to its commission, he has
done
the
last
proximate
act
necessary
to
constitute
the
completed offence, and when the completion of the offence is
only prevented by some cause, independent of his volition. The
P.W.-5 has categorically deposed in cross-examination that the
accused had ample opportunity to fire before the P.W.-5 jumped
upon him to snatch away his service SLR but the accused did not
fire. From the evidence of P.W.-4, it also appears that P.W.-4 has
admitted during the cross-examination that Rupak Paul lifted his
service SLR simply to frighten others, the accused had no
intention to fire. P.W.-4 also admitted that during the clutches
there was firing from the service SLR of the accused. The P.W.11 deposed that he was reported that the accused triggered
pointing them but the said fact being hearsay in nature does not
stand corroborated by other material witnesses like the P.Ws-4,
5, and that of the P.W.-6 , P.W.-7 , P.W.-9 , P.W.-10 , P.W.-12 ,
.PW.-1, P.W.-2, P.W.-3 and therefore the entire incident confirms
that there has been no target of firing by the accused person and
thereafter
intention
is
absent
in
the
present
case.
The
depositions of all the PWs are amply clear to prove that the
shooting incident took place as the accused fired round towards
the ground amidst the clutches alleging that he stole away 100
rupee note from the trunk of Sudhanya Debbarma ( P.W.09 )
and that it is also clearly evident that there is no iota evidence
showing an intention and target of firing by the accused. There
are marked contradictions in the depositions of the PWs in their
cross-examination by defence and I do not find any reason to
believe their depositions. Herein, in the present case, the
prosecution could not show that the accused had the intention to
kill nor did any act to cause death. Herein the P.W.-8(seizure list
witness), P.W.- 13 ( I.O. not being an eye witness) are only
formal in nature. During the cross examination, the I.O. (P.W.13) also confirmed that the P.W.-3 did not state to him that at
the material time Rakesh Debbarma , Chiranjit Roy , Tinku Das ,
Baju Rai Reang , Rupak Paul along with few others were present
at the barrack or that he could hear the sound of opening the
trunk and noticed that someone was going out of the barrack or
that
he
asked
Chiranjit
to
look
into
the
matter.
Such
contradiction of the P.W.-3(complainant)also appears to be a
material and fatal one striking at the very root of the prosecution
case. At the same time from the opinion of the P.W.-14
(Scientific officer cum chemical examiner), no inference related
to the fingerprint of the accused to ascertain as to the fact
whether the finger of the SLR revolver belongs to the accused or
not and that the accused had operated from the said revolver
could be shown by the prosecution. Depending upon the facts
and circumstances available on record it can be inferred that the
accused aimlessly resorted to fire gunshot that too amidst
clutches and altercations that occurred involving the allegation of
stealing 100 rupees note by the accused. So, it can be inferred
from the evidence that if the accused had the intention to kill,
then he would have resorted to firing gunshot targeting at them
to materialize his intention. As such prosecution has failed to
establish the fact that the accused-Rupak Paul had intentionally
resorted to fire gunshots to kill the victims. Thus from the
evidence on record, I am of the considered view that the
prosecution has miserably failed to prove the case against the
accused Rupak Paul beyond all reasonable doubt for
his
conviction under Section 307 IPC .
14)
As stated in the above discussion, the accrued herein
is also not found guilty of the charges leveled against him under
Section 27(1) of the Arms Act.
15)
Accordingly, this Court is of the view that the
impugned judgment of acquittal dated 15.07.2020 passed in
ST(T-2)02 of 2018 is just and proper and does not need
interference.
16)
Subsequently, this instant appeal is dismissed and
thus disposed of.
Send down the LCRs.
CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review