The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In view of the above discussion, the guilt of the accused herein is not established beyond reasonable doubt. As such, the Judgment and Order dated 01.07.2022, passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur, in case No.ST.34 of 2019 is confirmed and the appeal herein is dismissed.
16. As a sequel stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stands closed. suhanjit
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A NO.22 OF 2022
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the learned P.P. Prosecutor,
High Court of Tripura,
Agartala, West Tripura.
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
Sri Rasaraj Debnath,
S/o. Lt. Jadulal Debnath,
Resident of Powramura, Holakhet,
P.S.- R.K. Pur, Gomati Tripura
……. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. A. Basak, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 04.05.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
This present appeal has been filed under Section
378(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, against the
impugned Judgment & Order of acquittal dated 01.07.2022,
passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur,
in case No.ST.34 of 2019, whereby, the learned Judge has
acquitted the accused-respondent from the charges leveled
against him under Section 302 of IPC.
2.
The brief fact of the case leading to this present
appeal is that a written FIR was lodged by one Samir Debnath
alleging, inter-alia, that on 02.09.2018 at around 11-30 to 1145 p.m., suddenly he heard a hue and cry from the house of
his uncle Rasaraj Debnath i.e the accused-respondent which is
situated adjacent to his house. The informant and his brother
noticed that their grandmother Surabala Debnath was burning
in fire in the courtyard and their uncle Rasaraj Debnath was
pouring kerosene from a drum on her. Then he along with his
brother rushed to the rescue of their grandmother but they
were restrained by the accused-respondent who threatened to
kill them if they went for rescue. They raised alarm to which
the neighbouring people arrived at the spot and the accusedrespondent fled away. It is alleged by the informant that his
uncle, the accused-respondent herein killed the victim by
pouring kerosene oil and setting her ablaze.
3.
On receipt of the written complaint, O/C, R.K.Pur
P.S. Udaipur registered FIR No. 155 of 2018 dated 03.09.2018
under Section 302 of IPC and put S.I. Santanu Debbarma in
charge of the investigation. The I/O on completion of the
investigation submitted charge sheet against the accusedrespondent under Section 302 of IPC.
4.
Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gomati, Udaipur
took cognizance of offence under Section 302 of IPC and
transferred the case to the learned Judicial Magistrate 1st
Class, (Court No.2), Udaipur for disposal according to law.
Offence under Section 302 IPC being exclusively triable by the
Court of Sessions, the same was committed to the said Court
for trial after supplying the copies of incriminating papers to the
accused person under Section 207 Cr.P.C.
5.
Post commitment, the case was taken up for trial.
Charge was framed on 05.01.2020 under Section 302 of IPC
against the accused-respondent. The contents of the charge
were read over and explained to him in Bengali to which he
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
6.
In the course of the trial, the prosecution has
examined as many as 19 witnesses which are reproduced
herein under:PW.1 Sri Samir Debnath, Informant.
PW.2 Sri Arjun Debnath, Relative of deceased.
PW.3 Sri Mithun Debnath ,Neighbour.
PW.4 Sri Shiba Prasad Bhowmik, Neighbour.
PW.5 Md. Abdul Gani, Neighbour.
PW.6 Sri Ratan Debnath, Relative of deceased.
PW.7 Sri Prasenjit Debnath, Neighbour.
PW.8 Smt. Chinu Debnath, Neighbour.
PW.9 Dr. Jothika Debbarma, Medical Officer.
PW.10 ASI Satya Ranjan Debnath, Police personnel.
PW.11 Sri Sahadeb Debnath, Relative of deceased.
PW.12 Smt. Rina Debnath, Relative of deceased.
PW.13 Sri Pulak Bhowmik, Police Constable.
PW.14 WASI Hemlata Debbarma, Police personnel.
PW.15 Sri Jatan Debnath, Scribe.
PW.16 Sri Sridam Debnath, Son of deceased.
PW.17 Sri Abhijit Biswas, Police Constable.
PW.18 Smt. Kajal Rani Debnath, Relative of deceased.
PW.19 SI Santanu Debbarma, Investigating Officer.
7.
The prosecution also proved some documents
(Exbt-1 to Exbt-13). Upon closure of prosecution evidence, the
accused person was examined under section 313(1)(b) of
Cr.P.C. Accused-respondent denied the veracity of all the
prosecution evidence and also declined to lead any oral or
documentary evidence.
8.
The learned Sessions Judge after hearing the
arguments of both sides at length on 06.05.2022 and vide
Judgment dated 01.07.2022 acquitted the present accusedrespondents from the charge leveled under Section 302 of IPC.
9.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied by the said
Judgment and Order of acquittal dated 01.07.2022, the present
appeal has been filed praying to quash and set aside the
impugned Judgment and order of acquittal dated 01.07.2022.
10.
Heard Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. P.P.
appearing for the appellant-State as well as Mr. A. Basak,
learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
11.
the
Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for
appellant-State
submits
that
the
Court
below
while
acquitting the present accused-respondent ought to have
considered the evidence of P.W.-1, Sri Samir Debnath who is
the complainant and the eye witness to the alleged incident.
Learned Addl. P.P. further stated that he along with the brother
P.W.6, Ratan Debnath on hearing hue and cry in the house of
the accused person rushed to the P.O. and found that their
grandmother was burning and lying on the ground. They also
found that his uncle i.e., the accused respondent, and aunt i.e.
P.W.12 were present at the place of occurrence. They came to
learn from P.W.12 that the accused-respondent set fire to their
grandmother. P.W.-1 also stated that the accused respondent
also threatened them not to come to the rescue of the victim,
nor the accused respondent would kill them but the learned
Court below did not consider that evidence. P.W.6, who is the
brother of P.W.1 and the eyewitness to the alleged incident
corroborated P.W.1 i.e. the complainant of this case.
To support his argument, learned Addl. P.P.
pressed into service Para-22, 24, and 26 of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court Judgment reported in 2014(12) SCC 211
titled as State of Rajasthan Vs. Thakur Singh which is
reproduced here-in-under:-
“22. The law, therefore, is quite well settled that
the burden of proving the guilt of an accused is on the prosecution, but
there may be certain facts pertaining to a crime that can be known only
to the accused, or are virtually impossible for the prosecution to prove.
These facts need to be explained by the accused and if he does not do so,
then it is a strong circumstance pointing to his guilt based on those facts.
23. Applying this principle to the facts of the case,
since Dhapu Kunwar died an unnatural death in the room occupied by her
and Thakur Singh, the cause of the unnatural death was known to Thakur
Singh. There is no evidence that anybody else had entered their room or
could have entered their room. Thakur Singh did not set up any case that
he was not in their room or not in the vicinity of their room while the
incident occurred nor did he set up any case that some other person
entered the room and caused the unnatural death of his wife. The facts
relevant to the cause of Dhapu Kunwar’s death being known only to
Thakur Singh, yet he chose not to disclose them or to explain them. The
principle laid down in Section 106 of the Evidence Act is clearly applicable
to the facts of the case and there is, therefore, a very strong presumption
that Dhapu Kunwar was murdered by Thakur Singh.
24. It is not that Thakur Singh was obliged to prove his
innocence or prove that he had not committed any offence. All that was
required of Thakur Singh was to explain the unusual situation, namely, of
the unnatural death of his wife in their room, but he made no attempt to
do this.
26. In our opinion, the High Court has very cursorily
dealt with the evidence on record and has upset a finding of guilt by the
Trial Court in a situation where Thakur Singh failed to give any
explanation whatsoever for the death of his wife by asphyxia in his room.
Moreover, the very fact that all the relatives of Thakur Singh turned
hostile clearly gives room for suspicion and an impression that there is
much more to the case than meets the eye. Even the complainant,
Himmat Singh who squarely blamed Thakur Singh (in the FIR) for the
murder of his wife, turned hostile to the extent of denying his relationship
with Thakur Singh.”
12.
On the other hand, Mr. A. Basak, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent submits the learned Court below
rightly acquitted his client as he is innocent and the same has
been indicated by the learned Court below.
13.
record.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
14.
Learned Addl. P.P. relied upon the evidence of
P.W.-1 and P.W.-6 to establish his case. Here, the informant
(P.W.-1) was accompanied by his brother (P.W.-6) to the scene
of occurrence. Ratan Debnath (P.W.-6) stated that he found his
grand-mother totally burnt and the wife of the accused i.e.,
Rina Debnath (P.W.-12) was crying while the accused herein
was holding a ‘dao’ in his hand and threatening them not to
rescue or come to the aid of his grand-mother. He does not
speak anything about the information from their aunt that the
accused set fire to his mother. His evidence also does not
directly disclose that the accused herein set fire to his mother
after pouring kerosene. Both P.Ws-1 and 6 are the first to
arrive at the scene of the occurrence and both of them did not
see the accused setting fire to their grandmother. Their source
of information it seems is Rina Debnath(P.W.-12), wife of the
accused, and P.W.-12 turned hostile and did not depose against
the accused. The witnesses herein presented their evidence in a
scattered way specially P.Ws.- 1 and 6. None of the witnesses
including the informant stated that they saw the accused
setting fire to the victim by pouring kerosene. In such a
situation the benefit of the doubt must go to the accused.
Further, the motive is not established behind the reason as to
why the accused would set his mother on fire who is aged
about 90 years old. In the fact and circumstances of this case,
the Judgment as referred by the learned Addl. P.P is not
relevant to the fact of the case.
15.
In view of the above discussion, the guilt of the
accused herein is not established beyond reasonable doubt. As
such, the Judgment and Order dated 01.07.2022, passed by
the learned Sessions Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur, in case
No.ST.34 of 2019 is confirmed and the appeal herein is
dismissed.
16.
As a sequel stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review