The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. As we have observed, learned Trial Court also came to the conclusion on the above said grounds that the identification of the driver was not proved and finally acquitted him. According to the seizer list dated 22.07.2017, it appears that the owner of the said vehicle was one Sanjay Roy, but said Sanjay Roy was also not examined as a witness to gather information about the driver of his vehicle. In such a situation, we do not find any sort of impropriety or perversity to disturb the findings arrived at by the learned Trial Court that would warrant interference.
13. Law is fairly settled that an order of acquittal should not be lightly disturbed, even if the appellate court finds that there is some evidence pointing towards the guilt of the accused or even the appellate court finds its view more probable than the view of the trial court after appreciating the evidence. When a person is acquitted by the learned Trial Court, the presumption of his innocence is doubly reinforced. Unless there are compelling reasons for interference with the judgment of acquittal, the appellate court should go a bit slow in disturbing such findings.
14. For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, we find no merit in the instant appeal and accordingly the same is dismissed. Interim application(s), if any, also stand disposed of. (S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J Rohit SUJAY Digitally by SUJAY GHOSH GHOSH 17:09:27 +05'30' (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A. No.23 of 2023
The State of Tripura
Represented by the Ld. Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Tripura,
Agartala, West Tripura
----Appellant
Versus
Sri Puspak Saha @Ayan
S/o- Sri Parimal Saha @ Pranjal,
Resident of Vill- Srinagar Colony,
PS-Karimganj, Assam
---Respondent
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, PP
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. PP
For the de-facto complainant(s)
:
Mr. Pijush Kanti Biswas, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Pujan Biswas, Advocate
Mr. Hrishiraj Nath, Advocate
Mr. S. Debbarma, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
None
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
05.05.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
We have heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP appearing
for the appellant-State and Mr. Pijush Kanti Biswas, learned
senior counsel appearing for the informant of the case.
2.
The appeal arises out of the judgment and order of
acquittal dated 04.02.2023 passed by learned Sessions Judge,
North Tripura, Dharmanagar in Case No. S.T.(Type-1) 06 of
2019, whereby the accused-respondent, Sri Puspak Saha alias
Ayan was acquitted from the charge framed against him under
Sections 279 and 304 (Part-II) of Indian Penal Code (for short,
‘IPC’).
3.
The Case of the prosecution is that on 22.07.2017
(Saturday), at around 05.30 am, one Reba Basu (aged about 63
years) went out for morning walk and at around 06:00 am, when
she
was
returning
to
her
home
situated
at
Jail
Road,
Dharmanagar from Mantala area, one white colour Maruti Alto
vehicle bearing No.TR 02H 0220, proceeding from Dharmanagar
towards Kailasahar going on the wrong side of the road, dashed
her causing severe injuries on her person. After a while, the fire
service personnel arrived there and shifted her to Dharmanagar
Hospital and there the attending doctor declared her dead.
According to the prosecution, the accident occurred due to the
intentional rash and negligent driving of the driver. The police
authority received the FIR on the date of the incident at around
09:57 hrs and registered it as Dharmanagar PS Case No.2017
DMN 047 under Sections 279/304 (Part II) of IPC and upon
completion of the investigation, submitted the charge sheet
against the respondent under aforementioned provisions of law.
4.
Thereafter,
The respondent during the trial, denied the charges.
prosecution
tried
to
establish
the
charges
by
examining 16 witnesses, out of whom PW.3 and PW.5 appeared
to be key witnesses of the case through whom, according to the
prosecution, the identification of the respondent as the driver of
said offending vehicle at the time of alleged accident could be
established. The FIR was lodged by the son of the deceased,
namely, Pralay Raj Modak (PW.10) who was admittedly not an
eyewitness of the occurrence. Except above-said two witnesses,
no other witness of the occurrence was examined in this case.
5.
Both learned PP as well as learned senior counsel Mr.
P.K. Biswas, submit that learned Trial Court has miserably failed
to appreciate the evidence of PW.3 and PW.5 through whom the
complicity of the respondent in the accident as the driver of the
offending vehicle and his rash and negligent driving were
established, but the learned Trial Court failed to give due
credence to the testimonies of the above-said two witnesses,
leading to an improper and erroneous decision. It is also
categorically argued that PW.5 who was present on the road at
the time of accident and had occasion to witness the same,
categorically stated that just after the accident, he saw the driver
to come out from the vehicle and to flee away and then, in court,
he identified him also by face as driver of the said of offending
vehicle at the relevant time of accident. But, despite the same
and having no substantial cross-examination of that witness as to
the above-said part of evidence, Trial Court acquitted the
respondent. Learned PP also submits that learned Trial Court
erroneously discarded the entire evidence of PW.3 only on the
ground that he had failed to identify the respondent in the court,
though he was also an eyewitness to the occurrence and
narrated the entire incident without being shaken during his
cross-examination.
6.
In view of the submission of both the learned counsel
and also as discussed above, PW.3 and PW.5 are the most vital
witnesses of the case and hence their testimonies are required to
be considered first. PW.3, Sri Bikash Chakraborty, stated that on
22.07.2017 at around 05:00/5:30 a.m. while he was taking
preparation to go for morning walk, he heard a loud sound
outside his house, and also uproar of people on the road.
Immediately he rushed to the spot and noticed that one Maruti
Alto vehicle had collided with a truck on right-hand side of
Dharmanagar-Kailashahar road and in between the said truck
and Maruti Alto vehicle, one injured lady was lying with severe
bleeding on her person. At that time she was alive. He further
stated that he found driver of the Alto vehicle coming out of the
vehicle and fleeing towards the Mantala Market area. Thereafter,
all of them raised alarm to detain said person and accordingly he
was detained and he came to know that the name of driver was
Ayan Saha of Dewanpassa. According to him, the truck was lying
in its stationary condition for a long time at a distance of 3/4 feet
from the road. He failed to identify the said driver in the court
despite the respondent being present there.
7.
PW.5, Debashish Acharjee, also similarly stated that
on the relevant date and time, he came out from his house for a
morning walk and suddenly heard a loud sound on DharmanagarKailashahar road and found one Maruti Alto car had collided with
a truck which was lying in stationary condition for a long time. He
also stated that he saw the driver of the Alto vehicle fleeing from
the spot and some other morning walkers present there also
noticed the said incident and the driver fleeing. He, along with
others rushed to the spot and found that in between the said
truck and Maruti Alto vehicle, a woman was lying almost in dying
condition, and meanwhile, fire service personnel arrived there
and shifted her to Dharmanagar District Hospital. He also stated
that the driver was detained by some of the said morning
walkers at that point of time. He identified the respondent in the
court by face. In his cross-examination, it revealed that in his
previous statement made before the investigating officer, he only
stated that he found one person coming out from the vehicle
after the accident, and said person was detained by local people
but he did not specifically indicate him as driver of the vehicle.
However, he also stated voluntarily that except said person, no
one else was present in the vehicle at that time, and therefore,
he had no doubt that the said person was the driver of the
vehicle.
8.
PW 1, Debabrata Das, is the witness of the inquest
and PW.2 to Chitta Ranjan Goswami is one of the relatives of the
deceased who heard about the incident and was not present at
the scene of accident at the relevant time. PW.4, Raju Paul is a
witness of seizer of documents of vehicle, and PW.6, Dr.
Subhankar Nath is Scientific Officer of State Forensic Science
Laboratory who, after examining the blood samples collected
from the said Alto vehicle and from the ground and also the
specimen
blood
sample
of
the
deceased,
conducted
DNA
examination and finally found that all the said blood samples
belonged to the deceased. PW.7 Mohan Singha, is a Fireman who
shifted the deceased to the hospital, and PW.8, Constable Sri
Suman Sutradhar was the person who handed over the seized
blood samples in a parcel to the State Forensic Science
Laboratory, Narsinghgarh. PW.10, Sri Pralay Raj Modak (son of
the deceased) was the informant of the case who did not see the
accident, and PW.11, Sri Rajib Lohar is the scribe of the FIR.
PW.16, Dr. Debashis Debroy, conducted autopsy on the dead
body of the deceased, and found the laceration injuries over the
forehead, upper left abdomen, upper right abdomen, left lower
leg and bruises on the left upper abdomen, right upper abdomen,
multiple scratch marks in the left breast and fracture of ribs
along with rupture of liver of the deceased. According to him, the
cause of death was hypovolemic shock due to multiple fractures
and injury to the intra abdominal organ (liver) caused by blunt
trauma. PW.9, Sri Manik Kr. Barua, the recording officer who
registered the FIR and PW.12, PW.13 and PW.14 were the
respective investigating officers of the case.
9.
Jawhar
We have also taken note of the evidence of PW.15, Sri
Reang,
the
Motor
Vehicle
Inspector
who
upon
examination of the said Alto car on 07.09.2017, opined that
there was no mechanical disorder found in the vehicle and the
accident did not occur due to any such mechanical disorder. He
found wind screen, bonnet, front left side body and head light of
the left side of said vehicle in damage condition. Though, in his
evidence, he stated that during examination the brake system of
the vehicle was found not in working condition, but in his vehicle
inspection report he mentioned the condition of brake system to
be in working condition. Therefore, it appears that his evidence
and his report appear to be self-contradictory.
10.
We have also examined the case diary of the police
investigation, as placed by learned PP, and also meticulously
gone through the materials placed in record during trial. We have
no hesitation in noting that we found some flaws in the
investigation touching very foundational propriety of the case
relating to the identification of the present respondent. According
to PW.3 and PW.5, both of them found driver of the Alto vehicle
fleeing away from the spot, but none of them claimed to have
detained the said driver. According to them, some other morning
walkers detained said driver, but none of those persons who had
detained him was examined in this case. PW.3, despite claiming
that he was present on the spot and saw the driver, has failed to
identify him in the court. As per the Arrest Memo, the respondent
was arrested at Mantala on that day at around 12:15 hrs on that
day whereas according to PW.3 and PW.5, the driver was
detained just after the accident, i.e., around 06:00 am in the
morning on that day. Therefore, a serious doubt arises regarding
his whereabouts for about 6 hours before his arrest, if he was at
all detained by the locals immediately after the accident.
11.
Though the police authority mentioned some injuries
of the respondent in the Arrest Memo, this itself does not
conclusively establish the presence of the respondent at the time
of accident on the spot as the driver of the vehicle. We are also
surprised
to
see
that
the
police
authority
proceeded
for
investigation only after the FIR was registered at 09:57 hrs, i.e.,
around 10:00 am, though fire service people shifted said injured
woman to the hospital at around 6:00 am. When both fire service
authority and the hospital authority had knowledge of such
accident, it is hard to believe that no information was given by
them to the police about the said accident. Therefore, the
initiative led from the side of police for commencing the
investigation and arrest of the respondent at much later time
from the time of commencement of such investigation, and that
too from a separate place cast doubt on the veracity of the
prosecution’s story about the identification of the respondent as
driver of the vehicle. It is also quite surprising that though driver
of the offending vehicle was allegedly detained just after the
accident, but the informant did not mention the said fact in his
FIR lodged about 03 hours after the accident and did not mention
the name of the respondent in the FIR.
12.
As we have observed, learned Trial Court also came to
the conclusion on the above said grounds that the identification
of the driver was not proved and finally acquitted him. According
to the seizer list dated 22.07.2017, it appears that the owner of
the said vehicle was one Sanjay Roy, but said Sanjay Roy was
also not examined as a witness to gather information about the
driver of his vehicle. In such a situation, we do not find any sort
of impropriety or perversity to disturb the findings arrived at by
the learned Trial Court that would warrant interference.
13.
Law is fairly settled that an order of acquittal should
not be lightly disturbed, even if the appellate court finds that
there is some evidence pointing towards the guilt of the accused
or even the appellate court finds its view more probable than the
view of the trial court after appreciating the evidence. When a
person is acquitted by the learned Trial Court, the presumption of
his innocence is doubly reinforced. Unless there are compelling
reasons for interference with the judgment of acquittal, the
appellate court should go a bit slow in disturbing such findings.
14.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above,
we find no merit in the instant appeal and accordingly the same
is dismissed.
Interim application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Rohit
signed
SUJAY Digitally
by SUJAY GHOSH
Date: 2025.05.14
GHOSH 17:09:27 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review