Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A NO.17 OF 2021
The State of Tripura
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
Sri Nayan Das
S/o- Lt. Sukhen Ch. Das,
Of Bhati Abhoy Nagar, Agartala,
P.S.- West Tripura, District-West Tripura.
……. Respondent(s)
CRL.A NO.18 OF 2021
The State of Tripura
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
Sri Rajat Acharjee
S/o Lt. Raimohan Acharjee,
Of Hospital Road, Udaipur,
P.S. R.K. Pur, District-Gomati Tripura
……. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. R. Datta, P.P.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sarkar, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. H. Debnath, Advocate.
Ms. S. Banik, Advocate.
Ms. U. Chanda, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 13.03.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 16/03/2023
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Both these appeals are heard and taken up
together for disposal since they arise from common Judgment
and Order and similar question of facts and law are involved.
2.
The brief fact of the case is that the respondent of
Crl.A. No.18 of 2021, Sri Rajat Acharjee on 21.09.2007 took
over the charge of Rajnagar Government Food Godown as
Junior Store-Keeper from his predecessor i.e. the respondent
of Crl.A. No.17 of 2021 Sri Nayan Das, in presence of and to
the
satisfaction
of
the
then
Additional
Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Belonia, Sri Hiralal Debbarma, who certified that
there was no discrepancy or shortage of any goods, as per the
charge-list. But, subsequently during the period of Rajat
Acharjee, Sri. Ranjit Kr. Das (Food Inspector) inspected the
Go-down and reported him to arrange for a special verification
as he suspected discrepancies and a shortage of a huge
quantity of rice. In reply to this anxiety, the informant i.e. SubDivisional Magistrate, Belonia directed the then DCM, Rajnagar,
Sri Bhaswar Bhattacharjee to make verification about the
matter. Sri Bhattacharjee then submitted a report that a huge
quantity of rice, related to several Government schemes is
missing from the Go-down which was astonishing, and also
requested the informant to arrange for physical verification of
the concerned records and registers related to the last 02
(two) years. Owing to the above report, the informant stated
to have directed the then BDO, Rajnagar, Sri Subhashish
Bandopadhyay to cause another verification of the matter who
then submitted a report afresh stating that a total quantity of
1,61,306.805 kgs of rice was found short from the Go-down for
the period when Rajat Acharjee was In- Charge. The informant
supplied the last report to the Directorate, Food, Civil Supplies
& Consumer Affairs, Government of Tripura, and based on the
said report, the Director, Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer
Affairs, Government of Tripura issued one communication to
place
the
respondent-Rajat
Acharjee
under
immediate
suspension and directed another official to lodge an FIR against
him for alleged misappropriation of Government property.
Based on the report submitted by BDO, Rajnagar, it was
apparent that the respondent-Rajat Acharjee was involved in
the
misappropriation
of
Government
rice
weighing
1,61,306.805 Kgs and thus FIR was lodged before O.C. P.R.
Bari P.S. for legal action. Though initially, the FIR was lodged
against the respondent- Rajat Acharjee, but investigation of
the matter was done by the local Police of P.R. Bari P.S. and
subsequently by the CID, Agartala submitted a report (chargesheet) against both the respondents herein namely Rajat
Acharjee and Nayan Das under Section 409 of the Indian Penal
Code.
3.
Cognizance of this case was taken under Section
409 read with Section 34 of IPC. Learned trial Court after
observing all formalities framed charge against the accused
persons under Section 409 of IPC. To prove the case before
the learned trial Court as many as 39 (thirty-nine) witnesses
were examined by the prosecution and they are; Sri Bhajan
Kr. Saha as PW-1, Sri Jyoti Mohan Majumder as PW-2, Smt.
Manju Saha as PW-3, Sri Bibhu Das as PW-4, Sri Ranjit Kr.
Das as PW-5, Sri Manik Ch. Saha as PW-6, Sri Jitendra Shil as
PW-7, Sri Ranjit Kar (Informant) as PW-8, Sri Subhasish
Bandopadhyaya as PW-9, Sri Biplab Paul as PW-10, Sri Hiralal
Debbarma as PW-11, Sri Babul Ch. Saha as PW-12, Sri Manik
Lal Das as PW-13, Sri Amar Nag as PW-14, Sri Sangram Saha
as PW- 15, Sri Bhaswar Bhattacharjee as PW-16, Sri Satyajit
Parial as PW-17, Sri Anjan Kr. Dhar as PW-18, Sri Jitendra Ch.
Nama as PW-19, Sri Haripada Das as PW-20, Sri Sudhir Roy
as PW-21, Sri Apu Basak as PW-22, Sri Rabindra Kr. Das as
PW-23, Smt Padmini Gupta as PW-24, Sri Kajal Sinha as
PW25, Sri Subal Ch. Das as PW-26, Sri Lalit Debbarma as PW-
27, S.I. Swapan Sarkar (R.O.) as PW-28, Sri Kumbharai
Reang as PW-29, Sri Ranjan Deb as PW-30, Sri Subrata Kr.
Das as PW-31, Sri Nilmoni Debbarma as PW-32, Sri Siba
Prasad Das as PW-33, Sri Anil Rudra Paul as PW-34, S.I. Rajib
Debnath (I.O.) as PW-35, DSP, Babul Das (I.O.) as PW-36,
Inspector Anup Kr. Das (I.O.) as PW-37, S.I. Krishnadhan Das
(I.O.) as PW-38 and SDPO Sri Ratan Das (I.O.) as PW-39.
Based on that evidence, the learned trial Court came to the
conclusion that the accused persons are guilty of the offence
punishable under Section 409 of IPC, and, accordingly, the
learned Trial Court sentenced them to suffer R.I. for 3(three)
years and also to pay a fine of Rs.25,000/-, in default to
suffer S.I. for another 5(five) months.
4.
Thereafter, being aggrieved and dissatisfied with
the order of conviction and sentence, passed by the learned
Trial Court, the respondent-Nayan Das preferred an appeal
vide Crl. Appeal No.15 of 2018 and respondent Rajat Acharjee
preferred appeal vide Crl. Appeal No.12 of 2018 before the
learned Sessions Judge, South Tripura, Belonia. After hearing
the parties and also considering the materials and documents
on record, the learned First Appellate Court passed a common
Judgement dated 05.02.2021 thereby setting aside the order
of conviction & sentence by the learned Trial Court in Case
No.G.R.418 of 2008 on 28.05.2018. Accordingly acquitted
both the respondents herein from the charge framed against
them under Section 409 of IPC.
5.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the
order of acquittal passed by the learned Session Judge, South
Tripura Belonia in Crl. Appeal No.12 of 2018 and Crl. Appeal
No.15 of 2018, the appellant-State has preferred these instant
appeals praying for setting aside the impugned Judgment and
order of acquittal dated 05.02.2021 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in Criminal Appeal
No.15 of 2018 and Criminal Appeal No.12 of 2018 arising out
of order of conviction and Sentenced dated 28.05.2018
passed by learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, South Tripura,
Belonia in G.R. No.418 of 2008 whereby the respondent and
another were convicted under Section 409 of IPC and
sentenced them to suffer R.I. for three years and also to pay
a fine of Rs.25,000/- in default, to suffer SI for another five
years.
6.
Heard Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the
appellant-State and Mr. S. Sarkar, learned Sr. counsel assisted
by Ms. S. Banik, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
of Crl.A. No.17 of 2021 i.e. Sri Nayan Das and Mr. H. Debnath,
learned counsel assisted by Ms. U. Chanda, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent of Crl.A No.18 of 2021 i.e. Sri
Rajat Acharjee.
7.
The learned P.P. appearing for the petitioner-
State has pointed out that Exbt-M.O.9 and Exbt-M.O.10 series
clearly established that there was a misappropriation and
defalcation of public rice/food grain and learned Trial Court
after proper appreciation of all the evidence convicted the
respondents herein but the learned First Appellate Court failed
to appreciate so. Learned P.P. also submitted that the main
ingredient
of
Section
of
IPC
is
entrustment
and
misappropriation; here the respondents never denied that they
were not entrusted. Nowhere they have stated that from
01.04.2007 to 05.11.2007 they were not entrusted with their
duties, rather they admitted so. Learned P.P., relied upon the
evidence of P.W.8, the informant, P.W.-5 the Food Inspector,
P.W.9, BDO Rajangar, P.W.13, Dy. Director Food South,
P.W.16, DCM Rajnagar.
Learned P.P. also relied upon the
evidence on P.W.-25, P.W-26, P.W.-27, and P.W.-34 who were
the Audit team members. Learned P.P. further submitted that
the Judgment and Order as passed by the Lower Appellate
Court is perverse wherein it has been observed that there are
no specific exhibits i.e. M.O.9 series and 10 series were
marked. His further observation was as to how in absence of
any specific exhibits, the Trial Court has relied on the exhibited
documents. Stating thus, he contended that the order passed
by the Trial Court is just and proper and the Lower Appellate
Court has erred in not appreciating the Trial Court Judgment
and prayed to set aside the Judgment and Order as passed by
the Lower Appellate Court and allow this present appeals.
8.
Mr. Subrata Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner of Crl.A. No.17 of 2021 i.e. Sri Nayan Das
contended that the order of the Lower Appellate Court is not
perverse and this scope of revision is very limited and placed
reliance upon Paras-12 to 21 of the Apex Court Judgment
reported in (2010) 9 SCC 189 titled as Babu Vs. The State
of Kerala which is reproduced herein-below:“12. This court time and again has laid down the
guidelines for the High Court to interfere with the judgment and order
of acquittal passed by the Trial Court.
The appellate court should not ordinarily set aside a judgment of
acquittal in a case where two views are possible, though the view of
the appellate court may be more, the probable one. While dealing with
a judgment of acquittal, the appellate court has to consider the entire
evidence on record, so as to arrive at a finding as to whether the views
of the trial Court were perverse or otherwise unsustainable. The
appellate court is entitled to consider whether in arriving at a finding of
fact, the trial Court had failed to take into consideration admissible
evidence and/or had taken into consideration the evidence brought on
record contrary to law. Similarly, wrong placing of burden of proof may
also be a subject matter of scrutiny by the appellate court. (Vide Balak
Ram v. State of U.P. AIR 1974 SC 2165; Shambhoo Missir & Anr. v.
State of Bihar AIR 1991 SC 315; Shailendra Pratap & Anr. v. State of
U.P. AIR 2003 SC 1104; Narendra Singh v. State of M.P. (2004) 10
SCC 699; Budh Singh & Ors. v. State of U.P. AIR 2006 SC 2500; State
of U.P. v. Ramveer Singh AIR 2007 SC 3075; S. Rama Krishna v. S.
Rami Reddy (D) by his LRs. & Ors. AIR 2008 SC 2066; Arulvelu & Anr.
Vs. State (2009) 10 SCC 206; Perla Somasekhara Reddy & Ors. v.
State of A.P. (2009) 16 SCC 98; and Ram Singh alias Chhaju v. State
of Himachal Pradesh (2010) 2 SCC 445).
13. In Sheo Swarup and Ors. v. King Emperor AIR 1934 PC 227, the
Privy Council observed as under:
"...the High Court should and will always give proper weight and
consideration to such matters as (1) the views of the trial Judge as to
the credibility of the witnesses, (2) the presumption of innocence in
favour of the accused, a presumption certainly not weakened by the
fact that he has been acquitted at his trial, (3) the right of the accused
to the benefit of any doubt, and (4) the slowness of an appellate court
in disturbing a finding of fact arrived at by a Judge who had the
advantage of seeing the witnesses...."
14. The aforesaid principle of law has consistently been followed by
this Court. (See: Tulsiram Kanu v. The State AIR 1954 SC 1; Balbir
Singh v. State of Punjab AIR 1957 SC 216; M.G. Agarwal v. State of
Maharashtra AIR 1963 SC 200; Khedu Mohton & Ors. v. State of
Bihar AIR 1970 SC 66; Sambasivan and Ors. v. State of Kerala (1998)
5 SCC 412; Bhagwan Singh and Ors. v. State of M.P. (2002) 4 SCC 85;
and State of Goa v. Sanjay Thakran and Anr. (2007) 3 SCC
755).
15. In Chandrappa and Ors. v. State of Karnataka (2007) 4 SCC 415,
this Court reiterated the legal position as under:
"(1) An appellate court has full power to review, re-appreciate and
reconsider the evidence upon which the order of acquittal is founded.
(2) The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 puts no limitation, restriction
or condition on exercise of such power and an appellate court on the
evidence before it may reach its own conclusion, both on questions of
fact and of law.
(3) Various expressions, such as, "substantial and compelling reasons",
"good and sufficient grounds", "very strong circumstances", "distorted
conclusions", "glaring mistakes", etc. are not intended to curtail
extensive powers of an appellate court in an appeal against acquittal.
Such phraseologies are more in the nature of "flourishes of language"
to emphasise the reluctance of an appellate court to interfere with
acquittal than to curtail the power of the court to review the evidence
and to come to its own conclusion.
(4) An appellate court, however, must bear in mind that in case of
acquittal, there is double presumption in favour of the accused. Firstly,
the presumption of innocence is available to him under the
fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that every person shall
be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved guilty by a competent
court of law. Secondly, the accused having secured his acquittal, the
presumption of his innocence is further reinforced, reaffirmed and
strengthened by the trial court.
(5) If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis of the
evidence on record, the appellate court should not disturb the finding
of acquittal recorded by the trial court."
16. In Ghurey Lal v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2008) 10 SCC 450, this
Court re-iterated the said view, observing that the appellate court in
dealing with the cases in which the trial courts have acquitted the
accused, should bear in mind that the trial court's acquittal bolsters the
presumption that he is innocent. The appellate court must give due
weight andconsideration to the decision of the trial court as the trial
court had the distinct advantage of watching the demeanour of the
witnesses, and was in a better position to evaluate the credibility of the
witnesses.
17. In State of Rajasthan v. Naresh @ Ram Naresh (2009) 9 SCC 368,
the Court again examined the earlier judgments of this Court and laid
down that an "order of acquittal should not be lightly interfered with
even if the court believes that there is some evidence pointing out the
finger towards the accused."
18. In State of Uttar Pradesh v. Banne alias Baijnath & Ors. (2009) 4
SCC 271, this Court gave certain illustrative circumstances in which the
Court would be justified in interfering with a judgment of acquittal by
the High Court. The circumstances includes:
i) The High Court's decision is based on totally erroneous view of law
by ignoring the settled legal position;
ii) The High Court's conclusions are contrary to evidence and
documents on record;
iii) The entire approach of the High Court in dealing with the evidence
was patently illegal leading to grave miscarriage of justice;
iv) The High Court's judgment is manifestly unjust and unreasonable
based on erroneous law and facts on the record of the case;
v) This Court must always give proper weight and consideration to the
findings of the High Court;
vi) This Court would be extremely reluctant in interfering with a case
when both the Sessions Court and the High Court have recorded an
order of acquittal.
14. A similar view has been reiterated by this Court in Dhanapal v.
State by Public Prosecutor, Madras (2009) 10 SCC 401.
19. Thus, the law on the issue can be summarised to the effect that in
exceptional cases where there are compelling circumstances, and the
judgment under appeal is found to be perverse, the appellate court can
interfere with the order of acquittal. The appellate court should bear in
mind the presumption of innocence of the accused and further that the
trial Court's acquittal bolsters the presumption of his innocence.
Interference in a routine manner where the other view is possible
should be avoided, unless there are good reasons for interference.
20. The findings of fact recorded by a court can be held to be perverse
if the findings have been arrived at by ignoring or excluding relevant
material or by taking into consideration irrelevant/inadmissible
material. The finding may also be said to be perverse if it is "against
the weight of evidence", or if the finding so outrageously defies logic as
to suffer from the vice of irrationality. (Vide Rajinder Kumar Kindra v.
Delhi Administration AIR 1984 SC 1805; H.B. Gandhi & Ors. v. Gopi
Nath & Sons 1992 supp. (2) SCC 312; Triveni Rubber & Plastics v.
Collector of Central Excise, Cochin AIR 1994 SC 1341; Gaya Din (D)
thr. Lrs. & Ors. v. Hanuman Prasad (D) thr. Lrs. & Ors. AIR 2001 SC
386; Aruvelu & Anr. (Supra); and Gamini Bala Koteswara Rao & Ors. v.
State of Andhra Pradesh thr. Secretary (2009) 10 SCC 636).
21. In Kuldeep Singh v. Commissioner of Police & Ors. AIR 1999 SC
677, this Court held that if a decision is arrived at on the basis of no
evidence or thoroughly unreliable evidence and no reasonable person
would act upon it, the order would be perverse. But if there is some
evidence on record which is acceptable and which could be relied upon,
the conclusions would not be treated as perverse and the findings
would not be interfered with..
Mr. Sarkar, learned Sr. counsel further submitted
that there is no specific finding of the Court below with regard
to the shortage of rice and the auditors were not trained
persons.
9.
While adopting the arguments of Mr. Sarkar,
learned Sr. counsel, Mr. H. Debnath, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent of CRL.A. No.18 of 2021 has submitted that
Nayan Das was in charge of the Rajnagar Government Food
Go-Downs from 01.04.2007 to 21.09.2007 and on 21.09.2007
Rajat Acharjee took over the charge of Rajnagar Government
Food Go-Downs and carried on the charge upto 05.11.2007.
During the tenure, no proper verification on the stocks was
done and since the same is not decided, fixing of accountability
on the accused persons is unjust, and prayed to dismiss the
petition and uphold the order of acquittal of the Lower
Appellate Court.
10.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence
on record.
11.
Prima facie it is to be seen that the shortage
of more than 1,61,306.455 Kgs of rice is not a small issue and
definitely it needs a zoomed view of the prosecution and the
Courts in the interest of the citizens since the food grains are
set to have been misappropriated from the Food Go-downs of
the State and the accused persons were the in-charge of the
said
Food-Godowns.
It
cannot
be said that
more than
1,61,306.455 Kgs of rice is a small quantity and during the
transit or loading and unloading or for the lack of any
verification there was shortage of such quantity of rice. The
respondents being the in-charge and the responsible officers
are supposed to be diligent in their duties and while giving and
taking over charge during their tenure they are supposed to
take all precautions with regard to stock verification and entry
into the relevant registers. Accordingly, this Court feels that
the respondents failed in their duties and it lead to the
shortage of rice/food grains.
12.
In this background, FIR was lodged before the
O.C. P.R. Bari P.S. investigation was done by the local police of
P.R. Bari P.S. and subsequently by the CID, Agartala and
charge-sheet was submitted against both the respondents
under Section 409 of IPC. Learned Trial Court after observing
all
formalities
framed
the
following
charge
against
the
respondents:“ (i) Whether the accused Rajat Acharjee, for the period
from 21.09.2007 to 05.11.2007 at Rajnagar Govt. Food Go-down, being
entrusted with Govt. Property, to wit 1,61,306.455 Kgs. Of Govt. rice under
various Schemes, in the capacity of the Junior Store-Keeper, a public
servent, committed criminal breach of trust with respect to such property
and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 409 of the
Indian Penal Code?
(ii) Whether the accused Nayan Das during the period
from 01.04.2007 to 21.09.2007 Rajnagar Govt. Food Go-down, being
entrusted with Govt. Property, to wit 19,376,230 Kgs of Govt. Rice under
various Schemes, in the capacity of the Store-in-charge, public servant,
committed criminal breach of trust with respect of such property and
thereby committed an offence punishable U/S 409 of the Indian Penal
Code.”
The learned Trial Court, after examining the witnesses
and perusing the evidence, particularly based upon Exbt-M.O.9
and Exbt-M.O.10 found the accused herein guilty of offence
punishable under Section 409 of IPC and sentenced them as
mentioned herein above.
13.
The respondents-accused persons preferred an
appeal before the Lower Appellate Court and filed Crl. Appeal
No.15 of 2018 and Crl. Appeal No.12 of 2018 respectively. The
Lower Appellate Court has pointed out certain infirmities
committed by the Trial Court and set aside the sentence and
allowed the appeals and acquitted the accused persons.
14.
According to this Court, the Appellate Court when
came to a conclusion that the Trial Court has committed
certain errors while appreciating the evidence and referring to
the exhibits, it ought to have remanded back the matter to the
Trial Court to re-appreciate the evidence and examine the
exhibits and then pass an order accordingly. But instead, the
Lower Appellate Court has given the benefit of doubt while
pointing out the errors said to have been committed by the
Trial Court and has acquitted the accused persons by allowing
the appeals. It is pertinent to note here that the subject matter
involved here is not a crime against an individual but a crime
against society at large. When more than 1,61,306.455 Kgs of
rice/food grains has been misappropriated and a case has been
registered, it becomes the prima facie duty of the Court in the
interest of the public to go into the ground root level of the
matter and to pass a reasoned order on the strength of the
record.
15.
Since the Lower Appellate Court has found certain
errors in the Trial Court Judgments with regard to appreciating
the
depositions/evidence
and
the
documents
marked
as
exhibits, the Lower Appellate Court ought to have remanded
the matter back to the Trial Court for re-appreciating the
evidence and passing a reasoned order on the involvement of
the accused in the alleged crime. Hence accordingly, the
Judgment and Order of both the Trial Court dated 28.05.2018
and the Lower Appellate Court dated 05.02.2022 is set aside
and the matter is remanded back to the Trial Court for reappreciating the evidence of the prosecution witnesses and
also the documents marked and decide the matter. The Trial
Court is also at liberty to mark any further documents as
exhibits and also lead further evidence.
16.
In light of the above observation and direction,
these present appeals stands disposed of. Stay order if any
stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any stands closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review