Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A. No.22 of 2025
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary,
Home Department, Government of Tripura
…. Appellant.
Versus
Sahajahan Miah,
S/O Lt. Mantaj Miah Kamalnagar,
PS- Sonamura, District- Sepahijala District
For Appellant(s)
:
…….Respondent.
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Subrata Sarkar, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Ayesha Saha Hirawat, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
04.11.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
18.11.2025
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Leave granted.
2.
This appeal is preferred under Section 378(1)(b) of
Cr.P.C. challenging the judgment and order of acquittal dated
28.02.2024 delivered by Learned
Special Judge (NDPS),
Sepahijala
connection
Tripura,
Sonamura
in
with
Case
No.Special (NDPS) 52 of 2019.
3.
Heard Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta appearing on
behalf of the appellant and also heard Learned Senior Counsel,
Mr. Subrata Sarkar assisted by Learned Counsel, Ms. Ayesha
Saha Hirawat appearing on behalf of the respondent accused.
4.
At the time of hearing, Learned P.P., Mr. R. Datta
drawn the attention of the Court that on the basis of a secret
information that some contraband item was stored in the
residence
of
accused
Sahajahan
Miah.
Accordingly,
the
informant SI Srikanta Chakraborty of Sonamura PS along with
others conducted raid in the house of respondent accused and
recovered 338 (Three Hundred Thirty Eight) kgs of dry ganja
from the dwelling house of respondent accused. Regarding
possession, the accused could not show any document. Hence,
search and seizure was made and the suo moto complaint was
laid to O/C, Sonamura PS and accordingly the case was
registered
and
on
completion
of
investigation
the
I/O
submitted charge-sheet against the respondent accused.
5.
Before the Learned Trial Court, the prosecution to
substantiate the charge has adduced in total 9 (nine) numbers
of witnesses and the prosecution also relied upon some
documents which were marked as Exhibits and on conclusion of
trial, Learned Trial Court acquitted the accused on the ground
that
Section
of
NDPS
Act
was
not
complied
with.
Furthermore, no independent witnesses supported the case of
the prosecution and the prosecution also has failed to prove
the
chain
of
possession
possession of the accused.
of
contraband
items
from
the
6.
Learned P.P. further referred Annexure-2 and
Annexure-3 i.e. the extract copy of Sonamura PS, G.D. Entry
No.11/12 dated 25.10.2018 and also the communication made
by SI Srikanta Chakraborty on 25.10.2018 to SDPO, Sonamura
and
referring
those
documents
Learned
P.P.
drawn
the
attention of the Court that those documents were very much
relevant for decision of this case and those documents were
available with the record. But in course of trial, the counsel for
the prosecution failed to produce those documents for marking
as Exhibits. Even the Learned Trial Court also did not consider
the same at the time of appreciating the evidence on record for
which
the
Learned
Trial
Court
came
to
the
erroneous
observation that the case suffered from non-compliance of the
provision
of
Section
of NDPS
Act
and
furthermore,
considering the other materials on record, Learned P.P. further
submitted that even if it is found that no independent public
witness is supporting the case of the prosecution, in that case
also there is scope for convicting accused based upon the other
materials on record which the Learned Trial Court has failed to
consider/appreciate at the time of delivery of judgment.
Learned P.P. in support of his contention also relied
upon one judgment dated 30.07.2025 delivered by this
Division Bench of this High Court in Crl. A. No.04 of 2025 and
submitted that this present case is squarely covered by the
said judgment and urged for setting aside the judgment of the
Learned Trial Court and to remand back the matter to the
Learned Trial Court for fresh trial of the accused.
7.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S.
Sarkar assisted by Learned Counsel, Ms. A. Saha Hirawat
appearing on behalf of the respondent accused strongly
opposed the submission made by Learned P.P. and drawn the
attention of this Court that considering the evidence on record
Learned Trial Court rightly and reasonably has passed the
order of acquittal and there is no scope to interfere with the
findings of the Learned Trial Court and it was further submitted
by Learned Senior Counsel that there was total non-compliance
of the provision of Section 42 of NDPS Act by the prosecution
before the Learned Trial Court. So, at this stage, there is no
scope to fill up the gaps which emerged from the record of the
Learned Trial Court by the prosecution and urged for dismissal
of this appeal. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that,
if at this stage the matter is remanded back to the Learned
Trial Court, in that case the respondent accused would be
seriously prejudiced.
8.
We have heard both the sides at length and
perused the record of the Learned Trial Court including the
judgment delivered by the Learned Trial Court. It is the
admitted position that on the basis of the suo moto complaint
laid by SI Srikanta Chakraborty, O/C, Sonamura PS registered
the case. Now, if we go through the said FIR which was marked
as Exhibit-5, it appears that after receipt of the information
regarding availability and storage of contraband items in the
residence of Sahajahan Miah, the matter was entered in PS GD
Entry No.11 dated 25.10.2018 and then immediately the
information was conveyed to the higher authority for raid. In
course of investigation the I/O procured the extract copy of the
said GD Entry Nos.11/12/24 and also the I/O forwarded the
information in this regard addressing to SP, Sepahijala District.
But those documents were not proved as exhibits before the
Learned Trial Court by the prosecution. Even there was no
effort from the side of the Court also to consider those
documents. In this regard we would like to refer herein below
the relevant provision of Section 42 of NDPS Act:“42. Power of entry, search, seizure and
arrest without warrant or authorisation.—(1) Any
such officer (being an officer superior in rank to a
peon, sepoy or constable) of the departments of
central
excise,
narcotics,
customs,
revenue
intelligence or any other department of the Central
Government including para-military forces or
armed forces as is empowered in this behalf by
general
or
special
order
by
the
Central
Government, or any such officer (being an officer
superior in rank to a peon, sepoy or constable) of
the revenue, drugs control, excise, police or any
other department of a State Government as is
empowered in this behalf by general or special
order of the State Government, if he has reason to
believe from personal knowledge or information
given by any person and taken down in writing
that any narcotic drug, or psychotropic substance,
or controlled substance in respect of which an
offence punishable under this Act has been
committed or any document or other article which
may furnish evidence of the commission of such
offence or any illegally acquired property or any
document or other article which may furnish
evidence of holding any illegally acquired property
which is liable for seizure or freezing or forfeiture
under Chapter V-A of this Act is kept or concealed
in any building, conveyance or enclosed place,
may, between sunrise and sunset,—
(a)
(b)
enter into and search any such
building, conveyance or place;
in case of resistance, break open any
door and remove any obstacle to such
entry;
(c)
seize such drug or substance and all
materials used in the manufacture
thereof and any other article and any
animal or conveyance which he has
reason to believe to be liable to
confiscation under this Act and any
document or other article which he has
reason to believe may furnish evidence
of the commission of any offence
punishable under this Act or furnish
evidence
of
holding
any
illegally
acquired property which is liable for
seizure or freezing or forfeiture under
Chapter V-A of this Act; and
(d) detain and search, and, if he thinks
proper, arrest any person whom he has
reason to believe to have committed
any offence punishable under this Act:
Provided that in respect of holder of a licence
for manufacture of manufactured drugs or
psychotropic substances or controlled substances
granted under this Act or any rule or order made
thereunder, such power shall be exercised by an
officer not below the rank of sub-inspector:
Provided further that if such officer has
reason to believe that a search warrant or
authorisation cannot be obtained without affording
opportunity for the concealment of evidence or
facility for the escape of an offender, he may enter
and search such building, conveyance or enclosed
place at any time between sunset and sunrise after
recording the grounds of his belief.
(2) Where an officer takes down any
information in writing under sub-section (1) or
records grounds for his belief under the proviso
thereto, he shall within seventy-two hours send a
copy thereof to his immediate official superior.”
From the aforesaid provision of sub-section (2) of
Section 42 it appears that where an officer takes down any
information in writing under sub-section (1) or records grounds
for his belief under the proviso thereto, he shall within
seventy-two hours send a copy thereof to his immediate official
superior.
9.
Here in the case at hand it appears that initially the
informant after receipt of the information regarding storage of
contraband items entered the fact in GDE vide No.11 on
25.10.2018 and accordingly within the stipulated period he
made the communication to his controlling authority i.e. SP of
the District and those documents were very much available in
the record but for any reason the prosecution failed to exhibit
those documents before the Learned Trial Court and even the
Learned Trial Court also failed to consider those documents at
the time of delivery of the judgment and came to an
observation that Section 42(2) of NDPS Act has not been
complied with.
10.
We have also gone through the judgment delivered
by this Court in Crl. A. No.04 of 2025. At the time of hearing of
that case, Learned P.P. referred few citations which are
available at Para nos.5, 6 and 7. For the sake of convenience,
the same are reproduced herein below:“[5] To support his case, on the point of issuing
summons to the investigating officer, learned PP has
relied upon Para no.9 of a judgment of the apex court
in Shailendra Kumar vs. State of Bihar and Others
reported in (2002) 1 SCC 655 where the apex court
has observed as follows:
9. In our view, in a murder trial it is sordid
and repulsive matter that without informing
the police station officer-in-charge, the
matters are proceeded by the Court and by
the APP and tried to be disposed of as if the
prosecution has not led any evidence. From
the facts stated above, it appears that
accused wants to frustrate the prosecution
by unjustified means and it appears that by
one way or the other the Addl. Sessions
Judge as well as the APP have not taken any
interest in discharge of their duties. It was
the duty of the Sessions Judge to issue
summons to the investigating officer if he
failed to remain present at the time of trial
of the case. The presence of investigating
officer at the time of trial is must. It is his
duty to keep the witnesses present. If there
is failure on part of any witness to remain
present, it is the duty of the Court to take
appropriate action including issuance of
bailable/non-bailable warrants as the case
may be. It should be well understood that
prosecution cannot be frustrated by such
methods and victims of the crime cannot be
left in lurch.
[6] On the point of prescribing an outer limit for
conclusion of all criminal proceedings, learned PP has
relied upon Para no.29 of a judgment of the apex
court in P. Ramachandra Rao vs State of Karnataka
reported in (2002) 4 SCC 578 where the apex court
has observed as follows:
29. For all the foregoing reasons, we are of
the opinion that in Common Cause case (I)
(as modified in Common Cause (II) ) and Raj
Deo Sharma (I) and (II), the Court could not
have prescribed periods of limitation beyond
which the trial of a criminal case or a
criminal proceeding cannot continue and
must mandatorily be closed followed by an
order acquitting or discharging the accused.
In conclusion we hold:(1) The dictum in A.R. Antulay's case is
correct and still holds the field.
(2) The propositions emerging from Article
21 of the Constitution and expounding the
right to speedy trial laid down as guidelines
in A.R. Antulay's case, adequately take care
of right to speedy trial. We uphold and reaffirm the said propositions.
(3) The guidelines laid down in A.R.
Antulay's case are not exhaustive but only
illustrative. They are not intended to operate
as hard and fast rules or to be applied like a
strait-jacket formula. Their applicability
would depend on the fact-situation of each
case. It is difficult to foresee all situations
and no generalization can be made.
(4) It is neither advisable, nor feasible, nor
judicially permissible to draw or prescribe an
outer limit for conclusion of all criminal
proceedings. The time-limits or bars of
limitation
prescribed
in
the
several
directions made in Common Cause (I), Raj
Deo Sharma (I) and Raj Deo Sharma (II)
could not have been so prescribed or drawn
and are not good law. The criminal courts
are not obliged to terminate trial or criminal
proceedings merely on account of lapse of
time, as prescribed by the directions made in
Common Cause Case (I), Raj Deo Sharma
case (I) and (II). At the most the periods of
time prescribed in those decisions can be
taken by the courts seized of the trial or
proceedings to act as reminders when they
may be persuaded to apply their judicial
mind to the facts and circumstances of the
case before them and determine by taking
into consideration the several relevant
factors as pointed out in A.R. Antulay's case
and decide whether the trial or proceedings
have become so inordinately delayed as to
be called oppressive and unwarranted. Such
time-limits
cannot
and
will
not
by
themselves be treated by any Court as a bar
to further continuance of the trial or
proceedings and as mandatorily obliging the
court to terminate the same and acquit or
discharge the accused.
(5) The Criminal Courts should exercise their
available powers, such as those under
Sections 309, 311 and 258 of Code of
Criminal Procedure to effectuate the right to
speedy trial. A watchful and diligent trial
judge can prove to be better protector of
such
right
than
any
guidelines.
In
appropriate cases jurisdiction of High Court
under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. and Articles 226
and 227 of Constitution can be invoked
seeking
appropriate
relief
or
suitable
directions.
(6) This is an appropriate occasion to remind
the
Union
of
India
and
the
State
Governments
of
their
constitutional
obligation to strengthen the judiciaryquantitatively and qualitatively by providing
requisite
funds,
manpower
and
infrastructure. We hope and trust that the
Governments shall act.
We answer the questions posed in the orders
of reference dated September 19, 2000 and
April 26, 2001 in the abovesaid terms.
[7] On the point of responsibility of the court, learned
PP has relied upon Para no.19 of a judgment of the
apex court in Mina Lalita Baruwa vs State of Orissa
and Others reported in (2013) 16 SCC 173 where the
apex court has observed as follows:
19. In criminal jurisprudence, while the
offence is against the society, it is the
unfortunate victim who is the actual sufferer
and therefore, it is imperative for the State
and the prosecution to ensure that no stone
is left unturned. It is also the equal, if not
more, the duty and responsibility of the
Court to be alive and alert in the course of
trial of a criminal case and ensure that the
evidence recorded in accordance with law
reflect every bit of vital information placed
before it. It can also be said that in that
process the Court should be conscious of its
responsibility and at times when the
prosecution
either
deliberately
or
inadvertently omit to bring forth a notable
piece
of
evidence
or
a
conspicuous
statement of any witness with a view to
either support or prejudice the case of any
party, should not hesitate to interject and
prompt the prosecution side to clarify the
position or act on its own and get the record
of
proceedings
straight.
Neither
the
prosecution nor the Court should remain a
silent spectator in such situations. Like in
the present case where there is a wrong
statement made by a witness contrary to his
own record and the prosecution failed to
note the situation at that moment or later
when it was brought to light and whereafter
also the prosecution remained silent, the
Court should have acted promptly and taken
necessary steps to rectify the situation
appropriately. The whole scheme of the Code
of Criminal Procedure envisages foolproof
system in dealing with a crime alleged
against the accused and thereby ensure that
the guilty does not escape and innocent is
not punished. It is with the above
background, we feel that the present issue
involved in the case on hand should be dealt
with.”
11.
Here in the case at hand, Learned Court at the time
of delivery of judgment framed the following points for decision
of the case:Points for determination
(1)
(2)
(3)
12.
Whether search and seizure of contraband has
been proved through seized witnesses?
Whether there was compliance of Section
42(2) of NDPS Act in this case?
Whether chain of possession of contraband has
been proved?
Finally came to the observation that prosecution has
failed to prove the case against the accused and acquitted him.
But from the materials on record it appears that the trial of this
case could not be conducted properly by the prosecution and
even the Learned Trial Court also failed to appreciate the
evidence on record properly and came to the observation that
the seizure list witnesses did not support the case of the
prosecution.
13.
Now, if we go through the evidence of PW-2
Debashri Paul Chowdhury, Woman Constable; PW-3 Rati
Kumar Debbarma, Constable; PW-4 Archana Das, Woman
Constable; PW-6, Inspector Paritosh Das it appears that all the
said witnesses categorically stated that the seized contraband
item was recovered from the residence of the alleged accused.
But Learned Trial Court based upon the evidence on record of
PW-1
Billal
Hossain
Majumder
who
only
stated
that
Darogababu obtained his signature and he put his signature on
the seizure list. But he could not say anything about the
contents of seizure list and came to the observation that
seizure was not proved. In this regard, Hon’ble Supreme Court
in
a
case
reported
in
Rizwan
Khan
vs.
State
of
Chhattishgarh reported in (2020) 9 SCC 627, wherein in
Para No.12 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:“12. It is settled law that the testimony of the
official witnesses cannot be rejected on the ground
of non-corroboration by independent witness. As
observed and held by this Court in catena of
decisions, examination of independent witnesses is
not an indispensable requirement and such nonexamination is not necessarily fatal to the
prosecution case [State of H.P. v. Pardeep Kumar,
(2018) 13 SCC 808]”
From the aforesaid observation of the Hon’ble Apex
Court it appears that, in absence of evidence of private witness
there is scope for conviction of accused based upon evidence of
official witnesses if they are found to be trustworthy. But the
Learned Trial Court at the time of discussions of the evidence
on record came to the findings that independent seizure
witness did not support the case of the prosecution and at the
time of decision of point no.3 observed that no Malkhana
Register was proved and no handing over taking over memo
was prepared and the In-charge of Malkhana district go-down
was not examined which in our considered view was not proper
on the part of the Learned Trial Court.
14.
Thus, it appears to us that the Learned Trial Court
failed to apply his proper mind and deviated from the
established norms. In this regard, let us refer herein below the
scope of the Appellate Court at the time of appeal against
order of acquittal which provides as under:“386.
Powers of the Appellate Court.- After
perusing such record and hearing the appellant or
his pleader, if he appears, and the Public
Prosecutor if he appears, and in case of an appeal
under Section 377 or Section 378, the accused if he
appears, the Appellate Court may, if it considers
that there is no sufficient ground for interfering,
dismiss the appeal, or may(a)
in an appeal from an order of acquittal,
reverse such order and direct that further inquiry
be made, or that the accused be re-tried or
committed for trial, as the case may be, or find him
guilty and pass sentence on him according to law.”
15.
Here in the case at hand after going through the
evidence on record of the Learned Trial Court and also after
going through the judgment delivered by the Learned Trial
Court it appears to us that Learned Trial Court failed to
appreciate the evidence on record at the time of delivery of
judgment and also failed to appreciate the relevant prosecution
papers at the time of recording evidence of the prosecution for
which in our considered view the matter needs to be remanded
back to the Learned Trial Court to conduct a fresh trial by
calling upon the witnesses afresh allowing the prosecution to
prove the relevant documents in support of the prosecution
case and thereafter to deliver a fresh judgment in accordance
with law.
16.
In the result, the judgment and order of acquittal
dated 28.02.2024 delivered by Learned Special Judge (NDPS),
Sepahijala District, Sonamura is thus hereby set aside. The
matter is remanded back to the Learned Special Judge (NDPS),
Sepahijala District, Sonamura with a direction to conduct a
fresh trial by calling upon the witnesses of the prosecution
afresh and further allowing the prosecution to prove the
relevant documents in support of the prosecution case allowing
the accused to conduct the defence properly and thereupon to
deliver a fresh judgment in accordance with law. However, it is
made clear that if the parties want to rely upon the earlier
evidence on record in that case the Learned Special Judge may
examine the rest witnesses after hearing both the sides
affording reasonable opportunities to the parties. The trial shall
be conducted as expeditiously as possible. The respondent is
hereby directed to appear before the Learned Trial Court on or
before 07.01.2026. On his surrender, the Learned Trial Court
may consider bail application filed by him in accordance with
law, so that his right is not infringed.
The appeal is allowed.
With this observation, this appeal stands disposed of
on contest.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this
judgment/order immediately.
Pending applications, if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Amrita
AMRITA DEB
DEB
Date: 2025.11.18 17:15:54
+05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review