Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:44
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Reserved on
: 23.08.2024
Date of Decision: 02.09.2024
Crl. P. No. 17 of 2024
State of Meghalaya
Vs. Shri. Mathi Lyngkhoi
Represented by the Secretary to
(Accused).
The Government of Meghalaya,
Son of (L) R. Shangoid,
Home (Police) Department,
Resident of Mawrang Village,
Shillong.
West Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
::::PETITIONER.
::::RESPONDENT.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. N. D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. E. R. Chyne, GA.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Kharkrang, Adv.
(JUDGMENT & ORDER)
By this application under Section 482 Cr.P.C, the petitioner-State has
challenged the impugned order dated 25-07-2023 passed in Sessions
2024:MLHC:44
Case No. 30 of 2020 (G.R Case No. 187 of 2011) by the learned
Sessions Judge, South West Khasi Hills District, Mawkyrwat whereby
the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C filed by the prosecution for
summoning and examination of additional witnesses was rejected.
1.
The brief fact of the case is that an FIR dated 23-10-2011 was
lodged by Smti Prialdoris Mawlein before the Officer-in-Charge
Nongstoin Police Station alleging that on 23-10-2011, at about 1.30
AM, the respondent herein had brutally murdered one Shri. Komli
Mawlein Shianglang at a coal quarry by using a firewood while the
victim was asleep, and after committing the crime, the respondent fled
away from the spot. On the basis of the said FIR, the Nongstoin PS
Case No. 145 (10) 2011 under Section 302 IPC was registered by the
police. The case was later transferred to Ranikor PS and registered as
Ranikor PS Case No. 47 (10) 2011 under Section 302 IPC as the place
of occurrence was under jurisdiction of the Ranikor Police Station.
After conclusion of the investigation, a charge-sheet was filed in the
matter against the respondent and by order dated 21-01-2016, the
learned Trial Court framed charge under Section 302 IPC against him.
During the course of the trial, the prosecution examined five witnesses
and they were discharged after examination-in-chief and crossexamination.
After completion of recording of statement of the
respondent (accused) under Section 313 Cr.P.C, the prosecution filed
an application under Section 311 Cr.P.C on 17-04-2023 before the
Trial Court for calling 5(five) additional witnesses as their evidence
would be vital for the just decision of the case. A show-cause reply
dated 16-05-2023 was filed on behalf of the respondent against the
2024:MLHC:44
said application. The learned Trial Court, after hearing the parties,
vide impugned order dated 25-07-2023 rejected the application of the
prosecution on the ground of delay. Being aggrieved, the State has
preferred this criminal petition before this Court.
2.
Mr. N. D. Chullai, learned AAG appearing for the petitioner,
submits that the rejection of the application for calling of additional
witnesses by the Trial Court on the ground of delay is against the
settled propositions of law. He submits that the learned Trail Court
has failed to realize the gravity of the offence involved in the matter
and also the relevance and importance of the witnesses sought to be
called as additional witnesses by the prosecution. He submits that the
additional witnesses named in the application under Section 311
Cr.P.C. include eyewitnesses, seizure witnesses and the Magistrate
who recorded the confessional statement of the accused and, hence,
are very vital witnesses for unearthing the truth in the matter. He
submits that the learned Trial Court without realizing the importance
of the testimony of such witnesses, has passed the impugned order
mechanically only on the ground of delay. The learned AAG contends
that the prolonged pendency or the age of a case cannot be sole
decisive of the matter when the offence involved is grave in nature
and a prayer is made for examination of material witnesses.
He
submits that though delay is not desirable in a criminal trial, the
duration of a case cannot displace the basic requirement of ensuring
the just decision after taking all the necessary and material evidence
on record. He submits that the learned Trial Court while passing the
impugned order did not appreciate the importance of examination of
2024:MLHC:44
the additional witnesses named in the application and rejected the
same without applying its judicious mind. In support of his argument,
the learned AAG has places reliance on the decision of the Apex Court
reported in (2019) 6 SCC 203, Manju Devi Versus State of Rajasthan
and Another and prays for quashing of the impugned order and also
for allowing the prosecution to examine the additional witnesses
named in the application filed before the Trial Court under Section
311 Cr.P.C.
3.
Mr. R. Kharkrang, learned Counsel appearing for the
respondent, on the other hand, supported the impugned order and
submitted that there is no illegality and infirmity in the order passed
by the Trial Court.
He submits that the application for calling
additional witnesses by the prosecution was filed after the closure of
the prosecution witnesses and recording of statement of the accused
under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and, hence, the Trial Court was right in
rejecting the same on the ground of delay. He submits that the trial of
the case has been pending for more than 8 (eight) years and the
prosecution has not given any valid reason for filing the application
under Section 311 Cr.P.C. at a belated stage when the matter was
pending for final hearing. According to him, the right to speedy trial
is an inalienable right of the accused under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India and the said right cannot be taken away without
any valid or justified reason. He submits that the Trial Court while
rejecting the application of the prosecution under Section 311 Cr.P.C.
has recorded valid reason in the light of the established norms of
criminal jurisprudence.
The learned Counsel submits that where the
2024:MLHC:44
prosecution evidence is closed and the reasons for non-examination of
the witnesses earlier are not satisfactory, the summoning of the
additional witnesses at belated stage is highly prejudicial to the
accused and the decision of the Trial Court, as such, does not require
any interference by this Court. In support of his argument, the learned
Counsel has placed reliance on the decisions of the Apex Court
reported in (2019) 14 SCC 328, Swapan Kumar Chatterjee Versus
Central Bureau of Investigation and (2009) 3 SCC 355, Vakil Prasad
Singh Versus State of Bihar.
4.
Before coming to the controversy involved in the present case,
it would be appropriate for this Court to take note of the proposition of
law laid down in the decisions relied on by the learned Counsels for
the rival parties.
The Apex Court in Swapan Kumar Chatterjee
(supra) at para 12 held: “12.Where the prosecution evidence has been closed
long back and the reasons for non-examination of the
witness earlier are not satisfactory, the summoning of the
witness at belated stage would cause great prejudice to
the accused and should not be allowed. Similarly, the
court should not encourage the filing of successive
applications for recall of a witness under this provision.”
The aforesaid observation was made on the background of the fact
that repeated adjournments were granted to present expert witness
before the Court from 2004 to 2017, and yet the witness was not
produced before the Court. The fact involved therein was that the
public prosecutor had filed a petition praying for examination of
handwriting expert, which was allowed and a date was fixed on 24-03Page 5 of 13
2024:MLHC:44
2004 and then to 26-03-2004 for his examination.
However, the
witness failed to appear before the Court due to which the prosecutor
further sought time for fixing of a schedule till next day for his
examination.
The request of the prosecutor was accepted by the
Magistrate with a direction that the schedule is fixed on and from 1005-2004 to 12-05-2004. The said witness yet again failed to turn up.
The prosecutor did not pray for reissuing of summon and bailable
warrant, but a separate petition was filed by the prosecutor for
resummoning the witness.
Such prayer was considered by the
Magistrate as a last chance. From then onwards, whenever a date was
fixed for examining the handwriting expert, the witness failed to turn
up. This practice had continued for a period of 13 years starting from
the year 2004. In those circumstances, the Apex Court held that the
Court erred in repeatedly granting last opportunity to produce the
witness and in the light of the repeated failure to produce the witness
in Court, application for summoning the said witness was rejected by
the Supreme Court.
Thus, the factual background of Swapan Kumar Chatterjee
(supra) was totally different from the present case. In the said case, it
is nowhere observed by the Apex Court that the question of delay
should be the sole criteria for deciding an application under Section
311 Cr.P.C.
5.
In the case of Vakil Prasad Singh (supra), the Apex Court while
recognizing the right to speedy trial and public trial a constitutional
guarantee, at para 24 observed as follows: -
2024:MLHC:44
“24. It is, therefore, well settled that the right to speedy
trial in all criminal persecutions (sic prosecutions) is an
inalienable right under Article 21 of the Constitution.
This right is applicable not only to the actual
proceedings in Court but also includes within its sweep
the proceeding police investigations as well. The right to
speedy trial extends equally to all criminal prosecutions
and is not confined to any particular category of cases.
In every case, where the right to speedy trial is alleged to
have been infringed, the court has to perform the
balancing act upon taking into consideration all the
attendant circumstances, enumerated above, and
determine in each case whether the right to speedy trial
has been denied in a given case.”
In the above case, the Apex Court had also reiterated the propositions
of law laid down in (1992) 1 SCC 285 (A.R. Antulay case), some of
which were reflected at para 20 of the judgment of the case. The
propositions at sub paras (iv),(v) & (vi) laid down that while
determining whether undue delay has occurred (resulting in violation
of right to speedy trial) one must have regard to all the attendant
circumstances, including nature of offence, number of accused and
witnesses, the workload of the court concerned, prevailing local
conditions and so on – what is called, the systematic delays. It was
further observed that each and every delay does not necessarily
prejudice the accused.
advantage.
Some delays may indeed work to his
However, inordinate long delay may be taken as
presumptive proof of prejudice.
In this context, the fact of
incarceration of the accused will also be a relevant fact.
The
prosecution should not be allowed to become persecution. But when
does the prosecution become persecution, again depends upon the
2024:MLHC:44
facts of a given case. It was held that ultimately, the court has to
balance and weigh several relevant factors – ‘balancing test’ or
‘balancing process’ – and determine in each case whether the right to
speedy trial has been denied.
It emerges from the above that whenever a plea of infringement
of right to speedy trial is alleged or an objection is raised on the
ground of delay, the court has to perform the balancing act by taking
into consideration all the attendant circumstances including the nature
of offence.
6.
In Manju Devi (supra), the Apex Court while elaborating
powers under Section 311 Cr.PC., at paras 10 and 13 observed: “10. It needs hardly any emphasis that the discretionary powers
like those under Section 311 CrPC are essentially intended to
ensure that every necessary and appropriate measure is taken
by the Court to keep the record straight and to clear any
ambiguity insofar as the evidence is concerned as also to
ensure that no prejudice is caused to anyone. The principles
underlying Section 311 CrPC and amplitude of the powers of
the court thereunder have been explained by this Court in
several decisions. In Natasha Singh v. CBI³, though the
application for examination of witnesses was filed by the
accused but, on the principles relating to the exercise of powers
under Section 311, this Court observed, inter alia, as under:
(SCC pp. 746 & 748-49, paras 8 &15)
"8. Section 311 CrPC empowers the court to summon a
material witness, or to examine a person present at "any
stage" of "any enquiry", or "trial", or "any other
proceedings" under CrPC, or to summon any person as a
witness, or to recall and re-examine any person who has
already been examined if his evidence appears to it, to be
essential to the arrival of a just decision of the case.
2024:MLHC:44
Undoubtedly, CrPC has conferred a very wide
discretionary power upon the court in this respect, but
such a discretion is to be exercised judiciously and not
arbitrarily. The power of the court in this context is very
wide, and in exercise of the same, it may summon any
person as a witness at any stage of the trial, or other
proceedings. The court is competent to exercise such
power even suo motu if no such application has been
filed by either of the parties. However, the court must
satisfy itself, that it was in fact essential to examine such
a witness, or to recall him for further examination in
order to arrive at a just decision of the case.
*
*
*
15.The scope and object of the provision is to enable the
court to determine the truth and to render a just decision
after discovering all relevant facts and obtaining proper
proof of such facts, to arrive at a just decision of the
case. Power must be exercised judiciously and not
capriciously or arbitrarily, as any improper or
capricious exercise of such power may lead to
undesirable results. An application under Section 311
CrPC must not be allowed only to fill up a lacuna in the
case of the prosecution, or of the defence, or to the
disadvantage of the accused, or to cause serious
prejudice to the defence of the accused, or to give an
unfair advantage to the opposite party. Further, the
additional evidence must not be received as a disguise
for retrial, or to change the nature of the case against
either of the parties. Such a power must be exercised,
provided that the evidence that is likely to be tendered by
a witness, is germane to the issue involved. An
opportunity of rebuttal however, must be given to the
other party. The power conferred under Section 311
CrPC must therefore, be invoked by the court only in
order to meet the ends of justice, for strong and valid
reasons, and the same must be exercised with great
caution and circumspection. The very use of words such
as "any court", "at any stage", or "or any enquiry, trial
2024:MLHC:44
or other proceedings", "any person" and "any such
person" clearly spells out that the provisions of this
section have been expressed in the widest possible terms,
and do not limit the discretion of the court in any way.
There is thus no escape if the fresh evidence to be
obtained is essential to the just decision of the case. The
determinative factor should therefore be, whether the
summoning/recalling of the said witness is in fact,
essential to the just decision of the case.
13. Though it is expected that the trial of a sessions case should
proceed with reasonable expedition and pendency of such a
matter for about 8-9 years is not desirable but then, the
length/duration of a case cannot displace the basic requirement
of ensuring the just decision after taking all the necessary and
material evidence on record. In other words, the age of a case,
by itself, cannot be decisive of the matter when a prayer is
made for examination of a material witness.”
Thus, from the above, it is apparent that this scope and object of the
provisions of Section 311 Cr.PC is for the purpose of enabling the
Court to determine the truth and to render a just decision after
discovering all relevant facts and obtaining proper proof of such facts
to arrive at a just decision of the case. A duty is cast on the court to
ensure that the material evidence comes on record so as to arrive at
just and proper conclusion. The age of the case, by itself cannot be
decisive of the matter when a prayer is made for examination of
material witness.
7.
In the present case, the charge against the respondent was
framed on 21-01-2016 and the case has been pending for more than 8
years. The prosecution closed its evidence on 07-12-2022 and the
statement of the respondent under Section 313 Cr.P.C. was recorded
2024:MLHC:44
on 06-03-2023. The application under Section 311 Cr.P.C for calling
additional witnesses was filed by the prosecution on 17-04-2023. The
reason for non-examination of the witnesses earlier was stated to be
due to bona fide mistake and oversight, which is definitely a mistake
on the part of the prosecution. There was a gap of about 4(four)
months between the date of closure of prosecution evidence and date
of filing of the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. It is not the case
here that the prosecution had delayed the matter intentionally and did
not file the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. immediately after
realizing its mistake.
In such a situation, delay in preferring the
application for summoning additional witnesses cannot be termed as
inordinate long delay giving rise to presumptive proof of prejudice to
the respondent.
There is no dispute that the statements of all the
witnesses named in the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. were
recorded by the police at the stage of the investigation under Section
161 Cr.P.C. The indisputable facts and situation of the case remains
that the respondent is a named accused in the FIR and he has been
charged and tried for an offence under Section 302 IPC on the
accusation of brutally murdering one Shri. Komli Mawlein Shinglang,
which, undoubtedly is a grave offence.
8.
A perusal of the impugned order does not show that the Trial
Court had taken into consideration the importance of the evidence of
the witnesses named by the prosecution in its application filed under
Section 311 Cr.P.C. There is also nothing to indicate that the Trial
Court had shown any interest to determine whether the additional
witnesses named by the prosecution are material witnesses or not, and
2024:MLHC:44
what influence their testimony might have in the outcome of the trial.
A perusal of the statements of all the 5(five) named additional
witnesses under Section 161 Cr.P.C., annexed with the present
petition, reveal that they have played vital role in the investigation of
the matter and their evidence are essential for determination of truth
and for just decision of the case. No attempt was made by the Trial
Court to balance the situation by taking into consideration the gravity
of the offence involved and the probative value of the evidence of the
additional witnesses which are likely to be adduced by them.
Hence,
it can be concluded that the Trial Court, while passing the impugned
order, did not appreciate the matter in the light of the law laid down by
the Apex Court. The impugned order, as such, cannot be sustained in
law.
9.
For the reasons and discussions above, this criminal petition
succeeds. The impugned order dated 25-07-2023 passed in Sessions
Case No. 30 of 2020 (G.R Case No. 187 of 2011) by the learned
Sessions Judge, South West Khasi Hills District, Mawkyrwat is set
aside and quashed.
Resultantly, the application filed by the
prosecution before the Trial Court for summoning the additional
witnesses stands allowed.
The Trial Court is directed to issue
summons to the witnesses named in the application numbered as
Petition No.108 of 2023 filed by the prosecution by fixing a date or
different dates for recording their evidence.
10.
This criminal petition stands allowed.
2024:MLHC:44
JUDGE
Meghalaya
02.09.2024
“Biswarup-PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.09.02 19:40:13 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review