Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:817-DB
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl.A. No. 49 of 2024
Date of CAV: 14.07.2026
Date of pronouncement: 04.08.2026
Ram Dhar
...Appellant
- versus -
The State of Meghalaya represented by the Secretary, Home
Department.
...Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mrs. Justice Revati Mohite Dere, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
For the Respondent
: Mr J. Shylla, Adv. with
Mr M.L. Nongpiur, Adv.
: Mr N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr E.R. Chyne, GA
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
By this appeal, the appellant has impugned the judgment
dated 14.05.2024 and order dated 15.05.2024 respectively,
passed by the learned Sessions Judge, West Jaintia Hills
District, Jowai in Sessions Case No. 76 of 2015, convicting and
2026:MLHC:817-DB
sentencing him as under; – for the offence punishable under
Section 302 of the IPC to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life
and to pay fine of ₹5000/-.
2.
In addition, the learned Sessions Judge recommended
compensation of ₹3 lakh under Section 357A of Cr.P.C. to the
parents of the deceased – Trebor Hinge, to be given by the
Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, West Jaintia Hills
District.
3.
The prosecution case in brief is as under;
According to the prosecution, the incident took place on
11.02.2015 at around 1.30 p.m. The FIR was lodged by Shri
Kynjai Hinge, younger brother of the deceased, Trebor Hinge. It
is alleged by Shri Kynjai Hinge (PW1) that his elder brother –
Trebor Hinge was murdered by the appellant in the village. The
said FIR was lodged pursuant to the information received by
PW2 - Smti. Nika Thubru, an eyewitness to the incident.
Pursuant to the registration of the FIR, the Police commenced
with the investigation, recorded statements of witnesses,
performed an inquest panchnama, sent the body for post
2026:MLHC:817-DB
mortem examination and on conclusion of the investigation,
filed a charge-sheet as against the appellant for the offence
punishable under Section 302 of the IPC, in the Court of the
learned Magistrate. Since, the offence alleged was triable by the
Court of Sessions, the case came to be committed to the Court
of Sessions, for trial.
4.
The learned Sessions Judge framed charge against the
appellant on 10.12.2025, to which the appellant pleaded not
guilty and claimed to be tried.
5.
The prosecution in support of its case, examined six
witnesses;
PW1 – Shri. Kynjai Hinge (Younger brother of the deceased)
PW2 – Smti. Nika Thubru (Neighbour of both the deceased and
accused)
PW3 – Dr. E. Challam, Senior Medical & Health Officer.
PW4 – Shri Filing up Roy Thubru (Secretary of VDP, Nangbah
Village)
PW5 – Smti. Damonphika Shadap (Retd. Scientific Assistant)
PW6 – Shri Terence J. Synrem, Investigating Officer
2026:MLHC:817-DB
6.
After examination of the prosecution witnesses, the
learned Judge examined the appellant under Section 313
Cr.P.C. The appellant did not examine any defence witness.
7.
After hearing the learned counsel for the respective
parties, the trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant as
stated aforesaid in paragraph 1.
8.
The fact that the appellant died a homicidal death is not
seriously disputed by the learned counsel for the appellant.
From the evidence of PW3, Dr. Challam, it appears that the
deceased had sustained the following injuries i.e., incised wound
on the medial side of the upper thigh size 1½“ x 1“; laceration on
the left scapular region 1½“ x 1“; incised wound over right gluteal
region 3½“ x .75“; injuries of gluteus muscle; injury of the
inferior gluteal nerve and the inferior gluteal artery; incised
wound on the left cheek 4“x3“; incised wound on the right 3rd
intercostal space 2½ x .5; incised wound on the left 5th
intercostal space 2½“ x ½“, and fracture of the right 3rd rib. The
cause of death is stated to be shock and haemorrhage as a result
of multiple injuries caused by hard sharp object. The only
2026:MLHC:817-DB
question that arises for consideration is whether the prosecution
has proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant is the
author of the said injuries.
9.
In this context, it would be necessary to advert to the
evidence as has come on record.
10.
PW1 - Kynjai Hinge (first informant and brother of the
deceased) has deposed that the deceased was his elder brother.
He has further deposed that when he had gone to the paddy field
to work at 8 a.m., he received a call from his sister, Smti.
Marchynna Hinge informing him to reach home immediately as
their brother had been killed; that pursuant thereto, he rushed
home and found that their relatives had reached their house;
that they went to see the dead body of their brother (Trebor
Hinge) that was lying near the garden of Smt. Rika Thubru(PW2);
that he saw his brother had sustained cut injuries all over his
face; and that he saw the accused person carrying a knife in his
hand roaming in the village; and that pursuant thereto, the
police came and took the appellant and that he lodged an FIR as
against the appellant.
2026:MLHC:817-DB
11.
In his cross-examination, PW1 has admitted that his
deceased brother had not created any problems in the village nor
had any fights or quarrels with anyone; and that the appellant
was arrested from his house in the evening. It has also come in
the cross-examination of PW2, that it was during the day time
that he had seen the appellant roaming in the village with a knife
in his hand, however, had not informed the VDP or the headman
about the accused carrying a knife.
12.
PW2 - Smti. Nika Thubru, is an eyewitness to the alleged
incident of assault by the appellant on the deceased. PW2 in her
examination-in-chief has deposed that on the day of the
incident, she was washing clothes at around 12 noon; that after
washing clothes, her friend, Lika Hadia came and sat with her;
that around 12.30 p.m., the deceased (Trebor Hinge) came to her
house and they started chatting with them; that the deceased
(Trebor Hinge) wanted to buy piglets from her but they were not
mature for sale and hence, the deceased went to the pigsty to
look at the piglets; that since it was a hot day, the deceased sat
down and went to sleep near the pigsty; that at that time, the
2026:MLHC:817-DB
appellant came and went straight to where the deceased was
sleeping and woke him up, saying that they should chat and as
such, both started chatting and she continued to do her
household work; that she did not hear their talks but she saw
them chasing each other and hence, went to see what was
happening; that she saw the appellant chasing the deceased and
hence, called out to the appellant, telling him not to injure the
deceased; that the appellant was carrying a Tukri and chasing
the deceased, who was running in the garden; that finally the
appellant held the deceased and stabbed him; that on seeing the
same, she screamed and called out for help but none helped and
were only watching; that she ran towards the crowd which was
standing; and that she was scared and frightened; that she went
to the house of the deceased to inform his relatives to check if
the deceased was alive so as to take him to the hospital; that
pursuant thereto, the relatives of the deceased gathered and
thereafter, they went to the Police Station. According to PW2 Smti. Nika Thubru at around 2 p.m. the Police came to the spot
and removed the dead body from the spot.
2026:MLHC:817-DB
13.
In the cross examination, PW2 has admitted that she had
no inimical relations with the family of the appellant as she too
was related to the appellant through clanship; that she knew the
sister of the appellant; and, has admitted that there was a
quarrel between her and the sister of the appellant regarding
drinking water and that the appellant’s sister had thrown a
small stone at her prior to the incident. PW2 has further
admitted that she and the appellant’s entire family had stopped
talking to each other, however, and the matter was resolved and
they had started talking. PW2 has further admitted that she was
angry with the sister of the appellant as she was washing
utensils in a place where they would get drinking water,
however, prior to the incident, the dispute between her and the
appellant’s family had been resolved. According to PW2, the
relatives of the deceased had also come but they did not do
anything, as they were frightened; that she saw the appellant
stabbing the deceased from the back but could not remember
whether the appellant used his left hand or right hand to stab.
According to PW2, soon after the stabbing, the appellant ran
2026:MLHC:817-DB
from the said spot, pursuant to which she called the family
members of the deceased.
14.
There is nothing in the cross-examination of this witness
to disbelieve her testimony. To the contrary, suggestions show
that the appellant was present at the spot and that the PW2 saw
the appellant stabbing the deceased from the back. There is
absolutely no suggestion to the said witness i.e., PW2 that she
had not witnessed the incident or that she was falsely
implicating the appellant. Infact, the said evidence of PW1 is
duly corroborated by the medical evidence. PW3 – Dr. Challam,
has in detail described the nature of injuries sustained by the
deceased which have been set out in para 8 hereinabove. Thus,
the ocular evidence of PW2 clearly corroborates the medical
evidence of PW3 and as such, is sufficient to sustain the
conviction of the appellant.
15.
Although, there is discovery under Section 27 of Tukri at
the instance of the appellant and that PW4 was examined to
prove the same, it is difficult to place implicit reliance on the said
discovery, inasmuch as the Tukri (dagger) was kept at the
2026:MLHC:817-DB
appellant’s uncle house and it is the appellant’s uncle who
pulled out/produced the Tukri. Needless to state, merely
because the discovery evidence of Tukri is not proved by the
prosecution, will not in any way impact the prosecution case
inasmuch as, the prosecution has proved its case through PW2
– eyewitness, which in turn, is duly corroborated by the medical
evidence i.e., evidence of PW3 and the post mortem report.
16.
Accordingly, the appeal fails and as such, is dismissed
and the impugned judgment and order of conviction and
sentence passed by the learned Sessions Judge, West Jaintia
Hills District, Jowai in Sessions Case No. 76 of 2015, stands
confirmed.
17.
The appeal is disposed of.
18.
Since, the learned Sessions Judge has recommended
compensation of ₹3 lakh/- to be given to the parents of the
deceased – Trebor Hinge, we direct the Secretary, District Legal
Services Authority, West Jaintia Hills District, to submit a report
as to whether the said amount has been disbursed to them or
2026:MLHC:817-DB
not. The said report to be submitted before this Court within
four weeks.
19.
The Registry to forward forthwith a copy of this judgment
and order to the Secretary, District Legal Services Authority,
West Jaintia Hills District, to enable the Secretary to submit the
report.
20.
Place the aforesaid appeal for recording compliance of
paragraph 18 on 2nd September, 2026.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Revati Mohite Dere)
Chief Justice
LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2026.08.04 16:50:41 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review