The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. In view of the above discussion, the Appeals deserve to be partly allowed only to the extent of modification in respect of interest. The determination of market value at Rs.2,000/- per R and the consequential statutory benefits, subject to the modification regarding the period and 11-FA-5078-2017.odt computation of interest, do not call for interference. Hence, the following order: (i) The First Appeals are partly allowed. (ii) The common Judgment and Award dated 11.03.2013 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Osmanabad, in Land Acquisition Reference Nos.85 of 2007 and 440 of 2008 is modified to the aforesaid extent. (iii) The respondents-claimants shall be entitled to interest under Sections 28 and 34 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, in accordance with the law laid down by the Full Bench of this Court in State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari (supra). (iv) The remaining part of the common Judgment and Award dated
11. 03.2013 passed by the learned Reference Court in Land Acquisition Reference Nos.85 of 2007 and 440 of 2008 shall remain unaltered. (vi) The modified award be drawn accordingly. (vii) Pending Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed of. S P Rane [ SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE ]
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:41852
11-FA-5078-2017.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
11 FIRST APPEAL NO. 5078 OF 2017
The State of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Mangalbai Fulchand Yadav
……
12 FIRST APPEAL NO. 5079 OF 2017
The State of Maharashtra And Others
VERSUS
Chandrakant Zumbar Yadav And Another
……
Mr. S.N. Morampalle, AGP for Appellant-State in FA/5078/2017
Mr. S.S. Dande, AGP for Appellant-State in FA/5079/2017
Ms. Laxmi R. Thakur, Advocate h/f Mr. L.C. Patil, Advocate for RespondentsClaimants in both FAs
……
CORAM : SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.
DATE
: 04 SEPTEMBER, 2026
PER COURT :
1.
Heard learned AGPs appearing for the appellant-State and learned
counsel appearing for the respondents-claimants.
2.
These Appeals take exception to the common Judgment and Award
dated 11.03.2013 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division,
Osmanabad, in Land Acquisition Reference Nos.85 of 2007 and 440 of 2008,
whereby the learned Reference Court partly allowed the References under
Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, “the Act”) and
enhanced the compensation payable to the respective claimants along with
the statutory benefits.
3.
11-FA-5078-2017.odt
The lands belonging to the respective claimants, situated at village
Lasona, Taluka and District Osmanabad, came to be acquired for the
Percolation Tank, Lasona. The particulars of the acquired lands are as under:
Sr. No.
1.
2.
3.
LAR No.
85 of 2007
440 of 2008
Survey/Gat No.
153 & 174
Area Acquired
03 H 70 R
02 H 87 R
The notification under Section 4 of the Act was published on
17.04.1995. The possession of the acquired lands was taken on 29.04.1992,
i.e. prior to publication of the notification under Section 4 of the Act. The
Special Land Acquisition Officer (for short, “the SLAO”) passed the Award
under Section 11 of the Act on 30.07.1998 and determined the market value
of the acquired lands at the rates of Rs.130/-, Rs.145/- and Rs.170/- per R.
The claimants, being dissatisfied with the market value determined by the
SLAO, accepted the compensation under protest and sought references
under Section 18 of the Act. Accordingly, the references came to be made to
the learned Reference Court.
4.
Before the learned Reference Court, the claimants relied upon the
sale instances at Exhibits 23 and 24. The sale instance at Exhibit 23 is dated
09.09.1992, whereas the sale instance at Exhibit 24 is dated 31.03.1993.
The learned Reference Court placed reliance upon the sale instance at
Exhibit 23 and enhanced the market value of the acquired lands to
Rs.2,000/- per R, together with the statutory benefits. Hence, the present
11-FA-5078-2017.odt
Appeals at the instance of the State.
5.
Learned AGPs appearing for the appellant-State submit that the
learned Reference Court was not justified in enhancing the market value to
Rs.2,000/- per R. According to them, the sale instance relied upon by the
claimants was not a comparable transaction and the enhancement granted
by the learned Reference Court is excessive and without sufficient
evidentiary basis. It is submitted that the acquired lands and the land
covered by Exhibit 23 were not shown to be comparable with regard to their
situation, nature and potentiality. The learned AGPs, therefore, submit that
the impugned Judgment and Award deserves to be interfered with.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-claimants
supports the impugned Judgment and Award. She submits that the sale
instance at Exhibit 23 is a genuine transaction executed on 09.09.1992, i.e.
nearly three years prior to the notification under Section 4 of the Act, and
relates to land situated in the vicinity. She submits that the learned
Reference Court has not mechanically relied upon the sale consideration,
but has properly worked out the value attributable to the land after
excluding the amount referable to the share in the well and thereafter
granted appropriate escalation for the intervening period. According to her,
the ultimate determination of Rs.2,000/- per R is just, reasonable and
supported by the evidence on record. He, therefore, submits that no
interference is warranted.
7.
11-FA-5078-2017.odt
I have considered the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel for the respective parties and have carefully perused the impugned
Judgment and Award as well as the material available on record.
8.
The principal question that falls for consideration is whether the
learned Reference Court was justified in determining the market value of the
acquired lands at the rate of Rs.2,000/- per R on the basis of the sale
instance at Exhibit 23.
9.
The sale instance at Exhibit 23 is dated 09.09.1992. Thus, the
transaction is of a date about three years prior to the publication of the
notification under Section 4 of the Act on 17.04.1995. The transaction
covers an area of 99 R. The sale consideration mentioned therein is
Rs.1,50,000/-. The said consideration includes not only the price of the land
but also the price attributable to 1/3rd share in the well.
10.
The learned Reference Court considered the fact that the claimants
had not led any specific evidence enabling an exact bifurcation of the
consideration between the land and the 1/3rd share in the well. In the
circumstances, as a matter of prudence, the learned Reference Court
assessed the price attributable to the well at Rs.30,000/- and, having regard
to the fact that the transaction concerned 1/3rd share therein, deducted
Rs.10,000/- from the total sale consideration. Thus, the consideration
attributable to the land was taken at Rs.1,40,000/-. On dividing the amount
11-FA-5078-2017.odt
of Rs.1,40,000/- by the area of 99 R, the market value works out to
approximately Rs.1,414/- per R in the year 1992.
11.
The learned Reference Court thereafter granted escalation for the
period of three years between the date of the sale transaction and the date
of the notification. By applying an increase of 10% per annum, i.e. 30% for
the intervening period, an amount of approximately Rs.424/- per R was
added to the rate of Rs.1,414/- per R. Consequently, the rate worked out to
approximately Rs.1,838/- per R in the year 1995.
12.
Having regard to the aforesaid calculation, the learned Reference
Court ultimately determined the market value of the acquired lands at
Rs.2,000/- per R. Thus, the determination made by the learned Reference
Court is not without basis. On the contrary, the rate of Rs.2,000/- per R is
reasonably relatable to the rate emerging from the comparable sale
transaction after making appropriate adjustment for the amount attributable
to the well and the intervening escalation.
13.
It is well settled that while determining the market value of acquired
land, the Court is required to take into consideration the best available
evidence, particularly genuine and comparable sale instances proximate in
point of time to the relevant date. The transaction at Exhibit 23 is of a date
prior to the notification under Section 4 of the Act and provides a concrete
basis for determination of the market value. The appellant-State has not
11-FA-5078-2017.odt
been able to demonstrate that the said transaction is sham, artificial or
otherwise unreliable. Nor has the appellant-State brought on record any
better or more comparable sale instance so as to displace the evidence relied
upon by the learned Reference Court.
14.
Upon an independent re-appreciation of the evidence, I find that the
approach adopted by the learned Reference Court is reasonable and
supported by the material on record. The determination of market value at
Rs.2,000/- per R cannot be said to be perverse, arbitrary or excessive so as
to warrant interference in appellate jurisdiction. The compensation so
determined appears to be just and reasonable.
15.
However, the grievance of the appellant-State regarding the grant of
interest deserves consideration. The learned Reference Court has directed
payment of interest from the date of notification under Section 4 of the Act.
Such direction is not in consonance with the law laid down by the Full
Bench of this Court in State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari, 2016
(3) Mh.L.J. 457. Therefore, to that limited extent, the impugned Judgment
and Award requires modification.
16.
In view of the above discussion, the Appeals deserve to be partly
allowed only to the extent of modification in respect of interest. The
determination of market value at Rs.2,000/- per R and the consequential
statutory benefits, subject to the modification regarding the period and
11-FA-5078-2017.odt
computation of interest, do not call for interference. Hence, the following
order:
ORDER
(i)
The First Appeals are partly allowed.
(ii)
The common Judgment and Award dated 11.03.2013 passed by the
learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Osmanabad, in Land Acquisition
Reference Nos.85 of 2007 and 440 of 2008 is modified to the aforesaid
extent.
(iii)
The respondents-claimants shall be entitled to interest under
Sections 28 and 34 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, in accordance with
the law laid down by the Full Bench of this Court in State of Maharashtra
Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari (supra).
(iv)
The remaining part of the common Judgment and Award dated
11.03.2013 passed by the learned Reference Court in Land Acquisition
Reference Nos.85 of 2007 and 440 of 2008 shall remain unaltered.
(vi)
The modified award be drawn accordingly.
(vii)
Pending Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed of.
S P Rane
[ SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE ]
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review