Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:47295
-1-
CriAppeal-718-2006
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.718 OF 2006
The State of Maharashtra
Through P.S.O. Dharur
Police Station, Tq. Dharur,
District Beed.
Versus
1.
Nilkanth @ Bhagwan
s/o Madhavrao Shinde
Age: 32 years,
2.
Santosh s/o Madhavrao Shinde
Age: 20 years,
3.
Madhavrao s/o Baburao Shinde
Age: 65 years,
4.
Omprakash @ Ashok s/o Madhavrao
Shinde, Age: 27 years,
5.
Ashok Shridhar Nirmal
Age: 28 years,
6.
Navnath Dhondiram Nirmal
Age: 35 years,
7.
Shivaji s/o Asaram Kharat,
Age: 26 years,
8.
Sidheshwar s/o Shrirang Wani
Age: 22 years,
9.
Balu s/o Suryabhan Wani
Age: 24 years,
10.
Prakash s/o Dhondiram Nirmal
Age: 20 years,
.. Appellant
-2-
11.
Ambadas s/o Damodhar Wani,
Age: 22 years,
12.
Sonaji s/o Ginyandeo Wani,
Age: 23 years,
All R/o. Nirmalwai (Karalwadi)
Tq. And Dist. Beed.
CriAppeal-718-2006
.. Respondents
…
Mr. S. M. Ganachari, APP for the appellant/State.
Mr. S. J. Salunke, Advocate for respondent Nos.1 to 12.
...
CORAM :
ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.
Reserved on : 29.09.2026
Pronounced on : 08.10.2026
JUDGMENT :1.
In the State appeal, there is challenge to the judgment and
order of acquittal dated 17.05.2006 passed by learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Majalgaon in Sessions Case No.30 of 2005, thereby
acquitting all the respondents herein from charges under Sections
143, 147, 148, 353, 333, 325 read with Section 149 of the Indian
Penal Code.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE PROSECUTION CASE
2.
The prosecution case, in brief, is that PW5 injured Baliram
Mhatre, working as a Gramsevak at Gram Panchayat Khadkideola,
was directed by the Tahsildar to convene a Gram Sabha on
17.02.2004. When he reached the venue near Hanuman temple, the
-3-
CriAppeal-718-2006
accused, namely, Nilkanth, Madhavrao, Santosh, Ashok @ Omprakash
and others alighted from the jeep. They started reprimanding PW5 on
account of Gramsabha convened by him near Hanuman temple in
village Nirmalwadi. Thereafter, accused persons abused him,
threatened him and assaulted him in connection with the said
meeting. Meanwhile, Revenue Inspector Gangadhar Panchal PW1 and
Talathi Sk. Wajir PW4, who were proceeding to attend the meeting,
were intercepted by the accused. Accused Nilkanth allegedly dragged
PW4 Talathi from his motorcycle, while accused Madhavrao, Santosh
and Ashok assaulted him with stones. When PW1 intervened, accused
Madhavrao allegedly threw a stone at him, causing a fracture injury
to his forearm. The injured public servants were thereafter rescued by
the villagers and taken to the hospital. PW1 Gangadhar Panchal
lodged report, on the basis of which crime was registered,
investigated and the accused persons were duly charge-sheeted and
tried for above referred offences vide Sessions Case No.30 of 2005.
The trial ended up in acquittal. Hence, the appeal by the State
questioning the judgment and order of acquittal.
SUBMISSIONS
On behalf of the appellant/State :3.
Learned APP would apprise this Court about the prosecution
case in trial Court and would also took this Court through the
-4-
CriAppeal-718-2006
evidence adduced by prosecution in trial Court and would submit that
there was cogent, convincing and clinching evidence in support of the
charges. That, there is injured witness account as well as eye witness
account. Evidence of such witnesses has remained
intact during
cross. There was no variance or inconsistencies. Therefore, according
to him, learned Trial Court ought to have accepted the story of
prosecution. He would submit that essential ingredients for attracting
the charges were available in the testimonies of above witnesses.
There is incorrect appreciation of available evidence in its correct
perspective resulting into acquittal and hence, he prays for allowing
the appeal.
On behalf of respondents/original accused Nos.1 to 12 :4.
Per contra, learned Counsel for the respondents would justify
the judgment and order of acquittal by submitting that prosecution
witnesses are inconsistent on material counts. Their evidence is full of
material omissions and contradictions and therefore, finding that
testimonies are unworthy of credence, learned trial Court rightly
refused to rely on the same and acquitted the accused.
EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIAL COURT
5.
PW1 – Gangadhar Panchal, Revenue/Circle Inspector, deposed
at Exhibit-45 that on 17.02.2004, he and PW4 Talathi proceeded on a
-5-
CriAppeal-718-2006
motorcycle to village Nirmalwadi to attend the Gram Panchayat
meeting. Near the village boundary, the accused intercepted their
vehicle, accused Nilkanth dragged PW4 from the motorcycle, while
the accused assaulted him with stones. When PW1 intervened,
accused Madhavrao threw stones at him, causing a fracture injury to
his hand as well as other injuries. He also stated that accused
Nilkanth kicked him and that, during scuffle, his gold chain and
Rs.600/- were allegedly taken away, while PW4’s wristwatch and pen
were also allegedly stolen. Villagers, including Udhav Maske,
intervened and rescued them. He stated that all the injured persons as
well as himself were taken to the hospital at Beed, where his
statement was recorded, on the basis of which FIR (Exh.46) was
lodged. His blood-stained clothes were subsequently seized under a
panchnama and identified by him. In his supplementary statement, he
specifically stated that accused Nilkanth, Madhavrao and Santosh had
participated in the incident, but he could not state about the
participation of the remaining accused. He further stated that the
accused were protesting against the Government representatives
attending the meeting, as they intended to prevent allotment of the
fair price shop.
.
While under cross-examination, PW1 admitted that the office of
the Group Gram Panchayat was situated at Karalwadi. That, he was
-6-
CriAppeal-718-2006
acquainted with the accused. That, the incident occurred about 15–20
feet from the village boundary and that, 5–6 female members were
also present in the mob. He admitted that he had no conversation
with accused Nilkanth, Santosh and Madhavrao at the spot and had
no prior animosity with them. He further admitted that the assault
lasted about 5–10 minutes. That, except Udhav Maske he could not
recall the other persons who had gathered at the spot, and that, he
was travelling as a pillion rider. Further, he admitted that the
allegations regarding snatching of his golden chain and amount of
Rs.600/-, theft of wristwatch and pen of PW4 and the reason for their
being questioned by the accused were not stated in the FIR and were
brought on record subsequently in his supplementary statement. He
also admitted that the seizure panch witness Dattatraya was his son.
The suggestions put to him on behalf of defence that the alleged
incident had not occurred, that the complaint was false, and that he
was deposing falsely in collusion with Sarpanch Dilip Wani were
specifically denied by him.
6.
PW2 is the acquaintance of PW1 complainant, who at
Exhibit-49 deposed that, he witnessed the accused Madhavrao,
Nilkanth and others assaulting Gramsevak Baliram Mhatre and
intervened to rescue him. Thereafter, when the PW1 and PW4 arrived
-7-
CriAppeal-718-2006
on a motorcycle for official work relating to the fair-price shop, the
accused intercepted their motorcycle and assaulted them by pelting
stones. He stated that Nilkanth, Santosh, Madhavrao and Ashok @
Omprakash assaulted PW1, while PW4 also sustained injuries. PW2
intervened and rescued both officials, who were thereafter taken to
the hospital. He identified accused Nos.1 to 4 as the assailants, but
stated that he could not speak about the involvement of remaining
accused.
.
While under cross-examination, he admitted his relationship
with Sarpanch Dilip Wani.
Further, he admitted that there were
school and houses situated near the place of incident and that 7 to 8
persons had gathered during the assault on Gramsevak. He further
admitted that 8 to 10 persons, including women, were present during
the assault on PW1 and PW4, some of whom attempted to intervene,
but he could not recognize them. He also admitted having met the
police before recording his statement on 19.02.2004, though he
stated that he had no occasion to disclose the incident to them. He
admitted having stated to the police that accused Santosh assaulted
PW1 and PW4. He denied the defence case that the prosecution
witnesses, including Sarpanch Dilip Wani and his relatives, had
assaulted accused Omprakash @ Ashok with an axe and that the
present case was falsely lodged on account of such incident or
-8-
CriAppeal-718-2006
because of his relationship with the Sarpanch.
7.
PW3, who is the acquaintance of PW1 and PW4, deposed at
Exhibit-50 that on 17.02.2004, he saw accused Madhavrao, Nilkanth,
Omprakash @ Ashok and Santosh assaulting Gramsevak Mhatre near
the temple to prevent the Gram Sabha. He rescued Mhatre. He
thereafter saw Madhavrao, Santosh and Nilkanth assaulting PW1 and
PW4 at the village boundary by stones. He stated that Nilkanth
assaulted PW4 with stone as well as Madhavrao also assaulted PW1
with stone and inflicted injuries at his hand, head etc. and identified
the accused Madhavrao, Nilkanth, Omprakash and Santosh before the
Court. Further, he stated that rest of the accused were seen standing
on the spot of incident.
.
While under cross-examination, he admitted that he belonged
to NCP and the accused belonged to BJP. He also admitted that
Madhavrao was the previous Sarpanch and his wife had contested
against PW-3 in the year 2000. He also admitted that no Gram Sabha
was held from 2000 till the incident and that a chargesheet had been
filed against him and Bandu concerning the assault on Omprakash on
17.02.2004. Further, there are material omissions regarding his
presence at the spot, his intervention in the incident, the role
attributed to Udhav Mhaske, the allegation that Ashok had torn the
-9-
CriAppeal-718-2006
shirt of the Gramsevak, and the circumstances surrounding the entire
incident, including as to who had pelted stones, were brought on
record through PW7. He denied the suggestion that his deposition
was motivated by any political motive or that he was deposing falsely.
He also denied the defence suggestion regarding the existence of a
counter-case and the alleged assault on Omprakash with an axe.
8.
PW4 is the Talathi, who at Exhibit-57 deposed that, pursuant to
the letter of Tahsildar, he was required to attend the Gram Sabha at
Nirmalwadi in connection with allotment of the Fair Price Shop. He
travelled with PW1 on a motorcycle and, near the village boundary,
saw accused Nilkanth, Madhavrao, Santosh and others approaching
with stones. He stated that Nilkanth intercepted them, abused him
and assaulted him with a stone, causing injury to his right hand. He
further stated that Nilkanth pushed PW1 aside and kicked him, while
Madhavrao assaulted PW1 with a stone on his back and right elbow.
Udhav Maske rescued them. He was admitted to hospital for about
two days and identified Nilkanth and Madhavrao before the Court.
.
While under cross-examination, he admitted that he received
the letter on 13.02.2004 and he left village Deola at about 11.00 a.m.
He stated that he was not familiar with Udhav Maske and could not
speak about the persons who were present as onlookers. Omissions
-10-
CriAppeal-718-2006
were brought on record regarding the presence of Santosh in the
mob, the kick allegedly given by Nilkanth to PW1, and the stone blow
allegedly given by Madhavrao on the back of PW1. He could not
explain the omissions. He denied knowledge of or participation in the
alleged assault on Omprakash with an axe and denied that the
complaint was lodged falsely to compel withdrawal of the case.
9.
PW5, is the Gramsevak, who at Exhibit-59 deposed that,
Tahsildar had directed him to hold the Gram Sabha and that he had
issued the requisite publication and letters. He reached Nirmalwadi
on 17.02.2004, went to the house of Sarpanch and thereafter
proceeded towards the venue near Maruti temple. A jeep arrived
carrying 8-9 persons including Nilkanth, Madhavrao, Ashok and
Santosh. According to him, accused Nilkanth abused him and told
him not to hold the Gram Sabha and assaulted him on the head with
a chappal. Accused Ashok and Santosh caught hold of him, while
Madhavrao assaulted him with shoes and they attempted to tear his
shirt. One Udhav Maske rescued him. He was taken to hospital and
the Gram Sabha could not be held. He identified accused Nos.1 to 4.
.
While under cross-examination, he admitted that he had been
suspended by the BDO on an earlier occasion and that he had
received a letter directing that the Gram Sabha be held at Karalwadi
-11-
CriAppeal-718-2006
instead of Nirmalwadi. He admitted that Udhav Maske and Tukaram
Wani accompanied him to the venue and that several villagers,
including female members, were present. A material omission was
proved regarding the chappal blow allegedly given by Nilkanth.
Another material omission was proved regarding the allegation that
Ashok and Santosh had caught hold of him at the time of incident. He
could not explain the omissions. He denied the suggestions of false
deposition, forged documents, mala fides and the defence version
concerning the venue and counter-case.
10.
PW6, who is the acquaintance of accused, deposed at
Exhibit- 66 that, the incident occurred in front of the Maruti temple.
He deposed that Gramsevak and others, including Sarpanch, came to
the temple after taking tea. A jeep arrived carrying Nilkanth,
Madhavrao, Santosh and Ashok. Nilkanth abused Gramsevak for
arranging the Gram Sabha, and Nilkanth and Santosh assaulted him.
Accused Madhavrao attacked gramsevak Mhatre with shoes on his
head. He stated that he and Udhav intervened in the scuffle. Accused,
Nilkanth, Madhavrao, Santosh and Ashok also torned the clothes of
Gramsevak Mhatre. He further stated that he identified all the four
accused present before the Court.
.
While under cross-examination, he admitted that he was the
-12-
CriAppeal-718-2006
real brother of Sarpanch Dilip Wani and that there was political
rivalry between Dilip Wani and Nilkanth. He also admitted that Ashok
had sustained bleeding head injury and had lodged a complaint
against him, his brother and Gramsevak. He admitted that several
villagers were present but did not intervene. Omissions were proved
regarding his personal intervention and the presence of Sarpanch
accompanying Gramsevak to the temple. He stated nothing regarding
the assault on the PW1 and PW4. He denied the defence suggestions
that the case was false or that the Gramsevak's clothes were intact
and stated that he was unaware of the alleged assault on Ashok with
an axe.
11.
PW-7 is the Investigating Officer, who at Exhibit-67 deposed
regarding receipt of information about the incident, registration of the
FIR under Sections 147, 148, 353, 332 and 325 read with Section 149
of IPC, preparation of the spot panchnama, seizure of clothes,
recording of statements, collection of medical certificates and
investigation of the case. He stated that Section 395 of IPC was
initially added on the basis of supplementary statement of PW1.
During investigation, in absence of evidence against the accused
about the dacoity, he stated that he deleted the Section 395 of IPC
against accused. He collected the documents relating to the Gram
-13-
CriAppeal-718-2006
Sabha and filed the chargesheet for rest of offences.
.
While under cross-examination, he stated that he had not
recorded the statement of the Deola Police Patil, made no station
diary entry regarding the initial telephone information, did not record
statements of several witnesses on 17.02.2004 and 18.02.2004, and
did not record statements of nearby villagers, school teachers or
students. He also investigated the counter-case lodged by Ashok and
stated that Dilip Wani and Bandu Wani were charge-sheeted in that
case. Material omissions in the evidence of PW2 to PW6 were proved
through him. He denied suggestions that the FIR, addition of Section
395 of IPC and chargesheet were false or that he had acted at the
behest of Dilip Wani.
12.
PW8 is the medical expert. He deposed at Exhibit-70 regarding
the injuries sustained by PW1, PW4 and PW5. PW1 had a contusion
on the right forearm, fracture of the lower end of the right radius and
an abrasion on the face. The nature of fracture injuries was grievous.
PW4 had a CLW on the right elbow and PW5 had a contusion on the
left scalp, both the are stated to be simple in nature. He identified the
medical certificates issued by him.
.
While under cross-examination, he admitted that the injuries
were caused by hard and blunt objects and that the injuries of PW1
-14-
CriAppeal-718-2006
and PW4 could also be possible from a fall on a rough surface from a
motorcycle. He denied having issued false or spurious certificates or
deposing falsely. Rest is all denial.
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION
13.
Perused the record. As many as 12 accused persons were tried
vide above Sessions Case on the charge for offence under Sections
143, 147, 148, 353, 333, 325 read with Section 149 of IPC. The
occurrence has allegedly taken place on 17.02.2004. In short, it is the
case of prosecution that Tahsildar had directed Gramsevak Mhatre to
conduct meeting of villagers with regard to the allotment of Fair Price
Shop in the village and said meeting was scheduled on above date at
village Nirmalwadi. It is the case of prosecution that when Revenue
Inspector, Gangadhar Panchal PW1 and Talathi Sk. Wajir PW4 were
proceeding to attend the meeting on their motorcycle, on the
boundary of village Nirmalwadi itself, they were intercepted by a mob
and they were manhandled and assaulted by means of stones. The
case of the prosecution, to that extent, is sought to be established by
examining, in all, eight witnesses. The gist of the depositions of those
witnesses could be summarized as under:
PW1
Gangadhar Panchal at Exhibit-45 deposed that accused
Nilkanth dragged PW4 Talathi Sk. Wajir of the motorcycle and
-15-
CriAppeal-718-2006
hit him with stones, whereas Madhavrao threw a stone which
hit on his back as well as right hand and again Nilkanth kicked
him at his waist. However, so much of his testimony is not
reported by him in the FIR at his instance at Exhibit-46.
PW2
Udhav Mhaske at Exhibit-49 deposed that accused intercepted
the motorcycle, pelted stones and he named Santosh, Ashok,
Madhavrao and Nilkanth for beating PW1 Revenue Inspector
and he to be extricated.
PW3
Sarpanch Dilip, examined at Exhibit-50, testified that after the
assault on PW-5 Baliram Mhatre, he went home. Thereafter,
upon learning about the assault, he again rushed to the
boundary of the village and claims to have witnessed
Madhavrao, Santosh and Nilkanth assaulting PW1 and PW4.
PW4
Talathi Sk. Wajir is also a crucial witness who, at Exhibit-57,
testified that accused Nilkanth and Madhavrao, along with
others, came armed with stones. According to him, they
pushed the motorcycle, causing both the occupants to fall.
Thereafter, accused Nilkanth hit him with a stone and kicked
him on the waist, whereas accused Madhavrao assaulted him
with a stone.
CriAppeal-718-2006
-16-
PW5
Gramsevak Baliram Mhatre at Exhibit-59 deposed about
convening
meeting
and
according
to
him,
accused
Madhavrrao tried to remove his footwear to assault him.
PW6
Tukaram Wani, who is brother of Dilip Wani, at Exhibit-66
deposed that while he was sitting on the platform near Maruti
Temple, PW5 Baliram Mhatre and he himself were having tea
in the house of Dilip Wani and according to him, PW1
Gangadhar and PW4 Wajir were assaulted near Maruti
Temple, but he does not named any of the accused.
PW7
Investigating Officer, who at Exhibit-67, narrated all the steps
taken by him during investigation.
PW8
Medical Expert, at Exhibit-70, deposed regarding injuries
sustained by PW1, PW4 and PW5 and identified the medical
certificates issued by him.
14.
From above material, it is primarily emerging that witnesses are
not consistent on the role played by accused persons. Apparently, only
names of Madhavrao, Nilkanth, Santosh and Ashok are surfacing from
the testimonies of above witnesses. Therefore, only four persons are
identified and remaining are not identified. When there is charge of
-17-
CriAppeal-718-2006
Sections 147 and 148 of IPC, it is an essential and legal requirement
that five persons must be shown to be involved, but here it is not so.
As stated above, each of the above witness is attributing distinct role
even to accused Madhavrao, Nilkanth, Santosh and Ashok.
Even
when PW1 Gangadhar and PW4 Wajir are together, they are not
lending support to each other. Consequently, here, evidence is falling
short of formation of unlawful assembly, which requires five persons.
Only above named four persons are identified by witnesses.
Therefore, apparently, there is no formation of unlawful assembly. In
view of variance in the roles attributed to the named accused,
testimonies of above referred prosecution witnesses cannot be
straightaway accepted and relied.
15.
It is fairly settled position that mere presence at the scene of
riot or arrest from the spot does not by itself establish membership of
an unlawful assembly and law to this extent is fairly settled by catena
of judgments including recent judgment in the case of Dhirubhai
Bhailalbhai Chauhan and another vs. State of Gujarat and others,
[2025 SCC OnLine SC 601].
16.
Here, as stated above, required strength of five persons is not
met to attract unlawful assembly. Prosecution seems to have invoked
charge of Section 149 of IPC, but such liability cannot be presumed
CriAppeal-718-2006
-18-
merely by presence of a person in a mob, when common object and
participation is not proved beyond reasonable doubt. In support of
such legal proposition, reliance can be placed on the judgment of
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Musa Khan and others vs. State of
Maharashtra, (1977) 1 SCC 733.
17.
The cumulative effect of above discussion is that case of
prosecution is not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
18.
Perused the judgment under challenge. No infirmity or
perversity is brought to the notice of this Court so as to interfere.
Hence, the following order is passed :ORDER
.
Criminal Appeal is dismissed.
[ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.]
scm
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review