The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. 12.1997, 20 R. land from Gat No. 16 situated village Umerga Retu, Taluka Ahmedpur (at present Jalkot) was sold for Rs.63,000/- i.e. Rs. 3,15,000/- per H. Both the sale instances were prior to section 4 notification. The learned reference court has relied upon both the sale instances. As regards sale instance, Exh. 13 is concerned, the learned reference court has applied 1/4th deductions and as regards sale instance, Exh. 14 is concerned, the learned reference court has applied 1/3rd deduction and also deducted 15% more amount as towards one side of the land involved in sale instance, Exh. 14, there was Nala and after deducting FA 741/15 & Ors. the above amount, determined the market value of the acquired lands at the rate of Rs.1,88,000/- per H. There is no dispute about the fact that both the sale instances were from the same village and therefore, the reference court has considered plus and minus factors while determining the market value of the acquired lands. As regards sale instance, Exh. 13 is concerned, 50 R. land was sold for Rs.1,12,000/- and as per the said sale instance the rate comes to Rs.2,24,000/- per H. As per sale instance, Exh. 14, 20 R. land was sold for Rs.63,000/- and as per the said sale instance the rate comes to Rs.3,15,000/- per H. There was Nala towards one side of the land involved in sale instance, Exh. 14 and therefore, to make the said sale instanc…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:47011
FA 741/15 & Ors.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
334 FIRST APPEAL NO. 741 OF 2015
WITH
X-OBJECTION ST. NO. 24448 OF 2016
THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR, LATUR AND ANR
VERSUS
SHAIKH HAMMID KHADARSABHA
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 743 OF 2015
WITH
X-OBJECTION ST. NO. 24443 OF 2016
THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR, LATUR AND ANR
VERSUS
NAGNATH LAXMAN CHAME
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 742 OF 2015
WITH
X-OBJECTION ST. NO. 24447 OF 2016
THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR, LATUR AND ANR
VERSUS
SATISH SAMBHAJIRAO JADHAV
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 744 OF 2015
THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR, LATUR AND ANR
VERSUS
MOHAMMAD JAKIRA ALI
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 740 OF 2015
FA 741/15 & Ors.
WITH
X-OBJECTION ST. NO. 25295 OF 2016
THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR, LATUR AND ANR
VERSUS
MUBARAQMIYA VAHEYDMIYA DESHMUKH
…..
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 745 OF 2015
WITH
X-OBJECTION ST. NO. 22440 OF 2016
THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR, LATUR AND ANR
VERSUS
NIVRUTTI SUDAMA KAMBLE
...
AGP for Respondents/State in all matters : Mr. S.S. Dande
Advocate for respondents/Claimants in all matters: Mr. H.B. Nandagavale
…
341 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3362 OF 2016
WITH
X-OBJECTION ST. NO. 24526 OF 2016
THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR LATUR AND ANR
VERSUS
AVINASH UDHAV HASULE, MINOR THR. MOTHER LATABAI UDHAV HASULE
...
AGP for Respondents/State : Mr. A.M. Phule
Advocate for respondents/Claimants : Mr. H.B. Nandagavale
...
CORAM
: SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.
Dated
: September 30, 2026
PER COURT :1.
X-objection St. Nos. 24448, 24443, 2447, 25295, 22440 of 2016 are
not on board. Taken on board.
2.
As the acquisition proceeding is initiated in the year 1998, heard
FA 741/15 & Ors.
finally with the consent of learned AGP for appellants/State and Mr. H.B.
Nandagavale, learned counsel appearing for the original claimants in Xobjections.
3.
By these appeals, the appellants/State assails the judgments and
awards dated 3.5.2010 and 24.8.2010 passed by the learned Jt. Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Ahmedpur in LAR Nos. 121, 120, 117, 339, 123, 116 and
336 of 2004, whereby the learned reference court has enhanced the
compensation in favour of the original claimants at the rate of Rs.1,88,000/per H. The claimants also have filed cross objections, by contending that the
reference court has applied the deductions at higher side and determined
the rate.
4.
The lands of the claimants situated at village Sheldara and village
Umerga Retu, Tal. Jalkot, District Latur were acquired for the purpose of
construction of storage tank at Umerga Retu and Sheldara. Notification
under section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act came to be published
24.11.1998. Prior to that possession of the lands was taken through the
private negotiations on 17.5.1998. Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO)
declared award and has granted compensation at the rate of Rs.42,000/per H. and 47,000/- per H. The claimants accepted the amount under
protest and sought references under section 18 of the Act for enhancement
of compensation for their acquired lands.
5.
Before the reference court the claimants relied upon the sale
instance, dated 22.9.1997, by which 50 R. land from Gat No. 13 situated at
Umerga
Retu,
Taluka
Ahmedpur
(at
present
Jalkot)
was
sold
for
consideration of Rs. 1,12,000/- i.e. Rs.2,24,000/- per H. The claimants also
relied upon the sale instance dated 24.12.1997 by which 20 R. land from
FA 741/15 & Ors.
Gat No. 16 situated village Umerga Retu, Taluka Ahmedpur (at present
Jalkot) was sold for Rs.63,000/- i.e. Rs. 3,15,000/- per H. Those sale
instances are at Exhs. 13 and 14. Both the sale instances were prior to
section 4 notification and the learned reference court by relying upon those
sale instances determined the market value of the acquired lands at the rate
of Rs.1,88,000/- per H.
6.
Mr. H.B. Nandagavale, the learned counsel for the original claimants
submits that the SLAO has granted very meager compensation at the rate
of Rs.470/- per R., therefore, the claimants relied upon the sale instances,
Exhs. 13 and 14. The sale instance, Exh. 13 is dated 22.9.1997, by which
50 R. land from Gat No. 13 situated at Umerga Retu, Taluka Ahmedpur (at
present
Jalkot)
was
sold
for
consideration
of
Rs.
1,12,000/-
i.e.
Rs.2,24,000/- per H. The sale instance, Exh. 14 is dated 24.12.1997, by
which 20 R. land from Gat No. 16 situated village Umerga Retu, Taluka
Ahmedpur (at present Jalkot) was sold for Rs.63,000/- i.e. Rs. 3,15,000/per H. Both the sale instances were from the same village. The learned
reference court has relied upon both the sale instances. As regards sale
instance, Exh. 13 is concerned, the learned reference court has applied
1/4th deductions and as regards sale instance, Exh. 14 is concerned, the
learned reference court has applied 1/3rd deduction and also deducted 15%
more amount as towards one side of the land involved in sale instance, Exh.
14, there was Nala and after deducting the above amount determined the
market value of the acquired lands at the rate of Rs.1,88,000/- per H.
Therefore, he submits that once the reference court has observed that both
the sale instances are comparable sale instances, the reference court ought
to have granted compensation as claimed by the claimants.
7.
FA 741/15 & Ors.
Per contra, Mr. S.S. Dande and Mr. A.M. Phule, learned AGP for the
State vehemently submits that the learned reference court ought not to
have relied upon the sale instances, Exhs. 13 and 14, as those were in
respect of small piece of lands and therefore, the learned reference court
ought not to have considered those sale instances as comparable sale
instances, though they are from the same village.
8.
They further submit that as regards interest and other statutory
benefits are concerned, the reference court has granted the same from the
date of notification which is contrary to the law laid down by the full bench
of this Court in the case of State of Maharashtra vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari,
2016 (4) Mh.L.J. 457.
9.
Having heard the learned counsel for respective parties, with their
able assistance, I have gone through the record and proceedings and the
impugned judgment and award of the reference court. As per sale instance,
Exh. 13, dated 22.9.1997, 50 R. land from Gat No. 13 situated at Umerga
Retu, Taluka Ahmedpur (at present Jalkot) was sold for consideration of Rs.
1,12,000/- i.e. Rs.2,24,000/- per H. and as per sale instance, Exh. 14 dated
24.12.1997, 20 R. land from Gat No. 16 situated village Umerga Retu,
Taluka Ahmedpur (at present Jalkot) was sold for Rs.63,000/- i.e. Rs.
3,15,000/- per H. Both the sale instances were prior to section 4
notification. The learned reference court has relied upon both the sale
instances. As regards sale instance, Exh. 13 is concerned, the learned
reference court has applied 1/4th deductions and as regards sale instance,
Exh. 14 is concerned, the learned reference court has applied 1/3rd
deduction and also deducted 15% more amount as towards one side of the
land involved in sale instance, Exh. 14, there was Nala and after deducting
FA 741/15 & Ors.
the above amount, determined the market value of the acquired lands at
the rate of Rs.1,88,000/- per H. There is no dispute about the fact that both
the sale instances were from the same village and therefore, the reference
court has considered plus and minus factors while determining the market
value of the acquired lands. As regards sale instance, Exh. 13 is concerned,
50 R. land was sold for Rs.1,12,000/- and as per the said sale instance the
rate comes to Rs.2,24,000/- per H. As per sale instance, Exh. 14, 20 R. land
was sold for Rs.63,000/- and as per the said sale instance the rate comes to
Rs.3,15,000/- per H. There was Nala towards one side of the land involved
in sale instance, Exh. 14 and therefore, to make the said sale instance
comparable, 20% deductions would be proper deductions and after applying
20% deductions, the rate comes to Rs.2,52,000/- per H. Therefore, by
making round off the amount, I hold that the claimants are entitled to
receive compensation at the rate of Rs.2,50,000/- per H. Hence, I pass the
following order.
ORDER
(I)
The appeals filed by the State and the cross objections filed by the
claimants are partly allowed.
(II)
The claimants are entitled to receive compensation at the rate of
Rs.2,50,000/- per H. for their acquired lands.
(III)
The claimants shall be entitled to all consequential statutory benefits
including interest under sections 28 and 34 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 on the enhanced compensation in view of the judgment of Full Bench
of this Court in the case of State of Maharashtra vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari
(supra).
(IV)
The claimants shall pay the deficit court fee, if any, on the enhanced
FA 741/15 & Ors.
amount.
(V)
If there is delay in filing the cross objections, the claimants are not
entitled to receive interest and statutory benefits for the delayed period.
(V)
The impugned judgment and award of the reference court is modified
accordingly.
(VI)
Rest of the impugned award shall remain unaltered.
(VII) Pending civil application, if any, stands disposed of.
( SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J. )
ssc/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review