The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. The appeal is preferred with an inordinate delay of 329 days. In view of the settled legal principles of law when the delay and latches in filing the writ petitions/appeals cannot be brushed aside, otherwise, the same would amount to reviewing a dead/stale claim. the present appeal deserves to be dismissed on the ground of delay and latches alone. However, we deem it appropriate to deal 5:48:44 PM with the matter on merits as well.
10. It is an undisputed fact that respondent was given the pay scale of skilled helper Grade II and Grade I by the department itself. When the Joint Director Treasury and Accounts raised objection against the said pay revision from Grade III to Grade II and Grade I, the Executive Engineer issued show cause notices to similarly situated employees like that of the respondent and in the light of Circular dated 31.03.1984, concerned department cancelled the benefit of next higher pay scale granted to the respondents and other employees on the ground that there were no sanctioned posts, employees came up before this Court by filing petitions and succeeded. The order passed in the writ petition was thereafter challenged in writ appeal by the appellant/State and however, the appeal was dismissed by the Division Bench of this Court affirming the order passed in the writ petition. Under such circumstances, relying upon the orders passed in the cases of similarly situated employees, writ petition filed by the respondent herein has rightly been allowed by the learned Single Judge as the controversy involved has been affirmed by the Division Bench also. 11 . Since, co-ordinate Bench of this Court has already allowed writ petitions filed by similarly situated employees and the orders passed by the Single Judge have been affirmed by the Division Bench , this Court cannot take a different view th…
12. In the instant case, we have dealt with the issue of limitation and found that appeal is time barred by 347 days and thereafter, dealt with the 5:48:44 PM merits of the case as well and have arrived at a conclusion that no interference is warranted in the findings arrived at by the learned Single Judge while passing the order impugned in the light of the orders passed by this Court in case of similarly situated employees in writ petitions which were confirmed by the Division Bench of this Court also by dismissing the writ appeal filed by the appellant/State. 1 3 . Accordingly, this writ appeal being time barred and bereft of merits and substance is hereby dismissed on the ground of delay as well as merits. No order as to cost.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 24th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT APPEAL No. 188 of 2024
BETWEEN:1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH SECRETARY
PUBLIC HEALTH ENGINEERING VALLABH
BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
CHIEF ENGINEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENGINEERING
D EPARTM EN T MUSAKHEDI, DIST. INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
EXECUTIVE
ENGINEER
PUBLIC
HEALTH
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT DIVISION NO. 1
MANDLESHWAR
KHARGONE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
( SHRI BHUWAN GAUTAM - GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR THE
APPELLANTS/STATE)
AND
BIHARILAL KHANOD S/O SHRI KISHAN LAL, AGED
ABOUT 67 YEARS, OCCUPATION: RETIERED HELPER
CHOTI KHARGONE BEDIPURA WARD NO. 4 BHAWANI
CHOWK DISTT. KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( NONE PRESENT FOR THE RESPONDENT)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
ORDER
Heard on the question of admission.
Also heard on I.A. No. 590/2024, an application u/S 5 of the Limitation
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/25/2024
5:48:44 PM
Act seeking condonation of delay.
T his writ appeal under Section 2(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Uccha
Nyayalaya (Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 has been filed being
aggrieved by the order dated 04.11.2022 passed in Writ Petition No.23546/2022
whereby the writ petition filed by the respondent was allowed.
2. While arguing on I.A. seeking condonation of delay, learned counsel
for the appellants/State submitted that delay occurred in filing the present writ
appeal is bonafide as after being informed about the order passed in writ
petition, they have applied for certified copy of the order and on receipt of
certified copy of the order in the office, legal opinion was sought from the
Government Advocate vide letter dated 24.04.2023. The same was forwarded
to the higher authorities for necessary instructions and permission to file the
appeal which was granted on 16.06.2023. The OIC immediately collected the
entire record of the case and contacted
the AG Office, Indore
and on the
basis of record furnished by the OIC, appeal was prepared and presented
without any further delay.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant further contended that the delay is
genuine which has been caused due to procedural formalities and the same is
being bonafide on the part of the appellants. Therefore, delay of 347 days in
filing the appeal deserves to be condoned.
4. Learned counsel for the appellant/State submitted that respondent was
appointed in the office of Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering
Department Maintenance Division No.1 Mandleshwar vide order dated
20.12.1987 on the post of skilled Helper under the Work Charged and
Contingency Paid Establishment. A circular was issued by the Public Health
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/25/2024
5:48:44 PM
Engineering Department defining the name and number of sanctioned post in the
work charge establishment. The only post which was defined in the circular was
skilled helper and the respondent was appointed on the said post. The then
Superintending Engineer vide his order dtd 26.02.1997 has wrongly given the
pay scale of skilled helper Grade II to the petitioner and the Executive Engineer
granted the pay scale of Grade I Skilled Helper to the petitioner and other
employees. While considering the pension case of one of the employee, the
Joint Director, Treasury and Accounts, Indore raised an objection with regard
to grant of Pay revision from Grade III to Grade II and Grade I whereafter the
Executive Engineer issued show cause notice to all the employees on
13.02.2008. The Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering Department has
issued order dated 8.12.2015 whereby the benefit of next higher pay scale
granted to the petitioner and other similarly situated employees were cancelled
as there was no sanctioned post of wireless operator/skilled helper grade II and
I in the light of circular dated 31.03.1984 which provides that there is no
provision for grant of next higher pay scale to employees of work charged and
contingency paid establishment who have completed 5 and 10 years of service
without sanctioned post. It is submitted that respondent 's colleague has
preferred writ petition challenging the order passed by the department. which
was allowed relying on the point that upgradation was granted on account of
policy decision taken by the State Government which is evident from the order
dated 13.02.2008. Thereafter, petitioner has also preferred a writ petition which
was allowed taking into consideration the fact the the same order has been
challenged by other employees
in W.P. No. 8666/2015 and other connected
petitions which were allowed and impugned order was quashed entitling the
employees for all consequential benefits and the said order has been affirmed
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/25/2024
5:48:44 PM
by the Division Bench by dismissing the appeal filed by the State i.e. W.A. No.
1034/2018 vide order dated 27.09.2018.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant/State submitted that writ petition
was disposed without giving opportunity to the appellant/State to file reply. He
further submits that in such kind of case undertaking has also been taken by the
concerned department while granting higher pays scales /pay revisions so that
in case wrong or excess amount is being paid, the same would be recovered
from the concerned employees. Hence, the department has rightly passed the
order of recovery. However, the learned Single Judge has set aside the order of
recovery.
7. He further submits that learned Single Judge has erred in appreciating
that in the Public Health Engineering Department, the service circular only
provides for the service of skilled helper and there are no bifurcations or
separate post having been provided for Wireless Operator/Skilled Helper Grade
III or Grade I. Learned Single Judge has also not appreciated the fact that
respondent is eligible for the higher pay scale only in the light of policy rules
framed by the State Government in the year 2016 wherein there is no sanctioned
post on which respondent can be promoted. Hence, the appeal deserves to be
allowed by setting aside the order passed by the Single Judge.
8. Heard, learned counsel for the appellant and perused the record.
9. The appeal is preferred with an inordinate delay of 329 days. In view
of the settled legal principles of law when the delay and latches in filing the writ
petitions/appeals cannot be brushed aside, otherwise, the same would amount
to reviewing a dead/stale claim. the present appeal deserves to be dismissed on
the ground of delay and latches alone. However, we deem it appropriate to deal
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/25/2024
5:48:44 PM
with the matter on merits as well.
10. It is an undisputed fact that respondent was given the pay scale of
skilled helper Grade II and Grade I by the department itself. When the Joint
Director Treasury and Accounts raised objection against the said pay revision
from Grade III to Grade II and Grade I, the Executive Engineer issued show
cause notices to similarly situated employees like that of the respondent and in
the light of Circular dated 31.03.1984, concerned department cancelled the
benefit of next higher pay scale granted to the respondents and other employees
on the ground that there were no sanctioned posts, employees came up before
this Court by filing petitions and succeeded. The order passed in the writ
petition was thereafter challenged in writ appeal by the appellant/State and
however, the appeal was dismissed by the Division Bench of this Court
affirming the order passed in the writ petition. Under such circumstances,
relying upon the orders passed in the cases of similarly situated employees, writ
petition filed by the respondent herein has rightly been allowed by the learned
Single Judge as the controversy involved has been affirmed by the Division
Bench also.
11 . Since, co-ordinate Bench of this Court has already allowed writ
petitions filed by similarly situated employees and the orders passed by the
Single Judge have been affirmed by the Division Bench , this Court cannot take
a different view than the one taken by coordinate Bench as it would be
prejudicial in the interest of respondent as he is also on the same footing as that
of other employees
therefore, the order impugned does not called for any
interference by this Court.
12.
In the instant case, we have dealt with the issue of limitation and
found that appeal is time barred by 347 days and thereafter, dealt with the
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/25/2024
5:48:44 PM
merits of the case as well and have arrived at a conclusion that no interference is
warranted in the findings arrived at by the learned Single Judge while passing the
order impugned in the light of the orders passed by this Court in case of
similarly situated employees in writ petitions which were confirmed by the
Division Bench of this Court also by dismissing the writ appeal filed by the
appellant/State.
1 3 .
Accordingly, this writ appeal being time barred and bereft of
merits and substance is hereby dismissed on the ground of delay as well as
merits. No order as to cost.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
sh
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/25/2024
5:48:44 PM
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review