Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 44 of 2026
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Department of Health,
officiating from his office at ‘Project Bhawan’, P.O and P.S Jaganathpur,
Dist-Ranchi.
2. Deputy Commissioner, Deoghar, officiating from his office at O/o Deputy
Commissioner, Collectorate Building, P.O and P.S Deoghar, DistrictDeoghar.
3. Circle Officer, Deoghar, officiating from his office at Collectorate
Building, P.O and P.S Deoghar, District- Deoghar.
…. …
Appellants
Versus
Baba Baidyanath Medical Trust, having its principal office at DD-5,
Dhawandeep Building, Jantar Matar Road, P.O GPO, P.S Jantar Mantar, DistNew Delhi-110001 through its authorized representative Pankaj Kumar S/o
Shankar Prasad Keshri, aged about 37 years R/o Lawalong, Bazar Tand, P.O
and P.S Lawalong, District-Deoghar.
…. …
Respondent
With
L.P.A. No. 229 of 2026
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Department of Health,
officiating from his office at ‘Project Bhawan’, P.O and P.S Jaganathpur,
Dist-Ranchi.
2. Deputy Commissioner, Deoghar, officiating from his office at O/o Deputy
Commissioner, Collectorate Building, P.O and P.S Deoghar, DistrictDeoghar.
3. Circle Officer, Deoghar, officiating from his office at Collectorate
Building, P.O and P.S Deoghar, District- Deoghar.
…. …
Appellants
Versus
Baba Baidyanath Medical Trust, having its principal office at DD-5,
Dhawandeep Building, Jantar Matar Road, P.O GPO, P.S Jantar Mantar, DistNew Delhi-110001 through its authorized representative Pankaj Kumar S/o
Shankar Prasad Keshri, aged about 37 years R/o Lawalong, Bazar Tand, P.O
and P.S Lawalong, District-Deoghar.
…. …
Respondent
With
L.P.A. No. 242 of 2026
M/s Paritran Medical College & Hospital through its Secretary, Shivdutt
Sharma, aged about 57 years, son of Sri Jwala Prasad Singh (Trustee), resident
of Amardham Lane, Castair Town, Bawan Bigha, P.O. & P.S.- Deoghar,
District- Deoghar, Jharkhand.
... ... Appellant
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Department of Health,
officiating from his office at ‘Project Bhawan’, P.O and P.S Jaganathpur,
Dist-Ranchi.
2. Deputy Commissioner, Deoghar, officiating from his office at O/o Deputy
Commissioner, Collectorate Building, P.O and P.S Deoghar, DistrictDeoghar.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
3. Circle Officer, Deoghar, officiating from his office at Collectorate
Building, P.O and P.S Deoghar, District- Deoghar.
4. Baba Baidyanath Medical Trust, having its principal office at DD-5,
Dhawandeep Building, Jantar Matar Road, P.O GPO, P.S Jantar Mantar,
Dist-New Delhi-110001 through its authorized representative Pankaj
Kumar, son of Shankar Prasad Keshri, aged about 37 years R/o Lawalong,
Bazar Tand, P.O and P.S Lawalong, District-Deoghar.
…. …
Respondents
-----CORAM : HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
-----L.P.A.Nos. 44 & 229 of 2026
For the Appellants
:
Mr Manoj Kumar, GA-III
Mr Aditya Raman, AC to GA-III
For the Respondent
:
Mr Ajit Kumar, Sr. Advocate
Mr Parth Jalan, Advocate
Ms Shivani Jaluka, Advocate
Mr Akash Ajit Kumar, Advocate
L.P.A.No. 242 of 2026
For the Appellant
:
Mr Atanu Banerjee, Advocate
Mr Aditya Banerjee, Advocate
For the Resp. Nos. 1 to 3 :
Ms Rishi Bharti, AC to AAG-III
For the Resp. No. 4
:
Mr Ajit Kumar, Sr. Advocate
Mr Parth Jalan, Advocate
Ms Shivani Jaluka, Advocate
Mr Akash Ajit Kumar, Advocate
----11 /Dated: 15.07.2026
1.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
2.
These three Letters Patent Appeals were joined together because they
concern the same property and the issues largely overlap. Accordingly, the
learned Counsel for the parties agreed that it would be appropriate to dispose
of all these appeals by a common judgment and order.
3.
L.P.A. Nos. 44 of 2026 and 242 of 2026 challenge the learned Single
Judge’s judgment and order dated 03.11.2025 disposing of W.P.(C) No. 668
of 2025.
4.
W.P.(C) No. 668 of 2025 was instituted by Baba Baidyanath Medical
Trust (for short ‘BBMT’) to challenge the orders dated 04.12.2025 and
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
07.01.2025, under which the Circle Officer, Deoghar, rejected its application
for mutation.
5.
W.P.(C) No. 668 of 2025 was allowed by the learned Single Judge’s
impugned order dated 03.11.2025. The two orders dated 04.12.2025 and
07.01.2025 were quashed and set aside, and the Circle Officer, Deoghar, was
directed to complete the mutation process by making the necessary entry in
Register-II and to issue revenue rent receipts in favour of BBMT within four
weeks of receipt or production of a copy of this order.
6.
Surprisingly, the State has appealed the impugned order dated
03.11.2025, which concerns the mutation and the recording of BBMT’s name
in the revenue records in place of Paritran Medical College and Hospital (for
short ‘PMCH’), the appellant in L.P.A. No. 242 of 2026. Since PMCH was
not impleaded as a respondent in W.P.(C) No. 668 of 2025, it has, after
obtaining leave of this Court, instituted L.P.A. No. 242 of 2026 to challenge
the very same impugned order dated 03.11.2025 disposing of W.P.(C) No.
668 of 2025.
7.
The BBMT, which proposes to establish a Medical College on the
property that is the subject of these appeals, had applied for an essentiality
certificate to the State Government because such a certificate is one of the
requirements for approval by the N.M.C. to establish and operate a Medical
College. This application was not being considered and disposed of by the
State Government, thereby forcing the BBMT to institute W.P.(C) No. 662 of
2025.
8.
By a separate order also dated 03.11.2025, the learned Single Judge
allowed W.P. (C) No. 662 of 2025 and directed the Deputy Commissioner,
Deoghar, to complete the land verification process and issue an essentiality
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
certificate to BBMT within four weeks thereafter. The State, aggrieved by this
order, has instituted L.P.A. No. 229 of 2026.
9.
Mr Manoj Kumar, learned G.A.-III for the State, which is the appellant
in L.P.A. No. 44 of 2026 and L.P.A. No. 229 of 2026, submitted that BBMT’s
W.P.(C) No. 668 of 2025 should not have been entertained by the learned
Single Judge because BBMT had an alternate and efficacious remedy of an
appeal under the Bihar Tenant’s Holding (Maintenance of Record) Act, 1973.
10.
Mr Manoj Kumar further submitted that the land in question was Mul
Raiyati land and therefore, no mutation could be carried out in respect of such
land without due permission from the competent authority, i.e. Sub-Divisional
Officer, Deoghar. He also submitted that the transfer of such land, though
involuntarily, from PMCH to BBMT through a public auction cannot defeat
the provisions of the Santhal Pargana Tenancy Act, 1949 and the reliance on
the Santhal Pargana Manual, 2011 was incorrect. He submitted that such
auction proceeding, therefore, cannot vest any absolute title in BBMT.
11.
Mr Manoj Kumar further submitted that there was no evidence about
the change of user of the land and the findings to that effect in the impugned
order warrant interference. He also argued that since the sale letter was not
registered under Section 89 of the Registration Act, such sale letter could
never have been relied upon by the BBMT to insist upon mutation in their
favour.
12.
Mr Manoj Kumar submitted that since all these crucial aspects have not
been considered by the learned Single Judge or, in any event, not being
correctly considered by the learned Single Judge, the impugned order dated
03.11.2025 allowing W.P.(C) No. 668 of 2025 warrants interference.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
13.
Mr Atanu Banerjee, learned counsel for the PMCH, which is the
appellant in L.P.A. No. 242 of 2026, while adopting the submissions of Mr
Manoj Kumar in their entirety, submitted that the so-called sale in favour of
BBMT is still not finalised, because PMCH’s Chamber Appeal is still
pending. He submitted that the auction sale was in fact challenged by PMCH
before this Court, but the petition was not entertained for want of alternate
remedy. He submitted that PMCH did avail of such alternate remedy.
However, the registration of PMCH’s appeal before the Debt Recovery
Tribunal (DRT) was incorrectly refused by its Registrar. He submitted that,
against the refusal of registration, PMCH has filed a Chamber Appeal, which
to date has not been disposed of. He submitted that in such circumstances,
BBMT cannot claim any rights based on the auction sale and insist upon
mutation.
14.
Mr Banerjee submitted that in any event, there are issues of land being
Mul Raiyati and there was no permission from the Competent Authority for
the transfer of such land. He further submitted that PMCH was a necessary
party to W.P.(C) No. 668 of 2025 and in its absence, the impugned order could
not have been made.
15.
For all the above reasons, Mr Banerjee submitted that the impugned
order dated 03.11.2025 disposing of W.P.(C) No. 668 of 2025 deserves to be
interfered with in L.P.A. Nos. 44 of 2026 and 242 of 2026.
16.
Mr Ajit Kumar, learned senior counsel appearing for BBMT, first
questioned the propriety of the State Government challenging orders in a
matter of mutation. Secondly, he submitted that his arguments about the land
being Mul Raiyati or the absence of prior permission from the Competent
Officers were not the grounds in the orders dated 04.12.2025 and 07.01.2025,
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
by which the mutation applications were rejected. He submitted that the
authorities cannot add fresh grounds when the original order is challenged. He
relied upon the principle in Mohinder Singh Gill Vs. Chief Election
Commissioner (1978) 1 SCC 405.
17.
Mr Ajit Kumar submitted that the PMCH had mortgaged the property
in question to a bank to secure a loan. After it defaulted, the bank obtained a
decree for approximately Rs. 1.41 crores. Since no payments were made, the
bank auctioned the property. Almost nine attempts were made, all of which
failed. On the 10th attempt, BBMT purchased the property for valuable
consideration. Mr Kumar submitted that, at the time of the auction, the
property was recorded in the revenue records in the name of PMCH. He
therefore submitted that it is only proper that the revenue authorities now
mutate the property in the name of BBMT. He submitted that several attempts
by PMCH to question the auction sale have been made, but without success
before this Court, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, or the DRT. He submitted that,
in such circumstances, there is no question of PMCH now raising such
objections in mutation proceedings or before this Court.
18.
Mr Ajit Kumar submitted that the frivolous objections regarding the
land being Mul Raiyati or the absence of permission from the Competent
Authorities for transfer applied equally at the stage when mutations were
affected in favour of PMCH. He submitted that, at the very least, PMCH
should now cease raising objections before this Court or the revenue
authorities. He further submitted that, in any event, such permissions had been
obtained and that the State had also issued an essentiality certificate to PMCH
in the past to establish a medical college on the same land.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
19.
Mr Ajit Kumar submitted that the State, challenging orders in a case of
mutation, or the borrower, despite failing to succeed in challenges to the
auction sale, objecting to mutation favouring BBMT, amounts to an abuse of
the judicial process and, therefore, these L.P.As. must be dismissed with
exemplary costs.
20.
Insofar as, L.P.A. No. 229 of 2026 is concerned, Mr Manoj Kumar,
learned GA-III submitted that until the issue of title verification was
concluded, there was no question of issuing any writ of mandamus to the State
to grant the essentiality certificate. He submitted that there was a serious issue
about BBMT’s title, as was pointed out in the arguments concerning L.P.A.
No. 44 of 2026.
21.
Without prejudice, Mr Manoj Kumar submitted that the learned Single
Judge had exceeded jurisdiction in issuing the mandamus for grant of the
essentiality certificate because admittedly, BBMT’s application for issue of
essentiality certificate had never been rejected by the State Government and
it was BBMT’s case that the same was kept pending for an unreasonable
length of time. He submitted without prejudice that in such circumstances, the
maximum relief that could have been granted to BBMT was a direction to the
State to consider and dispose of BBMT’s application for essentiality
certificate within some reasonable period in accordance with law.
22.
Mr Ajit Kumar, learned senior advocate for the BBMT, submitted that
the arguments regarding title verification are frivolous and that, for almost
eleven months, no decision was taken on BBMT’s application for an
essentiality certificate. He reiterated that BBMT is an auction purchaser and
that the State cannot, for frivolous reasons, reject mutation and then urge a
defect in BBMT’s title as a ground for rejecting the essentiality certificate. He
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
further submitted that the State had also issued an essentiality certificate to
PMCH in the past to establish a medical college on the same land.
Accordingly, he submitted that there was no error if a direction was issued by
the learned Single Judge in its order dated 03.11.2025 disposing of W.P.(C)
No. 662 of 2025.
23.
The rival contentions now fall for our determination.
24.
In this case, there is no dispute that PMCH had acquired the ownership
of the land which is the subject matter of these appeals and mortgaged the
same in favour of the bank for securing a loan of Rs. 93.00 crore or above.
There is also no dispute that the PMCH defaulted in the payment of such loan,
prompting the bank to file O.A. No. 154 of 2013 before the Debt Recovery
Tribunal (DRT). This was allowed, and the certificate of recovery for an
amount of Rs. 141.00 crores (approximately) was issued for recovery of the
said amount from the PMCH.
25.
The record shows that a one-off settlement proposal was offered to
PMCH, but PMCH failed to avail itself of it. The record further shows that
PMCH was unable to deposit even the upfront payment of Rs. 5.00 crores to
avail itself of the OTS proposal.
26.
The record also shows that, in all, no less than 10 public auctions were
held for the enforcement of the recovery certificate of Rs. 141.00 crores
against PMCH. Nine auctions failed. However, in the 10th auction held on 20th
December, 2023, BBMT was declared as the successful bidder.
27.
To stall the sale, PMCH instituted W.P(C) No. 165 of 2024 before this
Court on 12.01.2024. This petition challenged the order by which PMCH’s
offer to make upfront payment of Rs. 6.00 crore and further settle the liability
by paying Rs. 60.00 crores were rejected. The Recovery Officer noted that
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
whenever the property was auctioned, PMCH came up with a fresh proposal
for settlement, but never actually settled the matter.
28.
During the pendency of W.P (C) No. 165 of 2024, a certificate of sale
was issued in favour of BBMT. Possession of the property was also handed
over to BBMT. W.P (C) No. 165 of 2024 was dismissed on the ground that
PMCH had an alternate and efficacious remedy before the DRT.
29.
PMCH challenged the dismissal of W.P (C) No. 165 of 2024 by
instituting L.P.A No. 167 of 2024. Even this was dismissed on 08.08.2024.
30.
Undeterred, PMCH instituted Special Leave Petition (Diary) No. 49186
of 2024 challenging the order dated 08.08.2024 dismissing LPA No. 167 of
2024. On 10.12.2024, the Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissed this SLP.
31.
After all this, PMCH approached the DRT by instituting an appeal
bearing No. E.D.R.T No. 87 of 2025. However, PMCH failed to make the
required pre-deposit, and therefore the registration of this appeal was refused
on 30.06.2025. PMCH now claims to have filed a Chamber Appeal No. 02 of
2025 against this appeal, which is stated to be pending.
32.
From the above narration of events, it is apparent that, at least as of
now, the sale certificate dated 23.01.2024 issued in favour of the BBMT has
attained finality, as PMCH’s challenges before various fora to date have not
met with any significant success.
33.
PMCH’s L.P.A. No. 242 of 2026 has therefore to be construed in the
background of the above facts which unmistakably show that PMCH is
making all out efforts to see that the property it had mortgaged cannot be
enjoyed by the subsequent purchaser at a public auction. This L.P.A is also
an attempt in the same direction.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
34.
It is inexplicable how the PMCH is today raising the issue of the
property being Mul Raiyati and that permissions are required for its transfer
when PMCH obtained a mutation in its favour despite the existence of such
so-called objection. PMCH transferred the property by way of mortgage in
favour of the bank and at that time, PMCH had no qualms about alleged
compliance with the provisions of the Santhal Pargana Tenancy Act, 1949 or
any such objections.
35.
Mr Ajit Kumar points out that at that stage, PMCH relied upon the
specific permission / NOC granted by the competent authorities of the State
Government and therefore, now, it is too late for either the State Government
or PMCH to raise such pleas and resist mutation in favour of BBMT.
36.
The arguments about want of registration, the sale not having attained
finality for the alleged breach of procedures during the auction process, the
impact of tenancy legislations, etc. are precisely the grounds that were urged
by BBMT before this Court and now in the appeal before the DRT. As noted
above, the proceedings before this Court were dismissed due to nonexhaustion of alternate remedies, and the appeal before the DRT was not even
registered for failure to comply with the precondition of deposit. The
pendency of a chamber appeal against registration cannot be stretched too far
to claim that the sale to BBMT has not attained finality thus far. The PMCH,
it appears, wants to keep the pot boiling, as a springboard to object to the
BBMT from enjoying the property it has acquired at a public auction.
37.
Therefore, based on the above objections, BBMT’s application for
mutation could not have been rejected. To be fair, the impugned orders
rejecting the BBMT’s mutation application (which BBMT challenged by
filing W.P (C) No. 668 of 2025) did not refer to such grounds. The State, when
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
defending those orders, and the PMCH, when assailing such orders, have now
raised all such grounds.
38.
Therefore, the learned Single Judge, in the impugned order dated
03.11.2025, has correctly invoked the principle in Mohinder Singh Gill
(Supra) which states that whenever a statutory functionary makes an order
based on certain grounds, its validity must be judged by the reason so
mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in the shape of an
affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order bad in the beginning may, by the
time it comes to the Court on account of a challenge, get validated by
additional grounds later brought about.
39.
The State’s argument about an alternative remedy also does not merit
much credence in the gross facts of the present case. Firstly, the rule that an
alternative remedy must be exhausted is only a self-imposed restriction on the
exercise of powers by this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Secondly, in the facts of the present case, where the application for mutation
was rejected on ex facie irrelevant grounds and relevant grounds, such as the
auction sale having attained finality, were sought to be completely ignored,
we cannot fault the discretion exercised by the learned Single Judge in
entertaining W.P(C) No. 668 of 2025 rather than relegating BBMT to the
alternative remedy of appeal.
40.
In this case, there was never any dispute that the land in question was
mutated in favour of PMCH. There is also no dispute that PMCH mortgaged
the land to the bank as a security for repayment of the loan. PMCH defaulted
in payment of this loan and therefore, the bank, after following all the due
procedures, sold this property through a public auction. BBMT was declared
as a successful auction purchaser.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
41.
Considering the above undisputed facts, the limited jurisdiction
conferred on the revenue authorities, and the fact that revenue entries are
mainly for fiscal purposes, the authorities could not have rejected BBMT’s
application for mutation. The revenue authority ignored the permissions
granted for transfer of the same land earlier and that a mutation was carried
out without raising all such objections in favour of PMCH. The record shows
that the PMCH was bent on frustrating the sale by auction and was creating
repeated hurdles to the BBMT's enjoyment of the property, but it is surprising
that the State should also join the BBMT in this misadventure.
42.
The Learned Single Judge has relied on the decision in Sahid Anwar
versus the State of Jharkhand and others in W.P (C) No. 1378 of 2016, in
which this Court has held as follows:
“8. It is an admitted position that though the land in question
was originally recorded as ‘Gair Mazarua Khas’ in the
Revisional Survey Records of Right and the Jamabandi in
respect of the said land had been running in the name of
Mehboob Ali and the vendor of the petitioner, namely, Gulam
Rasool. On the basis of the said Jamabandi, the respondents all
along accepted the rent and recognized the predecessors-ininterest of the petitioner as raiyats in respect of the said land
since long. The petitioner is a purchaser of the said land. After
purchasing the said land, he applied for mutation in his favour
before the Circle Officer, Kasmar, Bokaro (the respondent
No.6), however, the same was kept pending since 2013. Though
the said land is recorded as ‘Gair Mazarua Khas’ in the
Revisional Survey Records of Right, the State had recognized
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
the tenancy right of the processors-in-interest of the petitioner
by accepting the rent for last several decades. Their names had
been running in the Tenant’s Ledger/Register II maintained in
the Circle Office since long without objection from any quarter.
The respondent No.6 is not the authority to decide the right, title
and interest of any person over the land while deciding the
mutation case or granting the rent receipt. The respondents
have not disputed that the petitioner is not in possession of the
said land. Merely because the land was recorded as ‘Gair
Mazarua Khas’ in the Revisional Survey Records of Right does
not permit the Circle Officer to deny the mutation.”
43.
Further, the learned Single Judge has also relied upon the decision in
the case of Anil Kumar Bajaj versus State of Jharkhand and others [2024
SCC Online Jharkhand 4097], where this Court has held that the mutation
is not a judicial or quasi-judicial exercise, but an administrative exercise. The
purpose of mutation is simply to ascertain who is to pay rent to the public
exchequer and such entries are relevant for fiscal purposes.
44.
Accordingly, we find no merit whatsoever in LPA No. 44 of 2026
instituted by the State Government and LPA No. 242 of 2026 instituted by
PMCH challenging the learned Single Judge’s order dated 03.11.2025
disposing of W.P (C) No. 668 of 2025. Such appeals are liable to be dismissed
and are hereby dismissed.
45.
Insofar as, the LPA No. 229 of 2026 is concerned, we note that BBMT’s
application seeking an essentiality certificate was made on 10th of December,
2024. For a considerable period, or rather, for an unreasonable period, since
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
no decision was taken on such application, BBMT was forced to institute
W.P(C) No. 662 of 2025.
46.
In W.P(C) No. 662 of 2025, learned Government Advocate-III
appearing on behalf of the State raised strong objection to the prayers made
in the said writ petition by submitting that the application made by BBMT for
grant of essentiality certificate was ‘under consideration’.
47.
The learned Government Advocate-III relied on the counter affidavit
filed on 10.10.2025 and submitted that the State had almost completed all
formalities for grant of essentiality certificate, but due to want of proper
verification of the title of the land, no decision could be taken on the issue of
essentiality certificate.
48.
On behalf of the State Government, several decisions were cited in
support of the proposition that grant of essentiality certificate is not a
Ministerial act but is a quasi-judicial function and therefore, the authority is
bound to take a reasoned decision before granting essentiality certificate.
49.
The learned Single Judge in the impugned order dated 03.11.2025, at
paragraph 13, noted that the short issue involved in the instant writ petition
was as to whether the respondent authority was justified in keeping the
application filed by the petitioner (BBMT) for grant of essentiality certificate
pending and then urging the ground in the counter affidavit that the land
verification is required to be carried out before such certificate is issued.
50.
Learned Single Judge agreed with the State’s contention that the grant
of essentiality certificate was not a simple Ministerial process. However, after
agreeing with this, the learned Single Judge rightly noted that the authority
cannot keep the application for grant of essentiality certificate pending for an
unreasonable length of time.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
51.
There is no reason for us to take any different view on the proposition
that an application for essentiality certificate by any party must be disposed
of within a reasonable time. We note that starting a medical college involves
a tedious process. Timelines have to be adhered to. Therefore, the authorities
are expected to dispose of the application seeking an essentiality certificate
within a reasonable period. No doubt, what constitutes a reasonable period
would depend on the facts and circumstances of each case.
52.
The absence of a statutory time limit for disposing of applications for
essentiality certificates does not authorise the Authorities to keep such
applications pending for an unreasonable period. In these circumstances, the
learned Single Judge would have been justified in issuing a mandamus
directing the Deputy Commissioner, who is reported to be an appropriate
authority, to complete the land verification and then dispose of the BBMT’s
application for an essentiality certificate in accordance with law and on its
own merits.
53.
However, it is equally well settled that unless there are exceptional
circumstances, a writ of mandamus is never issued to direct the authorities to
act or exercise their discretion in a particular manner. Therefore, a further
direction that the essentiality certificate must be granted in favour of BBMT
within four weeks appears to us to be vulnerable.
54.
Admittedly, BBMT’s application for an essentiality certificate was
pending only at the stage when BBMT instituted W.P (C) No. 662 of 2025.
At that stage, and even at the stage of disposal of the said writ petition, this
Court did not have the benefit of any reasons, if any, for the refusal of the
essentiality certificate. W.P (C) No. 662 of 2025 was not a petition
challenging any order refusing the essentiality certificate. It was essentially a
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
petition complaining of inordinate and unreasonable delay in deciding
BBMT’s application for an essentiality certificate.
55.
At such a stage therefore, a mandamus to issue the essentiality
certificate was not warranted. The mandamus could have been to complete the
title verification process and dispose of the application seeking an essentiality
certificate in accordance with the law within a time-bound period.
56.
Therefore, we modify the impugned order dated 03.11.2025 in W.P(C)
No. 662 of 2025 by deleting the direction that the essentiality certificate must
be granted in favour of the petitioner within four weeks of completion of the
land verification process, and substituting it with a direction that the Deputy
Commissioner must complete the land verification process within four weeks
from today, and that the competent authority must then dispose of BBMT’s
application for an essentiality certificate in accordance with law and on its
own merits within six weeks thereafter.
57.
However, given the background of these matters and the State’s rather
surprising stance in the mutation proceedings, we clarify that the Deputy
Commissioner, when deciding the issue of land verification, must bear in
mind that he is not an adjudicatory authority like a Civil Court. All the
circumstances referred to in the impugned order dated 03.11.2025, as also in
this order, must be considered by the Deputy Commissioner.
58.
The Deputy Commissioner must be alive to the fact that PMCH was the
owner of the property, and it is in the name of PMCH that this land has been
mutated. The competent authority must also keep in mind that an essentiality
certificate had also been issued in favour of PMCH. Now, BBMT is the
successful auction purchaser in respect of the very land, and, at least till date,
no Court or Tribunal has set aside the sale letter issued in favour of BBMT.
( 2026:JHHC:21021-DB )
59.
In short, the modification of the learned Single Judge’s impugned order
to the extent indicated in paragraph 56 above, must not be construed as a
license to ignore relevant facts and circumstances or to rely on any
irrelevancies.
60.
Accordingly, LPA Nos. 44 of 2026 and 242 of 2026 are hereby
dismissed, and LPA No. 229 of 2026 is partly allowed to the above extent. No
costs.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
July 15, 2026
Ranjeet / R.Kr.
NAFR
Uploaded on 18.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review